Every time Julia Hartley-Brewer asked her guests to define a woman
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 січ 2023
- A compilation of all the occasions in which TalkTV's Julia Hartley-Brewer challenged her guests to define what a woman is, including an interview with a future Prime Minister.
#talktv
How do you define what a woman is?
Adult human female
I think the Prime Minister put it very well, and I agree with everything he says
XX Chromosomes
A vagina from birth
@@NPC--666 You need to go one step further and define what a female is.
Female - of or denoting the sex that can bear offspring or produce eggs, distinguished biologically by the production of gametes (ova) that can be fertilized by male gametes.
The fact we are even having a conversation like this just shows how far down the rabbit hole we have gone.
It shows how Marxists have taken over, they now use race and gender to usher in their Red Revolution. Notice a key part of their ideology is being the enemy of capitalism.
The sad thing is real issues aren't being addressed such as crime, poverty, housing, pensions and NHS waiting times because MPs are far too busy being politically correct.
@@Aerojet01 society is doomed
a thick blonde mp .... trans is short for transvestite
@@Aerojet01 It's not a worry about being "politically correct", those politicians who do "worry" are the ones putting-through the policies that vilify and single-out trans/gay/black/whatever other minority in the first place.
They're not "worried" about sodding "cancel-culture", they're using it as a cover while they fuck the country for the people to benefit Capitalists. Stop trying to excuse fascists, who are literally killing thousands of us, just for an excuse to hate 'the woke'.
I'm 64 and I never thought I would see the day when politicians struggle with the question can a woman have a penis god help us all
I loved that the Labour woman said we should use language in a way everyone understands and then spoke complete and utter gibberish!
Mad hatter's tea party.
Classic labour doubledygook
Sorry if the chancellor does not trust himself to give an answer to a simple question, how can we trust him to run the finances of the country.
Errr - he is P.M. now, and when he WAS Chancellor he could NOT run the finances of the Country.
Oh Rishi....how are you going to deal with Putin if you cant even have the balls to speak basic science........
He couldn't run anything and he still can't. He can rob us blind, as well as he can lie.
"The vast majority of people who get ovarian cancer are women." I thought Monty Python stopped writing comedy years ago.
Lol ..I know....its priceless...these people are beyond belief..
How did a small group of delusional people gain so much power as to dictate what our rulers can say? I'm genuinely impressed. Disgusted, terrified, enraged, but also impressed.
It is indeed incredible that a tiny amount of people has put the entire country through this rubbish
I am more terrified seeing how easy it was to make people believe a delusion, and even promote their own children for this hideous destruction.
Because we all let them. It is time to stand up to the idiots.
Every single public service has been infected by this ideology. It’s easier to bully women than men.
Well done Julia! I love it when she asks that question, one to see Politicians squirm and stutter, at such a simple question and also to see those who can't define one so I know not to vote for them.
julia should put her hand on the private part of a man who thinks they are a woman, on her show!! it should cause a stir!
@PanPan She said, 'a woman is an adult human female.'
the worst thing in the world for a woman is her doctor sitting her down and telling her she has testicular cancer 🤣🤣🤣🙈🙊
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Epic one😆😆😆😆
or her sperm count is low
"A trans woman is NOT a woman but let's all pretend they are just to keep them happy and deluded" seems to be the hidden message
A trans woman is a woman if woman pertains to gender. It's not pretend. The irrationality of a thing is no argument against its existence.
@@martynblackburn9632 it's the transgenders who are denying the reality of their god given bodies.
@@martynblackburn9632 would a trans woman be a woman on a desert Island without hormones or surgery?
@@martynblackburn9632 what makes a “transwoman” a woman?
@@lucacolombo7603 Yes, but only by gender identity, not by biological sex.
Keep it up Julia, I can't believe that I'm living in this madness 👏👏👏
I’m quite an old man and fully equipped, but I self identify as a beautiful twenty year old woman with big boobs. I’m expecting a call from Hollywood very soon.
And why not, you got it all- including the illusions. 😂
Old Man .........Prince Andrews looking for a new bride since Harry stole his last bit on the side.
@@geoffdundee. He’s too fake for me.
@@oldman1734 .........hes now skint too of course....better to aim higher LOL .......how about bill clinton?
Brilliant 😂
Julia is awesome.
And spent a lot of time calling people covidiots a couple of years ago.
Dixie Anderson she said Rishi Sunak did not answer the question correctly
but he was asked "WHAT IS A WOMAN" by Piers Morgan, he said an adult human female
she needs to do better research
If they can't answer a simple question they should not be in government .
Julia's question is clearly designed to "gotcha" the politician by getting him to respond only from a biological definition. If I were a politician I would refuse to answer Julia as well.
Why is it so hard to answer the biological definition.
