Why Doklam was a blunder | Part 2

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лют 2025
  • FORCE editor Pravin Sawhney explains how India completely misread the Chinese accretion of forces in Tibetan Autonomous Region. For more detailed analysis and reports visit www.forceindia.net

КОМЕНТАРІ • 303

  • @okramronan
    @okramronan 4 роки тому +12

    Wow. This was so refreshing. Sadly such critical thinking is death in indian media.

  • @saurabhsinha3069
    @saurabhsinha3069 5 років тому +29

    Brilliant analysis

  • @buntyanand8962
    @buntyanand8962 5 років тому +6

    Wow! Appreciate your analysis. Knew the Chinese had a bigger picture for actions in Doklam, but couldn't put my finger on it. You have cleared it so beautifully. How myopic we Indians are. You have to admire the Chinese.

  • @AbdulRehman-il7wv
    @AbdulRehman-il7wv 5 років тому +13

    Thanks for such insightful content

  • @Vik470
    @Vik470 5 років тому +43

    Sir your videos are better than any Hollywood thriller :-)
    Best of all its based on thoroughly investigated facts.
    Absolutely Brilliant. Thank you

    • @manout-kidin8735
      @manout-kidin8735 5 років тому +1

      That's why he's a defence analyst and we are just a so-so self tagged patriotic KEYBOARD warriors .

  • @pervezdurrani3421
    @pervezdurrani3421 4 роки тому +4

    Love to hear from you, peace is only solution for this region. First we have to finish poverty and corruption in our region.

  • @Shadow-vv1rg
    @Shadow-vv1rg 5 років тому +3

    you have good analytical skills, Sir. And we appreciate that someone is there to speak it out in better way for understanding of public in general. Many won't agree 100% (as a matter of fact) but obviously much appreciated the openness built up in your arguments.

  • @rahulchaudhry5393
    @rahulchaudhry5393 5 років тому +8

    Brilliant... waiting for third one.

  • @phizlee
    @phizlee 5 років тому +4

    Wish there were more ppl on your side like you who understand the gravity and truth about matters and face responsibility in true terms rather than giving away to hatred and go to any mean to get their own. Peace between India Pakistan/China will change dynamics of not only this region but the world as well. That is not acceptable to certain countries.

    • @ramdubey7155
      @ramdubey7155 5 років тому

      But first pakistan has to stop insurgencey in kashmir beacuse kashmir is integral part of india

    • @rf9164
      @rf9164 5 років тому

      Everyone has a legitimate claim.

  • @lachen7
    @lachen7 4 роки тому +6

    Seeing this vid only after a few months. But I agree that it was a mistake by India to have walked in into Doklam.

  • @muhammadazeem1262
    @muhammadazeem1262 5 років тому +17

    By entering in conflict zone between China and butan India give China right to intervene in Kashmir in the state of conflict between India and Pakistan

    • @mukeshpatial6387
      @mukeshpatial6387 5 років тому +4

      Yes of course Pakistan is equal to Bhutan 😂 😂 😂 😂

    • @muhammadazeem1262
      @muhammadazeem1262 5 років тому +1

      @@mukeshpatial6387 day dreaming lundian

    • @severus7519
      @severus7519 5 років тому +3

      @@boshengjones1778 and pakistanis are very logical. Such that surrender in 90000 no., Publicly and even give a guard of Honor to enemy. So logical.
      You do kargil first...and then rush to US on their holiday just to beg to stop India killing ur army like insects. So logical.
      You idiots first attack us in Akhnoor Sector in 65...u r the aggresor...and then u celebrate defence day that u saved Lahore in 65 war. 😂😂😂😂😂😂 Hight of Logic.

    • @جاسممحمد-ه5ر7ط
      @جاسممحمد-ه5ر7ط 5 років тому

      @@mukeshpatial6387 tell that to abhi nandan😅😅😅😅

    • @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438
      @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 5 років тому

      @@severus7519 EXCELLENT OBSERVATION Brother

  • @vivekpmc1992
    @vivekpmc1992 5 років тому +1

    Clear eye opener, even 1962 was strategy to engage and asses India and not just war

  • @rkt2583
    @rkt2583 5 років тому +24

    Modi is all about show-up. that's how he keeps Andh bhakt happy.

    • @gtanj
      @gtanj 5 років тому +2

      Yes, he should keep his mouth shut and keep you happy. Cheers!?

    • @someshsingh417
      @someshsingh417 4 роки тому +1

      Abe chutya k chhode

  • @ibneahmed8549
    @ibneahmed8549 5 років тому +16

    As usual Indian were aggressor on pre emotive assumption.. Hindu mentality. Indians needs to remain in their limits.

    • @severus7519
      @severus7519 5 років тому +1

      So do you...
      You know you don't want another Kargil adventure. 😂😂

    • @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438
      @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 5 років тому +1

      Want another Bangladesh ??

