Carbon fiber and fiberglass are not meant to be used in this type of loading. They resist _stretching_ exceptionally well. For bending or compression, use other materials.
This is a very interesting study. I was particularly surprised at the brass bar results. I honestly thought it would conform even more so than the 6061 did. Both are gummy to machine. Plus, it was stronger than carbon fiber in that perspective. Impressive! Thanks for sharing. 💪🏾💯🔥
In all seriousness, this video shows exactly which materials will give up in a catastrophic way, and which will flex - very instructive for materials selection.
There exists a myriad of alloys called brass, that contain copper (cu) and zinc (zn) as main components, but may also contain small amounts of tin, zirconium, arsenic, silicon, aluminium etc. Many cold/ heat treatments aswell. As many variaties as there are applications.
Would be neat to see the temperature of the samples as they are crushed. Tin, which has a much lower melting point, seemed more fluid as it distorted from the pressure.
i don't. this is a very engaging video and unwelcoming. please take your false statement to a place where it would be more appropriate. The police are coming to enforce an arrest warrant about you. Count your minutes.
@@O3wormer Your unwelcome reply is unjust. My statements here are all natural responses. Where are your witnesses while no wrong was committed by UA-cam Guidelines.
Also the grade in Titanium. I know it had a high yield, but that was impressive. I'm a machinist, so I kinda knew what to expect what to expect. Edit: Just noticed that the V-Block gave.
Would be great to know the masses of the pieces. And cost of each piece. Than it would be not only great video, yet awsome educational nerd-style video!
I prefer a material that bends itself instead of exploding catastrophically in pieces like some submarine. Also Titanium does it at a lighter weight per volumetric unit. The only problem of Titanium is it is so expensive.
And it’s heavier. Buoyancy is also a concern. Carbon Fibre isn’t wrong. Ocean Gate just was just completely incompetent. China has a submersible that has a carbon fibre pressure hull that’s capable of 9,000m. Idk if this has been verified by anyone else. It’s not a human sub but it shows that carbon fibre has unexplored capabilities. There just needs to be billions more in R&D.
Fiber-reinforced composites are far more sensitive to concentrated contact stresses than isotropic materials like most rolled/extruded metal shapes. If you had placed a hard rubber pad between the press head and the specimens, then the fiberglass and carbon fiber may have withstood significantly more load. You can see that the rupture initiates near the edges of the head on both specimens. Even though the edges are radiused, they are still digging in and locally deforming, crushing the fiber matrix since the corners of the head bear all of the load once the specimen starts bowing downward.
I am not a specialist, but i highly doubt. If its bent, then its structure is altered. If you use too much energy, and the metal doesnt go back to the state you started, you got plastic damage there. That mean not elastic stress region anymore. That mean you overdid. These are bent, but now are weaker than before.
I would like to see fiberglass layered with bamboo but compress the bamboo first to get it supper thin then over lap them using fiber glass do like a 2x4 with it see how strong it is .
Nice reminder that carbon fiber (and likely fiberglass too) only beat steel by mass and not by volume. An equal mass carbon fiber bar (much much larger) would beat steel by a fair margin, but not an equal size bar.
That test would strongly favor the less-dense materials due to the cubic relationship between cross section diameter and bending moment capacity. I believe the carbon fiber bar would come out on top, followed closely by fiberglass, then titanium a long way behind both, then tool steel a long way behind titanium, followed closely by acrylic, followed closely by aluminium. Yes, plastic narrowly beats aluminium, isn't that a shocker?
Very beautiful and informative video dear. It will be extra informative if you include the fracture force vs the weight (I.e strength vs weight ratio), it will help people see why some material are chided bs other for various applications.
Well, its a good demonstration however which type of carbon fiber prepreg is used, what is the fiber volume content, how is the ply stackage, these affect the test conclusions radically. I believe plies are tape and only oriented at longitudinal direction which makes this specimen incredibly strong at tensile stresses but weak at shear stresses in which specimens are subjected in this test. To wrap it up, if +45/-45 oriented plies are used at a proper amount we would have been seeing a lot a lot more resistance just so you know :) still very good video 👍🏻
mungkin anda perlu menambahkan informasi berapa berat masing masing bahan sebelum dites dengan mesin hidrolik. agar rasionya juga bisa jadi informasi yang lebih bermanfaat.
Steel has always been stronger than titanium. But with the combination of resistance to corrosion (like rust), and it's light weight like aluminum but with much higher heat resistance (2.5 times than aluminum) makes it a high value metal.
