Coffee Extraction Rant: Nicer Equipment+Higher Extraction=Better Coffee?

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 88

  • @xllvr
    @xllvr 10 місяців тому +22

    *The Rant*
    0:32 Gear Acquisition Syndrome
    ++ 2:09 The need for verification
    ++ 53:10 Don't have buyer's remorse
    3:30 Thesis statement for the stream
    7:05 Extraction yields
    ++ 7:54 Same extraction yield different grinders
    9:57 Preference for light roasts
    10:07 Aim for more even extractions (and repeatability)
    ++ 11:57 Consistency over all else
    12:59 Higher extraction and taste
    ++ 15:21 Not all coffees taste good at the same extraction
    17:09 Everclear for RDT and evaporation
    18:42 Extraction and dialing in
    19:53 How helpful is measuring extraction?
    20:44 "Budget" refractometer
    ++ 20:53 Propagation of extraction gatekeeping
    26:59 Shallow vs deep (espresso baskets) and efficiency of extraction
    29:56 Pressure and flow profiling
    33:01 New difluid?
    ++ 33:22 Get a VST if you can
    33:05 Maximum extraction (or how Lance tricked his kid to eat a puck)
    34:46 What are measurement tools known/incorporated from cooking?
    37:54 Don't do high extraction (extraction and bitterness)
    ++ 47:07 Extraction to 20+%
    38:38 Unifilter, temperature and extraction
    ++ 47:23 Unifilter and paper filter
    48:45 Improving consistency by going coarser and incorporating into workflow
    51:00 Extraction level measurement using oven drying
    *Misc*
    12:21 Sculptor arrives for someone in chat
    12:31 Which RDT bottle?
    14:31 Ghost burrs
    22:31 What water to rinse your filter with?
    23:04 Moonraker and Autocomb better than manual WDT?
    24:51 Cause for long preinfusions
    25:15 Thoughts on filter ratios
    26:25 How Lance grew his 'stache
    28:43 Hearts
    32:19 How to increase florality
    33:46 Double WDT
    36:27 Gaggia, Dimmer Mod and Gagguino
    ++ 40:28 Gagguino on the Gaggia Baby
    ++ 52:37 Gagguino and involved parts
    39:46 How long should Lotus Coffee water last?
    ++ 44:20 Lance's Water Set
    ++ 47:58 Cost per gallon math
    40:43 Competition and loud flavors
    ++ 44:57 Washed Panama Geisha in competition
    44:08 1-2-1 Lance Method
    ++ 45:01 Ethiopian Natural and getting a good cup
    ++ 45:57 Dealing with faster than expected/longer than expected drawdown
    51:28 SSP MP as upgrade vs new grinder
    53:53 Slow feeding on the EK
    ++ 56:10 Slow feeding on hand grinder
    ++ 57:45 Slow feeding vs single dosing
    54:41 Mazzer upgrade to 64 Zerno for Medium Roast?
    ++ 55:36 Slow feeding on Zerno
    57:10 Meticulous or Decent
    *Side Brew*
    5:36 Figuring out which coffee to drink
    8:55 Blowing out the chaff
    9:23 Getting the brewer
    11:47 Coffee ratio
    14:42 Tightening the bottom for the steep
    15:10 WWDT
    16:01 Messing up the brew in 4K
    17:01 WWDT Part 2
    18:08 Battery needs changing
    18:25 Getting a cup
    18:40 First sip
    20:29 More sips
    30:55 Deconstructed Lunar
    32:10 Type of filters
    33:41 V60 is his go to burr
    37:17 On Acaia batteries

  • @johanamilano
    @johanamilano 11 місяців тому +38

    Personally, I only go for 100% extraction which means that I just pour small doses of ground coffee into my mouth

    • @RavenSWE
      @RavenSWE 9 місяців тому +2

      Try rubbing the fines straight in your eyes, makes the caffeine hit harder

  • @ahpadt
    @ahpadt 11 місяців тому +18

    In the cooking world its been known for a while that higher extraction as a concept isnt always better. Particularly when making stock, you need to think about the end result intensity you want along with the key ingredient you use - fish, shellfish, poultry etc - because if you are cooking a fish stock for longer than 20 mins it’ll be horrible or a poultry can go bitter if you let it go for so long. Sometimes you want less extraction. It is harder sometimes to control how big of a coffee extraction you get tho, unlike pulling the pan off the hob.

  • @Athrix94
    @Athrix94 11 місяців тому +8

    I dont think I can express how awesome these streams are. Thank you Lance for doing this!!

  • @Glormpo
    @Glormpo 11 місяців тому +23

    Really like these live streams. More Lance is always more better.

  • @manniefred86
    @manniefred86 11 місяців тому +8

    I'm so glad you created this channel!

