Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today's video! Get 20% OFF + Free International Shipping + 2 Free Gifts with my promo code "FREDERATOR" at mnscpd.com/ChannelFrederator
Actually like, enjoy and agree with all most every you say, except... I think that it doesn't matter if is Anne or Luz, in the second temple the jem will not finish to charge and Luz will still be connected to the stone and that will appear, but she will use that power to shoot projectiles
For the Ivy in the run I think Luz would talk to Ivy's mom bout how she shouldn't put so much pressure on Ivy and to just tell that's that she's preparing her to travel the land together or else she'll push Ivy away, telling her about her relationship with her own mother.
Yeah i kinda hated that, like i get she was preparing her but she did it on the most condescending way possible, instead of doing it a way Ivy would have liked or telling her about it.
@@maximgvozdic3009 But Luz’s destiny is supposed to get her new friends and her girlfriend are going to go back to went the past on the Demon Realm for Belos to become the first emperor of the Boiling isles for his evil plan to wipe out the whole witches in the first place where he’s the witch hunter, that’s how it works for her to have happened when she will be a witch in the Owl House series.
@@ScruffySFM Can you imagine Bethos reaction Anne gose all blue hair mode, I've got a huntch that would ethier be pumped into submittion, or if some how miraculously escapes her onslaught, he would actively try to avoid being within 10 feet of Anne, and maybe ask the collector anything on what kind of power dose this girl wield.
@@MrGabeanator I know right, though I don't know how would the general Witch populatian would react when they see a blue hair human girl kicking the emperor to the curb.
I think a slighty different story would of happened but at the same time it would be interesting to see a what if series happy for Disney shows like this
Yeah I definitely think if I was explaining an idea like this, I would have Luz in Amphibia and the calamity trio getting sent to the boiling isles.. no awkward interactions between them because they wouldn't meet each other
Honestly, the biggest difference between Luz in Amphibia vs the Calamity trio is how her presence there would be far more positive and far more active on making the lives around her better wheras the trio was more spent on working through their own issues and their toxic friendship
Keep in mind, neither human characters would have the skills we know them for in their respective fantasy worlds. So the Calamity Trio may become witches, Luz would be, a somewhat non-magical sword fighter.
I think she would be more along the lines of a Paladin from DnD, or perhaps a magical sub-class for non magic class, such as an Eldridge Knight fighter.
Actually strike what I said. I just realized that Wartwood would start off by despising Luz out of fear, because that's how they reacted to Anne. As if Luz didn't have enough isolation issues on Earth
@MP I have watched Amphibia yet I've started it but didn't get the chance to finish but from the little I've seen he does seem like an Interesting and endearing character
18:33 Yeah, this might play out the same, but I could see this also being much like the end of Reaching Out. Maybe Luz is trying to distract from her father's passing or uses it to bond further with Sprig.
I feel like Luz would never be as close to Sprig as Anne was, but the conversation on the balcony about their lost parent/parents would definitely be an emotional moment that brings the two closer together.
I could really see Luz and Sprig bonding over having missing parents (which might lead to Sprig and Luz having a heart-to-heart about growing up without Dads).
I think if the king revealed truth about Marcy it wouldn't affect luz at all but Sasha would have been mad. liked if you included a little luz and feeding like a replacement goldfish for Anne
I'm glad you're doing the "Anne in the owl house" episode. I wonder how different Anne's and Amity's relationship would be? I doubt they'd be together (girlfriends) but hopefully, they become best friends.
Does it make sense to do Anne in the Owl house? The first epizode would be pretty much same. Anne meet Eda. Anne meet King. Anne would have propably helped them so she could go home. After they would have defeat Warden Anne would have propably go home because she doesn't have a dream to become witch like Luz not to mention she wanted to go home since epizode 1
@@knucklestheceoofmemes7755 Yes, i think Anne would go home almost immediately, she probably goes to Camila's house and tell's her everything and she helps her get to California
Thats True but Anne would end up going back to the boiling ises tho once she realized Marcy and Sasha aren’t in California. She would go back there to go looking for them, thinking they’re still in BI
My sons (5 and 9) and I just finished Amphibia, and man, I was BLOWN AWAY. The writing, the comedy, the pacing, the lore, the arcs, it is surely one of the best shows I've ever seen. It can be pretty heavy at times, but doesn't cop out to quick fixes and shallow platitudes. Loved it
I'm pretty sure that Luz would try to make magic potions when she returns to Earth... to no avail. Also, I wonder how Luz would react to being back home after the fight with Andrias.
Wait, would they be able to recharge that gem? Luz has no connection to the calamity box, so her power wouldn't be drained the way Marcy and Sasha's powers were (Anne stopped before the process was complete, which is why she still had her powers).
Unless...Whatever made Anne and Luz switch places also split the power of the blue gem between the two girls. So Luz could have had 50% of the blue gem's power in her.
Seeing as how at the start, he states that they "crossed the beams", I think he means that the portal door and the Calamity box were interfering with each other, and that's why Anne fell out of the sky in the Isles without the box and Luz appeared in Amphibia. So, it's not too unbelievable that she has a fraction of Calamity magic in her, but unlike Anne, hers would be far less. So the charging of the stones would completely drain her, but the gem should only have a little power, like less than a quarter.
@@Little_Eris It could be possible, though I don't if Amity could keep up with Anne's energetic nature; though it would interesting to see the two of practicing martial arts together, along with King perhaps.
