Memories of Murder | Hidden in Plain Sight
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 чер 2024
- What makes a film without a single scare, scary? Why is Bong Joon-ho's 2003 crime thriller, Memories of Murder so dark and gloomy, despite its plentiful comedic reliefs and lack of violence?
The secret is in its 'colours', or more precisely, the colours that are hidden in plain sight. Let's explore how Bong Joon-ho approaches visual storytelling, and what we can learn from his techniques.
Warning: take everything with a grain of salt - lots of fun speculations intended as a means to explore, dissect, and analyze the tricks.
Especially for this video, if you'd like my in-depth take on the film, my reasoning behind the argument, and how I came to different conclusions - i.e. no omission, full discussion - become a patron on my patreon page and listen to my monthly podcast, where I dissect my latest video in detail from creation to completion.
Watch Memories of Murder and other great films for free at
MUBI.com/spikimamovies by getting your extended 30 day trial.
///
Music download: spikima.wixsite.com/spikima
Patreon: / spikima
Paypal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/spikima
Instagram: @ spikima
Merch: www.teepublic.com/stores/spik...
Merch 2: www.bonfire.com/store/spikima/
Your support helps with keeping the channel running.
Love.
///
Extra Credits:
A fun read on what color scheme means in a film: www.studiobinder.com/blog/how...
Common color schemes:
www.cined.com/film-color-sche...
"Camera Shutter, Fast, A.wav" by InspectorJ (www.jshaw.co.uk) of Freesound.org
Some background sounds from www.freesound.org/people/klank...
Timestamp
0:00 The Tunnel Scene
2:19 Visual Storytelling
2:37 Characters
3:58 Hidden in Plain Sight
4:28 Red Green Blue
4:58 Desaturation
5:55 Opening Sequence
6:59 Blending Colors
7:55 White
8:49 The One Scene
9:24 Green
10:05 Blue
10:35 Red
11:17 The Colors
12:03 Memories of Murder
13:07 Thank you
#memoriesofmurder
#videoessay
#filmmaking - Фільми й анімація
Watch Memories of Murder and other great films for free at MUBI.com/spikimamovies - and with that, what's better? Parasite or Memories of Murder?
EDIT: Since many seem to ask, the 'right' VS 'righteous' actually DOES work in Korean; it's actually the other way around, that it just happens to work in English as well in a similar way with the word 'righteous'. I totally forgot to mention that in my video so I'm clarifying that here! (I'm also completely fluent in Korean, in case you're wondering)
It is my personal belief that Bong Joon-ho won several Oscars not just for Parasite but rather it was an amalgamation for all the masterpieces he created up to Parasite. With that being said both films are better than the other. Btw, I'm looking forward to your big screen debut and watching someone else do a video praising your decisions.
Please please please please analyse "AARANYA KAANDAM" SCREENPLAY AN
MASTERPIECE FROM INDIAN CINEMA
Memories of Murder - 100%. The plot, the screenplay, the character journeys, the spectacular camera work, the music, that chase scene, the climax. It's in my top 3 movies of all time.
A scene that always stuck with me is the ending when the kid told the detective the killer just looks like an average korean and the detective stared directly at the camera, at the audience, implying that 1. anyone you know or around you could be the/a killer, 2. the film breaks the fourth wall by directly acknowledging that the killer himself is probably watching.
give me chills
It was based on a real life events n the killer was out there when the movie was out. So the last scene is literally the killer watching the movie
Masterful ending.
Amongus
and the killer is arrested. finally.
I’ll never forget learning that the real life killer who’s murders this film was based on, watched the film. So in the end, when the detective stares directly into the camera, he’s staring into the eyes of the real life murderer.
Do you have a source for this? Last time I checked it was unknown who the killer was. I'd love to read more about it
FYI. After about three decades from initial murder in Hwaseong , korean police finally caught the killer whose name is Lee Chun Jae(이춘재). Director Bong Jun Ho said that it felt so strange and complicated to see a real life killer. He wanted to meet the killer whem shooting the movie if he had a chance, but in 2020 when the real killer was caught, director Bong said he would not like to meet the killer.
@@ShortyTwo42 the other comment has more details. I know when the movie was released, they didn't catch him yet but it's kind of like a Golden State Killer thing where more recently he was found
I don't think this is entirely accurate. I believe when the film was released, the killer was already caught but for another crime (family-related). So, unless he was able to watch the film in prison, I don't think he has seen the film at all. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
wasn't it more like the director kind of thought or knew that when the movie is released, the real serial killer would be watching, so he made the ending scene like that. so that the serial killer will be looking straight into the eyes of the detective if ever he'll be watching.
