Why did Scotland and England unite? (Animated History Documentary)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 жов 2024
  • Scotland and England spent most of the Medieval and Early Modern period hating each other but as you'll know they unified to create Great Britain in 1707. So why did two countries which loathed each other so much end up unifying into a single state? To find out watch this short and simple animated history documentary.
    A special thanks to my patreon supporters below:
    Rikspuckot
    Øystein Alsaker
    eddy.birdy
    SirJoe
    Myller
    MajesticFirebird
    Scott W
    George Kapoyanis
    Steven B
    robert lalonde
    CharÉTS
    Mathias.C
    Dennis Vandeban
    Brendan W
    Southside Mitch
    Michael Kram
    Heath Robertson
    Justin Kubusch
    Leonard Frank
    Cippalippus
    ChrisRom
    Aaron Conaway
    Steven Gibson
    Jason Vandeventer
    Alex Teplyakov
    Jamie van Brewen
    Sean Uzar
    Ron Johnson
    Joe DeVito
    Dr. Schtnizel
    mgnesium.poetry
    Leena Al-Souki
    Anthony McCann
    Matthew Toles
    Jacob Zachs
    Jesse Plung
    No way
    Travis Mount
    Matt Reed
    Blue Cardinal
    ContraryPython
    Zachary Pascalar
    BattleGoat Studios
    HeshtheNCHunter 1861
    Colm Byrne
    Valentyn
    Alex G.
    Tristan Kreller
    ZCoupon
    Clay Carroll
    Andrew Sever
    Kristian Kidd
    Wolf
    Joell Bel
    Jonny Minogue
    Tino
    Kevin Neuhaus
    Ian Smith
    Hunter Bayliss
    Steve Schroeder
    JT96
    Tony Belmonte
    Shauna K
    Studio Audience
    BenDrums24
    Duke
    Garrett Manarin
    Jane Sumpter
    Tyler Bomkamp
    Hapalochlaena Lunulata
    Tranier Bocaj
    Chris PeBenito
    Templar366
    Windischgraetz
    Tim Stone
    C. C. C.
    Warren Rudkin
    Justin Short
    Yosef Waysman
    Hexapuma
    Angel Aguiñaga
    Bobby Koys
    Bartosz Zasada
    Juan Castillo
    George Caponera
    Robin!
    Tim Sweeney
    Sean Long
    Nicholas Menghini
    Konstantin Bredyuk
    Joran Robbe
    erez87
    Robert Meehan
    Random Insanity
    Mars Project
    Samantha McCormick
    Larz Welo
    Donald Weaver
    Paul Munro
    David Spellmeyer
    Ethan Harlow
    Josefine Starlene
    Charles Kwiatkowski
    Mark Littlehale
    Mik Scheper
    Oriki
    KGO
    Jeremy Hernandez
    Ted Parsons
    Joseph Reinsch
    Burt Clothier
    Nathan Snyder
    Scriptmonkeys
    Kevin Phoenix
    Lord Beac
    Jack Beckman
    Philip Yip
    Nick Macarius
    Beth Resta
    John Gross-Whitaker
    Sean D.
    LambOfLeg
    John Orr
    Andreas Mosand
    Juan Benet
    Ned Burke
    Joshua Schneider
    War Penguin, PhD
    Andrew Patane
    Tim Stumbaugh
    Johann_Gambolputty_of_Ulm
    Ciege Engine
    Duane Bridges
    Afghanistan
    Moraxian
    Will Sullivan
    ARandomPaperClip
    Damon
    alexccg
    Nolan Peale
    Mario Mejia
    Rosebird
    Matthew Venuti
    Ben Jambor
    James
    Roko Lisica
    Harrison Wiener
    Matt Busch
    T. c. north
    Dustin Koellhoffer
    Ruben Rodriguez
    Carr Nyuli
    Jakester1238
    Mark Ploegstra
    Shakira
    SirAlpaka
    David Hilbert's Entscheidungsproblem
    blaZzinG_FurY
    george tyler
    Mr.Myoozik
    Nathan Ngumi
    Dr. Sarno
    blei95
    Mehhh❤️🌎🌍🌏
    Zachary
    Richard Wolfe
    Mario Peshev
    Jonathan Niehaus
    nullptr
    Contdoko12
    Sara Birnbaum
    Colin Cecil
    Allen Rines
    Tyler Jenkins
    Serius_Loyola
    Liquid Chief
    Josh the Great
    Rabbi Rob Thomas
    D. Mahlik
    Jeff Sharon
    Joseph Hutchins
    Dr. Dana L. Pertermann
    Nuukov
    Glassford Global
    bas mensink
    Jack Nelson
    The Funks
    khaki enthusiast
    Sethars
    Ali Sadighian
    Doug MacLean
    Adrian Marine
    Anthony Uk
    Kaiserrin
    Charles Doolittle
    Peter Hopkins
    Jasdeep Brar
    Ian M
    Dullis
    DefinitelyNattox
    StarshockNova
    YugiJitsu Games
    Erik Hare
    Hidamarisou - Webnovel translations
    Spencer DeRosier
    Patty Culp
    Yared Cristiano
    William Adderholdt
    ThePalestRose
    lesser_sam
    Jasmin Vikk
    Magdalena Reinberg-Leibel
    Peter Marino
    Tom Ebert
    WolfiZee
    Bren Ehnebuske
    Joel Wasserman
    Carl Blanton
    Adam Probert
    Steve Bonds
    Gin Aldeguer
    Miky Hidalgo Morriss
    Bruce Kozuma
    Thomas Wang
    Joshportunities
    Ted Ingram
    Seth Reeves
    Dusty Books
    A. J. Smart
    Bradley Backoff
    Brian Giordano
    Rob Rollins
    Tactical_Jackal
    Heytun
    Isabel Harrison
    Robert Brockway
    Chris Weisel
    SketerK
    Lord Chromium
    tegsirat
    Joseph Kerckhoff
    Thomas McGraw
    Shannon Cartee
    Hiro P
    Vegard Tønnessen
    Kairos
    Logical Insanity
    Ken Fitzgerald
    William Maywood
    Vladislav Vasilev
    Tommi Hewitt
    Robin_Col
    João Santos
    Lindorien
    Kasi
    M Scho
    Kameohawk
    Typhoon2401
    Jan Bart Verbist
    Hazzard
    Schwarzer Hai
    Jackarice26
    zemnmez
    James
    Rhys Jackson
    Ben L
    Tarsirrus
    Twinny Hill
    Phil Johnston
    Ash Elford
    Rhys Little

