Am I the only one who didn't think Michael was the killer from the start? He seemed genuinely distressed, his story stayed the same and he was completely cooperative with police from the second they arrived. Really makes you wonder how many completely innocent people are sitting in prison. It's terrifying.
The hard part about all of this is that it's really hard sometimes to base innocence just on actions. So many people are assumed guilty if they don't act a certain way, even if they are on the spectrum or any other diagnoses that alter their behavior. And even those that don"t will get seen as sus by police just because they have a hunch based on nothing.
Is the first guy I see in total panic . This guy didn’t even care he was accused … he was just trying to recover and keep telling them what happened. Glad to see he was not guilty and very sad to hear what happened to her.
A lot of people would dismiss him and letting the "sus" assumption that they already pre-conceived get into their brains. Officers ofc would put him as a suspect until evidence is shown. That's only natural.
Yeah all these people saying they were suspicious of him until the ring video make me so upset. Ive seen guilty and that was NOT guilty plus the fact that he was coherent but panicked and she had obviously only recently been attacked.
No way. They just would’ve had to keep digging. The restraining order and stuff would’ve been easy to find and investigate. The roommate was very willing to cooperate and they wouldn’t have been able to match any DNA.
@@erichiesha4070 and the cops probably really thought it was him too. That mustve been one of the worst nights of his life. Finding your roommate dead and almost being the prime suspect
Idk. I feel bad for him but at the same time he quite literally lived there and could have gone in to help her as he was hearing it happen. He cowered while it happend and then let the guy escape. Had he had the slightest bit of courage she may still be alive.
This is so frustrating. Imagine all of the innocent people calling police, and you’re always considered the first suspect just because you called the them.
It’s completely reasonable though. Police and detectives have to be 100% objective when it comes to these cases. Some criminals are good at acting, so if every cop went based off of feeling and guesses we’d have a lot more criminals running freely. Everyone on the crime scene is a potential suspect.
For real, tbh, if this happened to me (God forbid), me being stupid everytime I'm in distressed, plus my extreme anxiety, would 100% called the police asap without thinking anything, and maybe get my self in trouble
First half of the video: "Amie had no enemies. She was loved by everyone, no one ever wanted to hurt Amie. She had no bad relationships with anyone. Amie wad no enemies at all ever." Second half of the video: "So Amie had a serial stalker for 10 years and told everyone about it"
"She had no known enemies" "...except for her abusive boyfriend, she had to file twice to get a protective order against, who harassed, stalked, and broke into her house" If youre gonna be melodramatic at least be honest
yeah, and think of all the people agreeing with the sentence and denouncing those people as evil. people see these videos and just believe the conviction. literally the only reason everyone believes he's innocent and is denouncing innocents being sent to jail is because of the ring footage. if he'd been found guilty and sentenced, everyone here in the comments would be saying the complete opposite, even though in reality he's 100% innocent.
Imagine the guilt he has for being a coward and for being unarmed. People need to start taking responsibility for themselves, their homes and their loved one's (and friends). We do not just have the Right to self defense and the defense of our loved one's, but it is our Duty. This man will forever have to suffer the knowledge that he eft himself and his roommate undefended and she died while he cowered, completely defenseless.
Some people are just naturally sus. Sounds funny, but ppl go to jail for nothing all the time. Just because the cops knows he can do it and forget about it.
not really he answered questions without really thinking no pausing when answering or playing for time to think. it was the blood on his hands and being the only person present is which made him a suspect.
@@darthsaint7743 unfortunately if a man and a woman live together and/or have some history together and she's murdered then he is suspect number 1 until proven otherwise. I worry sometimes my ex wife will be murdered because I know they will assume I did it 😂
The weed smoking being somehow linked to a deadly nicotine syringe is like saying "yeah that guy has a pet cat so he probably has access to rattle snake poison, y'know …seeing as how he is familiar with animals!" ??????
She was seizing too at the time and I can tell you it is horrific to watch that happen, even without the blood and other injuries of having been attacked.
@@PrincessPebbles0_0I mean they still can’t rule out anyone, they need to make sure they have the right person, so they have to treat everyone as a suspect until they’re not. In this case the roommate did have markings on his body and blood on his hands, so it’s understandable why the cops and detectives had him as a suspect at first until their investigation proved otherwise
Poor guy seemed to be suspecious because of his vibrant personality but actually, he is the best roomate who was there for her when she was in real trouble. He was also so honest to the police by declaring that he smoked weed with out a fear that it would make him look bad in the eyes of the authorities. He desrves love and respect if you ask me.
How was he "there for her"? She was screaming and he did nothing to stop the attack. He called 911 and hung out waiting like a wuss. He could have saved her and did nothing.
@@24sumo Yeah hindsight 20/20 but his mere presence in that moment could have been the difference. We all like to think in that moment we would be heroes, i don't think i would hangout waiting for the police after hearing my roommate cry for help, but I've also never been in a situation even close to that.
A real answer rather than anger fueled retorts. Our prison system is a for profit organization, not one for rehabilitation. By allowing bonds they are able to make money of the person without putting them into a cell while waiting on trial. Our "innocent until proven guilty" process means, legally, he isn't guilty of the crime until trial and therefore has the legal right to freedom while awaiting trial.
Restraining orders only work for people who care about not going to jail. People who care about not going to jail, never have restraining orders on them to begin with.
Tell that to the courts then!! You can't arrest someone until they RO is issueys and they break it. It's literally the only way unless they catch him in the act. Ya'll know nothing about life yet be commenting in complete confidence 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
I had an ex co worker who had her ex husband stalking her. She had a restraining order and the cops didn't do anything when she called them, because he would leave before they arrived. They told her they can't do anything unless they catch him in the act. Restraining orders do nothing. Get a fire arm and get trained on how to use it. That will keep you a lot safer then some piece of paper.
