There should be another article added- General category students are not allowed to apply for government job. I think it would satisfy the needs of reserved category.
I am from obc but i don't like reservation in education . Bhot deserving log piche reh jate h. Jinko reservation milra vo toh bs hatered hi faila rr h sb jgh, maine bhot comments dkhe h aise.
@@halim5429 Aankh band karne se andhera nahi ho jaata. Baat isliye kar rahe hein kyonki jaatiwad khatam nahi hua hai. Ab bhi chal raha hai. Aur jab chalega, tab tak baat bhi chalega.
Thank you mam❤ Always eagerly waiting for your video. And when notification come ...i m just 😊😊 Thank you for being my teacher👏🏻 Belated happy teachers day 🙏🏻
1:06 : you are WRONG . Political reservations for Scs & Sts was for 10 years initially and it is provided that if found necessary it can be extended by another 10 years and so on. It was not fixed for 70 years. There is no such periodic limitation in respect of reservations in jobs n education…
@CEO of Secularism : reservations in politics was temporary and reservations in education n jobs was not but was subject to review ; how do u expect the imbalances created by Varnashram-reservations - of thousands of years - in favour of the oppressing castes would go away so soon…
Exactly obc was implented in support of BJP by VP singh govt and EWS was provide by Modi govt also OBC consist of 27%, it should be removed only reservation for SC ST ie 14% & 7% should be kept and 80% seats open for all
@@mother.95 please do not speak for all OBC people. There are many obcs whose families are still struggling to climb up the social ladder. They're still backwards socially and educationally despite the reservation being there since 1991. And if the reservation for OBC should be removed then so should be done for SC ST. Dekha jaye toh they have been provided reservation for too long and hence don't need it anymore like OBCs
It was in 1951 by the Virtue of 1st Constitutional Amendment Act, 1951 which amended the article 15(4) and 16(4) to enable the state and central government to reserve the seats for SC and ST in the government jobs and educational institutions.
No ist ammendment act talks about genral advancement of socially and educationally backward classes. It's actally 93rd ammendment act which catagorically talks about reservation in educational institutions.
@@mother.95 you r right , actually this ammendment was made to nullify the decision of sup.court in champakkam dorairajan vs. state of Madras in which sc declared the law made by Madras govt in which they reserved seats in med and engineering colleges on the basis of religion ,race and caste. Sup.court declared the law to be void as it discriminates on the ground of caste etc and it's voilation of Art.15 . . Here backward includes sc and st . And other backward classes also, in both the clause 15(4 & 5)For sc and st there is a reservation since the commencement of constitution but obc had given recognition only after mandal commission .
It's high time to use latest census data for reservation and re evaluate whether 50% reservation is necessary or not. Reseravation is the only barrier for indian to become developed nation.. Jai hind
Reservation is not stopping India to becoming developed nation. If that was so,then what is stopping India to win medal in Olympic, there is no reservations there. It's government policy which is hindering it. India spend less than 3% of GDP in education. Education was never in a priority list to any of our government.
@@AshishRanjan_in_iit a lot of undeserving candidates get selected through reservations. The ones who need it the most don't even know about it. So yes, major changes needs to happen in reservation system. And comparing reservations to sports is illogical, the sports scenario is totally different compared to this.
@@kangad4711 they arent undeseving but persecuted and they want equal representation in fields too lol... U cant decide who is undeserving if u keep them.away from tbeir rights from 5000+years and think 70yrs of reservation can compensate it
@@anamikasingh7356 people need to get educated plus many people doesn't even know the true meaning of reservation 🙏 Education is necessary that all...casteism is going on from thousands of years so surely it is impossible to eradicate in a year it will take time it's us the 3rd gen who can act on this. If u could understand!!
@@anamikasingh7356 .. Yes it is possible... I have seen many sc who are developed through reservation are now getting good status and atrocities also reduced..... And auntyji i belong to general caste
Reservation in educational institutions for Sc' and st's was provided by 93rd constitutional amendment Act 2005 under article 15(5) of indian Constitution
10% for EWS category is for economically weaker sections in general category whereas 50% is for SC, ST, OBC so this 10% has nothing to do with 50%. It is not included in 50%.
By placing such extensive discussion on topic of "Reservation" the main subject of "Social Advancement of the Poorest Sections of Society" gets lost in the details and deliberations.
भाई अर्जुन यह सबसे "गरीब" के बारे में नहीं है यह "वंचित समाज" OBC के बारे में है, please understand reservation is for dipressed part of society... It's not proverty upliftment.. it's about representation of their own.. सुदामा आरक्षण जो गरीबी के आधार पर दिया जाता है without data with out numbers...
not really - private jobs are free of reservations and will likely stay that way for some time ... or migrate to places like uttrakhand where UC's have high population and will keep a tab on limit of reservations. plus government jobs are less than 1% of all the jobs in the country - it doesn't make any difference - even for the sc st obc's if they get all the seats - why ? because if for the past 70 yrs nothing has changed - it'll not change in the coming years , the creamy layer of sc st will keep getting benefits , rest will be deprived. reservations are just political gimmicks.
@@nomadicbeing6750 what you said doesn't make any sense it's too vague. it can be said about each and every problem in our nation...or even the world... global warming ? And that thinking itself is what makes reservation at the first place algal blooms ? And that thinking itself is what makes reservation at the first place someone pooped their pants ? And that thinking itself is what makes reservation at the first place
You should study history of indian and polity, may be that will change your mind. Yeah the reservation system should change with time, for example shey should also add economical status of the reservation holder as a criteria for issuing the certificate.
Guys should our government really do the caste based census ? See my intension is not to hurt anyone thinking but my opinion is that if we talk about equality and all thing then why caste based census ? If the gov. Provide the reservation toh they should be examine very carefully who actually need the reservation . Not everyone in sc/st or obs are backward then why they come in that particular reservation . We all talking about the changes in society when this cast based census will change ??? Plz guys m not against about reservation . What i want to say is why caste based census ?
Yes it will. If there is a caste based census then we will have clear data as to which communities deserve reservation and which do not. It will help in better targetting of policies.
Shahu Maharaj was the first to implement caste-based reservation in the modern era of India. He declared 50% reservations from which only four castes were excluded: 1) Brahmin 2) Shenvi 3) Prabhu and 4) Parsi. All other castes except these were declared as constituting the Bahujan Samaj.
