The War in Ukraine is Over as Russia Has Destroyed Ukraine's Army | Col. Jacques Baud
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 тра 2024
- Jacques Baud is a former member of Swiss strategic intelligence, a specialist in Eastern European countries and head of United Nations peace operations doctrine. He was engaged in negotiations with top Russian military and intelligence officials right after the fall of the USSR. Within NATO, he participated in programs in Ukraine and in particular during the Maidan revolution in 2014.
Baud's Books: www.amazon.com.br/stores/auth...
For Lloyd Austin winning is based on Raytheon profits. It's the same criteria he had in Afghanistan and why it lasted 20 years.
well Afghanistan wasn’t his thing but i get your inference.
USA was also winning in Vietnam....
He's a SHOE SHINE BOY
In truth the Western Nations have glorified Hitler in their Nazi crimes of supporting a Nazi Ukrainian government: The west is now committed major crimes against humanity for more than 350 years
the funny is Russia warned yankees about afghanistan, but yankees are ramboooo...🤣. if u look they always lost against sandals army.🤷 they won only iraq, an inexistend army middle destroyed in iraq iran war.
brilliant quote: Without strategy, tactics are just noise before the defeat
it s true, if you not have strategy your tactics are useless and will fail
Total nonsense. Sounds fancy and means nothing.
@@sampohonkala4195 The Logic in your argument is flawless, particularly in relation to the collapse of NATO military industrial complex and the brake down of Ukrainian society
@@eoinhogan152 In reality Russian strategy has failed because they have no functioning battle tactics. Third year running and they have accomplished nothing .
Could listen to Jacques Baud every day.
Best man in the echo chamber❤🔥
Col Baud is always a great guest, thank you Nima.
Dialogue Works is one of my favorite channels, and Jacques Baud is one of my favorite analysts. Thank you Nima!
Jaques Baud is an european jewel of military an political analysis. You, Nima, earn the most honorable merrit to place and keep him present in the most relevant, opposed US networks. I am a retired German, aged 77, and I lift my hat and bow to you.
Nima is the greatest interviewer!
He has perfected the very advanced technique of asking no questions.
Thanks Nima. Col. Jacques Baud is awsome.
The empire of evil is falling, cheers friends!
Nima is such a gifted interviewer: what do you think about …. Then lets speak the guest for rest of the program.
Has an incredible sense of humbleness.
Col. Jacques Baud is sharp as a tack.
excellent analysis by M Baud. thank you and your excellent guest
Jacques Baud is one of the top three "experts" you can get.
This has become such a great channel 👏😁
Also Sun Tsu said “do not interrupt your enemy when he’s doing stupid mistakes”
Thank you, Nima. You ask intelligent questions and let your guests elaborate on their ideas in depth.
We learn a lot.
Love this channel. Love that the guests speak freely, uninterrupted! ❤
Good interview. So true and so sad that our gouvernements are so incapable. Here in the Netherlands only one party asked the prime minister what are the objectives. No answers...
Why would a vassal know the objectives of their colonial masters? All they need to know is they do what they are told, from allowing mass migration to ruining the farming sector to supporting Ukraine
same in Germany.
Excellent
Integrated defense. This is what Brian Berletic kept talking about. The Ukrainians aren't trained to incorporate all these various systems together.
I can't get over Brian's angry rant that Israel lobbyists have no more power than any other lobbyists. It shows he is not interested in truth when it clashes with his ideology. I lost a lot of respect for him.
@@arostwocents What would demonstrate that the Israel lobbyists have in general more influence over the United States than any other special interest group though? How do we know if there's not just a group in the establishment which has an interest in keeping the conflict going regardless of connections to Israel, and is outmaneuvering the opposition? If both were the case, then which one would matter more?
@arostwocents he completely dropped out of the conversation on Israel. Maybe he's Jewish? I know he tried to portray Hamas as being a group under western control early on which I don't believe. This war is terrible for the west. If Hamas was acting for the US it would make more sense for them to disappear and let Washington and Israel claim victory.
@ragabara1031 what would demonstrate it to me is that Israel's actions are so destructive to the US. If their lobby weren't so powerful the US would have thrown them under the bus years ago. Also because Netanyahu has bragged about Israel controlling the US. That's kind of a giveaway.
2:32 ...Says a colonel of the army that integrated a blade, fork, spoon, corkscrew and scissors into one knife.
We learn something from Col J on military strategy... Pointers which we have not heard from others talking on the ongoing U conflict.
Interesting indeed.
The U.S. strategy: "We're 'Murica for God's sake, and God is always on our side. We are the indispensable, exceptional nation and as such simply cannot lose."