@@maximgvozdic3009 Well, Luz is also energetic and Amity could live with it. (much more energy and same dorks as her sibling especially her brother) Even though she's not learning martial arts she does train hard for fighting. Pretty strong even without it if u ask me
I just thought of something, if we are crossing the streams this way then one would assume that Anne ended up in the boiling Isles. and of course, when Eda is boasting about how she's the best witch to the crowd to the crowd to impress Anne. A certain basilisk would slip into the Human Realm, and would be confronted by Camila, and Vee would try to disguise herself as the first Human she's seen, Anne.
I know right I personally can't wait for the reaction of the Witches to see Anne practicing martial arts, or Amity trying to learn about human Thai culture.
@@maximgvozdic3009 Oh, dang. I just imagined. Anne having her witches duel with Amity. Her combining her Muay Thai martial arts with magic to dominate Amity.
@@DarkGoldDrawings Absolutely, though that makes wonder if Anne and Amity's relationship would that of bitter rivals or something else intiery. Actually here is just as related question, would Anne still make the same friends as Luz dose so during her time on the boiling Isle or not?
@@maximgvozdic3009 I can see her getting along with Eda, King, Willow and Gus. As for Amity, it would very much likely be a everlasting rivalry. No romance between as, I'm not sure for certain, but I think Anne is straight. Given that the only relationships she ever talks about in Amphibia were hetero. As far as I remember.
@@DarkGoldDrawings speaking of Gus, do you think their would be potental of a love triangle between Gus, Hunter, and Anne, or do you think Anne would be more of a supporting friend towards Hunter ?
there is one point to have in account: what if luz learn maddie's way of sorcery? since we can assume that maddie have no bill sack, her sorcery seems diferent from that of the boiling isles, and it makes me wonder if, after learn many sorcery from maddie, such sorcery would still work for luz in the human realm...
I overall enjoyed this take on Luz in Amphibia! The only two things I think is a bit confusing is if the Marcy betrayal would’ve still happened with Andrias telling Sasha about it and how Eda’s portal door was able to sent Luz to Amphibia instead and not the BI while Anne didn’t get into Amphibia when it happened right when Marcy got her the box(though that probably be explained in your “What if Anne went to the Boiling Isles?” Video). Though I still enjoyed this very much and I’m excited for part 2. I will say though I’m curious for how Anne would stay in the Boiling Isles as since Anne isn’t like Luz or Marcy who would want to stay there to live out a fantasy, it’s kinda hard to imagine her staying that long.
"One is better than the other" I think its unfair to say that, I'd go to put one on for one reason and the other for a different one, that doesn't mean they aren't both some of the most exciting "tween cartoons" out in the last 3 years
To me this plot is kind of interesting. A human getting lost in a new world and wanting to get home and finding other humans who they never met before also wanting to get home. Also how would THIS version of Luz react to a version of Anne who went to the boiling isles.
you sure that they could charge the Heart gem? the way that it worked in amphibia is that it took the powers out of the girls and put it back in the stones. but you've made no references to Luz being connected to the stone, and as far as were aware, Anne's still the one with the heart of calamity who is presumably in the boiling isles.
Okay, but how does Luz recharge the stone, when the stone's power is within Anne? The show states that the gem's powers were transferred into the girls when they used the music box, and the temple thing was them returning the power to the gems and denying their destiny.
@@knucklestheceoofmemes7755 Yes and no, their many ways for Anne to stay in the boiling Isle, for instance Eda may convince Anne to stay because she may need her muscle; Anne may stay because she thinks of her friends are on the boiling Isles as well and she must search high and low for them, or maybe she stays in the demon realm because she views it as an escape from the reality of her family moving away. And that is just few out of many, personally I think Anne stays because she is enthralled by the character of Eda as a rebel and woman who does what she wants and with a disregard to what other say, and wants to follow in her footsteps.
@@maximgvozdic3009 wait her family/parents are moving away or is it just in this au ? also another reason to stay is when the portal door opens it leads to Luz's house not annes so she decides to stay until they find her house
8:00 I don’t think her mom is making Enchiladas usually considering she’s Dominican and Enchiladas are more Mexican I would have gone with something else. Something popular and simple in the US or something Dominican.
Thanks! I was not sure about this since I don't know too much about Dominican cousine but I was pretty sure they just said "Speaks spanish and isn't white? Mexican" kinda annoying ngl
This was interesting and makes me wish Disney would do a what if series, with that said I don’t think Luz’s mom would help/protect the Planters from Mr X so look forward to the next version of Luz in Amphibia & it sounds like your doing Anne in Boiling Isles so looking forward to that as well
I don’t wanna be that guy, but it seems that this is based on what people want it to be and not what it would actually be. For example: I don’t think Luz would even be able to handle the mantis. It would be much too fast and way too strong for her. Plus where could she possibly go that would neutralize the mantis without nuetralizing herself? Im not really sure Luz would she’d be able to survive at all in Amphibia, shown in the first episode of the owl house. When it comes down to a life or death Luz isn’t really the most ready. Anne had to survive 3 days in the wild, something Luz possibly couldn’t do as she hasn’t really shown no forest actual survival skills. This video kinda makes Luz seem like an Angel and Anne seem like a problem child. With Luz’s only notable flaw being she’s kinda “weird”. But in reality their both just as flawed as the other. And I find strange that this video doesn’t reflect that. Some of Luz’s flaws is: Luz has a temper while Anne is more chill, Luz is frail while Anne is athletic, Luz lacks common sense while Anne atleast has an average amount, Etc. I don’t hate Luz. She’s cool and skilled in her own ways. But this video kinda seems to overestimate her and down put Anne. Which is really strange.
