This is by far the most powerful message of WW1 I have ever experienced. I lost my grandfather’s brother, who served in the Royal Navy during this war.
First thought was this guide was over-the-top gruesome but so was the war. So, on further thought, well done. Every kid should be aware of the horror of war.
I watched this documentary over and over. Every time I have to wipe the tears from my eyes. What an incredible group of children listening breathlessly to their inspiring tour guide. How they show respect for what happened to their ancestors over 100 years ago. I am sure that, in the end, these leaders of tomorrow will make the world a better place. A deep bow from the Netherlands
I have never been so amazed, moved, and blown away by the sheer scale of world war one. This tour guide is fantastic in impressing the sheer size and the horrifying brutal nature of the war on future generations. 5 stars
Des Brogan of Mercat Tours is indeed an incredible guide. As producers of this film we feel extremely fortunate to have had him as the anchor of our film. Thank you for your comment.
"Des is the Best about the Worst War One. " His life experiences really purposed him with a passion to form his rich words and imagery. - And those amazing students - Each of them was Each of Us. Their fresh lives and worldly self esteem was pure and strong. Their minds and hearts understood "Des" oh so human stories and spoke it too. Bless 'em all... - A HUGE Hats Off to RUMBLE TV PRODUCTIONS whose Beautifully framed, expressive and emotional photography is pure eye candy. The Editing produced even more story with expressive cuts, fades and the Real Honest Portraits of the kids speaking their Honest feelings... wow. Sound, music, everything done so well it made it an incredibly special film. YOU BUSTED A MOVE and turned a potentially bland bused battlefield tour into a multi-level'd Bounty of Beauty and Grace. Bravo - Brava - ("Bitchin' Dudes" !) -- Thanx for sharing a very clear message that Any War is too many - whatever they are called. Thanx, DRiX in Oregon. (look it up - I'll be waving at you !@@!
So sad, the costs of war. What a teaching tool for the world to see. Sobering to the extreme. Thanks so much for allowing us the privilege to watch this video.
This film, in its entirety and chapters, was produced primarily to be an education tool and indeed it is an integral part of classroom teaching in schools. The wider aim, as you say, was for the world to see it to increase awareness of the horror and sacrifice of war. Thank you for your comment.
Thank you so much for taking time to give our film your feedback and share your family connections and experiences. The horror is unimaginable and reading such powerful comments about your Grandfathers and Great Uncles really does bring it home.
My great great uncle died at the age of 36 on the 1st of may 1915 in Ypre. He thought with the middlesex regiment and he was missing and presumed dead. His whereabouts are still unknown to this day and his name appears on the mennin gate which is dedicated to those who due to the fortunes of war remains have not been found and given a proper burial. Thank you for educating those on the horrors of war by making this awesome video and thank you for making this video for all those who fell in the great war.
A beautifully made film the guide was brilliant and all Credit to those young people for the way they conducted themselves. Can't understand the mentality of those who gave the thumb down.
Des Brogan did a brilliant job with these young people in particular one of the parts which stood out amongst many to me was where, He asked them to think visualise a person not a marble slab and known to god, age build hair color temperament and how that man, brother husband father son, felt and how they died. And as one young person aptly commented they should be remembered by people all of the time and not for a day. Very respectfully made piece of film documenting their history and sacrifice.
I went on this trip and had the same tour guide, it was an amazing experience that I will never forget, it changed me as a person and I would do it again for sure. This video brought it all back and made me get as emotional as I was when I was there, thanks
Cheers to a great educator who taught his youths the cost of their freedom! Not only in terms of the lives lost, but the hardships their ancestors had to endure. I wish there were more like him.
My life has been dedicated to service, and history. Grandfather was a 14 year old volunteer who ran away to Canada to join in 1916. When asked by a Canadian recruiting post in San Francisco (yes, really), what city he was from, he had forgotten what he had written upon a previous card. So, he was asked to go outside and "think about which city you were born in". He was actually born in Chicago, 1902, so could recall something like Toronto, but I suppose he could not recall which Canadian city he had recorded earlier. Well, he got it right the second time and served with the KRRC's. This film, has touched me in a way that allows me to recall the questions I had for my Grandpa.... he had many "polished" responses/stories from WWI, so it had been a while (for him), yet he served in WWII as well (another great set of stories) . I felt, as these kids did, "What was it like Grandpa?" He would respond, "When on a machine gun, seven seconds to live", or before an "Over The Top", he said he was counting... "I have 10 seconds to live... I have 9 seconds to live...." I thank you for this film, it really touched me deeply. What I see, is myself at 14 years old, asking questions.... about service in the military... death.. and, well, "life". Many Thanks - "Well Done" and I am so VERY proud of these kids who "took the journey". I had tears in my eyes several times. - Gratitude.