    • @nomoresunnydays7023
      @nomoresunnydays7023 4 роки тому

      Indian division is very near still 😆😆😆😆

    • @severus7519
      @severus7519 4 роки тому +1

      You Idiot... didn't u ever go history classes in ur school? Pakistan has attack India 4 times.... 48,65,71,99. India never attacked Pakistan... Not even in 71. You did. And you lost every time.
      We live in our limits...but when some jehadi idiot crosses his limits we know how to send him to 72 hoors. 😂😂😂 Dead bodies of kargil war Pak Army men are still waiting in Kashmir peaks for Pakistan to accept them.
      Period!
      Now...get lost

  • @aamiriqbal7790
    @aamiriqbal7790 5 років тому +8

    Always awesome shirts by
    Res. PS 👍👍👍

  • @zerogravity4749
    @zerogravity4749 5 років тому +2

    Same 70's mindset cost india at siachen badly they stucked in pakistan's smart move as they thought pakistan going to occupy the area till karakoram pass but this wasn't plan pakistan's strategy to pull Indian army in siachen and let them waste their resources and precious human life and look what happen they succeed in it and still going this use less conflict this man is right pakistan is a smart player

  • @parthasdasgupta
    @parthasdasgupta 4 роки тому +1

    Brilliant explanation. The best way India could settle the issue is look we can join OBOR but we must settle the border first. Secondly we are again missing a broader picture. China need agri products like Soyabean, Barley or wheat and even beaf in extremely large quantity. And to send those products in Chinise market we do need a railline through Himalaya.
    What is your opinion Sir.

  • @arin1512
    @arin1512 5 років тому +9

    You surely are quite knowledgeable about defense matters. You are talking with a hindsight vision on this matter, which undoubtedly should be 20/20. There is also a very good doze of know-it-all syndrome in your talks. If China wanted to bring more troops to TAR, they would do it. They didn’t need to create such a huge facade. Yes, I do agree that as a nation we have a myopic vision and we still aren’t planning our goals broken into short, medium, long term, urgent, important categories. Much to do is with our demography and way of governance. We can never act like China however we should do our own SWOT analysis and make & work on our long team plan.

    • @benishan3
      @benishan3 5 років тому +1

      China and India are bounded by border agreement to defuse tension. As such, either side can't just build up forces. But now Chine had built a huge military complex in Doklam after the standoff. The quantum has indeed changed, he's right.

    • @benishan3
      @benishan3 5 років тому +1

      www.ndtv.com/india-news/full-fledged-chinese-military-complex-in-doklam-show-satellite-pics-1801323

    • @ronlal652
      @ronlal652 5 років тому

      yes,our IBG light division will keep them,and PAK in line.

    • @doosra95
      @doosra95 5 років тому +1

      You are still in a class room with your SWOT analysis Theory’s 😂😂 he is an ex military man, show him some respect.

  • @shababkhan6227
    @shababkhan6227 5 років тому +22

    Sr what would be your opinion about kashmir issue, will wait for you vedio

    • @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438
      @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 5 років тому +3

      It doesn't matter what is his opinion or the world thinks.KASHMIR SHALL REMAIN WITH INDIA TILL THE END OF THIS WORLD

    • @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438
      @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 5 років тому +1

      Have you managed to gain one inch of KASHMIR in 72 years.you lost East Pakistan in the process

    • @sabdamumar1312
      @sabdamumar1312 5 років тому +1

      @@bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 I just can't understand why and how can you talk like this.muslims rules India for more than hundred years Indians could never defend their country in fact invaders invaded india through all their history ruled india but Indians could never defend their country.they don't even have real heroes their heroes are fictional characters from mythology.they simply don't have guts history reflects it.

    • @udayhotshot
      @udayhotshot 5 років тому +1

      @@sabdamumar1312 but my friend our heroes are ruling now! We are getting powerful! And don't forget that " we are getting " but we aren't at prime. We are not war mongers but we will show the world soon that if anyone messes with us we will annihilate them. And we don't care nuclear weapons because we know how to skip them before it reach us. Soon Pakistan and its allies will see Indias soft power but if they want to see hard power that mean its there annihilation.

    • @جاسممحمد-ه5ر7ط
      @جاسممحمد-ه5ر7ط 5 років тому

      @@bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 yes and the world is flat😁

  • @smartkitch
    @smartkitch 4 роки тому +4

    Sir, Read your extensive and scholastic report on the Dokla issue. We fail to understand the agenda of China. The whole Dokla episode was a shame.

  • @saysumesh
    @saysumesh 4 роки тому

    Nice to know all this, insider miltia info. Of china

  • @wasimch5348
    @wasimch5348 5 років тому

    very good analsys.thats why subscribed

  • @amoldharap8116
    @amoldharap8116 5 років тому +12

    Mr. Sawhney with your experience of several decades as a defence analyst and your experience of Chinese nature were you able to see through the Chinese plan at the time of the Doklam crisis and warn the Indian government at that time? Or is it easier to take advantage of hindsight and give expert comments much after the harm is done?

    • @ashtonbailey3970
      @ashtonbailey3970 5 років тому

      Amol Dharap
      Very possible

    • @nematsidhu9979
      @nematsidhu9979 5 років тому

      Do you think mudi and company would listened him impossible.

    • @baberzaman6398
      @baberzaman6398 5 років тому +3

      Do you really think people in power would have listen to him.he is just an analyst.you r kind of holding him accountable now!🤦‍♂️

    • @benishan3
      @benishan3 5 років тому

      Analysis can only be done after incident had happened, not before. Defence Analyst is not a fortune teller.