And the most important thing of all, the powers of the stones, Luz (since she had no contact with the Calamity Box in the way Anne Sasha and Marcy had) wouldn't be able to charge the 2 stone
The only thing i didn't like is Luz having the Calamity Box just because yes, it would had make more sense that she found it when she arrived to Amphibia or since Sasha and Marcy are in Amphibia like the OG story they should have the box instead of Luz And also i don't think Luz could charge the 2 stone due to it's relation with Anne from the beggining of the series Now that i think about it Polly would be dead since Anne and Sprig are the ones who created Frobo by accident, and in True Colors Frobo is the one who save Polly, and i don't think Luz would have been able to defeat Andrias because of his strenght and the frobots army
24:00 Guess this is confirm they had this video in the closet for a while! Speaking of season 3, it does make me wonder how it would had played out in this scenario due to Anne usage of the blue gem power. Luz would used the growth spell again against mecha Andria and they somehow destoryed the Core/ Darcy helmet before it flew off to the moon?
@@justinsm And assuming the only change is that Luz and Anne got swapped by the portal door/Calamity Box, it's possible that Vee is still on Earth disguised as Luz.
@@justinsm I found weird that once spring opens up with luz about his mother she doesn't mantion ehat happened with her father, it probably has to do with when was this video made
Wait if luz got too amphibia through the door the calamity box still would have been in that pawn shop and still would have sent the trio too amphibia.
A key element I think your forgetting is that throughout s1 Luz could always go home, and even still had contact with her mom, something that would not be posable in this scenario
True, but then again she may think her friends are also on the boiling Isles as well, plus if nothing else, may Anne would stay on the boiling Isles because of how she may see Eda and the demon realm as a fourm of rebelling against her parents and the process of moving. But that's just my Ideas what are yours?
@@maximgvozdic3009 But anne didn't had any big issues with her parents and wanted to go home since season 1. The only way she may stay is as you mentioned looking for her friends
@@hectorlackless yeah that makes sense, also do think she will attended hexside in order to blend in with other Witches or not; also do you think Eda and King will influence her character?
@@maximgvozdic3009 They probably would since this videos are for that. Although realistically I don't see Anne enrolling in hexide since she wouldn't really be that interested as luz and it was a lot of trouble. Maybe just a look like luz did in "I am a teenage abomination" to see if her friends are there.
I'd hate if Luz went to Amphibia, because... (Based on mid-series and canon facts) 1: No blue Calamity user 2: Luz would be dead because Sasha won't care for random. 3: All Luz will do will show-off her glyphs because as said, "Luz cares for what others think of her" (but will epicly fail) 4: Having Anne Boonchuy in Amphibia is better than having Luz Noceda because she would easily die if she had no Calamity early signs, and glyphs only work in the World of Witches. 5: Luz would ruin all the feelings with that fruity stuff (even with frogs ,_,)
It would be really fun to see that Anne was put in the owl house world but I feel like a lot of the episodes wouldn’t happen or part may or wouldn’t I think what happened was the owl lady was using her portal to earth like normal but it went on the fritz and when Luz entered it she got out in amphibia. Then the box noticed that there was 3 kids in amphibia already and it kicked Anne into the boiling island.
You completely forgot about the best character, frobo! I am ripping myself apart wondering how Luz would feel about having a big metal baebey on the team.
Hm, i have to say this were a pretty interesting Story and thought experiment, Though, i have to say, that the beginning, as well as some certain Plot-Points, i felt were a little lazily made, Regardless, i think this went sort of how i would’ve expected it go, especially when considering that Luz is basically Marcy if Marcy were the protagonist, However still though, while i think this was a well enough thought out What If Story, i feel that this could’ve been thought out a little more. Still interesting idea though.
Lotta things I could comment on, but I'll go with the last one; I think Luz would more likely try to pull a Gandalf-style "you shall not pass," giving her newfound friends a chance to escape through the portal. Could go any way from there, regarding what happens to whom.
I think both shows are good because the character development reminds me of the way it’s done in manga and anime. The characters start out underdogs and become great through effort and personal growth. 😃
*Surprised Luz going into alternate universes didn't become a meme/writing exercise*. Well at least I enjoyed writing some what ifs they were bad but fun. Like: -What if Luz ended up in the Ben 10 universe -What if Luz went to Muny -Luz's Bizarre Adventure (Steelball Run universe).
I think the events of the dead phone episode would also change, perhaps there was a curse that created electricity to charge her phone and the planters are looking for ingredients.
in teh episode of the crazy scientist lady in amphibia, we see a glance at the owl house depicted as a pixelated picture. This means, annes human world and luzs human world are in tha same universe
Wouldn't the music box bring Sasha and Marcy to the other world with Anne, and have Luz be alone in amphibia? You also didn't really change that much, even tho you changed the main character, which should really change more than just the main character if you know what I mean.
I love this but can you do a kingdom hearts what if sora was in amphibia or the owl house set after the events of Kingdom hearts 3 he would still have access to the keyblade and all his magic and abilities including summons like Simba or stitch.
@@cjgamer6356 for example Sora has to stay behind in amphibia to lock the music box after anna Sasha and Marcy leave to go back home the guardian tells Sora may his heart be his guiding key it has also met one of the keyblade wielders of the age of fairy tales the master of Masters he told the guardian that one day a keyblade wielder will come again.
@@cjgamer6356 well since owl house is being canceled by Disney I don't know how it would end I'm not sure I think sora might have a little fight with the emperor or a dangerous creature like the puppeteer or the monster during gorm night maybe he'll compete in that tournament that Amity wanted to compete in it would be like the coliseum matches The collector always wanted to own a keyblade but it's unable to.
