A CRITIC ONCE SAID THIS ABOUT SHINee [ON ONE ARTICLE EARLY THIS YEAR/2013] : "MAYBE SOME PEOPLE DOUBT THAT THEY SING LIVE BECAUSE THEY ARE TOO GOOD"!!, IN OTHER WORDS "THEY ARE TOO GOOD FOR SINGING LIVE WHILE DANCING SUCH AN INTENSE, ENERGETIC & IN SYNC DANCE/CHOREO STILL WITH STABLE VOICES"!! BUT INDEED, SHINee COULD PULL OFF AN AWESOME PERFORMANCE WITH THAT CONDITION !! SO IF WE DON'T KNOW THEM, BETTER DON'T SAY SOMETHING THAT COULD MAKE EMBARRASSED OURSELF..!! SHINee IS KNOWN FOR THEIR PERFECT LIVE SINGING, EVEN CRITICS ACKNOWLEDGE IT.!!
Onew looks like a prince charming who just got off his horse to entertain an entire audience with his amazing vocals~~ I mean that outfit with the horse riding boots--GAWD he looks so handsome~ He looks so much better with loose pants like these! I mean, how can one man be so charming--it feels like I'm under some sort of spell...ugh this feels so unhealthy...sometimes I wish he'd find himself a girlfriend so I can stop thinking that I might have a chance with him~ LOL
hahaha... have you seen them lip sync? they are so bad at it. they are the worst at it. I swear i have never seen anyone worse at lip synching than they are.
I don't think SHINee ever Lipsync ballads. Dance songs sometimes they do because of the complicated choreography and that's so normal. majority of western artists do that but these boys r capable of dancing n singing. It's not upto them. I uploaded their first concert on my channel n u can tell that they r Lipsync while dancing. It's obvious but I'm sure they hated it
their faces are like ㅎㅅㅎ when they lipsync but they don't lipsync very often just once in a while and that is still fine but i hate when people say "ha they can't sing" .-.
This song is so powerful, full of passion, and painfully beautiful. I remember at @3:21 Onew had been performing with a neck injury from the everybody era and we can see him hurting. But he maintained his voice so beautifully and steady. Ay I love SHInee so much 🥺❤️ 9 years later I’m still here
Thanks cameraman, I really wanted to watch my favorite singers perform from a mile away. But seriously, who hired this guy? GET CLOSE UPS. I can get this view from fancams, kthxbai.
AAAAAARRRGGGHHHH their voices kill me!!!!! I just hope that after all this excitement with their new album and the YTMAs that they can get some well deserved rest. They need it!!! Shinee fighting!!!!!
i think the first half is lip-sync and then the other half is live. nevertheless, the boys didn't fail to show their charms to the audience, especially ONEW..such a cute innocent look...i think i'm gonna fall off my seat while watching his stare...loved it so much!
I wonder if this was before or after Onew hurt himself! If he is hurt, can he not dance, thus shouldn't he atleast be sitting? Anyway, This is always so amazing!
This isn't live! This is lip sync... Look at Onew at 3:47 but it's true, their lives are much better and awesome. I don' understand why they didn't sing live here
To me its understandable why SHINee lip synced the dancing part to their performance. If they didn't, you'd probably hear gasps of air in between each word xD I'm not bothered by that at all because I already know that what they bring to the stage is their raw talent. They're very skilled at dancing and singing, and I would go on, but it would end up in fangirlish squeals and whatnot. Symptoms is one of the most powerful songs I've ever heard them sing. Lip syncing does not make them fake. I mean come on, you've already heard what they can do just from the recording alone! As you can see, I'm very fond of them lol I'll just cut this comment off here before this turns into an essay. Go SHINee!♡☆
+Özge Dağoğlu to answer you question, I say that this is lip synched because the audio thats playing sounds EXACTLY like the song on the actual recording of the song. Plus you can hear by ear (after listening to the full version over a thousand times like I did xD) when they are singing with the music. There would've been a slight difference as to how they sang the song compared to the original. Yes there are adlibs, but there are adlibs in the original as well and you can tell that the adlibs are the same. I am not saying this to shame them. Several bands do this all the time! Like I said in my previous comment, they are not fake. I'm sure you and I can both agree that they are VERY talented and their overall performance was amazing!! But I do believe that they lip synced at least the majority of their performance and Im not the only one who sees that. No, them lip synching was not disappointing nor will they EVER disappoint me. I will always be proud to be a SHINee fan and I hope to see them live myself to see their talents up close and personal ♡_♡ So yea...hope that answered your question! lol
:O i guess i got it but i thought they were singing live with the audio on the background thank you very much for answering :) i will look at the video again to fully understand
+Özge Dağoğlu No problem ^-^ and dont worry, we all have our opinions! It doesn't change the fact that whether its a recording or live singing, everyone in SHINee are still amazing. No need for autotune because thats their real voice! At least we can agree that SHINee is terrific! ♡
i'm so disappointed that kibummie only got one closeup even though he had many parts... even minho who only had two lines got more closeups than key... what's the cameraman doing?!