One of my all time favourite , a timeless classic of atmospheric horror and the fact that this is based on a real life incident just adds to the gloom .
I not sure if that was your intention, but when i read your comment, it felt like you were dismissing the film, as another horror story. I came to this film knowing it was based on a true story, so watching the film was horrifying rather than entertaining for the sake of horror.
@@wintaweldemariam8325 ofcourse I meant the horror pertaining to the reality behind the movie and how the film makers brilliantly captured the tension , not just the entertainment - horror . I appreciate your view🙌
The flying kick is alone worth watching the movie.
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻.Dont forget to leave your comment and thought! thank you
Sadly he lost the leg and can no longer kick anymoe
I first watched this on July 2nd, 2020. I remember it so clearly because when I finished it, I was curious and looked up the case, and was instantly overwhelmed. During the exact two hours I was watching it, was when the real-life killer was identified and confirmed as the culprit, including some cases they had no idea about.
The film was a really thrilling, interesting watch, but it was still so far away, the string of violence happening before I was even born. Then, all of a sudden, it felt like it might as well have been happening next-door.
It being announced at the moment I was watching this horrible investigation, gave me that really heavy dread kind of fear... the timing was absolutely freaky, it left me unnerved for a week
Holy shit! I watched it a week after you and I definitely had the same feeling of profound anxiety.
몇년전 범인 경찰에 잡혀습닉다
Memories of Murder is based on a harrowing series of real life crimes that have spanned for years or decades. The visuals of this film are otherworldly. You can clearly see how eerie and hopeless the characters look. They’re trapped in an endless cycle of events that will continue to haunt them for a long time. South Korea may seem like a utopia to some, but in reality, it’s just like any other country out there in the world that continues to suffer the consequences as a result of other peoples’ actions. Great analysis as always.
amogus
tbh south korea looks very depressing to me.
Who are these people thinking South Korea is utopia? The closest place to that would be nordic countries. Are you talking about their pop fans? Coz most people know there's entertainment and irl. Most people are aware that school workload, gender equality, and suicide rates are a big problem in south korea
SUS
when the killer is sus
The eyes failed.
The leg got chopped off.
The documents failed.
Damn, you ve just summarize all three and they re all failed..
Whenever I think you can't outdo your last work in terms of how beautifully and exquisitely you analyse films, you always manage to bewilder me by locating newer and deeper unnoticed details
You're the reason why I'm so into analyzing films. Every video and this one is always beautifully made! 🌷
The killer does grizzly things but it has to be my favourite Bong Joon Ho film. Incredible filmmaking, and such a chaotic emotional journey like when I saw Mother
This was the movie that made my love for korean cinema starts. It means so much to me. I Remember the happiness I felt when I was finally able to see Memories of murder in Theaters here in Italy in 2021
Wow, allora esistono altri italiani che seguono questo canale
One of your best essays yet. As a director, your videos always make me think deeper about what I’m saying and how, whilst appreciating the sheer single mindedness of the greats. Thank you so much!
the time and effort you put into your editing and analysis is so intricate that it made realize the hard work that was put into movies which made me love the creation of it.
I also noticed that the girl in the end said that the guy had "an ordinary face" throughout the film the detective mostly suspected "ugly men" and the good looking guy. You can see the look on his face realising how "narrow minded" he was
I really do love these videos, they always allow me to see films I’ve watched and enjoyed in a different way, something like the colours is something I don’t think I would catch on any amount of rewatches and yet is so interesting to see the thought process of the filmmakers
Your power of analysis when it comes to movies is outstanding. This is one of my favorite channels. Thanks for the amazing quality of content. I would love to see a visual breakdown from you on the trilogy of "Pusher" featuring Mads Mikkelsen.
Finally a mind-blowing throughout analysis of one of the greatest movies that's ever made in our history. I've been waiting for it for ages, and you really did not dissapoint.
My favourite movie of all time. Seat belt buckled in for this video essay!
My favourite crime movies. The atmosphere, the character, the flow and now your analysis about the colour made me love this movie even more.
I'm so blown away from your analysis, might be my favorite one yet.
One of the best horror channels on UA-cam, without a doubt. You go into such marvelous detail not only about what the films do, but how the accomplish their target effects, with things like framing, editing, color, and sound design.
Wow, I've seen this film many times and it's my favorite Korean film but I never noticed the colors in that detail! I did feel that there was a difference between the color tone in the beginning and end of the film with the rest of the film and noticed the scenes where red popped out but I couldn't explain what was so significant about the colors. Thanks for the video essay!
