The Harley Reid show, Elliot Yeo’s big offer & why Andrew Brayshaw needs to play in the guts
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 вер 2024
- Remember where you were when you watched Harley Reid destroy Melbourne because we are witnessing something really special. The boys break down both WA clubs strong wins and discuss Elliot Yeo’s monster offer from Adelaide. Schoey also has strong feelings toward Andy Brayshaw’s role in the Dockers.
PATREON
/ shelterfootycast
BackChat Ale out now!
shelterbrewing...
Music by The Southern River Band.
Shelter is born and brewed in Busselton, Western Australia.
shelterbrewing...
Follow us on Instagram: @shelterfootycast.
Shelter FootyCast is produced and recorded at BackChat Studios.
w: www.backchatpo...
ig: backchat__
e: footycast@backchatstudios.com.au
#Football #ShelterFootyCast #BackChat #ShelterFootyCast #AFL #WillSchofield #MarkReadings #westcoasteagles #fremantledockers #podcast
that Reid goal was one of the purest bit of football I have ever seen in my 75 years - thinking of Whitten Barassi Baldock Ablett - truly that was so pure no matter who you barrack for
It's something special, isn't it.
How good is Hough? One of the most improved in the comp.
Loving his effort every week proper lockdown defender
He is a gun only going to get better.
I think you mean Hough good is he?
I'll see myself out.
@@danielkneeshaw6564 nice 👏
Love the Hough. Kids a gun.
If your Yeo you would almost have to take the deal at his current stage
3 years big dollars would have to take it
1.2 million totalling around 3 million. West Coast's best offer might be 800k per season for 2 seasons. Huge difference.
Would be hard to turn down...Would you blame him as an Eagles fan?
@@BackChat Couldn’t blame him gotta think about his future.
Bubs on the way getting married at some point gives the man something to think about. His pub will still be here in a couple of years for him to come back to
One of the main criticisms of the umpire paying the free kick against Rankine was the fact there was under a minute left in a close game and the umpire needed to "sense the moment" and to "feel the moment".
In round 6 Sam Draper swan dived on the ball and it was clearly holding the ball. There are 4 on field umpires and the big criticism at that time was that none of the 4 umpire had the guts to blow the whistle as they were too scared to call it in case they got it wrong.
I will conced that there is a difference as 15metre free kicks are rarely called but if we want umps to umpire in a "situational sense" it becomes a very slippery slope quickly. When the player infringed by such a large margin then the umpires shouldn't be criticised for paying the free kick when we hounded them the other way a month ago.
There was this guy, who dived on the ball in round 6...
I've always felt that the "15m penalty" took into consideration things like speed/whether a person was being chased, not intentionally, but just due to the nature of the rule.
First umpires have a dozen things to be looking at, it's very difficult to know where a person is exactly when they get the ball, and then at what point in any given direction is 15m. If a player is running slowly it's easier to determine, or to get a sense that it's "too far".
The crowd making nervous sounds is also a bit of a giveaway that they're concerned the player either needs to dispose of it or bounce (usually dispose of it).
We all know what "obviously too far" looks like, but that range from "Alright he should think about bouncing soon" to that point is very hard to gauge.
The fact the umpire made that call, when it was 21m probably just shows how skillful he is able to ascertain that, but to me it looked like a borderline call that should have been let go.
Rankin isn't trying to run too far, he's obviously just not able to get a sense of how far he is run given the fact he's aiming on getting a goal, it's late, he's tired, he's being chased, etc.
But anyway, the point is that it's very hard for an umpire to know what 15m is exactly, and that is made even harder when that player is very quick. Quick players are much more likely to "get away" with it.
Great analysis!
Schoie carrying the commentary team again this weekend!!💪🏼
I loved watching Melbourne getting rolled by your boys.
Any chance you’d get the gig for any of the Vic, SA, QLD or NSW games?
The commentating has become quite stale.
Cheers, Buff.
Battled to conceal the barracking old schoey. In saying that good on them not much to get excited about the last. 2 years
@@eamonreeves4171 Pretty hard not to get excited about what happened on the weekend...Schoey isn't even a West Coast fan.
Where does this go up when it’s live?
Its interesting that all the Umpire calls have been against non-victorian sides. 2022 - Adelaide v Sydney ( Sth Melb), 2023 - Frem v Carlton, Adelaide v Essendon, Adelaide v Collingwood.