    • @LanceHedrickUnfiltered
      @LanceHedrickUnfiltered  11 місяців тому +2

      Same! I enjoy it quite a lot

    • @manniefred86
      @manniefred86 11 місяців тому

      Unrelated, have you tried the MHW-3bomber assassin kettle? (I know, the branding is insane...). I just came across it and the base looks like the fellow base while the kettle looks more like the timemore kettle so might be the perfect combination for you (I'm in no way associated with the brand and have never tried any of their products just thought it might be interesting to give a try)

  • @anthonyzouki
    @anthonyzouki 2 місяці тому

    More videos like this, I enjoyed it

  • @TheHabadababa
    @TheHabadababa 11 місяців тому +3

    I experienced this so much with my last 2 coffees, the first one was an Ethiopian coffee that just tasted sour, unbalanced and flat on a standard extraction (1 to 2.5 in 28s with a short preinfusion). When I tried a blooming shot with temps a little lower I first saturated the puck which took like 5 bars because I ground what I thought was way too fine, I let it bloom for about 20s and when I tried to pull the shot it took a lot of pressure and about 60 seconds to get to the same ratio as the first coffee. I tasted it thinking it would just be a bitter mess but to my surprise it was one of the best cups of coffee I ever tasted. Perfectly balanced acidity and bitterness with incredible sweetness and this intense dried plum taste, also amazing body. When I tried the same on the bag of Peruvian Gesha I opened a few days ago, the long blooming shot just tasted stale and muddy, but doing a much faster extraction that would have tasted way too sour on the first coffee I got a great cup that was incredibly floral with a lot of clarity and some very mild stonefruit notes.

    • @mauort6870
      @mauort6870 11 місяців тому

      I'm scared to order some of these 90+euro / kg coffees because when you burn a hundred grams of a two hundred gram bag just dialing in it makes it all taste sour.. unless you get one of those life changing shots... then worth it

    • @TheHabadababa
      @TheHabadababa 11 місяців тому

      It's an endless cycle of tasting something new and amazing and then you keep chasing that but never quite find it but you stumble across new amazing things on the way there.

  • @TrissyT73
    @TrissyT73 11 місяців тому +5

    This is probably one of your best ever videos!!! Uncut is the way forward. Keeping it real is the way forward

  • @TH-tl8hy
    @TH-tl8hy 11 місяців тому +2

    Love the vibe of these lives.

  • @sanslait
    @sanslait 8 місяців тому

    Wonderful as always! Would be stoked on a Monolith review!

  • @europa.
    @europa. 11 місяців тому +2

    just leaving a comment to say that i enjoy the unscripted, almost podcast, thoughts-flowing format. sometimes some real good tidbits of info come out of "rants" and "q&a" sessions that wouldn't otherwise. still appreciate your main channel a lot, of course, but there's definitely value in these chats

  • @GunfighterAlpha
    @GunfighterAlpha 11 місяців тому +3

    I've been playing with ratios and I'm really enjoying a 1 : 20, I find it separates the flavor profiles better. I could be factually wrong but my mouth says its right lol. Using a K-Max and a Hario Switch. Only thing I play with (for now) is grind size depending on the coffee I'm drinking at the time.

    • @JusBThankful
      @JusBThankful 11 місяців тому +1

      Was struggling to get much out of pricey bag of Sey. They recommended 1:20 and it made a difference over the normal 1:18 for their coffee

    • @kingmidas430
      @kingmidas430 10 місяців тому

      @@JusBThankful I’m new, could you help me understand how that would help with the taste over 1:15 or 1:16? My newbie mind feels like I would taste more with the higher coffee concentration.

    • @JusBThankful
      @JusBThankful 10 місяців тому

      @@kingmidas430 coffees that are harder to extract (lighter/denser) can sometimes benefit from longer ratios. More water contact equals higher, extraction. However, coffees with more roast defects, darker roasts, or maybe even just coffees that you don't like a higher extraction taste of would do better with shorter ratios and (typically) lower water temperatures, like what you described.
      Take whatever coffee you have, and try brewing a cup at both ends of the spectrum

  • @naantipa
    @naantipa 11 місяців тому

    My stance on the higher extraction capable grinder is that it gives you the maximum control. If a coffee works better with a higher dose and lower extraction, I can do that. Some coffees seem to really only be good (to me) if I manage low dose and high extraction. With a crappy grinder I can't reach the latter, so certain coffees are hard to pull off. With a nicer set of burrs I can choose where I want to be on the extraction spectrum.

  • @Rusty924
    @Rusty924 10 місяців тому

    Sorry for a silly question. Love the video. What is the brand of those glass cups that you use at around 18:33 ? I would love to buy those for my V60s :)

  • @LarryShwang
    @LarryShwang 11 місяців тому

    Subscribed! Gutted i missed this live.

