Julia Hartley-Brewer slams Church for failing to define what a woman is
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 лип 2022
- The Church of England has come out saying there is ‘no official definition’ of a woman.
The comments have provoked criticism, with England's first woman priest saying she is 'not totally happy' with the Bishop in Europe's answer.
It comes as a tax expert who lost out on a job after claiming people cannot change their biological sex has won three claims in a fresh employment tribunal following an appeal.
Maya Forstater’s contract at the Centre for Global Development (CGD) was not renewed in March 2019 after she said biological sex could not be changed.
The tribunal heard she posted “inflammatory and objectionable” tweets over transgender people and opposed Government proposals to reform the Gender Recognition Act to allow people to identify as the opposite sex.
But in a judgment handed down on Wednesday, employment judge Andrew Glennie said the “complaints of direct discrimination because of belief are well founded” over the decision to not offer Ms Forstater a contract or renew a fellowship following her tweets.
Judge Glennie added that her complaint that she was victimised after being removed from a company website was also “well founded”.#talktv #talkradio
Can you define what a women is?
🔸Julia Hartley Brewer asks Labour MP: 'Can a woman have a penis?' ► ua-cam.com/video/SSC8-CwMCuM/v-deo.html
🔸Julia Hartley Brewer's furious response to being called a CIS-woman ► ua-cam.com/video/VQHiOuTv5qM/v-deo.html
🔸Julia Hartley Brewer exasperated by trans-rights 'madness' ► ua-cam.com/video/NVPUnRzOF5U/v-deo.html
Adult human female. Quite simple.
It's sad that people still believe in gods. It doesn't say much for human intelligence.
Adult human female
AMAZING --- one religion kowtowing to another religion.
@@agi1041 its sad to think that people believe that this beautiful earth and all the thousands of species happened by chance
Hard to believe that we have to go to court to defend what up until recently was agreed by everyone.
Exactly… it’s like yesterday’s medical facts is today’s hate speech.
Actually it's what anyone with a scintilla of reason accepts. Chromosomes aren't negotiable.
Let's not let facts get in the way of ideology.
There are three genders, Male, Female and DELUSIONAL.
As just a bloke, a husband and a dad of girls, I regard Maya as an absolute hero.
As a woman, a wife and a mum I applaud her 👏👏👏
As a human being with a logical mind I also applaud her.
Another femofacist that opened the floodgates to all this nonsense. Working for a quango that we pay for.
Thank God for ladies like Maya and Julia.
She was so calm; what a legend
When someone plays the role of a character in a film, they DO NOT become that person... The same is true if someone dresses like a woman.
Biology is real
And there are biological differences in trans people’s brains suggesting that biology supports the fact that trans women identify as women.
When someone plays the role of a character they are acting, so it makes no sense that people are reserving roles for trans/gay people to play trans/gay characters. It's not acting if you are playing yourself 🤣
Biology is real would make a great teashirt.
Well they are playing to themselves because just like actors they are in la la land.
If I could like a comment 1 million times I would for this one!
Adult human female. Quite simple.
Right and they want to say that sex and gender are separate, that gender is a social construct. Well hate to break it to them but female is right in the definition of a women. So it looks like the two are not separate at all.
And so what makes someone female?
@Good Day
dictionary definition for you
adjective
of or denoting the sex that can bear offspring or produce eggs, distinguished biologically by the production of gametes (ova) which can be fertilized by male gametes.
SOOO... Someone born with female reproductive sex organs are female...pretty simple really. NOT a male WANTING to be...
@@Hollyisthedog So then is a transgender man - (Chaz Bono for example) someone who was born female yet can no longer bear offspring, a man or a woman?
@@goodday512 you answered this yourself... Born female.
I fear soon doctors won't be able to tell the parents the sex of their unborn child for fear of being descriminative. How on earth did we get to the stage where a tiny minority of spiteful hateful people, are able to dictate to the majority like this. There's something else going on here. I believe there's a reason why the establishment has decided to give these people this power and control and its nothing to do with trans rights.
I agree pokie. Can't fathom it out though. Batshit 🤪 crazy.
The sex of an unborn child is not given per se in various hospital areas due to the first born not being a male.
pokie you asked how we got to this position ? -I personally believe that political groups have been secretly shifting people of their own persuasion into positions of power for many years now. It is the only answer. Many issues especially relating to child education would have been greeted with disgust not long ago.
@@garypautard1069
This attack on gender, morality and the traditional family unit is straight out of the marxist instruction manual.