I have been watching your channel since your first video and was eagerly waiting for you to cover Memories of Murder, one of my absolute favorite films. Such a great video! I can't believe I never noticed the color scheme details even after watching this movie so many times. You have brilliant analytical and writing skills! :)
One of my favorite movies. And the description was so in depth and worth. The voice and pace, everything perfect. Beautiful narration. 😇
Thanks for your video on Memories of Murder. There are few videos that review/analyze this film with much depth and so I appreciated your very thoughtful and considered insights. This is the first time I’ve ever sent a a super thanks but, after watching your video, I just felt like I needed to let you know I appreciated it and I look forward to seeing what you do in the future. Thanks again. Steve
I'm right there with you. Just watched this video after rewatching the film for the third time. Impeccable analysis.
Thank you! :) This is the first time I receive one as well - appreciate the support and love, and am glad to hear you found this vid to be helpful and entertaining! Cheers!
pretty late to the party but such a solid and unique way of carrying out this analysis, your editing is out of this world and I can not appreciate it enough.
Man, your analysis is so beautiful and well-structured. This movie is one of my favorites and your video helped me in appreciating the genius of the movie even more. I really like your content. Please keep making such videos for the future.
I love this film have watched a couple videos on it and you're the first to mention the color scheme with the red/green/blue/white! Really fascinating how simply utilizing the colors like that sets up the groundwork for how the audience perceives the setting/characters. It's so subtle that I never noticed it in any of my rewatches. Great analysis!
another amazing analysis. i have never heard of this movie or many others that you talk about, but it makes me want to watch them
Love your breakdown and analysis of such nuanced movies, seeing it through the eye or perspective of the director and one like bong joon ho, top tier💯💯
i had just watched for the first time today so good coincidence i found this video. i like these interpretations of the colors. the desaturation also makes it feel more like a memory in dooman’s mind and the yellow paddy fields probably feel more vivid to him bc of the innocence esp as it’s the start of the crazy case he goes thru and the erosion of hope and his ideals and perception of himself.
i also think blue and red and yellow are frequently used by bong joon ho in this movie and others of his work bc of their significance in korean esp with the tricolored taegeuk which features red, blue and yellow representing heaven, earth and humanity.
you are really good at analyzing dude
Broooo!! the level of your analytical prowess leaves me speechless. - mind-blowing 🤯
your explanation of that tunnel scene was perfect. my fav film channel
I'm only halfway through this but god you kill it every time. I love your analysis; thank you for doing these all so well!
I was patiently waiting for you to do a video on this one, this is by far one of the defining movies of South Korean cinema, Truly the Best work of Boon Joon Ho.
Man, your essays are so beautiful and spot on. You just sold me on this film! I haven’t watched it but, although you’ve just spoiled the finale, I’ll definitely watch it now.
This is the first video that I've watched from this channel. For quite some time Ive stated that I liked Mother by Bong Joon-ho more than I liked Memories of Murder, but this makes me want to give it another go to appreciate it fully, good work!
your content is always time incredibly well spent. thank you
So impressing, so sophisticated and so informative an analysis of the visual storytelling .
Thank you always for a terrific video!
incredible analysis, this channel is so good.
Beautiful as always, amazing video
Bravo Spiki!
If I ever wondered why I support your channel, here's the answer.
Your analysis is luminous and I'm always deeply impressed how you can extrapolate from a couple of scenes.
Film theory at its best!
Keep up the good work my dear.
This video added so much more depth to the film. Thank you!
Aye man, let me just tell you how chill your voice is and its very calming.
god damn this is perfect timing! Just finished this 2 nights ago and i absolutely loved it! keep up the good work :)
Trully brilliant and thanks for the explanation. First, this is my first Bong Joon Ho movie I watch at 2008-2009, since then, every year I always re-watching this movie. I kinda feel what you explained about all of these exactly what I've experience (but I keep it to myself haha). Once again, Bravo!
this was great!!! definitely made me appreciate the film more after hearing your analysis on color and how it played such a big role wow thank you
Ugh I love this film and your analysis is soo greaat
Man, storytelling in film is complex. So fascinating.
I love "Memories of Murder" more than "Parasites". I go back rewatching it and I find more and more intersting and amazed by its cinematography.
been so excited for this video ever since you mentioned it in your community post and ive watched it! instense movie and perfect video
Amazing analysis as always. Kudos.
i always love ur videos man!, it always provides me with top quality horror movies to watch
me too!
its about time u make a video about this masterpiece
Director Bong Joon-ho 's bestest and greatest movie for sure and the ending montage man 🔥🔥🔥
7:05 , I just love how he breaks the sentence to let the sound of the person getting kicked by the detective
So beautifully done
this movie is just so good, i remember watching this movie without knowing anything abt joon ho, after watching parasite i watched this as i wanted more from him, and this, i have to say is my favorite movie from him. The ending just hits so different.