  • @Robinzorz
    @Robinzorz 11 місяців тому

    This is top tier content!! Love it!

  • @mgsboedmisodpc2
    @mgsboedmisodpc2 11 місяців тому

    time 27:01 "extracting expresso with a shallower bed was much more efficient than a thicker bed because the water becomes less efficient...but its probably less tastier...I much prefer deeper beds" Lance, for a specific weight of coffee do you prefer coffee puck depth or height provided by a 51, 54, or 58 mm portafilter basket?

  • @clammyclaude
    @clammyclaude 10 місяців тому

    Please do a video where you go through how to use lotus water based on different coffee profiles….how to dial in lotus water

  • @JohnReddersen
    @JohnReddersen 11 місяців тому

    Do you think a slow feeder like the one you showed would benefit a Baratza Encore ESP or is the anti-popcorning entrance already slowing the beans down enough?

  • @Old_el_pablo
    @Old_el_pablo 10 місяців тому

    You need to do more videos like this, they are really interesting and informative. Did I spy the Subminimal Flick WDT? I've been tempted to pick it up for a while but had concerns for longevity or jamming. Any comments on how it performs please?

  • @coleyoung912
    @coleyoung912 11 місяців тому

    Really enjoying these unfiltered videos!

  • @knumph
    @knumph 11 місяців тому +1

    Can’t tell you how many times I’ve had a better tasting cup out of my baratza preciso than out of my hyperaligned 98mm flat and just concluded something is wrong with *me*

  • @Caffeine.And.Carvings
    @Caffeine.And.Carvings 11 місяців тому

    In todays flooded market, what grinder do you think delivers enough quality for its money. Like what should be a pricepoint a pro sumer should aim for, to not be chasing the dragon after purchase or having fomo after buying. For example, i think even an avid pro sumer would overspend on a Monolith or ww eg1. While the grinders around 500 dollars, according to reviews often leave the pro sumer wanting. So in which ballpark would i need to think, to get a grinder for life

  • @coreycannon4511
    @coreycannon4511 11 місяців тому +1

    Drinking a Froot Loop latte while cozying up for an hour of Lance!

    • @145Mars145
      @145Mars145 10 місяців тому

      This is a joke right? Right?

  • @Dotes111
    @Dotes111 11 місяців тому

    Thanks for the helpful info!
    Anyone have suggestions on water to use for the Lotus Coffee drops? I am interested in getting into the custom water game, but am worried about the sustainability and cost of sourcing distilled water.

  • @sofiaclemente7925
    @sofiaclemente7925 11 місяців тому

    Lance is like the perfect combo of coffee mad scientist and himbo @ 28:00

  • @jeffjones6667
    @jeffjones6667 11 місяців тому

    Topic for future video, basket diameter vs dose vs flavor separation? Old debate 54 vs 58 ...58 is winner for options but should it be? Or is Londinium right,,, 65mm basket?

  • @RTOBarista
    @RTOBarista 11 місяців тому

    I understand that you will be doing a review on the Unica Pro after a software update. Will this occur before the end of the year?

  • @rupertmcleod4198
    @rupertmcleod4198 11 місяців тому

    Great vid, esp the use of "arse" and "bollocks" :D

  • @isaiahh.4683
    @isaiahh.4683 11 місяців тому

    We need a Lance Hedrick origin story and family reveal!!!

  • @MrHoiza
    @MrHoiza 11 місяців тому

    Hello Lance! I've been watching your videos for quite a long time and I'm always amazed at the new approaches you bring to the table when it comes to brewing. Thanks for that! Your videos are fun and very educational at the same time.
    I have own a Rancilio Silvia for a long time and have it pimped up with an ito / leva! - kit . Do you know the ito kit? Wouldn't that be a "better" project than the Gaggiuino ? Would love to hear your thoughts and opinions on this. If you want to compare the two directly, I'll be happy to send you my machine ;)
    What else to say?! Lance Hedrik Unflitered is great! I love it❤❤
    Greetings from Austria

  • @letterzx
    @letterzx 11 місяців тому

    love these so much! would be nice to see the chat replay for better context, the first one had it but not this one

  • @gibbions
    @gibbions 11 місяців тому

    Keep up the good work old chap! Love your videos 😊

  • @braxtonjens7839
    @braxtonjens7839 11 місяців тому

    If BH made a 53/54mm autocomb, I would be all over that for when I’m catering/pop ups with the la spaziale vivaldi.

  • @govindmukundan6799
    @govindmukundan6799 11 місяців тому +1

    What was in the dropper that he used after filling the kettle with water? Around the 2:00 minute mark

    • @gissuatsamot
      @gissuatsamot 11 місяців тому +1

      Lotus Coffee mineral solutions. His own company

  • @CoreProject05
    @CoreProject05 11 місяців тому

    Hey Lance,
    on the topic of FOMO, Bigger better, More expensive -» better -» much nicer to use lane: Would you pick a well built well aligned 64 (e.g.: p64 mizenv2 - or zerno) over let's say a not even released df83V with an SSP Cast burr? This let's go bigger and buy the next DF that beats everything is like ... more watts in Hifi, it does not mean your system is better and most probably it is not.