КОМЕНТАРІ • 858

  • @bigblue6917
    @bigblue6917 3 години тому +548

    The problem with the Panama colony is that the land belonged to Spain and if Spain was not busy fighting England the Scots would have been removed sooner.

    • @christianweibrecht6555
      @christianweibrecht6555 3 години тому +67

      Seriously I wonder why they believed colonizing Spanish territory would’ve been profitable

    • @TheDanEdwards
      @TheDanEdwards 3 години тому +10

      "The problem with the Panama colony is that the land belonged to Spain"

    • @shorewall
      @shorewall 3 години тому +127

      @@TheDanEdwards Don't be coy, you know how colonialism works.

    • @hirocheeto7795
      @hirocheeto7795 3 години тому +57

      @@TheDanEdwards *Should* Spain have owned it is a different question than *whether* Spain owned it. On the world stage, guns and practicality outweigh morality. This is a bad thing, naturally, but it's the fact of the matter.

    • @samiamrg7
      @samiamrg7 3 години тому +15

      It didn’t help that the Scots were also not very good at settling in rough, tropical terrain and chose a region which is to this day sparsely populated due to the unforgiving terrain.

  • @timmccarthy9917
    @timmccarthy9917 4 години тому +1614

    If only Kelly Moneymaker had bailed out the Panama colony. I mean, controlling the Panama isthmus is a pretty solid idea on paper.

    • @JarrodFrates
      @JarrodFrates 3 години тому +76

      If you're going to do things at places far away with lots of water in between, you need lots of ships with guns. England had already figured out that part, and so had Spain. Scotland hoped to prove that it wasn't necessary, and Spain proved them wrong.

    • @GamesTwiceOver
      @GamesTwiceOver 3 години тому +3

      That would have made everything a little too easy, I'm afraid.

    • @LexlutherVII
      @LexlutherVII 3 години тому +5

      He was busy with saving Nederlands 😂

    • @markstott6689
      @markstott6689 3 години тому +31

      The Scots couldn't have picked a worse spot in central America. Tropical rainforest, mountains, and swamps. The Darien Gap, even in the 21st century, is still untamed. With malaria and other tropical diseases, it's still a hell hole for human beings native to the area. For European settlers, it was a disaster waiting to happen. There's a break in the transcontinental road as the Darien Gap is still uncrossed by any kind of paved road.
      Even if the Scots settlers had unlimited Moneymaker and a large Navy to protect them, I suspect that the colony would still have failed.

    • @wentoneisendon6502
      @wentoneisendon6502 3 години тому +5

      Spinning 3 plates had already colonised them

  • @joshuawells835
    @joshuawells835 3 години тому +425

    2:58-It was just the Kingdom of Great Britain. The "United" part wouldn't be added for another century, when the Acts of Union of 1800 merged Great Britain and Ireland.

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland 3 години тому +11

      It was on occasion referred by united kingdom of Great Britain

    • @zarabada6125
      @zarabada6125 3 години тому +44

      If you read the 1707 Act of Union, you will see the new entity referred to as the "united Kingdom of Great Britain," (though some online copies capitalise the U).
      In the 1801 Acts, the new entity is the "United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland."
      There are many fascinating debates online about the capitalisation (or lack thereof) of the "u" in the 1707 Act and when the country actually became the "United Kingdom."

    • @Roadsguy
      @Roadsguy Годину тому +3

      @@zarabada6125 So like in the US Declaration of Independence, "the united States of America" since our own name hadn't been finalized yet and it was more a description than a name.

    • @martychisnall
      @martychisnall Годину тому +3

      Incorrect, the acts of union themselves specifically refer to it as the “United Kingdom of Great Britain” numerous times.