    • @amoldharap8116
      @amoldharap8116 5 років тому

      @@benishan3 Thank you for stating the obvious. My question still stands.

  • @vaibhavkaushik1990
    @vaibhavkaushik1990 4 роки тому +1

    Good analysis.....now it make sense why they brought 200k soldiers in Tibet.....its for current aggression in Galwa, pangong TSO and Dapsang

  • @manout-kidin8735
    @manout-kidin8735 5 років тому +2

    Noodle eaters knew their chess game inside out . Great analysis by this analyst .

  • @NeranTips
    @NeranTips 5 років тому +2

    this man is like hassan nisar for Indian people .

  • @wattooz
    @wattooz 5 років тому +4

    In depth analysis

  • @zaffarkhanzada5577
    @zaffarkhanzada5577 5 років тому +18

    Your analysis are based on facts
    Kidly discuss burning issue kashmir
    Can pakistan and india solve this
    Issue without atomic war
    War stepping on door step

    • @GovExamsJobsofIndia
      @GovExamsJobsofIndia 5 років тому +2

      Pakistan cant start a war

    • @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438
      @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 5 років тому +3

      Pls see where you are compared to even Bangladesh.Forget about JIHAD and kashmir. Be practical and improve the plight of your country. INDIA IS FAR FAR AHEAD OF PAKISTAN IN MILITARY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AS WELL AS HAVING A STABLE GOVT.
      LAUNCH JIHAD AGAINST CORRUPTION AND POVERTY.THIS IS A BROTHERLY ADVICE TO YOU.BE REASONABLE

    • @Be_Rational89
      @Be_Rational89 5 років тому +2

      Once POK is taken back. Kashmor problem will be solved.

    • @afzalmakh9561
      @afzalmakh9561 5 років тому +2

      @@bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 Indians seem to think that they are far superior to Pakistan , well keep on dreaming!!!!!!!!!!but the reality is different.

    • @Arunxolo
      @Arunxolo 5 років тому +2

      @@afzalmakh9561 what is 1971 . Was funtastic 😪

  • @usamaqayyum963
    @usamaqayyum963 5 років тому +25

    Articulate !! Best Defense Analyst .

    • @neutralobserver7161
      @neutralobserver7161 4 роки тому +2

      Really ? Is he better than Zaid Hamid and Tariq Peerzada ?

  • @rahulmelge
    @rahulmelge 10 місяців тому

    Sir
    With due respect
    Time stamp
    2:18
    To the east is Bhutan
    To west is Sikkim (INDIA)
    Need to correct this

  • @nassermj7671
    @nassermj7671 5 років тому +6

    But your wisdom will be ignored - in the interest of unfactual public consumption.

  • @hamidraza2948
    @hamidraza2948 5 років тому +3

    You are a great person, respect you,, May Allah Bless You,,, indians are deeply deaf, they are not Listening you,

  • @DoggLeash
    @DoggLeash 5 років тому

    Your stories are very educational and insightful, Very honest in your narration,👍🏾👍🏾, keep up the good work however hard your critics maybe.

  • @sknair5731
    @sknair5731 5 років тому

    You said it very correctly about the strategy.

  • @ashtonbailey3970
    @ashtonbailey3970 5 років тому +2

    Sir, can you comment on the likely outcome if there is a conventional war between India & Pakistan limited to Indian Administered Kashmir

    • @ashkhan3080
      @ashkhan3080 5 років тому

      The likely outcome should be similar to what happened in Bangladesh in 1971, with the winners and losers having been switched this time around...

    • @ic5442
      @ic5442 5 років тому +1

      @@ashkhan3080 what's the price of naans & petrol my dear? How much has the Fuckistani Rupee devalued against the US dollar? Are you like most of your countrymen a product of cousin marriage? Why's it that since Mohammed Ghaznavi, Punjabi Musalamaan like being cuckolded? By Arabs, Turks, Mughals, Marathas, Sikhs, Indians, Americans? When will it end Nadeem baaji?

    • @ashtonbailey3970
      @ashtonbailey3970 5 років тому +2

      @@ashkhan3080
      Contrary to popular beliefs..Pakistan won in 1971 on the West liberating more of Kashmir from India and this line is known as the LOC. Before, it was 1965 Ceasefire line.
      Further, it was not India but USSR fighting and some of the IAF planes shot down had USSR pilot in them who were captured. Pakistan avenaged this in 1989 by wiping USSR off the MAP and now we have Russia which is mu h smaller in size then USSR so victory was ours. And what did India gain? Nothing because its advantage of stopping PAF attacks was short-lived when in late 1979 PAF acquired the ability to strike anywhere on Indian soil! And what did India lose? More territory in Kashmir and 130 IAF planes destroyed. Although the USSR navy (most people believe it was Indian Navy) destroyed the fuel storage in Karachi port, Pakistan destroyed India's Okha harbor and the fuel storage facility...No wonder Pervin Sawhney admits that India lost every war on Pakistan's western front.

