Milwaukee Cordless Table Saw - Robin's Site Test

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 116

  • @DPJOINERY
    @DPJOINERY 5 років тому +8

    If i were the bigwigs of say Festool, Mafell, Dewalt etc it sure would be Robin Clevett who i'd want to give reviews on our tools!
    That was an outstanding honest review for Milwaukee's table saw
    Thank you Sir!!

  • @barneyleadhead2596
    @barneyleadhead2596 5 років тому +8

    I treated myself to one as a birthday present back in June and been very happy with it.
    Whilst I bought it mainly for home use I went cordless just in case I did need to take it on site with me in the future and because it is quieter than most mains table saws for home use.
    I have upgraded my mitre gauge to an Incra version with positive stops which is a world apart from the plastic thing supplied.
    Useful review as always so Many Thanks Robin.

  • @paulauten1945
    @paulauten1945 5 років тому +7

    I had this saw for about 2 weeks, exhanged it 3 times, end ended up going back to the dewalt, all 3 had the same issue with poor fitment of the removable blade cover. All 3 the plastic was flimsy, did not create a seal, and even with a dust extractor hooked up it was shooting tons of debris under the saw, 1st dewalt flexvolt i took out with dust extractor did not spit out any dust except for on too of the material as to be expected. Dewalt gets a win in my book also for having a vacuum hookup on the blade guard that milwaukee doesn’t have yet

  • @StrawbyteWorkshop
    @StrawbyteWorkshop 5 років тому +5

    I have this saw and have been mightily impressed by its build and performance, however the dust collection is really not as good as it could be, but it's only a problem with MDF.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  5 років тому +1

      Dust collection is a problem and no brand has the perfect solution at the moment.

  • @whitacrebespoke
    @whitacrebespoke 5 років тому +13

    Those kick back pawls want to go in the nearest scrap skip.

  • @darrenroche9225
    @darrenroche9225 5 років тому +3

    Another excellent review , cordless tools are getting so advanced , I can only imagine what's n store for us in the future

  • @Mortern
    @Mortern 5 років тому +1

    Thanks for the honest review, but as one said: if you are using a table saw together with a vacuum cleaner( that runs on mains) it makes little sense to use battery powered table saw. For job sites without AC power: cordless circular saw will cover 90 + % of use cases.

  • @user-zz8ln3uh5x
    @user-zz8ln3uh5x 5 років тому +16

    Looks like DeWalt's fence patents expired.

  • @marvinbenjamin3015
    @marvinbenjamin3015 5 років тому +2

    I think there are 2 main issues with battery power tools. One is longevity of battery under heavy use and two constant power under load.

  • @jonesconrad1
    @jonesconrad1 4 роки тому +3

    I'd suggest a track saw for breaking down a huge sheet of ply rather than rollers etc/

  • @hyland1984
    @hyland1984 5 років тому +4

    £200 for a battery. Ouch. Pick up 2 JCB table saws for that in B&Q. I love your honest review Robin. Cheers.

    • @hyland1984
      @hyland1984 5 років тому

      @@SammyInnit no. & I wouldn't imagine it's for professional use. My point was ...for £400/£500 you can get a corded Dewalt table saw or 2 cheap table saws for the price of a battery. The overhead cost of a cordless table saw vs a corded one, outshine. You'd want to be a serious player like Robin in the business to be able to afford one. Most carpenters I know avoid them.

    • @hyland1984
      @hyland1984 5 років тому +1

      @@SammyInnit yeah true Sam. The same battery is very helpful. But again the pros and cons of cordless tools: no leads, less health and safety issues but if your doing serious work on site, your going to need a charging station. Which equals more money, more hassle. So either way your gonna need some sort of power on site. Table saws use serious power. You'd really want 2 of those £200 babies if your a pro.
      I thought about buying the cordless dewalt table saw or the DW745. Did a tonne of research. Saw Richie from finish carpentry using the cordless Milwaukee & dewalt ones & he was cutting hardwood. They both couldn't do it. Spoke to a few professional guys doing work in houses, spoke to a carpentry teacher for advice. They basically all said stay corded when it comes to table saws. Or buy a cordless circular saw if your planning to do site work. Or the only option is, is to wait till a company make a cordless/corded one where you can use in the workshop & on the job.

    • @TheToolnut
      @TheToolnut 5 років тому +1

      @@hyland1984 I disagree, the Dewalt flexvolt cordless tablesaw is the balls.

  • @sandervandijk2373
    @sandervandijk2373 5 років тому +5

    Looks the same as the DeWalt Flexvolt. But you can buy a portable tablesaw with your batteryplatform, nice.