WOOOOOO SPIKIMA UPLOADED
This cinematic breakdown is insane with information and meaning!
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻.Dont forget to leave your comment and thought! thank you (:
If you liked Memories of Murder then you should definitely watch Memoir of a Murderer aswell its such a good movie.
But do not confuse Memoir of a Murderer with the movie Memoirs of a Murderer.
Memoir of a Murderer is a movie from 2017 directed by Shin-Yeon Won.
Memoirs of a Murderer is a movie from 2017 directed by Yû Irie which is a remake of a movie called Confession of Murder directed by Byung-Gil Jung in 2012.
Let me tell you what a headache it was to track these movies down based on reviews when people mistake Memories of Murder with Confession of Murder with Memoirs of a Murderer with Memoir of a Murderer .................
Come on man. The theory that he kicks only with his RIGHT leg because he's a RIGHTEOUS character is such a stretch not even elastic man could catch that.
Well yeh, but it was intended by the director + it makes a lot more sense and is a lot more intuitive in Korean- just happens to work in English as well albeit not as great ;)
@@SpikimaMovies Oh I didn't know the same word game applies in korean, what a coincidence!
I love your videos! Memories of Murder is my all time favourite movie. It really is a masterpiece
I completely rediscovered this film thanks to your analysis
Just rewatched this movie recently, this is his best film.
This video was amazing. It made me realize how much I actually have yet to learn about cinematography.
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻.Dont forget to leave your comment and thought! thank you
Your videos are excellent. Thankyou so much for your content Spikima!
Thanks for watching!
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻.Dont forget to leave your comment and thought! thank you
This is so brilliant and just adds to my appreciation of film!
I loved this movie but this analysis makes me appreciate it all the more.
Brilliant analysis!
Thanks to this channel I've entering in this awesome world that is soutkorean cinema. Thank you so much!
터널 장면은 막연히 느낌만 가지고 있었는데 이리 설명해 주시니까... 시원하기도 하고 감탄이 계속 나오기도 하네요...
i have just realized i enjoy commentaries more than the actual film. (i'm obsessed with finding meaning.) anyway--filmmaking is the greatest form of storytelling and bong joon-ho is a genius. spikima, you're a genius as well.
What a fantastic analysis! Thank you.
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻.Dont forget to leave your comment and thought! thank you
Very astute breakdown, I was wondering how you get the clips for these video essays?
Excellent! Thank you.
봉준호 감독님 영상들을 쭉 살펴보다고 우연히 접한 채널영상인데.. 목소리가 너무 편안하고 좋네요.. 예전에는 한글 자막을 달아주셨는데 요즘은 영어자막을 달아주시니 더 좋습니다.. 저런 걸 어떻게 영어로 표현할까 하는 궁금증도 해결되고 말이죠.. 영상들 소중히 보겠습니다.. 감사합니다..😊😊
안녕하세요! 한글과 영어자막 둘 다 지원됩니다 :) 편하신 자막 골라서 시청하시면 되겠습니다.
재밌게 봐주셔서 감사합니다 :)
after watching this movie, i dreamed the whole night of the detectives trying to catch the killer and failling over and over, i didnt sleep weel and i woke up in the morning in an anxiety state, my stomach hurt the entire day because of anxiety, in fact i went to the hospital but all was fine. the creator said this film is about the people involved in the crime, who suffer from these crimes and not about the killer itself. u can really feel the frustration that the detectives feel and later the despair. and man your videos are simply beautiful as good as the films you review
Love the fact that the movies I've seen recently have a Spikima video about them. Truly the cherry on top watching these videos right after watching such amazing films. 😌
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻.Dont forget to leave your comment and thought! thank you (:
How come you don't have ten or a hundred mill subscribers! Whenever I come across the word "criminally underrated",your name comes to mind.
:')...ty, spread the word.
This is one of the many movies that I couldn't conjure up courage to watch had it not been for my translation professor. Aside from all the victims and their families, what adds to tragedy is the number of lives of innocent suspects who all suffered till their deaths or died from torture.
It's a really heavy film indeed, and rightfully so. But it's also a film you must eventually watch!
Holy shit, this video is so fire. Awe-inspiring.
Masterful analysis
This might be my favorite video of yours.