    • @ashtonbailey3970
      @ashtonbailey3970 5 років тому

      @@ic5442
      YOU STUPID RAW AGENT....Devaluation benefits a country by making exports cheap and imports expensive, thus saving foreign revenue on imports as less are bought and at the same time making more on import duty due to devaluation..but than an Idiot like you who only has tunnel visions and no banking, qualifications will not know this!
      And just so you know, the PRK was deliberately kept at a high value because the corrupt previous leaders like the Sharifs and Zardari could get more foreign currency for less PKR. Just go and do what you know best....play with your marbles

    • @mukeshpatial6387
      @mukeshpatial6387 5 років тому

      @@ashtonbailey3970 Bhai Tu Apney sapno mein hi reh 😂 😂 😂 bus ab Baluchistan azad hoga to bolna Israeli aye thy 😂 😂 😂

  • @manjitbajwa7726
    @manjitbajwa7726 5 років тому +6

    when it comes to China-India he says look at Big picture . when it comes to India-Pakistan he says look at tactical view.

    • @ashtonbailey3970
      @ashtonbailey3970 5 років тому +3

      manjit Singh
      Yes he does, because he understands. Pakistan & China are very different.

    • @faisalkhan-jo1sw
      @faisalkhan-jo1sw 5 років тому

      i think it is important for indians to understand pakistan.... china and pakistan are not the same.... china is a much larger military and economic power and therefore has more to lose and it would preffer to fight in conventional style to utilize its superiority. pakistan on the other hand is a smaller military and economic force than india and india has a lot more to lose in a war with pak. listen to PM Imran khans speech at UNGA.... he underlined Pakistan's defense doctrine there. you can attack us and maybe even conquer us but we will make sure the cost is so huge for you that you will not even think about attacking. it acts as a deter ant. it is a very high risk and some would say irresponsible doctrine in the international context but it works! and that's whats brilliant about it.

    • @faisalkhan-jo1sw
      @faisalkhan-jo1sw 5 років тому

      @Virat rc childish reply..... They work.... They work perfectly well.... Pakistan is not threatening with balistic missiles anymore.... Its tactical nukes on cruise missile that are a threat.... And emotional childish talk is not going to get you anywhere.... I was giving you an unbiased view of pakistans defence doctrine.... And you give me patriotic bullshit and no arguments.... Please dont reply bye

    • @faisalkhan-jo1sw
      @faisalkhan-jo1sw 5 років тому

      @Virat rc again i seem to be talking to a little kid here who just wants to nurse his patriotic ego. Bye

    • @faisalkhan-jo1sw
      @faisalkhan-jo1sw 5 років тому

      And as for terror attacks..... Was pulwama a terror attack???
      It was an attack.... May have been carried out by terrorists but i dont think the attack itself was terroristic in nature.

  • @narendrakhilnani6578
    @narendrakhilnani6578 5 років тому

    Actions have consequences, but not taking an action also has consequences. In this case available information at that indicated that military action was appropriate. Hindsight is always 20/20.

  • @AzamKhan-ht7wx
    @AzamKhan-ht7wx 5 років тому +1

    Please make a video on the Kashmir crisis.

  • @Time2Act
    @Time2Act 4 роки тому +2

    Better to use some maps to elaborate on the details.

  • @prashantdhawan6040
    @prashantdhawan6040 5 років тому +16

    Next video - Why India actually lost 1971 War and should ask Bangladesh to join Pakistan again

    • @cricketfan317
      @cricketfan317 5 років тому +1

      Great suggestion !
      Let us hear him on this topic

    • @TheJack1947
      @TheJack1947 5 років тому +1

      he is like why India still it should have long gone to either pakistan or china .. he so disappointed ..

    • @Babayagaom
      @Babayagaom 5 років тому +2

      He is dickhead always talking shit and can turn every positive thing into negativity

    • @OnkarShrma
      @OnkarShrma 5 років тому

      😂😂😂👍

    • @Arunxolo
      @Arunxolo 5 років тому

      😂😂😂lolll

  • @harisasif2
    @harisasif2 5 років тому +2

    Please do analysis of 1965 war which pakistan won according to all international too,but india claims it won which is not true but a light on it

    • @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438
      @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 5 років тому

      I have photos of Indian tanks in Lahore in 1965 war. Is Lahore in India.Dont live in a FOOLS PARADISE. INDIA IS TOO BIG AND TOO STRONG FOR PAKISTAN.PAKISTAN WILL GAIN NOTHING FROM THIS ANTI INDIA SENTIMENT

    • @asifupdates6313
      @asifupdates6313 4 роки тому

      Bhaskarjyoti Kakoty khem karan and chamb jorian and jaisalmir are not in Pakistan too, we have more real photos plus indian tanks graveyard can still be seen in sialkot chawinda sector💪🏽💪🏽💪🏽

  • @xqliu9356
    @xqliu9356 5 років тому +3

    I knew China was preparing for a war with India back then. Does anyone know how India prepared for it?