    • @EricDillingham
      @EricDillingham 47 хвилин тому

      actually, dumbass, it wasn't even the kingdom of great britain even if you get semantical, just "Great Britain". go outside

  • @aidanfedorochko3728
    @aidanfedorochko3728 4 години тому +62

    When it comes to why things happen is usually comes down with one idea: To Hell with France.

  • @nosoupforyou8202
    @nosoupforyou8202 3 години тому +29

    1:05 "too busy having his head cut off to really give it a go"
    Did not expect this and giggled about it

  • @MrFancyDragon
    @MrFancyDragon 3 години тому +269

    I know History Matters has a lot of iconic lines
    But it would be hilarious if one of his videos had his “But Fun Fact…” followed up by a “Yes” instead of a “No”

    • @davepratt9909
      @davepratt9909 2 години тому +37

      It would be the most paused/replayed line as 1.7M viewers go, "What??"

    • @adamwarlock1
      @adamwarlock1 Годину тому +11

      Yes! It should be for some unexpectedly positive decision someone made. "No one expected Napoleon to agree to Britain's peace offer, but fun fact...yes!"

    • @JenniferinIllinois
      @JenniferinIllinois Годину тому +2

      If that ever happened, the world as we know it will end.

  • @crosshair4483
    @crosshair4483 4 години тому +590

    Last time I was this early japan was ruled by a Shogunate

    • @Oran_Fitz
      @Oran_Fitz 4 години тому

      How The Actual Fuck Are You One Hundred And Fifty Seven Years Old? Secondly, How The Actual Fuck Was UA-cam A Thing In The Eighteen-Sixties?

    • @GGdude
      @GGdude 3 години тому +6

      Thats what she said!

    • @Amaan_Zargar
      @Amaan_Zargar 3 години тому +11

      They still let the emperor dress like an emperor

    • @adamk.7177
      @adamk.7177 3 години тому +3

      @@Amaan_Zargar You can also dress like an emperor. It's not illegal. Nobody's stopping you. Do it.

    • @Sam-I-Am981
      @Sam-I-Am981 3 години тому +1

      Yup

  • @Trofusky
    @Trofusky 4 години тому +317

    I thought James Bizonet just asked them to politely play nice

    • @jamesbissonette8002
      @jamesbissonette8002 2 години тому +11

      I like that spelling!

    • @anaverageyoutubeuser
      @anaverageyoutubeuser Годину тому +4

      @@jamesbissonette8002the legend himself.

    • @Artifis0743
      @Artifis0743 21 хвилина тому

      Who is James Bizonet

    • @LostToaster
      @LostToaster 21 хвилина тому

      How do you think the english managed to bribe all those people? Obviously James Bissonette funded it.

  • @LuukvdHoogen
    @LuukvdHoogen 3 години тому +142

    I like how they probably avoided any naming disputes by naming the new kingdom after the island.

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland 3 години тому +20

      Well the monarch was already styled king/queen of great britain so it was a no brainer

    • @togerboy5396
      @togerboy5396 3 години тому +8

      @@RoyalRegimentofScotland And the seven old Anglo-Saxon kingdoms (despite only controlling England’s territory) would grant the most powerful of the seven kings the title of “Bretwalda” meaning wielder, or ruler, of Britain, despite not controlling Scotland nor Wales.

    • @johnnyxrcfc
      @johnnyxrcfc 2 години тому +4

      Not strictly true, the island at the time was known as ‘Albion’. The name ‘Britain’ comes from the Latin Britannia/ Greek ‘Britanios’ which were the lands south of hadrians wall i.e. modern day England and Wales.

    • @cynicat74
      @cynicat74 2 години тому +2

      @@johnnyxrcfc You're completely wrong. The island was known as "Prydain", which is where the Romans got the word "Britannia" from. Albion only consisted of England, Alba consisted of Scotland, and Cymru consisted of Wales.

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland 2 години тому

      @@togerboy5396 Bretwalda wasn't actually a title. It was more of like a very generic term for strongest guy in britian. Its effectively just king of the Britons in old English

  • @ambeatch
    @ambeatch 2 години тому +17

    One of these days he’s gunna hit me with a “fun fact Yes” and I’ll be floored

  • @MatthewMopo
    @MatthewMopo 4 години тому +503

    Being Welsh, it’s depressing to watch an entire video where my country is referred to as England. It’s even more depressing given how historically accurate this is.

    • @howtoappearincompletely9739
      @howtoappearincompletely9739 4 години тому +11

      Indeed. Diolch, Harri Tudur! :pouting_face:

    • @dwgray9000
      @dwgray9000 3 години тому +21

      Because the english refuse to admit after they ran out vikings that really liked brie and yorkshire, they got conquered by the welsh.

    • @ToastieBRRRN
      @ToastieBRRRN 3 години тому +22

      Well that's what violent annexation does to you. Instead of peaceful personal union. Which reminds me, is that why Wales is referred to as Principality? Or was it the title Prince used be a bit more prestigious than King? 🤔

    • @ToastieBRRRN
      @ToastieBRRRN 3 години тому +14

      Ironically merged by Henry VIII, a Welsh King, if you get what I mean...😅

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland 3 години тому +15

      ​@@ToastieBRRRNBecause prince of Wales was already a title. Wales wasn't actually a kingdom

  • @ElladanKenet
    @ElladanKenet 3 години тому +12

    Elizabeth: Aight, I don't feel like getting married or having kids
    Parliament: But those are literally your two jobs
    Elizabeth: Oh well!

