@@thatsmadcrazy8953 well he did have a darker side that came out often, but that's only when the doctor gets carried away and his human friends are the ones who help him be kinder and remind him that there's bravery in being soft.
Can confirm as having watched nuwho as my introduction to Doctor Who....that regeneration put me through a loop. One minute I was crying and elated from the previous episode...next minute I am just like..." what just happened?"
Does make me wonder if there was a timelord that would cut off a hand or something directly after regeneration so they'd keep their faces longer through metacrises. Only haveto explain the new face like 6 times then.
It’s something that every Doctor goes through. Each one, in the beginning, tends to show bits of the previous Doctor’s persona before their persona starts to set in. My guess it’s a side effect of the regeneration; their bodies may look done, but their brains are still being rewired.
@RoxanneDrew I only watched the show because I knew David Tennant was in it (I'm a big Shakespearean fan), but I'm so glad I did. After that line, though, I loved him even more.
I didn't appreciate at the time how clever this episode is. Rose is the audience surrogate and having her so outwardly uncomfortable and unhappy with the change perfectly mirrors how much of the audience felt. People in general don't like change and if the show didn't acknowledge that such a change is difficult, the audience would feel alienated. Instead, Rose is the one who is 'alienated' from Doctor Who in our place, allowing us tag along. David Tennant does almost nothing in this episode, again giving us the space we need to grieve and accept the change. Then just as things are getting desperate, he makes his heroic return, puts on his outfit and we realise that "of course that's still the Doctor" at the same time as Rose.
I feel really bad for the doctor when his companions don’t recognise him for his new faces and it’s not exactly his fault it’s the “nature of a timelord”
@@meme-fj6rj his real face would be human looking, i think its a variation from race to gender to species but the doctor ended up with a human face. I think it was stated that time lords dont have natural births, and the doctor was either the last natural born time lord or was artificial as was the others. He could also regenerate into a different species, he just chooses to look human. Though theres a tie in with a different theory that the doctor is half human and was only ever confirmed for the 8th/9th Doctor. From then on it was forgotten.
I remmeber watching this video on how timelords were actually just a regular species who couldnt do any of that till later when new technology was being evolved
clara tambien actuo realista, tomando en cuenta que ya conocia a profundidad el fenomeno de la regeneracion y sabia que podia regenerarse sin cambiar de cara por que 11 se lo dijo
Clara reacted in a similar way. She had more of a heads up than Rose due to meeting other Doctor's before Smith's regeneration but she still felt unsafe around Capaldi at first. Of course, Capaldi absolutely didn't help due to abandoning her in Deep Breath and Kill the Moon.
@@E.C.O.escrivadelacalle entiendo, es que es una serie bastante vieja, también, directamente parece que ya no hubiera gente viendo este tipo de clips tan nostálgicos.
Imo she only wanted him to change back because he was unfamiliar. It only took her one ep to do a full 180 on her stance because of his extreme charm and likability.
Rose really makes this scene work. Very understated, a world of confused emotions whirling thru her mind, yet almost paralyzed with a single facial expression, speaking as little as possible, and a half turned posture, like she isnt sure about talking, running, or hiding. As the show has gone on it has gotten sillier, bigger, and less reliant on such performances and more on quips and cleverness.
I still find it so sweet that usually the Doctor can't remember much after a regeneration (takes time to get used to the new body) however 9 loved Rose so much that the thought of going to Barcelona & thus making Rose happy was still present even after regen
Man this takes me back. Chris was my first Doctor and I loved him. When David showed up I was of the same opinion as Rose. "Who is this guy? This isn't the Doctor!". Then a few episodes later I'm all, "This is my Doctor!"
Russell T Davies said, it was originally gonna be at the end of The Parting Of The Ways or The Beginning of The Christmas Invasion, but they went over the time slot so they chopped it off the episode and used it for Children in Need.
it's soul crushing to me that 10th starts of as a happy, cheerful doctor with a strong vibe of child-like innocence, while ends up as the saddest, most broken doctor😭😭😭
Love every bit of it. The Doctor is still very mindful and respectful, not acting like she HAD to understand. And Rose being doubtful and therefore somewhat smart. Emotional: yes. Panicking: no. Two great characters being portrayed even better.
@@sensen1080 Thank You and there are people out there who don't think that the Doctor was in love with her. it's like they were watching a completely different show. Rose is my Fav and so is Donna.
@@natalieybarra5207 Some people don't want to change their minds, I guess. But anyway, Word of God says he was in love with her, that they were in love with each other, and no one can dispute that.
Her best friend just changed into a completely different person right in front of her. Yeah, she should probably have made the connection sooner, but honestly, what would your reaction be?
David Tennant hopping around like a kid on sugar, not good for my heart! Anyway, this is so sad. You could really see the excitement of the Doctor fade and turn to disappointment. He immediately thought of returning Rose back home, offered to let her go. He must've been scared too, scared that Rose would accept the invitation without second thought because he's changed.
@@equestrianforever844 It was a minisode called "Born Again" that aired as part of the BBC's Nov. 2005 Children In Need appeal but wasn't in an episode. Bridged Season One and the Xmas special and built anticipation for the latter. Guessing it's included in DVD extras but not on streaming. Thanks be to UA-cam!