  • @fizzyfeetsmith2131
    @fizzyfeetsmith2131 5 років тому +2

    Hi Robin, love your vids. Does the saw also come with a mains plug?

  • @stevendouglas3860
    @stevendouglas3860 5 років тому +1

    Robin always give a good review .

  • @timmargereson332
    @timmargereson332 5 років тому +1

    Hi Robin,
    If you used the Milwaukee platform, so you had the batteries, would you buy this saw?
    I bought a Makita mains site saw and really couldn't get on with it, far too heavy & huge gaps in the insert plate around the blade.
    I'm using a festool track saw at present and am getting the Milwaukee rear handled circular saw tomorrow so I'm unsure whether the table saw would be worth the cost (without being able to try it before buying one).
    I really don't want to be lumbered with another table saw. If not, is there a site table saw (mains or battery) you would really recommend?
    Regards
    Tim

    • @TheToolnut
      @TheToolnut 5 років тому

      Get the Dewalt Flexvolt cordless tablesaw with roller stand, 👍

    • @timmargereson332
      @timmargereson332 5 років тому +1

      @@TheToolnut Thank you, I'll have a look.
      Regards Tim

  • @wilkinsoncarpentry6278
    @wilkinsoncarpentry6278 5 років тому

    They’d be upset you said not good for the first fix Chippy , love your honesty though, I’ve been thinking about buying one and I do everything from start to finish new builds and Reno’s , so yea I reckon. It would suit my site

  • @ShakespeareCafe
    @ShakespeareCafe 2 роки тому +1

    Great review. Glad you focused only on the Milwaukee saw. Comparisons to DeWalt are meaningless to someone who already has invested in the specific battery and tool platform. The 12 Ah and 9 Ah batteries that came with my chain/pole saw set are beasts. Mine just arrived today. Can't wait for Xmas vacation to build some bird houses. .

  • @rubikasuto
    @rubikasuto 5 років тому +1

    Robin which snickers are you wearing, like the style, and good video, Roger just cancelled coming up north to see us and one of my guys, (probably you no'1 fun) is gutted

  • @michaelc7283
    @michaelc7283 5 років тому +1

    Hi,
    Nice review. Just to let you know that Metabo has a cordless and corded 10 inch table saw on the market. Yes dual power, now that might be worth it.
    Waiting to see how soon the rest of the other brands are going to follow Metabo design.
    Thanks for the review...

    • @MangoGino
      @MangoGino 5 років тому +1

      The Metabo one is awesome! But it's huge.

    • @michaelc7283
      @michaelc7283 5 років тому

      @@MangoGino
      Oh yeah, you're right

  • @adamjwhite50
    @adamjwhite50 5 років тому

    That’s a clever bit of kit seems they have thought of almost everything

  • @moquahd
    @moquahd 5 років тому +1

    I have this saw. Love it.

  • @chekymonkey4452
    @chekymonkey4452 5 років тому +2

    I think Dewalt was there 2 years ago with this. it's verry close to DeWalt's saw

  • @MsElijah16
    @MsElijah16 5 років тому +2

    Cheers Robin, From NZ

  • @scoobydo2
    @scoobydo2 5 років тому

    Very informative review, thanks Robin :-)

  • @jimcraiggeezer
    @jimcraiggeezer 5 років тому

    Like with all tools you have to choose the right ones for the job.. Cordless is the way forward but sometimes corded are needed for high level power.. But, in general I reach for my cordless 80% of the time.. Thanks.

  • @ron1martens
    @ron1martens 5 років тому

    Nice video Robin. As usual the perfectionist you are always an enjoyment to watch with detail and issues with the machine.
    I guess if you were to cut sheet goods it's perhaps setting up a table with a sacrificial board and use the track saw unless they are smaller cuts.
    I understand the festool and metabo table saw have a pull in function. The festool table saw been as expensive as it is I have not made the transition of owning any table saw except for low end table saws which I have relegated entirely.
    I have the festool plunge saw to cut my sheet goods and welded a table carrying a sacrificial board. In fact I have a form work board and put other boards on top. As this is outside between two sheds I built a cover between two sheds so the boards get water damage. I wanted to build a big shed that would have sorted a few issues. Anyway I guess I just have to make good with what I got. Unfortunately metabo don't make a pull in cordless table saw for Australia.

  • @Faber_Nox
    @Faber_Nox 4 роки тому

    Do you think this saw as an entry table saw to woodworking would be ok at cutting hardwood timbers? I saw another UA-cam video a person cutting maple with this saw and it kept shutting off halfway through the cut.