Definitely made me remember Zodiac of Fincher, the constructing ambiguity that develops with each new suspect and the character's growing in their own ways for example the lead detective was bumbling and by the end his character was serious and stern, wondering about who it could've been, the detective from Seoul was the type of guy who always trusted documents, except for when in the end the ball wasn't in his court. They all grew in depths of each's character and became the opposite of who they were in the end. I also felt like the last 5 minutes of this movie was perfect Storytelling , just like the last 3 minutes of Prisoners by Villeneuve, it felt captivating even though not many words were said. The more I think about how the story developed in Zodiac the more I can feel the similarity between the two awesome movies. How the characters were accusing every suspect and how badly they wanted the guilty, Fincher had the Zodiac Killer, Bong has the Rain Man, Fincher had Mark, RDJ and Gyllenhaal, Bong had the Dropkicker, Detective Park and The smoker guy. They both had their one last suspect that one of the detectives knew was the killed but couldn't prove it and went crazy. And the most similar thing between the two Top Tier Mystery Thrillers : "I'll know who the killer is by looking him in the eye." Literally both movies even had almost the same dialogue and the same style of throwing suspicions. Gyllenhaal even looked at the bald guy in the end of Zodiac as if he had found his killer. Now that's a brilliant way of character intro and the acting by the characters in this film just made it exponentially better.
Now, lemme make this clear, from the starting of this thing I was very intrigued by the acting by the actors and the music scores as well. Bong joon did an amazing job choosing the music scores and thriller sounds to drop in middle, it made the scene so much more intense, I'm afraid Bong has definitely learnt from his mentor in how to make a scene suspenseful. No name needed.
The long takes of cinematography were equally melancholic, as well as they were strikingly photographed depicting how far we are from the conclusion and how every thing looks different from a different perspective. Direction of the movie was also seemingly well done and it's no joke why Bong Joon Ho is one of the best directors of our generation.
Again, I'd like to appreciate the acting a lot more because what they have pulled with this is a fine piece of art. From the start it was funny as hell , those out of the blue drop kicks just had me rolling. And by the end how the characters molded into a more saddened and angered version of themselves was quite the change. It felt strong, it felt changing, but what didn't change is that the monster was still out there hunting, that felt unchanged.
8.5/10
Reminded me off zodiac too.. prisoners not so much .. because she was caught and whole mystery was infront of us.. the last look in the shop of zodiac and the last look here .. helpless feeling that you just can't do anything.
@@suryansh8069 I noted the similar thing between Prisoners and Zodiac and it wasn't the fact the the killer is caught or anything. If you have seen Prisoners you'd know what I'm talking about when saying the last 3 minutes of the movie was perfect storytelling. That scene has a deeper meaning than most are able to interpret. That's the similar thing between these two films.
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻.Dont forget to leave your comment and thought! thank you (:
This was an awesome movie that while not your typical movie to watch with family, was one that my parents and brothers and i will never forget watching together
My favorite part of this film is the soundtrack, God is it good, it just emphasizes the tragedy of the story and how sometimes you just cant catch the killer, and justice wont always be brought upon the criminal.
One of the best parts, the ending with the detective staring at the camera, the audience, has imo one of the best pieces of original soundtrack in any film.
It would be so great if you make the viedo about decision to leave!!! It's such a masterpiece
You're crazy. I honestly think you're a genius. I love your videos.
This might just be one of my favorite movies ever. It's almost perfect in every level.
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻.Dont forget to leave your comment and thought! thank you (:
This movie is a masterpiece!!! If you havent watched it yet…WATCH IT!!!!!
One of the best vieos I have watched on this platform.
Such great analysis. The inadequacy of the policemen in this film despite the power they weild and abuse is sadly a truth that doesn't evolve over time.
Honey wake up, spikima uploaded!
Thankful that my family discover Spikima 😁❤️😁
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻.Dont forget to leave your comment and thought! thank you
Thanks for whispering, almost blew my eardrums out
I have watched this movie long ago, but with ur speculations this makes the movie already go from my ultra favourite to top. We dismiss the effects of colour so much when watching film, and I think that's what is truly the most interesting in the end. The ability of the director to combine the essence of the story with the symbolism of the overlooked colours is what true film watchers see.
Hi,we made short film inspired/reffrence by memories of murders too,feel free to watch (: mystery/thriller just search RASIAN (2023) on youtube 🙏🏻 leave your comment
watching the movie i knew the drastic desaturation had to have had some kind of thematic meaning behind it besides just "oooo gloomy scary murder bleh" but man. Bong Joon-ho being so in touch with visual storying in his first major film is insane.
i happen to have watched this on the criterion blu-ray edition and it includes his final student short film as an extra. and to see the jump from that to Memories of Murder is insane. and yeah i'm sure he worked on other stuff between the two projects but mannnnnnn.
crazy good stuff. beautiful and haunting movie.
Damn your videos are amazing