It's pathetically laughable and makes me ashamed to be an American for the first time in my 61 years of life. A big part of that shame is I've only started to realize it in the last few years.
An empire built on the bodies and blood of the natives
My compliments to you, sir , better late than never… and it’s not easy to change the mentality of an entire life and shifting the POV. So kudos to you !
Wotch mean. 60 years of blind loyalty. You know what they say. Blind loyalty is not loyalty.
Our enemy is the swamp, not Putin.
You know who else had this attitude? Germany in 30s and we all know how that turned out.
Very nice analysis. Another point from Sun Tzu is “the importance of not interrupt an enemie when he’s commiting an error”. That’s what Russians must have politely been made when seeing Ukranians being trained by Nato.
Thank you both
Keep bringing us truth
Thank you Nima, great commentary from Col. Baud.
Why has Switzerland become so warped and how has the US twisted their arms to break them from a great legacy of nuterality
The US threatened the Swiss banking system with sanctions if they did not integrate more with the EU. Swiss bank accounts are no longer protected like they used to be.
The Usa needed the information from the Banks to twist the arms of the politicians who had a Bank account in Switzerland to do as the Usa wanted them to do. By Jove, Switzerland is not more neutral !!!
Excellent speech and analysis. No clear and well acceptable objectives, no win in any war in real sense ! Correct. 🌺🌼💚-bmd
Common sense really, when it's put so clearly and simply by a master analyst.
Smart man that is very pragmatic. SUNK COST
Thanks to Nema and Jacques Baud !
Excuses excuses, Ukraine militants were trained for 10 years by nato instructors for this war! 😂
This war will be over when Russian units are crossing the Dnieper River and advancing west relatively unopposed.
The AFU command has no stated objectives as their goal is the slaughter of anyone who isn't a NAZI.
These are the Ukrainian 73% who voted for an end to corruption, and peace with Russia, when they voted for Zelenskiy.
Ukrainians have never wanted this war, and have fled the country since 2004 for this very reason.
Everyone who comments on Kiev's "strategy" makes the mistake of thinking the government is concerned with Ukraine's best interests.
Vladimir Zelenskiy, “I hope that the Congress will approve this financial assistance for our crimes… country”.
The notion the most corrupt nation on Earth could successfully defend itself is laughable.
Ukrainian defence is designed to protect oligarch Swiss bank accounts and fill them with skimmed 'aid money'.
Like all other US-NAYOYO collaborators, constant whining for support is just a way to ‘skim’ more money before defeat ends the good times.
As the whining gets louder, the war's end gets closer.
This explains Zelenskiy's begging for more money and weapons to sell on the black market.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR), 1936: ‘We had to struggle with the old enemies of peace - business and financial monopoly, speculation, reckless banking, class antagonism, sectionalism, war profiteering.’
Ninety years later nothing has changed in US-NAYOYO countries or their collaborators.
Thomas Mann (1875 - 1955): "War is a cowardly escape from the problems of peace."
This war will be over when Russian units are crossing the Dnieper River and advancing west relatively unopposed.
The AFU command has no stated objectives as their goal is the slaughter of anyone who isn't a NAZI.
These are the Ukrainian 73% who voted for an end to corruption, and peace with Russia, when they voted for Zelenskiy.
Ukrainians have never wanted this war, and have fled the country since 2004 for this very reason.
Everyone who comments on Kiev's "strategy" makes the mistake of thinking the government is concerned with Ukraine's best interests.
Vladimir Zelenskiy, “I hope that the Congress will approve this financial assistance for our crimes… country”.
The notion the most corrupt nation on Earth could successfully defend itself is laughable.
Ukrainian defence is designed to protect oligarch Swiss bank accounts and fill them with skimmed 'aid money'.
Like all other US-NAYOYO collaborators, constant whining for support is just a way to ‘skim’ more money before defeat ends the good times.
As the whining gets louder, the war's end gets closer.
This explains Zelenskiy's begging for more money and weapons to sell on the black market.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR), 1936: ‘We had to struggle with the old enemies of peace - business and financial monopoly, speculation, reckless banking, class antagonism, sectionalism, war profiteering.’
Ninety years later nothing has changed in US-NAYOYO countries or their collaborators.
Thomas Mann (1875 - 1955): "War is a cowardly escape from the problems of peace."
No wonder they lost.
NATO is only "good" at killing poor people. And even then, they still get kicked out in the end. NATO can't handle Russia or China. Americans don't know as a collective what it is like to suffer. Russians and Chinese do. They won't be bullied by America's NATO thugs.
nato is vastly inferior to russia.
Bitter truth.