It's high time general candidates should gather and raise voice against this whole reservation system.. Kb tk jheeloge mitro.. Jaha dekho waha reservation..
@@manmohanrautela0731 reservation lene waale kam kaabil hote hein, ye bol rahe ho? Matlab, 10% EWS waale bhi mand-boodhi hai ya sirf dalito ko bewakoof bol rahe ho? Hypocrite ho ya dimaag se lapahij?
Sabse accha hai ki hum general category log apna alag country banale....bohot atchyachar ho rha abhi general category students ke sath...bhad me jaaye this shiiitty country named India.
@@neeloobharti6040 sach bol rha hun...agar govt abhi nhi jagi toh hume aazadi ki ladai ladni padegi....nhi toh yeh sarkar ka bas chale toh sab general category waalo ko bheekh mangne par mazbur kar denge....
What a joke atyachar ho raha h. Kitna victim card khelega be sab jagah tum log hindu muslim jatiwad or mob lynching promote karte ho. Hate spech me tum aage. Or upar victim card play karne aag gaye
@@kamartaj3010 jo khud paida hone se marne tak victim bana rahta hai ab wo mereko victim card khelna bta rha.....aur sabse jyada jaativad aur hindu muslim tum log karte ho....aur beta aage hai toh apne dum par reservation lekar nhi... Aur phir yahi log kahte hai india develop kyu nhi ho rha... Agar reservation raha toh India 100 saal baad bhi developing country hi rahega 😂.
I know after this comment many of u start criticizing or use abusive language. But really I dont feel any emotional attachment with India which a citizen should have may be bcz of this reservation syst.
The time has come when all types of reservations based on caste creed religion etc should be ended. The only Reservation left should be based on economic conditions and women.... The country should not demotivate deserving candidates in the name of Reservations . Vote bank politics is the main hurdle... Great political will is required to remove this evil..
Childish thought....roam around jhuggis and slum areas across the nation and Read Laxmikant, you might then realise how superficial thoughts you are living in it.
@@Viraj_2305 i don't believe that's a utopian idea of providing reservation on the basis of economic condition of the citizens as we are already doing so ( EWS - 10%) we only need to identify the loopholes in the EWS portion, the criteria is set for 8 lakh per annum which covers a good amount of population! Apart from that census taken based on caste and creed itself provides for caste based distinction and the benefits of reservation often don't even reach the needy. So the correct way of implementation of reservation is actually economic based census and provisions that matches the socio- economic conditions.
@@sejal8718 if you are coming to this conclusion based on the fact u mentioned, I must say that u have to read a lot to understand that ECONOMIC BASED reservation is not at all the solution of this. Bcz RESERVATION IS NOT A POVERTY ALLEVIATION PROGRAM .... It's representation of all the caste creed, races, gender, religion to bring equal social status. By ur method (economical basis) there wouldn't be any difference between a begger and bankrupt millioner afterall both are with zero economic status. How can be it same?No... अगर ऐसा होता तो सारे जहां में इकोनामिक बेसिस पर ही रिजर्वेशन होते हैं
@@Viraj_2305 yes i know that reservation is not a poverty alleviation programme, still does not justifies it efficiency after years of its implementation i believe now we can look forward for better methods to mainstreaming the downtrodden rather than just affecting the administrative efficiency. And why economic reservation should be provided is because they actually need the reservation to catch up into mainstream . Reservation right now is like a painkiller tablet which is just numbing the pain and not doing much for the disease. Reservation was very good policy when it was implemented but in current scenario it's a stagnant policy with very less relevance. And for the part where we want all sections to be equally representative ... we need this in parliament and legislative bodies so that they can be representative in policy formulation and not in jobs and colleges ! Apart from that i still don't understand if a we want a society based on no differences why are we providing reservation on that basis only? Rather find better methods? Haina?
Being an OBC guy I thought lucky people are SC and ST because most of the exam which they didn't take money from sc/ st people .. But OBC have to pay same amount as general is paying 😒
aur toh bhai kuch khaash fayda v nhi milta mai jee me agar bhot niche wala nit/iiit aagr gen ke liye 95 percentile pe band hota h toh obc ka 94-94.5 pe 2 question ke fark aur Gate me toh score me toh lagbhag same rehta hai wahi neet ,me agar gen ko 650 pe x college milta hai toh obc ko 645 pe 🤐 ... wahi aur fir obc-ncl se thaa toh mujhe lga fees kam lgegi par IIITs me toh puri fees dena padta hai aur scholarship v nhi milti 🥲 sc-st ko scholarship v milti poora enjoy krte hai woh toh bekar hai ye obc reservation mai toh toot gaya
Reservation is only for name !! In reality there's only 1 or 2% beneficiary who aware of schemes. Lot of funds coming for various schemes in the name of these & all going to trap !!
@@rohanjha7116 kinse re babua? Kinse? 2000 saal se padhai likhai par brahmins ka 100% reservation tha. Tab to nahi chillaya ki kyon brahmin ko reservation hein. Ab 70 saal mein aag lag gayi?
Mutual tolerance hona chahiya insaan mein jo aap mein nahi Veda Vyasa’s extraordinary achievements are evidence that those who came from the Dalit and lower-caste communities Vedas was assemble by sudhras vedvyas so how can a low caste vedvyas can assemble most of the vedas if they are not allowed to study Vedvyas born due to intercaste marriage Or itna gyaan de ra hai tujhe apni community ki nahi bhus apni padhi hai Agar tum log kshatriya bantey matlab hathiyar othatey jab invasion horey thae toh tumlogon ki slavery kabhi nahi hoti We are not the one who depressed you maurya empire,gupta period,harshvardhan empire were Kshatriya and brahmins who had protected India That time land revenue was 1/6 After the invasion tax revenue increase to 10/11+ jaziya made to change most of your brother their religion So go greece,Britain and central asia from where it was the origin of war on religion started and asked for your rights Swamy naam rakhnae se gyaani nahi bantey padhna padta hai reservation boy
One day general seat will be zero. If modi govt. increases reservation then General has to unite and make the union govt . They are doing this only for some votes of OBCs in elections.Very dirty game being played.
