This guy is a known secular. Islam is a way of life. There was no need to create a separate secular country. Islam ensures minority rights, that's what QA meant, that minorities will be free to practice their religion in Pakistan.
Dear I totally disagree with this gentleman,Pakistan was proposed on the basis of two religions theory that is why Sindh Assembly passed bill to join Pakistan and left the option to remain and independent state with centuries history.After declaring Pakistan as new country ,Qusid e Azam was surrounded Zafrullah Khan who was Qadiyani and many others,unfortunately early death of Quaide Azam created gap of leadership further due to Assassination of Liaqat Ali Khan and Qadiyanis loby strengthened their position role which was major cause of fall of Dhaka.Bhutoo got Pakistan with half area and unhappy provinces,he made constitution giving confidence to them.Bhutto in new constitution made Pakistan as Islamic Republic and Covered Conference of Muslim heads world over in Lahore when whole Muslim world supported Pakistan to survive from next Indian attack and 4 years gave country Nuclear technology to war torn country.And today s Pakistan is safe due Nuclear Deterrence.Just review after fall of USSR ,USA directly attacked Afghanistan,Iraq and Libya and none other had Islamic Constitution.Syria and Yemen too don't have Islamic Constitution.Its matter thinking only .We are proud being Muslim and Pakistan as Islamic Republic.
Mehdi Hasan was a legend (probably a younger brother of another intellectual, Dr. Mubashar Hasan, an old-good-time PPP stalwart.mnow we only have tat poonjias left in that camp). I hope we do not lose Sayyidah Zahra too soon, she is another legend belonging to the same category we can genuinely take pride on. Why are there so few excellent educators and thinkers in a Muslim country of 220 m people? A sad commentary on the state of Muslims in general and the Muslims of the South Asia in particular.
He is distorting the facts quaid wanted to make Pakistan an Islamic welfare state. The far cry before partition was Pakistan ka matlab kia la ilaha illalallah. My mother at the time of partition was thirteen years old and she vividly remembers the emotions and sentiment at the time was that we want a separate nation where we would spend our lives according to Islamic faith. This was the essence of two nations theory and also the spirit of allama Iqbal’s dreams. He is talking nonsense how can you spend your lives according to Islam if the way of life is unislamic and laws are against islam. This bastard was I believe in ZAB’s cabinet as well and was a commie at the time
You are saying this all because you have been taught the fabricated history this is on record that quaid speech was censored and that’s a fact from PRO office and this speech clearly dictates Pakistan was meant to be democracy
Khudara...!! Muje aj pta chala k muhtarma Fatima jinnah ny b election Lada or wo us mai haar gai.... Kya zulm Hai k muje class syllabus ki Pakistan studies m asi tareekh ay mahroom rakha gya jo main smjta hun k mere liye naguzeer thi...Kya muj jese buchy, jawan or buzurg ta umer asi tabnaak tareekh sy mehrooom rhain gy????
Islam is the only solution! Ek Islamic state ma minorities k rights bhi hute hn....Kisi ko zabardasti Muslim bna dena haraam h.....Implement shariah,,,implement Islam 👍
1947 mein britishARO se AZADI HINDUSTAN KO MILI THI .. PAKISTAN KA BORN HUA THA INDIA SE... ISLIYE HUM KAHENGE .. HAPPY BIRTHDAY PAKISTAN ... OR EK BAAT JINNAH SIR KA KOI ROLL NAHI THA BRITISH SE DESH ( HINDUSTAN ) KO AZAD KARVANE SE .. IN 1944 MEIN BRITISH GOVERMENT NE ALREADY PAKISTAN Ka MAP BANALIYA THA .. OR JINNAH SIR REPRESENTIVE THE BRITISH GOVERMENT KE ... BOOK IS AVAILABE IN LIBRARY U CAN READ IT ... JINNAH SIR NE EK BHI LATHI NAHI KHAI BRITISH GOVERMENT KI AZADI KE MOVEMENT KO LEKER ...
@jams bond. Bro agar history ka pata nahi to tang mat arao. Jinnah sahib 1 bahut bare aur mudabbar leader thee. Tumhare khiyal main kiya sirf lathiyan khane se leader banta hai. Gandhi ji ko kitni lathiyan pari theen? Jinnah sahib bare leader thee, aur wo politically Pakistan ka case larr rahe thee, woh roads per aa ker logon aur government ko black mail nahi ker rahe thee. Jis leader ke pass kerne ko kuch nahi hota, woh roads per aa ker lathiyan kha ker hero ban jata hai. Jinnah sahib jaise leaders sadyon main aik dafa peeda hote hain. Tum pehle apna naam sahi tarah likhna seekho. Chill......