@@wonjubhoyyea she was definitely the og in the first doctor who but the “remake” I think rose is one of the best ones bc it felt like an instant connection for them
14th is the female incarnation after the old guy? I've not kept up to date on the show after the series that was focused on Clara as "The Impossible Girl."
@@HilmyA.S. You didn't. It was filmed for Children in Need. The Christmas Invasion (Tennant's first full appearance of the Doctor) starts with the TARDIS already crashing into Earth, the Doctor steps out and pretty much immediately faints. So this scene takes place between two episodes.
Rose I feel has the best reaction to a Regeneration. She speaks for every new Who fan that began in 2005 and didn't have anything from Classic Who to go back on. Or knew anyone who had grown up with the Classic era.
Tennant was literally the resurrection of 'The Doctor'. So appropriate that the delightful Piper was there with him at this beginning. I miss them both.
Then how could I remember this? Very first word I ever said to you. Trapped in that cellar. Surrounded by shop window dummies.... oh..such a long time ago. I took your hand...I said one word... just one word, I said... 'run'. 2.53
@@madina8775 Yup but he didn't know that yet and she didn't have a reason to remember that random stranger who wished her happy new year way before she even met the Doctor.
Its a realy good deep thinking episode. Why they bring it out like a delete szene? We learn who a real person would react to a modern regeneration. That Rose is not so easy thinking "Okay, he is New. Like the Face. Moving On.". This should happend more often. Good Work Piper! Good Work Tenneth!
I love how at first, the audience (or at least me) feels the same way as Rose, we're not quite sure if this guy can replace the fantastic 9 but overtime he becomes one of the most popular doctors ever (and my favourite).
Rose reaction is what I except the new companion reaction to be like, instead of "oh okay u got new face" its like something unexpected just happend in your face and u are just scared
@@fulcrum1257 she eventually accepted him tho, and she didn't leave him. She could have decided to not travel with him anymore because of how he looked, but she didn't. She wanted to stay and since he was all over the place and kept passing out after he regenerated she felt the need to be his 'carer', if you will. She knew he needed her support, but she didn't ask for him to change back. She learnt what she had to and came to realise that just because the doctor looks different it doesn't mean he isn't there anymore.
yes, although I do love Matt Smith as an actor, but considering the knowledge I already have about the writer who's written his era, I highly doubt his doctor will be anywhere near as great and powerful character as 9th and 10th
I still remember being so shocked when 9 became 10. I had never heard of Doctor who at the time. But it had me crying. I was like who the hell is this!? Then he grew on me in the end. Then he lost so much and gah!! He and nine will both have a special place in my heart forever.
Dan Jonesy Amy and Rory "dragged on"? You can't tell me they were worse than Clara. Granted, Amys story before Rory waited 2000 years was running a bit slow but i think Rory added a bunch of life into the storyline for a while. I do agree with you about the ending though.
Clara was AWFUL. She was bland and boring alongside Eleven but at least generally minded herself better. She was a total control freak with Twelve and became absolutely insufferable. I couldn’t stand her and her ending up with her own TARDIS at the end just infuriates me even more. I’ve never been so ready to be done with a DW companion as I was Clara (Donna being a close second).
oh god so do i why he didn't say i love yoou and live together as a couple :p but he was kinda happy cuz we have seen him smiling ,,, when rose and meta crisis doctor kissed ,,,, it was like he feel exactly what his "copy" feel ,,, ( enjoying his love story with rose and the feeling of living with her a normal life as a couple) ,,,, and i really hope it was the case and he did feel this feeling like he was with rose not the meta crisis like the meta crisis was just a sort of connexion way between them ,,, and the doctor could live his love story with his rose through him ,,,, anyway thats what i feel everytime i see him smiling at them when kissing ,,,, ^^ what's ur opinion ? am i right ? or a little bit too romantic xD
@@meriemcullen8510 I mean there was a special connection, far and wide. Warmed the heart. Not sure about romantic (maybe little) but meaningful definitely.
It's wild that this scene hasn't been re-edited into parting of the ways (or Christmas Invasion) after all this time. I feel like a lot of newcomers don't even realize this was a thing, and I worry that one day it will become lost media if it isn't properly preserved
@@designate_om OK, I misremembered then. Yeah, they really need to edit the shorts into the episodes. This and the one with the Fifth Doctor, especially, since they tie the episodes together.
I loved that rose went into defense mode. Like from her perspective the doctor was in trouble he exploded, or was taken somewhere in a weakened state and she went into "okay rose lets think what could this possibly be think like the doctor, teleport, no the tardis has protocols against hostile teleportation from inside it, transmits wouldnt replace a person, this is a bad guy i should start monologing to buy some time in case its dangerous" She went 100% doctor
I imagine it has to do with 9 being so accepting of his regeneration. 10 obviously didn't want to go and probably fought against it with all he had. 11 had just been given a new regeneration cycle so it makes sense the process would be less stable.
@@sonicfan4511 Oh yeah, that's definitely it, I think. If you watch 12 to 13, you can see how calm and excited she was; that was due to the 12th doctor being so accepting of his regeneration
I really find it funny how Nine goes through the process of explaining everything and he’s like “You’re ready now. I’m gonna change, okay? Don’t panic.” And then when he does, Rose just goes “....nope, not him. IMPOSTER!”
You know, Rose seeing the 10th Doctor is kinda like seeing an old friend after a couple of decades. They're still them but they've changed and you don't exactly know if you like them the way they are now.