What an incredible documentiary. Verry impressive, the way the children are educated by this tour guide. They will never forget this, I am sure. This is remembrance at it's best. Be proud of those who died for our freedom. Lest we forget. (hans/Netherlands)
An unbelievably well knowledgeable tour guide, tip of the hat to you sir. I feel that every school kid should be taken to visit the western front, to know and remember the horrors of what war can do to the world and to appreciate the sacrifices these brave men gave so that we could have our today.
Without doubt that is one of the greatest history lessons ever. Cleverly edited to draw the viewer into the narrative and to witness the emotions of the youngsters was a masterstroke of editing.
Great video! I have been to the battlefields of France and Belgium a few times, but I never cried as much as with this documentary. Kudos for the young people in it and for the producers...
Jesus Garcia Thank you for this comment. We thoroughly enjoyed making this documentary and the young people were a credit to their school. Would you mind if we put your comment on our website?
Ive visited the battlefield many times and have to tell you what a wonderful film this is. Not only were the students extremely respectful, but the guide was amazing and ive learned so much from this. Thank you again.
This has to be one of the best ever tributes to the soldiers of the Great War and should be viewed by all ages and generations to come.Both my grandfathers fought in this war and this gives a powerful insight into what they endured.A huge thank you to the pupils and staff who took part in this film.
Thank you for your comment and for a such an incredibly strong endorsement of our film. It gives us great pleasure to know that you found it a powerful insight. The experience was certainly very powerful for those who took part and it delights us that this is conveyed in the film and felt by those who watch. We very much hope this reaches people of all generations; this was certainly the objective of the project.
I see a lot of negative comments that's sad in my opinion. What I see is inspiring this is a group of young British, Scottish, possibly Irish children touring deeply emotional Great War sights. Several have ties with dead British soldiers. Some of the children are interviewed alone with the camera proving the youngest generation actually "get it" The children March and sing the cadence ww1 soldiers sang and, march the same path that their forefathers marched.... If you have a doubt about the generation who will be tasked with leading the world when we're gone. Then do your self a favor and watch this it will bring you some hope and relief. This is a Great video and a much different approach to education than we're all use to. These children have learned and have been exposed to our forefathers mistakes. I have no doubt it's sunk in to each of them.
Kenny Human Thank you for taking the time to comment. Such is the impact on these young people, that they will often go back on the trip a second time, without letting on about any of what will unfold over the course of the trip to their peers. It was a privilege to observe their journeys.
rumblelimited You're very welcome. It is a truly unique and awesome experience for them. I would love to have that opportunity some day too. I'm glad the kids see the value in this.
I know it's been said a few times but what a great tour guide. I've been to a few of the places in this video and it doesn't half hit you once you are 'stood in their footsteps' I like watching things like this and I've learnt a few things from watching this.Thank you.
I have watched many videos over the last week about different aspects of WW1 and they have been excellent. Informative, interesting, sad and humbling. THIS however was somehow almost tangible. The guide was so good and the kids were so moved by it all. Some were crying and for that please don't feel shame or embarrassment, it's a human emotion and you own your feelings. You were ALL a credit to your peers, your school and groups and your teachers but most of all, to yourselves. Thank you one and all.
I just found this. What a super video of a very charismatic and knowledgeable guide. The kids attending this tour had a real treat. For those who can't take part in such a tour, this video will make excellent viewing. Especially as we approach the centenary. And an excellent ending with The Corries singing "the Green Fields of France."
I was very impressed with the tour guide and even more so with the students. They cared about their own history. I have visited the Argonne where my Great Uncle is buried and hope someday to get back to Europe and visit this site. Thank you for sharing this tour.
Inspired to watch this film by the recent centenary of the Battle of the Somme. My grandfather was an artillery gunner at the Somme, and later supported the Canadians at Vimy Ridge. He made it through, having lied about his age, or I wouldn't be typing this! Glad these kids had such a wonderful guide to bring the subject to life for them.
This is a very effective documentary. The part about the Lees made me choke up. The fact that the father has the same name as the American Confederate General was ironic for me as a Yank. The tour guide is outstanding. His passion and knowledge for the subject is readily apparent.
He is the best guide I have ever heard, compassionate, articulate, caring. Well done. I am sitting with tears in my eyes thinking of the lost generation. Lest we forget
I guess this is one of the best informative education docu, for using it for pupils.The none censured therms and examples to these young kids , makes them thinking as they stood there. This is the way to show the young pubers that life today is based on expecting, but 100 years ago it was only hope in a dark time.Thank u for this film!
