THE DEBATE - Italy's cry for help: What's Europe's answer to the migrant crisis?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 жов 2024
- Subscribe to France 24 now:
f24.my/youtubeEN
FRANCE 24 live news stream: all the latest news 24/7
f24.my/YTliveEN
Last week, overwhelmed Italy threatened to shut its border. That forced a crisis meeting of European Union interior ministers to try to impose a long-promised sharing of the burden when it comes to refugees and migrants who continue to aim for Europe's shores. Two years after the deal with Turkey to close the Balkan route, what's the right response to another summer of deadly tragedy?
Produced by Daniel BARNEY, Alessandro XENOS, Christopher DAVIS.
Visit our website:
www.france24.com
Subscribe to our UA-cam channel:
f24.my/youtubeEN
Like us on Facebook:
/ france24.english
Follow us on Twitter:
/ france24_en
that women is a dangerous flake, what about the rights of italians whose country is collapsing economically and socially.
Then they should stop taking the money from the eu
Italy actually gives money to the EU. Quite a lot.
Yeah she is an absolute enabler
I don't think she knows the definition of solidarity. Hospitality?! Let these people move into her house and see how long her opinion stays the same. What we've seen in Italy we now are seeing in the English Channel.
Say NO to SHARIA LAW!!!!! Entitled Muslim migrants are not willing to assimilate! Poland and Hungary have the right ideas!!
This is why woman should not debate the migrant crisis. They all scream human rights, human rights, human rights. WHAT ABOUT OUR RIGHTS LADY????????
WHAT ABOUT YOUR CHILDREN'S RIGHT? AND THEIR CHILDREN'S RIGHTS?
That women is insane.
She's just your typical marxist.
Italians need to leave the EU now, and take back Italy.
why should africa be allowed to move to europe. they should do what australia did-send them with no hope of residency if they invade illegally
You are very stupid
you must be a migrant.
Marion Mann why African will not come to urop .uropean come to Africa to come and us power to African took them to urop for slavery.
their right is in France, 90% of them are from French speaking African countries and France have been stealing their resources and they are printing money for 14 French speaking countries. It's pay back time 🤣🤣🤣
You are DEAD right!!!!! Come visit SA !!!
These boats appear to be completely full of fighting age men. Where are the women and children. Single men should not even be admitted. They should be protecting the women children and elderly in there own country. How do they even feed all of these men.
They tax the people of Europe to pay for food, medicine, and other things. Vat and so many other taxes! Europe is famous for high taxes. To feed all of Africa, apparently, if the wonderful elites of the EU Bureaucracy don't change their minds. They've been at it for years now, and it's still keeping on, isn't it?
@@carriersailor2474 just think Africa will have + 120 million people more in less than 10 years and they will not have the food or jobs necessary to sustain them, failed continent
This woman is clearly insane, doesn't want to debate important questions/issues and is blinded by sainthood.
This woman invites burglars into her house probably every night, I mean, she is so hospitable
Herman Geldenhuys And lovely 😆😆😆
This woman has no idea what these foreign men are doing to europe and its citizens. It is a huge burden. omg, I can't even listen to her.
Italy should of stood up years ago and said NO!.....their own fault...All rests on the insane shoulders of Merkel
Ray D a
Look how many Americans want immigration reform/tightening in the USA, but the liberal left wants America to be a 'free-for-all' for anyone and everyone.
I believe many of these lefties are young, and do not have a clue what it is they're asking for and inviting-in! I'm hoping this current president, President Trump, holds true to his promises he made during the campaign; tighten immigration and put a stop to immigrants coming from terrorist countries. America has enough to deal with, we don't need any more. These immigrants should have gone to Saudi arabia, but that wasn't part of their agenda.
They go out of their way to save them from drowning, whilst their own citizens are suffering.
Thank you for your perspective Captain Hindsight.