Hmm yeah I see/know what you mean. Good analogy. For me it's usually a spawn of bad memories. Like seeing a ghost of my past. Upsets me/saddens me. Deeply. Cause wish things hadn't gone that way. Just Makes me very sad. Inside.
I’m not calling him ugly at all but y’all really sleep on the fact that Rose wanted 10 to change back into 9. It’s not just because she was used to that face, it’s the person she fell in love with. 10 is a pretty boy compared to 9 and she still wouldn’t have given him the time of day because she loved 9. She believed 10 was still 9 and she was right. That’s the only reason she stayed with him.
I felt that too that the only reason she accepted him cause he said he was the same as 9 and with the metacrisis doctor the doctor says that me when we first met
Shame its incomplete, this is the best quality video I have ever seen of this short. Literally the first time I could actually hear that one line "Ooh, I haven't used this one in years"
"can you change back?" I wish he could. Eccleston was the best.. shame we only got one season with the 9th doctor. Don't get me wrong David was terrific. But Eccleston was FANTASTIC!
He’s the first doctor that I’ve ever seen ( before I decided to watch the whole series from the beginning☺️) He has a different place in my heart 💗 cause 10th doc introduced me to the show :)
The first episode after a regeneration, when the new Doctor wears the clothes you most associate with the Doctor that came before him always hurts. Seeing Ten wear Nine's clothes, or Elven wearing Ten's clothes etc etc. It just feels weird. It only lasts for one episode, but that whole time you can't help but feel like it's just 'off'. And once they don their own new wardrobe, it's back to normal again. Or, you know, as close to normal as this show can get.
I remember this so well in 2005, I was 15 and Eccleston was my introduction to Dr Who earlier that year. It was in the media after the first episode he wouldn’t be returning for series 2 but that didn’t help prevent me get attached to him and love him in the role. When he regenerated into Tennant and this little intro of him aired on children in need later that year I didn’t want to accept him in the role but at the same time found him intriguing, weird and alien and later grew to love him in the role too. I don’t think anyone else could have took over from Eccleston so successfully and make the role completely his own once again with such a level of enthusiasm. Looking back it’s amazing how successfully the show was revived with a new doctor in 2005 and then introduced a new new doctor so soon after.
Man, we never got to see Barcelona.
One Day the Doctor will change back and forth by Konzentration. Technology is always changing.The First Doctor has no Screwdriver, remember?
no its just random places 🤣
R.I.P
Just got you to 1K
No dogs with no noses for us :(
The doctor looks so disappointed when she says that she wants him to change back
Its like she had the same reactions as the fans, and that was David Tennants actual reaction too. Dude never knew how great he would be
Ashya Perez ;-; if he changed back to the 9th doctor we would all be disappointed
@@lunahetfield I like the 9th doctor
@@lunahetfield imagine if he did change back, then went like "naw, feels weird, i like having some hair for a change", then changed back to Tennant.
It hurts a lot more being older and seeing this
His “hello” was so cute after rose said “Doctor?”
Jenna Mattson ikr its so cute! Even when he hops its just too adorable! :3
True, i love his smile 😊🥰 10th doctor is a sweetheart, that's for sure ❤
@@puppycatsbee nah he ain't none of the doctors have been
@@thatsmadcrazy8953 well he did have a darker side that came out often, but that's only when the doctor gets carried away and his human friends are the ones who help him be kinder and remind him that there's bravery in being soft.
ikr so cute
Tennant looks so smol in the leather jacket
Tomato Queen ikr
And hes a like a foot taller than rose
small*
Caw caw Bitch I actually never noticed but now that you mention it
Stop body shaming you bitches and david tennant is hot btw
“Can you change back”
“Do you want me too?”
“Yeah”
“Oh...”
:(
He was so sad 😢
Probably why he chose to keep his looks the second time he regenerated in front of Rose
@@whalesinlamentation5351 Second time?
@@Julie-ok4ht Just before the metacrisis.
Tennant in a leather jacket looks weird
Nicholas Williams *very
Imagine him in a bow tie and tweed
It had happen to me to
I sort of like it
Nicholas Williams he regenerated what did you really expect
ROSE IS THINKING SHE'S SEEN THAT FACE BEFORE...
Squicx I know!!!! 😭😭😭😭
Because she has, in the end of time she did... oh.. spoilers
@@kassiewin can you explain
1 January 2005
Squicx Wibely Woberly Timey-Wimey 😄
This scene always gets me because he's trying so hard to get her to like him cause he's so worried she'll hate him
Oh I know right? 😢
Rose was bit of a cunt in this scene. A selfish c***. Pisses me off. Stop being (making it) all about YOU.
It’s even sadder when you consider that he actually regenerated into this youthful, dashing incarnation for her.
800th like
but in the end she will end up loving him more
Rose's reaction is probably the same as every Who fan who started at the beginning of of NuWho
Same and rose is like danm first he was not sexy but then he became sexy
NuWho????????
@@tealwashablemarker8886 Um, yeah, that's how many people call the new series
Can confirm as having watched nuwho as my introduction to Doctor Who....that regeneration put me through a loop. One minute I was crying and elated from the previous episode...next minute I am just like..." what just happened?"
@@tealwashablemarker8886 They mean New Who. It isnt "NuWho" that makes no sense.