    • @rf9164
      @rf9164 5 років тому

      XQ is troublemaker

    • @blackmamba1025
      @blackmamba1025 5 років тому +2

      We have RSS and Bajrang Dal goons who Will fight with Chinese with their small lulli..... hahahaha

    • @nomoresunnydays7023
      @nomoresunnydays7023 4 роки тому

      @@blackmamba1025
      Hahaha😆😆😆😆😆great joke boy

    • @nomoresunnydays7023
      @nomoresunnydays7023 4 роки тому

      Yes India prepare to loose the war in less than thevweek😆😆😆😆

  • @rmazim500
    @rmazim500 4 роки тому +1

    🇮🇳Very Good Analysis.Unfortunately and Ultimately the Veteran and Venerable Lt .General Praveen Bakshi, earlier G.O.C.in C Northern Command and thereafter G.O.C.in C Eastern Command, front runner for the post of Army Chief and ignoring His and the Trend of Seniority being the lone criteria based on some anonymous letters,was overlooked and superceded for the post of Chief of Army Staff in favour of Gen.Bipin Rawat.🇮🇳

  • @pakshaheen7890
    @pakshaheen7890 5 років тому +4

    Sir how both countries can resolve Kashmir issue. It is difficult but not impossible. What is your opinion?

    • @ashtonbailey3970
      @ashtonbailey3970 5 років тому +4

      PAK SHAHEEN
      It’s very simple
      Act on the 11 UN resolutions within 9 months!

    • @ic5442
      @ic5442 5 років тому

      @@ashtonbailey3970 so when's Paxstan withdrawing it's troops and Punjabi Mussalman from PoK?

    • @jgacfhhahjjshggqhhqikwhh3919
      @jgacfhhahjjshggqhhqikwhh3919 5 років тому

      Its not going to happen for a very basic reason both sides presently have a opposing aims for the region.

    • @mirzashakeel7074
      @mirzashakeel7074 5 років тому

      He would tell how to dismantle Pakistan because that is only solution for them.

    • @jgacfhhahjjshggqhhqikwhh3919
      @jgacfhhahjjshggqhhqikwhh3919 5 років тому

      @@mirzashakeel7074 actualy under manmohan singh rule. The unoffical policy was to co opt the ruling elite of pakisthan through trade and through them force the pakisthan state to stop cross border terrorism.

  • @AftabAlam-lw5fv
    @AftabAlam-lw5fv 5 років тому +1

    Dear Sir,, a waiting your video about I mean Khan speech & Kashmir issue in present time... Tkx & rgds. from Pakistan

    • @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438
      @bhaskarjyotikakoty8438 5 років тому

      My suggestion is FORGET KASHMIR FOR GOOD.YOUR NATION LOST EAST PAKISTAN IN THE PROCESS OF GETTING KASHMIR.

  • @pravinutankar2107
    @pravinutankar2107 5 років тому +1

    IA is no match to PLA but don't forget CIA will train them and that's what is Indo Pacific tie.

  • @riazhassan6570
    @riazhassan6570 3 роки тому

    It is easy to predict this man’s analysis on various points. For him, whatever the experts do is wrong

  • @magisterludi1733
    @magisterludi1733 5 років тому +8

    I have read many editions of this magazine. In one of its edition it's editor gazala Wahab wrote that kashmiri pandits were lucky that they were persecuted . So they moved out of the valley and settled well all over India. Muslims were unlucky that they stayed behind . Strange logic! 😲😲😲
    Probably that's Islamic logic. 🙄🙄🙄.
    I have come to the conclusion that if u r born a muslim no amount of education, development or anything can ever correct the mental distortion created by Islam.

    • @tayztayz2318
      @tayztayz2318 5 років тому

      And thats why Muslims did 4some with your endu era and endu subcontinent😂😂😂😂

    • @tayztayz2318
      @tayztayz2318 5 років тому

      Islam is fastest religion in world😂😂😂

    • @magisterludi1733
      @magisterludi1733 5 років тому +1

      @@tayztayz2318 even Bacteria spreads very fast , doesn't mean it's good.

    • @Shadow-vv1rg
      @Shadow-vv1rg 5 років тому

      Magister - With due respect, Islam has nothing do with what you are trying to conclude here. Read more about Islam instead of reading so called muslims around you. Good and bad people are every where in the world no matter what is their religion, caste, color, region, etc. Also everyone's opinion must absolutely be regarded but pointing out finger straight away on 1.3 billion people would further worsen the world situation and would never bring harmony and peace. Don't forget we all are children of one Adam. I see everyday people from both India & Pak are just posting comments for point scoring without making any sense in what they say. Thanks.

    • @baberzaman6398
      @baberzaman6398 5 років тому

      The same goes for u as well.no amount of all those aforementioned traits are able to hide your hate and envy against islam.i mean wat the hell is wrong with you people.you saw a muslim name and started blaming islam.wat about her personal and individual mind, ideas and analysis

  • @SHARPGFX-dc9gj
    @SHARPGFX-dc9gj 5 років тому +1

    I like your videos.

  • @theclub9767
    @theclub9767 4 роки тому +1

    Why Doklam is not of India concern??

  • @dheeraj742002
    @dheeraj742002 5 років тому +1

    Most idiotic assessment .. all he is saying is india made a mistake trying to stop chineses from aggression .. we lost 40 000 sq miles to chinese and we didn't do anything so this was a better strategy ..

