Barstool Pizza Review - Oath Pizza NYC (Bonus Chocolate Chip Cookie Review)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
  • Oath Pizza in Nantucket, MA has had their place in the pizza review history when they were blessed by a rookie score from the now veteran pizza king. Now, with a new location in NYC, Dave has a chance to right his wrong.
    Check out Barstool Sports for more: www.barstoolspo...
    Follow Barstool Sports here:
    Facebook: / barstoolsports
    Twitter: / barstoolsports
    Instagram: / barstoolsports

КОМЕНТАРІ • 277

  • @bloatedsodium7301
    @bloatedsodium7301 6 років тому +620

    Congrats Oath, y'all just played yourself.

  • @MattyVice
    @MattyVice 4 роки тому +118

    He’s going to throw it in the 8s out of pity........
    Gives a 6.5......
    👌🏼

  • @SevenCostanza
    @SevenCostanza 5 років тому +145

    if you got a 9.3 already why would you want him to come back and redo it. you can only go down

    • @henrygrand695
      @henrygrand695 4 роки тому +26

      They just wanted free press for the new location

    • @tedschmitt178
      @tedschmitt178 4 роки тому +3

      Because the sign says new crust. New crust gets a new score.

    • @JakeW26
      @JakeW26 4 роки тому +1

      They asked him to come...

    • @JayTac1
      @JayTac1 3 роки тому +2

      People were complaining about the 9.3. Oath thought they were going to shut them up with another good score.

    • @itsheff3929
      @itsheff3929 3 роки тому +2

      @@JakeW26 we know. The comment is saying why would the company ask for him to come back

  • @Tex-Toons
    @Tex-Toons Рік тому +19

    Watching Dave put on a t-shirt like a 4 year old gave me the good belly laugh I needed this morning.

  • @chaim5397
    @chaim5397 6 років тому +354

    Can’t change your score rookie.

    • @natedowdy3565
      @natedowdy3565 5 років тому +12

      different location.

    • @joem13yearsago73
      @joem13yearsago73 4 роки тому +5

      Different location

    • @JG-id5vi
      @JG-id5vi 4 роки тому +6

      DiFfeReNt LoCaTiOn.!

    • @gx-hu7eq
      @gx-hu7eq 4 роки тому +4

      The location is different

    • @DaggerMan11
      @DaggerMan11 4 роки тому +6

      one new location, everybody knows scores at the original location don't apply to it

  • @matthewperez555
    @matthewperez555 3 роки тому +43

    Dave has the funniest random things go on in his reviews lol

    • @EdoKwin
      @EdoKwin 2 роки тому

      Just another day in the city

  • @CoolHandC
    @CoolHandC 5 років тому +78

    I have put my shirt on backwards before but I never put my head through the arm sleeve. I give Dave a 1.2 on that debacle!

  • @mcmuffin7612
    @mcmuffin7612 6 років тому +13

    That's the cutest pizza box I've ever seen. Also, I've never seem someone have a harder time putting on a shirt.

  • @ricky9720
    @ricky9720 6 років тому +40

    the new "coked out"score.

  • @ScottMartinD
    @ScottMartinD 6 років тому +13

    So he's basically saying we should ignore his early reviews (~pre-2017)

  • @OkieAllDay
    @OkieAllDay 6 років тому +35

    has he never put a shirt on before?

  • @JamesStillings
    @JamesStillings 5 років тому +13

    Damn, really missed an opportunity to give that cookie a 9.3 and stick it to Oath

  • @mbj920
    @mbj920 3 роки тому +42

    Dave needs to do the redemption tour... his scores early on were to inaccurate by today’s standards

  • @mikebels719
    @mikebels719 6 років тому +39

    One mastication everybody knows the operation

  • @fprosk
    @fprosk 6 років тому +9

    Thing is you don't go to Oath for the classic, you go for the cool flavor combos

  • @blynch9239
    @blynch9239 6 років тому +108

    It looks like a Tombstone frozen pizza that you cooked in your oven

    • @mariagriffin5873
      @mariagriffin5873 5 років тому +1

      ThE BaD gUy no it’s so good don’t even judge before u haven’t tried it just cause one person didn’t

    • @jayhomes4868
      @jayhomes4868 4 роки тому

      You should see the jack's pizza he cooked in his oven..

  • @colethornton4285
    @colethornton4285 5 років тому +4

    He doesn't eat pizza, he inhales it.

  • @KatySmith3
    @KatySmith3 6 років тому +19

    Can't believe when he was listing off stuff that was wrong with the original review those god awful orange seer sucker shorts didn't make the cut.