@@AmitKumar-qn7zz Kashmir per hamla iss liye kiya kiyonke woh partition rule ki wajah se hamara tha, jaise india ne junagadh per hamla kiya. Tum samajhte ko ke Jinnah ko hum ne jaan boojh ker mara to Gandhi ji ko tum logon ne kiyon qatal ker diya. Un ka kiya kasoor tha. Aur tumhari yeh ghalat information hai ke Jinnah sahib pork khate the, woh shia thee aur shia muslim hi hote hain, haan un ki family ke kuch log parsi bhi thee. Aur tum kiya samjhte ho ke dunya main kiya sab log hindu hi thee jo convert ho ker muslim ban gae. Allam Iqbal ki family kashmiri thi aur woh log hindu nahi, christian thee bahut centuries pehle. Aur main bhi Pathan hoon, aur Pathan bhi hindu nahi thee, hum log bani israel hain, aur prophesies ke mutabiq Allah ke huqam se yahudi se muslim ho gae. History ki sab se bari ghalti yeh hai ke aap log abhi bhi khayali world main rehte ho, Pakistan ko abhi tak accept nahi ker rahe. Jab aap log Pakistan ko waqai accept ker lo ge to sab masael khatam ho jaen ge.
Sochny wali baat hai, such bolna har kisi ka kam nahi....great man
The jewels of lahore Dr. Mehdi hassan and Dr. Arifa syeda zahra
یےہے سچ جو کم لوگ جنتے ھے شکریا اپ
کیا ہے جی سچ ہم کو بھی بتائیں۔
Exactly sir.
Great scholar who always spoke the truth without any fear.
Dr. Mehdi Hassan a great scholar.
Sir! I have found you in 2022. I don’t know if you are alive right now or not. But I feel very happy to have found your talks and speeches on UA-cam.
Today 23rd February he died.
A great scholar
Greate video
This guy is a known secular. Islam is a way of life. There was no need to create a separate secular country. Islam ensures minority rights, that's what QA meant, that minorities will be free to practice their religion in Pakistan.
The interview was shortened by time, is there another continuing video? It was such a good interview, thank you.
Islam: ان الحکم الّا للّٰہ
Democracy: Government of people
Islam is the solution!
But of which Sect dear brother? Shia or Sunni? Barailvee or Deonandi?
Great historian
RABBUL izzat aapko sehat yaab rakkhe....Foundamentelist mullahs se mahfooz rakkhe.
Ameen SumAmeen
Shukriya Qaid E Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah Pakistan zindabad afwaj Pakistan zindabad
Dear I totally disagree with this gentleman,Pakistan was proposed on the basis of two religions theory that is why Sindh Assembly passed bill to join Pakistan and left the option to remain and independent state with centuries history.After declaring Pakistan as new country ,Qusid e Azam was surrounded Zafrullah Khan who was Qadiyani and many others,unfortunately early death of Quaide Azam created gap of leadership further due to Assassination of Liaqat Ali Khan and Qadiyanis loby strengthened their position role which was major cause of fall of Dhaka.Bhutoo got Pakistan with half area and unhappy provinces,he made constitution giving confidence to them.Bhutto in new constitution made Pakistan as Islamic Republic and Covered Conference of Muslim heads world over in Lahore when whole Muslim world supported Pakistan to survive from next Indian attack and 4 years gave country Nuclear technology to war torn country.And today s Pakistan is safe due Nuclear Deterrence.Just review after fall of USSR ,USA directly attacked Afghanistan,Iraq and Libya and none other had Islamic Constitution.Syria and Yemen too don't have Islamic Constitution.Its matter thinking only .We are proud being Muslim and Pakistan as Islamic Republic.
Pakistan zindabad
Mehdi Hasan was a legend (probably a younger brother of another intellectual, Dr. Mubashar Hasan, an old-good-time PPP stalwart.mnow we only have tat poonjias left in that camp).
I hope we do not lose Sayyidah Zahra too soon, she is another legend belonging to the same category we can genuinely take pride on.
Why are there so few excellent educators and thinkers in a Muslim country of 220 m people? A sad commentary on the state of Muslims in general and the Muslims of the South Asia in particular.
Baba g sahi angrayzo ka glum lag rahay😂
He is distorting the facts quaid wanted to make Pakistan an Islamic welfare state. The far cry before partition was Pakistan ka matlab kia la ilaha illalallah. My mother at the time of partition was thirteen years old and she vividly remembers the emotions and sentiment at the time was that we want a separate nation where we would spend our lives according to Islamic faith. This was the essence of two nations theory and also the spirit of allama Iqbal’s dreams.
