Great video!!! Although Mariah definitely has live F#5s in emotions worth showing and one that was sharp to G5, and Celine in that song had also mixed B5 in a performance!!! Great video nonetheless, I always look forward to your videos! It was a very interesting pick for Celine, kudos for that!
nailed it! sober is such a hard song to sing. btw she had 2 hours and a half of sleep that day! and she was on her period on the clip with the extra F#5
@@atolm1 She has the technique to keep singing live, she just chooses not to obviously due to her health condition. But "Tous Les Blues Sont Ecris Pour Toi" was sung live on every occasion.
For Emotions, the 1991-92 performances where she performed -1 semitone from studio is by far the most challenging version that she’s performed. The constant phrased Eb5s and E5s and some F#5s are insane.
Interesting. For Kelly, I'd have maybe chosen something like BTHE or Timeless. For Demi, not sure. She's got some very intricate climaxes in every album
@@addictedtovocals yeah :/ I think she had a pretty bad vocal injury from touring her impossible songs and never lip syncing and she never fully recovered. It so sad, *but* when she was Grizabella in Cats on Broadway she fucking MURDERED it
@@rhettmitchell she did two full 18 song tours in 2/3 different years, with her nose job done and her constant performing after falling sick from the 2012 tour, things just got worse from there.
ain’t there a G5 belt in emotions?? i think kelly would NAIL this song, that’s the only song i think would be a challenge for her because she barely uses her whistle register but she has such a good control with it, so idk
@@doctorits nah not in emotions the E3s aren't just simple and so is the g5s even tho the dynamics and the runs and whisle transitions are literally so weird ,i mean legacy is legacy she's Mariah f carey after all
Kelly is one of the best vocalists today but she cannot sing Emotions and i’m not talking about the transitions whistles parts only but as a whole. Just because you can hit some G5’s or E3’s doesn’t mean that you can nail this song, the phrassing of that song requires alot of support in those multiples upper belts with power and clear ennunciation in between runs and riffs for each ‘word’. You don’t just have to hit E3’s but sometimes doing melismas going even lower till C3 and then going up again in the same breath, I don’t even think of kelly hitting rounded E3’s without taking breaths and I’ve never heard Kelly sing a song in the same « TEMPO » as Emotions which is the most difficult part to be able to do all of that. Kelly sung ‘Love takes time’ which seems easy but we already saw the struggle, it doesn’t sound as effortless just because the support required to phrase Mariah’s notes need alot of Chest M2 coordination which is hard to achieve. Most singers will clearly change Mariah’s Original arrangement and ‘TEMPO’ even Patti labelle did so it’s not just because she is ‘Kelly Clarkson’.
YESS PUT SOME RESPECT ON LEONA'S HOMELESS!!! THAT SONG IS ONE OF THE HARDEST SONGS IN LIFE. I love her agility in the ascending melisma for when she says "anymore." Leona's agility in general is very underrated, probably because she rarely shows it off, but when she does it's impressive. Also Broken is up there too!!
all mariah’s songs are a suicide for common singers … dont you dare think you can sing her discography… you are not mariah (open arms, butterfly, someday, we belong together etc)
We need part 2! Agree for Mariah. Emotions for me is the hardest song to sing. I would choose Mariah's performance from 1991 VMA where she hits Bb7 ua-cam.com/video/BzBS7nx00Kw/v-deo.html&ab_channel=TMF-TheMusicFactory
2:42 can we just take a moment for appreciate this woman? She is so talented, her voice is a gift. However I think the hardest song to sing live for Mariah (she never sang it live bc it is VERY hard, almost impossible) is You are so cold. Obv my opinion.
Ariana’s breathin SWT(belting up to bb5, multiple g#5’s, falsettos up to c6 and ending with a sustained f5) or dangerous woman we can survive(falsetto up to e6, sustained e5 leading up to multiple g5’s and a belted a5) climax should be added tbh
All of what U mentioned were adlibs. None of those notes were in the original song so they don’t count. Except for DW because the climax is still difficult even without all the adlibs
Emotions obviously belongs on this list!!!!!! I would also say Demi Lovato's Confident Rock Version is VERY difficult, especially with the C#6 BELT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
No one has duplicated her songs. Her national anthem is still the greatest. You have to have the voice. Many have tried and failed. Mariah has always been gravely and hoarse. Whitney was crystal clear pure tone. Even AI cleans up Mariah cracking with Whitney’s voice. Any Whitney AI of Mariah has all the top notes clear and strong. Mariah always cracks when belting or trying sustain notes.
@@Kenyon712 actually there are COUNTLESS people duplicating/covering her songs. Just because they don't SOUND like her doesn't mean they did a bad job or weren't able to sing the song. Her tone was what was most special.