  • @abzzeus
    @abzzeus Годину тому +8

    The Kingdoms United, stopped trying to conquer each other and decide to see what they could conquer together - turns out they could conquer, a *LOT*

  • @bonwatcher
    @bonwatcher 3 години тому +10

    Love the sign of Elizabeth I reading, "Buns in the oven: 0." At least she didn't lose her head over it like her mom.

    • @paulluka2029
      @paulluka2029 2 години тому +1

      Very underrated comment it should be pinned.

  • @wordytoed9887
    @wordytoed9887 4 години тому +11

    The video I have been waiting for.

    • @segiraldovi
      @segiraldovi 2 години тому

      One thing I will always regret was that he didn't make the Acts of Union video in the English history series. It could have been a nice ending considering that England would then cease to exist and become Great Britain.

  • @samsonsoturian6013
    @samsonsoturian6013 3 години тому +20

    Correction: Feelings on the union were mixed in Scotland, not overwhelming against. They favored the union when the King was Scottish, but turned against his son who grew up in London.

  • @feynstein1004
    @feynstein1004 3 години тому +97

    Politics aside, you gotta admit the Union Jack looks a hell of a lot cooler than its individual constituents.

    • @damienreilly4347
      @damienreilly4347 2 години тому +26

      The union flag has to be one of the coolest flags there is.

    • @alistairmrkerr1336
      @alistairmrkerr1336 2 години тому +15

      The Scottish flag is the second oldest in the world, the Welsh don't get represented on the Butchers Apron but do get to war under it

    • @brad5426
      @brad5426 2 години тому +8

      ​@@alistairmrkerr1336 Obvious anglophobe located

    • @melaniedrogr951
      @melaniedrogr951 2 години тому +7

      nah whales has the best flag with its dragons

    • @alistairmrkerr1336
      @alistairmrkerr1336 2 години тому +4

      @@brad5426 is Wales represented on the Union Flag ? Do Welsh soldiers fight under the Union Flag ? Where did I mention England?

  • @dazai_.992
    @dazai_.992 4 години тому +48

    My 7th great grandfather came to America as a deserter Scottish soldier in 1746 after the Jacobite defeat at the Battle of Culloden, I'm actually interested in that.

  • @MekarWB
    @MekarWB 4 години тому +8

    Hating each other is fine but hating the continent is stronger

  • @harveya1a952
    @harveya1a952 4 години тому +30

    Because uniting would allow them to establish the James Bisonette empire

    • @Svalbaz
      @Svalbaz 3 години тому +2

      Glory to he❤

    • @1trackmind28
      @1trackmind28 51 хвилина тому

      Bisontium Empire

  • @darkphoenix2745
    @darkphoenix2745 2 години тому +5

    Because James Bizonet wasn't there to prevent Scottland's bankrupcy.

  • @adambashaxd420
    @adambashaxd420 4 години тому +162

    Its obviously Napoleon, of course its him.

    • @RevolutionaryGoose
      @RevolutionaryGoose 4 години тому +14

      Nah it was failing to colonise Panama and going broke

    • @balabanasireti
      @balabanasireti 4 години тому

      Boring

    • @gegecry
      @gegecry 4 години тому +11

      Fun fact:No

    • @benjaminlynch9958
      @benjaminlynch9958 3 години тому +7

      Yep, Napoleon gets credit for uniting two separate countries unrelated to France and doing so nearly a full century before Napoleon’s rise to power.
      Make it make sense! 🫠

    • @SirBoggins
      @SirBoggins 3 години тому

      Him being short meant that the English & Scots wanted to one up him by making their nation taller than him!

  • @bjiornbjiorn
    @bjiornbjiorn 3 години тому +15

    Wow! An accurate summary of the Darien affair. A surprise, to be sure, but a welcome one.

  • @blackdiamond5977
    @blackdiamond5977 4 години тому +165

    England: "And then, after hundreds of years of fighting me, all it took was some bribes. Funniest shit I've ever seen"
    Scotland: "Worst Mistake of my Life"

    • @randomguy-tg7ok
      @randomguy-tg7ok 3 години тому +46

      To be fair, bribery is a lot easier if your enemy has blown 20% of their entire wealth on trying to colonise the single worst choice they realistically could have ever made.

    • @Lp-army1
      @Lp-army1 3 години тому +7

      @@randomguy-tg7ok 8/10 on choice 1/10 on actually being able to supply said choice

    • @attiepollard7847
      @attiepollard7847 3 години тому

      The Scottish better be lucky that they are even in the Union. In a Scottish better be lucky that the English themselves want to keep Scotland identity. Because it seems that other Scottish want to import foreigners in to erase Scottish identity all in the name of international socialism. Damn shame

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland 3 години тому +4

      Tbh this is a bit simplistic it was more complicated than that

    • @thedrinkinggamemaker9749
      @thedrinkinggamemaker9749 2 години тому

      I can't understand why we let someone else rule our land,
      Cap in hand
      🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @aleksandarvil5718
    @aleksandarvil5718 4 години тому +7

    Island version of *France & Bretagne* !!!