  • @ferozkhansahab917
    @ferozkhansahab917 5 років тому +2

    Sir like the US India should also select its enemies

  • @shaheer316
    @shaheer316 5 років тому +2

    Sir, i like your shirt style in all videos, which brand it is. Thanks

    • @a2zadi
      @a2zadi 5 років тому

      Kurla West Sunday Bazaar 😁

    • @shaheer316
      @shaheer316 5 років тому

      @@a2zadi its in trend man....no jokes
      www.balls.ie/mma/rafael-dos-anjos-mcgregor-shirt-322630

    • @doosra95
      @doosra95 5 років тому

      From 1960‘s psychedelic art selection 😂😂😂

  • @javidmajeedwani
    @javidmajeedwani 4 роки тому +1

    Deep analysis. I wonder !!!!!?

  • @tyme5837
    @tyme5837 5 років тому

    You have a good point, but still I am glad no body had an itchy trigger finger.

  • @dhuanabsa774
    @dhuanabsa774 5 років тому

    Problem is, whether looking at the small or big picture, I still couldn't find 'Why Doklam is a blunder Part 1.'😊
    - China has a function - to be a big brother to Pakistan. Period.
    - China rising militarism in the South East Asia Sea, is against the will of the ASEAN countries and the world communities.
    - India cannot match China militarily at least for a couple more decades looking at how things are progressing. India's defence industry is in disarray, China is a major arms exporter whilst India is still a major weapons importer.
    - India's mindset is more towards diplomacy, no doubt being formerly being colonized by the British. You can maintain this posture but your military must have a very clear advantage in capabilities which India does not have over China at the present time. Pakistan military strength alone which only a 3rd of India's, still it is a force 'to reckon with' so to speak.
    - 23:50 , for the first time I saw you smile for a couple of seconds which is wonderful!😊
    Thanks for the great work.

  • @farrukhhameed4328
    @farrukhhameed4328 5 років тому

    Do you think that if the summit doesn't go well then china might up the anti.

  • @ibrahimmohammed1864
    @ibrahimmohammed1864 5 років тому +1

    Please make video about Kashmir from Pakistan point of view and India point of view. And who has strategic advantage aswell as world support on this issue

    • @ic5442
      @ic5442 5 років тому

      What do you think he's been doing so far?

    • @ibrahimmohammed1864
      @ibrahimmohammed1864 5 років тому

      @@ic5442 where is the video on Kashmir

    • @ic5442
      @ic5442 5 років тому

      @@ibrahimmohammed1864 🙄

    • @ibrahimmohammed1864
      @ibrahimmohammed1864 5 років тому

      Doklam is not kashmir.
      Doklam is Doklam

  • @irfanghazanfar28
    @irfanghazanfar28 5 років тому +2

    Excellent 👍

  • @ارسلانپٹھان-ف2خ
    @ارسلانپٹھان-ف2خ 5 років тому

    Good

  • @jawaidrashed5870
    @jawaidrashed5870 4 роки тому

    kindly throw some light on why india undertook the responsibility to guard nepal and bhutan from any foreign invasion and what good it will do to india?

  • @KPAU07
    @KPAU07 5 років тому +1

    ..full scale war has never ever happen even in historical times. Small scale border clash maybe.

  • @satyajithga936
    @satyajithga936 4 роки тому

    Reality and perception....A wide gap...

  • @MajidAli-if7cm
    @MajidAli-if7cm 5 років тому +3

    Talk about Imran khan speach in un

  • @elroinoronha433
    @elroinoronha433 5 років тому

    Mind blown sir

  • @babamunna1080
    @babamunna1080 5 років тому

    Indian govt has vengience to finish Pakistan some how that they did ,they made Bangladesh,they broke international treaty UNO,Bundonge treaty in Indonesia, India govt,Indian peoples,Kashmir issues, is the main reason the military strong hold, failure of democracy,martial law,language problems,economic disasters in Islamic republic of Pakistan .

    • @babamunna1080
      @babamunna1080 5 років тому

      Ruaaian invasion in Afghanistan's internel matters, try to take resources of Afghanistan, millions of refugees in Pakistan's, Drugs came to Pakistan,economical burden on Pakistan due to the refugees, terrorisim in Pakistan,Pakistan lost 100,000citizens who were made shared in this circumstances,123 billions dollars which were gone due to all these problems, and enemy our next India, Bangladesh govts,biasedpeoples of Bangladesh and India, Afghanistan govt, our enemies have lots of vengeances against Govt and peoples of Pakistan,they are laughing on Pakistan as failure state ,they do not see the reasons how much Pakistan peoples suffered,that is why I ask Allah to create anAfghanistan near your border ofindia and Bangladesh,and let Russia invade your neighbour, let refugee's come to your country,let you two vengeance country suffer,let you both spent 123 billions of dollars,and sacrifice of 100,000 citizen,then the world and me ask you how is your economy's, are you a failure states.

    • @babamunna1080
      @babamunna1080 5 років тому

      If you sow bad things to others,it will come back to you,Allah is watching,every good or bad action has a reactions,Russia broke,Roman and Persian empires destroyed,big big nations destroyed by Almighty's power ful Allah ,or Lord,learn the lesson of history's, then who are you,so called super powers,your bad deeds results are coming too.

