I wonder if Melon will ever say "I'm feeling a strong 9 to a 10" but then "Strong 9" appears on the screen instead of the 10. I feel like that would make some heads explode.
@@rotar-5078 I just double checked and he said "decent to strong 9" at the end of the review. I remember he did a lets argue where someone accused him of purposely not giving it a 10 for some stupid reason though.
I liked her past albums much better. So many people liking this album to THIS extent is just strange to me 💀 I heard this album twice completely and gotta say it was a painful listen
@@Joshua68187ngl im a big kanye fan but mbdtf is hella overrated. it is not one of the best albums of all time neither one of kanye's bests. i find more quality in kanye's most personal records like 808s or ye, or even donda. mbdtf its a 7/10 for me
Yeah I’m completely fine with him giving brat a 10 but it’s just that he doesn’t seem anywhere near as passionate as he does in his other reviews of 10s or even 9s tbh
Death Grips - The Money Store Swans - To Be Kind Kendrick Lamar - To Pimp A Butterfly Kanye West & Kid Cudi - Kids See Ghosts Daughters - You Won’t Get What You Want Spellling - The Turning Wheel Lingua Ignota - Sinner Get Ready Charli XCX - Brat
I think the album that really should have made it is "Like Clockwork" by Queens of the Stone Age. Maybe "The Forever Story" by JID as well. The only criticisms he had for those records, I found myself disagreeing with.
I wonder if Melon will ever say "I'm feeling a strong 9 to a 10" but then "Strong 9" appears on the screen instead of the 10. I feel like that would make some heads explode.
The ultimate cock block
iirc he did that already with A Crow Looked At Me
@@rotar-5078 I just double checked and he said "decent to strong 9" at the end of the review. I remember he did a lets argue where someone accused him of purposely not giving it a 10 for some stupid reason though.
@@Quorthayn it always pissed me off when he does that with other scores lol 🤣 but it’s just a number so it should be such a difference in enjoyment
Brat was a well deserved addition to the club fr fr
No it's not. It's a stain on his review legacy.
@@P_er23 You should take a nap, you seem grumpy
@@P_er23 bumpin that, bumpin that
@@samgayney88 if you love it if you hate it I don't fucking care what you think 🎵
@@P_er23you gon jump if A.G made it
Can't wait for the tenth 10 and then we can get his top 10 tens.
Same.
but then there'd be only 9 tens, Brat was the eighth
@@demi172 See y'all in two 10s, then.
@@Lunatasmawill we be alive then?
@@teagan3598LOL
You forgot speeding bullet 2 heaven
A dude called micro_ did a much better version of this compilation here: ua-cam.com/video/rDGqKG-NRJI/v-deo.htmlsi=3FGEtdvCupO-uUtC
His standards for a 10 took a nosedive in 2018 and basically means nothing now.
Sure
You stopped taking his (10/10) opinions seriously in 2018 and you still watch his clips? Cmon man😂
first 10 album with a green album cover
True I wonder what fans of black and white will think about this
i wish he gave igor a 10
I agree 😢
Indeed
This, atrocity exhibition and ants from up there all deserved 10s
But it isn’t a 10 though. It has I don’t love you anymore as a track which is like a 4/10 so Igor’s more an 8 or 9
@@Finger4138I don't love you anymore is just as strong as every other track on Igor
You forgot "These albums are 10s 1960s-2000s"
Brat was so out of nowhere like that Ken Carson one
Charli had two 9s before this
@@mattylatvala43 two 9s?
@@RegisteredLate123they misremembered, she had a 9 and two 8’s
I liked her past albums much better. So many people liking this album to THIS extent is just strange to me 💀 I heard this album twice completely and gotta say it was a painful listen
He has good taste in music
Yet mdtf is a 6
@@Joshua68187 so what it's his opinion? And I think his opinion is a little better than ours since we haven't heard half as much music as him
@@Joshua68187that proves he has good taste.
@@Joshua68187ngl im a big kanye fan but mbdtf is hella overrated. it is not one of the best albums of all time neither one of kanye's bests. i find more quality in kanye's most personal records like 808s or ye, or even donda. mbdtf its a 7/10 for me
@@neufremios1574 I never said it deserved a 10, I'm just saying that it doesn't deserve the rating. It's not even in my top 50
His brat pick looked like easily the least confident score here
Yeah I’m completely fine with him giving brat a 10 but it’s just that he doesn’t seem anywhere near as passionate as he does in his other reviews of 10s or even 9s tbh
Damn, even Metacritic didn't give brat a perfect score
Because it's a collective review averaged amongst many critics
who's that
How could Mr Meta. C Ritic do this?
Not eternal atake, that’s for sure
I wish taboo and tfs was on here, he likes those albums too😢
both of them are 10s for me
Love taboo but it's not even a 9
taboo aint even denzels best album 😭🙏
@@nuclrtoaster7594 yes it is
What a silly little thumbnail you got there lol
Name of the albums... Please
Death Grips - The Money Store
Swans - To Be Kind
Kendrick Lamar - To Pimp A Butterfly
Kanye West & Kid Cudi - Kids See Ghosts
Daughters - You Won’t Get What You Want
Spellling - The Turning Wheel
Lingua Ignota - Sinner Get Ready
Charli XCX - Brat
I think he also gave the college dropout a 10
Madvilliany as well, but those are Classsic reviews @@amogusus911
@@amogusus911there were a ton of albums that were 10s on his RYM but I think he said not to go by it, or that they weren’t “canon” or something.
I think the album that really should have made it is "Like Clockwork" by Queens of the Stone Age. Maybe "The Forever Story" by JID as well. The only criticisms he had for those records, I found myself disagreeing with.
Where’s glass beach?
i love cal
Bro brat will forever be the least deserved 10 ever reviewed by fantano
@@jacksoncrou2050 hard disagree icl
The daughters one did not age well…
Brat is a great album but it kinda pisses me off that he gave it a ten, instead of giving it to albums like ants from up there or the forever story
well this makes sense since brat is miles better than those that you listed
@@tavua"miles better"
@@mattylatvala43 dont think i said anything wrong
@@tavua aint no way
@@tavua365 alone clears most albums😭
Not just giving it a 10 but calling TBAP a benchmark aged so well
Edit: TPAB!!!!!!!!!!!
To Bimp a Putterfly
@@JavaGodFB I'm dead