Let me just say when it comes to 50/50 decisions, you know which team is going to get an advantage. Surprised alot of clubs are not doing stats internally.
Should change the rules to steps taken instead of distance covered for bouncing the ball, simplifies the game.
Why have the rule in the first place? 18 on the field, close the space if a player starts running.
I think it would be waaay harder for an umpire to count steps in real time when they have so many things to look at and keep track of. It also (dis/)advantages players based on their stride length
What's Harley going to be like with 50/60 games and a full preseason under his belt.
Yeo‘s rumor came out because we are playing Adelaide soon in R11
Warner Gibney Read Kelly, like to see that
Would be unstoppable
Would eagles get the same compensation the McKay got if yeo leaves?
Like McKay, it's dependent on the contract that he is offered. North only got that pick due to how much Essendon paid him.
No audio
don't players need a career after footy. if he stays in Perth and works on business opportunities with people associated with the club then wouldn't he be better staying. He gets paid more and goes over east. But then he still needs to return here but will need to start again and his brand will be damaged because he left and he may have less opportunities.
Interesting call, will put this to the boys on Thursday.
Give Harley the rising star now.
Also fk skeetz is a good bloke
We love Skeet 😍
No audio? Or just me?
All good now.
I've got audio
Can we get Dan Curtin and a first round draft pick for Yeo? Also we need that Bulldogs defender from EP.
Do you think they would give him up?
@@BackChat I think we'll be given pick 22 approx (free agency) for Yeo. Then we'd have an extra draft pick to pick a player or package together a bid for a player. Someone in the early mid 20s would be ideal.
@BDub2024 why only 22? Genuinely curious, seeing as how North got pick 3 for McKay
@@chriskelly9476 The talk is that Yeo due to his age will be considered a free agent pick at the END of the first round. This could be anywhere from 20 to 29. Remember Eagles had first pick in the second round last year and it was pick 30. McKay had certain criteria including age which meant that North received a pick at the beginning of the first round.
@@BDub2024 thanks for the info
West coast will finish level with the dockers this year and above them next year.
WCE premiership in 2026 dockers still yet to win one
theyre three wins outside the eight
This is a massive call Aaron. Will hold you to this at the end of the year.
@@BackChat haha 😜 might be a bit of the eagles nuffy coming out of me with the call for this year but I stand by next years call
Awareness yes but I think saying a player bares responsibility also for other opponents hitting him in the head is a very poor choice of words.
Get Brayshaw to West Coast and give him number 3.
What would you be prepared to give up?
@@BackChat Actually Brayshaw has a big decision. Born and bred in Melbourne with a Melbourne fiancé. Has 8 years remaining. If he went to a club with a big corporate support he'd set himself up for life after footy. Corporate career, marketing and promotion, speaking engagements etc... IF he will end up living in Melbourne, then he may as well go now and start building contacts and a career after footy. 30 years of working, you want to utilise all your footy contacts. Pointless if he moves to Melb but his footy contacts are in Perth. Being played on the wing for Freo he'd be getting frustrated.
Your comments about Luke Parker are bizarre. Are you drunk???
He should have bounced it a second time ..as much as pains people the rules say 15 Meters ...
Haha is this the same bloke saying to leave Harley alone and stop hyping him up?
He said that by admitting his hypocrisy
@@SuperDecdog so admitting you're a hypocrite makes it ok? Naa
@@fire_titan5735 I mean, you started your comment by trying to reveal his hypocrisy, and it was diffused pretty quickly by him going, 'I know I have argued the opposite before.'
Was just a dumb comment from you
What is holding the ball these days
Apparently two of them cancel each other out
The problem with Eagles is that in next 3 year you'll have 11 of their better players retired. And some of those kids won't end up developing and will be delisted. That's the worry for the Eagles long term. Players gone will be Ryan Gaff Sheed Hunt Yeo Kelly Duggan Cripps McGovern Darling Barrass. Then you still need to delist 5 guys from the main list this year. Not rookies or academy players but main list. That's tough on some really good kids that have just had bad luck. Who is in the firing line? Rotham Burgiel (unlucky) Witherden Jamieson Culley Ledwards Hedwards... remember 2-3 retirements too. But if we bring in some free agents then you'll need more of a turnover.
Great comment. Will put this to the boys on Thursday
Yes get Fyfe out, he's basically "playing well", getting the ball, and yet his use is consistently not good.