  • @tonybarrett8543
    @tonybarrett8543 5 років тому

    The battery is system is now probably the most important consideration when buying tools in my case. I use Flexvolt and unless there was a serious difference in standards, that dictates what I buy. Until batteries are universal or the technology improves to make it worthwhile for second parties to manufacture them to a high spec, I reckon there are many more like me.

  • @onlineoffgrid
    @onlineoffgrid 5 років тому +1

    Nice review 👍👍

  • @MrDINODINO74
    @MrDINODINO74 4 роки тому

    ... you are doing this reviews Saturdays or Sundays ?

  • @morganplatt6762
    @morganplatt6762 5 років тому +2

    Excellent video again Robin and can I just say to the arse who nicked my trainers and hi viz jacket yesterday, you can run but you can't hide!

  • @itmsolver
    @itmsolver 9 місяців тому

    Funny the little latch on my stand is broken! Haha funny he mentioned it being flimsy! Totally true

  • @gerrydoherty7895
    @gerrydoherty7895 5 років тому

    Good review robin,
    I must agree that I like to have a table saw on site for its versatility but that seems a little bit pricey ...😯😯
    For what your getting even if your just doing fit out and second fix, now that most decent carpenters have got track saw's and cordless saws to hand
    That's probably the problem now we got to much choice regarding cutting utensils...!!
    When I started my apprenticeship the norm was a couple of hand saws and if you were lucky
    You might work for a company that had a half decent skill saw to use .
    Anyway enough about those days ....!!
    Keep up the reviews.
    Regards,
    Gerry

  • @garyblake3130
    @garyblake3130 5 років тому +1

    Hi Robin, not really interested in the brand of saw. However very interested that you quoted the safety regs regarding the use of the saw. I currently instruct at my local college and am very glad that you number 1 kept the guard on, number 2 spoke about the requirement of having your hand no closer than 300mm to the blade, number 3 using the push stick. Why would you not keep the guard on? baffles me every time I see someone on youtube using a table saw, got their safety glasses, ear defenders, dust mask on and then take the guard off, would be like Lewis Hamilton getting in his F1 car with all his safety gear on and leaving his seat belt off. Thank you for a good unbiased review of a decent saw but a very big thank you keeping the guard on and showing a safe use of the machine. Also thank you for mentioning any one who has their qualifications at college would know the safe practice and use of the saw.

    • @ukconstruction
      @ukconstruction 5 років тому +1

      No problem Gary, really glad you appreciate the video, equally its great that there are guys like you training the next generation of tradesmen and women, all the best Robin

  • @herbertherbomoore415
    @herbertherbomoore415 3 роки тому

    Your hands are extremely close to that blade with the battery in it! 😱🙏🏾🙇🏾😭

  • @benjaminromshak9904
    @benjaminromshak9904 5 років тому

    Compare this to the Hikoki (Metabo HPT) Multivolt table saw. Great show as always, 🍻 cheers🍻

  • @mikehall6433
    @mikehall6433 5 років тому

    nice. You getting the new gen 2 18g brad nailer in for a review.

  • @jameslittle3505
    @jameslittle3505 5 років тому

    I have the metabo cordless table saw and i love it!!

  • @covcarpenter9158
    @covcarpenter9158 5 років тому

    Its a big leap from a corded saw to a cordless one mate.

  • @ShadowzGSD
    @ShadowzGSD 5 років тому +2

    skill builder is nothing but adverts now, if it is not hikoki it is milwauke. the days of good informative content are over.

    • @johndaniells4440
      @johndaniells4440 5 років тому +2

      Disagree with that mind. And who doesn't appreciate a tool review anyway? Thought Robin was quite honest with the positives and negatives.

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  5 років тому +7

      This is a review, just like any other on SB since 2013. We weren't paid and Robin even said he's not sure if he'd want to have one on his site. If the mere mention of a brand has you crying foul then there's no pleasing you to be honest. Imagine if we told you something was good and it turned out to be total crap, that's not going to work for anybody.

    • @gbwildlifeuk8269
      @gbwildlifeuk8269 5 років тому +2

      LeicaGermanShepherd if you think there's a back hander for them or anything else you don't agree with, you can always not watch!
      Unless you've appointed yourself the reviewer of the reviews?

    • @darrenroche9225
      @darrenroche9225 5 років тому +2

      very harsh ,I find theses lads very honest, excellent tradesmen and genuinely nice guys who get a joy out of sharing their experiences and in trades and tools

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  5 років тому +2

      @@gbwildlifeuk8269 Thanks, we've never been offered a backhander. I reckon if we made a video about how we were offered a bribe it would be our most popular episode!