Right?! I came to comment this, how tf was he given bond? Immediately tried to flee the country smh. I watched the trial and never knew this detail. Ridiculous
It sounds like you don't understand psychopathy. Psychopathy isn't something you can just prevent by raising your child properly. These are people who literally can't experience remorse. Even as children they are known to torture small animals (like rodents or cats) or having a fascination with arson. Their brains are broken from the start.
Nah, they would need proof of his guilt and they wouldn't be able to find any. Just being suspected by cops doesn't automatically mean you'll lose your Freedom/life. They would have to have evidence that places him at the scene at the time of the murder and they never would have found it. He cowered, so he never had any chance of his footprints being in blood, or having blood on his clothes, or having her blood on him at all, etc... etc... We still have Rights in this country, like the Right to be presumed innocent, the Right to an attorney, the Right to a fair trial and an jury, etc... etc...
What? That’s no true at all. What about the DNA? His alibi? You guys are all so over dramatic it’s insane. The is man was never arrested at all. Nothing happened to him. If the cops find a man covered in blood in a house with a dead lady what should they do? Not ask him wtf happened? You guys act like 99% of people Cops deal with lie to them
And that is how innocent people are wrongly accused and convicted of a crime they didn't commit. Thank God for Ring cameras, or the roommate would be in prison for life. Talk about lucky.
No, not in this case. There was no forensic evident to tie him to the scene of the crime(her bedroom) and Gareth's well-known history with Amie would have always drawn the attention to him, ring camera or not.
He wasn’t wrongly anything. He was questioned as anyone should be in this situation. A child was murdered and dumped in the woods by our house. Cops knocked on everyone’s doors to ask what happened and if we saw anything. We immediately all talked to them and helped and gave our camera footage. No one saw anything and no cameras did. But what should we have done? Turned the cops away? wtf. There was a dead CHILD that deserved our help. His mother and her boyfriend killed him and drove to our state to dump him here. Very sad. But I can’t imagine being a crazy person like you and not help the cops and that poor boy in that situation. Because what you’re saying is I should have not said anything, kept my cameras to myself, and paid $1,000 for an attorney to say no comment 😢you people are evil
Being a suspect means u r on a waiting list between guilty or innocent. U r basically noted as a potential criminal link with the crime in question. That's it.
Anyone else find it ridiculous how nonchalant everyone is and how no one’s in a rush? You would think they would send an ambulance BEFORE going to the house where someone was attacked. If she had any chance the officers and responders on the phone took it from her. What a shame.
That's why you should DRIVE someone to the hospital if possible, instead of waiting for an ambulance. They ALWAYS move slow as Hell, it took them 15 minutes (!) from arriving at our house, to get my mom in the ambulance! Just casual af, I learned my lesson that night!!
From my understanding EMTS/first responders don’t go straight to the injured unless the crime scene is locked down & secured by law enforcement. In this case they don’t know if the attacker was still in the house or if there was multiple attackers. @mike yes that also depends on the situation. If it was a physical accident that you could control that was caused by yourself or friends/family member… sure… but in this case it’s a crime scene & you don’t wanna tamper with anything until authorities get there and start their investigation .
When I broke my arm, my bone went through the skin, and I was bleeding. It took them an hr and 12 mins before anyone came, the fire fighters got to me first. My friends immediately called 911 within the minute I fell down because they saw my bone. Yet it still took them long.
Absolutely unbelievable. How many times the poor guy had to repeat himself and the urgency. From the time he made the 911 call to the arrival of the officers. Who trains these people?
@@amberstorm1139imagine calling someone Karen for saying disrespecting the dead is disgusting. Kid get off the internet and stop watching narrating Reddit post channel.
I had a stalker for over 10 years. Never saw his face. It was the days before cameras. Even getting married and having kids only escalated his behavior. A police man suggested that I gain weight. At about 175, I lost him.
This is so funny and sad at the same time. I’m so sorry about this!! Must’ve been really scary! Was it someone you knew? I was never stalked to this extent but I was followed once going to the store to get groceries despite me being on the heavier side. After this experience I’ve opted to carry a sharp pen with me in my pocket ever since but the paranoia nor anxiety never really goes away
Damn, that's terrible. I had protected a friend of mine for a couple weeks one time when a guy was stalking her and she was a mess. The mental and emotional stress was overwhelming for her. She was well under 21, but I ended up getting a gun for her and it possibly ended up saving her life. Her stalker finally found a time when she was in a dark "transitional space" and came up behind her, but she expected him and had her gun in her hand already. It was the first and last time she ever saw his face. She believes that he never covered his face, because he had planned to kill her and seeing his face didn't matter. In the end though, he was never identified and we still have no idea who he was (over 20 years later). Your comment reminded me of the whole situation and now I'm wondering if I should suggest for her to go through mug shots and the sex offender website to see if he was ever arrested before or after that. I think the sex offender registry existed before that... or at least I think that sex offenders from those days will be on there also if they're still alive. I don't think he could ever be charged for stalking her though after so long. They never indicted him at that time, so the statute of limitations would make it impossible to have him charged. (My x brother in law stabbed my sister years ago and although he fled and was never caught, he was indicted, so the statute of limitations will never protect him from being charged if he's ever caught, even if 50 years goes by).
Narrator needs to be better. Mentioning things that weren’t correct. No masked man, the roommate didn’t try medical and other minor issues. Good video, but get narration right for 10/10. Right now it’s 7/10.
I agree that they sound incredibly aggravating, but they're trained to get people to repeat things to make them clear, and also to keep people on the phone talking while stuff is going on. They don't want incomplete, unclear phone calls that end too soon.