He had a slight weakness in his hand...so they made sure he grew a new one...never noticed that before lol
Does make me wonder if there was a timelord that would cut off a hand or something directly after regeneration so they'd keep their faces longer through metacrises. Only haveto explain the new face like 6 times then.
I know that is insane attention to detail
@@TerminianLinkVT i think time lords just consider regeneration simply as an appearance change
It was cut off then he grew a new one because of his early stage regeneration
I love how Eccleston-y he still sounds here. You can tell it's still the Doctor and that he's still changing and forming a new identity.
It’s something that every Doctor goes through. Each one, in the beginning, tends to show bits of the previous Doctor’s persona before their persona starts to set in. My guess it’s a side effect of the regeneration; their bodies may look done, but their brains are still being rewired.
Damn fan boys...this is literally just Tennant or the director trying to keep the same feel as the previous actor did...
Take off your foil hats boys
@@DelusionalInsider It's not about having a foil hat you degenerate pile of hateful garbage.
@MbS And why would they do that if it wasn't intentional? I don't understand your problem
@@OpenMawProductions damn someone's fucking crying..told ya, fucking fanboys
Love his smile after he says Barcelona
Gillian Steele GiillanSteele
Gillian Steele its soooo cuuuttttteeeeee!!!!!!!!!! I luv it!!! Hes so cute :3
@RoxanneDrew I only watched the show because I knew David Tennant was in it (I'm a big Shakespearean fan), but I'm so glad I did. After that line, though, I loved him even more.
Could watch this 24/7 just to see that smile.
OMG ME TOO
He literally had us all at "hello"
Miss Okita yes he did
Truth be told he actually had me a little before that when he whispered “run” the “hello” just sealed the deal.
I didn't appreciate at the time how clever this episode is. Rose is the audience surrogate and having her so outwardly uncomfortable and unhappy with the change perfectly mirrors how much of the audience felt. People in general don't like change and if the show didn't acknowledge that such a change is difficult, the audience would feel alienated. Instead, Rose is the one who is 'alienated' from Doctor Who in our place, allowing us tag along. David Tennant does almost nothing in this episode, again giving us the space we need to grieve and accept the change. Then just as things are getting desperate, he makes his heroic return, puts on his outfit and we realise that "of course that's still the Doctor" at the same time as Rose.
fast foward to today and everyone is relieved about change and him being 14
@@AmbivalentMind As the ultimate 10 fan, I didn't want him to come back but now I know you're right! Hence, I'm back here re-living my old obsession!
I miss 11 and the ponds unlike the rest of the others they never came back. I know they died happy but I need more
They did the same thing with Clara and 12
Which episode?
tennant falling in love with rose and smith finding a family in amy and rory was the sweetest era of doctor who
i like all of what you're saying but nine fell in love with Rose and she loved him too.
Oh Boy!
@@natalieybarra5207 I feel 9 and Rose where more friends
So true 💯
@@mrmaclovin255 The dancing, captain envy, dress oggling, and departure kiss didn’t seem like a friend zone thing.
Barty Crouch Jr. really perked up after the Triwizard Tournament.
Ryan Newman Yup. His dad was in a wheelchair, which surprised me the most.
Barty.
TheGeek1984 Stupid autocorrect...
Shame he killed his dad. Twice
i keep forgetting he was in that 😂
I feel really bad for the doctor when his companions don’t recognise him for his new faces and it’s not exactly his fault it’s the “nature of a timelord”
tbh i feel like the doctor should explain regen to their companions bc it could happen at any moment
I wonder what the real doctors face looks like. Is he a wierd alien person?
@@meme-fj6rj his real face would be human looking, i think its a variation from race to gender to species but the doctor ended up with a human face. I think it was stated that time lords dont have natural births, and the doctor was either the last natural born time lord or was artificial as was the others.
He could also regenerate into a different species, he just chooses to look human. Though theres a tie in with a different theory that the doctor is half human and was only ever confirmed for the 8th/9th Doctor. From then on it was forgotten.
meme From what I've heard, I think his true form is the 1st Doctor William Hartnell.
I remmeber watching this video on how timelords were actually just a regular species who couldnt do any of that till later when new technology was being evolved
Doctor:
Hello
25,000,000 people:
(Faints)
The truth
Now watch David Tennant kissed a guy
TRUTH.
@@dhanarsantika and?
@@dhanarsantika link.
The only time a companion actually reacted realistically to The Doctor changing.
If one of my friends did that, I'd freak
clara tambien actuo realista, tomando en cuenta que ya conocia a profundidad el fenomeno de la regeneracion y sabia que podia regenerarse sin cambiar de cara por que 11 se lo dijo
Clara reacted in a similar way. She had more of a heads up than Rose due to meeting other Doctor's before Smith's regeneration but she still felt unsafe around Capaldi at first. Of course, Capaldi absolutely didn't help due to abandoning her in Deep Breath and Kill the Moon.
@@E.C.O.escrivadelacalle primera vez que veo un comentario en español en clips de Doctor who, comenzaba a pensar que estaba solo jaja.
@@RavenandWolf muchos son de latam o españa pero como todos comentan en ingles pues comentan en ese idioma para no desentonar
@@E.C.O.escrivadelacalle entiendo, es que es una serie bastante vieja, también, directamente parece que ya no hubiera gente viendo este tipo de clips tan nostálgicos.