  • @hjaltesrensen8214
    @hjaltesrensen8214 4 години тому +26

    42 secunds is maybe the quickest ive ever discovered a video like this.

  • @gyo900
    @gyo900 4 години тому +65

    Because James Bissonette was the one pulling the strings all along.

    • @NobleGamer889
      @NobleGamer889 4 години тому +4

      He was truly 2 steps ahead

    • @balabanasireti
      @balabanasireti 4 години тому +1

      Boring

    • @jackroberts8382
      @jackroberts8382 4 години тому +3

      “It was Bisonette All Along!”

    • @allenkennedy99
      @allenkennedy99 4 години тому +3

      Can't believe James Bissonette was the Bay Harbor Butcher all along.

    • @Artifis0743
      @Artifis0743 19 хвилин тому

      Who is James Bisonette

  • @theboxingarmadillo1610
    @theboxingarmadillo1610 4 години тому +2

    You are just awesome. Thank you!

  • @matthewgillies7509
    @matthewgillies7509 3 години тому +11

    I did a paper of this in 2007, and had to go back and read the minutes from the debates in both parliaments from these ponderous tomes that were copied and published in 1707. I can still smell those books today.

  • @flyhyland
    @flyhyland 2 години тому +4

    Because England tickled Scotland until she finally relented and joined in the fun.

  • @kubus0024
    @kubus0024 3 години тому +14

    1:29 funny. On some advanced history classes (In Poland we don't talk THAT much about it) I was told The Navigation Acts were designed to fight Dutch traders being everywhere back at the time.

    • @thepatriarchy819
      @thepatriarchy819 3 години тому +2

      Both can be true

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland 3 години тому +6

      Because they were

    • @jeroenimus7528
      @jeroenimus7528 2 години тому

      Only reason they stopped fighting Dutch traders is because the Dutch seriously defeated and humiliated the English navy after which the aenglish parliament plotted to replace their monarch by the Dutch Prince of Orange in the "glorious/bloodless revolution. (Who wasted no time in subjugating those in Scotland and Ireland who opposed in a far from glorious or bloodless series of battles as well as outright murders)

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland Годину тому

      @@jeroenimus7528 This literally just isn't true. William wasn't even the one invited he was literally a couple monarch because he had a hissy fit when he was going to be made a consort

  • @kecajkecajowski568
    @kecajkecajowski568 4 години тому +16

    Make a video on why polish-swedish union didint happend

    • @TrocaTheNero
      @TrocaTheNero 3 години тому +4

      Long story short: John III of Sweden had married a Polish princess: Catherine Jagiellon and their son: Sigismund, was elected King of Poland and Grand Duke of Lithuania when Stephen Bathory died, becoming Sigismund III. He was then guaranteed to also become King of Sweden since Sweden had a hereditary monarchy. John III dies, Sigismund becomes King of Sweden as well and so we have a personal union. But Karl, John III's younger brother and Sigismund III's uncle, wasn't very happy about this because Poland-Lithuania (and Sigismund) was Catholic and Sweden was Lutheran. So, he started a rebellion leading to the deposition of Sigismund from the Swedish throne in 1599. Karl then became "riksföreståndare" (regent) of Sweden until 1604 when he was officially crowned king as Karl IX.

    • @Zadlo14
      @Zadlo14 3 години тому

      ​@@TrocaTheNero Sweden wasn't entirely Lutheran back then. It became Lutheran due to attempts of Charles IX.

    • @010101110100
      @010101110100 Годину тому

      After the collapse of polish-Swedish fusion cuisine it was decided humanity would be better off without

  • @no.6660
    @no.6660 2 години тому +3

    You gotta love that the most unlikely alliance ended up becoming the most powerful nation on earth

  • @dannyarcher6370
    @dannyarcher6370 Годину тому +11

    Rules for Conquest:
    1. Never invade Russia in the Winter.
    2. Don't settle the Darien Gap.

    • @joec9693
      @joec9693 43 секунди тому

      And never get in against a Sicilian when death is on the line!!

  • @shadowsingularity
    @shadowsingularity 4 години тому +6

    I just searched history matters and you upload a video at the same time lol

  • @uglywornoutshoelace9654
    @uglywornoutshoelace9654 2 години тому +2

    It’s important to mention that the Scot’s were basically given Jamaica too. Which at the time made more money than all the 13 colonies combined

  • @flippern3726
    @flippern3726 4 години тому +4

    Because James bissonette wanted to see Great Britain united

  • @BlazeClone
    @BlazeClone 2 години тому +2

    0:53 is one of the many reasons that some people in Scotland campaign for independence

  • @Jay-ql4gp
    @Jay-ql4gp 29 хвилин тому

    I enjoyed this! Thank you!

  • @teamskulltron25
    @teamskulltron25 Годину тому +2

    Finally one about my homeland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

  • @TransformersBoss
    @TransformersBoss Годину тому +2

    As you said in a previous video, the Scots were afraid of being Wales’ed

  • @MineONite
    @MineONite 3 години тому +19

    0:28 buns in the oven is absolutely absurd

  • @charliespurr7325
    @charliespurr7325 4 години тому +4

    Because James Bisonette wanted to drive from the north coast to the south

  • @nahuelpiguillem2949
    @nahuelpiguillem2949 3 години тому +2

    Last time i was this early Argentina was part of the Viceroyalty of the Río de la Plata

  • @schindler80
    @schindler80 Годину тому +2

    It would be worth mentioning that partaking in the exploits of the East India Company in India played a role in strengthening the bonds of the union ... and the scots were disproportionately employed within the EIC.