Yes, something is going on. Transhumanism and men still in dominant leadership that see it as a grand opportunity to finally get back at women for putting on pants and taking over men only spaces…
The Scriptures are very clear and makes a clear distinction between a man and woman. The “church” may bow to woke ideology but the Scriptures don’t .
Yes you know it makes sense ,in a senseless world
The church of England was founded so Henry could have his end away. The lesson is this the powers that be can and will change history to suit their whims.
Psalms 82:3 is woke.
@@martynblackburn9632
Thank you for taking the time to respond to my post . Firstly, the whole premise of being “woke” is to be informed of something previously unknown or suppressed . Since the God of Scripture is all-known , then that eliminates the possibility of applying any of form of “woke” to Scripture .
Secondly, Psalm 82:3 is a plea to God for justice not man. The very last verse calls for God to to judge the earth.
Wokeism will not work because the human heart is sinful . Man is trying to change the outside when it is the heart that needs change . Change the heart and you will change the man.
Maya is a wonderful woman. I’m so grateful to her.
Church doesn't even know who Christ is let alone a woman. 🙏🏻
I honestly think there is a virus in the air that's sending these people off their rocker , how can any normal person take th seriously
Well said
Fact.. There's no record that Jesus was ever born... Tony cuenca
@@craphead9842 how do you know that
@@craphead9842 Surely it would be on record at the DHSS? The point is that record-keeping wasn't exactly an art back in the day.
A victory for common sense. Well done. And two fingers up to these nutters that can't comprehend that there are ONLY males and females. End of.
You've missed the point.
@@goodday512 Translation: they by-passed the bullshit.
Funny that primary age children can tell boys from girls BUT some grown up adults can't
Yes, the established “church” in this country is pandering to social whims rather than following biblical teaching and the historical results from such social whims.
Ezekiel 23:20 🙌🙌🙌
the local churches near me couldent get their BLM matters posters up quick enough a year or so ago, just re-enforced my critical view on the church. where is their stand on murdering babies? no-where. love this woman who stands for the plain and simple truth. good on her.
Thus rendering themselves even less relevant than they previously were.
Archbishop of Canterbury leading the way!
@@jettyharrison4377 Thank goodness !
The bloody world has gone mad!!.
People like her now need to sue employers in the most painful way, in order to stop this nonsense.
Julia's my kind of Woman, 100% Female, no imitations will ever be accepted
Female and woke.
@@martynblackburn9632 yes, she is.
@@martynblackburn9632 a woke conservative??
@@ironknobsteelworks4063 Yes a woke conservative. Woke isn't the sole domain of liberals or progressives. It stretches right across the spectrum.
@@martynblackburn9632 why is she woke then?
Well said, great programme. It's a pity the church lacks the courage of your brave guest.Riveting.
Why does someone putting on a black face and imitating a member of the black community cause such a storm while some guy dressing as a woman is somehow applauded. Weird. My wife, late mother and all my sister's know they ARE women.
sisters. Why do people put an apostrophe in a plural?
@@agi1041 are you familiar with autocorrect, learning difficulties and also the fact this is the internet, not an English exam?
Being transracial is way less radical then being transgender
I gave up on the CoE when Welby allowed all his churches to be closed during the Covid hysteria, the very time the people needed help!
All of the churches and fellowships closed John, all cowards, and the pastors taking that jab. One pastor said the vaccine was a gift from God. Shameful!!
As a believer in Jesus Christ im so sorry for the Church of England and it’s woeful existence
Maybe we should start a petition to have it disbanded as a failed and dangerous organisation.
Never mind you will soon be able to go to your local mosque.
Considering it was founded so Henry the 8th could have his end away means it was never legit to begin with.
Just a quote for you to use in future:
There is a BIG difference between following Jesus of Nazareth and the political/nationalistic movement that is often called Christianity.
@@hencesmidt668 No religions are legit, every single one of them is about one lot of people controlling the masses. Look at the translation of "islam": submission. That tells you everything you need to know about such a vile ideology and the rest aren't much better.
There is a BIG difference between following Jesus of Nazareth and the political/nationalistic movement that is often called Christianity.
men are men and women are women simple as that end of well done that lady for being brave
Harriet Harman says the next Leader of the Labour Party must be a woman but as no senior Labour politician can say what a woman is how will they know if they have elected one?
Brilliant response
Harriet Harman - the n0nce enabler
The archbishop doesn't have a Christian bone in his body
Genesis 1:27: “So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them.”