Surely that’s why are they perfect to be in government. As no politician can answer a simple question.
@MGame It's not that simple for politicians. It would certainly be easier for a biologist, but not a politician.
@MGame That's not what I meant, but okay. So politicians have to be wary of saying certain things in interviews, on camera. They are PR people. They cannot come across as uncaring or out-of-touch, though many fail at this. But still, they have to be careful not to come across like they are margilising others. The biological question can easily be spun into a gotcha and the politicians can be made to look uncaring, and so politicians think it's much easier just to say nothing or act like they don't know.
It's like watching adults trying to answer "Is Santa Claus real?" in front of their 4 year old kid.
Exactly. Pathetic
I find this hilarious ....then these politicians want to run a country..
Julia you are fantastic…thankyou!
Sunak obviously does not identify as Man with a backbone.
He just blocked the Scottish gender self-ID bill
After billions of years of evolution our species can look far into the universe & ponder the great mysteries held within it........but we cannot define what a woman is!
Just some of us, the rest are sound.
Thank you Julia Hartley-Brewer
hey, it gets better....the new Supreme Court Justice said that she couldn't say what a woman was....because she wasn't a biologist. One commenter gave a brilliant answer...she said that she wasn't a veterinarian, but she knew what a dog was.
Kellie-Jay Keen was the commenter.
@@lexiburrows8127 THANK YOU! (Imterrible with names.) All the best to you and yours!!
@@lexiburrows8127 she said that to a spectator at a swimming competition in the USA as well🤣
At this rate very soon there will be "no women" left in the world.
Ridiculous hyperbole.
That's the idea.
@@martynblackburn9632 Do you deliberately miss the point or are you genuinely this obtuse?
Thanks Julia ❤️
Julia did a great job teaching Sunak what a woman is. :-)
In the Film "Kindergarten Cop" a small boy, the son of a Gynaecologist informs Arnie that Little boys have a Penis and Little girls have a vagina, for which Arnie thanks him for the information. Surprising really that the idiots haven't yet demanded the line be removed from the film .( You're Gonna be whatever you wanna be)
The first Nazi book burning was in 1933. The German Student Union made an organised attack on Magnus Hirschfeld's Institut für Sexualwissenschaft (roughly: Institute of Sex Research). Its library and archives of around 20,000 books and journals were publicly hauled out and burned in the street. Its collection included unique works on intersexuality, homosexuality, and transgender topics
Watched that again a few weeks back.
That kid's probably gonna get cancelled now
It's all about WOKE culture. Being more concerned about feelings, than facts.
Sorry you feel that way.
nope. its about marxism. confuse and divide. create a perpetual left voting base. there's a reason trotsky himself called them useful idiots. feed them pretty sounding lies and they will do the heavy lifting for you. did you ever see a socialist official who was living the life they force on the populus?
Nobody listens to facts anymore.
@@mattygroves21478 Don't be, I'm not.
@@topquark6919 I believe your feelings
I'm too scared of losing my job and being set upon to answer that question. Leaders indeed!
Well Julia is certainly a gorgeous woman!
And if I want to be White, can I choose it to be so? From Black South African.
Wanting to be white would automatically make you a white supremacist so I advise cautious wishing. ^^
Only if the woke allows it be so.
Doreen Musson ........you will loose your privilege card if you identify as white
Of course you can Doreen. Just say you are and that will make it true😀
Don't you just loathe politicians?!
I despair of these ridiculous people who cannot answer a simple question!
LEGEND STATUS, TWO WOMEN. Julia Hartley-Brewer and Naomi Cunninham. Next up, Wishy wash SUNAK. Can't answer the simplest question. More alarming, SUNAK does not even have the intelligence to 'swerve' the question. How can we possibly have a leader that acts like a clone of HANCOCK. Add WES STREETING TO THE LEGEND LIST. Well done WES, for being so straight forward and honest...
Thank heavens for Julia.
Could you imagine watching and trying to fathom this video just three years ago?
What an insane society we live in.
Oh Rishi....how are you going to deal with Putin if you cant even have the balls to speak basic science........
You’ve got to love Julia. That was funny.
Great entertainment. Thank you, Julia.
Well done Wes
Shows what a wet week of a PM we have in Sunak, and our so called political elite.
He just blocked the Scottish gender self-ID bill
Bravo Julia. One of the rare interviewers who actually expects an answer as opposed to simply asking some vapid question and then letting the interviewee off the hook when they hem, haw, vacillate and obfuscate.
In 2023 anyone who can’t define what a woman is needs to go back to school and educate themselves at their own cost! All the surgery in the world and a bit of lipstick along with size 14high heels do not make a man a woman!
poxeh ....... i know one whos had all the surgery top and bottom and done the name change at registrars,etc.......wears flat shoes as theyve not mastered heels..........still has hands as big as shovels,swaggers and drinks pints down like a man and has a voice deeper than mine........now legally a woman
@@geoffdundee That's because the law is an ass. Creating laws to make insanity a protected characteristic is insane.