  • @dlamb2840
    @dlamb2840 5 років тому +6

    Great review. I’d genuinely take your word about a tool before buying it, about whether to buy it or not!
    Superstar tradesman and I don’t think you’d ever give a good report for a shitty item.
    Good geezer!!

  • @nb2211
    @nb2211 5 років тому

    Great tool review as always. On a different note tho just wondering whats with the blue trimmers in the roof lights Robin?

    • @ukconstruction
      @ukconstruction 5 років тому

      These trimmers are made from a structural plywood that finishes 45mm by the height of the joists I believe that it is called Keto, it's great gear and very strong and stable if kept dry

    • @nb2211
      @nb2211 5 років тому

      @@ukconstruction Great!! cheers for the reply robin ill be looking into this.

  • @bencavanagh5425
    @bencavanagh5425 5 років тому +1

    Just buy the DeWalt flex volt. The Milwaukee is a good saw but not as good as DeWalt. I purchased the Milwaukee and wished had not after using the dewalt flex volt. Also to add, if you need a battery saw on buy DeWalt but if battery you do t need just buy power saw, the saw runs perfect when battery is fully charged. Also buy the right blade like freud pro blades , the Milwaukee blade is rubbish and the stand is rubbish too, the clip snapped off on me first time using, called Milwaukee and they didn't want to know!! Buy the DeWalt flex volt or mains power Don't waste your money on Milwaukee !!!!!!

  • @leonbrava
    @leonbrava Рік тому

    does this saw work with 5ah battery? could someone let me know. thanks

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  Рік тому

      Not very well and I think it stuffs the batteries.

  • @stayspicy9456
    @stayspicy9456 5 років тому +1

    A chippy that rips door liners down?! Every chippy i've ever followed just expects us to put on 10mm of skim either side 🙈

    • @ukconstruction
      @ukconstruction 5 років тому +1

      Some of my best mates are plasterers I will always get the lining to suit the plasterer, that's the way it should be!

    • @stayspicy9456
      @stayspicy9456 5 років тому +2

      We should all help each other out. This games hard enough without having to battle with the other trades. I clean all the back boxes out for the spark. Make sure the walls dont scollop out on the skirting lines for the chippy. Anything to make life easier.

    • @ukconstruction
      @ukconstruction 5 років тому

      @@stayspicy9456 defo

  • @kevinohara8671
    @kevinohara8671 11 місяців тому

    Milwaukee has just bought out the first cordless charger lol you can charge your Tesla whilst driving along and looking out the window with a smirk I do it all the time and nod lol

  • @jakeboyle11
    @jakeboyle11 5 років тому

    How would you do firings on this?

  • @kennysender6804
    @kennysender6804 5 років тому

    Shoukd come with a plug in powersupply too and if it could charge the battery at same time would be a bonus ...

  • @gbwildlifeuk8269
    @gbwildlifeuk8269 5 років тому +6

    Looks for all the world lije the Dewalt 745

  • @covcarpenter9158
    @covcarpenter9158 5 років тому

    The other thing is robin is that on site you have to have dust extraction which means you need power anyway lol good honest review tho mate 👍👍

  • @dread4836
    @dread4836 4 роки тому

    ok not getting one now, thanks

  • @daledurbin2354
    @daledurbin2354 5 років тому

    Saw sounded like it was really straining cutting the two by. I use a "skill" saw turned upside down under a job built table when remote, in the shop the old Rockwell 2 1/2 horse cabinet saw serves well, Not a fan of Battery powered tools except for drills and small impacts.

    • @MsElijah16
      @MsElijah16 5 років тому

      Dale Durbin hahah my old man use to put his skillie upside down through a wooden box

  • @randomtask9029
    @randomtask9029 5 років тому +1

    £200 for one battery! Doesn't make sense, just use a corded table saw. Here's an idea - you can plug it in where the lights are plugged in. Oh, and where the battery charger would be plugged in...

  • @plasticpaddy5278
    @plasticpaddy5278 5 років тому

    this without battery and charger is 635 euro. i can get a dw745 with a stand for 7 euro more from same supplier.
    you can see robin s dewalt in the background - elephant in the room

    • @covcarpenter9158
      @covcarpenter9158 5 років тому

      plasticpaddy and in truth thats dewalt 745 is the saw you should buy save yourself the argo and get a proper saw.

  • @olgajoachimosmundsen4647
    @olgajoachimosmundsen4647 5 років тому +1

    It didn't look that powerful compared to a cable one

    • @covcarpenter9158
      @covcarpenter9158 5 років тому

      Na cordless isnt the way forward when it comes to machines like that. Never will be either.