Him trying to cheer her up breaks my tiny black heart
Always thought Ten rocked that messy hair style and the leather jacket in this particular scene...
Yeah it suits him...Ha Ha get it? Suits him!
How can you get David Tennant and be disappointed?
One of the great unsolved mysteries of this show
Imo she only wanted him to change back because he was unfamiliar. It only took her one ep to do a full 180 on her stance because of his extreme charm and likability.
I'm a lesbian and he's probably the only man I feel attracted to haha ♥
@@mikaelalovett So- You aren't lesbian-
@@mv9370 Tennant is not a man. He is an ascended being far beyond the human race
Rose really makes this scene work. Very understated, a world of confused emotions whirling thru her mind, yet almost paralyzed with a single facial expression, speaking as little as possible, and a half turned posture, like she isnt sure about talking, running, or hiding. As the show has gone on it has gotten sillier, bigger, and less reliant on such performances and more on quips and cleverness.
So true!
Exactly
Yes, so much yes. The nuance is gone. It's all about some big gesture and big speech. But those scenes don't make the heart sing like these ones.
you're dead right
I still find it so sweet that usually the Doctor can't remember much after a regeneration (takes time to get used to the new body) however 9 loved Rose so much that the thought of going to Barcelona & thus making Rose happy was still present even after regen
Man this takes me back. Chris was my first Doctor and I loved him. When David showed up I was of the same opinion as Rose. "Who is this guy? This isn't the Doctor!". Then a few episodes later I'm all, "This is my Doctor!"
I was the same way
I'm a bit older fan. I was the same way when I first saw Peter Davison after years with Tom Baker reruns on PBS
@@krissssssss5401 I literally had the same idea and feeling as well haha. Then the 10th doctor became awesome to me. XD
just like me
"Do you fancy Billie Piper sir?"
Lauren Cooper
DO YOU DISRESPECT THE HOUSE OF COOPER??!!!
Armando Willem ARE YOU CALLING MY FATHER A GOODLY ROTTEN APPLE??!
@@harrietjonesformerprimemin2545 omg now i have to go watch that skit again lol
Irish Hearts XD
Sunflower Sunnydays I STILL AINT BOVVERED
They REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEALLY should have had this part in the Christmas special.
Exactly what I said would of been the best part of the episode
Samuel Joseph The Christmas Invasion is THE BEST Xmas special!!!
I wonder where it would fit in though!
Right at the beginning of the episode, this should have been the cold open for it.
Russell T Davies said, it was originally gonna be at the end of The Parting Of The Ways or The Beginning of The Christmas Invasion, but they went over the time slot so they chopped it off the episode and used it for Children in Need.
3:38 "Can you change back?"
"No... well actually yeah but you'll have to wait like 15 years."
I swear you comment on over half the videos I watch. Dang Jedi.
Looks at random switch
Doctor: I haven’t flipped this one in years.
Flips it
He's so precious in this scene, and also so heartbreaking. Of course, precious and heartbreaking pretty much sums up Ten.
Awwww! 😭❤️
Aaaw, my poor, precious 10th doctor 💔 So happy he found some peace now ☺️
it's soul crushing to me that 10th starts of as a happy, cheerful doctor with a strong vibe of child-like innocence, while ends up as the saddest, most broken doctor😭😭😭
Love every bit of it. The Doctor is still very mindful and respectful, not acting like she HAD to understand. And Rose being doubtful and therefore somewhat smart. Emotional: yes. Panicking: no. Two great characters being portrayed even better.
I know, Rose was written so well. I can't understand people who hate her except they must not understand her character for some reason.
@@sensen1080 Yes. I love her.
@@sensen1080 Thank You and there are people out there who don't think that the Doctor was in love with her. it's like they were watching a completely different show. Rose is my Fav and so is Donna.
@@natalieybarra5207 Some people don't want to change their minds, I guess. But anyway, Word of God says he was in love with her, that they were in love with each other, and no one can dispute that.
@@sensen1080 yeah everyone that wrote the show and starred in it did say they loved each other. Russell T Davies did such good writing.
Aww I forgot how heartbroken she was at first
Awwee dam. Just made a bigoted comment as well about it :S 😬
9th Doctor: “I’m gonna change.”
*Changes*
Rose: “ Where’s the Doctor?! What have you done to him?!”
IKR it's like "didn't you listen to any of what I just said?"
Her best friend just changed into a completely different person right in front of her. Yeah, she should probably have made the connection sooner, but honestly, what would your reaction be?
D'oh!!
Aidan Farren-Hart if the Doctor changed in front of me i'd be like "sweet! New Doctor! Lets move on! :D" not questioning, if hes the Doctor coz he is!
Aidan Farren-Hart imagine if she see 13th..
10 is so adorable can I just hug him forever please!
YES
Yes!
Yes I want to so bad 😢
When your weird friend with a time machine goes from looking like Christopher Ecellston to looking like David Tennant.
I hate when that happens
@@theonethesequel same
I love when that happens!
Lmao brilliant!
@HQ The only time it will be not so annoying when you get David Tennant.
David Tennant hopping around like a kid on sugar, not good for my heart!
Anyway, this is so sad. You could really see the excitement of the Doctor fade and turn to disappointment. He immediately thought of returning Rose back home, offered to let her go. He must've been scared too, scared that Rose would accept the invitation without second thought because he's changed.