![[YTMA] SHINee 샤이니 - "Everybody"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zQy51eMRjik/mqdefault.jpg)
A CRITIC ONCE SAID THIS ABOUT SHINee [ON ONE ARTICLE EARLY THIS YEAR/2013] : "MAYBE SOME PEOPLE DOUBT THAT THEY SING LIVE BECAUSE THEY ARE TOO GOOD"!!, IN OTHER WORDS "THEY ARE TOO GOOD FOR SINGING LIVE WHILE DANCING SUCH AN INTENSE, ENERGETIC & IN SYNC DANCE/CHOREO STILL WITH STABLE VOICES"!! BUT INDEED, SHINee COULD PULL OFF AN AWESOME PERFORMANCE WITH THAT CONDITION !! SO IF WE DON'T KNOW THEM, BETTER DON'T SAY SOMETHING THAT COULD MAKE EMBARRASSED OURSELF..!! SHINee IS KNOWN FOR THEIR PERFECT LIVE SINGING, EVEN CRITICS ACKNOWLEDGE IT.!!
Just when i think i have found my fave SHINee song
BOOM this comes along
SHINee never fail to amaze me
if you realise, Key is the only one dancing in the box HAHAHA SO CUTE
Loved how Key still wanted to do the dance in his little box X'D this is why I adore him
Onew looks like a prince charming who just got off his horse to entertain an entire audience with his amazing vocals~~ I mean that outfit with the horse riding boots--GAWD he looks so handsome~ He looks so much better with loose pants like these! I mean, how can one man be so charming--it feels like I'm under some sort of spell...ugh this feels so unhealthy...sometimes I wish he'd find himself a girlfriend so I can stop thinking that I might have a chance with him~ LOL
Omg.....lols
This song seriously needs a MV. Is much better than Everybody imo.
I love them both U.U SHINee rocks......
Love Onew 's voice
Hahaha your name
This is definitely LIVE not Lipsync. They are THAT good!! CDNee
yup it is that is why i'm a proud shawol :3
hahaha... have you seen them lip sync? they are so bad at it. they are the worst at it. I swear i have never seen anyone worse at lip synching than they are.
I don't think SHINee ever Lipsync ballads. Dance songs sometimes they do because of the complicated choreography and that's so normal. majority of western artists do that but these boys r capable of dancing n singing. It's not upto them. I uploaded their first concert on my channel n u can tell that they r Lipsync while dancing. It's obvious but I'm sure they hated it
their faces are like ㅎㅅㅎ when they lipsync but they don't lipsync very often just once in a while and that is still fine but i hate when people say "ha they can't sing" .-.
Pple r jealous haters. Us fans know the truth. They r masters of dance n vocals. They r gold
This song is so powerful, full of passion, and painfully beautiful. I remember at @3:21 Onew had been performing with a neck injury from the everybody era and we can see him hurting. But he maintained his voice so beautifully and steady. Ay I love SHInee so much 🥺❤️
9 years later I’m still here
3:22 Why Onew 😍😭 your voice kill me everytime 💞 i love the way you adlibs to high notes 💖 ICONIC
omg!!! onew's voice is like a honey but also seductive.....he's voice such a golden voice...i miss hearing them seeing...shinEE fighting
Thanks cameraman, I really wanted to watch my favorite singers perform from a mile away.
But seriously, who hired this guy? GET CLOSE UPS. I can get this view from fancams, kthxbai.
Key is awesome！
This video should come with a warning, seriously Jonghyun is killing me! 😍
I love them and their voice's.....
i would play all those SHINee's song before i go to bed...
hoping that someday i can met with them...
I love Onew
I love this show version
I could be listening to this song forever
Their live singing is so *chef kiss
WHY DIDN'T THEY ZOOM KEY WHEN HE WAS INSIDE THE BOX?! :(
헐 이영상 레전드영상인데
Onew for sure, I know his handsome and made me scream Onprince!!!!!!
Taemin...so sexy and handsome, HIS DANCES
YTMA in Seoul was a big success, way better than the one in New York. No offense for American
jonghyun and taemin
Best K-Pop song of 2013... Daebak!
I love this song so much! Not a big fan of K-Pop but this is awesome
i never doubt it, coz its SHINEE...
omg taemin
they are really good....
ONEW ♥
Their vocal abilitys are AWESOME and shame you you for the people that think they are lip synching 🇰🇷🇰🇷❤️❤️❤️
Nicey kaau! This deserves more and more views honestly
jonghyung your voice is killing me .
hm-
Shinee my favorite now-
Perfect song for me toward SHINee.....
the reason i'm in love and forever a shawol.
It's great to have #Shinee symptoms! 😘
their vocal wooow amazing voice and dancers
DieHard Fan of SHINee Sarang hae Yo
I miss you jonghyun oppa....without your voice it's awkward to listen shinee's performance.. u did well jonghyun oppa plz reborn again missing u
taemin look like a black angel..😍😍
taemin is so beautiful
Love this performance!
Beautiful .
these boys are my music
i freakin love love love this song!!! best song in their album imo! xD
It's very very very very very very very very very very very very very very great!!!!!!!!I very love it!!!!!!!!! keep up!!!!
