In a way, floch was burdened by that speech. As the sole survivor of that charge, he felt like he HAS to make a difference, no matter the cost, to give meaning to all the lives that are lost
@@transfo47 yes, but I wasn't criticizing his morals, I was saying he was burdened with guilt of sending the cadets and Erwin to hell, and that's why he has to do something about it
@Amro, Recruiting a strong soldier like Levi, using Eren’s titan for Paradise’s benefit, Almost sacrificing himself to overthrow the corrupt royals. He pretty much fought for Paradise. His goal was only there so he didn’t end himself like Reiner almost did.
@@bishopalexander9164 wrong. His primarly goal was to save humanity in the end and he proved it. He could have run to the basement to get his answer before diying but he choose to die on the battlefield for humanity. He did exactly what Levi said "abandon your dream and lead the recruits into hell". He died sacrificing himself and his dream for humanity in the end, by respect for those who did the same under his command. A true hero indeed
Even if it's fiction, the show used the best way to convince soldiers to give up their lives: make them believe they're a part of something greater, that will continue even after their deaths You're not a person trying to survive, you are the country's shield, mankind's protectors, the first line of the whole
yea, but the difference is that erwin himself was giving away his life, he wasnt being hypocritical like generals in a room (as in real life) he was spitting out the cruel true, the cruel reality and accepting that he had to do what he gotta do
In a way he's actually very manipulative and would not care to sacrifice anyone, anything or even himself to achieve his goals. But that's what make him the goat. That's the kind of person you'll need to achieve victory when the circumstances are hard. What a beautifully written character. 👏
'sacrificing their own humanity in order to bring change to a world where those who cannot sacrifice the important things in life will not change anything.'
What’s amazing about this scene is that I have never watched this anime but my brother has shown me this scene and I was ready to charge to my death on a horse for Erwin. So powerful
So Erwin's speech starts off like yea life is meaningless before he quickly turns it around and says that's not true. Some headass got excited and went "what a speech!" when Erwin's still talking about hopelessness 🤣
we were doing a marathon of the whole show coz it was my first time but wasn't my brother's. since his death, i cried ALL THE WAY till s4p1 (which was the latest one at that time). every episode. my brother has to consider stopping coz he was worried, i was bawling and my chest was hurting
Erwin's speech did not just resonate in the AOT, basically the ENTIRE HUMAN RACE, fighting WHATEVER, be it Titans, Aliens, cosmic horror, anomalies, everything, it just FITS.
Smh people still had the audacity to question Floch’s mission , how do u witness this and be like yeah let me help protect the world and damn my country smh
Soy latinoamericano y al ver esta escena veo un hombre que murio con dignidad y heroismo por eso honraremos al comandante erwin como un heroe de la legion de reconocimiento
Can someone tell any other Animes with these kinda feels and vibes and speeches... Like the I still get goosebumps when I watch this scene and hear Erwin... I'll be thankful if someone tell me some good similar vibe series!
Not in the same way as erwin, but i feel like black clover and vinland saga especially vinland saga has a lot of these type deep speeches, not necessarily exact same feeling as this though different emotions. Also code geass has some good ones
Am I the only one who viewed erwin as a villain I respected him but at the end of the day he was throwing the lives of thousands away all for the sake of answering the questions only he cared about yes he wanted to help but at the end he would've thrown it all away for awnsers
You are the only one. If answers was the only thing he cared, he would have saved his life in order to witness those answers. Especially when those answers were just a few metres away from him. He cared for those answers cos he knew that it was the best bet for humanity's survival. Without knowing the true scope of things, humanity would not survive the onslaught of Titans. He sacrificed his life and that of his soldiers so that the rest of humanity is one step closer to being saved.