Dude, I don’t think you understand what they’re trying to do. The dispatcher is both gathering information and keeping the caller calm without them hanging up. They literally just need you to be talking the whole time. You could say some important information, you could go into a panic which makes it worse for first responders, they’re job is get your info, send people, then do investigation
they're called "defense attorney", they're ensuring the client receives a fair trial by protecting their constitutional rights and to prevent wrongful convictions since there was no evidence if he threw her to the ground then its fair to assume that she fell whilst trying to escape
Another reason why it’s good science has gotten to where it is, because she had DNA under her fingernails that matched Garret. If they never saw the video footage it’s likely the DNA would’ve removed Micheal as a suspect cause it wouldn’t have matched
It's like that with a lot of these true crime vids - way too many details reiterated and overexplaining unimportant stuff.. I blame some sort of automated Ai script the authors are utilizing
@@veezopolis hit the nail on the head 🎉 i believe his exact words were "she had no known enemies among her friends and family" like her enemies would tell the cops they were her enemies? Lol.
All this video tells me is if someone is being murdered I need to just mind my own business or they're going to send me to jail for calling the police lol
Kills one person that's a "celebrity" and gets life sentence without parole, yet i keep seeing other people kill 3-5 others and get 20 years or 40 years. What is this system
Premeditation is what constitutes 1st degree murder which is life w/o parole. a 2nd degree murder charge might be what caused those ppl to get less time.
That's right it's okay to be suspicious, but they need to reserve their comments for after the investigation to not make biased conclusions. If i had their mentality every time i said a pitbull, I'd never work in the animal field. It's called professionalism, and unfortunately police across the nation have little to none at all and allow their emotions to dictate actions and thoughts.
He was super in shock too, these cops were horrible. They didn't have any patience with him at all, just told him stuff like "breathe" and "calm down" which I don't think is the thing to do as a trained cop
i thought they had tech that can sharpen a blurred image or zoom in on the damn face. i guess that is only on tv shows or when they choose to actually do any work.
Yes lets automatically blame the police for being reasonable, its a form of suspecting people, and usually people who report crimes including murderers can sometimes be the culprit, do you know how suspicious it sounds for 1. Being the only person on site 2. Being the only witness on site 3. Having wounds that the "Suspect" can't explain Cops have to come to quick assumptions and make sure evidence isn't destroyed, so they take the prime suspect which is usually a person who is closely related to the victim or the only person present during the crime, the United States as you might know is based off of a Innocent until proven guilty, this situation may seem like its contradicting it but he's still innocent, and their following regular procedure to make sure that he IS innocent whilst the evidence is still present and "Fresh"
I've just discovered this channel and I absolutely love the stories being told after their conclusion. The video evidence and testimony makes everything come together so well. Great story telling.
What a ridiculous comment. C'mon now. There was plenty of other evidence, like the murderer's DNA under her nails. Do you really think that NEVER would have come up?
@nittygritty7503 not necessarily. A lot of times, this type of situation, without the cameras, would make the cops get tunnel vision and hone in on him. He could've 100% been charged and probably convicted.
@@kimberlyhayes6006 He wouldn't have been convicted or even charged for that matter. As soon as they ran the DNA that was found under her fingernails, that alone *should* clear him.
No crime is complete, her fingers has his DNA, she was fighting the killer, and the other proofs, the ring made everything easy to recognize the killer
Caller: "Somebody just attacked my room-mate and she is there upstairs, screaming." 911 : "Is she screaming for help?" That's the most disturbing thing I have ever heard since 19 December 2002, it was on a Friday.
That defense was absolutely ridiculous. "Ahhh yes, she was just scared and fell off the balcony.". Honestly, kudos for that lawyer for not trying very hard...
It's a reminder that we don't just have the Right to bear arms and to defend ourselves and those around us... but the Duty to do so. He literally cowered on the phone while she was being murdered, because he didn't even have the basic tools that were available to him. No he's going to have to remember that for the rest of his life. His roommate was murdered, because he didn't save her.
10:22 I’m confused… in the body cam, he had said that he was sleeping and the narrator says that “he came home and heard screams.” Not only that but again in the body cam, it seemed like he just found Amie on the ground along with the cops and on the 911 call, he didn’t mention finding her… but the narrator says that Michael was giving her CPR while cops came?? What? Either you didn’t get the story straight or maybe the way the story was presented in the video is confusing 😅
He killed her because he was so jelous of her,that she was smart, Beautiful,successful and famous,she was all what he wanted to be, that's why he was asking his losers friends to make a Book about him. What an envious loser
Why? Everyone’s a suspect till they’re not. Especially a MALE roommate with an attractive dead woman. The police were just trying to get up to speed (imo) at the scene and didn’t know what they had. Just my take anyways
Then they checked all the evidence and realised he wasn't. Hard call to make but you can't just let someone walk away from a murder scene if they're covered in blood spatter.
@da1uheardabt that's right have 0 argument against what he said so you just call him dumb for disagreeing with you. What do you expect the guy was the last person to see her alive obviously he'd be a suspect?
Judge that gave him a BOND to be allowed out of custody SHOULD be sentenced to 6 months in Jail. That is absolutley BS that he was given a CHANCE to ESCAPE his murder charges!!! That is NOT OK! HOW? HOW? HOW IS THAT EVEN POSSIBLE!!! 😮
I'd trust someone who suffered from abuse better to help me than someone who has always been out of that loop, bc they understand better what the bottom of the barrel look like and help you climb back out just as good
@@Chillaxpepper She would have to have it figured out first. Which means she would manage to form healthy relationship herself before trying to help others achieve it.
How is that remotely her fault? Men are abusive shitheads; take it up with them, not the women they abuse. "Oh she didn't immediately read this lunatics mind and find out he was gonna murder her; boo it's her fault". Save the life of a future woman; maybe don't raise any kids. You don't have the mindset conducive to healthy, stable relationships.
She doesn’t have enemies, except that guy she has reported for stalking and abuse for years and had a restraining order on. But her roommate is a suspect.
It is pretty messed up but I would assume it has something to do with "innocent until proven guilty" and the nature of the crime. A mass murder suspect wouldn't get bail.
comedians are a little depressed or have some odditys but this dude was straight up messed up in the head thats why he wasn't funny. If he focused on his jokes rather than stocking he probably would've done better for himself smh
The urgency of the response and the cops on scene was so casual, there was an attack in progress for crying out loud! I wonder if they had responded quicker, went in immediately with paramedics they might have been able to save her.