An exceptionally done piece. This inspires me even more to visit these sites. More importantly, many thanks to this teacher who cares enough to impart the concepts of valor, sacrifice and honor on these youngsters. The world sees too little of that today. I have had many of the same sentiments these youngsters had while visiting cemeteries in places like Gettysburg, Antietam and Fredricksburg and I always make a point to place a flower on the grave of an unknown. I have also stood in the same field as my great-great grandfather did when he was an 18 year-old in the 137th PA Vols in September 1862. He lived to be an old man and I place a flower on his grave every year also. Thank you again for this exceptional video.
Admire the Brits and Scots for the way they remember and honor their veterans. Remember what Captain Miller told Pvt Ryan...Be worthy of their sacrifice. Most Americans don't understand this.
Wonderful film, thank you so much for making such a thought provoking film. It was good to see the students taking such a genuine interest in this part of our recent history. Particular thanks also to the guide, he was fantastic, great sense of timing and he brought an even greater perspective to it. Once again, thank you.
This is an absolutely incredible documentary so so informative I thought I was there with you all. My dad's granddad was in the royal field artillery and luckily survived the war. I am planning on going on a coach holiday to the somme and other places featured in this incredible film. The students are a credit to their school and I send you all my best wishes
Thank you for taking time to comment. As producers of the film, this is really what we wanted this piece to achieve: for you to feel as though you are standing there in person and to encourage people to visit the battlefields and learn about the sacrifices of war and the importance of remembering. The students were indeed a huge credit to their school Bishopbriggs Academy.
My Grandad was in the first world war he was 18 years old never spoke about it to anyone,Only in his sleep as he got older, he screamed and screamed at night ,sometimes for his mummy and cried the devils are here again they shot all my pals my friend have gone . .R.I.P Grandad see you soon.
Amazingly powerful. Thank you so much. You've some good young people to carry on for us all. I would like to see someone here in the U.S.A. do a similar program about the Doughboys. I wish my father were here to share this. He was a DDay vet. Again, thank you.
It's hard to do one for the doughboys, as they - in the context of WWI - took only very few casualties compared to any of the other armies in the field, no disrespect to those brave boys intended. For every american cemetary you can find probably 100 of other nations. However anyone advocating for war rly should visit flanders fields, as the sheer number of graveyards, monuments, memorials etc should put anyone off from ever going to war. It would also put those who still think america won the war in their place as this attitude show nothing but disrespect to the millions of british, french, belgian, russian, italian, romanian, etc soldiers that fought bravely and were eaten up by the moloch of war, and let's not forget the german, austrian, hungarien, bulgarian etc soldiers either, they suffered just as much. If WWI should teach us anything it is that all wars are futile, and that glory in war simply doesn't exit, in war there is only suffering and death. We owe a debt of gratitude to all the men that fought during this war no matter which side they were on, their sacrifice showed us the futility and utter inhumanity of war. Unfortunately this is a lesson often forgotten by those that think that wars nowadays are 'clean', and the idiots that believe them as they bravely walk towards the guns for the glory and wealth of another.
fascinating to see Scotish/British kids views on the first world war. Watching them see the battlefields and seeing their ancestors graves in humbling. I never saw anything like this in school. I think it is pathetic that American schools teach so little about WW1. Most couldn't even tell you that more British and French died in the first world war than the 2nd. Great documentary and makes me appreciate the British people and you have a great generation ahead
@@califtom American schools teach about war. And the brutality of it. Most Americans at the time of WWI were against that stupid war. Eugene Debbs of the Christian Socialist, was jailed, Sufragette women were jailed for speaking out against this war. The white supremacist president Woodrow Wilson, finally released them, after their hunger strike. The last time any social justice legislation was passed by the US government, for working people, poor, college students, minorities, women, was in in the 1960's during the administration's of JFK/LBJ. Europe has superior social justice over the US. Universal health care, Universal education. America has been involved in perpetual war ever since. The goal of the British in WW I and WW II was protecting their empire.
Two of my Great Uncles from Forfar, Scotland both fought and died there. My Grandfather from Montreal, Canada (originally from Glasgow) served there as a Trench Runner. He never spoke one word about the war. Thank you.
A small and respectful correction to the information provided during the visit to the Vimy Memorial. The 11,285 names inscribed at the base of that beautiful monument are those of Canadian soldiers who died in France and have no known grave. The Menin Gate bears the names of another 6,940 missing Canadians who died in Belgium. It was heartwarming to see the students becoming engaged in the stories of the people who lived, and died, during that terrible conflict. Thank you.
I'm loving this video, I done this trip 14/15years ago, this guy was also my tour guide! glad this is online as one of my school teachers recorded our trip but the video tape is long gone unfortunately
Visited several sites on the Somme last month. Was stunned by the enormity of it all. Will seek out a Tour next time. Excellent production - respects to all involved.