It's true, as much as i feel for the Ukrainian people because this is truly a miserable tragedy, i cant stop wondering wtf were they thinking?
How much hate must you have for the Russians to go sacrifice your life and the future of your country against a determined Russia, while the most irresponsible and self serving entity on the planet claims to have your back?
This must be the most egregious failure of risk calculation.
I just don't get it.
Blinded by NeoNazi ideology of Ukrainian exceptionalism and greatness.
Brilliant analysis.Jacques Baud is a Great guest.👌👍
Tolle Sendung Danke!!!!!!
The next time the US goes to war I suggest first checking the map. Ukr is close to Russia. Taiwan close to China. It’s not hard.
it's over the way WW2 was over in 1943 but the war continued and plenty of people died after it was "over"
The German defeat in Stalingrad was the beginning of the end for the nazis but the war wasn't 'over'for more than 2 years
Some said Japan definite lose is when they lose at midway….
War continue years😂…
Its over again when usa bomb tokyo,but jap isnt surrender 😂
And they got two nukes…😂😂
I say it was decided in the late summer / early fall of 1941, when the USSR didn't simply collapse.
@@bozo5632Certainly by December 1941 when Hitler declared war on the USA.
@@Worldturnedupsidedownyou misunderstood his point completely.
I get where he described integration of equipment. I operated a heavy recovery vehicle in the British Army. It was equipped to recover any vehicle in the entire British fleet of wheeled vehicles. Now imagine how you would cope with multiple countries vehicles. The mechanics were trained on our vehicles not multiple foreign variants. So even from a logistics and engineering standpoint it’s a massive problem. Then add to that the fighting forces operating multiple platforms.
Here is wisdom.
The books of Col. Baud are fountains of precious information based on facts and common sense. Thank you Nima for inviting him.
Spending ammunition on attacking civilian targets in Belgorod is the idiocy from military standpoint. Nothing but terrorism of Ukrainian state. Exactly opposite effects from intended ones.
This formervmilitary expert , swiss citizen ....a really smart Guy.... ❤
The West has not heard of Sunk Cost 😅
They also haven't heard of '"Winning". It's been 80 years since they won anything.
They're worried about china's overcapacity 😂🤣
All this technical speak about war when they could be manufacturing goods of use.
Toujours un plaisir d'entendre JB, surtout sur des chaînes telles que Dialogue Works et The Duran.
I love the way Alkhorshid respectfully nods their very well shaped head in attention throughout the speakers' answers :3
I like his sense of humour
Col Jacques Baud’s analysis is enlightening. I learned something new
I heard for the first time from someone who said 'I don't know what Russians think' . . . that was honest . . . otherwise, everyone knows what the Russians are thinking, especially the English, who have ears that can hear thoughts . . . 🙂
Amazing
It's worth noting that you can sense sorrow for the tragedy only in the words of the military people, because they know what war is like. Respect for col Baud, I never miss a chance to listen to his analysis
Excellent interview!
Well as You perhaps understand of my question, I am not very familiar with war. But isn't the goal in Ukraine even, not only weaken Russia, but maintain the grounds belonging to the international founding companies? And that is their democrazy the Ukrainians are fighting for?
It is very sad for all of us. And i hope with all my heart that the Ukrainians will have rectification.
It is.
"And that is their democrazy the Ukrainians are fighting for?" What democracy? Ukraine is NOT a democracy!
Gratitude; much needed quality of judgement
That's is brilliant analysis ..by Mr J.Boud 😊
Thanks
Excellent guest.
Very informative
Thanks Nima and col. Baud
Greetings from Australia
Nice show, thank you.
According to Blinken, the new game changer weapons have arrived 😮
I don't think so.
yes the latest technology...the Bow and Arrow..
There is nothing left. The only game changer would be if they send UFOs and they are not going to Ukraine
Unfortunately for Blinken it's on the Russian side of the front aimed at Ukraine.
Dear people, no matter how well coordinated the West's input might have been is completely irrelevant; the reason being Russia would have never tolerated a defeat against the West on the Ukrainian soil, for the Russian nation it was, and it is a question of to be or not to be: it is an existential struggle; losing to the West is no option; even if it demands of Russia to go for its nukes against the West! The West likes to play silly games at the expense of others, but Russia does not play games when it comes to its survival -- the same applies to China!
It's vital that everyone understands that for Russia it's a matter of survival....how can we all forget the huge sacrifice that Russia paid in defeating the Nazis
The ex satellites of USSR had to become brand new NEUTRAL independent states right after the end of the Cold War, and all borders in Central Europe would have been definitely much, much clearer + safer for everyone. Most elementary common sense...