Does anyone know what happened to Bee and Puppycat? Channel Frederator said there would be a Netflix show, but that's all we got. So are there going to be any updates? Thanks?
I think this would an wonderful fanfic if the writer is able to pull it off well. Me I would have Luz stay with Maddie and her family. Also I don't think Sprig and Maddie would be engaged due to the events of Hop Luck happening differently. For the second temple, when Valeriana accuses Luz of running away, Luz would say that's not what happen. Then Valeriana say "True, but answer me this. If you had found a way back to Earth on the first day arrived, you would have stayed in Amphibia? Or would you return and go to camp like you mother wanted?" Luz would realize that she would choose to stay in Amphibia and admit this.
SPRUZ AGAINST THE WORD Also woah you're really just swapping the two with wierd retcon magic huh Luz and Marcy would be a crazy duo ngl Anne's pov will be amazing looking forward what you give her powerset in a magic-dominated world
One thing that's minor, but is 100% incorrect is saying Luz finds frogs disgusting. This is a girl that handles snakes no problem and has no issue with spiders crawling on her.
Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today's video! Get 20% OFF + Free International Shipping + 2 Free Gifts with my promo code "FREDERATOR" at mnscpd.com/ChannelFrederator
Gummy secrets I found gummy secrets
What if Lincoln stay as the duke
Btw Amphibia as a whole has ended so you cal finish now
Actually like, enjoy and agree with all most every you say, except... I think that it doesn't matter if is Anne or Luz, in the second temple the jem will not finish to charge and Luz will still be connected to the stone and that will appear, but she will use that power to shoot projectiles
Season of amphibia has been finished so is it possible to make a redo w/ season 3 included or a part 2?
For the Ivy in the run I think Luz would talk to Ivy's mom bout how she shouldn't put so much pressure on Ivy and to just tell that's that she's preparing her to travel the land together or else she'll push Ivy away, telling her about her relationship with her own mother.
*"Speech 100"*
*spelling 100*
My brain just imploded reading this
Yeah i kinda hated that, like i get she was preparing her but she did it on the most condescending way possible, instead of doing it a way Ivy would have liked or telling her about it.
I love the idea of Luz hanging out with Maddie, they'd be great friends. I wish Maddie had gotten more screen time
Same here.
Same
@@johanstenfelt1206 Maddie got too much screen time as it is.
Just kidding, she should have had more screen time.
@@frankficcle7081 She should have been the main cast.
@@maximgvozdic3009 But Luz’s destiny is supposed to get her new friends and her girlfriend are going to go back to went the past on the Demon Realm for Belos to become the first emperor of the Boiling isles for his evil plan to wipe out the whole witches in the first place where he’s the witch hunter, that’s how it works for her to have happened when she will be a witch in the Owl House series.
I would definitely would love to see in a sequel what if scenario of what if Anne Boonchuy was in The Boiling Isles
She technically would still be connected to the stones since she never goes to the temple, so imagine that coming into play
@@ScruffySFM Can you imagine Bethos reaction Anne gose all blue hair mode, I've got a huntch that would ethier be pumped into submittion, or if some how miraculously escapes her onslaught, he would actively try to avoid being within 10 feet of Anne, and maybe ask the collector anything on what kind of power dose this girl wield.
ithats what i'm thinkin
@@MrGabeanator I know right, though I don't know how would the general Witch populatian would react when they see a blue hair human girl kicking the emperor to the curb.
@@maximgvozdic3009 neither do i
I think a slighty different story would of happened but at the same time it would be interesting to see a what if series happy for Disney shows like this
YES
OMG same here
Yeah I definitely think if I was explaining an idea like this, I would have Luz in Amphibia and the calamity trio getting sent to the boiling isles.. no awkward interactions between them because they wouldn't meet each other
disney should make a what if series of the disney shows rn ohmygod-
The Watcher is watching the event unfold and how different it goes
Honestly, the biggest difference between Luz in Amphibia vs the Calamity trio is how her presence there would be far more positive and far more active on making the lives around her better wheras the trio was more spent on working through their own issues and their toxic friendship
Cap
@@rest1585 well anne made wartwood better
@@Hollowmello1285 I was saying cap to how they think if Luz was in Amphibia she would have improved the town more than Anne. But that’s cap.
@@rest1585 cap?
@@brandonvortex995 cap means calling someone’s bluff, like saying somethings a lie
Keep in mind, neither human characters would have the skills we know them for in their respective fantasy worlds. So the Calamity Trio may become witches, Luz would be, a somewhat non-magical sword fighter.
I think she would be more along the lines of a Paladin from DnD, or perhaps a magical sub-class for non magic class, such as an Eldridge Knight fighter.
How about a crossbow? that's Polly's biggest wishes
@@justinsm not bad if Anne were to become some kind of DnD inspired Arcane Archer Fighter.
Actually strike what I said. I just realized that Wartwood would start off by despising Luz out of fear, because that's how they reacted to Anne. As if Luz didn't have enough isolation issues on Earth
Marcy and Luz are pretty complimentary.
I could see Luz reacting in a similar way towards Sprig as she did when she first met King.
But, we never knew if she loves Frog that much
@@justinsm, she loves snakes I don’t think frogs are out of the question then again the realistic version is pretty horrifying.
King is definitely way cuter then Sprig in my opinion
@MP I have watched Amphibia yet I've started it but didn't get the chance to finish but from the little I've seen he does seem like an Interesting and endearing character
What if luz Was sent to Equestrian
18:33 Yeah, this might play out the same, but I could see this also being much like the end of Reaching Out. Maybe Luz is trying to distract from her father's passing or uses it to bond further with Sprig.