I'm extremely impressed by the quality of this video and by the moving experience provided by this amazing tour guide. I'm very interested in the First World War, have seen many a film, and have visited many of the battle fields, but this gives the history a more vivid personal feel. Thank you for posting it.
I visited there.... It had a profound effect on me... To this day.. .. I visited Ypres 6years ago.. Hardy a day goes by that I don't think of them all. Respect .. They we're all heroes Rest in peace..
Well thank you. That is exactly what we set out to achieve with this film so your feedback is great to hear. To make the information as accessible as possible, the content is available in sections here on You Tube and to be used in schools. 'The Green Fields of France' is an extremely beautiful track of music and we are delighted that The Corries gave us permission to use it. As someone has added, Des Brogan (guide) is a legend and his WW1 Battlefields Experience is incredible.
A worthy piece of educational television. It clearly affected the youngsters taking part and hopefully will similarly deter others from seeing war as a solution to the word's squabbles.
We do indeed. Spent the best part of a week with this fine man... Des Brogan of Mercat Tours International. You should get yourself firmly booked on one of his tours as he is a legend! Can obviously recommend his WW1 Battlefields tour however he does many more. You will find his website in the video description (can't put the link here!)
They cried for their mum because those young boys lost their lives here before it begun. A complete horror story was this war, but every war is that. That common people have to die for what their leaders decided to do. Crazy is this, people never learn from the past.
Fantastic film. Very informative and very moving. I have been to many of these places myself and though there is nothing like actually being there and seeing it with your own eyes, this film really takes you on a journey.
I have watched a lot of documentaries on UA-cam about the first world war and I have only recently stumbled upon this one. I have found it very moving and despite being to the battlefields several times I have learnt a lot from this very informative tour guide. Watching the kids reactions is amazing and very moving indeed. This should be in the curriculum in every school in the country. The kids were all so respectful. Well done. An excellent documentary. Thank you!!
That good parents quote why would you want to go and look at graves. For those people who couldn't care less .we would not be here only for those brave souls. They are what you call a hero lest we forget.
An excellent teacher! Some of the terminology he used was wrong, but very inspiring. My one regret? he did not take them to St Symphorien cemetery where the grave of the first british soldier to die in WW1 faces that of the last. That really brings it home
I was watching this with interest but in a kind of detached way, but at 42:55 the emotion caught me off guard and I found myself weeping aswell. From that moment on you can see the emotion on the faces of these young people, and there are a few other weep moments that follow. Very powerful and well animated by the tour guide.
This is by far the most powerful message of WW1 I have ever experienced. I lost my grandfather’s brother, who served in the Royal Navy during this war.
First thought was this guide was over-the-top gruesome but so was the war. So, on further thought, well done. Every kid should be aware of the horror of war.
Now that how to educate our young people .these brave souls should never be forgotten.
Kudos to this teacher for really showing these kids the tragedy of it all.
I watched this documentary over and over. Every time I have to wipe the tears from my eyes.
What an incredible group of children listening breathlessly to their inspiring tour guide.
How they show respect for what happened to their ancestors over 100 years ago.
I am sure that, in the end, these leaders of tomorrow will make the world a better place.
A deep bow from the Netherlands
This documentary was such a powerful way of bringing home the horrors and sacrifice of the First World War. The tour guide was outstanding.
A wonderful tour, the guide was nothing short of brilliant.
Best tour guide I've ever seen. Even manages to hold the attention of teenagers while talking about history.
Nice to know that the youth are being taught of the sacrifices of a former generation have given for them. Canadian Proud !!
All teens in school should visit the graves of our fallen soldiers to appreciate their sacrifices and the freedoms they enjoy now.
Well said
Shame it cost £520
Heartbreaking lesson from an excellent tour guide and teacher. Lest we forget.
I have never been so amazed, moved, and blown away by the sheer scale of world war one. This tour guide is fantastic in impressing the sheer size and the horrifying brutal nature of the war on future generations. 5 stars
very sad, but what a great guide to explain the horror off war to those youngsters,
Des Brogan of Mercat Tours is indeed an incredible guide. As producers of this film we feel extremely fortunate to have had him as the anchor of our film. Thank you for your comment.
"Des is the Best about the Worst War One. " His life experiences really purposed him with a passion to form his rich words and imagery.
- And those amazing students - Each of them was Each of Us. Their fresh lives and worldly self esteem was pure and strong. Their minds and hearts understood "Des" oh so human stories and spoke it too. Bless 'em all...
- A HUGE Hats Off to RUMBLE TV PRODUCTIONS whose Beautifully framed, expressive and emotional photography is pure eye candy.
The Editing produced even more story with expressive cuts, fades and the Real Honest Portraits of the kids speaking their Honest feelings... wow. Sound, music, everything done so well it made it an incredibly special film.