Created Adam, Adam comes from the word awdawm, = man who can show blood in his face, he blushed when he realised he was naked, when he became conscious and left the animal world, before we were called white we were known as awdawm
Ezekiel 23:20 🙏
Duck.. What about language 6000 different languages.. Logic would say impossible... Tony cuenca
I wish Adam had kept all his ribs inside his body.
It does what it says in scripture and of Male and female he created us in his image God has masculine and feminine attributes the whole of creation is the same
MAYA WE'RE WITH YOU 10000FOLD MY OUR SISTER BLESS YOU
It seems Welby and co are doing their very best to bring the church to its knees.
Almost as if there is some "profit" in an end game where no church exists
Not into conspiracy theories, but ......
Save tax payers a lot of money if religion stopped getting big tax breaks we need a secular state.
be careful, which religion isn't taking prisoners and whose fighters are pouring across the english channel. you do know that boris johnson is from a turkish muslim family.
This has gone beyond allowing personal choice to forcing ideological political views on others.
One cannot continue to remain silent and hope it goes away.
What can be peacefully done to stop this?
Stop people voting for left-wing political parties.
Nothing!
So the Church can not define what a "woman" is, a real living human right in front of them BUT can define a MAKE BELIEVE GOD no one has ever seen and have no proof just blind faith, WOW.
Spot on, makes no sense
I have my doubts the Church of England would be willing to even do that
Wasn’t long ago the church didn’t want to ordain women, so they know who they are, but no longer want to admit it 🤷♂️
@@jettyharrison4377 you're blowing my mind with this new scientific information!
All religions are retarded
What about the Judge James Tayler, who said the view that there are only two sexes is not worthy of respect in a civilised society.
How do people like this become judges?
Judge Taylor thinks that his position gives him the right to judge views, as well as points of law. Sort of like Trudeau and his comment about "acceptable views". No one, including judges and Prime Ministers, has the right to force their "acceptable views" on others.
There is man and woman. You cannot deny biological fact. Those who deny this, need to understand the perfect right of this deduction.
They need sectioning!
no-one is denying there are two sexes. The question is how do you distinguish between the two.
Phobia is Fear Hatred and Disagreement is not phobia they need to stop saying transphobic.
@@goodday512 pee pee or vaj vaj simple
One can deny facts of nature, however that makes that person delusional. Gender dysmorphia is a delusional disorder.
AMAZING --- one religion kowtowing to another religion.
If the church is unable to define what is a woman or womanhood that means it's time for me to leave the church.
The Church of England stands for nothing.
It is a written fact in the Jewish and Christian book from over 5000 years ago...
When they shut their doors and advocated for satanic muzzles, anti social distancing and experimental gene jabs was the time to leave.
Biological reality trumps feelings every time.
Evolution.
Considering the church knew what a woman was when they burnt/drowned them I find this rather surprising
The C of E are going too woke for my liking! I’m afraid they’re going to loose so many parishioners if they carry on like this. 😕 oh dear! Penny Mordaunt has just gone down in my estimation!
JB... England is COE anything else isn't Christian... I might be wrong.. Tony cuenca
Penny Mordaunt has confirmed that she now knows what a woman is.
@@jeremyboughtono2 no she hasn't, she believes men with a gender recognition certificate are also women.
@@apebass2215 I wouldnt vote for any of them anyway.
ISAIAH 5:20
Woe to those who call evil good, and good evil; Who put darkness for light, and light for darkness; Who put bitter for sweet, and sweet for bitter!
If any organisation should be able to define a woman surely it is the Church.
Someone said they didn't have trouble recognising a woman when they were burning them at the stake!!
Just because you fit a Rolls Royce grill to the front of a Toyota, doesn't make it a Rolls Royce.
What do these so called men who spout this absolute nonsense call their wives? I have 5 sisters and if I called them anything other than a woman, I would certainly be put in my place.🏴🇬🇧
And the church wonders why it’s becoming less and less relevant in todays times!
Scientific discoveries and less power
The Church of England doesn't know how to define what a woman is? Interesting. Could they, say, define what a Bishop is? And can anyone decide to identify as a Bishop? Would he/she then have a right to function ecclesiastically as a Bishop, and to access private spaces reserved for Bishops, etc?
They were keen to have women as bishops, so must have known which ones were women!
I stand by this woman because I want to protect women from this dangerous madness.
Can’t transitioning also be female into male ? In which case. It works both ways. They can’t define what a man is either.
It really doesn't affect men in the same way. A woman "transitioning" into a "man" poses less of a threat to men.
World is full of nutcases!
