There is something very impressive about this because when the german conductor conducts the slavsya, it sounds like German music. And when the russian conductor conducts the ode to joy, it sounds like something russian classical compser would have written.
Music has nothing to do with politics or war. I hope that one day the Russians and the Germans will get along again and can make beautiful music together like here.
@@russkayaimperiya4918 Jetzt wird die Ukraine zum Grab der jungen Männer der russischen Armee. Warum? Weil ein alter Mann eine Frau aus Deutschland kopieren will.
Medvedev vốn là chính trị gia thân phương tây, lần đầu tiên ông cho chơi bàn ode to joy ở lễ diễu binh. Nhưng sau lybia năm 2011, mọi chuyện đã thay đổi, ông đã nhìn rõ bản chất ! Người nga luôn là một trong những dân tộc tuyệt vời, kể cả những lúc họ khó khăn nhất họ vẫn giúp người khác, lịch thiệp và khiêm nhường ! Trân trọng !
Thân cái gì :)) Medvedev về cơ bản là bù nhìn của Putin thôi, chẳng qua lúc đó Nga với Phương Tây còn thân nhau nên còn cho chơi Ode To Joy ở lễ diễu binh.
@@lilmonix mình biết . Việc mình muốn nói ở đây là : Nga trước đây rất muốn gần gũi phương tây, muốn tham gia vào cộng đồng chung châu âu. Nhưng kể cả lịch sử đến hiện tại, châu âu chưa bao giờ ưa nga, kể cả trong suy nghĩ của người dân và lãnh đạo của họ luôn coi người Nga là giống người mọi rợ.
Russians, you should have made Slavsya your new national anthem, what a song! Then again you should also have avoided invading your neighbours... Well, it's never too late to improve.
Russia is defending Russians within in it's neighbors borders. It's own people, ethnic Russians witch lives are in danger, in witch the state has every right to intervene. And how many US citizens lived in Iraq or Afghanistan before they were attacked ? NONE, And why do the US attack countries separated from them by Oceans and pose no Threat to them or their people ? Is the US an universal COP or something ? And don't let me get started about NATO and Kosovo, the Referendum is legitimate. I am sorry if I am over exaggerating, but I couldn't let this lie down !
Periapse "Russians, you should have made Slavsya your new national anthem, what a song! Then again you should also have avoided invading your neighbours... Well, it's never too late to improve." No. This is just glory song, but not an anthem.
@@principetnomusic Most of the "ethnic republics" are inhabited by large amount of Russians, or heavily mixed with Russians, and they exist in an area surrounded by Russian ethnic space.
@@Porkeater2610957 But are they ethnic Russians? No. Russia is only 80% ethnic Russian. If it was even 90% ethnic Russian, I'd accept the lyrics. But not now.
@@principetnomusic "Only". So what? Rare are the countries, especially major countries, where the primary ethnic group exceeds 80%. The lyrics don't offend anyone. Even if Russians are 10% of the population, the lyrics are OK. They don't offend anyone. Russians should have the right to be proud of their culture. Have you seen the text, lyrics of the French anthem?
@@Porkeater2610957 The difference is that Russian ethnic territories are former colonies, while the non-ethnic Frenchmen came to France by choice. Even then, 90% of Frenchmen are ethnic French. Do not compare Russia with France; compare it instead with the UK. Is God Save the Queen about the Englishmen? Is Marcha Real about the Castillans? Is the March of the Volunteers about the Han? The mention of the Russian people only does not offend anyone, but it simply does not *resonate* with Tatars, Bashkirs, and countless other Russian ethnic groups. An anthem needs to unite the country, not divide it.
Slavsya (Russian song) conducted by a German, and Ode to Joy (German song) conducted by a Russian... Impressive!!
Yes
Bruh and I thought the exact opposite of what you said of the composers of those respective songs are
I wish we could all still live together like that...
There is something very impressive about this because when the german conductor conducts the slavsya, it sounds like German music. And when the russian conductor conducts the ode to joy, it sounds like something russian classical compser would have written.
Everything is finished yet.
Сейчас сложно представить немецкий военный оркестр на Красной площади, как же все-таки все изменилось
Ich kann mir das vorstellen und das wird wieder sein.
Europa!! 2:14
Это не военный марш - это гимн Европы
they sing in German
Ah yes the good old days before we all suddenly became enemys literally overnight. So depressing but let us Hope Things will get better
Music has nothing to do with politics or war. I hope that one day the Russians and the Germans will get along again and can make beautiful music together like here.
Watching this in 2022 is kinda depressing....
Yeah...((((
Even more depressing in 2024.
No more brother wars💔
WE all have so much in common....just need to understand that!
Heh
Do we? I don’t have any desire to invade Canada or persecute homosexuals. I wouldn’t elect a poisoner or a brutal psycho.
Very impressive. Never heard Ode to Joy in Russian before.
It's in German
Ахаахахаха
@@flagflow1232 russian accent
Glorious!
Впечатлительно!
haha the Danish Royal Guard is just standing xD
Russia are soo proud military parade party Slavsya and Ode To Joy
Russia Country In Europe from Moscow.
Rip general valery khalilov
good old time
2:11 ode to joy russian version
История уже!
impressive!! friendship forever!!