Major ego couldn't take rejection, even though he was physically abusing her. Years of seething revenge from someone you casually dated. Imagine having children with such a narcissist.
My sisters x husband (she had a daughter with) cheated on her several times and was having a relationship with at least one other woman when my sister decided to leave him... so he ended up stabbing her. She's okay now and he's still wanted by the state of NY and the FBI... but it just goes to how what kind of person it takes to be like that. Just the mere suspicion (without any evidence) that she was cheating on him threw him into a fit, as he was literally having sex with other women. Then when she decided to leave him it was the last straw for him. He was a narcissist and a coward and he couldn't handle the consequences of his own actions.
@@deucedeuce1572 sorry that happened to your sister, but i mean, she chose him...if the guy was an angel with no criminal record, that's one thing. If he was a known pos, that's another thing. Women, choose better men!
Wait a minute… I thought it was said that the guy (roommate) locked himself out and couldn’t get back over the fence or something to that effect… but in the video, it says that he found the front door open and her body and gave her CPR until the ambulance arrived… he never mentioned that on the 911 call. Am I completely missing something? I mean, the video clearly shows him discovering her the same time that the police did???
That confused me too. He made it seem like he didn’t know if she was in danger but apparently had already discovered her body. Maybe it was edited weird. So I’m guessing he heard screaming, called 911 but didn’t want to check on her because he feared there was a weapon involved, eventually went down and found her, went for help but locked himself out, tried scaling the fence but injured himself, cops arrive and they successfully go over the fence, and maybe the shock we’re hearing is witnessing her having a seizure?
I don't understand how we are still thinking that a piece of paper is going to keep someone away ... Do y'all know how many people end up dead by the people who have a restraining order? It's something we need to look into and fix
Right? Im still confused about where he was when he heard that.. he said he was alseep and some other stuff, but confusing.. If it werent for those cameras😮😮😮😮😮😮
He smokes weed. That can make some people paranoid. Also does he look like the type of guy that can fight? Probably feels guilty about it now. Also who knows if he would've been killed too. Don't forget what happened to Nicole Brown Simpson & Ron Goldman.
@@mikeydude750 The Constitution doesn't mandate bail/bond and many people are denied bail/bond when the evidence against them is strong and it's a bad enough crime. You also shouldn't speak as if you know the law when you so clearly know Nothing at all.
What behavior? All they did was question him and cleared him? What if they do besides think logically? They see a blood man and a dead woman. Should they not question that person? When 99% of the time it’s the person you live with that kills you.. I don’t get what they did that’s so awful.
You can’t ways read a persons emotional response to trauma. I was definitely impulsive to who appeared to be the culprit through the initial body cams. Also, huge respect to the officers who walk up to this.
This dude better give a five star review to Ring cameras. They are why he isn’t in prison for life.
I
DNA under her fingernails is what saved him.
@@bullymonkeybaby9000 exactly
yeah also he had solid alibi and witnesses. And no forensic trace on the victim. He never had any possibility of being convicted, ring camera or not
There was no need for a ring camera to figure out that crazy nutjob did it. So many clues, no wonder many of you bums will never be detectives.
Am I the only one who didn't think Michael was the killer from the start? He seemed genuinely distressed, his story stayed the same and he was completely cooperative with police from the second they arrived. Really makes you wonder how many completely innocent people are sitting in prison. It's terrifying.
The hard part about all of this is that it's really hard sometimes to base innocence just on actions. So many people are assumed guilty if they don't act a certain way, even if they are on the spectrum or any other diagnoses that alter their behavior. And even those that don"t will get seen as sus by police just because they have a hunch based on nothing.
Is the first guy I see in total panic . This guy didn’t even care he was accused … he was just trying to recover and keep telling them what happened. Glad to see he was not guilty and very sad to hear what happened to her.
A lot of people would dismiss him and letting the "sus" assumption that they already pre-conceived get into their brains.
Officers ofc would put him as a suspect until evidence is shown. That's only natural.
Yeah all these people saying they were suspicious of him until the ring video make me so upset. Ive seen guilty and that was NOT guilty plus the fact that he was coherent but panicked and she had obviously only recently been attacked.
Me too. He sounded legitimately concerned and scared.
"He's very shakey" yeah dude its called adrenaline from someone breaking in and then hearing the roommates scream.
That part pissed me off so much.
His pupils are black, suspicious
I couldn't believe he said such a ridiculous thing. Of course he's Shakey. He just heard his roommate being murdered.
the police, "what do we do"
damn if you do and damn if you don’t. Even if he was calm they would still attack him for being calm.
If Ring didn't exist, that poor roommate would have 100% been convicted.
it is outrageous how they can somethimes force false confessions out of people
crystal ball science
@colinsss3019 he didn't falsely confess, he just looked and sounded guilty af and his story was terrible.
Thanks to Shaq!
No way. They just would’ve had to keep digging. The restraining order and stuff would’ve been easy to find and investigate. The roommate was very willing to cooperate and they wouldn’t have been able to match any DNA.
I feel for the roommate like how traumatized is he now
He couldn’t stop shaking the whole interview poor guy
@@erichiesha4070 and the cops probably really thought it was him too. That mustve been one of the worst nights of his life. Finding your roommate dead and almost being the prime suspect
Idk. I feel bad for him but at the same time he quite literally lived there and could have gone in to help her as he was hearing it happen. He cowered while it happend and then let the guy escape. Had he had the slightest bit of courage she may still be alive.
I feel like if i heard a scream I wouldve gone in with a weapon to see who it was
@@A_Goat Exactly!
So you mean to tell me they HAVE HIM ON TAPE murdering someone and they STILL released him back into society??
Two words: Cali & Fornia
Keep voting for Democrats and it'll continue.