@@dami9186 Konsa upper caste , mera koi caste hai hi nahi. Jinone kiya tha o log mar gaye, tum bhi marke unse badla. Hum se badla mat. Bhar me gaye tum log . Reservation should be zero. Ghadhe koi naukri nahi.
Instead of reservation, make education and medical free for economical weaker sections. Jobs should be merit based. Lebnon did the same, it constitutionalised religion based seats (same as caste reservation) today the country is facing bankruptcy and there is almost civil war like situation. If we don't stop this reservation madness here we will too face the same.
Education is sure to be made available for free but i disagree with medically. You're being too far leftist, cause Health care is service to mankind not a right to be obtained. Besides there are schemes and beneficiary available and we SC n ST have benefited from that
You are confusing Social Justice (Reservation) with Welfare State, while welfare state is for everyone, Reservation is for those who are socially outcaste till today..
Bewakoof mat bano... Lebanon ko Isis ne destroy kiya hai... Pehle Lebanon bhi normal country tha, islamic hone ke vajah se barbaad hua, not due to caste based help to backward castes... Idiotic comment
6:35 ma'am according to Supreme Court 50% se reservation extend ni honi chahiye but hm EWS categories ke log ko jo 10% reservation mili hai then usse milakr toh 60% ho jati hai ????
@@democraticlegalservice3096 but ye toh overall seat me se hin na 10% reserve ho ri hai...I mean baaki general category ke seat me se hin n 10% jaa rahi hai
@@ashishraulin 50 % reservation cap is for socially and educationally backward classes of citizens whereas EWS is for economically backward sections of citizens. Hence, that 10% won't be accounted. Just a game of words. 🙂
yeahh u all r right it's a great step taken by Govt. By the way I'm eligible for EWS certificate but the process is quit complicated that's why I didn't made it till now 😊
@Raj Singh I don't think what you are saying is related to my question and the videos. I'm expressing my doubt, a/c to Indra Sawhney judgement reservation cant be exceed 50%, but we'd 50% reservation (SC/T+OBC). How could EWS be put in reservation ?
@@mother.95 yeah sc st need reservation but not obc , where you see yadav got discrimination ? I can say obc are just another form of EWS category only sc sts are real victim and I can admit that
@@abhinavpandey840 Finally one sensible comment in 600 comment. Phew. I had almost given up. Edit: And coming from a 'Pandey' , it makes me happy. You are one of us.
First of all, why the reservation??, Second why subsidies??. These two things killed India's progress, India was a skilled, righteous and duty bound citizens who never ever begged or demanded for their basic rights and authority. Handful of British to rule these large number of subjects wanted sympathizers, followers, slaves, stooges in to their side, so the reservation devil came onto the picture. Due to these two draconian law, all learned,educated, professional are drained out and settled abroad and doing miracle over there. Instead of this, try to encourage the uneducated to do education, while giving that try to give them the knowledge of current affairs, technological advances etc. All tribes were skilled in an PERTICULAR way, caste is not even herd in india till 18th century. Anyway when last benchers,useless fellows start these rules and regulations one cannot do anything.
Ooh shut up plzz ,,subsides are important for the poor farmers and people who are really i. Need . But we have to stop the loopholes which are perform in name of subsides .
Pls correct the fact: Reservation was not for 70 years it was initially for 10 years. Day by day,year by year it was extended by 10 years with constitutional amendments. No offence You all are doing great work,keep it up.
Why can't govt provide reservation to those who are financially weak , now we are not living in 1950s , sc, St , OBC or general ,we can't decide their status just by these categories. Why the heck real talent has to suffer . Give reservation to those who really deserves . But to be honest this reservation system should not exist anymore , this is cheating to those who prepared hard and not getting the seat bcoz of reservation!!
Exactly. It's an easy way to escape responsibility. Government hasn't been able to do grassroot work , so they are trying to fix this mistake by providing reservation. No body wants to know why don't government provide good education to SC/ST/OBC kids so they can perform well and do good in life ,but why work so hard , when you cam make the community happi by providing a lollipop.
@@needhisingh7274 ya , doing all these analysis and then finding a cure for it would be difficult and time consuming ,so what is easier for them is providing reservation. That's what they are doing , zero responsibility=zero development in education sector !
SC/ST act has been misused and used this law as a weapon by some people just to escape the law from any kind of illegal activities. They just file a police complaint stating that he/she was abused by a upper cast person by calling him as a ******. If a person of upper cast is abused by a person from the SC/ST community and then can the upper cast person file a complaint for abusing his community ?
Your unsolicited comments diluting the basic concepts & purpose of this video presentation. Basically you should understand that FINOLOGY is an educational platform to transfer the knowledge and explain the statutes to the viewers. FINOLOGY never invited any one to debate on disputes in this section. If you are aggrieved of any dispute, we have a strong judiciary and fight legally. Never give vague statements. If you have case laws, please provide them for our use. Try to understand, FINOLOGY has not given any undertakeing to anyone with respect to implimentation or usage of statutes or IPC or CRPC. Hence hereinafter, being an educated person, before making any statement think twice and post. We appreciate If you are ready with relevant case laws pertaining to the matter under consideration.
@@ramulugouri5768. Look Any law enacted to uplift any community is good in a Democracy but in India people don't respect the law and the Judiciary is watching all kinds of illegal activities of people and policiticians as a mute spectator. Therefore, explaining about law is irrelevant for me and my point of view is to create awareness amongst people to follow the law and respect the same as law abiding citizen. Some people misuse the same law which was enacted for their own upliftment and that is my problem.
@@ramulugouri5768 It is not necessary to be a lawyer to understand the law. You are taking about the job reservation for SC/ST and other community people but due to hard scale authorization even in Army these percentage of quota will not serve any purpose.
Reservation for first time was added by KAKA KELKAR COMMISSION. It was the first commission for granting and prividing for reservation to SC/ST in Independent India.
EWS reservation is out of that 50% which is for general candidate.. If you leave your OBC quota and you are poor enough in front of govt. Then you can also get EWS reservation. It is for everyone who is poor. And is not enjoying any reservation.
@@karanbirsingh3102 Poore samaj ko gaali de rahe ho, aur phir bolte ho ki Jaatiwad kaha hai desh mein, kyon de Reservation. Akal se lapahij hein kya ji tum?