I’m female but I never wear lipstick, or dresses, I don’t like pink, I don’t do trout pout or the head tilt. Guess I must be a man!
Julia 😂😂😂 she does make me laugh
Great bit of middle-aged crumpet 😍
Why are we entertaining an illness!!!!!!!!
Why are these people so afraid of speaking the truth ? Politicians should be sworn in, and promise to be truthful before they are allowed to represent the public.
OMG - these people are SO afraid of being cancelled, they are losing their wits. No wonder this country is in the mess it is. Those leading, and those giving them advice, are all falling over themselves to be cutting edge in the new ideas, everything-to-all stakes. Good grief! I could do a far better job of running this country than any of them. So could you, Julia.
she said Rishi Sunak avoided the question, but he been asked the question by Piers Morgan and he had correctly saying adult human, that is well known
julia is a real woman with brains
A civilisation that cannot answer a simple question like this does have long to live
The fact that we are having discussions like this just demonstrates how great our lives are in our country. You wont find this nonsense in societies where there are real life struggles. Go to the poorest nations in the world and tell them you want to discuss Gender identification.
Bingo. I doubt many men are identifying as women in Iran right now either.
In the last days of Rome, the last Caesar married a man .
@@BanjoPixelSnack In iran? There's forced surgery for gay people there...
lets all play pretend until reality hits us full in the face😂😂😂
It's all to do with compliance if you refuse to tell truth your complaint with WEF as George Orwell said
No way! Physically, they will never be the same. It's not fair. If trans people have the same rights, then they have the right to compete with born women in sports and games, and they will always have an advantage. So no! You may feel like a woman, but you never will be.
Can someone explain what “feel like a woman” is like and how is it different from “feel like a man”? How do someone knows that feeling they feel is of a woman and not of a confused man?
@@Leon-ty6bw Never understood that. How can you feel like something you have never been? All a male can do is see the superficial outside, never the inner workings. Especially when they do not possess the same biology.
@@alphonsemoonflee299 I agree. It’s just like saying I feel like a bird - it’s totally baseless nonsense.
I blame the stupid doctors who go along with these peoples delusions and give the m hormones and gender reassignment surgery! It should be beanned!
Thank God Sunak blocked the Scottish Gender law....
Ask Keir Starmer he's not to sure ,but wants to be the next PM of the UK
This is EXACTLY why I don't trust, respect or like career politicians, any of them. Sunak's preposterous 'answer' to Julia's question was intolerable. What a ridiculous bloke.
Excellent J H-B
What does he mean when he says "we should acknowledge that' ? No we most decidedly do NOT.
WELL SAID THAT WOMEN.😃👍
"Wr shall soon be in a world in which a man may be howled down for saying that two and two make four, in which furious party cries will be raised against anybody who says that cows have horns, in which people will persecute the heresy of calling a triangle a three-sided figure, and hang a man for maddening the mob with the news that grass is green. "
GK Chesterton
Prescient or what?
2+2=22
Our parents and grand parents would be turning in their graves
WOMEN (ADULT FEMALE)
MEN (ADULT MALE)
You have missed two definitions out: WOMEN (adult female, male) MEN (adult male, female).
@@martynblackburn9632 no, the comment was right in the beginning, your definitions are totally wrong.
@@hellsbells7271 My definitions are complete and inclusive. Yours is just bigotry.
@@martynblackburn9632 if I was you ide look up the definition of bigotry being as though you can't get definitions right, as in your previous comments.
Bigotry, no, talking factual and honestly, yes, there's a huge difference between the two.
When people don't have a genuine argument they always pull the bigotry, transphobic, or homophobic card.
@@hellsbells7271 Is hurdler Maria Patino a man or a woman?
Vast majority 😂 I just burst out laughing on the 136 … what strange looks I got …. They should be for the guest who said this 😂
I know this is a serious topic, but I find this to be very good comedy.
The fact that this is even a question that keeps being asked shows how far humanity will bend and finally break. Well done to all of those that endorse this madness. At one point it was follow the science and now it's throw the science of biology out the window because it doesn't fit the narrative. 😂
I could never be a politician because I actually answer questions!
As a societal question - People can identify how they want, and they can ask to be identified as they want, but that doesn't mean society at large will identify them as that. Even some Men who identify as Men won't be identified as Men by society at large.
As a biological question - the answer is very straight forward.
Can a man get cervical or ovarian cancer ?? Can a woman get prostate cancer ??
No. Of course not. Can a man identify as a woman? Yes. Yes they can. It's gender identity not biology.
What is happening when the prime minister doesn't know that there is male and female.