Where is this scene on netflix It just dosnt exist?
@@equestrianforever844 It was a minisode called "Born Again" that aired as part of the BBC's Nov. 2005 Children In Need appeal but wasn't in an episode. Bridged Season One and the Xmas special and built anticipation for the latter. Guessing it's included in DVD extras but not on streaming. Thanks be to UA-cam!
Billy Piper had the best screen chemistry of any companion with "her" doctors.
Sarah jane was just as good.
@@wonjubhoyyea she was definitely the og in the first doctor who but the “remake” I think rose is one of the best ones bc it felt like an instant connection for them
@@beepboop4016river had chemistry with 3 doctors
@@Lexie955 - if you're idea of chemistry is battery acid.
Jamie was great with the Second Doctor, as was Victoria and later Zoe. Imo, the Doctor, Jamie and Zoe were the best TARDIS team
" Rose :- Can you change back?
10- Do you want me to?
Rose - Yeah
10- Oh
Rose : Can you?
10 : No."
About 15 years later :
14th : Hold my beer.
Ikr. It wasn't planned but man does it give this scene a whole new meaning. 😂😂😂
14th is the female incarnation after the old guy? I've not kept up to date on the show after the series that was focused on Clara as "The Impossible Girl."
@@ciderfan823 no it's the incarnation after her
@@giovannaargon9010who is also played by David Tennant
@@diccchocolate416 that's the joke 😉
Billie's acting is so on point that you forget she knows exactly what regeneration is in Doctor Who and that it is the Doctor.
Billie Piper, I miss her so much.
Who? All I see is Rose.
@@elijahfordsidioticvarietys8770 she plays Rose
Plays Rose?! Like an actor?!?
@@elijahfordsidioticvarietys8770 yep she's the actor who plays rose
Actor?!?!?
"can you change back?"
"d'you want me to?"
"yes"
"oh."
littlesnowflakepunk that was so heartbreaking
He didn’t notice his accent had gone... 😂
I think, and this is just a theory. That to the Doctor. They sounds the same. Meaning they sound like that old man from the very first series.
@@NeonStreaks thats a really cool theory and should be a headcanon.
@@NeonStreaks That could explain why the 13th Doctor didn't notice her new voice was feminine.
But 12 noticed he was scottish?
And the Master noticed his new voice after regeneration.
Rose: "Can you change back?"
10th Doctor: "No."
The Curator: "Am I a joke to you?"
He didn't Change Back He Just Regenerated Into A Body That Looked Like His Fourth Incarnation
This was long before the Curator existed. As far as the Doctor knows at this point, he can't change back.
We don't even know if that IS an incarnation...
@Mr. Graves Yes. Because a galifreyan should only have 13 incarnations.
@@danielbergonzi7319 have u not seen timeless child, the doctor isnt galifreyan
Guess how i got interested in doctor who
I watched doctor who being sassy for 10 minutes
valid
That’s legit
oh my god same. that and the other 2 made by allonsy.mp4
Same, kinda got me back into the Dr Who. Though Im not *that* into it
same
wish they had kept this scene in the show.
Er.... it was.
@@peterward2275 it wasn't. It was never meant to be in the show, either. It was filmed for Children in Need.
@@GiantFootPrint what ? I swear i saw this in the first episode of the season
@@HilmyA.S. You didn't. It was filmed for Children in Need. The Christmas Invasion (Tennant's first full appearance of the Doctor) starts with the TARDIS already crashing into Earth, the Doctor steps out and pretty much immediately faints. So this scene takes place between two episodes.
@@GiantFootPrint That's odd because I remember seeing this part when Doctor Who was on Netflix 6-7 years ago.
Best doctor if you ask me
Can we all agree that 10 looks hot in 9's clothes?
Yeah 😘💕
Yep !
Yesss
10 looks hot in anything.
Fanofmanythings 10 looks hot in anything
I love their chemistry. Rose will always be my favorite companion. I love love love their chemistry so much.
Ten: Mgfh, new teeth, that's weird.
Where was I?
Oh that's right....
Barcelona.
*Gives a really pretty smile*
Me: *MAKES A PTERODACTYL SCREECH*
This comment 😂😂😂
I don't think I've laughed this much in my entire life.
Not one to argue, but I think the name your looking for is Pteranodon, considering that Pterodactyl wasn’t an actual creature.
@@LastNexus as a fan of paleontology, I thank you for your efforts.
This... This is me with anything David Tennant. XD
All that glorious hopping
Tennant in this scene is so baby-faced. He looks amazing 😍
Rose I feel has the best reaction to a Regeneration. She speaks for every new Who fan that began in 2005 and didn't have anything from Classic Who to go back on. Or knew anyone who had grown up with the Classic era.
Tennant was literally the resurrection of 'The Doctor'.
So appropriate that the delightful Piper was there with him at this beginning.
I miss them both.
Then how could I remember this? Very first word I ever said to you. Trapped in that cellar. Surrounded by shop window dummies.... oh..such a long time ago. I took your hand...I said one word... just one word, I said... 'run'.
2.53
Cristian Rocco CistianRocco
STRAIGHT INTO YOUR ARMS TENSIE!! 😭
🤗
tears.
Unless, very first words he said to her was at the end of season 4
@@madina8775 Yup but he didn't know that yet and she didn't have a reason to remember that random stranger who wished her happy new year way before she even met the Doctor.