Such a lucid & simple way of explaining. Connecting the dots is what makes things easy. Kudos to finology legal, you guys are doing a great job.
Brilliant summarizing done by both of you. I Appreciate the short brainstorming in between as well 🙌
Hello
Reservation should be increased to 100%...
So that we(general) students don't have to sit in any exam only!
Agreed
True mate...
Quotas are proportioned at the cost of OM...as if we are all elites lol
Scene set
Good option though...
Or we should have been provided with time machines where Lower castes should do the same as the UC's did ...
We have 50.5% reservation for generals.
Why don't you see this ?
Finology legal is extremely good for preparation of polity. Thnx to finology team.
In 1951 SC / ST provided educational reservation in 1st amendment through case "state of Madras vs. Champkam doraiajan".
Correct
Hello mam
Hi
Hi Jyoti bala
Aspirant spotted
whenever i encounter problem in any topic i start searching for the same on ur chanel ..thank u very much for the great work..
You are so beautiful priya
Happy Teachers day to all the teachers of Finology Legal 😘❤️🙏
Happy Belated Teachers day to all the members of Finology Legal...🤓🤓😄😄🙏🏼🙏🏼Best wishes from Sudhansu Sekhar (From Puri, Odisha)
great and decent explanation with historical background... thnks finology team
There should be another article added- General category students are not allowed to apply for government job.
I think it would satisfy the needs of reserved category.
🤣😭 right
💩
I am from obc but i don't like reservation in education . Bhot deserving log piche reh jate h. Jinko reservation milra vo toh bs hatered hi faila rr h sb jgh, maine bhot comments dkhe h aise.
@@gauravsahu-kj9fw ask for increase in seats, use logic, think first, Not Gulamgiri to upper caste ideology
Joke of the day 🤣🤣🤣
All GENERAL CATEGORIES CANDIDATES ASSEMBLE
WE ARE GOING TO HIMALAYAS
🤣🤣🤣
@@halim5429 🤣 himalaya mein bhi 50% space reserved
@@halim5429 Milega bhai. Path-pooja mein to upar jaat waalo ka poora hakk hein. 2000 saal se to tha,aur ab bhi hai.
@@halim5429 Aankh band karne se andhera nahi ho jaata.
Baat isliye kar rahe hein kyonki jaatiwad khatam nahi hua hai. Ab bhi chal raha hai. Aur jab chalega, tab tak baat bhi chalega.
@@debarunmondal Sahi keh rahe ho
Many many congratulations on 1 Million Subscribers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Truly and absolutely well-deserved!!!!!!!!!!!!
Overwhelming thanks to the whole team of finology legal ❤️...
Thank you mam❤
Always eagerly waiting for your video. And when notification come ...i m just 😊😊
Thank you for being my teacher👏🏻
Belated happy teachers day 🙏🏻
Having discrimination 😂. Where is the credit of sir 🤣
1:06 : you are WRONG . Political reservations for Scs & Sts was for 10 years initially and it is provided that if found necessary it can be extended by another 10 years and so on. It was not fixed for 70 years. There is no such periodic limitation in respect of reservations in jobs n education…
Good point👍
@CEO of Secularism : reservations in politics was temporary and reservations in education n jobs was not but was subject to review ; how do u expect the imbalances created by Varnashram-reservations - of thousands of years - in favour of the oppressing castes would go away so soon…
@@123xyzabccba Who is going to clean latrines of dominant caste if there are educated dalits in society?
Power of laxmikanth
@@123xyzabccba bheek khul k mango 🤣 hum dete rahenge
Explain it in a very simple way.......hats off to your team......
Everyone should be equal to law...genral category also have low economic section...
Yesss
hope that would have been considered but the reservation is given to ensure representation of all parts of society
Yes their is EWS general
@@sigma_fail kya ghanta EWS
@@shekharpandey964 general se ho kya ?
All teachers of finology legal are legend😯😯
The initial reservation were only for sc &st article 15(4) and article 16(4). OBCs were included in the ambit of reservation in 1991 article 15(5)
Exactly obc was implented in support of BJP by VP singh govt and EWS was provide by Modi govt also OBC consist of 27%, it should be removed only reservation for SC ST ie 14% & 7% should be kept and 80% seats open for all
@@rajkaregakhalsa9367 Bang on. Absolutely agreed with you. OBCs are not socially backward. They do not deserve reservation. Thanks for speaking up.
@@mother.95 obc themselves discriminate the sc/st guys.
@@mother.95 please do not speak for all OBC people. There are many obcs whose families are still struggling to climb up the social ladder. They're still backwards socially and educationally despite the reservation being there since 1991. And if the reservation for OBC should be removed then so should be done for SC ST. Dekha jaye toh they have been provided reservation for too long and hence don't need it anymore like OBCs
@@rajkaregakhalsa9367 Will never happen due to dirty politics
Can I say u people are great, I mean how can someone make boring topics easy and interesting, loads of love ❤️❤️❤️❤️
It was in 1951 by the Virtue of 1st Constitutional Amendment Act, 1951 which amended the article 15(4) and 16(4) to enable the state and central government to reserve the seats for SC and ST in the government jobs and educational institutions.
Right
No ist ammendment act talks about genral advancement of socially and educationally backward classes. It's actally 93rd ammendment act which catagorically talks about reservation in educational institutions.
@@mother.95 you r right , actually this ammendment was made to nullify the decision of sup.court in champakkam dorairajan vs. state of Madras in which sc declared the law made by Madras govt in which they reserved seats in med and engineering colleges on the basis of religion ,race and caste. Sup.court declared the law to be void as it discriminates on the ground of caste etc and it's voilation of Art.15 . . Here backward includes sc and st . And other backward classes also, in both the clause 15(4 & 5)For sc and st there is a reservation since the commencement of constitution but obc had given recognition only after mandal commission .
@@uzmaamin1699 Thanks. You are not wrong in your first line of your First comment either. Right?
Bahot badiya padaya hai pura clear ho gaya thanks
It's high time to use latest census data for reservation and re evaluate whether 50% reservation is necessary or not. Reseravation is the only barrier for indian to become developed nation..
Jai hind
Reservation is not stopping India to becoming developed nation. If that was so,then what is stopping India to win medal in Olympic, there is no reservations there.