What are you talking about? It's clear from the responses that they ALL know there is male and female.
At last some sense! How refreshing!
Love you Julia
Hilarious!
Get me off this planet
🤣🇺🇸👍
Right behind you💛🇬🇧💛
Beam me up Scottie 🙂
What a slimeball Rishi is. While sharpening his knife to stab Boris, he also flushed down women.
Not bothered about Sunaks words - more concerned with his actions. He just blocked the Scottish gender self-ID bill
A M ...best thing hes done all year
To be fair that was good
Not all bad then, at least for a tory.
R.
Very true but....how is he going to deal with Putin if he doesn't even have the balls to speak basic science........
Wes would not try to advise Starmer. He would loose his job.
The sad thing is these people are more interested in their big salaries than telling the truth and actually protecting real women.
I cant believe I'm agreeing with Wes Streeting!
"can a woman have a penis ", is this a trick question ?
Why are people confused ?
They're not confused, just cornered by reality, and to cowardly to admit it .
Because people are advocating a biological essentialist position and either do not understand the distinction between gender identity and biological sex or they are just bigoted.
Sunak is the Prime Minister , I despair. Some of these answers are laugh able.
If you went back 10 years and was like “dude! In 2023 it’s controversial to say only women can be women and men can be men!” I would not only not believe you but I would be so confused and would have so many questions like how did it come to this?
Some of these answers are so insulting. We’re half the population! Do they not want our votes?!
Well let’s start at the beginning eve
Patch Lolly .......thats NOT the beginning..............there were males and females before Adam and Eve.
A woman is something that should have my dinner ready for when I get home, now go cook me some pie!😊
No surprise with Sunaks answer
Rishi - how guttless!
Dickless.
Is this for real?
Imagine asking Maggie that question! God rest her soul.
And they are in charge!
Even if you change sex..totally, the bits you get are not real, pretend lookalikes. Lol
They can’t change sex. They can drill a hole in his inverted pen!s, and that’s what it is, an inverted pen!s.
So they are not like born women. I always say when your body has you captive on a birthing bed, that is the time you are truly a women😁.....Delia Morris
Apparently it's the mother of the person who posed this question!!
all the important topics discussed on Talk TV
What is a man?
A human being that seems to have to constantly apologise. Not me by the way I'm very proud.
A man is an adult human male or a female who identifies as a man.
@@martynblackburn9632 no it isn't, a female cannot be a man just like a Man cannot be a woman .
@@hellsbells7271 Yes they can. Don't be a bigot. People can identify as whatever gender they like. It's not up to us.
@@stuartsimister5042 of what?
When has a politician ever told the Truth!!! NEVER!!!
Julia is really loving this. We are in this "mess" because we are at last trying to recognise the transgender and transition people. There are only a few of them, very, very few, but some people (Julia) are loving blowing it up into a big battle - it's paying her wages. God bless her cotton socks.
I'm not sure the word transition is the right word. It seems, from what I can gather, the word mutilation might be more accurate.
This is a dangerous cult.
I don't think it's Julia who has turned this into a big battle.
If it is so very very few people who are affected by this then why does the rest of the country have to adapt and bend to their wishes
If you can't define what a woman is then how could anyone want to be a woman as the word is meaningless
Women's rights are under attack. Julia is one of few speaking about it. Trans people are trans people they are not the opposite sex. They have the right to dress, have surgery, behave however they wish but they have not changed their sex. In society we should all be polite but in reality as in law it must be based on facts not subjective feelings as it impacts a whole demographic: women. This is where the mess has come from.
@@timewilltell5309 Are you really feeling as though you have to 'adapt and bend'? It has not affected my life in any way except having to hear from people who are struggling with it. It may be that word does not become meaningless but has to expand its meaning a bit every now and then. Words meanings change - inevitable.
@@Johnshaw111 I'm not personally affected by this but our society and laws are being changed to accommodate a delusional ideology that is, as you say, only a very very few people. Its the forced nature of this. I believe there are two sexes male and female. Me and 99% plus of the population believe this. People can believe what they want to and live how they want to but they have no right to force that opinion on me.
Two questions.
1. Tell me a word who's meaning has changed?
2. What is a woman?
Must admit, looking at her I never thought she'd give that answer.
Fed up with this debate. It should be taken off the agenda!
The reason we are in this mess truly is very simple - Too much tolerance!
Yr welcome.
Good job Julia xx
It’s scary that people can’t answer this question …
The reason politicians are scared to really say how they feel about trans and what a woman is is because the media will rip them apart and will have to resign. This is the sad state we are in.
Yeah, because they totally aren't in cahoots with the media.
Confused if you are talking to rishi sunak as an MP! When was this recorded and what PM are we refering to exactly.... Last I checked Sunak was prime minister of the uk