  • @RadioMartyT1B
    @RadioMartyT1B 21 хвилина тому +1

    WALES: "Am I a joke to you?"
    ENGLAND & SCOTLAND: "Well, yes actually."

  • @blitzgaming9561
    @blitzgaming9561 3 години тому

    Been waiting for this video for a while.

  • @downfall9830
    @downfall9830 3 години тому +9

    Man I sure hope there isn’t any modern political discussion under this video…

  • @bullmoosevelt4495
    @bullmoosevelt4495 4 години тому +35

    The last time I was this early Scotland was still independent.

    • @ToastieBRRRN
      @ToastieBRRRN 3 години тому +1

      Last time I was this early, the Scots was still in Ireland.

    • @hentehoo27
      @hentehoo27 3 години тому +2

      I expected Scots to yell *"FREEDOM!!"* here.

    • @thedrinkinggamemaker9749
      @thedrinkinggamemaker9749 2 години тому +1

      Oh flower of Scotland
      When will we see your like again

  • @cam4146
    @cam4146 4 години тому +1

    Yay! I'm early! Love the vids!

  • @CinematicCraft4310
    @CinematicCraft4310 4 години тому +6

    buns in the oven is wild

    • @Tjalve70
      @Tjalve70 3 години тому +2

      Insert "You had one job"-joke here.

  • @Sermentian1867
    @Sermentian1867 4 години тому +17

    Can you please make a 10 minute history video on the 7 years war?

    • @SuchDarkness
      @SuchDarkness 4 години тому +8

      he stopped doing 10 minute history because youtube's monetization systems changed, meaning he would lose money on longer videos

    • @Xapheus
      @Xapheus 3 години тому

      @@SuchDarkness
      Ah, with "The UA-cam Algorithm" audience desires and quality are secondary.
      The main metric is "engagement".
      So shorter videos give more viewers, maximizing revenue for both UA-cam and the channel itself.
      But, when looking back in history, the best videos would include the additional depth OOP and many of us are looking for.

  • @jakethegardenrake8418
    @jakethegardenrake8418 2 години тому +2

    So that's where the Darien gap comes from, interesting

  • @SeeASquaRE
    @SeeASquaRE 3 години тому +1

    All this lore is necessary to understand that clip of Scottish old lady's distaste of Magaret Thatcher at her funeral.

  • @SethSilver24
    @SethSilver24 3 години тому +4

    Babe wake up, HM uploaded

  • @FastTquick
    @FastTquick 3 години тому +4

    This video makes me think there should be a video on why Castile and Aragon merged together into Spain?

    • @Hudpix16
      @Hudpix16 3 хвилини тому

      They had been ruled by the same monarch since 1516 for some 200 years until the Bourbons got rid of their privileges.

  • @Quin_Ram
    @Quin_Ram 4 години тому +5

    Because of Caesar.

  • @omnisel
    @omnisel 56 хвилин тому

    love how they very well could have joined peacefully multiple times but it just couldn't have ended in any way but force.

  • @justinfenner869
    @justinfenner869 3 години тому +4

    For a follow up to this, perhaps a vid on why did Ireland and Great Britain unite?

    • @Finnbobjimbob
      @Finnbobjimbob 2 години тому +3

      Settler colonialism

    • @ValiantValium
      @ValiantValium Годину тому

      oh thats simple: Because Great Britain said so

    • @gumloproductions
      @gumloproductions 48 хвилин тому +2

      Subjugation, with the goal of supplanting the Catholic majority of Ireland in favour of Anglo-Irish Anglicans and Ulster Scots Presbyterians, ultimately for the goal of full access to the pastoral land, agriculture and lumber, and a pacified neighbour. Much of Ireland's woodland was exploited for industrial expansion in the North of England and in the Scottish Lowlands. A lot of land in Ireland was owned by England and Scottish landowners.

  • @michaelowino228
    @michaelowino228 25 хвилин тому +1

    Good video.

  • @markojojic6223
    @markojojic6223 3 години тому

    Happy to have come from CGP Grey

  • @SafwanSheikh-g9k
    @SafwanSheikh-g9k 4 години тому +15

    "SCOTLAND FOREVER!!!"

    • @MRBaLlisStiK
      @MRBaLlisStiK 3 години тому

      Englands better except Blackpool I fucking hate it there

  • @zeppelinprime7892
    @zeppelinprime7892 17 хвилин тому

    Watched your Communism in Russia 10 minute video in class recently.I had to explain to my teacher in leaving cert history who you were and the benefits of watching your content. Keep up the great work.

  • @michaelball93
    @michaelball93 4 години тому +4

    Wow, 20 seconds and I'm in.

  • @ColumbidaeKing
    @ColumbidaeKing 4 години тому +5

    W video 🔥

  • @pixelsthered
    @pixelsthered 35 хвилин тому +2

    Correction: Your graphic shows the Isle of Man as being part of England, and latterly Great Britain. It has never been part of either and remains a separate Crown Dependency to this day.