YOU BUSTED A MOVE and turned a potentially bland bused battlefield tour into a multi-level'd Bounty of Beauty and Grace.
Bravo - Brava - ("Bitchin' Dudes" !)
-- Thanx for sharing a very clear message that
Any War is too many - whatever they are called.
Thanx, DRiX in Oregon. (look it up - I'll be waving at you !@@!
Wow What a Tour guide a credit to teach the kids the horrors of WW1
That best thing I did at school so educational and a eye opener as to what out troops coped with
That was a wonderful tour. I'm sure those kids will remember it for a long time.
So sad, the costs of war. What a teaching tool for the world to see. Sobering to the extreme.
Thanks so much for allowing us the privilege to watch this video.
This film, in its entirety and chapters, was produced primarily to be an education tool and indeed it is an integral part of classroom teaching in schools. The wider aim, as you say, was for the world to see it to increase awareness of the horror and sacrifice of war. Thank you for your comment.
Thank you so much for taking time to give our film your feedback and share your family connections and experiences. The horror is unimaginable and reading such powerful comments about your Grandfathers and Great Uncles really does bring it home.
My great great uncle died at the age of 36 on the 1st of may 1915 in Ypre. He thought with the middlesex regiment and he was missing and presumed dead. His whereabouts are still unknown to this day and his name appears on the mennin gate which is dedicated to those who due to the fortunes of war remains have not been found and given a proper burial. Thank you for educating those on the horrors of war by making this awesome video and thank you for making this video for all those who fell in the great war.
A beautifully made film the guide was brilliant and all Credit to those young people for the way they conducted themselves. Can't understand the mentality of those who gave the thumb down.
I'm very impressed by the insightful comments of these young people.
Brilliant video , kids showed so much respect at what they was told by the excellent tour guide.
Adorable kids. I found this video after discovering a great uncle died in WW1 and is buried there. Thanks.. showed me what he must have gone through.
Des Brogan did a brilliant job with these young people in particular one of the parts which stood out amongst many to me was where,
He asked them to think visualise a person not a marble slab and known to god, age build hair color temperament and how that man, brother husband father son, felt and how they died.
And as one young person aptly commented they should be remembered by people all of the time and not for a day.
Very respectfully made piece of film documenting their history and sacrifice.
I went on this trip and had the same tour guide, it was an amazing experience that I will never forget, it changed me as a person and I would do it again for sure. This video brought it all back and made me get as emotional as I was when I was there, thanks
An experience like this trip never leaves you. You must feel very privileged to have been. Thank you for watching.
Cheers to a great educator who taught his youths the cost of their freedom! Not only in terms of the lives lost, but the hardships their ancestors had to endure.
I wish there were more like him.
My life has been dedicated to service, and history. Grandfather was a 14 year old volunteer who ran away to Canada to join in 1916. When asked by a Canadian recruiting post in San Francisco (yes, really), what city he was from, he had forgotten what he had written upon a previous card. So, he was asked to go outside and "think about which city you were born in". He was actually born in Chicago, 1902, so could recall something like Toronto, but I suppose he could not recall which Canadian city he had recorded earlier. Well, he got it right the second time and served with the KRRC's. This film, has touched me in a way that allows me to recall the questions I had for my Grandpa.... he had many "polished" responses/stories from WWI, so it had been a while (for him), yet he served in WWII as well (another great set of stories) . I felt, as these kids did, "What was it like Grandpa?" He would respond, "When on a machine gun, seven seconds to live", or before an "Over The Top", he said he was counting... "I have 10 seconds to live... I have 9 seconds to live...." I thank you for this film, it really touched me deeply. What I see, is myself at 14 years old, asking questions.... about service in the military... death.. and, well, "life". Many Thanks - "Well Done" and I am so VERY proud of these kids who "took the journey". I had tears in my eyes several times. - Gratitude.
A thumbs up doesn't do it, a great writing, thank you Gary Alstrand.
What an incredible documentiary. Verry impressive, the way the children are educated by this tour guide. They will never forget this, I am sure. This is remembrance at it's best. Be proud of those who died for our freedom. Lest we forget. (hans/Netherlands)
Fantastic educational film, really brought home the horrors of what the WW1 soldiers endured
An unbelievably well knowledgeable tour guide, tip of the hat to you sir. I feel that every school kid should be taken to visit the western front, to know and remember the horrors of what war can do to the world and to appreciate the sacrifices these brave men gave so that we could have our today.
Without doubt that is one of the greatest history lessons ever. Cleverly edited to draw the viewer into the narrative and to witness the emotions of the youngsters was a masterstroke of editing.
Great video! I have been to the battlefields of France and Belgium a few times, but I never cried as much as with this documentary. Kudos for the young people in it and for the producers...