We couldn't do much, we were even neglected to vote. It's funny how EU people have become somewhat scared when 5 Stelle and Lega got elected!
i want to know what this lady smoking because shes in lala land lol .
Glue...
She's lost the plot, we should support the Italian population.
It's too late, the damage has been done, keep providing a taxi service Italy. Europe will be destroyed.
Those international NGOs are aiding human traffickers. Isn't that sort of the opposite of their mission statement? This is why naive people with money are dangerous......
MUST CLOSE THE BORDERS...THATS IT NO MORE TALK!!
Simple answer ignore EU directives and leave !
i am afraid to say italy will be stuck with the problem soon no eu states will take anymore.its gone to far.
That woman on top of having loud and annoying voice has very disturbing views.
Dismantel the EU and the UN. Neither is needed nor wantwd!!
What is that woman talking about? How is Europe Required to take on responsibility for the human rights violations of other nations? Are wonen in politics all Leftists? She's just screaming. Get her out! They aren't even working but taking welfare. Cant the young Muslim men make a government in Libya?
the middle east needs to take them in but they won't because they know what will happen to their country.
YOU NEVER HEAR THE EU TALKING ABOUT SENDING THEM BACK AND TAKING CARE OF THOSE PEOPLE IN THEIR OWN COUNTRIES.
That woman is dreaming. It is just impossible to take in everybody.
Declare a state of emergency, round up all immigrants and sail them back to Libya. A cry for help to the EU from a sovereign nation is code for giving the former more of the latter's powers.
The lady is delusional, most of the invaders don't work. R I P ( REST IN PIECES) 😈
what is wrong with this women????
Does Europe have to have the whole of AFRICA IN EUROPE.?????????
i just cannot stand that lady. its like a little idealistic girl in an adults' conversation
15:04: Trafficking: "to deal or trade in something illegal". The NGOs often go out of territorial waters right to the coast of Libya as discussed shortly afterwards. The NGOs are trafficking - they're human traffickers. Not lawful.
It seems to me that we will not tolerate one country invading another but it is OK for their citizens to just push their way into other countries and expect to be fed watered and housed at others’ expense.
Europe for Europeans! ONLY!
THE EU AND GEORGE SOROS IS LAUGHING AT ALL THIS.
There's always an extreme-left/amnesty international creature in these debates. Where is the water cannon?
Shoshna Fine talks about migrants been needed in Germany because of it's ageing population,if that is the case why doesn't Germany employ people from Spain,Greece and other parts of Europe whose unemployment is skyrocketing?
Because people from Spain, Greece and other parts of Europe are lazy!
They have right to free movement in the EU but prefer to stay at home and not work.
I congratulate the refugees and migrants for making their European dream come true!
Kevin the best: Are you for real ???
France, Germany and Belgium should take them all. It's their policy.
who to blame for all of this and what is the solution to all of this?
SAINT WORDS
add swedistan
BJ Martin no one is obligated. You're wrong.
they are economic migrants, get your facts straight.
How many migrants has Shoshana Fine taken into her home?
Switzerland is in Schengen; send the migrants to Davos!
Also: any migrant woman with 2 children from her country MUST ACCEPT AN IUD, until she's shipped back to her country after her country is settled somewhat, so NO CHILD IS BORN IN YOUR COUNTRY.
The people WANT THEIR OWN COUNTRY...help financially settle the country of origin & return these migrants ASAP.
Nancy Anthoulakis Agreed. Keep in mind these Muslim women have an average of five to six children and they live in families with a total of three or four wives. The entire family often consists of 15 to 20 children. Guess who's paying.... Certainly NOT the Refugee /illegal Father if he can even GET a job in Western Europe, being illiterate or an IQ averaging high 70s highest mid-eighties. And these women don't/ or are not allowed to work by their husbands.There are only so many labor jobs to go around which are actually needed by the native people of the countries themselves.... It's a recipe for economic destruction of Western Europe.