She might acting the same like she does in Reaching out when the day came in Newtopia
I feel like Luz would never be as close to Sprig as Anne was, but the conversation on the balcony about their lost parent/parents would definitely be an emotional moment that brings the two closer together.
Ooooh yeah
I think a good comparison for Luz's probable reaction would most likely be somewhat like Marcy's reaction in the Theme Song take over
Wake up in newtopia
@@justinsm Where she'll fall down a flight of stairs
@@justinsm where i fell down a flight of stairs
@@sophiaring2721 broke my leg but luckily
trade off between being alot less clumsy in exchange for being significantly stupider. marcy at least landed in a locaiton with free healthcare.
I could really see Luz and Sprig bonding over having missing parents (which might lead to Sprig and Luz having a heart-to-heart about growing up without Dads).
Luz isn't much of a fighter like Anne, so I feel like 99% of the fighting scenes would be drastically different
I wouldn't imagine finding her book in the trash, rather I would imagine her finding the calamity box in the trash, and opening it
Luz learning magic with Maddie and bonding over shared interests with Marcy is super wholesome!!!
Yasss
I think if the king revealed truth about Marcy it wouldn't affect luz at all but Sasha would have been mad. liked if you included a little luz and feeding like a replacement goldfish for Anne
Luz be like:Your parents are making you move away?!
I'm glad you're doing the "Anne in the owl house" episode. I wonder how different Anne's and Amity's relationship would be? I doubt they'd be together (girlfriends) but hopefully, they become best friends.
Does it make sense to do Anne in the Owl house?
The first epizode would be pretty much same. Anne meet Eda. Anne meet King. Anne would have propably helped them so she could go home. After they would have defeat Warden Anne would have propably go home because she doesn't have a dream to become witch like Luz not to mention she wanted to go home since epizode 1
@@knucklestheceoofmemes7755 Yes, i think Anne would go home almost immediately, she probably goes to Camila's house and tell's her everything and she helps her get to California
Anne would ask Eda if she could bring Marcy and Sash to learn magic too.
Sasha is bi. She and Amity might
Thats True but Anne would end up going back to the boiling ises tho once she realized Marcy and Sasha aren’t in California. She would go back there to go looking for them, thinking they’re still in BI
My sons (5 and 9) and I just finished Amphibia, and man, I was BLOWN AWAY. The writing, the comedy, the pacing, the lore, the arcs, it is surely one of the best shows I've ever seen. It can be pretty heavy at times, but doesn't cop out to quick fixes and shallow platitudes. Loved it
I think Luz and Sprig would bond after sharing each other information regarding Luz's father and Sprig's parents' deaths.
Luz would be like Marcy. Aware of the world and excited to explore
Yessssss
Problem i don’t think they would be able to charge the Blue gem cause they needed Anne to do that as each girl needed to be there for the recharging
I'm pretty sure that Luz would try to make magic potions when she returns to Earth... to no avail. Also, I wonder how Luz would react to being back home after the fight with Andrias.
Same as how the original goes albeit different
Wait, would they be able to recharge that gem? Luz has no connection to the calamity box, so her power wouldn't be drained the way Marcy and Sasha's powers were (Anne stopped before the process was complete, which is why she still had her powers).
exactly that what made me confused
Unless...Whatever made Anne and Luz switch places also split the power of the blue gem between the two girls. So Luz could have had 50% of the blue gem's power in her.
@@hannahthelibrarian2933 maybe
@@hannahthelibrarian2933 that's plausible too
Seeing as how at the start, he states that they "crossed the beams", I think he means that the portal door and the Calamity box were interfering with each other, and that's why Anne fell out of the sky in the Isles without the box and Luz appeared in Amphibia. So, it's not too unbelievable that she has a fraction of Calamity magic in her, but unlike Anne, hers would be far less. So the charging of the stones would completely drain her, but the gem should only have a little power, like less than a quarter.
I Still Think That Maybe It Would Be A Lot Cooler If Disney’s The Owl House Did Crossover With Disney’s Amphibia
If Luz wasn’t in the Demon Realm, then there won’t be any Lumity
Therefor, the internet wouldn't care for it as much.😆
PlotTwist! Anne and Amity fall in Love if we get a What if Anne was in the boiling isles.
@@Little_Eris It could be possible, though I don't if Amity could keep up with Anne's energetic nature; though it would interesting to see the two of practicing martial arts together, along with King perhaps.
@@maximgvozdic3009 Well, Luz is also energetic and Amity could live with it. (much more energy and same dorks as her sibling especially her brother) Even though she's not learning martial arts she does train hard for fighting. Pretty strong even without it if u ask me
Wait what about luz and marcy
I just thought of something, if we are crossing the streams this way then one would assume that Anne ended up in the boiling Isles. and of course, when Eda is boasting about how she's the best witch to the crowd to the crowd to impress Anne. A certain basilisk would slip into the Human Realm, and would be confronted by Camila, and Vee would try to disguise herself as the first Human she's seen, Anne.
I Totally Think That Maybe It Would Be A Lot Cooler If Disney’s The Owl House Did Crossover With Disney’s Amphibia
That happened once not a episode but still a crossover
@@Indiegamelover1 was it a webcomic
@@Indiegamelover1 I like your profile pic.
@@leeferguson-piper4841 it was a comic con thing I think
What didn’t they do an official crossover
You got me so invested in the plot
I actually felt like i was watching amphibia except with luz in it
I hope we have a part 2 to this (especially since Amphibia has concluded now) and the story of Anne in the Boiling Isles.
I know right I personally can't wait for the reaction of the Witches to see Anne practicing martial arts, or Amity trying to learn about human Thai culture.