اسهل 6 طرق لكسب الثواب بعد الموت : 1- اترك نسخه للقرآن الكريم في أي مسجد. 2- تبرع بكرسي متحرك في أي مستشفي. 3- شارك في بناء مسجد بما يقدرك الله. 4- ضع مبرد في مكان عام. 5- ازرع شجرة ولك اجر من استظل بها. 6- علم أحد دعاء أو ذكر او اية. والأسهل من هذا كله نشر هذه الرسالة . (ربي اغفر لي وتب علي أنك أنت التواب الرحيم. ) صلي على النبي ♥️🌹٠
Carbon fiber and fiberglass are not meant to be used in this type of loading. They resist _stretching_ exceptionally well. For bending or compression, use other materials.
Exactly, there meant for rigidity and weight saving over load strength.
I was amazed at how ductile titanium was.
I got curious to see the forged carbon fiber against regular one, it’s supposed to be much better in such applications.
Did you know carbon fiber can hold up against lava.
🤓☝️
I like seeing the difference in "it failed, but it's still very strong" vs "it failed and it's done now"
People like different things
That’s what we call brittle and ductile 😂
Its called residual resistance
Remember kids, do not make your own submarines from carbon fiber at home!
bruh
pauahahhshahhc
too late, gonna take it to the Titanic tomorrow. Nobody is going to stop me.
Jajajaja ok!
@@benjaminaebersold7488 😂 Hells Gate?
That High-speed steel turned into "high-speed projectile."
Do not repeat at home I have hydraulic press at home 😂😂😂
Me too 😅
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@MCWR32and who doesn't? 😂
@@ttomas6254me and like 1 billion other people
and the hydraulic machine on my dad's pocket 😢😂😂
This is a very interesting study. I was particularly surprised at the brass bar results. I honestly thought it would conform even more so than the 6061 did. Both are gummy to machine. Plus, it was stronger than carbon fiber in that perspective. Impressive! Thanks for sharing. 💪🏾💯🔥
Stockton would have LOVED the sound of that carbon fiber snapping. Too soon? Great video!
In all seriousness, this video shows exactly which materials will give up in a catastrophic way, and which will flex - very instructive for materials selection.
You be as serious as you want. I'll spend my life having fun with idiots.@@mufflejoy
You be serious! I will have fun. Bye!@@mufflejoy
@@DonnyHooterHoot Ehm, OK I guess. See you at the bottom then.
Ever since that one thing happened back then.. Every time i hear the word carbon fiber i think of Stockton Lol
I'm just gonna say this: the acrylic did a whole lot better than I thought it would.
Thank you for the warning😮. I almost brought my hydraulic press home to crush some titanium! Scary.... 😨
🫨🫨
Timestamps:
- First Part:
0:48 - Acryllic
1:19 - Fiberglass
2:12 - Aluminum 6061
3:10- Carbonfiber
3:56 - Brass
4:39 - Titanium
5:46 - High-Speed Steel (HSS)
- Second Part Will Be Soon:
COMING SOON
I was surprised that the brass fractured. I was definitely expecting it to bend and not break. Very interesting.
As someone who has worked with brass it is often surprising brittle.
I expected the fracture. Brass is a powder metal alloy. The structure is not as consistent as aluminum.
There exists a myriad of alloys called brass, that contain copper (cu) and zinc (zn) as main components, but may also contain small amounts of tin, zirconium, arsenic, silicon, aluminium etc. Many cold/ heat treatments aswell. As many variaties as there are applications.
Both alloy brass and steel broken apart🤔 must have something to do with molecular binding
It's supposed to be considerably malleable atleast.
It would be fun to show the weight of each. Also it would be interesting to see the force it takes to get each to a certain amount of deflection.
I love the warning don’t try this at home, but how many of us have a hydraulic press?
its so youtube doesnt take down the video
@@tomichuswhat?
Don't use carbon Fiber as a stair if you have a fat chick is basically the message
at least 40
I have my stone hydraulic press 😂
I didn’t understand a word of this, but somehow I feel smarter just for watching it. Is that how science works?
What's the material of the press itself?
Hardened steel.
@@bensemusx or some hardened iron
Would be neat to see the temperature of the samples as they are crushed. Tin, which has a much lower melting point, seemed more fluid as it distorted from the pressure.
High speed steel alloys can beat titanium but they are a lot heavier, as well!
But the same dimensions, i think that was pure titanium not titanium alloy
it seems to me that it wasn't titanium but some kind of steel. Titanium doesn't have such scale on the surface as this piece of rod
I like how you say nothing and let the screen words do all the talking in your show. 💯
i don't. this is a very engaging video and unwelcoming. please take your false statement to a place where it would be more appropriate. The police are coming to enforce an arrest warrant about you. Count your minutes.