Jesus Garcia Thank you for this comment. We thoroughly enjoyed making this documentary and the young people were a credit to their school. Would you mind if we put your comment on our website?
Ive visited the battlefield many times and have to tell you what a wonderful film this is. Not only were the students extremely respectful, but the guide was amazing and ive learned so much from this. Thank you again.
Mr Anderson had me glued to his every word. Super video!
What a nice and very informative tour guide!
This has to be one of the best ever tributes to the soldiers of the Great War and should be viewed by all ages and generations to come.Both my grandfathers fought in this war and this gives a powerful insight into what they endured.A huge thank you to the pupils and staff who took part in this film.
Thank you for your comment and for a such an incredibly strong endorsement of our film. It gives us great pleasure to know that you found it a powerful insight. The experience was certainly very powerful for those who took part and it delights us that this is conveyed in the film and felt by those who watch. We very much hope this reaches people of all generations; this was certainly the objective of the project.
I see a lot of negative comments that's sad in my opinion. What I see is inspiring this is a group of young British, Scottish, possibly Irish children touring deeply emotional Great War sights. Several have ties with dead British soldiers. Some of the children are interviewed alone with the camera proving the youngest generation actually "get it" The children March and sing the cadence ww1 soldiers sang and, march the same path that their forefathers marched.... If you have a doubt about the generation who will be tasked with leading the world when we're gone. Then do your self a favor and watch this it will bring you some hope and relief. This is a Great video and a much different approach to education than we're all use to. These children have learned and have been exposed to our forefathers mistakes. I have no doubt it's sunk in to each of them.
Kenny Human Thank you for taking the time to comment. Such is the impact on these young people, that they will often go back on the trip a second time, without letting on about any of what will unfold over the course of the trip to their peers. It was a privilege to observe their journeys.
rumblelimited
You're very welcome. It is a truly unique and awesome experience for them. I would love to have that opportunity some day too. I'm glad the kids see the value in this.
I know it's been said a few times but what a great tour guide. I've been to a few of the places in this video and it doesn't half hit you once you are 'stood in their footsteps' I like watching things like this and I've learnt a few things from watching this.Thank you.
Thank you for taking time to comment. Glad you enjoyed it.
I have watched many videos over the last week about different aspects of WW1 and they have been excellent. Informative, interesting, sad and humbling. THIS however was somehow almost tangible. The guide was so good and the kids were so moved by it all. Some were crying and for that please don't feel shame or embarrassment, it's a human emotion and you own your feelings. You were ALL a credit to your peers, your school and groups and your teachers but most of all, to yourselves. Thank you one and all.
I just found this. What a super video of a very charismatic and knowledgeable guide. The kids attending this tour had a real treat. For those who can't take part in such a tour, this video will make excellent viewing. Especially as we approach the centenary. And an excellent ending with The Corries singing "the Green Fields of France."
I was very impressed with the tour guide and even more so with the students. They cared about their own history. I have visited the Argonne where my Great Uncle is buried and hope someday to get back to Europe and visit this site. Thank you for sharing this tour.
Inspired to watch this film by the recent centenary of the Battle of the Somme. My grandfather was an artillery gunner at the Somme, and later supported the Canadians at Vimy Ridge. He made it through, having lied about his age, or I wouldn't be typing this! Glad these kids had such a wonderful guide to bring the subject to life for them.
This is a very effective documentary. The part about the Lees made me choke up. The fact that the father has the same name as the American Confederate General was ironic for me as a Yank.
The tour guide is outstanding. His passion and knowledge for the subject is readily apparent.
He is the best guide I have ever heard, compassionate, articulate, caring. Well done. I am sitting with tears in my eyes thinking of the lost generation. Lest we forget
I guess this is one of the best informative education docu, for using it for pupils.The none censured therms and examples to these young kids , makes them thinking as they stood there. This is the way to show the young pubers that life today is based on expecting, but 100 years ago it was only hope in a dark time.Thank u for this film!
I wasnt on this particular trip but I have been on the same trip with the same guide and its very moving.
I live in the United States. Thank you so much for posting this film! I don't know what else to say.
Thank you for the amazing documentary!
ive been the somme a few times its a fantastic experience to go a see were are troops fought and to pay your respects to the men in the cemetrys
Sending all my prayers and good thoughts for the ones who lost their lives in the Great War, we shall mourne together. Respect from Romania.
It's best Great War documents film on UA-cam, lots of detail information and lots of respect for soldiers on both side.
Being apart of this was absolutely amazing. It is the best thing i have ever done
I’m looking forward to taking this tour myself, how impressive.
Oh ya, thanks for adding some of Canada's battles in this as well! Greetings from Canada (a former colony of the U.K.) :-)
This goes beyond simply the stats, strategy & tactics & adds a humanity that many war docu's don't have
I'm impressed about the quality of this video..Dutch youth should watch !