I love the sub version of the anime but how this speech is presented in dub is just so much better hearing them both i much prefer the speech in dub a lot more emotion
Actually if u watch it u will know the answer, bcs Erwin already explain it Let me tell you, they can climb the wall but they can't retreat to headquarters district trost, bcs the only way is using horse. even horse need a day night trip, using cable is complete mistake bcs their gas is limited. Ok what about just stay and hide in the upper side wall, yeah sounds make sense, but they are human and need Supplies, meanwhile titan didn't, beast titan armor titan and colossal they're must be have much supplies bcs they bring cart titan who can bring supplies for them But survey corpse didn't. Yes they did bring supplies but just for few days if am not wrong Erwin said less then a week, So if they climb the wall and wait. Titan will not kill them but hungry will kill them all So the only way is distracting beasts titan focus, with suicide rage run so Levi can come close and kill him once for all Yeah that's why i love AoT every victory is gain by really high price, even sometimes not equal. In this scene it's like u play chess sacrifices everything but 1 pawn so u can check mate the king enemy Adding if u still confused Beast titan already block the way for horse to hide to the other side of the wall with Boulder, and with chip stone aiming for horse Their position like this HQ - BEAST TITAN - SURVEY CORPSE - SHIGANSINA DISTRICT That's why they can't just run with horse bcs in their back is titan corpse
@@adrianlubis7889 I see that makes sense. But for me I think I would take my chance with ODM gear and walk the walls and try to survive with normal titans along the way. u know what i mean.
I will still say this. "erwin is the one who should have been revived". call me toxic if you want. I will remain as firm as a pole star on this opinion P. S: his death is what made floch go apeshit and I love that. Lord eren, King floch and God erwin.
no bruh , armin was the key . believe it or not but during erwin's time of being the commander , the survey corps didn't make any progress and just kept losing till eren and armin came , don't forget all of this was armin's plan , not erwin's . if armin wasn't there , they would have been long dead including eren . and erwin couldn't have done anything to influence eren during the rumbling , armin is basically the main character if we look at it from a hero pov instead of the protagonist pov
![[Full Episode] Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba Season 2 Episode 10/17 Reaction Mashup | 鬼滅の刃](/img/n.gif)
My heart beat rises whenever i hear erwin voice, its like thunder
@@risottoner0 bruh
That is the best description 😭
@@risottoner0 sure i will watch
@@risottoner0 oraoraora
hu guru 🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲
Little did we know, that speech would turn Floch into a MENACE
King Floch 🤭😝💅🏼
In a way, floch was burdened by that speech. As the sole survivor of that charge, he felt like he HAS to make a difference, no matter the cost, to give meaning to all the lives that are lost
@@davidtitanium22 like captain Levi, but without the skill that comes with it
@@meandtheboys9356 Not really, Levi has morals. He's not just some robot. For example, he revived Armin instead of Erwin (even if he regretted it).
@@transfo47 yes, but I wasn't criticizing his morals, I was saying he was burdened with guilt of sending the cadets and Erwin to hell, and that's why he has to do something about it
Erwin Smith, one of the greatest heroes of aot. Fighting to save humanity and free eldians from titan rule
you mean fighting for his dream
Wasn't fighting for humanity, his dream just happened to align with humanity's goals. Even still, he's by far my favorite. Long live Erwin.
@Amro, Recruiting a strong soldier like Levi, using Eren’s titan for Paradise’s benefit, Almost sacrificing himself to overthrow the corrupt royals. He pretty much fought for Paradise. His goal was only there so he didn’t end himself like Reiner almost did.
@@bishopalexander9164 wrong. His primarly goal was to save humanity in the end and he proved it. He could have run to the basement to get his answer before diying but he choose to die on the battlefield for humanity. He did exactly what Levi said "abandon your dream and lead the recruits into hell". He died sacrificing himself and his dream for humanity in the end, by respect for those who did the same under his command. A true hero indeed
He is not fighting for that at all 😂😂.
Man i cried like a baby for erwin 😭
Do not defile his soul by crying, he died for us
@@ilgrandeverro8392 😂
Erwin could convince me to do literally anything.
It is I, Erwin.
I have fallen on hard times and need some money to send to the Titan fighters because of Eren.
Will you assist me soldier?
@@thato8000 Sir, yes, sir.