@@O3wormer Your unwelcome reply is unjust. My statements here are all natural responses. Where are your witnesses while no wrong was committed by UA-cam Guidelines.
@@rudytoth I AM NOT HAPPY WITH YOU I WILL REPOTRt YOU UA-cam YOU WILL BAN NO OWRM WOMR NO YOUGET NO WORMS
Curious which heat treatment the 6061 AL was. T4, T6 or ?
Also would like to see mild steel in the mix as well.
Also the grade in Titanium. I know it had a high yield, but that was impressive. I'm a machinist, so I kinda knew what to expect what to expect.
Edit: Just noticed that the V-Block gave.
I wanna know grades too about aluminium am titanium
Remember guys, don't put your iPhone 15 Pro Max under a Hydraulic Press.
De la merde
tech yt channels:
Would be great to know the masses of the pieces. And cost of each piece. Than it would be not only great video, yet awsome educational nerd-style video!
I'm actually pretty shocked by these comparisons, great video.
I prefer a material that bends itself instead of exploding catastrophically in pieces like some submarine. Also Titanium does it at a lighter weight per volumetric unit. The only problem of Titanium is it is so expensive.
And it’s heavier. Buoyancy is also a concern. Carbon Fibre isn’t wrong. Ocean Gate just was just completely incompetent. China has a submersible that has a carbon fibre pressure hull that’s capable of 9,000m. Idk if this has been verified by anyone else. It’s not a human sub but it shows that carbon fibre has unexplored capabilities. There just needs to be billions more in R&D.
Any transparent aluminum
beautiful vid !!! I was more impressed with the fiberglass than the carbon fiber 🤔...just to be otherwise
so are you testing the tensile strength of carbon fiber or is it a different term used? id think its tensile strength, tell me if im wrong
Fiber-reinforced composites are far more sensitive to concentrated contact stresses than isotropic materials like most rolled/extruded metal shapes. If you had placed a hard rubber pad between the press head and the specimens, then the fiberglass and carbon fiber may have withstood significantly more load. You can see that the rupture initiates near the edges of the head on both specimens. Even though the edges are radiused, they are still digging in and locally deforming, crushing the fiber matrix since the corners of the head bear all of the load once the specimen starts bowing downward.
Do you use the same load cell for all of the tests or do you use an appropriate load cell for the amount of force expected?
I would be happy if you can compare steel at diferents temperatures from 0 to 600 C. Is it possible??
The structural integrity of aluminum and titanium was not compromised. So they were not broken. They just bent.
I am not a specialist, but i highly doubt. If its bent, then its structure is altered. If you use too much energy, and the metal doesnt go back to the state you started, you got plastic damage there. That mean not elastic stress region anymore. That mean you overdid. These are bent, but now are weaker than before.
Titanium so much strength
What the heck is the stand holding everything made of??? That's my pick!!!
Hahahahahahahahah iden
A spring that's stops under load. it takes the load till it reaches the bottom of the press
Oh I gotta try this at home because I saw this on UA-cam!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
What were the weights of the samples?
I wonder what made this compressor
6:34 that high speed steel was pretty quick 😂
3:10 " might be, this is what you came for..." Is a nice song though.
what was the weight to strength ratio of the bars?
Bro try to show weight also... It will be fun to see same size materials with different weights
what was the condition of the high speed steel was it normalized or was it hardened
9:55 Яка це бронза, це латунь ЛС59, або подібна.
Can you do 6061 vs 7075 vs 7075 + scandium ?
And cryo treatment and heat treatment ?
What made the High Speed Steel so much stronger but brittle?
2:40 cool beat
I would like to see fiberglass layered with bamboo but compress the bamboo first to get it supper thin then over lap them using fiber glass do like a 2x4 with it see how strong it is .
What were their weights?
Thank you, what's the density and weight of each material?
1:27 wear a mask when working with fiberglass
I want to know instead of destroying things hydrolic press is used for
Hydraulic press made from which steel
Graphene qube please
Nice reminder that carbon fiber (and likely fiberglass too) only beat steel by mass and not by volume. An equal mass carbon fiber bar (much much larger) would beat steel by a fair margin, but not an equal size bar.
Very interesting. It would also be vey interesting if you could repeat this test with these materials in different cross section but equal weight.
That test would strongly favor the less-dense materials due to the cubic relationship between cross section diameter and bending moment capacity. I believe the carbon fiber bar would come out on top, followed closely by fiberglass, then titanium a long way behind both, then tool steel a long way behind titanium, followed closely by acrylic, followed closely by aluminium. Yes, plastic narrowly beats aluminium, isn't that a shocker?