White privilege . Keeping it real
@@TheErockaustin Okay child marriage state
2 words. Role playing chat room
This is so frustrating. Imagine all of the innocent people calling police, and you’re always considered the first suspect just because you called the them.
That’s normal. There’re many cases that the caller was a murderer. Not the only thing, but that should be the first thing they consider IMO
The police would suspect the roommate out of all the billions of other people anyways 😅
It’s completely reasonable though. Police and detectives have to be 100% objective when it comes to these cases. Some criminals are good at acting, so if every cop went based off of feeling and guesses we’d have a lot more criminals running freely. Everyone on the crime scene is a potential suspect.
You do know why… right?
For real, tbh, if this happened to me (God forbid), me being stupid everytime I'm in distressed, plus my extreme anxiety, would 100% called the police asap without thinking anything, and maybe get my self in trouble
That Hershey's joke should've added years to his sentence.
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
Ideally capital punishment
Facts
it's just highlighting delusion
I can imagine how the roommate’s struggle has been in coping up with the trauma. Wishing him all the best.
His reaction to seeing her on the ground😢😢😢 poor guy
How do you explain why you need a new roommate 😐
He probably had to move because I doubt he could afford the rent on that place on his own.
@@georgejones3526 What a wonderfully thought out and informative comment you've made. Thanks so much for your needed input, George Jones.
@
You are very welcome.
"this masked individual was responsible for this murder." proceeds to show videos of his bare face.
😂
This shit is so foul
Damn, "I wonder how we're ever going to be able to identify him".
i'm sure they can reduce the blur of the camera but our justice system is so inept its scary.
They didn't had problem with pointing at roommate as murderer. No evidence on their side too.
First half of the video: "Amie had no enemies. She was loved by everyone, no one ever wanted to hurt Amie. She had no bad relationships with anyone. Amie wad no enemies at all ever."
Second half of the video: "So Amie had a serial stalker for 10 years and told everyone about it"
They uncover that Amy had a history of troubled relationships and many people had it out for her.
@@Bantybantsmomentsfunny coming from someone that it a relationship therapist 😂
They literally mention that she had an abusive stalker by 1:25 seconds in...
@@sherriebrown8318 They literally don't say that.
Lmfaom
"She had no known enemies"
"...except for her abusive boyfriend, she had to file twice to get a protective order against, who harassed, stalked, and broke into her house"
If youre gonna be melodramatic at least be honest
The justice system failed her
Imagine the number of innocent people who are in prison......RIGHT NOW!😢😢
That's the most important reason why no one should talk to the police without an attorney. That includes questioning, even if one is not under arrest.
yeah, and think of all the people agreeing with the sentence and denouncing those people as evil. people see these videos and just believe the conviction. literally the only reason everyone believes he's innocent and is denouncing innocents being sent to jail is because of the ring footage. if he'd been found guilty and sentenced, everyone here in the comments would be saying the complete opposite, even though in reality he's 100% innocent.
Yah they all are innocent, give me a break!
Imagine the guilt he has for being a coward and for being unarmed. People need to start taking responsibility for themselves, their homes and their loved one's (and friends). We do not just have the Right to self defense and the defense of our loved one's, but it is our Duty. This man will forever have to suffer the knowledge that he eft himself and his roommate undefended and she died while he cowered, completely defenseless.
My dad is and he has been in one for 13 y . He didn't do anything but in Iraq a lot of innocent people be like that in jail
Not gonna lie. The roommate was sus until i saw the Ring camera. What's crazy is if it it wasn't there, he may be in jail.
Some people are just naturally sus. Sounds funny, but ppl go to jail for nothing all the time. Just because the cops knows he can do it and forget about it.
not really he answered questions without really thinking no pausing when answering or playing for time to think. it was the blood on his hands and being the only person present is which made him a suspect.
@@darthsaint7743 unfortunately if a man and a woman live together and/or have some history together and she's murdered then he is suspect number 1 until proven otherwise. I worry sometimes my ex wife will be murdered because I know they will assume I did it 😂
I thought he looked very understandably freaked out. Didn't seem like a suspect at all to me. But, that's what investigations are for.
Well, going to jail and being sentenced for the murder are two different things.
"Amy's bedroom was a mess"
*shows immaculate bedroom with unmade bed*
Ikr
That threw me off guard, made me look at my own room, literally said “Damn” aloud
They weren’t talking about it being “messy”. By a mess they meant there were signs of a struggle. That should’ve been obvious
and urine on the floor of the bathroom signifying struggle..
Yikes. If police entered my bedroom, they'd be certain a murder happened there.
How can a murderer be bonded out of jail with all that evidence? This is just unbelievable.
Cali.
California
And they just let Trump would be hitman out.
America 🇺🇸
How do so many people gain so much fat while in prison awaiting their murder trial? Is prison food actually good, lol? 😂
Ya really gotta stop implying that weed, types of music, or hobbies such as video games etc makes you suspicious or more likely to be a murderer.
Exactly. Bad people are bad people.
Your honor he was crankin 90s in fortnite he is obviously guilty@@ShookOne1980
They do. Maybe not videogames but music is legitimately observed to do this.
It does make me lose any respect I do have for these uploaders. Pathetic.
Junkie, chill. Your habits draw a picture about yourself. So it's ok to have these suspicions.
Ring doorbells literally sell themselves. So many stories of them saving the day.
The weed smoking being somehow linked to a deadly nicotine syringe is like saying "yeah that guy has a pet cat so he probably has access to rattle snake poison, y'know …seeing as how he is familiar with animals!" ??????
That syringe looked like it was filled with heroin they wouldn't have been able to find out it's nicotine until lab tests.
Yup, police are imbociles
Pretty solid analogy honestly. The bloody scratchy arms didn’t help him avoid suspicion though lol
Right, had he said he just drinks they wouldn't have said that
I was thinking that too
I've never seen anyone see their friend dead for the first time. That was a true genuine, terrified reaction.
Exactly, he immediately wanted to help her and was even held back by police. I knew then he was innocent!
