19:38 No need to imagine, India did captured almost whole lahore in 1965 and the soldiers even took pics in front of the Lahore police station with Indian flag. Even alot of Punjabi troop went in lahore to see their paternal properties.
Yeah I was reading more about it after the video. Why would India agree to the terms of Russia and USA and end the war and give the land back. They could have pushed and taken all of Pakistan with just a bit more time
@@ReldrikGeo nah I don't think it would have been realistic...first, the us and soviets could (probably) be engaged in a war (which could have been nuclear especially after the cuban missile crisis in 1962) and secondly, the mentality of the people. Religion is a very big thing here and even if Pakistan was captured, there would be countless communal riots and massacres. Eventually it would turn into a civil war. Also the Chinese would be waiting for the right moment to strike again.
@@ReldrikGeoI think we don’t have a choice back then because we are economically exhausted and lacking good diplomacy regarding close ties, cooperation etc. India was not able to counter the pressure from two major superpowers US and Soviet. (The Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Cooperation was signed in August 1971; so, India- Soviet Union’s close cooperation was not a thing in this war )India captured significant land in Pakistan, despite having upper hand, Army de-escalated and land was given back.
But in hindsight I think partition of India was ultimately a blessing in disguise imagine the population ratio ( 17 percent Moslems of india + 99 percent moslem of Pakistan and Bangladesh) would have led to the formation of a super Islamic nation and we all know what happens to minorities in moslem countries.
6:12 A crucial error or blatant lie in the video - J&K's ascession to India was in exchange for Indian military aid AFTER the invasion by Pakistani militias initiated the conflict. Maharaja Hari Singh had tried to stay independent...! Kashmir's decision did create the war, the war created the decision!
their is no one who gives as detaild analysis as reldrik.... most of the people just give reactions just for views....meanwhile reldrik provides actual details....which is good.... keep it up brother....we also learn lot of new things from your learnings...
i hate when people say india is a new country, we all know about east INDIA company (1700s), before that it was hindustan, before that it was bharat or bharatvarsh, and before that it was aryavart. there was always a concept of india. Chandragupta maurya, ashoka, marathas, delhi sultanate, mughals, british many formed an empire that covered entire region of indian subcontinent.
@@ReldrikGeo Remember. Brits of those times never bothered to learn the authentic pronunciation of words foreign to them and they created their own versions. Now other English speaking countries, especially the US, are propagating the same distorted pronunciations. I can give you multiple examples of such words commonly used in Modern English if you want.
Many of the channels you react to like real life lore, cogito, odd compass, useful charts and the graphic earth and India in pixels and now the armchair historian are all the channels i subscribed to. They are all great channels.
Now I look at this war after Independence It's just war ok not operations 1. 1947-1948 1st Indo pak war After then direct 2. 1961 India Portugese war 3. 1962 1st Indo Sino war 4. 1965 2nd Indo pak war 5. 1967 2nd Indo Sino war 6. 1971 3rd Indo pak Between 1960 to 1971 it was continuous war after war of India 7. 1999 Kargil war (4th Indo Pak war)
India was not the first to start the war, it was pakistani militant on one side and pak army on other side opened front....india with full force defended and entered lahore
@ReldrikGeo I think it's more than fair if you end up adding like a spin wheel or just scroll until the timer stops and that's the pick would be a dope series outro
The British aren't to blame for causing the partition; it was bound to happen The Brits did indeed go about the partition in such a way that the region was in perennial conflict.
Indian army captured Lahore and started marching towards Islamabad you can see historical images taken by some soldiers you clearly see the Indian flag over the popular landmarks of Lahore so technically India captured pakistani land during war but as our moral values and ingrained culture after war ended india returned the occupied land back to Pakistan.
the prime minister of India , Shastriji were found deceased in his room in Taskent, after signing the peace agreement. Cause of death was natural but.....just saying
On 11 January 1966, India's second Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri died in Tashkent, USSR (now Uzbekistan) after signing the Tashkent Declaration with Pakistani President Ayub Khan.