Fighting weaker enemies and losing! What irony!
Good analysis.
I believe Putin himself said recently that "it's going to take a long time." The Ukrainian military does not appear defeated yet and the Russian advance is grindingly slow.
Where is the Jill Stein interview?
It was several days ago.. maybe a week ago? She is really terrific. She won me over.
It’s truthful picture on the front line and beyond in Ukraine and Russia. Thank you Mr. Baud. O. S.
Is CensorTube interfering with comments again, hmmmmm? 🤔
Always😂
@@kewintaylor7056I clicked to write that 😂
Every second of my comments disappeared within minutes....
Ad aeternum
I get notifications of replies when my comment does not even show up lol.
Good thought
Col. Jacques Baud has covered the Ukraine situation so clearly and on point. I agree with his analysis and conclusion to this War. Where is Boris Johnson now sipping scotch and puffing a cigar at the Boys Club while thousands of Ukrainians and Russians die "prick".
Hello Jacques, that is what a girl told me once. It is not how big it is, it is how you use it. Great advice.
How will this defeat affect America? And Israel?
Ukraine is hiring , ...world of warcraft and call of duty veterans are welcome to apply for an important function in the ukraine army.
Pay is negatiable and dependant on specialism.
Boeing whistleblowers looking for a safe place are welcome as well.
What about World of Tanks players? Ukraine could partner with them for their constant UA-cam channel ads. Get a free premium tank when you log on from Ukraine and give your foreign troop registration number?
A brilliant analysis and in depth assessment
of the realities surrounding Ukraine, in this
Western pushed tragedy! The thorough
explanation that Col. Jacques Baud has
given here, leaves no room for doubt in
the minds of the audience , as to the fact
that this entire conflict was needless and
the suffering and loss of lives on both sides
could have been avoided, had it not been
for the hubris and reckless behavior of the
U.S. and its NATO Allies in this entire
endeavor! As Col. Baud pointed out, the
West never had an effective strategy or
game plan for the Ukrainians, from the
outset of this conflict. The shortcomings
of this have only increased over time, and
causing Ukraine to suffer one
catastrophic loss after another, losing
hundreds of thousands of soldiers, and
significant portions of territory to the
Russians , as a result. In the end, what
will be left of Ukraine , will be a failed
state, that likely will never have the
potential to thrive again. This could
have all been avoided, had the West
allowed Ukraine to settle this via
negotiations with the Russians at the
outset of this conflict , as was well in
the process of being ratified by both
Russia and Ukraine in early 2021.
Thank you Nina for inviting the very
knowledgeable and experienced
analyst, Col. Jacques Baud, back on
as a guest, to your wonderful podcast!
We are all better informed after listening
to his responses to your thought
provoking questions. You are doing
an excellent job keeping us all well
informed, keep up the good work!
Theres been over 1m casualties
with the wounded and missing - definitely yes
Jacques Baud asks the right question: what is the motivation of the Ukraine, what of Russia.
However we need to differentiate:
What is the motivation of the Galicians and what that of the Russians.
The Galicians want a racially pure state integrated in the US empire, like the Polish.
The Russians of course want to stay sovereign, outside the empire and in their cultural sphere.
Now we experience the violent divorce which will end the Ukraine and split it up into its ethincal constituents.
When he's talking about Sun Tzu, part of what Ukraine is able to achieve we also need to include both sides. What is Ukraine's strategy for making Russia give up its aims? Going to the 1991 borders doesn't actually make Russia capitulate. Not only does Ukraine lack the remaining men to get back to the 2014 or 1991 borders, but it also lacks the forces to reach Moscow as an obvious extension. Diplomacy, with war being an extension thereof, seems to be a tool outside their toolbox. Diplomacy is only being used to sustain the fighting, when fighting is only happening because the two involved countries are being kept apart. While some complain about Istanbul - Ukraine went on fighting because of promises it was made. It could have swallowed the bitter pill, much as the Austro-Hungarian Empire also could have in 1914. Does the country survive, or not?
To learn objective is from the late prime minister Lee Kuan Yew
We here in the 'west', just expect it as a given that we will always win, no matter what 'we' do. Because the 'enemy' is evil, and dumb, and 'we' are good and virtuous, therefore, we cant lose. That how it works in (amerikan) movies right? 'Good' always triumphs. When we do lose, it is always someone else's fault or shortcoming.
And yet they always lose. Or leave a situation that is far worse than before.
But alas, the MIC always win.
The war is like the stock market, the more you lose, the more you invest and expect the market to turn around.
this war is about the world order. the 2nd world order war.
that's something totally special.
More or less a bandage army. Or dad’s army.