She was seizing too at the time and I can tell you it is horrific to watch that happen, even without the blood and other injuries of having been attacked.
Poor guy was scared and innocent, yet treated like the criminal. They should have been more compassionate to him.
That’s not how it works, too many times when that person is the killer
@@Youafool500 Actually that’s not true… and that is EXACTLY how it is supposed to work.
Innocent until proven guilty.
@@PrincessPebbles0_0I mean they still can’t rule out anyone, they need to make sure they have the right person, so they have to treat everyone as a suspect until they’re not. In this case the roommate did have markings on his body and blood on his hands, so it’s understandable why the cops and detectives had him as a suspect at first until their investigation proved otherwise
Poor guy seemed to be suspecious because of his vibrant personality but actually, he is the best roomate who was there for her when she was in real trouble. He was also so honest to the police by declaring that he smoked weed with out a fear that it would make him look bad in the eyes of the authorities. He desrves love and respect if you ask me.
How was he "there for her"? She was screaming and he did nothing to stop the attack. He called 911 and hung out waiting like a wuss. He could have saved her and did nothing.
Without is 0ne word, DopeY 🤦
@@wmason1961 Because he is a beta male. That's why. Girly male.
Was there for her? He ran off lol.
The absolute opposite of being there for her. He could have saved her
@@24sumo Yeah hindsight 20/20 but his mere presence in that moment could have been the difference. We all like to think in that moment we would be heroes, i don't think i would hangout waiting for the police after hearing my roommate cry for help, but I've also never been in a situation even close to that.
I know he’s lucky that the ring cameras got him cleared, but his reaction to finding her body was very real
Yeah it made him looked guilty ngl
@@Bantybantsmomentsno, the opposite, he was very shocked
@@eeeehuu2130 it came across as bad acting to me, and I'm obviously not the only one.
@mydogeatspuke He's innocent so it wasn't acting.
@@mydogeatspuke that sounds like something you need to seek therapy for.
How on earth does someone who's charged with first degree murder get a bond allowed....
Welcome to Commiefornia
California
Because he is white
because our system is soft and sucks. they don’t give a shit about anyone’s safety and can’t properly do their job.
A real answer rather than anger fueled retorts. Our prison system is a for profit organization, not one for rehabilitation. By allowing bonds they are able to make money of the person without putting them into a cell while waiting on trial. Our "innocent until proven guilty" process means, legally, he isn't guilty of the crime until trial and therefore has the legal right to freedom while awaiting trial.
Never understand how people think a restraining order will stop someone who is mentally ill.
Restraining orders only work for people who care about not going to jail. People who care about not going to jail, never have restraining orders on them to begin with.
They don’t think it will stop them but it gives legal cause to arrest or detain them if they break the order which could prevent future harm
He was pure evil. Not everything is MH
Tell that to the courts then!! You can't arrest someone until they RO is issueys and they break it. It's literally the only way unless they catch him in the act. Ya'll know nothing about life yet be commenting in complete confidence 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
I had an ex co worker who had her ex husband stalking her. She had a restraining order and the cops didn't do anything when she called them, because he would leave before they arrived. They told her they can't do anything unless they catch him in the act. Restraining orders do nothing. Get a fire arm and get trained on how to use it. That will keep you a lot safer then some piece of paper.
Bail for someone like this. Insane!
This. Like wtf 😭
Right?! I came to comment this, how tf was he given bond? Immediately tried to flee the country smh. I watched the trial and never knew this detail. Ridiculous
Money talks at the end of the day sadly
Bail like that is reserved only for White Privilege.
Democrats
Parents - teach your kids, 'No' and being able to handle rejection. Otherwise your raising potential psychopaths.
Or you're just raising a woman.
It sounds like you don't understand psychopathy. Psychopathy isn't something you can just prevent by raising your child properly. These are people who literally can't experience remorse. Even as children they are known to torture small animals (like rodents or cats) or having a fascination with arson. Their brains are broken from the start.
"masked individual?" I could have sworn that dude wasn't wearing a mask.
LoL he wasn't wearing one that's how they new it was him his face is pretty clear lol
i feel like they said "unmasked individuel"
It was a mask of his own face duh
You do know AI isn't perfect, right?
@MarceloPinto-fw5sw you're kidding 😱
It’s genuinely terrifying that if that ring camera wasn’t there this innocent man would practically lose his life
Nah, they would need proof of his guilt and they wouldn't be able to find any. Just being suspected by cops doesn't automatically mean you'll lose your Freedom/life. They would have to have evidence that places him at the scene at the time of the murder and they never would have found it. He cowered, so he never had any chance of his footprints being in blood, or having blood on his clothes, or having her blood on him at all, etc... etc... We still have Rights in this country, like the Right to be presumed innocent, the Right to an attorney, the Right to a fair trial and an jury, etc... etc...
What? That’s no true at all. What about the DNA? His alibi? You guys are all so over dramatic it’s insane. The is man was never arrested at all. Nothing happened to him. If the cops find a man covered in blood in a house with a dead lady what should they do? Not ask him wtf happened? You guys act like 99% of people
Cops deal with lie to them
@@deucedeuce1572ever heard of the Central Park 5 people are wrongly accused or coerced all the time
@@deucedeuce1572you do realize there have been plenty of juries that have found innocent people guilty.
I lost it when he said all of her ex boyfriends came out clean and I see Marilyn Manson was one of them 😂😂
Yeah.. big mistake saying that 😡
Clear from THIS particular crime i guess
And that is how innocent people are wrongly accused and convicted of a crime they didn't commit. Thank God for Ring cameras, or the roommate would be in prison for life. Talk about lucky.
Exactly, that's why no one should talk to the police without an attorney.
No, not in this case. There was no forensic evident to tie him to the scene of the crime(her bedroom) and Gareth's well-known history with Amie would have always drawn the attention to him, ring camera or not.