@@ezioblazesit9017My soldiers do not ignore, or report. My soldiers wire! My soldiers send! My soldiers PayPal!
@@thato8000YES I WILL!🫡
Even if it's fiction, the show used the best way to convince soldiers to give up their lives: make them believe they're a part of something greater, that will continue even after their deaths
You're not a person trying to survive, you are the country's shield, mankind's protectors, the first line of the whole
yea, but the difference is that erwin himself was giving away his life, he wasnt being hypocritical like generals in a room (as in real life) he was spitting out the cruel true, the cruel reality and accepting that he had to do what he gotta do
nope, dying for the living is meaningless, thats why the most scary thing for athiests is dying, on the other hand the best thing is faith in God
@@_Cfocus you dont decide whats meaningless or not, they do, and they had faith, faith in their comrades
@@_Cfocus i'm not atheist but you thoroughly misjudged them if that's what you believe
@@user-ph9lq9ss9mspeech so effective, Floch lived and just tried go give meaning to all the suicide chargers till another death
I like how the manga shows how badly Erwin was injured. His horse’s face and his stomach had a huge hole from the rock.
Every man from the military should listen to this.I said to my uncle to listen to this as he is in army and I'mma jus' say...HE CRIED ALOT😭
Erwin turned Floch into an absolute BEAST lmao
Floch : I will treasure this man's speech in my whole life 🔥🔥🔥
In a way he's actually very manipulative and would not care to sacrifice anyone, anything or even himself to achieve his goals. But that's what make him the goat. That's the kind of person you'll need to achieve victory when the circumstances are hard.
What a beautifully written character. 👏
'sacrificing their own humanity in order to bring change to a world where those who cannot sacrifice the important things in life will not change anything.'
Precisely thats why people love him
It's enough to make a grown man cry😢
What’s amazing about this scene is that I have never watched this anime but my brother has shown me this scene and I was ready to charge to my death on a horse for Erwin. So powerful
Erwiin made floch a changed man 🔥
A true acension to menacehood.
Whenever I hear his speech, I get goosebumps
Best commander ever i'd follow him to the bitter end
I will gladly stand at his side as we charge head first into our deaths
shit would've been different if erwin had lived
they wouldnt also figure out reiner is in the walls
@@senji8719 they figured it out when Armin was alive
Honestly Armin didn't do shit in season 4 he should've died
@@senji8719 Armin isn't dead yet that time lmao
Indeed, he would've gotten way more soldiers killed.
This is the only anime scene I’ve watched where the English dub of this absolutely crushed the performance. #1 anime moment for me in all history.
I just can't cry bcz of that speach , real respect 🌷
Bruh the 3rd guy on right was really feeling it
So Erwin's speech starts off like yea life is meaningless before he quickly turns it around and says that's not true. Some headass got excited and went "what a speech!" when Erwin's still talking about hopelessness 🤣
Third one down on the right hand side was trying way too hard to pretend he hadn't watched it before.
He turned whimpering cowards into men turned them into warriors
Erwin may be just a human but he has the heart of a Super Saiyan, the voice of thunder and the balls of meteorite.
Yup. I still cry after all these years 😢
Man up until this point AOT was arguably one of the greatest works of fiction ever created.
It still is
we were doing a marathon of the whole show coz it was my first time but wasn't my brother's. since his death, i cried ALL THE WAY till s4p1 (which was the latest one at that time). every episode. my brother has to consider stopping coz he was worried, i was bawling and my chest was hurting
i love how they were all blabing the whole video but when Floch started speaking they shut up and focused on the moment
Erwin GOAT Smith, you transformed the life of your spiritual son and your worthy heir during this charge...
Bro that little laugh got me while I was being emotional
All that when He was told to let his dream die.
Erwin's speech did not just resonate in the AOT, basically the ENTIRE HUMAN RACE, fighting WHATEVER, be it Titans, Aliens, cosmic horror, anomalies, everything, it just FITS.
after optimus prime, erwin has the best speeches period..