@ReldrikGeo No, it wasn’t part of the conflict, but there are theories suggesting external involvement, especially the USA or USSR. Shastri's work with Dr. Homi Bhabha on atomic energy at the time adds fuel to these speculations. Both passed away under mysterious circumstances in quick succession.
5:59 This is such a gross oversimplifaction. Numerically, the Muslims were in majority; but they were all mostly concentrated in barely 10-15% area of the entire disputed region; the rest was non-Muslim.
When partion happened jinnah named the newly formed country pakistan hoping india will be renamed as Hindustan which will create a image one country is for muslims and other for Hindus but nehru opt for name india . And as pakistan was created from religious idea as home for muslims they assumed jammu and kashmir will be the part of pakistan as it has majorly muslim population but the ruler of Kashmir was hindu and he didn't wanted to be part of any country pakistan unsatisfied try to inforce there way in j&k . To protect the princely state of j&k, ruler of j&k signed a treaty with india which is popularly known as article 370 . After which India helped j&k to protect from invasion of pakistan.
That's blatant ignorance, Pakistan's economy and currency was doing better at that time and was being provided weapon far more advance than what India had by the US. Pakistan had America's support even with the setting up of terrorist organizations for guerilla warfare.
Just a suggestion you should react to defences detective as he has covered all the wars fought between India and Pakistan in detail with facts and proper information
This guy's views and opinions about the war were as western as his pronunciation of Kashmir. Even so, he got a lot of the facts right about the war, so I can't fault him entirely.
5:18 o no none of the young brits know any of the evil deeds done by their ancestors there is no such discussion in their history books i was once looking at a video about british college students reacting to a video about jalian wala bag incident & then i came to know that they know nothing about their dark history & at the end of the video they just said that o it was all the previous generations we have nothing to do with it we don't fell responsible for any of it man i died laughing hearing them 😂😂😂 & thinking how much unaware could they be of their own history 😂
@ReldrikGeo well America didn't remove the native american's history , Australia went ahead two steps and is constantly trying their level best to repay the native black australian people for their historical wrong doings by giving them free housing space, food , education & many other facilities
Hy did you know if you see in the african continent most of the countries have a straight border line 😂 even that's also because of the brits they literally just drew lines on the map on a table by a ruler & divided the entire continent among the other colonizers 😂😂😂😂 man that's both funny & sad at the same time😅
@@ReldrikGeo my point was we know more about World wars and civil wars in other countries like lebnon and shrilanka even Belgium politics than our own wars I studied history till 10th standard and there was hardly mention of any Indo-Pak wars while indo Chinese war was briefly mentioned somewhere i dont remember
A misinformation by armchair historian. He said that, the first Kashmir war started as Maharaja hari singh of kashmir joined india. This is false. Infact, Pakistan attacked Kashmir first which forced the Maharaja to ask India to help him. India told him that India cant help until Kashmir joins India and becomes Indian territory. It was Pakistan's attack which forced Maharaja of Kashmir to join hands with India.
Yeah, the submarine was leased to Pakistan for 4 years and India sank it. Pakistan said that it sank because of an internal explosion or because of the mines it was setting but that makes it look even worse. Either India destroyed it or it was their own incompetence that caused it to sink lol
@@RigelVision I am feeling that the way you are pronouncing it is under influence Persian language. Where are you from and where do people pronounce it like this? I make me completely wrong, but you can correct me. As per my understanding, in all the languages where the word Kashmir is taken from Sanskrit it is either pronounced as "Kaa(ka)-Sh-Mir(meer)" or "Kaa(ka)-S-Mir(meer)". I never knew that "Ku" sound (like in "Kumar") comes in that word.