Abco van Meekeren I think that all dutch youngsters have to learn more about ww1
An exceptionally done piece. This inspires me even more to visit these sites. More importantly, many thanks to this teacher who cares enough to impart the concepts of valor, sacrifice and honor on these youngsters. The world sees too little of that today. I have had many of the same sentiments these youngsters had while visiting cemeteries in places like Gettysburg, Antietam and Fredricksburg and I always make a point to place a flower on the grave of an unknown. I have also stood in the same field as my great-great grandfather did when he was an 18 year-old in the 137th PA Vols in September 1862. He lived to be an old man and I place a flower on his grave every year also. Thank you again for this exceptional video.
EXCELLENT VIDEO, and good to see the kids showing due respect.
Lest We Forget.
Thankyou.
Admire the Brits and Scots for the way they remember and honor their veterans. Remember what Captain Miller told Pvt Ryan...Be worthy of their sacrifice. Most Americans don't understand this.
Wonderful film, thank you so much for making such a thought provoking film. It was good to see the students taking such a genuine interest in this part of our recent history. Particular thanks also to the guide, he was fantastic, great sense of timing and he brought an even greater perspective to it. Once again, thank you.
Moving!! Thank you soldiers for your sacrifice. Prayers to you
This is an absolutely incredible documentary so so informative I thought I was there with you all. My dad's granddad was in the royal field artillery and luckily survived the war. I am planning on going on a coach holiday to the somme and other places featured in this incredible film. The students are a credit to their school and I send you all my best wishes
Thank you for taking time to comment. As producers of the film, this is really what we wanted this piece to achieve: for you to feel as though you are standing there in person and to encourage people to visit the battlefields and learn about the sacrifices of war and the importance of remembering. The students were indeed a huge credit to their school Bishopbriggs Academy.
+rumblelimited This is a fantastic film and it brings the history to life...thank you for your hard work. Mark, Wisconsin, USA.
Fine & excellent education. Such a precious Up load.Thank you.
My Grandad was in the first world war he was 18 years old never spoke about it to anyone,Only in his sleep as he got older, he screamed and screamed at night ,sometimes for his mummy and cried the devils are here again they shot all my pals my friend have gone . .R.I.P Grandad see you soon.
Excellent narrator. Very moving.
Amazingly powerful. Thank you so much. You've some good young people to carry on for us all. I would like to see someone here in the U.S.A. do a similar program about the Doughboys. I wish my father were here to share this. He was a DDay vet. Again, thank you.
It's hard to do one for the doughboys, as they - in the context of WWI - took only very few casualties compared to any of the other armies in the field, no disrespect to those brave boys intended. For every american cemetary you can find probably 100 of other nations. However anyone advocating for war rly should visit flanders fields, as the sheer number of graveyards, monuments, memorials etc should put anyone off from ever going to war. It would also put those who still think america won the war in their place as this attitude show nothing but disrespect to the millions of british, french, belgian, russian, italian, romanian, etc soldiers that fought bravely and were eaten up by the moloch of war, and let's not forget the german, austrian, hungarien, bulgarian etc soldiers either, they suffered just as much. If WWI should teach us anything it is that all wars are futile, and that glory in war simply doesn't exit, in war there is only suffering and death.
We owe a debt of gratitude to all the men that fought during this war no matter which side they were on, their sacrifice showed us the futility and utter inhumanity of war. Unfortunately this is a lesson often forgotten by those that think that wars nowadays are 'clean', and the idiots that believe them as they bravely walk towards the guns for the glory and wealth of another.
fascinating to see Scotish/British kids views on the first world war. Watching them see the battlefields and seeing their ancestors graves in humbling. I never saw anything like this in school. I think it is pathetic that American schools teach so little about WW1. Most couldn't even tell you that more British and French died in the first world war than the 2nd. Great documentary and makes me appreciate the British people and you have a great generation ahead
American schools are too busy teaching transgender junk science and social justice to be bothered with history
@@califtom American schools teach about war. And the brutality of it. Most Americans at the time of WWI were against that stupid war. Eugene Debbs of the Christian Socialist, was jailed, Sufragette women were jailed for speaking out against this war. The white supremacist president Woodrow Wilson, finally released them, after their hunger strike. The last time any social justice legislation was passed by the US government, for working people, poor, college students, minorities, women, was in in the 1960's during the administration's of JFK/LBJ. Europe has superior social justice over the US. Universal health care, Universal education. America has been involved in perpetual war ever since. The goal of the British in WW I and WW II was protecting their empire.
Two of my Great Uncles from Forfar, Scotland both fought and died there. My Grandfather from Montreal, Canada (originally from Glasgow) served there as a Trench Runner. He never spoke one word about the war. Thank you.