@@Lovebirdd Covering is different from duplicating. She had the greatest head voice. No one is duplicating that. When great singers cover her you can see his great she was. They can’t do it.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I forgot that Mariah belted G5 in 1992 and sang up to G#7💀 braindead ass me
You mean Bb7 at MTV VMA 1991?
@@airbanks5754 yeah well... the debate is open, I think she did hit Bb7 but at the same time no...
@@addictedtovocals She did a lil bit flat A7 mostly but still A7, although Mariah also did another A7 in this song in Music box tour
@@DaydreamCarey1234 Yeah the A7 is legit! She slays it!
@DaydreamCarey1234 it's a Bb7 💀
8:54 love how powerful that C#5 sounds
Great video!!! Although Mariah definitely has live F#5s in emotions worth showing and one that was sharp to G5, and Celine in that song had also mixed B5 in a performance!!! Great video nonetheless, I always look forward to your videos! It was a very interesting pick for Celine, kudos for that!
I was BRAINDEAD before finishing this video I totally forgot about the 1991/2/3 performances 😭💀
nailed it! sober is such a hard song to sing. btw she had 2 hours and a half of sleep that day! and she was on her period on the clip with the extra F#5
Celine’s power vocals are just crazy. It’s when she come on that my blood just starts pumping 🙌
and i would say demi’s “confident (rock version)” is hard as fvck too, that’s the ONLY SONG of her catalogue that i can’t sing 😭😭😭
9:35 the E3 sounded better than the G#5
ar 50 years c#5 celine is very chest power and clear impressive
Love her but part of the reason for that is the decades of lip synching she has done to preserve her voice.
@@atolm1 this song IS. '''Tout Blues '' she sing live also. In concert french
@@atolm1 whith Big raspy in her c#5. 😁
@@atolm1 August 2016. (Thé end ). Her voice very broken ..c#5. ua-cam.com/video/YdY_F5dYjYo/v-deo.htmlsi=qsOsJ2XFML746V5k
@@atolm1 She has the technique to keep singing live, she just chooses not to obviously due to her health condition. But "Tous Les Blues Sont Ecris Pour Toi" was sung live on every occasion.
For Emotions, the 1991-92 performances where she performed -1 semitone from studio is by far the most challenging version that she’s performed. The constant phrased Eb5s and E5s and some F#5s are insane.
Yeah, I totally forgot about these performances as I was braindead
Interesting. For Kelly, I'd have maybe chosen something like BTHE or Timeless.
For Demi, not sure. She's got some very intricate climaxes in every album
Why no one talk about Leona Lewis beautiful voice? She has such a wonderful voice!
She has the most gorgeous tone in the industry to me, people slept on her, she was up there with the all time greats for a while.
@@atolm1she was up there from 2008 to 2013.. she seemed to decline from then
@@addictedtovocals yeah :/ I think she had a pretty bad vocal injury from touring her impossible songs and never lip syncing and she never fully recovered. It so sad, *but* when she was Grizabella in Cats on Broadway she fucking MURDERED it
@@rhettmitchell she did two full 18 song tours in 2/3 different years, with her nose job done and her constant performing after falling sick from the 2012 tour, things just got worse from there.
ain’t there a G5 belt in emotions?? i think kelly would NAIL this song, that’s the only song i think would be a challenge for her because she barely uses her whistle register but she has such a good control with it, so idk
🤣🤣🤣 ain't no way that song is a suicide even in terms of belts and low notes that song is just crazy
@@aymenakabusiness631 kelly can hit E3s and G5s easily. that’s what happens when you’re constantly working on your vocal technique
@@doctorits nah not in emotions the E3s aren't just simple and so is the g5s even tho the dynamics and the runs and whisle transitions are literally so weird ,i mean legacy is legacy she's Mariah f carey after all
@@aymenakabusiness631 stop being delusional, we’re talking about KELLY CLARKSON and not a random singer
Kelly is one of the best vocalists today but she cannot sing Emotions and i’m not talking about the transitions whistles parts only but as a whole.
Just because you can hit some G5’s or E3’s doesn’t mean that you can nail this song, the phrassing of that song requires alot of support in those multiples upper belts with power and clear ennunciation in between runs and riffs for each ‘word’.
You don’t just have to hit E3’s but sometimes doing melismas going even lower till C3 and then going up again in the same breath, I don’t even think of kelly hitting rounded E3’s without taking breaths and I’ve never heard Kelly sing a song in the same « TEMPO » as Emotions which is the most difficult part to be able to do all of that.
Kelly sung ‘Love takes time’ which seems easy but we already saw the struggle, it doesn’t sound as effortless just because the support required to phrase Mariah’s notes need alot of Chest M2 coordination which is hard to achieve.
Most singers will clearly change Mariah’s Original arrangement and ‘TEMPO’ even Patti labelle did so it’s not just because she is ‘Kelly Clarkson’.