  • @Icanjizzya
    @Icanjizzya 4 роки тому +13

    Did no one catch the Adam Sandler reference - “Thats assault brotha”?

    • @bcuztheinternet
      @bcuztheinternet 4 роки тому +3

      Kamahao I caught it 😁 “you double dare me?” Lmao

    • @HunchoBlanco144
      @HunchoBlanco144 Рік тому

      I just commented about that before seeing this comment. Glad someone else caught it. 🙏🏽

    • @HunchoBlanco144
      @HunchoBlanco144 Рік тому

      One Billy Madison reference, not everybody knows the rules, unfortunately.

  • @at7828
    @at7828 5 років тому +10

    Best score you gave is to *Di Fara*, which was 9.4

    • @Bdots44
      @Bdots44 4 роки тому

      Jeffro Lans people forget

  • @Brandon9thGen
    @Brandon9thGen 6 років тому +165

    Someone needs to create a list with all the scores

  • @Joe-wr9fn
    @Joe-wr9fn 6 років тому +16

    One taste everybody knows the protocol

  • @TheTruthTeller5000
    @TheTruthTeller5000 6 років тому +22

    I love how he/she pawned the flag on him and left him to deal with it. He/she is the greatest, mad props ssooonnn/daughter.

  • @nirkytime85
    @nirkytime85 5 років тому +6

    Makes me wanna go on a pizza tour..I love this shit

  • @MrBEARDEDLEGEND
    @MrBEARDEDLEGEND 6 років тому +10

    9.2 for the Billy "Davey Pageviews" Madison "that was assault, brotha"

  • @RJ1999x
    @RJ1999x Рік тому +3

    Prez thinks going to Nantucket is some kind of honor, I wouldn't go to Nantucket if you paid me

  • @bradwendtross2027
    @bradwendtross2027 2 роки тому +1

    It looked better than a 6.5 but so small should a been $7-8 bucks.

  • @patsfan4life
    @patsfan4life 3 роки тому +1

    A lot to digest in this one 😂 no pun intended

  • @milkymigs
    @milkymigs 6 років тому +29

    Wonder if Frankie gets a slice after every review?

    • @shaodynasty1017
      @shaodynasty1017 6 років тому +6

      milkymigs almost always. He's shown it many times and Frankie has even done a full review himself. Watch the jersey shore cast pizza review

  • @coryt93
    @coryt93 6 років тому +63

    Pres’ ego is so f’n big he actually thinks Oath cares more about them not maintaining their 9.3 than them marketing their new store lmao

    • @WK12112
      @WK12112 5 років тому +33

      I heard they didn’t even open it after this. Shut it down. Owner killed himself, shot his dog too - hate to see it.

    • @BonnieAndClydeAquatics
      @BonnieAndClydeAquatics 5 років тому

      Your a gay el pres is the best ever

  • @TacoStacks
    @TacoStacks 6 років тому +143

    One bite everyone knows the Frankie.

    • @mcmuffin7612
      @mcmuffin7612 6 років тому

      Taco Stacks one score, everyone knows the rules

    • @joseorozco4152
      @joseorozco4152 6 років тому

      That shit made me laugh

    • @jackgibson3297
      @jackgibson3297 3 роки тому

      Your on every single one of these

  • @Blearysine
    @Blearysine 4 роки тому

    idk why but that "the fuck" at 0:42 was mad funny

  • @chickenmcpoopy112
    @chickenmcpoopy112 4 роки тому +1

    I love how you always say one bite as a troll 😂

  • @the40yogamer
    @the40yogamer 6 років тому +52

    i feel bad for them but hey they asked for it

  • @midwestshitshow5887
    @midwestshitshow5887 5 років тому +2

    But like I said. Spiral pizza in hastings Minnesota..
    8.2

  • @Natalie-ek2sz
    @Natalie-ek2sz 6 років тому +2

    No changing scores

  • @johnpappo4391
    @johnpappo4391 6 років тому +6

    What about DiFara's DOUBLE 9.4???

  • @WHR17
    @WHR17 6 років тому +3

    9.3 rookie mistake, El Pres could even handle a t-shirt back then!!!

  • @benjaminrahman5225
    @benjaminrahman5225 6 років тому

    My friend Austin says you use Yelp for reviews, is this true?

  • @ikillyoudead
    @ikillyoudead 6 років тому +2

    Pres, hit up Pleasant Cafe in Roslindale

  • @kyleblake1273
    @kyleblake1273 4 роки тому +1

    I love when I guess the number he says.

  • @humanmoron
    @humanmoron 6 років тому +6

    prez lucky to be alive

  • @KyleHurd
    @KyleHurd Рік тому +1

    Imagine being Oath Pizza and swinging for the fences with a paper bat.