It's government policy which is hindering it. India spend less than 3% of GDP in education. Education was never in a priority list to any of our government.
@@AshishRanjan_in_iit a lot of undeserving candidates get selected through reservations. The ones who need it the most don't even know about it. So yes, major changes needs to happen in reservation system. And comparing reservations to sports is illogical, the sports scenario is totally different compared to this.
Reservations are there even in USA. Red Indians have reservations in all fields.
@@kangad4711 they arent undeseving but persecuted and they want equal representation in fields too lol...
U cant decide who is undeserving if u keep them.away from tbeir rights from 5000+years and think 70yrs of reservation can compensate it
@@PKSUN true...its all abt affirmative actions
Thanks you sister Iam from Nagaland.I am a 2nd comments n 2nd viewers.
India is on a stage that it should give reservations only on the basis of Economic conditions and not just no the basis of caste.
What about caste based atrocities and mind set of upper class people?
@@abhishekvarun7752 and what do you think with this caste based reservation system , will u be able to eradicate it ever
@@anamikasingh7356 people need to get educated plus many people doesn't even know the true meaning of reservation 🙏
Education is necessary that all...casteism is going on from thousands of years so surely it is impossible to eradicate in a year it will take time it's us the 3rd gen who can act on this. If u could understand!!
@@anamikasingh7356 .. Yes it is possible... I have seen many sc who are developed through reservation are now getting good status and atrocities also reduced..... And auntyji i belong to general caste
Best video of this topic on UA-cam
Happy Belated Teacher's Day to Team Of Finology Legal
Really cleared my so many doubts...Thank You finology legal😚
Reservation in educational institutions for Sc' and st's was provided by 93rd constitutional amendment Act 2005 under article 15(5) of indian Constitution
That was for OBC plz correct ur facts.
just wanna say Thank u finology legal for such a wonderful explanation.
I have a question : Doesn't 10% reservation for EWS violates limit of 50%?
I would say EWS is the most justified reservation so far in India. It ensures the general unreserved people from bigotry who are financially weak
10% for EWS category is for economically weaker sections in general category whereas 50% is for SC, ST, OBC so this 10% has nothing to do with 50%. It is not included in 50%.
@@_FinologyLegal mam since state can now make list on to decide which sub caste be included. Is it justified if the state violates 50% cap now?
@@_FinologyLegal 50% cap is on reservation, no where it is mentioned SC/ST/OBC only.
@@YadvendraSinghRawat 50% cap is on caste based reservation but EWS is not caste based so it was emplenented easily
Bap re abhi tk mujhe is channel k bare kyu nhi pta tha itna easy kon samjhata hai 🤥😀👌👌
By placing such extensive discussion on topic of "Reservation" the main subject of "Social Advancement of the Poorest Sections of Society" gets lost in the details and deliberations.
भाई अर्जुन यह सबसे "गरीब" के बारे में नहीं है यह "वंचित समाज" OBC के बारे में है, please understand reservation is for dipressed part of society... It's not proverty upliftment.. it's about representation of their own.. सुदामा आरक्षण जो गरीबी के आधार पर दिया जाता है without data with out numbers...
Ohh band karo yeh representation ka drama... Why not ending caste system all together..
Super se bhi upar .....gjb 😊
Thank you both 🙏🙏
the caste based census will break the social harmony and general category will become most deprived one.
And that thinking itself is what makes reservation at the first place
not really - private jobs are free of reservations and will likely stay that way for some time ... or migrate to places like uttrakhand where UC's have high population and will keep a tab on limit of reservations.
plus government jobs are less than 1% of all the jobs in the country - it doesn't make any difference - even for the sc st obc's if they get all the seats - why ?
because if for the past 70 yrs nothing has changed - it'll not change in the coming years , the creamy layer of sc st will keep getting benefits , rest will be deprived.
reservations are just political gimmicks.
@@nomadicbeing6750 what you said doesn't make any sense it's too vague.
it can be said about each and every problem in our nation...or even the world...
global warming ?
And that thinking itself is what makes reservation at the first place
algal blooms ?
And that thinking itself is what makes reservation at the first place
someone pooped their pants ?
And that thinking itself is what makes reservation at the first place
You should study history of indian and polity, may be that will change your mind. Yeah the reservation system should change with time, for example shey should also add economical status of the reservation holder as a criteria for issuing the certificate.
I literally appreciate your efforts. This video has good explanation. Thank you.
Glad it was helpful!
Very well explained 👏 tq for explaining in such a good way 👏❤️
This is the simple way to explain the amendments and laws , u guyz doing grt job
At least make the exam fees equal like ₹ 100 to all category at least the burden student will be reduced.
Wow impressed the way you guys explained...very very simple 👌
Do not forget to include EWS-10%
EWS kyu krege...ye So called Upper class jo haii..
@@YogeshSingh-jz6zj upper class nahi Dominant caste bolo. Aur dusro ko oppressed bolo.
Whatever you have taught through your video I got it everything thank you for sharing such beneficial and useful video with all of us .
We want 40 percentage reservation for economical Week person of any caste 🙃
We don't want caste discrimination
@Sharaddha Anand in that case , it's not "bro" it's brother
Very good explanation revision ho hya
Guys should our government really do the caste based census ? See my intension is not to hurt anyone thinking but my opinion is that if we talk about equality and all thing then why caste based census ? If the gov. Provide the reservation toh they should be examine very carefully who actually need the reservation . Not everyone in sc/st or obs are backward then why they come in that particular reservation . We all talking about the changes in society when this cast based census will change ???
Plz guys m not against about reservation . What i want to say is why caste based census ?
Yes it will. If there is a caste based census then we will have clear data as to which communities deserve reservation and which do not. It will help in better targetting of policies.
I am in support of Caste base census
Gr8 work by both of u
All over india ek merit. Honi chahiye
No EWS, sc, bc, obc...
Fight should v one on one 👍
Shahu Maharaj was the first to implement caste-based reservation in the modern era of India. He declared 50% reservations from which only four castes were excluded: 1) Brahmin 2) Shenvi 3) Prabhu and 4) Parsi. All other castes except these were declared as constituting the Bahujan Samaj.
It's high time general candidates should gather and raise voice against this whole reservation system..