  • @vansglitches1192
    @vansglitches1192 4 години тому +3

    Nice

  • @napoleonibonaparte7198
    @napoleonibonaparte7198 3 години тому +2

    But hey, the benefits are glorious. a single British market, English market access, no more significant territorial conflicts, more focus on innovation, Britain starts to look outward instead of inward constantly...

  • @moonshinewilly01
    @moonshinewilly01 3 години тому

    Thanks!

  • @AnotherLuckyStar
    @AnotherLuckyStar 3 години тому +1

    It's nice to finally learn all the stuff that was missing from CGP Grey's video on the topic from like 12 years ago.

  • @shawdow357
    @shawdow357 Годину тому

    I was literally just researching this yesterday. Get out of my head!

  • @Minotaur-of-Malice
    @Minotaur-of-Malice 34 хвилини тому

    Even though the answers to most of these videos are essentially “because it was easier”, “because money”, or “because they’re French”,
    It is still entertaining to watch the information dive leading up to the answer. Fun as always!

  • @benfrancis7745
    @benfrancis7745 26 хвилин тому +1

    Very interesting. I'd only been taught the anglified version (essentially we saved scotland from their debt by doing it). I guess with us English being nice to our neighbours was just too good to be true

  • @robertszynal4745
    @robertszynal4745 56 хвилин тому +1

    "United" was added when Ireland "joined" the kingdom in 1801. It was just "The Kingdom Of Great Britain" when Scotland and England United.
    So "The United Kingdom Of Great Britain and Ireland" from 1801, then from 1922 "The United Kingdom Of Great Britain and Northern Ireland".
    Who knows, maybe we'll change again at some point.

  • @WashingtonBall
    @WashingtonBall 4 години тому +5

    Because Kelly moneymaker said so

  • @thomasdallor2128
    @thomasdallor2128 Годину тому +1

    She should've named James Bizonet to be her heir

  • @brucebullard762
    @brucebullard762 32 хвилини тому

    Thank you for this. This was always a gray area for me.

  • @morleyabbott502
    @morleyabbott502 4 години тому

    And they state happily united for the rest of time *nervous glances*.

  • @vexillologymaster
    @vexillologymaster Годину тому

    2:11
    It's only a matter of time before we get thrown a curve ball: *"But fun fact... Yes."*

  • @BallTheRascal
    @BallTheRascal 4 години тому +4

    Cool

  • @midkemian1
    @midkemian1 3 години тому +25

    A surprisingly accurate telling, although you ,missed out England encouraging Spain's blockade

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland 3 години тому +3

      It's a bit simplistic but it's a good basic description

    • @midkemian1
      @midkemian1 3 години тому +4

      @@RoyalRegimentofScotland agreed, it doesn't shy away from placing the blame where it lies but does neglect to point out that it wasn't just the Scottish population that were against the Union - the English were too

    • @bebedor_de_cafe3272
      @bebedor_de_cafe3272 3 години тому +1

      Welcome to the history matters channel. It’s surprisingly very accurate for the length of his videos

    • @minamagdy4126
      @minamagdy4126 3 години тому

      He does say that the English of James I's time were against it. It wasn't too clear how those in Queen Anne's time felt, but I imaginethey were easier to bribe @@midkemian1

    • @VValkyr
      @VValkyr 3 години тому

      @@midkemian1 I mean, I am pretty sure at the beginning of the video he states that the populations of both nations were reluctant to that.

  • @HoennMaster
    @HoennMaster 3 години тому +4

    England: stop asking questions, we’re happy!

  • @GarkKahn
    @GarkKahn 3 години тому +4

    Another idea
    Why and how both halfs of ireland got divided

    • @martinmorles1
      @martinmorles1 3 години тому +1

      The English confiscated the lands of Irish Catholics and gave them to English Protestants in an attempt to establish a firm grip on Ireland.
      Which resulted in a pro British community establishing in the north who opposed independence

    • @joedh23
      @joedh23 3 години тому +3

      Already done I think

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland 3 години тому +3

      Pretty simple Scottish colonists

    • @Neutralino
      @Neutralino 3 години тому +2

      @@martinmorles1 Most of the Protestant ancestry in the North is Scottish, not English. Hence the existence of the Ulster Scots dialect.

  • @ColumbidaeKing
    @ColumbidaeKing 4 години тому +4

    Always wondered lol

  • @sciencefliestothemoon2305
    @sciencefliestothemoon2305 3 години тому +3

    Damn that was one of the worst places to start a colony.

    • @RoyalRegimentofScotland
      @RoyalRegimentofScotland 3 години тому +1

      It's pretty funny how stupid the sceme was. Little Scotland practically decided to declare war on the Spanish empire 😂

    • @segiraldovi
      @segiraldovi 2 години тому

      Let's see, it's not a bad idea if you take into account that it was the location of the Panama Canal. The problem is that you didn't have the technology or tens of thousands of slaves to finish it in a reasonable way. It also wasn't a great idea to do it when Spain was not yet the dead body that it was during the 19th and 20th centuries.