    • @babamunna1080
      @babamunna1080 5 років тому

      Pakistan army had been through lots of struggles,which India,Bangladesh, Afghan armies not gone through,that is the reason it made Pakistan armies lots of experience and strong force in the regions. So be very care ful to think that enemy is weak,never underestimate the power of one single man or a woman.

  • @naveedkhan-fk8sq
    @naveedkhan-fk8sq 5 років тому

    USA want to made India is a thanedaar of Asia which is not possible. You people totally underestimate china😂

  • @santosh_979
    @santosh_979 5 років тому

    Any agreement done earlier with china is on there mercy unless capabilities are increased no point in discussing any tactical manoeuvre.

  • @Googl963
    @Googl963 5 років тому

    Sir..your opinions are not up to the mark. U r uselessly exaggerating your feelings. China will never fight on borders, it's not in line with its business as China is engaged in belt and road at many places. U should think..if u have brain.

  • @someshsingh417
    @someshsingh417 4 роки тому

    China + India vs western countary

  • @pradeepkoushik5074
    @pradeepkoushik5074 5 років тому +5

    This man is self defeating burocrat with no solutions .Seems like he could spend 2 more lives explaining why nothing can be done by India justifying earlier do nothings by him.

  • @karansarda8026
    @karansarda8026 5 років тому +2

    Sir why do you think we are lacking in infrastructure in our border areas. How can we build a great army and what is the way forward for India. Since we have very hostile neighbours.

    • @ghazalawahab520
      @ghazalawahab520 5 років тому +1

      These issues will be addressed in the subsequent videos

  • @bipinsingh171
    @bipinsingh171 5 років тому +1

    Sir we understand, if Chinese could they would have swallowed India at Doclam, however treaties and understanding is, regarded differently by Chinese than by Indians, their perception about any treaty is to buy time and not to honour it beyond that. However this is all about perceptions. The krucks of the matter is, if you want please , use it to prepare for war and be ready for it. No body can expect in India that neglect of decades can be corrected in a year or two, Chinese bought time by treatise to build up their infrastructure and treatise had no value for them once they were completed, they would have brought in their troops in on one pretext or other. What India need to understand is that China is a permanent adversery and prepare accordingly, treaty or no treaty.

    • @afrozmalik9921
      @afrozmalik9921 5 років тому

      Treaties have no value for indians either...bcoz you need teal guts for that...a greedy coward will prefer to backstab you like raw n kalbhushan. And you talk about attacking us...we know you'll never in dreams.

  • @assifkhan3803
    @assifkhan3803 4 роки тому

    How can this be brilliant analysis as some comment suggest.brilliant when one backs up with some visual and maps .that little bit more make the difference between brilliant and good .this analysis is average so to disappoint and the English for ex army is pretty dismal especially when he says but.butt butt.please don't make a laughing stock of us and the tone of voice is submissive in nature it transmit a sign of weakness

  • @surendrashahi8343
    @surendrashahi8343 5 років тому +1

    It is bit naive to suggest that Chinese wouldn't be able to bring their newly formed CABs into TAR if India had not reacted in Doklam. As part of their defence restructuring, they had decided to bring in their troops in TAR and there was no way India could stop them. Forget TAR, we can't even stop them from bringing troops in PoK. That's the reality and we have to operate within it.

  • @cricketfan317
    @cricketfan317 5 років тому

    He is a tap which sarts and ends only when the tank gets empty.
    Great Sir !

  • @emailkunalsharma
    @emailkunalsharma 5 років тому

    Why Indian Army raises the Issues and get involved in Scuffles PERTINENT QUESTION IS WHT AND WHY ITBPF (SO KALLED FORCE) DOESN'T GET INTO SCUFFLES SOO ITBPF IS GRT HENCE LET THEM TAKE KARE OF ARMY, ITBPF IS IPS LED (PENCIL LEAD) I HOPE YOU GET WHT I MEANT, GRT...MHA

  • @Ajayjadhav39
    @Ajayjadhav39 4 роки тому +1

    So what should have been done ? Let the Chinese build the road that would have threatened the Siliguri corridor? If the Chinese really did want to increase deployment, they would have done it anyhow. If India had not objected at Doklam they would have, some other place would have been chosen.
    I wish the choices were as simple as the speaker would have us believe. With the benefit of hindsight, fault can be found with any decision taken in such a situation.

    •  4 роки тому

      They have already built the road today

  • @punjabiveer1256
    @punjabiveer1256 5 років тому

    So according to u Jo marzi china Kari jaye Indian wld not resist..kya baat hai Bhai..bhutan's defence is guaranteed by India u shld know

  • @SalimKhan-hm3gk
    @SalimKhan-hm3gk 4 роки тому

    Best nalysis

  • @tyme5837
    @tyme5837 5 років тому

    Lucky no war.

  • @shailamkantsahodra9515
    @shailamkantsahodra9515 5 років тому +1

    Your analytical skills are good but NSA and current army personnel has much broader idea of what exactly can happen in future..

  • @manzoor2000
    @manzoor2000 5 років тому

    what is your salary?