@@newname69 w pakistan 🤓? Sure buddy. 1) Constant political instability. 2) Military involvement in politics. 3) Compromised fake elections 4) Filled with many terror outfits. 5) Always on verge of bankruptcy. 6) Always ask for more loans to pay previous loans. 7) School textbook filled with inaccuracies and false narratives. Your country is so f**ked
@@ReldrikGeo don't worry they are delusional to the core. Till now none of their prime ministers completed their full term in the office, their military controls everything, and the economy is in the shambles and it's running on foreign given loans but still they think Pakistan is the best country in the world.
@Omnitaku7 No, I'm not. Its true that India is focusing on internal growth, but Pakistan is not and therefore, our focus can be easily distracted by Pakistan and Peace can't be established until Pakistan and Bangladesh focus on their own growth.
19:38 No need to imagine, India did captured almost whole lahore in 1965 and the soldiers even took pics in front of the Lahore police station with Indian flag. Even alot of Punjabi troop went in lahore to see their paternal properties.
Yeah I was reading more about it after the video. Why would India agree to the terms of Russia and USA and end the war and give the land back. They could have pushed and taken all of Pakistan with just a bit more time
yeah bro why not
@@ReldrikGeo nah I don't think it would have been realistic...first, the us and soviets could (probably) be engaged in a war (which could have been nuclear especially after the cuban missile crisis in 1962) and secondly, the mentality of the people. Religion is a very big thing here and even if Pakistan was captured, there would be countless communal riots and massacres. Eventually it would turn into a civil war. Also the Chinese would be waiting for the right moment to strike again.
@@newname69must hurt deep in ur bund.
@@ReldrikGeoI think we don’t have a choice back then because we are economically exhausted and lacking good diplomacy regarding close ties, cooperation etc. India was not able to counter the pressure from two major superpowers US and Soviet. (The Treaty of Peace, Friendship and Cooperation was signed in August 1971; so, India- Soviet Union’s close cooperation was not a thing in this war )India captured significant land in Pakistan, despite having upper hand, Army de-escalated and land was given back.
Pakistan has fought 4 wars with India , all started by Pakistan, Pakistan lost all of them
okay jeet
@@newname69😂 suars are out 😂
Pakistan lost all, but India didn't win all
@@newname69 soovars should just stay away I suggest.
@arnavranka4510 cry
Pakistan always started the wars and spectacularly lost all of them 😂😂
Yeah, their number of losses seem to be much higher
@@ReldrikGeo much higher??
It's 4-0 😂
But in hindsight I think partition of India was ultimately a blessing in disguise imagine the population ratio ( 17 percent Moslems of india + 99 percent moslem of Pakistan and Bangladesh) would have led to the formation of a super Islamic nation and we all know what happens to minorities in moslem countries.
Yes I've seen videos of what happens
6:14 The Maharaja wanted to stay independent. He acceded to India only after Pakistan invaded Jammu and Kashmir.
Same happened in Hyderabad
@sajidmalik7563 Hyderabad was a different scenario; it was not border state; it was homogeneously non-Muslim majority throughout
The maharaja was an idiot. Sorry not sorry
All war fought... India lost ZERO...now that's some level of Flex 😂
.China enters the lobby.
.Not_Deb left the lobby.
Except 1962 under the weakest prime Minister kabootarbazz nehru.
@@Harsh-oh2ev The ability to Read the Frikin Title of the Video comes and Harsh leaves
@@Not_Deb I am replying to Not_Deb's lame comment. Not replying to arm chair historians title of the video.
@@Harsh-oh2ev Dumas the all war are in the context of Paxtan...R3tards everywhere ffs
no pakistan was the first to engage in war in kutch and in kashmir,, they crossed the international border
Yeah I read more about it after the video
6:12 A crucial error or blatant lie in the video -
J&K's ascession to India was in exchange for Indian military aid AFTER the invasion by Pakistani militias initiated the conflict. Maharaja Hari Singh had tried to stay independent...!
Kashmir's decision did create the war, the war created the decision!