Its a realy good deep thinking episode. Why they bring it out like a delete szene? We learn who a real person would react to a modern regeneration. That Rose is not so easy thinking "Okay, he is New. Like the Face. Moving On.". This should happend more often. Good Work Piper! Good Work Tenneth!
This wasn't a deleted scene this was filmed for Children in need as "the first apparition of Tennant as The Doctor"
@@ambarodriguez4 Thnx coz I couldn't figure out why this was missing on my BR!
I love how at first, the audience (or at least me) feels the same way as Rose, we're not quite sure if this guy can replace the fantastic 9 but overtime he becomes one of the most popular doctors ever (and my favourite).
Rose reaction is what I except the new companion reaction to be like, instead of "oh okay u got new face" its like something unexpected just happend in your face and u are just scared
Clara had an entire episode dedicated to her not accepting the new doctor
@@fulcrum1257 They didn't get along over several episodes I think.
@@jochenstacker7448 they were somewhat getting along but it was a rocky start.
@@fulcrum1257 she eventually accepted him tho, and she didn't leave him. She could have decided to not travel with him anymore because of how he looked, but she didn't. She wanted to stay and since he was all over the place and kept passing out after he regenerated she felt the need to be his 'carer', if you will. She knew he needed her support, but she didn't ask for him to change back. She learnt what she had to and came to realise that just because the doctor looks different it doesn't mean he isn't there anymore.
Rose and Clara, my favourite companions. Especially Rose, she's a live one.
The 9th and the 10th doctor are the best doctors out of the seasons of the show.
11 has his issues, 12's run was a mess, and 13 is... well, the less said is for the better
I'll always say 2 and 4 are the best.
yes, although I do love Matt Smith as an actor, but considering the knowledge I already have about the writer who's written his era, I highly doubt his doctor will be anywhere near as great and powerful character as 9th and 10th
I still remember being so shocked when 9 became 10. I had never heard of Doctor who at the time. But it had me crying. I was like who the hell is this!? Then he grew on me in the end. Then he lost so much and gah!! He and nine will both have a special place in my heart forever.
"New teeth,Barcelona!"
Almost like Freddy Mercury referrences...
Crowley would be proud
10: *burps up time vortex energy* OH COME ON I JUST GOT HERE
RadialEnergy XD
10 effortlessly slipped into the role and I loved him instantly.
Top 3 companions: Rose, Donna, Amy
I'd personally swap Donna for Rory
Can’t stand Amy or Rory, their time dragged on and I was happy they left by the end which was an unsatisfying departure anyway.
Dan Jonesy Amy and Rory "dragged on"? You can't tell me they were worse than Clara. Granted, Amys story before Rory waited 2000 years was running a bit slow but i think Rory added a bunch of life into the storyline for a while. I do agree with you about the ending though.
D Brooke Clara is not a bad character.
Clara was AWFUL. She was bland and boring alongside Eleven but at least generally minded herself better. She was a total control freak with Twelve and became absolutely insufferable. I couldn’t stand her and her ending up with her own TARDIS at the end just infuriates me even more. I’ve never been so ready to be done with a DW companion as I was Clara (Donna being a close second).
This scene makes me so happy.
I love how he told her the first word he ever told her. It was great.
Gosh 10 is adorable lol
“Love the mole”
The doctor and rose is the cutest and most amazing thing ever! I hated the way it had to end. :(
oh god so do i
why he didn't say i love yoou and live together as a couple :p
but he was kinda happy cuz we have seen him smiling ,,, when rose and meta crisis doctor kissed ,,,, it was like he feel exactly what his "copy" feel ,,, ( enjoying his love story with rose and the feeling of living with her a normal life as a couple) ,,,, and i really hope it was the case and he did feel this feeling like he was with rose not the meta crisis like the meta crisis was just a sort of connexion way between them ,,, and the doctor could live his love story with his rose through him ,,,,
anyway thats what i feel everytime i see him smiling at them when kissing ,,,, ^^
what's ur opinion ? am i right ? or a little bit too romantic xD
@@meriemcullen8510 I mean there was a special connection, far and wide. Warmed the heart. Not sure about romantic (maybe little) but meaningful definitely.
That smile. Loved that smile. Later loved this Doctor.
I remember being pissed off when Chris left but then I fell in love with david
"Can you change back?"
"Do you want me to?"
"Yeah."
"Oh. No."
WELL AKSHUALLYYYY
It's wild that this scene hasn't been re-edited into parting of the ways (or Christmas Invasion) after all this time. I feel like a lot of newcomers don't even realize this was a thing, and I worry that one day it will become lost media if it isn't properly preserved
There are a lot of dvd copies though, plus the BBC have probably learnt their lesson about not backing up their most famous/beloved shows
i literally kept asking myself what happened to this scene cause i saw it years ago and was wondering why it was gone while rewatching
They cut it out? Why? I can't imagine how they thought it would work without it.
@@BrandonVout it was a webisode, it was never in the episode itselt
@@designate_om OK, I misremembered then. Yeah, they really need to edit the shorts into the episodes. This and the one with the Fifth Doctor, especially, since they tie the episodes together.
I think everybody fell in love with David Tennant in this scene, cause I did!