@@supernovagirl5008 At least 500 girls come to have a Supernova experience so let them be.
Celebrate and take it Higher.
get merkel out now or europes going dwn the drain
Please ask the woman if she thinks countries should help stabilize the reason and if the men of fighting age should be trained to fight their own battles within their own countries as men should do. She just demands everyone give shelter and handouts which only create hateRed towards the migrants/refugees and tensions between the citizens and their own govt. why should the citizens pay tallies and send thier children to fight for them, where is thier pride and loyalty, if they have none for their own country what makes you think they will have any for their host country. I wouldn’t want a man that runs to father my children. The world does not need more weak and ignorant. Birth control and education is the answer to all the worlds problems!
that girl o debate is totaly out of mind..."solidarity"? with economy refugees? she s sick
i hope this woman will be willing to stand in the front line, when it all kicks off as it eventually will..
Of course, she will be in hiding, like all the people like her!
Build that wall ! and then build Africa ! Help all people, give them technology and jobs and help them build their continent !
No need to give them anything, it's enough to stop stealing their resources, but this will not happen.
@@МаяТонева Theving will never stop it's in their G.
That woman is an embarrassment to rational, intelligent females everywhere!
"solidarity" there is that word again, we don't owe those economic migrants anything.
She should take home some refugees!
women should not be involved in government are policy decisions, the whole material thing. they can't make tough decisions, there is the rare exception, but overall women are disastrous in important national decisions
Gary Murtagh Proven to be quite true. The protectors of societies throughout history have been men.
Does Africa have a lot of women leaders? How about central America? If women are to blame they would be the most prosperous
That woman is impossible.
Italy make me laugh they invited all immigrates-and now are crying for help !!!!
gotta love this italian guy " dont live in a world of unicorn and rainbows ":D
That woman is a nut job ...
The woman is speaking like an insane person....needs to be dropped down over Lebanon so she can do some more research!
Too late, Italy will need someone like Mussolini.
In this situation Mussolini wouldn't be able to hang himself with Spaghetti.😅
This woman is very dangerous short term thinker and has no idea what she's saying. She needs to spend a few months in one of those countries all alone by herself and if she survives, then make up her mind.
Is she NUTS!! 1st do away with your security?
Lebanon is not a fair comparison. They have the same religion and language and culture as Syrians. You can NOT compare that to Europe.
They should go to Jordan
Where is the mafia when you want them
Transporting people from Afrika and Asia, off course all planned in advance and ordered by those who rule the World.
Fit huge springs around the entire coast of Europe and UK so they can all bounce off back home and "celebrate" an international cry-for-a-migrant day instead. Joking aside, this really has to stop. It has gone way too far already.
Poland took within last tree years about 1.4 milions newely economic migrants and many refuges from Ukraine, Belarus, Russia, etc. (from Eastern direction) because if you didn't notice Poland also have EU external border. EU Commission must punish French, Italians etc. for not showing solidarity with Poles (which within last two years took more economic migrants than for example Italy). Luckily for Polish society (due to British pound devaluation, chauvinism and murders committed on Polish people by radical ethnic nationalist in UK and finally due to terrorist attacks of islamofascists radical religious terrorists which murdered many Polish people in Western Europe) Polish people has started to go back to Poland from emigration. We see historical change; first time since decades more people settled in Poland than went away. We also have record numbers of tourists because of lack of terrorist attacks in our country. I guess we should be thankful for reckless migration policy of Western Europe because it helps our economy. Personally I'm supporting the idea that Poland should take this 7000 carefully selected refugees which was promised by previous Polish government (because pacta sunt servanda) but at the same time I see that a blackmail of EU Commission that threatens to take EU funds only helps to win another elections to current catho-authoritarian government (what really piss me off). Unfortunately the ruling party is raising lately in the polls due to this blunt threats from EU Commission so as you can see what they're doing is totally counterproductive; they lessens the chances of the restoration of the rule of law in Poland.