Kb tk jheeloge mitro..
Jaha dekho waha reservation..
🥺🥺true
Oh geez! Stop blaming reservation for your failure!!🤦♀️🤦♀️
@@PlatypusPerry- dekho ab 50 jagah reservation lene waale bhi dusru ki kaabiliyat judge kr rhe hn..
@@manmohanrautela0731 EWS reservation ke baarey aaisa mat Bolo.....general category wale galli denge!! 🙄🙄
@@manmohanrautela0731 reservation lene waale kam kaabil hote hein, ye bol rahe ho?
Matlab, 10% EWS waale bhi mand-boodhi hai ya sirf dalito ko bewakoof bol rahe ho?
Hypocrite ho ya dimaag se lapahij?
Bahut hi badhiya
Very very thank to finology team
Complete explanation on the topic
Keep up this good work...
Bht educational factual shandar video
Thank you so much 😀
Sabse accha hai ki hum general category log apna alag country banale....bohot atchyachar ho rha abhi general category students ke sath...bhad me jaaye this shiiitty country named India.
🥺🥺🥺🥺 Bna hi lete h
@@neeloobharti6040 sach bol rha hun...agar govt abhi nhi jagi toh hume aazadi ki ladai ladni padegi....nhi toh yeh sarkar ka bas chale toh sab general category waalo ko bheekh mangne par mazbur kar denge....
What a joke atyachar ho raha h. Kitna victim card khelega be sab jagah tum log hindu muslim jatiwad or mob lynching promote karte ho. Hate spech me tum aage. Or upar victim card play karne aag gaye
@@kamartaj3010 jo khud paida hone se marne tak victim bana rahta hai ab wo mereko victim card khelna bta rha.....aur sabse jyada jaativad aur hindu muslim tum log karte ho....aur beta aage hai toh apne dum par reservation lekar nhi...
Aur phir yahi log kahte hai india develop kyu nhi ho rha...
Agar reservation raha toh India 100 saal baad bhi developing country hi rahega 😂.
bhai mai bhi general hu
but is chakkar mai India ko bura mat bolo
galti politicians ki hai
रोचक जानकारी देने के लिए धन्यवाद 🌷
I know after this comment many of u start criticizing or use abusive language.
But really I dont feel any emotional attachment with India which a citizen should have may be bcz of this reservation syst.
Central govt. very shrewdly assigned all the powers in its hands with 102 amendment. Good explaination.
The time has come when all types of reservations based on caste creed religion etc should be ended. The only Reservation left should be based on economic conditions and women.... The country should not demotivate deserving candidates in the name of Reservations . Vote bank politics is the main hurdle... Great political will is required to remove this evil..
Childish thought....roam around jhuggis and slum areas across the nation and Read Laxmikant, you might then realise how superficial thoughts you are living in it.
@@Viraj_2305 i don't believe that's a utopian idea of providing reservation on the basis of economic condition of the citizens as we are already doing so ( EWS - 10%) we only need to identify the loopholes in the EWS portion, the criteria is set for 8 lakh per annum which covers a good amount of population! Apart from that census taken based on caste and creed itself provides for caste based distinction and the benefits of reservation often don't even reach the needy. So the correct way of implementation of reservation is actually economic based census and provisions that matches the socio- economic conditions.
@@Viraj_2305 Thats why only EWS criteria should remain upto a certain percentage.
@@sejal8718 if you are coming to this conclusion based on the fact u mentioned, I must say that u have to read a lot to understand that ECONOMIC BASED reservation is not at all the solution of this. Bcz RESERVATION IS NOT A POVERTY ALLEVIATION PROGRAM .... It's representation of all the caste creed, races, gender, religion to bring equal social status. By ur method (economical basis) there wouldn't be any difference between a begger and bankrupt millioner afterall both are with zero economic status. How can be it same?No... अगर ऐसा होता तो सारे जहां में इकोनामिक बेसिस पर ही रिजर्वेशन होते हैं
@@Viraj_2305 yes i know that reservation is not a poverty alleviation programme, still does not justifies it efficiency after years of its implementation i believe now we can look forward for better methods to mainstreaming the downtrodden rather than just affecting the administrative efficiency. And why economic reservation should be provided is because they actually need the reservation to catch up into mainstream . Reservation right now is like a painkiller tablet which is just numbing the pain and not doing much for the disease. Reservation was very good policy when it was implemented but in current scenario it's a stagnant policy with very less relevance. And for the part where we want all sections to be equally representative ... we need this in parliament and legislative bodies so that they can be representative in policy formulation and not in jobs and colleges ! Apart from that i still don't understand if a we want a society based on no differences why are we providing reservation on that basis only? Rather find better methods? Haina?
Thanks ma'am ,I like your way of teaching ❤️💕 lot of loves from jammu
10% reservation to the EWS also violates indira sawhney's judgement...please explain this.
Bruh ews is under general category
@@democraticlegalservice3096 what do you mean by "Under general category"?
@CEO of Secularism but still it is a reservation
@@YadvendraSinghRawat it is not caste based reservation . Indra sahani case is regarding caste based reservation
Excellent lecture expect more from u mam on reservation landmark cases
My doubt: doesn't 10% reservation for EWS violates limit of 50% ?
50% cap is only for socially and educational background.
EWS not included. Games of words.
What's your problem with EWS
Are u SC?
EWS are not socially backward they are just economically backward.
@@shrutigupta4955 do you come from dominant caste?
amazing and qualitative work it is. Loads of thanks to the team behind this effort.
Being an OBC guy I thought lucky people are SC and ST because most of the exam which they didn't take money from sc/ st people .. But OBC have to pay same amount as general is paying 😒
Even they are getting college education free although I'm obc but i have to pay full fees like general i think reservation should be on financial base
@@manishayadav663 then why the govt is playing with OBC people 🥴😔
@@dragonproduction777 they are saying that reservations is also for obc but in reality it's totally different 😞
@@manishayadav663 you are right mam,, govt ko kuch karna hey bol ke kuch b kar le te hey.... 😑
aur toh bhai kuch khaash fayda v nhi milta mai jee me agar bhot niche wala nit/iiit aagr gen ke liye 95 percentile pe band hota h toh obc ka 94-94.5 pe 2 question ke fark aur Gate me toh score me toh lagbhag same rehta hai wahi neet ,me agar gen ko 650 pe x college milta hai toh obc ko 645 pe 🤐 ... wahi aur fir obc-ncl se thaa toh mujhe lga fees kam lgegi par IIITs me toh puri fees dena padta hai aur scholarship v nhi milti 🥲 sc-st ko scholarship v milti poora enjoy krte hai woh toh bekar hai ye obc reservation mai toh toot gaya
Great information for me and thanks a lot both of you
Reservation is only for name !! In reality there's only 1 or 2% beneficiary who aware of schemes. Lot of funds coming for various schemes in the name of these & all going to trap !!