  • @rajendranuk268
    @rajendranuk268 5 років тому

    We should maintain a strong defense along the north eastern and western borders.Unlike China who made very good infrastructure at the borders for the last decades,we didn't do enough during that period to meet our basic needs. I believe that shortfall has now being addressed on a war footing. Both China and Pakistan are aligned together and China will always assist Pakistan at all levels.If we have credible defense at all levels nobody dare to attack.
    Unfortunately ,every acquisition of defense equipment ends up in endless controversies as the opposition and ruling party want to score over each other. We have to talk less and do more at all strategic and military levels.

  • @Hi-ph5uf
    @Hi-ph5uf 5 років тому

    Hi

  • @TheJack1947
    @TheJack1947 5 років тому +5

    In his opinion indian defence forces r guarding with sticks while every other countries are so advance n have brilliant strategies..

    • @ashtonbailey3970
      @ashtonbailey3970 5 років тому

      jackson jackson
      Well if you use equipment 45 years old then what do you expect

    • @TheJack1947
      @TheJack1947 5 років тому

      @@ashtonbailey3970 if we're. So weak n old y don't u come get ur Kashmir ? Ur trying for 74 yrs now .. 1 inch bi nahi le paye n u lost half country .. in 71 ..

    • @uroojnafees3436
      @uroojnafees3436 5 років тому +1

      @@TheJack1947 we have half of kashmir😂..please get your facts straight

    • @TheJack1947
      @TheJack1947 5 років тому

      @@uroojnafees3436 u have half Kashmir .. ok .. so it justifies u loosing half country ..

  • @mustanzar
    @mustanzar 5 років тому

    Here

  • @misterbean5308
    @misterbean5308 4 роки тому

    Doklam is important to indian defense at siliguri corridor and it belongs to bhutan but bullied by chinese. the indian had an agreement with bhutan for its defense and they came to defend it. actually the chinese are the real aggressor in bhutan.

  • @Babayagaom
    @Babayagaom 5 років тому +5

    This guy can turn every positive thing into negative thing...saw his many videos ..he was unhappy after asat also.. Wondering when was he happy last time

    • @ashtonbailey3970
      @ashtonbailey3970 5 років тому +2

      Omi Koch
      Truth is hard to stomach, specially if you are an India subject to fake news.

    • @Babayagaom
      @Babayagaom 5 років тому

      @@ashtonbailey3970 look who's talking ..guy who's country celebrate 1965 war without winning 1 inch Kashmir 😂😂

  • @m4st3rm1nd9
    @m4st3rm1nd9 5 років тому

    2:03 you got east and west mixed up there

  • @nikhiljha00
    @nikhiljha00 5 років тому

    Your theory is wrong, Chinese is very large army or world largest army. India need to developed it own defence industry and large scale production and ready Indian population for war. Indian army need to prepare for war with China and BSF should be prepared for Pakistan front.

  • @AshishVerma-dz9ug
    @AshishVerma-dz9ug 5 років тому

    Mr Sawhney you are right that china took advantage of opportunity to build infrastructure against the previous agreements. Why ignoring that India too is building huge build up at diklam. Anybody can see on Google Earth. Both sides getting equal opportunity of any training or deployment.

  • @dindaacademy5669
    @dindaacademy5669 5 років тому +1

    I think you should be our CDS instead of Bipin Rawat why you resigned otherwise Indian army could have made you one hahaha

  • @charanjitalwar1480
    @charanjitalwar1480 4 роки тому

    It is very disturbing for mister Sunny that India has managed doklam issue amicably but he fail to Chinese views of War if China wants to to improve its Troops and training there is no way of stopping them they have their sovereign powers and can do what they can Mr Sunny you are unable to explain anything

  • @VivekSinghVivek
    @VivekSinghVivek 5 років тому

    I love to hear cycnics and skeptics ..... But seems like a time waste over the time .... As India is beyond, narratives, Modis, Manmohan Singhs, ... It is going to race past the best economies in upcoming 50 years unless you nuke India. So these detailed level minute errors are irrelevant.

  • @salzburgsf49ersfan56
    @salzburgsf49ersfan56 4 роки тому

    1

  • @NusratRizvi-ox3fg
    @NusratRizvi-ox3fg 5 років тому

    You only speak for Punjabis not for rest of Pakistan who have nothing but disgust for Punjabis.

  • @amitneotia1981
    @amitneotia1981 5 років тому

    Whatever India did was correct. If PLA had faught this battle Indian army would have the invincibility myth of Chinese . China backed out of Docklam knowing this only.

    • @rostamsunny8802
      @rostamsunny8802 5 років тому +5

      Lol did u not hear properly. He said the Indians backed out. The Chinese stayed and carried on building their infrastructure. U must be a special kind of stupid.

  • @vikrammehta5738
    @vikrammehta5738 5 років тому

    Nonsense - he is trying to potray India as aggressor, seems to be on Commnist payroll - he says because of Doklam, Chinese have increased force levels in Tibet only because of Doklam, and they would not have done it if Doklam would not happened - so simplistic and 'congress type thinking' - as if they will not do so during conflict !!!

  • @newdawndecends2357
    @newdawndecends2357 4 роки тому

    Will you stop preaching hate speeches against India and pamper your Master.

    • @edialva4110
      @edialva4110 4 роки тому +1

      Are u scared of thr truth ?