Raju Baju how many poles have been murdered in U.K. By "ethnic nationalists "??????
Raju Baju The Visgrad Four, of : Poland, Hungry, Slovakia and the Czech Republic, in my opinion is the future and only salvation for Christianity in Europe. The rest will fall unless something is done ......soon. Some countries there already have little chance of turning things around. The Islamization of Western Europe will be its downfall. Again the IQs of these incoming illegals/refugees is something quite scary .....but only looking at the worldwide IQ chart can one totally see what type of people are coming in and how they CAN'T be a positive contribution to a European society that is Progressive. It will be the dumbing-down of Europe and hence its destruction. They will never be able to compete with Nations like : China/South Korea who have IQs of around 108.! The immigrants from Africa and the Middle East average IQs are around mid to low 70s with a few in the low-80s. How will they integrate with a Europe of apprix. 100-102 average IQ.??? They must be planning on interbreeding...... because genetics tells you an Offspring usually has the IQ of their mothers and fathers.
The answer: The Dillon Aero M134D Gatling Gun.
put "Shoshana" in one of those boats to "report on the crossing" and see what she thinks if she makes it back.
What does the pope say. They have money.
Poland; We have told you, but you are not listening.
What for you need this people , for what?
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes
Sorry, Poland will not help u ;/ Where is your army?
atexxoo The Visgrad four of: Hungry, Poland, Slovakia and the Czech Republic + Austria & Romania, all Eastern European countries, are the only salvation for a Christian Europe. Westrrn seems screwed with a big S!!
People like Shoshanna should not be a part of serious discussions like this. Her level of immaturity is detrimental and offensive.
man that chick is insane
I'm glad we're out of it, 80% don't even look for work.
A CLEVER person can somehow rescue himself from a situation that a WISE person will never enters!!!0
panzer shrek l dont lough. l feel sorrow for what happaned in europe. lts bad situation for everyone. clash of civilizations. interesting but sad.
@@hanabiro their right is in France, 90% of them are from French speaking African countries and France have been stealing their resources and they are printing money for 14 French speaking countries. It's pay back time 🤣🤣🤣
@@hanabiro What's so sad let the Light in from Hasbara.
There's no Government in Libya and they have no work so numbers of migrant is going to be popular
Their Muslim brothers need to take them in.....Saudia Arabia and Qatar have TONS of money to take care of them for the rest of their lives and also have the mosques in which they can celebrate their common religion.
Send her my I the Middle Easter and live for six months łmmwithout security’
Debates are the classic way to keep nagging problems under wraps and Carlyle below explains why this is the case :
If you do not wish a man to do a thing, you had better get him to talk about it; for the more men talk, the more likely they are to do nothing else.
- Thomas Carlyle, 1795 - 1881
Its very sad that they create that cind of contitions and they push peacefull people to their limits and after acuse them for Racism. It is mind blowing. And also the people that deliberatly coming in are we shure they share the same values with us?
Free speach , expresing of feelings , Philosofy , art , CONSTITUTION? For what exacly we swap our way of life? Our mind set?
Even if you have good attentions please be carful we live in Cheeky times.
All military age male
EU countries should have the policy that any immigrant/migrant/refugee must get and keep a job in order to remain. stop the open ended welfare paid to them, if they are unwilling to support themselves they shouldn't be allowed to be a BURDEN on the people of the EU. if these migrants are so enriching to the economic status, then why is Italy in such a bad state of economic crisis? whether people like it or not, the native population of the EU countries have a right to THEIR culture and sovereignty and should not be forced to accommodate "guest"and their culture.
People aren't so worried about elderly, women, and children. Why is it always young fit men traveling past multiple nations to get into the EU?
Lady is off her rocker.