He wasn’t wrongly anything. He was questioned as anyone should be in this situation. A child was murdered and dumped in the woods by our house. Cops knocked on everyone’s doors to ask what happened and if we saw anything. We immediately all talked to them and helped and gave our camera footage. No one saw anything and no cameras did. But what should we have done? Turned the cops away? wtf. There was a dead CHILD that deserved our help. His mother and her boyfriend killed him and drove to our state to dump him here. Very sad. But I can’t imagine being a crazy person like you and not help the cops and that poor boy in that situation. Because what you’re saying is I should have not said anything, kept my cameras to myself, and paid $1,000 for an attorney to say no comment 😢you people are evil
God had nothing to do with anything. Thank Jamie Siminoff for inventing the Ring Camera .... smdh
Being a suspect means u r on a waiting list between guilty or innocent. U r basically noted as a potential criminal link with the crime in question. That's it.
Anyone else find it ridiculous how nonchalant everyone is and how no one’s in a rush? You would think they would send an ambulance BEFORE going to the house where someone was attacked. If she had any chance the officers and responders on the phone took it from her. What a shame.
That's why you should DRIVE someone to the hospital if possible, instead of waiting for an ambulance. They ALWAYS move slow as Hell, it took them 15 minutes (!) from arriving at our house, to get my mom in the ambulance! Just casual af, I learned my lesson that night!!
From my understanding EMTS/first responders don’t go straight to the injured unless the crime scene is locked down & secured by law enforcement. In this case they don’t know if the attacker was still in the house or if there was multiple attackers.
@mike yes that also depends on the situation. If it was a physical accident that you could control that was caused by yourself or friends/family member… sure… but in this case it’s a crime scene & you don’t wanna tamper with anything until authorities get there and start their investigation .
When I broke my arm, my bone went through the skin, and I was bleeding.
It took them an hr and 12 mins before anyone came, the fire fighters got to me first.
My friends immediately called 911 within the minute I fell down because they saw my bone. Yet it still took them long.
You don’t send the ambulance before police in a situation like this
I wish police would try to render aid. They stand around watching. Then the paramedics take such a long time to get them out and to the hospital.
Absolutely unbelievable. How many times the poor guy had to repeat himself and the urgency. From the time he made the 911 call to the arrival of the officers. Who trains these people?
The black bar across her face was done disrespectfully as hell.
i thought it was strange too
It was my first and last time watching a video on this channel.i dont understand why that was necessary to do.
Saw this comment right as that part came up and I'm so glad I'm not the only one who was immediately disgusted.
@@amberstorm1139imagine calling someone Karen for saying disrespecting the dead is disgusting. Kid get off the internet and stop watching narrating Reddit post channel.
@@stilettoswinger7404what a Karen thing to do. Bye
I had a stalker for over 10 years. Never saw his face. It was the days before cameras. Even getting married and having kids only escalated his behavior. A police man suggested that I gain weight. At about 175, I lost him.
Haha...Weight gain works for all stalked people.Hope you are joking
This is so funny and sad at the same time. I’m so sorry about this!! Must’ve been really scary! Was it someone you knew? I was never stalked to this extent but I was followed once going to the store to get groceries despite me being on the heavier side. After this experience I’ve opted to carry a sharp pen with me in my pocket ever since but the paranoia nor anxiety never really goes away
Damn, that's terrible. I had protected a friend of mine for a couple weeks one time when a guy was stalking her and she was a mess. The mental and emotional stress was overwhelming for her. She was well under 21, but I ended up getting a gun for her and it possibly ended up saving her life. Her stalker finally found a time when she was in a dark "transitional space" and came up behind her, but she expected him and had her gun in her hand already. It was the first and last time she ever saw his face. She believes that he never covered his face, because he had planned to kill her and seeing his face didn't matter. In the end though, he was never identified and we still have no idea who he was (over 20 years later). Your comment reminded me of the whole situation and now I'm wondering if I should suggest for her to go through mug shots and the sex offender website to see if he was ever arrested before or after that. I think the sex offender registry existed before that... or at least I think that sex offenders from those days will be on there also if they're still alive. I don't think he could ever be charged for stalking her though after so long. They never indicted him at that time, so the statute of limitations would make it impossible to have him charged. (My x brother in law stabbed my sister years ago and although he fled and was never caught, he was indicted, so the statute of limitations will never protect him from being charged if he's ever caught, even if 50 years goes by).
@@cristinaestrellaThey said that they never saw his face, so I don't think they knew him.
never saw his face......scary!!!! i've seen videos like that. the person stands there in the dark like a robot.
Giving bail to this dude should put whoever did it in jail. There is zero reason for why a murder with this much evidence against him gets bail.
Narrator needs to be better. Mentioning things that weren’t correct. No masked man, the roommate didn’t try medical and other minor issues. Good video, but get narration right for 10/10. Right now it’s 7/10.
Plus, he makes the same mistake so many of these crime vids do: randomly flipping between past and present tenses.
How do u know the roommate didn't try medical
@@YaoEspiritothis
@johndoe5715 he found the body after the police came as shown so.
The videos are AI generated and not vetted well before going live
Literally cannot stand police dispatchers. They're so incompetent
"Someone is currently being attacked"
"So, can you hear what is going on"
FFS, the guy doesn't sound like he's reporting a shoplifter.
@@samblack5313what does he look like, what’s the victims name, what’s your name, why do you think she is in trouble 😮
I agree that they sound incredibly aggravating, but they're trained to get people to repeat things to make them clear, and also to keep people on the phone talking while stuff is going on. They don't want incomplete, unclear phone calls that end too soon.
So you're reporting a person screaming. You don't know if she's being attacked. 🙄
Dude, I don’t think you understand what they’re trying to do. The dispatcher is both gathering information and keeping the caller calm without them hanging up. They literally just need you to be talking the whole time. You could say some important information, you could go into a panic which makes it worse for first responders, they’re job is get your info, send people, then do investigation
The lawyer defending the killer 🤬 saying, maybe she fell trying to get away from him. unbelievable 😡
they're called "defense attorney", they're ensuring the client receives a fair trial by protecting their constitutional rights and to prevent wrongful convictions since there was no evidence if he threw her to the ground then its fair to assume that she fell whilst trying to escape
ahhh yes, because all of my stoner friends are very familiar with nicotine syringes due to their weed use... like wtf
I know. I didn't even know that existed.