    • @sciencefliestothemoon2305
      @sciencefliestothemoon2305 2 години тому

      @@segiraldovi the Panama canal failed the first because of yellow fever and malaria. Only after the role of the mosquito as a disease vector was realized were they able to actually build it.
      Malaria has a 20% mortality rate and yellow fever up to 50%. That's some attrition for the workforce

    • @roguishpaladin
      @roguishpaladin Годину тому

      @@sciencefliestothemoon2305 This is a solid case of "hindsight is 20/20". Without knowing about the disease-ridden nature of the area, the Spanish would seem to be the only real opposition to the Scottish (not getting into the morals of colonization here) and maybe they thought their fellow Catholics would give them a break to spit in England's face.

  • @Red_Planet
    @Red_Planet 3 години тому +36

    They united because it’s part of England’s mission tree and England had admin tech 10 by it, not to mention Great Britain’s ideas are so much more better than England’s. Not to mention Scotland likes to go wild with colonization, it disrupts good borders when they make a new colonial nation in North America and the “Stop subject from colonizing” button doesn’t work.

    • @ItsGroundhogDay
      @ItsGroundhogDay 3 години тому

      Here I was expecting them to be done in the 1400s.

    • @segiraldovi
      @segiraldovi 2 години тому +2

      I will never understand why Paradox would never implement a system where:
      1) My PU does not make colonies where one of my colonies already exists
      2) I could tell them where to colonize (with Spain it would be excellent)
      3) Peacefully join 2 colonies in the same region if I am the owner of the PU

    • @andreamarino6010
      @andreamarino6010 2 години тому +1

      ​@@segiraldovido i need to remind you that paradox locked behind a paywall the feauture to transfer occupied land during wars? (Till some months ago, so 11 years)

    • @nicolad8822
      @nicolad8822 2 години тому +1

      Translation?

    • @segiraldovi
      @segiraldovi 2 години тому

      @@nicolad8822 Europa Universalis 4 stuff

  • @КГБКолДжорджКостанца
    @КГБКолДжорджКостанца 4 години тому +1

    Ahh my daily dose of great history slop

  • @CampbellWolfe
    @CampbellWolfe Годину тому

    Oh a really interesting tid bit - the English did actually send supplies and such to the colony in Darien, and they arrived two weeks too late. The colony held out against all odds for two years and in its last hours was so close to recieve support it didn't know was coming but the colonists had bailed by the time it arrived, and only just.
    Source: Read 'The Man Who Saw The Future' a book about William Paterson who was the schemes founder. (He also founded the Bank of England) Also, the colony was new Caledonia, not New Edinburgh.

  • @kodieight
    @kodieight 3 години тому +2

    Why ? Because two small countries on a tiny island makes sense . Simple.

  • @magnushultgrenhtc
    @magnushultgrenhtc 3 години тому +16

    "The anti-British sentiment in Scotland didn't last too long." *Looks at watch, day-planner, calendar, decade counter, century measure*... Yup. Checks out.

    • @bebedor_de_cafe3272
      @bebedor_de_cafe3272 3 години тому +2

      Scots may bash on England, but still vote to remain in Britain and will get offended if you say something bad about the people in the UK

  • @fugchugson
    @fugchugson Годину тому

    And the reason the Darien colony was so expensive was because it was in the Darien Gap, one of the most inhospitable places for humans on Earth.

  • @flangeclamp4239
    @flangeclamp4239 2 години тому +1

    Do the Northern Ireland bit! Do the Northern Ireland bit! The Uni-Ted Klingerdom Ov Brate Gritain And Norvern Ireluhnd!

  • @Yabuturtle
    @Yabuturtle 3 години тому +1

    It always seems like the main reason why any country does anything is that it is convenient or cost effective. xD

  • @igncom1
    @igncom1 Годину тому +1

    Britain/England bribing it's problems away is a common tactic of ours.

  • @pabcu2507
    @pabcu2507 4 години тому +1

    James bissonette promised them both funding if they united

  • @8thFurno
    @8thFurno 4 години тому +3

    Wales: 😢

  • @solidjb
    @solidjb Годину тому

    Fun fact, despite being beheaded in this episode Charles the 1st, he still supported this video!

  • @joeylawn36111
    @joeylawn36111 Годину тому

    Another thing that may have helped is that Queen Anne had no offspring that survived her pregnancies/infancy. An heir may have complicated things.

  • @MariaMartinez-researcher
    @MariaMartinez-researcher 3 години тому +1

    It was remarkable that part of King Charles III coronation's duties included telling the Scottish he promised to respect their church and laws.

    • @jeremywilliams5107
      @jeremywilliams5107 Годину тому

      Personal union = geographical schizophrenia 😅

    • @DaDARKPass
      @DaDARKPass Годину тому

      @@jeremywilliams5107 its not a personal union - the UK is one kingdom, not 2 or 3 or 4

    • @jeremywilliams5107
      @jeremywilliams5107 Годину тому

      @@DaDARKPass it was in the time of Charles II

    • @DaDARKPass
      @DaDARKPass Годину тому +1

      @@jeremywilliams5107 the commenter said charles III

  • @15oClock
    @15oClock 3 години тому

    Here I thought the story ended where it began, but thus is the folly of only reading the first chapter.