Men are men, women are women but I have no idea what that Welby man is, HE is something else.
As Professòr Winston said our DNA is in every cell of our body.
So men in frocks can't define what a woman is 🤔
PS. Were Muslim clerics asked this question? Im sure they would have a better answer
"Give me just one generation of youth, and I’ll transform the whole world."
"Give me four years to teach the children and the seed I have sown will never be uprooted."
"Destroy the family, you destroy the country. The way to crush the bourgeoisie is to grind them between the millstones of taxation and inflation."
..Vladimir Ilyich Lenin
You can’t blame all this stuff on Lenin. As for the family aspect, it’s the family who are taking their kids to the Dr to get hormones and stuff to give to the kids so how is that destroying the family when they are all acting as one together? Sex changes have been around for more than one generation.
@@jujutrini8412 Because they went to school/uni and got conditioned/pressured to accept that as the norm, by teachers who had adopted the cultural marxism.
Those uni degree students then got adopted in the workplace into HR departments.
@@jujutrini8412 Same sex couples cant have kids, other than by state run adoption or corporate enterprise.
@@RuneRelic Nonsense. Julia Hartley Brewer went to university. I went to university. We have different opinions on some things and agreement on others. I went to university with people who vote Tory, Labour, Libdem and Green!
@@jujutrini8412 Then perhaps you should educate yourself on the material and organisation involved in our education system now, or simply see the results of cancel culture in those universities.
I cant fix ignorance.
"At it's heart wokeness is devisive, exclusionary and hateful. It basically gives mean people a shield to be mean and cruel, armoured in false virtue."
Elon Musk.
Thank you for stepping up and setting an example for all to follow, helping to take some of the fear away for just being a woman and saying so. This world Has a long way to go but we are headed in the right direction. You are recognized and admired by woman of Canada 🇨🇦
Now you know why most people don't go to church 😃
It's a made up religion from the middle east?
I’m a Transgendered Woman who has gone through all the procedures and I have lived as a woman for a number of years! However I am a man and will always be a man, like it or lump it that is the end of the matter no ifs no buts!
Of course you are
If you know you're a man, stop calling yourself a woman. You've never 'lived as a woman' because you're NOT one.
@@crumblyduckling403 How much does ole Kelz and the Westbro Baptist lot pay to spout the same drivel over and over?
And you wonder why the CoE is dying on it's feet, the Church should stick to preaching religion and shut up on politics, Amen
"what is a woman?" is the defining question of our millennium.
As Maya says Penny Mordaunt had difficulty defining what a woman was and has changed her tune. I would not believe her therefore on any of her policy. Changing opinions according to the way the wind blows is not something I would vote for. She lost my vote sometime ago. Would not trust her. Woman - adult human female. No male can become a woman! Biological sex is a fact and truth is very important.
Then you wonder why the flock is so low low 🤷🏻♂️
Unbelievable 🤬
What a crazy crazy world we are living in
CAN YOU ADAM AND EVE IT !!
Does the CofE actually follow or upholds God's word and his standards anymore?
It never has.
It was ceated for Henry the 8th to have a divorce.
The short answer is no. Tragic.
@@jameswhite7997 Do they think donkeys talk?
Much like your James Max. Even after he was humiliatingly owned by Kellie jay Keen on his own show. No matter how many biological and scientific facts she nuked him with. The man remained deluded in his own little la la land. Putting forward his pseudo argument. A argument he himself would have thought completely absurd until a few years ago. But now like the church, kier Starmer and numerous others in public life. He has succumbed to ideological indoctrination. Making him and the others a very dangerous people. For woman and especially children.
This world has gone nuts .
How dare the government/church or anyone else if it comes to that, try to stop/ impede on our human rights to be able to state/ say something that is factually true !! 😡 I really do despair .. what is this country coming to ??? 😞
I wish people would stop saying what the world is coming to its only western society who are messed up.
@@samuelhutchison8433 only a turn of phase, didnt think writing it would have offended anybody. It still dosnt change the fact that this shouldn't be happening thats my point.
Is anyone surprised the church can't define a woman, I don't think the church could define Jesus or God anymore.
It just goes to show where we are as a species for even discussing this.
C/E what a Crap.'Lost the Plot' organisation.
You wonder how these people get into these positions, with the lack of basic knowledge.
Even a bloody six year old would know.
Crap ain't they!! 😡
"So God created Man in his image, in the image of God He created him; male and female He created them".
Genesis 1, 27. Can someone forward this to the Church of England?