That is so true.
mainly Savarnas people who remain in administration, steal those funds.
Best than anyone else
Since Vedas there was reservation!! 100% for Brahmins
Narasimha Swamy You have misunderstood it completely
Compete kro unse
@@rohanjha7116 kinse re babua? Kinse? 2000 saal se padhai likhai par brahmins ka 100% reservation tha. Tab to nahi chillaya ki kyon brahmin ko reservation hein. Ab 70 saal mein aag lag gayi?
@@Shubham_pandey-nk1un Nope. You understood it perfectly and still trying to be ignorant.
Mutual tolerance hona chahiya insaan mein jo aap mein nahi
Veda Vyasa’s extraordinary achievements are evidence that those who came from the Dalit and lower-caste communities
Vedas was assemble by sudhras vedvyas so how can a low caste vedvyas can assemble most of the vedas if they are not allowed to study
Vedvyas born due to intercaste marriage
Or itna gyaan de ra hai tujhe apni community ki nahi bhus apni padhi hai
Agar tum log kshatriya bantey matlab hathiyar othatey jab invasion horey thae toh tumlogon ki slavery kabhi nahi hoti
We are not the one who depressed you maurya empire,gupta period,harshvardhan empire were Kshatriya and brahmins who had protected India
That time land revenue was 1/6
After the invasion tax revenue increase to 10/11+ jaziya made to change most of your brother their religion
So go greece,Britain and central asia from where it was the origin of war on religion started and asked for your rights
Swamy naam rakhnae se gyaani nahi bantey padhna padta hai reservation boy
Incredible Presentation
👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
One day general seat will be zero.
If modi govt. increases reservation then General has to unite and make the union govt . They are doing this only for some votes of OBCs in elections.Very dirty game being played.
Kitna rote ho tumlog yar... thodi toh sharam rakho... hazaro saal se upper caste ne jo hakk chhina OBC ka...uski bharpaai kaise hogi ?
@@dami9186 Konsa upper caste , mera koi caste hai hi nahi. Jinone kiya tha o log mar gaye, tum bhi marke unse badla. Hum se badla mat. Bhar me gaye tum log . Reservation should be zero. Ghadhe koi naukri nahi.
I'm impressed by both of you ..how bilingually you explained everything 👍🏼
Instead of reservation, make education and medical free for economical weaker sections. Jobs should be merit based. Lebnon did the same, it constitutionalised religion based seats (same as caste reservation) today the country is facing bankruptcy and there is almost civil war like situation. If we don't stop this reservation madness here we will too face the same.
Education is sure to be made available for free but i disagree with medically. You're being too far leftist, cause Health care is service to mankind not a right to be obtained. Besides there are schemes and beneficiary available and we SC n ST have benefited from that
You are confusing Social Justice (Reservation) with Welfare State, while welfare state is for everyone, Reservation is for those who are socially outcaste till today..
Bhai shuv shuv bolo! 😭
Bewakoof mat bano... Lebanon ko Isis ne destroy kiya hai...
Pehle Lebanon bhi normal country tha, islamic hone ke vajah se barbaad hua, not due to caste based help to backward castes... Idiotic comment
Superb explanation in such a less time. Thankyou so much guys! 😊
Thank you finology legal ...you guys made my exam easy .. Such a nice explanation..thank you very much
Thanks a lot team Finology Legal 👏
6:35 ma'am according to Supreme Court 50% se reservation extend ni honi chahiye but hm EWS categories ke log ko jo 10% reservation mili hai then usse milakr toh 60% ho jati hai ????
Ews general category mai fall krta hai
@@democraticlegalservice3096 but ye toh overall seat me se hin na 10% reserve ho ri hai...I mean baaki general category ke seat me se hin n 10% jaa rahi hai
@@ashishraulin 50 % reservation cap is for socially and educationally backward classes of citizens whereas EWS is for economically backward sections of citizens. Hence, that 10% won't be accounted. Just a game of words. 🙂
Ews is a caste neutral Reservation policy.
yeahh u all r right it's a great step taken by Govt. By the way I'm eligible for EWS certificate but the process is quit complicated that's why I didn't made it till now 😊
Awesome & very Informative in easy way. Thank you
Sir/Ma'am, EWS got extra 10% reservation. It bypass the 50%cap. How it didn't get scrapped ?
@Raj Singh I don't think what you are saying is related to my question and the videos. I'm expressing my doubt, a/c to Indra Sawhney judgement reservation cant be exceed 50%, but we'd 50% reservation (SC/T+OBC). How could EWS be put in reservation ?
@Raj Singh why don't you talk about casteism in India?
@@Ailee-Jaw 50% was for caste based reservation but EWS was not caste based reservation
@@mother.95 yeah sc st need reservation but not obc , where you see yadav got discrimination ? I can say obc are just another form of EWS category only sc sts are real victim and I can admit that
@@abhinavpandey840 Finally one sensible comment in 600 comment. Phew. I had almost given up.
Edit: And coming from a 'Pandey' , it makes me happy. You are one of us.
Thanks very much teacher and really awesome work 👌and now waiting for u r next important vedio 🙂
10:36 ceiling of 50 percent in reservation was put on by MR balaji vs state of mysore not in indira sawhney case
Very nice explained
First of all, why the reservation??, Second why subsidies??.
These two things killed India's progress, India was a skilled, righteous and duty bound citizens who never ever begged or demanded for their basic rights and authority.
Handful of British to rule these large number of subjects wanted sympathizers, followers, slaves, stooges in to their side, so the reservation devil came onto the picture.
Due to these two draconian law, all learned,educated, professional are drained out and settled abroad and doing miracle over there.