Rip Khaliliov
This is what Beethoven wanted ❤
Rip Comrade Khalilov
love the German conductor
He is not German. He is Valeriy Khalilov. A Russian.
@@depressedguy600 He's talking about the man who conducted "Slav'sya"
@@ho4ngl1nh Walter Ratzek
@ 0:50 i noticed the head stones across the Kremlin wall Necropolis are covered...
Царство небесное генералу Халилову.
偉大なるロシアとドイツに栄光あれ！
君、防共協定忘れたか？
日本が大好きです
What year is Spasskaya Tower Festival this?
2008 or 2010
@@sibbearian 2007
Халилов.
The Germans made it to Moscow!
In a grave. )
@@russkayaimperiya4918
Jetzt wird die Ukraine zum Grab der jungen Männer der russischen Armee. Warum? Weil ein alter Mann eine Frau aus Deutschland kopieren will.
Слишком по военному звучит, хотя не удивительно военный же фестиваль
Ода к Радости да, есть такое. А "Славься!" Так и должна быть)))
The Kremlin Zoria Military Tattoo.
Сбылась мечта папки Вальтера
Vive la Russie !
Molotov-Ribbentrop pact revived?
Нет, Гитлер-Пилсудский.
0:41 German drummers pretend that they are playing?)))
Medvedev vốn là chính trị gia thân phương tây, lần đầu tiên ông cho chơi bàn ode to joy ở lễ diễu binh. Nhưng sau lybia năm 2011, mọi chuyện đã thay đổi, ông đã nhìn rõ bản chất ! Người nga luôn là một trong những dân tộc tuyệt vời, kể cả những lúc họ khó khăn nhất họ vẫn giúp người khác, lịch thiệp và khiêm nhường ! Trân trọng !
Thân cái gì :)) Medvedev về cơ bản là bù nhìn của Putin thôi, chẳng qua lúc đó Nga với Phương Tây còn thân nhau nên còn cho chơi Ode To Joy ở lễ diễu binh.
@@lilmonix bạn suy nghĩ đơn giản quá.
@@kienletrung9842Bạn ko biết Mevedev đã là bạn thân của Putin và trong chiến dịch tranh cử của Putin năm 2000.
@@lilmonix mình biết . Việc mình muốn nói ở đây là : Nga trước đây rất muốn gần gũi phương tây, muốn tham gia vào cộng đồng chung châu âu. Nhưng kể cả lịch sử đến hiện tại, châu âu chưa bao giờ ưa nga, kể cả trong suy nghĩ của người dân và lãnh đạo của họ luôn coi người Nga là giống người mọi rợ.
Russians, you should have made Slavsya your new national anthem, what a song! Then again you should also have avoided invading your neighbours... Well, it's never too late to improve.
Russia is defending Russians within in it's neighbors borders. It's own people, ethnic Russians witch lives are in danger, in witch the state has every right to intervene. And how many US citizens lived in Iraq or Afghanistan before they were attacked ? NONE, And why do the US attack countries separated from them by Oceans and pose no Threat to them or their people ? Is the US an universal COP or something ? And don't let me get started about NATO and Kosovo, the Referendum is legitimate.
I am sorry if I am over exaggerating, but I couldn't let this lie down !
Iwell, actually its pan-european thing to invade, not only russian :3
tell NATO to stop expending and provoking war against Russia first
Well, wanna know that the most European thing is beating the shit out of other European.
Periapse "Russians, you should have made Slavsya your new national anthem, what a song! Then again you should also have avoided invading your neighbours... Well, it's never too late to improve."
No. This is just glory song, but not an anthem.
Too bad they use the multiculti lyrics for the song, the original version by Glinka praised the Russian people very specifically.
You do not want to use the multiculti lyrics, give up all the ethnic republics.
@@principetnomusic Most of the "ethnic republics" are inhabited by large amount of Russians, or heavily mixed with Russians, and they exist in an area surrounded by Russian ethnic space.
@@Porkeater2610957 But are they ethnic Russians? No. Russia is only 80% ethnic Russian. If it was even 90% ethnic Russian, I'd accept the lyrics. But not now.
@@principetnomusic "Only". So what? Rare are the countries, especially major countries, where the primary ethnic group exceeds 80%. The lyrics don't offend anyone. Even if Russians are 10% of the population, the lyrics are OK. They don't offend anyone. Russians should have the right to be proud of their culture.
Have you seen the text, lyrics of the French anthem?
@@Porkeater2610957 The difference is that Russian ethnic territories are former colonies, while the non-ethnic Frenchmen came to France by choice. Even then, 90% of Frenchmen are ethnic French. Do not compare Russia with France; compare it instead with the UK. Is God Save the Queen about the Englishmen? Is Marcha Real about the Castillans? Is the March of the Volunteers about the Han?
The mention of the Russian people only does not offend anyone, but it simply does not *resonate* with Tatars, Bashkirs, and countless other Russian ethnic groups. An anthem needs to unite the country, not divide it.
thats german!
You are right thou my dear friend
facepalm
no querida russia la arruinaron con la vanda de Inglaterra justo esos conflictivos piratas para russia mi corazón para Inglaterra no 🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷❤👍