  • @kregan1986
    @kregan1986 2 роки тому +1

    he would give it a minimum 7.1 today since he hands out 7's like nothing nowadays

  • @mrknebin
    @mrknebin 5 років тому +4

    One Roll-Up, everybody knows the assault

  • @johnk230
    @johnk230 4 роки тому +3

    why is there always a weird thing that happens

  • @J-B-P
    @J-B-P 4 роки тому +1

    Oath is like that kid in class who gets 89% on an assignment and begs for a 90%... teacher drops ya down to 85%
    KARMA

  • @originalfiremancancelled7303
    @originalfiremancancelled7303 2 роки тому +2

    Everybody knows the rules you can't change the number that's a rookie move

  • @GFkilla17
    @GFkilla17 Рік тому

    Smoke drifting by 2:33

  • @jeffpaul6292
    @jeffpaul6292 6 років тому +1

    You'll never go but Twin's Pizza- North Providence, RI

  • @Greeezy
    @Greeezy 6 років тому +27

    I strongly feel that if there has been 2 scores for one brand of pizza. They should be averaged out. Which gives Oath a 7.9.

    • @amberleaf3n144
      @amberleaf3n144 6 років тому +9

      Bullshit statement. If your pizzas bad its bad. The scoring scale begins to lose its integrity when you play around with the rules

    • @Greeezy
      @Greeezy 6 років тому +3

      Colm Mcneill sir. I am not playing with the rules. I am simply implying that if your pizza is being reviewed multiple times, that your previous score should affect the secondary score. If you're gonna just erase historical scores then you should really assess your life choicss and come to terms with the truth. And the truth is a an averaged tally.

    • @amberleaf3n144
      @amberleaf3n144 6 років тому +8

      PowerfulKramerJanglez If it's the same spot I agree with you completely. He reviewed a new location so the score should be kept separate.

    • @amberleaf3n144
      @amberleaf3n144 6 років тому +1

      On an average joe scale yeah, id eat any fucking pizza. Prez is a self proclaimed pizza man, "a man of the pizza". Hes working with tighter standards.

    • @Greeezy
      @Greeezy 6 років тому

      Colm Mcneill one could argue that if we are reviewing per spot, that the review really boils down to the equipment used. But if we are reviewing a brand, then there should a continued score. Variables such as location and equipment used to make the pizza are irrelevant in our situation.

  • @eeeeee217
    @eeeeee217 2 роки тому +2

    Dave, do blind tests on places you already gave high scores. This taste test was your revenge and ego searching for realizing that you gave a high score as a rooky. I bet you will not score as high or as low some of the same places if you revisit with blind fold.

  • @mikeb3327
    @mikeb3327 6 років тому +14

    Show his bias towards Massachusetts

  • @TomYaboYoga
    @TomYaboYoga 5 років тому +6

    Who's insulted by a 9.3 and demands a rescore?

  • @ginosanchez7
    @ginosanchez7 5 років тому +1

    Dave is a man of integrity, i respek that

  • @genebigs1749
    @genebigs1749 4 роки тому

    How many times I gotta hear about Nantucket? I get it, you're rich. God bless America, baby!

  • @grahamconklin5464
    @grahamconklin5464 6 років тому +1

    Someone tell Dave he gave a 9.5 during the slice out hunger event

  • @Eldeibi84
    @Eldeibi84 2 роки тому +2

    Wow that’s the biggest self ownage in business history. Talk about losing millions of dollars

  • @steveallen5072
    @steveallen5072 6 років тому +2

    Double talk Dave

  • @bryanschneider8120
    @bryanschneider8120 6 років тому +8

    One byte, everybody knows the code.

  • @trueblueyou6114
    @trueblueyou6114 5 років тому

    You need a stamp video graphic w/a louder sound effect

  • @tylervollet5395
    @tylervollet5395 4 роки тому

    That start was fucking hard to watch good god

  • @Armandusins
    @Armandusins Місяць тому

    Someone get fired in that day 6.5 lmao

  • @davidapple8047
    @davidapple8047 2 роки тому +1

    Just looking at that pizza only scores a 6.4..

  • @tradehead
    @tradehead 11 місяців тому

    Dave, could have thanked her for helping out. Somebody doesn't know the rules.

  • @xapemanx
    @xapemanx 6 років тому +5

    A major upset for the home crowd

  • @jessiegarcia9410
    @jessiegarcia9410 5 років тому +1

    Instead of just taking the knee and running out the clock for the win, Oath Pizza decides to run a pass play for some unknown reason that gets intercepted and the other team scores and wins the game.