  • @notme123123
    @notme123123 11 місяців тому +1

    How many open bags of coffee do you have at any given time and how long will you keep them open before noticing flavor drop off? I usually have two open coffees (a light and a medium/dark).

    • @bznelson91
      @bznelson91 10 місяців тому +1

      I am but a mere Lance fan, but I do strictly filter coffee (for now), and most often have over ten (!) bags working at a time, which sounds crazy (and maybe is). But I keep them frozen in their respective bags, all within an enclosed (but not absolutely sealed) box in the freezer, and I bring out a bit at a time for daily grinding. It's worked well for me.

  • @tobiasbouma4071
    @tobiasbouma4071 11 місяців тому

    Wouldn't higher extraction equipment (say basket) improve texturial experience ? Since the same can be extracted at tighter ratio ?

  • @wakeawaken430
    @wakeawaken430 11 місяців тому

    1:00am here, i guess i an not going to sleep tonight...😂

  • @gammonwalker
    @gammonwalker 11 місяців тому

    Does anyone know what that grinder is on the right of the thumbnail?

  • @Akdale777
    @Akdale777 11 місяців тому

    As you have said many times. How does it taste to YOU? There really is no better objective source of the best tasting coffee than the tasters tongue.

  • @gulag_inmate69
    @gulag_inmate69 7 місяців тому

    Yo boss you should dispose of that battery that's a fire hazard

  • @JohnInIndia7
    @JohnInIndia7 11 місяців тому

    Lance! I am loving this new channel! I was thinking about doing lives myself to help get watch time for monetization! About how much watch time do you get from these lives?

  • @LordWaterBottle
    @LordWaterBottle 11 місяців тому

    Does anyone know if there has been any testing done on if/how air pressure affects brews? I recently moved to the from range of the rockies and am curious if there are any alterations I should make to my routine.

    • @BoZ-s2x
      @BoZ-s2x 10 місяців тому

      Consider the change of boiling temperature and how that affects coffee extraction.

  • @NeilNatic
    @NeilNatic 11 місяців тому

    What is the make and model of that refractometer he mentioned at 20:00?

  • @atavax311
    @atavax311 11 місяців тому +1

    I got a niche relatively early on my specialty coffee journey and after awhile I found a favorite coffee. Awhile later i got a zp6 and was excited to try my favorite coffee with very high clarity grinder and then was surprised when it wasn't as good, not as complex, as with the niche. Unfortunately not as simple as improving equipment to improve coffee. One of the reasons I have 3 burr sets for my z1

    • @LanceHedrickUnfiltered
      @LanceHedrickUnfiltered  11 місяців тому +7

      Exactly. Like I was saying, you can have a heavily channeled shot and love it and not enjoy its corralary well pulled shot. Coffee is frustrating.
      Though, to be honest, I'm horribly shocked to read you preferred the niche pourover over anything due simply to the overwhelming amount of heat damage it produces..

  • @notfam0us
    @notfam0us 11 місяців тому

    Lance blowing grounds 😂😂😂

  • @parasbhargava6047
    @parasbhargava6047 11 місяців тому

    nice video lance!

  • @JohnInIndia7
    @JohnInIndia7 11 місяців тому

    Lance, I have heard that watch time only counts for when people watch the live after it is finished and posted but not during the actual live. Have you found that to be true?

    • @LanceHedrickUnfiltered
      @LanceHedrickUnfiltered  11 місяців тому

      Yes, sadly. Just found this out about 3 minutes ago haha! How apt to find your comment.

    • @JohnInIndia7
      @JohnInIndia7 11 місяців тому

      @@LanceHedrickUnfiltered I still think this is a great idea for a channel because on your other channel i only watch pour over and hand grinders videos but for the live I watch all of them and every single second...after they are finished and posted for all of us to see.

  • @BaronSenf
    @BaronSenf 11 місяців тому

    Anyone knows which espresso machine is the white one on the left?

  • @hskrwr9495
    @hskrwr9495 11 місяців тому +2

    Call me crazy, but i think this lance guy might be interested in the world of coffee and all the scoence and details around it 🤔

  • @nickr9784
    @nickr9784 11 місяців тому +1

    What was that brewer/ dripper?

  • @jobopening5085
    @jobopening5085 10 місяців тому

    Meatballs

  • @demmidemmi
    @demmidemmi 11 місяців тому

    No matter how much you like Logics music you probably shouldn't be taking coffee advice from him.