A small and respectful correction to the information provided during the visit to the Vimy Memorial. The 11,285 names inscribed at the base of that beautiful monument are those of Canadian soldiers who died in France and have no known grave. The Menin Gate bears the names of another 6,940 missing Canadians who died in Belgium. It was heartwarming to see the students becoming engaged in the stories of the people who lived, and died, during that terrible conflict. Thank you.
Bob Penhale a
I'm loving this video, I done this trip 14/15years ago, this guy was also my tour guide! glad this is online as one of my school teachers recorded our trip but the video tape is long gone unfortunately
Great Guide. My grandfather was there and his brother and brother -in-law. Possible a couple of other relatives too.
dang,,im still watching,,,very impactual video,,teach these kids what war is,,,geeze!,,i got a lump in my throat,,,
Visited several sites on the Somme last month. Was stunned by the enormity of it all. Will seek out a Tour next time.
Excellent production - respects to all involved.
I'm extremely impressed by the quality of this video and by the moving experience provided by this amazing tour guide. I'm very interested in the First World War, have seen many a film, and have visited many of the battle fields, but this gives the history a more vivid personal feel. Thank you for posting it.
44% mortality rate...mind blowing
I visited there....
It had a profound effect on me... To this day.. ..
I visited Ypres 6years ago..
Hardy a day goes by that I don't think of them all.
Respect .. They we're all heroes
Rest in peace..
Very good work with the kids. Cheers from Mexico.
Well thank you. That is exactly what we set out to achieve with this film so your feedback is great to hear. To make the information as accessible as possible, the content is available in sections here on You Tube and to be used in schools. 'The Green Fields of France' is an extremely beautiful track of music and we are delighted that The Corries gave us permission to use it. As someone has added, Des Brogan (guide) is a legend and his WW1 Battlefields Experience is incredible.
A worthy piece of educational television. It clearly affected the youngsters taking part and hopefully will similarly deter others from seeing war as a solution to the word's squabbles.
We do indeed. Spent the best part of a week with this fine man... Des Brogan of Mercat Tours International. You should get yourself firmly booked on one of his tours as he is a legend! Can obviously recommend his WW1 Battlefields tour however he does many more. You will find his website in the video description (can't put the link here!)
Thanks for your feedback. The kids are from Bishopbriggs Academy and were impeccably behaved - an absolute pleasure to work with!
They cried for their mum because those young boys lost their lives here before it begun.
A complete horror story was this war, but every war is that. That common people have to die for what their leaders decided to do. Crazy is this, people never learn from the past.
all the death and destruction because of old men seeking power
The death and destruction is deliberate. The war was a planned sacrafice.
My great uncle tommy died in this war ......he was just fourteen .!!!!!!.....he lied about his age .RIP xxx
Fantastic film. Very informative and very moving. I have been to many of these places myself and though there is nothing like actually being there and seeing it with your own eyes, this film really takes you on a journey.
Excellent. Very educational . THANKYOU.
Absolutely fabulous video and very educational. Just what I was looking for. Thank you.
My great grandfather was a general in ww1 and ww2 aswell as my other grandfather who fought in ww2
amazing...thanks...
Very informative video. thank you! The teenagers were so attentive... wonderful kids.
I have watched a lot of documentaries on UA-cam about the first world war and I have only recently stumbled upon this one. I have found it very moving and despite being to the battlefields several times I have learnt a lot from this very informative tour guide. Watching the kids reactions is amazing and very moving indeed. This should be in the curriculum in every school in the country. The kids were all so respectful. Well done. An excellent documentary. Thank you!!
These kids are so respectful to the teacher, I don’t think American kids would behave in the manner. 👍
excellent guide no wonder i bookmarked this video
The tour guide certainly knows his stuff . This is a great vid.
That good parents quote why would you want to go and look at graves. For those people who couldn't care less .we would not be here only for those brave souls. They are what you call a hero lest we forget.
I really enjoyed this..well filmed..well documented..and i have personally been there..very sombre
Fascinating. Thank you for this.
i did the same tour with my school and was incredible
An excellent teacher! Some of the terminology he used was wrong, but very inspiring. My one regret? he did not take them to St Symphorien cemetery where the grave of the first british soldier to die in WW1 faces that of the last. That really brings it home
Amazing.
I went here in a trip and did all the same stuff such an experience
This was very insightful. I felt like I was a student on tour with them
It was a fantastic experience for us too Emma
I was watching this with interest but in a kind of detached way, but at 42:55 the emotion caught me off guard and I found myself weeping aswell. From that moment on you can see the emotion on the faces of these young people, and there are a few other weep moments that follow. Very powerful and well animated by the tour guide.