True
their is no one who gives as detaild analysis as reldrik....
most of the people just give reactions just for views....meanwhile reldrik provides actual details....which is good....
keep it up brother....we also learn lot of new things from your learnings...
i hate when people say india is a new country, we all know about east INDIA company (1700s), before that it was hindustan, before that it was bharat or bharatvarsh, and before that it was aryavart. there was always a concept of india. Chandragupta maurya, ashoka, marathas, delhi sultanate, mughals, british many formed an empire that covered entire region of indian subcontinent.
Yeah India has always been around at different points in time it just had many divisions and kingdoms come through. Much like China in a way
"Cash mere" is what Westerners would pronounce it as
Its an incorrect pronunciation in this region.
Yeah that's what I thought
@@ReldrikGeo Remember. Brits of those times never bothered to learn the authentic pronunciation of words foreign to them and they created their own versions. Now other English speaking countries, especially the US, are propagating the same distorted pronunciations. I can give you multiple examples of such words commonly used in Modern English if you want.
No Pakistan started first with Operation Gibraltar
but india started full scale war
Yeah, Pakistan went in and tried to cause the locals to revolt and India stepped in to counter the Pakistani troops
@@newname69lol kiddo.. what is this full n half..
India ka dekhte baithega agar teri lumber 1 army attacking kashmir?
Kaise diya phir ...Lahore tak 😂
@@newname69 brother so u think u guys can come and destabilize us and we should accept that. U r truly delusional to the core 😅
Many of the channels you react to like real life lore, cogito, odd compass, useful charts and the graphic earth and India in pixels and now the armchair historian are all the channels i subscribed to. They are all great channels.
Oh that's awesome, definitely means they are quality then
Now I look at this war after Independence
It's just war ok not operations
1. 1947-1948 1st Indo pak war
After then direct
2. 1961 India Portugese war
3. 1962 1st Indo Sino war
4. 1965 2nd Indo pak war
5. 1967 2nd Indo Sino war
6. 1971 3rd Indo pak
Between 1960 to 1971 it was continuous war after war of India
7. 1999 Kargil war (4th Indo Pak war)
India was not the first to start the war, it was pakistani militant on one side and pak army on other side opened front....india with full force defended and entered lahore
I like the rolling concept, it might be a game changer for community as well
I think it's the only fair thing to do with so many people recommending videos
@ReldrikGeo I think it's more than fair if you end up adding like a spin wheel or just scroll until the timer stops and that's the pick would be a dope series outro
24:18 next video on 26/11
The British aren't to blame for causing the partition; it was bound to happen
The Brits did indeed go about the partition in such a way that the region was in perennial conflict.
Indian army captured Lahore and started marching towards Islamabad you can see historical images taken by some soldiers you clearly see the Indian flag over the popular landmarks of Lahore so technically India captured pakistani land during war but as our moral values and ingrained culture after war ended india returned the occupied land back to Pakistan.
the prime minister of India , Shastriji were found deceased in his room in Taskent, after signing the peace agreement. Cause of death was natural but.....just saying
Definitely seems suspicious thats for sure
On 11 January 1966, India's second Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri died in Tashkent, USSR (now Uzbekistan) after signing the Tashkent Declaration with Pakistani President Ayub Khan.
But that wouldn't be considered part of this conflict would it?
@ReldrikGeo No, it wasn’t part of the conflict, but there are theories suggesting external involvement, especially the USA or USSR. Shastri's work with Dr. Homi Bhabha on atomic energy at the time adds fuel to these speculations. Both passed away under mysterious circumstances in quick succession.
Yeah I was reading about it just now. Highly suspect
5:59 This is such a gross oversimplifaction. Numerically, the Muslims were in majority; but they were all mostly concentrated in barely 10-15% area of the entire disputed region; the rest was non-Muslim.
When partion happened jinnah named the newly formed country pakistan hoping india will be renamed as Hindustan which will create a image one country is for muslims and other for Hindus but nehru opt for name india . And as pakistan was created from religious idea as home for muslims they assumed jammu and kashmir will be the part of pakistan as it has majorly muslim population but the ruler of Kashmir was hindu and he didn't wanted to be part of any country pakistan unsatisfied try to inforce there way in j&k . To protect the princely state of j&k, ruler of j&k signed a treaty with india which is popularly known as article 370 . After which India helped j&k to protect from invasion of pakistan.