They don't need help, now they are helping themselves
NGO are sure lives in La-la-land.
they get money for war
but can't feed the poor
They are not asylum seekers they are economic migrants from Libya. One immediate useful action would be to confiscate or sink the traffickers boats once the migrants have been taken on board the NGO boats. Why cannot the traffickers be arrested by a EU naval force ?
ITALIANI KARI KIP THE GARBIGE
They should have gone after the smugglers to stop refugee crisis.It's a terrible mess for Europe.
Hey, to my fellow Italians. Want to hear a funny joke? The World Cup that was won by France, they only had 3 white players on the team, hehehe. France is becoming an Black African Country. They are even thinking of changing their name to Wakanda! hehe
Roman Darius > Its like old days black & white what are these French fries going to do about it😆
With Gaddafi there was no problem that is why certain people wanted him gone. All those NGOs are all registered in Israel,now there's a coincidence.
I would like to get a closer look at Miss Fine.
That woman is off her head.
The whole world economy should invest in "oasis" for migrants to go to for work, clean water, family friendly shelter; find a better life in reasonable protected hubs of advanced innovation and development, so they don't all need to go to Europe.
People should be sent to countries with similar cultures including religion. Italy has a special culture they want to preserve.
Do not bring sea pirates to Italy. If sea pirates want to drown let they drown.
This crap really needs to stop
The problem is not Libya, solidarity, Africans or muslims. The prpblems are italians and europeans. So this is not THE debate.
Italy's main problem is that they belong to the EU. Rules come from Brussels.
Europe's answer? We'll schedule a meeting in a few years. Hopefully everyone will have forgotten about it before then.
Confiscate the boats, send the people back to the Libyan shore.
Why can't these people live in there own country's I don't see mostly young men
Mass- migration is a phenomenon of our times similar to the time of Attila the Hun but in this time often without an identifiable aggressor. I am a migrant and my aggressor was fear itself from fellow fear makers who are not always fear makers and do not wear a label. Fear in form of anxiety/ discouragement breaks out in specific situations like a sickness. Where is the root of this? Why would we move about out of fear? Can we transform our moving about into a pilgrimage searching for beauty and living the fullness of it? My moving about should rather be a pilgrimage and I like to encourage everybody to find beauty.
Migranten aufnehmen heisst Arbeit anbieten und gerechte Loehne bezahlen. Je nach Koennen und Leistung einer Person soll sie unterstuetzt/ gefoerdert werden sodass sie sich schnellstens selbststaendig machen kann und weiterhin Platz fuer Arbeitnehmer schafft. Propagieren Sie einen geordneten Markt und Produktentwicklung was auf noble Weise ausgebaut und global vernetzt wird. Man braucht eine gute Erkennungsfaehigkeit von solchen Personen (ob Migranten mit Familie oder Einheimische) mit Faehigkeiten und Talenten, Leute die vielleicht ein eigenes Unternehmen gehabt haben und Erfahrung aufzeigen fuer einen Neuaufbau. Wir brauchen Einheimische die mit ihren Rechten sich in Positionen stellen um zu entscheiden ob und wie weit man den Neuankoemmling foerdert. Die Unterstuetzung ist in meisten Faellen keine Geldfrage sondern eine Erlaubnisfrage im Rechtsstaat. Ich, ein Auslandsoesterreicher seit ueber 14 Jahre, stelle mich gern fuer solch eine Positon zur Verfuegung
The question is why does Italy allow migrant boats to dock in Italy? France and Spain won't allow them to. I have sympathy with Italy in that most of the 600 000 migrants that have made it to Italy want to move on to other EU nations. In context of this broadcast from France 24 many migrants in Italy are from French speaking nations in the ME and Africa and want to get to France. Soshana Fine tries to avoid the issue and seems to think that unlimited numbers can migrate - she is quite mad.
If your house is full then closes the door stop looking for who to defraud,if the EU need migrants then they will send the workers money and other assistance.does it means that Italy can't control their boarder if the war of terorists starts?????????????????????