All i thought you put All by myself as the hardest song of Celine Dion
YESS PUT SOME RESPECT ON LEONA'S HOMELESS!!! THAT SONG IS ONE OF THE HARDEST SONGS IN LIFE. I love her agility in the ascending melisma for when she says "anymore." Leona's agility in general is very underrated, probably because she rarely shows it off, but when she does it's impressive. Also Broken is up there too!!
I love how all these people sitting at home Annie's music Majors that know all of these different notes that this artists are hitting
Just get some app to identify the note and use your ears.
That G#5 mix of Celine is not even in the official audio of that song, and i never seen that she had sing this live in her prime
love it
Celine sustainable voice most clear and powerful than two
Forever by Mariah Carey was one of the hardest song to sing/cover
all mariah’s songs are a suicide for common singers … dont you dare think you can sing her discography… you are not mariah (open arms, butterfly, someday, we belong together etc)
We need part 2! Agree for Mariah. Emotions for me is the hardest song to sing. I would choose Mariah's performance from 1991 VMA where she hits Bb7 ua-cam.com/video/BzBS7nx00Kw/v-deo.html&ab_channel=TMF-TheMusicFactory
Yeah, i chose different performances due to copyright, I was so braindead when i edited the video 😭😭😭
2:42 can we just take a moment for appreciate this woman? She is so talented, her voice is a gift. However I think the hardest song to sing live for Mariah (she never sang it live bc it is VERY hard, almost impossible) is You are so cold. Obv my opinion.
For Mariah i would put anyaf too
I ♥️ U sooooooooo much Mariah!😘♥️😘♥️😘♥️😘♥️😘 Proud to be a LAMB!♥️😘♥️
Ain’t no way, run to you, how can I ease the pain, unbreak my heart, fighter are such easy songs that you forgot to add them!
😤😤😤
And I Telling You Jhud Version It's harder than all of these, apart from emotions
Ariana’s breathin SWT(belting up to bb5, multiple g#5’s, falsettos up to c6 and ending with a sustained f5) or dangerous woman we can survive(falsetto up to e6, sustained e5 leading up to multiple g5’s and a belted a5) climax should be added tbh
All of what U mentioned were adlibs. None of those notes were in the original song so they don’t count. Except for DW because the climax is still difficult even without all the adlibs
@@grandeflamesbutera3949 okay u got a point there. Quick question tho, pink champagne could have been in this vid right, the vocals aren’t adlibs🙂
@@Blijtoeter Pink Champagne does count especially since Ariana only sung it live twice fully on HMT & like 10 times before Yours Truly
i think The trouble with love is harder than Sober
Christina Aguilera Songs ❤
Emotions obviously belongs on this list!!!!!! I would also say Demi Lovato's Confident Rock Version is VERY difficult, especially with the C#6 BELT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Unpopular opinion: Adele’s hardest song is All I Ask or To Be Loved
Mariah Carey’s hardest song is Fly Like A Bird
Awesome video!!!❤
ALL of mariah carey’s songs are hard 😭 well it depends for who
@@whoevr True, I think Fly Like a Bird is at least on the same level as Emotions, don’t you think?😇
@@whoevrheyy, i’m redoing ari vs. kelly video!!!
Heavenly is much harder imp like the range (lows-belt-whistle), transitions, runs and constantly phrasing of complex vocals is unreal.
@@DaydreamCarey1234Mariah never sung Heavenly live tho, she had done the song but I think it’s fully lipped
I woulda said the hardest song for Demi is actually Fall in Line!!
I thought all MC's songs are hardest lol
Mariah's songs are hard, but not at all on the same level.
Mariah really should stop wearing that damn corcet
I wouldn’t say Sober by Kelly is hard for her AT ALL!
sober is a difficult song wha-💀
Demi hardest song is dancing with devil
Demi hardest song is Stone Cold.
Dimash song veri difficult to sing everyone
Without Whitney, it’s a joke.
Whitney songs are very singable by the standard vocalist..
Her songs are not that difficult
No one has duplicated her songs. Her national anthem is still the greatest. You have to have the voice. Many have tried and failed. Mariah has always been gravely and hoarse. Whitney was crystal clear pure tone. Even AI cleans up Mariah cracking with Whitney’s voice. Any Whitney AI of Mariah has all the top notes clear and strong. Mariah always cracks when belting or trying sustain notes.
@@Kenyon712 actually there are COUNTLESS people duplicating/covering her songs. Just because they don't SOUND like her doesn't mean they did a bad job or weren't able to sing the song. Her tone was what was most special.
@@Lovebirdd Covering is different from duplicating. She had the greatest head voice. No one is duplicating that. When great singers cover her you can see his great she was. They can’t do it.