@@maximgvozdic3009 Oh, dang. I just imagined. Anne having her witches duel with Amity. Her combining her Muay Thai martial arts with magic to dominate Amity.
@@DarkGoldDrawings Absolutely, though that makes wonder if Anne and Amity's relationship would that of bitter rivals or something else intiery. Actually here is just as related question, would Anne still make the same friends as Luz dose so during her time on the boiling Isle or not?
@@maximgvozdic3009 I can see her getting along with Eda, King, Willow and Gus. As for Amity, it would very much likely be a everlasting rivalry. No romance between as, I'm not sure for certain, but I think Anne is straight. Given that the only relationships she ever talks about in Amphibia were hetero. As far as I remember.
@@DarkGoldDrawings speaking of Gus, do you think their would be potental of a love triangle between Gus, Hunter, and Anne, or do you think Anne would be more of a supporting friend towards Hunter ?
there is one point to have in account: what if luz learn maddie's way of sorcery? since we can assume that maddie have no bill sack, her sorcery seems diferent from that of the boiling isles, and it makes me wonder if, after learn many sorcery from maddie, such sorcery would still work for luz in the human realm...
The Disney isekai arc has probably been good for kids, especially with the way the world has been.
What If Saiyans Escape Destruction Of Planet Vegeta (Dragon Ball) And Landed On Realm Of Edenia (Mortal Kombat)
You should do “what if Anne, Sasha, and Marcy were sent to the boiling isle
I like this idea.
I think it would be just Anne in the boiling Isles, though I do wonder, what would the relationship be between her and Amity be like?
@@maximgvozdic3009 she'd bond with Willow more.
@@solierix So how deep would this bond be, would they be just friends, or something more 🤔
@@maximgvozdic3009 Anne would probably be reminded of Sasha
Yeah, Luz would definitely cling to and become BFFs with Maddie and Marcy.
I can't wait to hear how Anne reacts to Eda and King
I overall enjoyed this take on Luz in Amphibia! The only two things I think is a bit confusing is if the Marcy betrayal would’ve still happened with Andrias telling Sasha about it and how Eda’s portal door was able to sent Luz to Amphibia instead and not the BI while Anne didn’t get into Amphibia when it happened right when Marcy got her the box(though that probably be explained in your “What if Anne went to the Boiling Isles?” Video). Though I still enjoyed this very much and I’m excited for part 2. I will say though I’m curious for how Anne would stay in the Boiling Isles as since Anne isn’t like Luz or Marcy who would want to stay there to live out a fantasy, it’s kinda hard to imagine her staying that long.
For a moment I didn't remembered Luz could have gone home for all season 1
"One is better than the other" I think its unfair to say that, I'd go to put one on for one reason and the other for a different one, that doesn't mean they aren't both some of the most exciting "tween cartoons" out in the last 3 years
To me this plot is kind of interesting. A human getting lost in a new world and wanting to get home and finding other humans who they never met before also wanting to get home. Also how would THIS version of Luz react to a version of Anne who went to the boiling isles.
you sure that they could charge the Heart gem? the way that it worked in amphibia is that it took the powers out of the girls and put it back in the stones. but you've made no references to Luz being connected to the stone, and as far as were aware, Anne's still the one with the heart of calamity who is presumably in the boiling isles.
i feel like luz would definitely not become as close with sprig as anne did as they wouldn’t spend to much time together or hang out much
Luz would be close with Sprig similar to how she became close with King and some others.
You should do “what if Anne, Sasha, and Marcy were sent to the boiling isle”
Okay, but how does Luz recharge the stone, when the stone's power is within Anne? The show states that the gem's powers were transferred into the girls when they used the music box, and the temple thing was them returning the power to the gems and denying their destiny.
i was lukewarm on this at first but was it really interesting how u guys put it together. This actually surprised me a bit.
Upon watching this, I wonder what Anne's journey would've been like if she ended up in the Boiling Isles
She learning magic combining with martial arts
Pretty much the first epizode would be same but in the end Anne would go home because she doesn't have any dream to become witch.
@@knucklestheceoofmemes7755 Yes and no, their many ways for Anne to stay in the boiling Isle, for instance Eda may convince Anne to stay because she may need her muscle; Anne may stay because she thinks of her friends are on the boiling Isles as well and she must search high and low for them, or maybe she stays in the demon realm because she views it as an escape from the reality of her family moving away. And that is just few out of many, personally I think Anne stays because she is enthralled by the character of Eda as a rebel and woman who does what she wants and with a disregard to what other say, and wants to follow in her footsteps.
@@maximgvozdic3009 wait her family/parents are moving away or is it just in this au ? also another reason to stay is when the portal door opens it leads to Luz's house not annes so she decides to stay until they find her house
@@maximgvozdic3009 you still didnt answer my question can you please answer it ? is anne family moving away ?
22:46 :ah yes, "grim and sasha"
This is an awesome series, i would love it if you guys did this as “what if dipper and Mabel were transported to amphibia?”
A lot of this is like if Marcy landed in Wartwood, which is understandable
8:00 I don’t think her mom is making Enchiladas usually considering she’s Dominican and Enchiladas are more Mexican I would have gone with something else. Something popular and simple in the US or something Dominican.
Thanks! I was not sure about this since I don't know too much about Dominican cousine but I was pretty sure they just said "Speaks spanish and isn't white? Mexican" kinda annoying ngl
Pizza could work just as well then.