The brass bar would be a lot weaker than the aluminium because it would be at such a disadvantage in area moment of inertia.
What material is the machine made of? Is it tungsten?
Very beautiful and informative video dear. It will be extra informative if you include the fracture force vs the weight (I.e strength vs weight ratio), it will help people see why some material are chided bs other for various applications.
What is that machine press made up of ?
Paper mache
If Oceangate had used Brass _Stocky_ might still be here!
It is even worse, carbon fiber is one of those rare materials that isn't strong under compression.
Do not repeat at home what you saw in this video 😂
Sh**t I’ll have to send back that massive hydraulic press I just ordered from Amazon
I know it would be expensive experiment but also it would be awesome when you could include diamond and gold in the experiment.
Well, its a good demonstration however which type of carbon fiber prepreg is used, what is the fiber volume content, how is the ply stackage, these affect the test conclusions radically. I believe plies are tape and only oriented at longitudinal direction which makes this specimen incredibly strong at tensile stresses but weak at shear stresses in which specimens are subjected in this test. To wrap it up, if +45/-45 oriented plies are used at a proper amount we would have been seeing a lot a lot more resistance just so you know :) still very good video 👍🏻
Can you a weaver carbon fiber piece and test it ?
Can you do the adamantium test?
Wow, that was interesting!
How hot was that to titanium when u pulled it out?
From here I can hear indian drum music 2:23
South Indian
@@ShashiDas291still Indian ❤
Can you tell me what material the hydraulic press is made of?
It would be interesting to see the temperature displayed.
'Do not repeat at home' like I have hydraulic press
Could You reaped those tests for the same materials with arc shape, please?
What about tungsten?
Which is the meterial of using for hydraulic
Curious about graphene
0:01 thank you! I won’t use my hydraulic press in my room at home!
Hello
What is the weight of each one?
Thanks
weight vs load bearing capacity?
mungkin anda perlu menambahkan informasi berapa berat masing masing bahan sebelum dites dengan mesin hidrolik. agar rasionya juga bisa jadi informasi yang lebih bermanfaat.
You should show the weight of each sample..
¿De que material estan hechos la parte superior e inferior de la prensa que hacen contacto con los distintos materiales?
marshmallows
لا اعلم متى سيصبح الكاربون فايبر رخيص ويتم استخدامه في ادوات مهمه كثيرة
Please test adamantium & vibranium.
What is the metal or material that is impossible to break? 🤔
"Do not try this at home!"
Sure, anyone has a hydraulic press in his basement 😂
I didn't expect Steel to fail like that! I thought it was more ductile (like Titanium)... BTW What is "High Speed" Steel?
It would be interresting to measure the weight of each material
Its easy to calculate
Why ?????
Would like to watch it with thermal screen, it will be interesting to know which part of the metal gets hot during hydraulic press
Can you compare supertuff nylon vs Aluminum?
Did fibre glass carry more than aluminum
0:00 i dont have any hydraulic press or titanium or carbon fiber blocks casually sitting around
Adamantium???
Should know how cost each one and in what areas they can be used
does it mean that steel is stronger than titanium?
Steel has always been stronger than titanium. But with the combination of resistance to corrosion (like rust), and it's light weight like aluminum but with much higher heat resistance (2.5 times than aluminum) makes it a high value metal.
Can u weighg it before u put it on press
Can you crush a JPMorgan Chase card?
No
Ah yes this Carbon Fiber Looks very Safe I think I‘ll build a submarine out of this and visit The Titanic
-Ocean Gate CEO
Because it’s safe
Missed opportunity when you make a thing called the Titan to take super rich people to the Titanic and still not use Titanium?
by volume alone steel wins, but by weight ?
Die frage ist, wie lange scharf?
Endlich eine deutsch Kommentare
Klar, eure Test's sehen wir hier in Germany ebenso, mit Spannung !@@Eisenwolf.de1
اسهل 6 طرق لكسب الثواب بعد الموت :
1- اترك نسخه للقرآن الكريم في أي مسجد.
2- تبرع بكرسي متحرك في أي مستشفي.
3- شارك في بناء مسجد بما يقدرك الله.
4- ضع مبرد في مكان عام.
5- ازرع شجرة ولك اجر من استظل بها.
6- علم أحد دعاء أو ذكر او اية. والأسهل من هذا كله نشر هذه الرسالة . (ربي اغفر لي وتب علي أنك أنت التواب الرحيم. ) صلي على النبي ♥️🌹٠
You should point out the grade of titanium and type of high speed steel
It appears that the machine is constructed from the strongest material. I wonder what material it is made of.
5:01 wow nice music 🎵