I loved that rose went into defense mode. Like from her perspective the doctor was in trouble he exploded, or was taken somewhere in a weakened state and she went into "okay rose lets think what could this possibly be think like the doctor, teleport, no the tardis has protocols against hostile teleportation from inside it, transmits wouldnt replace a person, this is a bad guy i should start monologing to buy some time in case its dangerous" She went 100% doctor
"Can you?"
"No"
Rule 1: The Doctor lies
David is sooo cute, especially in that leather jacket
This is the doctor I grew up with so to me he is the best doctor out of them all
Can we appreciate how calm Tenth was compared to his latter incarnations. He was just a bit disoriented while the rest were full blown maniac.
Unlike other incarnations, 10 was born out of love and had his beloved Rose next to him during regeneration
I imagine it has to do with 9 being so accepting of his regeneration. 10 obviously didn't want to go and probably fought against it with all he had. 11 had just been given a new regeneration cycle so it makes sense the process would be less stable.
@@sonicfan4511 Oh yeah, that's definitely it, I think. If you watch 12 to 13, you can see how calm and excited she was; that was due to the 12th doctor being so accepting of his regeneration
Tenth was NOT calm at all, what are you talking about?
David does such an amazing job on this scene. Yiu can see that moment where she broke his heart... the rejection. ❤😥
It’s the fact that he gradually becomes less goofy throughout his era as he has to let everyone he loves go
don't remind it to me, it's soul crushing watching that process😭😭😭
Who's here after The Power of the Doctor?!!! 🙌🙌
Looking back on this seeing his face bless him as he realises Rose is having a difficult time with his regeneration
I really find it funny how Nine goes through the process of explaining everything and he’s like “You’re ready now. I’m gonna change, okay? Don’t panic.” And then when he does, Rose just goes “....nope, not him. IMPOSTER!”
Christopher Eccelston, David Tennant, and Matt Smith are the magical big 3, 3 of my most favorite doctors.
2005: “I love the mole.”
2023: “I love the moles.”
A reference only Rose would’ve understood :(
You know, Rose seeing the 10th Doctor is kinda like seeing an old friend after a couple of decades. They're still them but they've changed and you don't exactly know if you like them the way they are now.
Hmm yeah I see/know what you mean. Good analogy. For me it's usually a spawn of bad memories. Like seeing a ghost of my past. Upsets me/saddens me. Deeply. Cause wish things hadn't gone that way. Just Makes me very sad. Inside.
I love this moment, he's acting a lot more like 9 would, as he's not really sure who he is.
I’m not calling him ugly at all but y’all really sleep on the fact that Rose wanted 10 to change back into 9. It’s not just because she was used to that face, it’s the person she fell in love with. 10 is a pretty boy compared to 9 and she still wouldn’t have given him the time of day because she loved 9. She believed 10 was still 9 and she was right. That’s the only reason she stayed with him.
I felt that too that the only reason she accepted him cause he said he was the same as 9 and with the metacrisis doctor the doctor says that me when we first met
she loved The Doctor and after witnessing it, didn't matter if he was 9 or 10
9th Doctor: I'm gonna change.
Rose: Ok.
*CHANGES*
Rose: *surprised pikachu face*
How did I get here? It 6 pm and I have to write an essay!
Its almost midnight and i have a swimming test tomorrow
do you have 90 minutes?
Shame its incomplete, this is the best quality video I have ever seen of this short. Literally the first time I could actually hear that one line "Ooh, I haven't used this one in years"
The way he says Bercelona. 😢 Cutest thing ive ever seen
"can you change back?" I wish he could. Eccleston was the best.. shame we only got one season with the 9th doctor. Don't get me wrong David was terrific. But Eccleston was FANTASTIC!
When he said "hello" you could actually see a little bit of Chris Eccleston in his face
“Can you change back?”
“No”
O RLY MR TENNANT 👀
He’s the first doctor that I’ve ever seen ( before I decided to watch the whole series from the beginning☺️)
He has a different place in my heart 💗 cause
10th doc introduced me to the show :)
The first episode after a regeneration, when the new Doctor wears the clothes you most associate with the Doctor that came before him always hurts. Seeing Ten wear Nine's clothes, or Elven wearing Ten's clothes etc etc. It just feels weird. It only lasts for one episode, but that whole time you can't help but feel like it's just 'off'. And once they don their own new wardrobe, it's back to normal again. Or, you know, as close to normal as this show can get.
I like the Tenth Doctor in the Ninth's jacket. Wish we'd had more of it.
I remember this so well in 2005, I was 15 and Eccleston was my introduction to Dr Who earlier that year. It was in the media after the first episode he wouldn’t be returning for series 2 but that didn’t help prevent me get attached to him and love him in the role.
When he regenerated into Tennant and this little intro of him aired on children in need later that year I didn’t want to accept him in the role but at the same time found him intriguing, weird and alien and later grew to love him in the role too. I don’t think anyone else could have took over from Eccleston so successfully and make the role completely his own once again with such a level of enthusiasm. Looking back it’s amazing how successfully the show was revived with a new doctor in 2005 and then introduced a new new doctor so soon after.
The line about being thinner has really aged badly now we know Eccleston suffered from anorexia throughout the whole shoot.
Oh No yeah I thought that was really horrible
Never knew that about Christopher Eccleston
@@larat8252 yeah that was my first thought 😬🤫
I guess the writer couldn’t have known that at the time.