This was interesting and makes me wish Disney would do a what if series, with that said I don’t think Luz’s mom would help/protect the Planters from Mr X so look forward to the next version of Luz in Amphibia & it sounds like your doing Anne in Boiling Isles so looking forward to that as well
Start petition for this as a miniseries
I don’t wanna be that guy, but it seems that this is based on what people want it to be and not what it would actually be.
For example: I don’t think Luz would even be able to handle the mantis. It would be much too fast and way too strong for her. Plus where could she possibly go that would neutralize the mantis without nuetralizing herself?
Im not really sure Luz would she’d be able to survive at all in Amphibia, shown in the first episode of the owl house. When it comes down to a life or death Luz isn’t really the most ready. Anne had to survive 3 days in the wild, something Luz possibly couldn’t do as she hasn’t really shown no forest actual survival skills.
This video kinda makes Luz seem like an Angel and Anne seem like a problem child. With Luz’s only notable flaw being she’s kinda “weird”. But in reality their both just as flawed as the other. And I find strange that this video doesn’t reflect that.
Some of Luz’s flaws is: Luz has a temper while Anne is more chill, Luz is frail while Anne is athletic, Luz lacks common sense while Anne atleast has an average amount, Etc.
I don’t hate Luz. She’s cool and skilled in her own ways. But this video kinda seems to overestimate her and down put Anne. Which is really strange.
And the most important thing of all, the powers of the stones, Luz (since she had no contact with the Calamity Box in the way Anne Sasha and Marcy had) wouldn't be able to charge the 2 stone
I feel like Anne in the Owl House will be more interesting
The only thing i didn't like is Luz having the Calamity Box just because yes, it would had make more sense that she found it when she arrived to Amphibia or since Sasha and Marcy are in Amphibia like the OG story they should have the box instead of Luz
And also i don't think Luz could charge the 2 stone due to it's relation with Anne from the beggining of the series
Now that i think about it Polly would be dead since Anne and Sprig are the ones who created Frobo by accident, and in True Colors Frobo is the one who save Polly, and i don't think Luz would have been able to defeat Andrias because of his strenght and the frobots army
24:00 Guess this is confirm they had this video in the closet for a while!
Speaking of season 3, it does make me wonder how it would had played out in this scenario due to Anne usage of the blue gem power. Luz would used the growth spell again against mecha Andria and they somehow destoryed the Core/ Darcy helmet before it flew off to the moon?
The best thing is between Camilla and the Plantar. Don't forget when one of them finds out about Luz's dad
@@justinsm And assuming the only change is that Luz and Anne got swapped by the portal door/Calamity Box, it's possible that Vee is still on Earth disguised as Luz.
@@Janoha17 ho oh, that I gotta see :)
@@justinsm I found weird that once spring opens up with luz about his mother she doesn't mantion ehat happened with her father, it probably has to do with when was this video made
Sasha: Hey, have you ever noticed that Luz is in a totally different art style?
Wait if luz got too amphibia through the door the calamity box still would have been in that pawn shop and still would have sent the trio too amphibia.
I feel like if anne was stuck in the owl house. She would be in panic mode
Luz would die in the first episode before anyone found her.
It is canon that both shows exist in the same universe/multiverse.
A key element I think your forgetting is that throughout s1 Luz could always go home, and even still had contact with her mom, something that would not be posable in this scenario
True, but then again she may think her friends are also on the boiling Isles as well, plus if nothing else, may Anne would stay on the boiling Isles because of how she may see Eda and the demon realm as a fourm of rebelling against her parents and the process of moving. But that's just my Ideas what are yours?
@@maximgvozdic3009 But anne didn't had any big issues with her parents and wanted to go home since season 1. The only way she may stay is as you mentioned looking for her friends
@@hectorlackless yeah that makes sense, also do think she will attended hexside in order to blend in with other Witches or not; also do you think Eda and King will influence her character?
@@maximgvozdic3009 They probably would since this videos are for that. Although realistically I don't see Anne enrolling in hexide since she wouldn't really be that interested as luz and it was a lot of trouble. Maybe just a look like luz did in "I am a teenage abomination" to see if her friends are there.
I'd hate if Luz went to Amphibia, because... (Based on mid-series and canon facts)
1: No blue Calamity user
2: Luz would be dead because Sasha won't care for random.
3: All Luz will do will show-off her glyphs because as said, "Luz cares for what others think of her" (but will epicly fail)
4: Having Anne Boonchuy in Amphibia is better than having Luz Noceda because she would easily die if she had no Calamity early signs, and glyphs only work in the World of Witches.
5: Luz would ruin all the feelings with that fruity stuff (even with frogs ,_,)
It would be really fun to see that Anne was put in the owl house world but I feel like a lot of the episodes wouldn’t happen or part may or wouldn’t I think what happened was the owl lady was using her portal to earth like normal but it went on the fritz and when Luz entered it she got out in amphibia. Then the box noticed that there was 3 kids in amphibia already and it kicked Anne into the boiling island.
23:25 A giant Luz would’ve been awesome to see.
Crossing them will mix up the portals travel so luz would end up in la not the old house this will in fact cause Anne to turn up at the old house
Literally said this like 4 episodes into these two shows, like if this was old school the cross over would have happened already
I do like the idea, but I'm glad Luz is only on The Owl House. I love Lumity so much.
Given the quality of this video, I cannot wait to see its second part and see Anne in the Boiling Isles.
You completely forgot about the best character, frobo! I am ripping myself apart wondering how Luz would feel about having a big metal baebey on the team.
They actually had an entire animatic episode crossover.
When?
@@-Devoid- It's the cast from both teams but with a fan animatic.