Period
erwin is far greater
This guy speech is so good you actually want to go in and ride a horse with all of them
Man i would die for Erwin Smith in that chapter
This one is amazing but the dub for this speech hits me so differently I use a remix at the gym lol
Erwin Smith was Floch's spiritual father.
both hange and erwin died sacrificing themselves, rip to the best commanders✊
小野さん素晴らしい👏！このセリフに魂が入ってる。鳥肌たちました。
進撃は声優も含め質が高いですよね！
Damn, i would never hesitate shit or having a second thoughts if erwin convince me to fight the Beast Titan Alone.
Same shit
Smh people still had the audacity to question Floch’s mission , how do u witness this and be like yeah let me help protect the world and damn my country smh
Este capítulo me rompió por completo, venía amando al comandante Erwin Smith y cuando murió lloré como un niño pequeño
Soy latinoamericano y al ver esta escena veo un hombre que murio con dignidad y heroismo por eso honraremos al comandante erwin como un heroe de la legion de reconocimiento
Erwin breaths
humanity - LET'S FUCKING GOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Gosh! Too many chills!
Me, I just started crying once the episode ended.
Gotta say this anime is not golden, nor diamond. It’s fcking neutron star. It’s too good, simply put it. And yes, one of the best cliff hanger ever.
It's a fucking Masterpiece, easily among my top 2 of my favorite shows of all time
@@alphagamer9505 Ik it's way too late, but... What's the other?
@@Akshay_PJO its not too late,its Breaking Bad
@@alphagamer9505 Ayyy, my man (or woman, etc.) 🤝
I think the soundtrack make it hit harder!!!
Erwin will stay as the Greatest Commander to ever life 😭
Best Season! When Erwin died and the hype as well.
their face is so funny omg😂😂😂😂😂
That's why real japanese warriors has a lot of courage.. because of they're speech.
heishi yo, ikare! heishi yo, sakebe! heishi yo, tatakae
The guy who yell OOOOOOOOOO makes this better lol😂
この作品の描写で日本の特攻や切腹が、外国の方に変に誤解されずに済むのかも…知れない
King Floch 👑 in making
このアニメのこのシーンを観たことのあるウクライナ人とロシア人が今、実際の戦場で戦ってると思うと辛いな。
戦争は残忍で、誰もそれを望んでいないのに、あなたがどのように感じているかは理解できます。
Erwin : sinzo sasageyo
Me : yess my lord
Erwin went to beast mode
If he wanted me to jump out of a plane without a parachute I’d listen
Can someone tell any other Animes with these kinda feels and vibes and speeches... Like the I still get goosebumps when I watch this scene and hear Erwin... I'll be thankful if someone tell me some good similar vibe series!
Boku no Pico
Macross Saga. Gundam Saga. Legend of the Galatic Heroes. Space Cruiser Yamato. Space Runaway Ideon. Gunbuster.
@Johan, I hate u😂
Not in the same way as erwin, but i feel like black clover and vinland saga especially vinland saga has a lot of these type deep speeches, not necessarily exact same feeling as this though different emotions.
Also code geass has some good ones
One Piece has a lot of great speeches and moments that are very emotional
Erwin can convince me to punch Chuck Norris in the face.
I need him to give me a speech at my wedding
Theyd be in tears if they heard the dubbed version
DAISUKE ONO IS A GOD FOR THIS
And people overlooks this just cuz Sieg (Zeek) got abs...
Erwin : all troops line up!
Reaction mashup : -_-🔇
Isayama you fuking master.
This scene in dub just hits different
「我々はここで死に 次の生者に意味を託す」
潔い🗡🏯サムライだ
Erwin was My fav character man
Con ese discurso. Consagré mi corazón 🫡
Please do Gilgamesh vs Shirou final fight ubw.