The Church of England can no longer accept the word of God, if he is unable to define word woman, even though he designed the first one on Earth. God replied: I never thought I would have to define the word woman, as it is so bleeding obvious once a month in a woman!
He didn't design the first woman on earth.
It's a made up book from the middle east.
@@andrewoliver8930 I know, it's a joke.
@@andrewoliver8930 Yes, but the CofE is a religion based on a 'holy' book that they are supposed to believe in as God's word. Whether you or I believe or not is irrelevant.
God made Man in his likeness and made him a companion a Woman if the church cannot hold true to this then they should get a proper job like the rest of us, what a bunch of cheats
Does it matter what the church says these days? More bishops and vicars than congregations! Churches closing around the country but bishops still live in palaces and sit in the House of Lords! They have little authority in this century apart from Africa .
Fair play to you, you female woman, good on you.
its a shame she keeps referring to her position as 'beliefs'. the statement that men can not become women is not a belief. lets not muddy the waters with the trans issue by saying to the ideologists 'you have your beliefs and i have mine'. lets be clearer than that. they have their beliefs and we have basic facts/reality/truth
"Reality is that which is still there even after you stop believing in it."
Unfortunately, that was the only way that Maya could win her case. I agree it's not ideal. She only stated facts.
Men get a grc in recognition of a preferred gender...and that certificate can be lawfully removed ....being a woman doesn't come with a certificate it can't be given it can't be removed...fact..
What happened to common sense? When did the lunatics take over the asylum?
It's an organisation that thinks donkeys can talk.
Would it make any difference if we asked What is a Man?
Julia is unbelievable best presenter by far
For all these people that believe about inclusiveness, they can't understand basic biology, and have no idea about human beings at all,they need to go to school or just shut up altogether.its tedious and pathetic. Their own mental state is down to them,but pushing their incredibly misguided ideas on a population that knows the difference is stupid at best and very telling that they should look at themselves and get a bloody grip.
Good result for this lady, good news for freedom of speech and expression.😊👍❤️😊👍
And then God made Woman.....but we can't actually say what a Woman is?, the C of E emptying Churches like a Boss!
Thankyou Maya & Julia, for helping undoing this back to front IDEOLOGY. I'm so glad you're on the right side of History ❤
What a time to be alive, there is a good chance a future Labour Prime Minister will not know what a woman is 😳
I'm glad this woman won her case. This nonsense is getting way beyond a joke, it's dangerous and absolutely ridiculous.
The answer is simple. Most babies have a clearly defined genders at conception. Male or female a tiny minority have both male and female genitals these are known as hermaphrodite. Female have female genitalia and males have male genitals. However some people who have gender dysphoria feel they are in the wrong body. I believe in the scientific facts. Children who experience gender confusion, usually resolve such feelings after they have gone through puberty. Only a small minority require medical support. Research has proven the majority of children and young people who go through the process of gender reassignment want the process reversed.
Research hasn’t proven most want the process reversed
If maybe the church had a book that was thousands of years old they could follow that explained it all, it should be all fine
I still want to know the Political Reasons behind this Trans Ideology. Things like this are possibly to make us into robots because we dont know who we are any more. Governments just Love Robots
This is scary stuff.
They believe in talking donkeys.
I refuse to be lectured about gender by a churchman who is wearing a dress.
Penny Mordaunt has made herself unelectable with her weasel words.
The CofE is the CofWoke.
What a sad mixed up world we live in.🤪
what do you expect they cant tell the difference between a child and an adult either.
We need Bill Hicks to be 'raised from the dead' for his searing humour on this topic.
Ask them to define a man
Might be easier
If it wasn't for those men and women we wouldn't be having this pathetic argument!! Like it or not!
I’ve never had a problem with anyone trans. However the more this kind of behaviour goes on the more I’m beginning to have a problem.
If someone wants me to accept them for whomever they are, they need to accept me for who I am.
Thought the story of Adam and Eve would easily sum things up
Women are made from male ribs?
It is time to steer clear of any polition who can not answer a simple question such as, "What is a woman".
Still can't understand why this extremely minority subject, is given so much air time. For goodness sake, I for one am sick to death hearing about trans gender issues in the media. An issue most unlikely to affect 99% of peoples lives. Just let trans people get on with what they want to do QUIETLY !!!
Very bad idea to not pay attention to "gender ideology". Ignoring a cancer won't make it go away. It will keep on growing and spreading until it destroys your whole body. This "gender ideology" nonsense affects ALL of us - especially our children. We must nip it in the bud.
Well done that women speaking common sense and standing up for your views