I appreciate Jacques Baud, but still the war in Ukriane os far of being over. And we don't know yet what the end of ths war could be, because we don't yet how nato countries are willing to double down again and again. The ukrainian defeat can be a long end.
The war is obviously far from over. Saying it is over is a means applied by Russian propaganda to discourage the western countries to send new supplies to Ukraine.
If you have listened carefully it is what J. Baud is saying and, by the way, we are not talking about an Ukrainian defeat but about a US/UK/NATO defeat in their war by proxy in Ukraine!
@@JP-ve7pp I listen carfeully what he said. First he makes the affirmation and then he retropedal on his affirmation. Ukraine, nato and Russia: the whole thing is mix. And nobody know for sure what the end of this war really mean. The zlensky gang is clearly loosing. But we don't know yet up to what these people are winning to go and to what point the western political leadership is winning to double down in the hope of not loosing face.
The Kiev regime is already considering moving the capital from Kiev to Lvov in the West. What more needs to be added?
People. If you live in the west and are for Russia. Like the comment. I want to see how many of us think the same.
Z
Zelensky reminds me The Black Knight from Monty Python and the Holy Grail priceless scene.
"Your arm's off!"
"No it isn't!"
“Look you stupid bastard you’ve got no arms left!”
"It's a flesh wound. I've had worse.
"Well what's that then?"
"I’m invincible!”
“You’re a looney.”
“Alright, we’ll call it a draw!”
Yet as long as the Kiev's regime is in place, the war will go on. As Russia is not willing to go up to the Polish and the Slovak borders, this war can last several years unless the US and Europe stop helping Zelensky. Remenber that Russia had to go up to Berlin to end WW II.
Yes, if the collective West doesn't goes bankrupt meanwhile
It’s funny, I seem to remember that he already said that in March 2022
The problem of Ukraine is threefold:
1. Lack of people
2. Lack of weapons and MIC
3. Lack of ideology - the country is too diverse with central and eastern part honoring Russia and western part pro-west.
With those limitations Ukraine never had a chance to prevail against Russia. West new that but they do not care about its Ukrainians who are dying(((
For the u.s. it's about profits $$.
the mixed bag of tricks works but against an integrated system it has a huge disadvantage. for a radical example, modern missiles and drones would wipe patton out even if they didn't match.
fighting the world's best army with this mix of over rated nato crap, ridiculous.
I remember seeing an Ukrainian soldier asking his German instructor what to do about those minefields and the German said, just go around it 😂. Well how if 1000k front line where mined?
👍👍👍
Tell that to Ukraine They are still fighting.
the gerontoarmy is still holding land
@@TheFergarfergar More like Ukrainian women are kicking the hades out of Russian troops.
Even when you are in free fall from the 120th floor, after 100 floors you can STILL repeat "so far so good". Then the 120th floor arrives...and is over.
@@lukasfontana7589 Gravity works downwards not upwards. You fall from the 120th floor to the 1st floor not the other way around. Usually you won't fall alone. People with a lot of lead in them tend to fall ahead of you. except for the ones who were loaded down with lead where it all started and never made it to the 120th floor. Like they say, its a game of give and take. If you are going to give, you will have to take. .
As an American you never have to say sorry. Indigenous people, Vietnam, Serbia, Lybia, Afghanistan, Laos, Iraq... I feel sorry for the average American. They pay with their tax dollars and their sons for all this.
The most clear eyed analysis , he leaves no chance for Ukraine to win. The US knew this and pushed ahead with the NATO nonsense anyway
And if you questioned this you were called a traitor...
This is amazing, how deep is he seeing all the thin military specificity of this campaing.
And its a real disaster for Washington, that hundreds and southands of high-class military sepcialistsin pentagon are worthless and simply can't deliver the same facts to the ruling class.
The problem with this is is that it's right in our face. To put into perspective the cause for civilization. In the macrocosm that could be understood in the microcosm, of a single life. Where does it lead to ? To an empty grave that we can fill. You're missing the cause of creators objective, and that you cannot run from. Why would you want to stop those that are subjective to alive that is beyond the comprehension of the objective. There's no purpose in that
I thought according to you guys was already over last week ?
President Putin said in a video to the West at the start of this war: "you don't want to do this". But they laughed at Him. Now they see.
Profiling leadership and the Russian military I was saying right from the get-go that Ukraine doesn't have a minute chance of winning this conflict." To hear from the west about washing machine chips and shovels being the reason I didn't expect.
The war is system.
💰
Then you better inform Putin, because he is one who started it and the one who wants to continue it.
@@andyglastonbury6032 terroristamerikka started this war! it is a fact now be quiet and sit down