He is talking nonsense how can you spend your lives according to Islam if the way of life is unislamic and laws are against islam. This bastard was I believe in ZAB’s cabinet as well and was a commie at the time
You are saying this all because you have been taught the fabricated history this is on record that quaid speech was censored and that’s a fact from PRO office and this speech clearly dictates Pakistan was meant to be democracy
Khudara...!! Muje aj pta chala k muhtarma Fatima jinnah ny b election Lada or wo us mai haar gai.... Kya zulm Hai k muje class syllabus ki Pakistan studies m asi tareekh ay mahroom rakha gya jo main smjta hun k mere liye naguzeer thi...Kya muj jese buchy, jawan or buzurg ta umer asi tabnaak tareekh sy mehrooom rhain gy????
They never teach us about Bangladesh and Fatima jinnah because we as a nation are politically influenced and corrupt.
What a true question! 👌👌👌
Bhai Islam ki history b aesi e a
قائد اعظم نے بھی . کلمہ طیبہ . کا نام جو استعمال کیا . . یہ مذھب . سے الگ . ھے
Then why Jinnah oppose Gaandhi on the basis of two nation theory
Islam is the only solution! Ek Islamic state ma minorities k rights bhi hute hn....Kisi ko zabardasti Muslim bna dena haraam h.....Implement shariah,,,implement Islam 👍
Happy birthday pakistan 😅😅
It seems the future of pakistan is dark.
All rubbish
Chutto Scholar.
1947 mein britishARO se AZADI HINDUSTAN KO MILI THI .. PAKISTAN KA BORN HUA THA INDIA SE... ISLIYE HUM KAHENGE .. HAPPY BIRTHDAY PAKISTAN ... OR EK BAAT JINNAH SIR KA KOI ROLL NAHI THA BRITISH SE DESH ( HINDUSTAN ) KO AZAD KARVANE SE .. IN 1944 MEIN BRITISH GOVERMENT NE ALREADY PAKISTAN Ka MAP BANALIYA THA .. OR JINNAH SIR REPRESENTIVE THE BRITISH GOVERMENT KE ... BOOK IS AVAILABE IN LIBRARY U CAN READ IT ... JINNAH SIR NE EK BHI LATHI NAHI KHAI BRITISH GOVERMENT KI AZADI KE MOVEMENT KO LEKER ...
@jams bond. Bro agar history ka pata nahi to tang mat arao. Jinnah sahib 1 bahut bare aur mudabbar leader thee. Tumhare khiyal main kiya sirf lathiyan khane se leader banta hai. Gandhi ji ko kitni lathiyan pari theen? Jinnah sahib bare leader thee, aur wo politically Pakistan ka case larr rahe thee, woh roads per aa ker logon aur government ko black mail nahi ker rahe thee. Jis leader ke pass kerne ko kuch nahi hota, woh roads per aa ker lathiyan kha ker hero ban jata hai. Jinnah sahib jaise leaders sadyon main aik dafa peeda hote hain. Tum pehle apna naam sahi tarah likhna seekho. Chill......
@@AmitKumar-qn7zz Kashmir per hamla iss liye kiya kiyonke woh partition rule ki wajah se hamara tha, jaise india ne junagadh per hamla kiya. Tum samajhte ko ke Jinnah ko hum ne jaan boojh ker mara to Gandhi ji ko tum logon ne kiyon qatal ker diya. Un ka kiya kasoor tha. Aur tumhari yeh ghalat information hai ke Jinnah sahib pork khate the, woh shia thee aur shia muslim hi hote hain, haan un ki family ke kuch log parsi bhi thee. Aur tum kiya samjhte ho ke dunya main kiya sab log hindu hi thee jo convert ho ker muslim ban gae. Allam Iqbal ki family kashmiri thi aur woh log hindu nahi, christian thee bahut centuries pehle. Aur main bhi Pathan hoon, aur Pathan bhi hindu nahi thee, hum log bani israel hain, aur prophesies ke mutabiq Allah ke huqam se yahudi se muslim ho gae.
History ki sab se bari ghalti yeh hai ke aap log abhi bhi khayali world main rehte ho, Pakistan ko abhi tak accept nahi ker rahe. Jab aap log Pakistan ko waqai accept ker lo ge to sab masael khatam ho jaen ge.
Safar and Travel happy birthday pakistan
@@prabhaskumarmohanty5910 Thanx bro. Same wishes for india too. Happy independence day india.
jinnah kuch nahi tha.. saab histry padh chuka hu beta