I second this
Гильгамеша слили
why the man at the right corner laughing wtf💀
9.11の時アメリカメディアが自爆テロを「kamikaze」って表現してたけど，「お前らこれ見た後にあの自爆テロとこのエルヴィンの攻撃を同一視できんの？」っていう諌山先生のアメリカ世論に対する強烈なアンチテーゼが含まれてるよな
Am I the only one who viewed erwin as a villain I respected him but at the end of the day he was throwing the lives of thousands away all for the sake of answering the questions only he cared about yes he wanted to help but at the end he would've thrown it all away for awnsers
You are the only one.
If answers was the only thing he cared, he would have saved his life in order to witness those answers. Especially when those answers were just a few metres away from him.
He cared for those answers cos he knew that it was the best bet for humanity's survival. Without knowing the true scope of things, humanity would not survive the onslaught of Titans. He sacrificed his life and that of his soldiers so that the rest of humanity is one step closer to being saved.
@@scientia.veritas well said.
Some people just lack the brain cells to think or size up situations
Heroic
Erwin Smith, what a fucking chad.
RIP Jotaro
he has massive iron balls
The dub was fire 🔥🔥🔥
Tatakae !!!
声优是真强
Erwin is GOAT
I love the sub version of the anime but how this speech is presented in dub is just so much better hearing them both i much prefer the speech in dub a lot more emotion
Archer vs lancer UBW
Chills
Erwins still....Erwins still...ohhhmam
This scene in dub 100%
Im sorry if im wrong but cant they use the cable thing to jump over the wall?
I think bcs they need to keep the beast titan away from eren n his group (who are fighting Reiner/Bertholdt)
but technically they can indeed still run away using their gear
I think even if they tried, there wouldn't be a high chance of success since they may get hit mid air. But the chance does exist.
Actually if u watch it u will know the answer, bcs Erwin already explain it
Let me tell you, they can climb the wall but they can't retreat to headquarters district trost, bcs the only way is using horse. even horse need a day night trip, using cable is complete mistake bcs their gas is limited.
Ok what about just stay and hide in the upper side wall, yeah sounds make sense, but they are human and need Supplies, meanwhile titan didn't, beast titan armor titan and colossal they're must be have much supplies bcs they bring cart titan who can bring supplies for them
But survey corpse didn't. Yes they did bring supplies but just for few days if am not wrong Erwin said less then a week,
So if they climb the wall and wait. Titan will not kill them but hungry will kill them all
So the only way is distracting beasts titan focus, with suicide rage run so Levi can come close and kill him once for all
Yeah that's why i love AoT every victory is gain by really high price, even sometimes not equal. In this scene it's like u play chess sacrifices everything but 1 pawn so u can check mate the king enemy
Adding if u still confused Beast titan already block the way for horse to hide to the other side of the wall with Boulder, and with chip stone aiming for horse
Their position like this
HQ - BEAST TITAN - SURVEY CORPSE - SHIGANSINA DISTRICT
That's why they can't just run with horse bcs in their back is titan corpse
@@adrianlubis7889 I see that makes sense. But for me I think I would take my chance with ODM gear and walk the walls and try to survive with normal titans along the way. u know what i mean.
KAMIKAZE ATTACK
I am so glad that they didn’t bring him back, it would ruin the whole meaning or his character.
Who is the girl with purple hair and the hat at the bottom?
Erwin just changed floch
3:27 la ptm que buen seiyu el de erwin.
Who is the Indian girl to the left?
I will still say this.
"erwin is the one who should have been revived".
call me toxic if you want. I will remain as firm as a pole star on this opinion
P. S: his death is what made floch go apeshit and I love that.
Lord eren, King floch and God erwin.
nice that someone give some credits to floch
no bruh , armin was the key . believe it or not but during erwin's time of being the commander , the survey corps didn't make any progress and just kept losing till eren and armin came , don't forget all of this was armin's plan , not erwin's . if armin wasn't there , they would have been long dead including eren . and erwin couldn't have done anything to influence eren during the rumbling , armin is basically the main character if we look at it from a hero pov instead of the protagonist pov
Erwin reincarnated as floch
I would follow Erwin to hell if he asked
You better die when erwin command the charge
intro them name ?