    • @TheToolnut
      @TheToolnut 5 років тому +1

      @@covcarpenter9158 I disagree, cordless tools are the future for the job site. I'm almost completely cordless, can't be beaten for portability and convenience. I have the Dewalt flexvolt cordless tablesaw with roller stand and it's the balls!

    • @covcarpenter9158
      @covcarpenter9158 5 років тому

      TheToolnut well i guess its personal preference. But to be honest i bought the full size milwaukee circular saw and a 9ah battery and it simpy isnt a replacement for a corded saw iv had all of the internal parts changed and it still freaks out when ripping 2 by material. I dont like having to buy the ultra thin blades either i think it just a way of manufacturers tying you in to there blades. Its just not for me. Some cordless tools are great but some just dont work for me. But like i said its personal preference.

    • @TheToolnut
      @TheToolnut 5 років тому

      @@covcarpenter9158 I have a Makita 6-1/2" cordless circ saw and a Makita 36V worm drive type circ saw. Can't fault either of them, and they do ninty per cent of the cutting I need a circ saw to do. Heavy duty ripping of big timber is for a corded circ saw, we're agreed on that.

    • @covcarpenter9158
      @covcarpenter9158 5 років тому

      TheToolnut its like the cordless chainsaws. The will never replace a petrol saw not ever but i suppose they have a place if you only need to cut in a garden and its only bushes. I like the cordless track saws its a shame makita didnt build it to run on 36 and 18v ie 1 battery or 2 and i think recip saw should only be in cordless

  • @jimmorris5700
    @jimmorris5700 4 роки тому

    Rob our a clevit sod lol

  • @DMSparky
    @DMSparky 5 років тому +2

    Kinda looks like a POS... And I'm a Milwaukee guy seems like they don't build their tools like they used to.

    • @MsElijah16
      @MsElijah16 5 років тому

      Daniel M , their cordless vac looks like a POS as well, I think their sawzall is still good though , I'm Milwaukee as well

  • @oscarcocom6732
    @oscarcocom6732 9 місяців тому

    Dont buy used once have to sed it back to the factory

  • @johnmontague69
    @johnmontague69 5 років тому +2

    Sounds like it's got the handbrake jammed on!
    It's not a building site saw that's for sure.
    Good try Milwalki but I don't think you'll be pulling the wool over Robin and Rogers eyes with this one!
    Why can't anybody build tools like the Germans?
    Because they aren't German I suppose!

  • @philipjones9297
    @philipjones9297 5 років тому +2

    Dewalt rip off

    • @MTMSA1280
      @MTMSA1280 4 роки тому

      True but what to do if all you own is Milwaukee?
      Then buy Milwaukee!?

    • @kensfestoolchannel7916
      @kensfestoolchannel7916 4 роки тому

      Just Clay if all you own is red china, better start making better life choices

    • @MTMSA1280
      @MTMSA1280 4 роки тому

      @@kensfestoolchannel7916 ok. So there's nothing around your house made in China?
      Please be a lil more mature.
      Thank you and God bless you sir.

  • @stephenmurray4916
    @stephenmurray4916 5 років тому +2

    15 min ad for Milwaukee. Cordless tablesaws should not be a thing. They lack power massively. All of them are crap

    • @Roger-Bisby1
      @Roger-Bisby1 5 років тому

      Hi Stephen
      I agree with you to a large extent, the boundaries of what is possible with cordless are changing but the reasons for losing the cord are mainly portability. I think the way forward is for main/cordless machines. There are times when you don't want to lug a 110 volt transformer around and there are times when you can't get mains power but for most of us most of the time a main powered saw is cheaper, more powerful and keeps going
      Robin acknowledges that this saw is good for second fix. I would not even bother running boards through it because a tracksaw is easier. I have, however been using it today on an oak flooring job for doing the rips on the skirtings and on the engineered oak. It was very nice to use.

    • @stephenmurray4916
      @stephenmurray4916 5 років тому

      @@Roger-Bisby1 the 110v transformer is the bane of my life. Have switched to mainly cordless makita tools over the past few years but have just been left underwhelmed by the cordless mitre saws and tablesaws. I'm sure at some point the battery technology will catch up. I have a 36v makita cordless skill saw. Love it to bit but I nearly killed it ripping ferring strips. Great channel lads. 😁

  • @IsaacHernandez-pp7xc
    @IsaacHernandez-pp7xc 4 роки тому

    Camera guy needs some work....

    • @SkillBuilder
      @SkillBuilder  4 роки тому +2

      agree with that. Sometimes we can't get the cameraman in on the day so in this case Roger had a go. He has a way to go but he is keen to improve.