PERFECT! Yeah it's SHINing SHINee!!
love SHINee more n more... ♡♡♡
AAAAAARRRGGGHHHH their voices kill me!!!!! I just hope that after all this excitement with their new album and the YTMAs that they can get some well deserved rest. They need it!!! Shinee fighting!!!!!
Love this song.
Awesome!
taemin i fall in love with you every time i watch you
love this song sooooooo freaking much!
Best performance of this song
From 3:15 onew jjong key minho taem 😘😘😘😘😘
they are amazing
i think the first half is lip-sync and then the other half is live. nevertheless, the boys didn't fail to show their charms to the audience, especially ONEW..such a cute innocent look...i think i'm gonna fall off my seat while watching his stare...loved it so much!
Me too!!, onew is my bias!!! And I think SHINee makes me hard to correct if they lip sync or live....they.so perfect😂😚
full of emotions..")
Es una de mis canciones favoritas amo está canción. Claro quisiera un versión en Jonghyun solo q cante está cancion
Love it...
Me encanto la presentacion ,Shinee me encanta :)
This is my first time hearing this and OMG!!!!! Wow!
Still in love with this. 2018 ❤️
Shinee ♥♥♥♥♥
Argh I was so upset no close ups on key damn biased camera people argh
amo a shinee!!♥ y amo a taemin!!♥
Melhor música deles
lee jinki!!!!!!
tell me this is LIVE!! taemin bias here but jeez!! key is a hell of a HOT man..!!
Que hermosa cancion :3 샤이니 I Love!!!
想你們了
i think taemin and jonghyun look good in those hats XD
That was hot, indeed!
♥
Hermosos *3*
Camera man get your shit together damn you made me miss most of jonghyuns parts
what?? minho screen time was of him ending his parts -.-
Aizan NY OK.
Joaaahhhh!!!
The close-up shot of Taemin looks like a paiting
Awww man what.. only one closeup of Key..?
can anyone tell me.. the cameraman is Key's hater or what? only one close up for Key and it is only 3 second...
Jonghyun...I miss you.........
And this is the music I love the best :,)
Taemin is bae.
OMFG FEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEELSSSSSSSS!!!!!
태민♥
I wonder if this was before or after Onew hurt himself! If he is hurt, can he not dance, thus shouldn't he atleast be sitting? Anyway, This is always so amazing!
he was already hurt :__: they did so well !
This isn't live! This is lip sync... Look at Onew at 3:47
but it's true, their lives are much better and awesome. I don' understand why they didn't sing live here
Taemin *¬*
Isn't that the same sweater Key wore in the Everybody MV? :3
아진짜 립싱큰데도 이리몰입도가 쩌는지..?사랑해샤이니ㅠㅠ
I shall believe that yt loves to make shinee dangerous to warn sasaeng fans
:-))
To me its understandable why SHINee lip synced the dancing part to their performance. If they didn't, you'd probably hear gasps of air in between each word xD I'm not bothered by that at all because I already know that what they bring to the stage is their raw talent. They're very skilled at dancing and singing, and I would go on, but it would end up in fangirlish squeals and whatnot. Symptoms is one of the most powerful songs I've ever heard them sing. Lip syncing does not make them fake. I mean come on, you've already heard what they can do just from the recording alone! As you can see, I'm very fond of them lol I'll just cut this comment off here before this turns into an essay. Go SHINee!♡☆
Ariachan8D Arent there even adlibs?How can you say this is lyp synched.This is an actual question.Not for bashing.
+Özge Dağoğlu to answer you question, I say that this is lip synched because the audio thats playing sounds EXACTLY like the song on the actual recording of the song. Plus you can hear by ear (after listening to the full version over a thousand times like I did xD) when they are singing with the music. There would've been a slight difference as to how they sang the song compared to the original. Yes there are adlibs, but there are adlibs in the original as well and you can tell that the adlibs are the same. I am not saying this to shame them. Several bands do this all the time! Like I said in my previous comment, they are not fake. I'm sure you and I can both agree that they are VERY talented and their overall performance was amazing!! But I do believe that they lip synced at least the majority of their performance and Im not the only one who sees that. No, them lip synching was not disappointing nor will they EVER disappoint me. I will always be proud to be a SHINee fan and I hope to see them live myself to see their talents up close and personal ♡_♡ So yea...hope that answered your question! lol
:O i guess i got it but i thought they were singing live with the audio on the background thank you very much for answering :) i will look at the video again to fully understand
+Özge Dağoğlu No problem ^-^ and dont worry, we all have our opinions! It doesn't change the fact that whether its a recording or live singing, everyone in SHINee are still amazing. No need for autotune because thats their real voice! At least we can agree that SHINee is terrific! ♡
Taemin that hat tho
I really love this song. :) Jonghyun wrote this, right?
Now Taemin is not BABY Taemin
But SEXY Taemin
i'm so disappointed that kibummie only got one closeup even though he had many parts... even minho who only had two lines got more closeups than key... what's the cameraman doing?!
cameraman is obviously Minho biased xD Shawol cameramen~
what is shinee doing to me
Why does Key get so few close up ?
No close up of Key, in box :/