India was bigger and stronger than pakistan even at that time.Salute to Pakistan courage to fought with giant resourceful country with huge population
That's blatant ignorance, Pakistan's economy and currency was doing better at that time and was being provided weapon far more advance than what India had by the US. Pakistan had America's support even with the setting up of terrorist organizations for guerilla warfare.
@@alekhsingh9970 true
Just a suggestion you should react to defences detective as he has covered all the wars fought between India and Pakistan in detail with facts and proper information
Keep posting 😗 I'm enjoying very well ...
Thank you, I will
It's not 'Cash-meer' its 'kush-meer' meer not pronounced as mere. And kash as in lush, rush or blush
grape lady is all time classic
The edit I watched on video was terrible though 💀 original with no zoomer edit was way better
both kashmir and kaashmir are correct, pronunciation depends on which region youre from and what language you speak
Oh okay thank you
This guy's views and opinions about the war were as western as his pronunciation of Kashmir. Even so, he got a lot of the facts right about the war, so I can't fault him entirely.
Our view of the world is always going to be through a slightly different lens unfortunately
You could react to the extra history video series on the Empire of brazil its pretty interesting
I'll add it to the list
5:18
o no none of the young brits know any of the evil deeds done by their ancestors there is no such discussion in their history books
i was once looking at a video about british college students reacting to a video about jalian wala bag incident & then i came to know that they know nothing about their dark history
& at the end of the video they just said that o it was all the previous generations we have nothing to do with it we don't fell responsible for any of it
man i died laughing hearing them 😂😂😂 & thinking how much unaware could they be of their own history 😂
The shame of a country is usually written out of its history unfortunately
@ReldrikGeo well America didn't remove the native american's history , Australia went ahead two steps and is constantly trying their level best to repay the native black australian people for their historical wrong doings by giving them free housing space, food , education & many other facilities
Hy did you know if you see in the african continent most of the countries have a straight border line 😂 even that's also because of the brits they literally just drew lines on the map on a table by a ruler & divided the entire continent among the other colonizers 😂😂😂😂 man that's both funny & sad at the same time😅
And unfortunately to this day Africa is filled with constant war and slavery because of it
World of warships mobile version matchmaking and gameplay depends on how much money you have thrown at them
It's 100% pay to win just like many other of these freemium games
17:10 Operation Gibraltar???
How do you find these channels plz reply
bro is the first youtuber to react on the sponsorship even
If I'm reacting to a video I feel like it's my obligation to at least react to all of the persons content including the sponsor lol
Don't worry my friend even our history book don't talk about it in Details like they talk about 2 certain European wars calling them World wars
Well it was more than just a European conflict. The US and Japan fought all throughout the Pacific. There was even fighting in Northern Africa
@@ReldrikGeo my point was we know more about World wars and civil wars in other countries like lebnon and shrilanka even Belgium politics than our own wars I studied history till 10th standard and there was hardly mention of any Indo-Pak wars while indo Chinese war was briefly mentioned somewhere i dont remember
It's a shame that it's not taught more even in your own country. Very sad actually
India never started war with any country. All wars were started by Pakistan. India is very peaceful country.
Yeah I read more after
Kashmir is actually how you pronounce it ( Cuss-mir ) not ( cash-mir )
Awesome thank you
Not cuss, Kush
@@RigelVision I wrote it so that he ( a foreigner) could understand
@@RigelVision Kush can also be pronounced as ( koosh) so not a very good example when trying to explain a pronunciation with just spellings
Most accurate one
Armchair historian has vids about ww2 from India's perspective
Has one about China aswell
I will have to check these out
A misinformation by armchair historian. He said that, the first Kashmir war started as Maharaja hari singh of kashmir joined india.