Hm, i have to say this were a pretty interesting Story and thought experiment,
Though, i have to say, that the beginning, as well as some certain Plot-Points, i felt were a little lazily made,
Regardless, i think this went sort of how i would’ve expected it go, especially when considering that Luz is basically Marcy if Marcy were the protagonist,
However still though, while i think this was a well enough thought out What If Story, i feel that this could’ve been thought out a little more.
Still interesting idea though.
Why aren't there books, or comics, made of this type of story telling?
Fans would *LOVE* to see this. lol
Well there is calamitous intervention.
Lotta things I could comment on, but I'll go with the last one; I think Luz would more likely try to pull a Gandalf-style "you shall not pass," giving her newfound friends a chance to escape through the portal. Could go any way from there, regarding what happens to whom.
I think both shows are good because the character development reminds me of the way it’s done in manga and anime. The characters start out underdogs and become great through effort and personal growth. 😃
I feel like Luz not resonating with any gem and Anne being missing will lead to a bad ending...
I wonder what would happen if Anna was in the Boiling Isles instead.
22:50 Grim and Sasha 💀💀💀💀
*Surprised Luz going into alternate universes didn't become a meme/writing exercise*. Well at least I enjoyed writing some what ifs they were bad but fun. Like:
-What if Luz ended up in the Ben 10 universe
-What if Luz went to Muny
-Luz's Bizarre Adventure (Steelball Run universe).
I've been stuck on The Owl House since it first started RIGHT before COVID-19 back in the start of 2020!
Yo I like this but I'm so curious how Anne is doing in the boiling isles? Like you have to make a huge crossover now.
I'm curious as to how Anne's chemistry would be with King, Eda and Hooty compared to Luz.
I think the events of the dead phone episode would also change, perhaps there was a curse that created electricity to charge her phone and the planters are looking for ingredients.
Still Amphibia and the owl house are Are both wicked awesome But they could’ve added Titan luz At the final chapter like with the owl house Finale
in teh episode of the crazy scientist lady in amphibia, we see a glance at the owl house depicted as a pixelated picture. This means, annes human world and luzs human world are in tha same universe
Wouldn't the music box bring Sasha and Marcy to the other world with Anne, and have Luz be alone in amphibia?
You also didn't really change that much, even tho you changed the main character, which should really change more than just the main character if you know what I mean.
I love this but can you do a kingdom hearts what if sora was in amphibia or the owl house set after the events of Kingdom hearts 3 he would still have access to the keyblade and all his magic and abilities including summons like Simba or stitch.
That would be awesome
@@cjgamer6356 for example Sora has to stay behind in amphibia to lock the music box after anna Sasha and Marcy leave to go back home the guardian tells Sora may his heart be his guiding key it has also met one of the keyblade wielders of the age of fairy tales the master of Masters he told the guardian that one day a keyblade wielder will come again.
@@noahdean9685 OK but what about Sora in the Boiling Isles
@@cjgamer6356 well since owl house is being canceled by Disney I don't know how it would end I'm not sure I think sora might have a little fight with the emperor or a dangerous creature like the puppeteer or the monster during gorm night maybe he'll compete in that tournament that Amity wanted to compete in it would be like the coliseum matches The collector always wanted to own a keyblade but it's unable to.
@@noahdean9685 OK how about Sora in Gravity Falls
Does anyone know what happened to Bee and Puppycat? Channel Frederator said there would be a Netflix show, but that's all we got. So are there going to be any updates? Thanks?
Well, she wouldn't meet Amity, so the internet wouldn't be as interested. XD
but she could date sasha or marcy
I was expecting luz to use clamity powers but her going huge is cool too!
i love the whole amphibia stupor for quality. Its not even a light hearted take when TOH hasn't even concluded yet
Do not give me the mental image of Luz getting stabbed by Andrias before being possessed by the Core.
Would this mean her Azura book still went to the boiling Isles?
I think this would an wonderful fanfic if the writer is able to pull it off well. Me I would have Luz stay with Maddie and her family. Also I don't think Sprig and Maddie would be engaged due to the events of Hop Luck happening differently. For the second temple, when Valeriana accuses Luz of running away, Luz would say that's not what happen. Then Valeriana say "True, but answer me this. If you had found a way back to Earth on the first day arrived, you would have stayed in Amphibia? Or would you return and go to camp like you mother wanted?" Luz would realize that she would choose to stay in Amphibia and admit this.
SPRUZ AGAINST THE WORD
Also woah you're really just swapping the two with wierd retcon magic huh
Luz and Marcy would be a crazy duo ngl
Anne's pov will be amazing looking forward what you give her powerset in a magic-dominated world
16:50 I MUST SEE THE TWO OF THEM INTERACTING WITH EACH OTHER, it does not matter how long it takes, even if it can take thousands of years!
FOR REAL!!!!!!! It would be chaos 🤚🤚🤚🤚🤚🤚🤚🤚🤚🤚🤚🤚🤚
oh man i just got a killer idea what if marcy ends up moving to connecicut
I hope they can do a what if series based on this. This would so be a must watch and a new idea to try out
.
I swear if disney ever plans to atleast bring back amphibia or the owl house for a bit, it should be these what ifs
I love it how observed if Luz ever watches suspicious island.
One thing that's minor, but is 100% incorrect is saying Luz finds frogs disgusting. This is a girl that handles snakes no problem and has no issue with spiders crawling on her.
i personally like the owl house more than amphibia lol
For sure season 3 hasn't ended yet for sure I haven't cried already
Now Images If There Was A Scenario Where The Greens From Big City Greens Moved To Brighton From The Ghost And Molly McGee And Vice Versa
"A new season is out" how long ago was this made???