    • @skendrix7
      @skendrix7 5 років тому

      Jessie Garcia Patriots never scored they just intercepted and the game was over 😏

  • @RyujiRoyalSkull
    @RyujiRoyalSkull 5 років тому

    Straight savage on that slice

  • @blakehamilton813
    @blakehamilton813 5 років тому +1

    Chick just lets it hit her and falls

  • @63ah1275
    @63ah1275 6 років тому

    Holy shit! I called the 7.2 on the cookie.

  • @1chip4you
    @1chip4you 5 років тому

    One bite everybody knows ‘takes another bite’

  • @torres0230
    @torres0230 5 років тому

    Pizza Town in Park Slope Brooklyn a solid 8.4💪

  • @thomasharner92
    @thomasharner92 4 роки тому +1

    Wouldn't even go as high as 6.5 dawg

  • @ethanhamm3823
    @ethanhamm3823 3 роки тому

    00:40 lol

  • @HEARD201
    @HEARD201 6 років тому +1

    I like how that girl just walked away when he was trying to adjust it. Weirdo

  • @realtalktampa8795
    @realtalktampa8795 4 роки тому

    Wait what happen to not giving 2 scores

  • @dandannerson5925
    @dandannerson5925 6 років тому

    EL PRES!!! GOTTA TRY OZONE PIZZA IN OZONE PARK QUEENS!!

  • @izwansabri3663
    @izwansabri3663 5 років тому

    One bite. Y'all better know the rules!

  • @chipsandsalsa2520
    @chipsandsalsa2520 5 років тому

    That shit looks like a Jack's Frozen that you pick up at Menard's while your picking up 2x4's

  • @nelgonz1428
    @nelgonz1428 6 років тому +4

    Hold on You gave Di faras a 9.4 so how is johns of Bleeker 9.3 the highest score you ever gave?

    • @Choatsy
      @Choatsy 6 років тому

      Nel Gonz in Manhattan

    • @nelgonz1428
      @nelgonz1428 6 років тому

      He said 9.3 was the highest score there ever was on the show watch it again, Keep in mind Dave is rating the best pizza he has ever had which is why he travels to all 5 boroughs, even to other states.

    • @johnchase4408
      @johnchase4408 5 років тому

      John's on Bleeker was reviewed 1st.

  • @aquiariots72
    @aquiariots72 6 років тому

    You own a house on Nantucket ?? Wow, you are sooo cool!!

  • @alittleofeverything4190
    @alittleofeverything4190 4 роки тому

    NY state of mind, nice.

  • @mashedpotatoes6529
    @mashedpotatoes6529 4 роки тому

    1:47 looks like mark zuckerbergs dumber brother

  • @astral16
    @astral16 6 років тому

    That sign!

  • @michaelbell2897
    @michaelbell2897 4 роки тому

    Never mentions his 9.4 di vara. Is that a legit score ?

    • @matthewmiles1433
      @matthewmiles1433 4 роки тому

      I think it is legit, there's one review where he goes back to difara and they have the score framed on the wall. But I think in the review he says both 9.3 and 9.4 at two times

  • @kelvinpeterson6169
    @kelvinpeterson6169 4 роки тому

    He's a man from Nantucket?

  • @boland73
    @boland73 5 років тому

    This just proves the score would be higher in Mass trope to be true

  • @wild_cam
    @wild_cam 6 років тому

    Did he say Kentucky?

  • @tomy5868
    @tomy5868 4 роки тому

    inhale one slice...everybody knows the rules.

  • @therealadaa9
    @therealadaa9 4 роки тому

    but you gotta do the Spicy M.C.

  • @Xoniksken
    @Xoniksken 6 років тому

    How did I miss this one?

  • @ras124
    @ras124 5 років тому

    There once was a man from Nantucket

  • @joevega5477
    @joevega5477 4 роки тому

    You cant change the rules score rookies 9.3

  • @edwinearl4584
    @edwinearl4584 3 роки тому

    Quit while you’re ahead. Everybody knows the rules.

  • @tomriley1492
    @tomriley1492 6 років тому

    “9.3 is the worst thing I ever said” -Pres

  • @craigslistmeetup8598
    @craigslistmeetup8598 4 роки тому

    Oath is a solid 4.3

  • @jasonrainbow3298
    @jasonrainbow3298 6 років тому

    You said 7.3 in the rookie review not 9.3

  • @khl2445
    @khl2445 11 місяців тому

    nobody gonna give credit to the owner for doing this?
    ok ig

  • @joevega5477
    @joevega5477 4 роки тому

    One month doing cocaine in Nantucket

  • @NicholasD
    @NicholasD 4 роки тому

    Rookie move by changing your score... rook