This is false. Infact, Pakistan attacked Kashmir first which forced the Maharaja to ask India to help him. India told him that India cant help until Kashmir joins India and becomes Indian territory.
It was Pakistan's attack which forced Maharaja of Kashmir to join hands with India.
True
What India invention of Goa?😂😂😂
I think this term is only said because at the time Goa was technically a Portuguese colony and not part of India.
You don't know India Portugese war?
Invading on Goa, Daman and Diu
Invention?
Bacche english nahi ati toh mat bol 😂
becoz they have damn veto power.
Maybe react to shershah movie based on indo pak war 1999 to visualise it
❤❤
What happened to 'gazi' submarine gifted by US to Pakistan 😂
Yeah, the submarine was leased to Pakistan for 4 years and India sank it. Pakistan said that it sank because of an internal explosion or because of the mines it was setting but that makes it look even worse. Either India destroyed it or it was their own incompetence that caused it to sink lol
6:10 Kaa-Shh-Mee-rr
My brain hurts lol I need to sit down with someone for some language lessons lol
Its not kaaaash-meeer, just 'Kush-meer'.
The UP, Bihari people call it Kaaash-meer or Kaaas-meer
@@RigelVision I am feeling that the way you are pronouncing it is under influence Persian language.
Where are you from and where do people pronounce it like this?
I make me completely wrong, but you can correct me.
As per my understanding, in all the languages where the word Kashmir is taken from Sanskrit it is either pronounced as "Kaa(ka)-Sh-Mir(meer)" or "Kaa(ka)-S-Mir(meer)".
I never knew that "Ku" sound (like in "Kumar") comes in that word.
@@harikrishnayadav3320 not kooshmeer bro I meant Kush as in the word lush, blush, rush, etc or in hindi
कश्मीर ✅
काश्मीर ❌
Pakistan government say always azar Kashmir that means (free Kashmir ) then why Pakistan government control azar Kashmir its make no sense
Yeah if they say that then you would think they would want it to become independent of both India and Pakistan
Armchair is broken. Pls watch series of defence detective videos for indo pak war. Truth accepted by former pak army and air cheifs
hey can you react to netaji subhash chandra bose?
I have a few videos about him on my playlist and I've actually read a bit more about him just today too
Oh that just pakistani propoganda 😂
Is it?
@@ReldrikGeonahh
Cus-meer
That doesn't help me much. Is that pronounced kuz-meer?
@@ReldrikGeo Lemme help you, Kash is pronounced like Hush, just replace "H" with "K" sound.. & Mir like Beer, replace "B" with "M".
@NitinSwaroop perfect thank you
Plz react on kashmir hindus and also on kashmir files 😢
I did in the past. Google flagged my account as hateful content and I believe I was forced to either private this and a few other videos
w pakistan
Yeah?
@@newname69 w pakistan 🤓? Sure buddy.
1) Constant political instability.
2) Military involvement in politics.
3) Compromised fake elections
4) Filled with many terror outfits.
5) Always on verge of bankruptcy.
6) Always ask for more loans to pay previous loans.
7) School textbook filled with inaccuracies and false narratives.
Your country is so f**ked
@@ReldrikGeo don't worry they are delusional to the core. Till now none of their prime ministers completed their full term in the office, their military controls everything, and the economy is in the shambles and it's running on foreign given loans but still they think Pakistan is the best country in the world.
ua-cam.com/video/2Kq8AkIf-bA/v-deo.htmlsi=kDHQj9tP2BFpkKCE
In my opinion, both countries should accept their current realities, end their rivalry, and focus on internal growth to achieve true peace.
I think you are living under the rock. India is doing exactly that.
@Omnitaku7 No, I'm not. Its true that India is focusing on internal growth, but Pakistan is not and therefore, our focus can be easily distracted by Pakistan and Peace can't be established until Pakistan and Bangladesh focus on their own growth.
@@akshaysamel8972 true
React to India in pixels video regarding MALAYALAM language
I want to
Checkout Telugu as well