Instead of this, try to encourage the uneducated to do education, while giving that try to give them the knowledge of current affairs, technological advances etc.
All tribes were skilled in an PERTICULAR way, caste is not even herd in india till 18th century.
Anyway when last benchers,useless fellows start these rules and regulations one cannot do anything.
Hahahahahahahahahahahahhahahhahahahha
Right ✅🥲
Your lack of knowledge combined with confidence is fascinating.
so much stupidity this comment has
Ooh shut up plzz ,,subsides are important for the poor farmers and people who are really i. Need . But we have to stop the loopholes which are perform in name of subsides .
Pls correct the fact:
Reservation was not for 70 years it was initially for 10 years. Day by day,year by year it was extended by 10 years with constitutional amendments.
No offence
You all are doing great work,keep it up.
It was for 10 years only in politics. It was *not fixed* for education/promotion.
_Half-knowledge makes you a dangerous person_
@@mother.95 Bhai to bta dete simply, apne to dangerous tak phcha diya,Jabki ap iski jagah thora or bta dete to mera concept ban jata 🌝
Educational Reservation was given in 2002 by 86th Amendment.
Was it?
SC/ST got their educational provision through 1st amendment. OBC s got it through 93rd.
Check it again and correct me please?
Explaining in a very good way. you guys thank you sir
Why can't govt provide reservation to those who are financially weak , now we are not living in 1950s , sc, St , OBC or general ,we can't decide their status just by these categories. Why the heck real talent has to suffer . Give reservation to those who really deserves . But to be honest this reservation system should not exist anymore , this is cheating to those who prepared hard and not getting the seat bcoz of reservation!!
R u an advocate?
@@mukeshmittal5341 no I'm preparing for clat 2023
@@wander_lust.13 where r u from??
Exactly. It's an easy way to escape responsibility. Government hasn't been able to do grassroot work , so they are trying to fix this mistake by providing reservation. No body wants to know why don't government provide good education to SC/ST/OBC kids so they can perform well and do good in life ,but why work so hard , when you cam make the community happi by providing a lollipop.
@@needhisingh7274 ya , doing all these analysis and then finding a cure for it would be difficult and time consuming ,so what is easier for them is providing reservation. That's what they are doing , zero responsibility=zero development in education sector !
Nice mam sir knowledge and class
SC/ST act has been misused and used this law as a weapon by some people just to escape the law from any kind of illegal activities. They just file a police complaint stating that he/she was abused by a upper cast person by calling him as a ******. If a person of upper cast is abused by a person from the SC/ST community and then can the upper cast person file a complaint for abusing his community ?
Your unsolicited comments diluting the basic concepts & purpose of this video presentation.
Basically you should understand that FINOLOGY is an educational platform to transfer the knowledge and explain the statutes to the viewers. FINOLOGY never invited any one to debate on disputes in this section.
If you are aggrieved of any dispute, we have a strong judiciary and fight legally. Never give vague statements. If you have case laws, please provide them for our use.
Try to understand, FINOLOGY has not given any undertakeing to anyone with respect to implimentation or usage of statutes or IPC or CRPC.
Hence hereinafter, being an educated person, before making any statement think twice and post. We appreciate If you are ready with relevant case laws pertaining to the matter under consideration.
@@ramulugouri5768. Look Any law enacted to uplift any community is good in a Democracy but in India people don't respect the law and the Judiciary is watching all kinds of illegal activities of people and policiticians as a mute spectator. Therefore, explaining about law is irrelevant for me and my point of view is to create awareness amongst people to follow the law and respect the same as law abiding citizen. Some people misuse the same law which was enacted for their own upliftment and that is my problem.
@@Soldier85409 Understood that you are not an Advocate.
Please approach an advocate to find solution to your queries.
@@ramulugouri5768 It is not necessary to be a lawyer to understand the law. You are taking about the job reservation for SC/ST and other community people but due to hard scale authorization even in Army these percentage of quota will not serve any purpose.
Nice. Beautifully explained.👍
Reservation for first time was added by KAKA KELKAR COMMISSION. It was the first commission for granting and prividing for reservation to SC/ST in Independent India.
Bhai isne hi bola tha ki meine Jo obc ka data calecylt Kiya mei bhi rji nai hu isiliye obc ko Jada reservation nai mila
@@mohandhande7874 OBCs do not deserve reservation.
@@mother.95 if OBCs don't deserve reservation then so do general category!!
@@PlatypusPerry- Only SC/ST deserve reservation. No one else.
Thank you again for a detail explanation on this topic
Then the EWS reservation also exceeds the 50% (indra sahani statement)
आपके चैनल द्वारा इन लोगों को भी हिंदी दिवस की बधाई जो भारत देश की मातृभाषा को छोड़कर अंग्रेजी में ही कॉमेंट कर रहे हैं अंग्रेज़ी गुलाम कही के। 🙏🏻
Thank you
Awesome video 👍👏 full of knowledge 👌👏
doesn't 10% reservation for EWS violates limit of 50% ?
Then don't take your reservation for SC/ST
EWS reservation is out of that 50% which is for general candidate..
If you leave your OBC quota and you are poor enough in front of govt. Then you can also get EWS reservation.
It is for everyone who is poor. And is not enjoying any reservation.
Very well explained..and much needed amendment 👍
Missing factual data currently reservation even the EWS in on the basis of caste
Ur giving false info.
Ews is not based on caste .
Its just given to people who are already not given any reservation.
@@zeegamesandtech2002 Agreed
@@karanbirsingh3102 Poore samaj ko gaali de rahe ho, aur phir bolte ho ki Jaatiwad kaha hai desh mein, kyon de Reservation. Akal se lapahij hein kya ji tum?
Thanks for the short and Crisp informative videos.
Pls. Speech in English because we are from south indian. Particularly we are from Tamil Nadu.
So what ....if u learnt english then u shld learn hindi also 😒
@@Batman-cx8ce stop it bro. It's his choice which language he wants to speak. Don't impose hindi on him.
Sir ji go their Insta story, they have uploaded the video in English.
@@Batman-cx8ce No man you should not force anybody to learn hindi
They can then force us to learn Tamil
Rahul Ravi Sorry for my brother's mistake
Thanks yar..... Very well explanation 👌🏻
Thanks and welcome