33:08 The Asharis response to this would be 2 hands in the language refers to Power not 2 powers and the language permits this. Reference: Ibn Jawzi in Daf ash shubha says: “there is such a convention in the language. The Arabs used to say: He does not have two hands in this affair" meaning that, "He has no power in it whatsoever." "Urwa ibn Hizām said, "So, they said: 'May God cure you, By God, we do not have two hands in what the ribs have con- cealed."
@Messi10266 do me a favour Google 1)Who Mythra is to christainty 2) what day was he born and to what type of women and in which location and 3) how many followers he had and what his mission was on earth.
I would be very grateful if you and especially Mohammed Hijab could educate us more closely on the subject of Christians regarding the Athariyya, because somehow they have heard about it and are bringing good arguments against us Muslims in this direction
Quran says that if there were three gods then each will have its own creation and there would be disagreement. BUT... what do Christians believe? Christians believe that the persons of the trinity have THE SAME WILL, they can't disagree with each other!! MEANING THEY ARE THE SAME GOD!
MashaAllah, it was joy to watch this video. Absoloutley trinity goes against everything. It doesnt make sense, as Allah said in the quran: if there were therein ( in the heavens and the earth) gods besides Allah then verily both would heve been disordered.
22:35 due to the principle of sufficient reason there cannot be an explanation to the greatest explanation, if there were then we have an infinite no of explanations which negates the principle of sufficient reason itself, hence thats why allah does not have physicalist parts, i e both anthropromorphism and etc, because physicalist hands, minds, faces all are constituents of explanation. JAZAKALLAH.
The standard islamic narrative throughout history is that the Quran has multiple modes. All are from the seven ahruf dimensions. But it must be going back to the Prophet pbuh. Al-Makkî categorized it like 1. Change of i'rab 2. Change of dialectical recitation. 3. Ta'kheer taqdeem 4. Change of definite indefinite etc etc for a more accurate categorization please refer to the famous classical work of him Ibānah. Please dont impose upon Islam your western narrative. The Quran is above your western standards. It is more advanced than your literature
Quran didn't understand the trinity! Thinks mary is one of them 😂 Best case scenario is to say quran doesn't define the trinity, which is embarrassing because he has to articulate and refute it, but it didn't.
33:08 The Asharis response to this would be 2 hands in the language refers to Power not 2 powers and the language permits this. Reference: Ibn Jawzi in Daf ash shubha says: “there is such a convention in the language. The Arabs used to say: He does not have two hands in this affair" meaning that, "He has no power in it whatsoever." "Urwa ibn Hizām said, "So, they said: 'May God cure you, By God, we do not have two hands in what the ribs have con- cealed."
In page 52 of the book*
I was waiting for this. The notion thst the trinity violates all 3 laws of logic was a great lesson from last time.
Okay, what about Islam -are there 2 eternal entities.?
@Messi10266 do me a favour Google 1)Who Mythra is to christainty 2) what day was he born and to what type of women and in which location and 3) how many followers he had and what his mission was on earth.
Suboor is the best Christian debater I have ever heard.
may Allah bless the Sapience brothers
I would be very grateful if you and especially Mohammed Hijab could educate us more closely on the subject of Christians regarding the Athariyya, because somehow they have heard about it and are bringing good arguments against us Muslims in this direction
Quran says that if there were three gods then each will have its own creation and there would be disagreement.
BUT...
what do Christians believe?
Christians believe that the persons of the trinity have THE SAME WILL, they can't disagree with each other!! MEANING THEY ARE THE SAME GOD!
So if God on earth for 33 years couldn't explain trinity so how come we human explain this mystery
JazakAllahu khair
Loving these
Where can we go for debate practice?
There will be those who understand those that do not. Hijad is one that does not
As Salaam, Mash-Allah, very helpful video. May Allah Ta'ala bless and increase you
MashaAllah, it was joy to watch this video. Absoloutley trinity goes against everything. It doesnt make sense, as Allah said in the quran: if there were therein ( in the heavens and the earth) gods besides Allah then verily both would heve been disordered.
22:35 due to the principle of sufficient reason there cannot be an explanation to the greatest explanation, if there were then we have an infinite no of explanations which negates the principle of sufficient reason itself, hence thats why allah does not have physicalist parts, i e both anthropromorphism and etc, because physicalist hands, minds, faces all are constituents of explanation. JAZAKALLAH.
Mashallah
Banger episode
Mashallah 😂😂😂
Why not ask him about the 30 versions of the quran that breaks the standard Islamic narrative.
The standard islamic narrative throughout history is that the Quran has multiple modes. All are from the seven ahruf dimensions. But it must be going back to the Prophet pbuh. Al-Makkî categorized it like 1. Change of i'rab 2. Change of dialectical recitation. 3. Ta'kheer taqdeem 4. Change of definite indefinite etc etc for a more accurate categorization please refer to the famous classical work of him Ibānah. Please dont impose upon Islam your western narrative. The Quran is above your western standards. It is more advanced than your literature
Quran didn't understand the trinity!
Thinks mary is one of them 😂
Best case scenario is to say quran doesn't define the trinity, which is embarrassing because he has to articulate and refute it, but it didn't.
Auwal
second.
@@ayeshayasir8665 You mean ithnan?