Never seen or heard of a nicotine syringe wth
👛 🏠!
I make my own vape liquid with nicotine salts, I use a syringe, but a blunt needle that is the size of a medium nail
Stupid fucking channel owner and their propaganda
Scary to think how easily that roommate could’ve been put away for this.
Another reason why it’s good science has gotten to where it is, because she had DNA under her fingernails that matched Garret. If they never saw the video footage it’s likely the DNA would’ve removed Micheal as a suspect cause it wouldn’t have matched
Shark Tank really fumbles when they reject Ring Camera
Ok so did she have almost no enemies or did a lot of people have it out for her? You gotta learn to be more consistent and accurate.
Yeah, I noticed this too... very lazily done video.
@@huggablepenguin1465 purposefully done for view retention, OP strat for youtubers, especially true crime
Typical European American things.
It's like that with a lot of these true crime vids - way too many details reiterated and overexplaining unimportant stuff.. I blame some sort of automated Ai script the authors are utilizing
@@AlexPletcherPhoto I agree 100%
“She had no known enemies…”
And
“She has an abusive ex stalker known to family and friends”
These things actually ARE mutually exclusive
This channel is just chat gpt garbage
it said “almost no enemies”
@@veezopolis hit the nail on the head 🎉 i believe his exact words were "she had no known enemies among her friends and family" like her enemies would tell the cops they were her enemies? Lol.
wtf did I just read
@@allyjudge1216wrong. "No known enemies" MULTIPLE times
All this video tells me is if someone is being murdered I need to just mind my own business or they're going to send me to jail for calling the police lol
Kills one person that's a "celebrity" and gets life sentence without parole, yet i keep seeing other people kill 3-5 others and get 20 years or 40 years. What is this system
not all states have the same laws. not all cases have the same jury or judge. not all lawyers are the same. etc.
Premeditation is what constitutes 1st degree murder which is life w/o parole. a 2nd degree murder charge might be what caused those ppl to get less time.
Depends on the state and the judge.
Money talks in America
If he had pled out he may have gotten a lighter sentence but idiots to waste everyone time with their bull shit clam that they are innocent
(Roommate complying with all of the officers commands with her body there) "Yeah idk he's acting suspicious" lol what? Lazy cops are so dangerous.
its reasonable to be suspicious of anyone nearby? its not lazy its precautious
Ngl he did seem suspicious
That's right it's okay to be suspicious, but they need to reserve their comments for after the investigation to not make biased conclusions. If i had their mentality every time i said a pitbull, I'd never work in the animal field. It's called professionalism, and unfortunately police across the nation have little to none at all and allow their emotions to dictate actions and thoughts.
@@cat19649 he was suspicious af lol
He was super in shock too, these cops were horrible. They didn't have any patience with him at all, just told him stuff like "breathe" and "calm down" which I don't think is the thing to do as a trained cop
I smoke cannabis, used to everyday. Doesn’t mean I know a damn thing about hard drugs.
Same....
To accuse someone who uses cannabis as also a hard drug user is like saying someone who drinks a lot of coffee is probably also an alcoholic
Well, he told the cop he did weed “and stuff”, so a cop will assume anything at that point.
To be honest, your comment made me realise I need supplies. I'm out
The classic move of covering a camera after you have walked past it. Works every time genius
i thought they had tech that can sharpen a blurred image or zoom in on the damn face. i guess that is only on tv shows or when they choose to actually do any work.
😂😂
This is literally Insane! The roommate must be so happy he got those cameras
...and so guilty that he didn't get a gun.
They weren't his cameras. The video literally says, "on his neighbor's ring camera"
@@jordanalbareed I can't read!
@@Deviusroachhahahaha got em
@@tone1585 lol yes sir
At this point I feel like police will put anyone in jail innocent or not just to say they caught the “culprit”
Disheartening how quickly they tried accusing him of it
Well to be fair he was suspicious as hell because of the blood on his clothing and the wounds on his hands
@@tryzub353yea hindsight is 20/20 , you make decisions based on the information you have at the time.
Yes lets automatically blame the police for being reasonable, its a form of suspecting people, and usually people who report crimes including murderers can sometimes be the culprit, do you know how suspicious it sounds for
1. Being the only person on site
2. Being the only witness on site
3. Having wounds that the "Suspect" can't explain
Cops have to come to quick assumptions and make sure evidence isn't destroyed, so they take the prime suspect which is usually a person who is closely related to the victim or the only person present during the crime, the United States as you might know is based off of a Innocent until proven guilty, this situation may seem like its contradicting it but he's still innocent, and their following regular procedure to make sure that he IS innocent whilst the evidence is still present and "Fresh"
Yes let's blame the police for suspecting the last person to see her alive. Let's blame them for doing their jobs.
No i blame them for interjecting their emotions and assumptions in lou of evidence. Guy smokes pot, must know get poison. What a leap@@natebeal18
Im buying a ring cam now. This is my biggest fear as a recreational cannabis user
this is so real LMFAO
I just had a few puffs ... ima take a nap and get back to you 🚬
How about stop using it?
@@bubgum00easier said than done for a lot of people.
@@bubgum00Look I don't like potheads either but as long as they're only doing it at home who fuckin cares?
I've just discovered this channel and I absolutely love the stories being told after their conclusion. The video evidence and testimony makes everything come together so well.
Great story telling.
If not for a ring cam there’s no doubt that the roommate would be in prison for life
Not true they would dig and find out about this psycho either way
What a ridiculous comment. C'mon now. There was plenty of other evidence, like the murderer's DNA under her nails. Do you really think that NEVER would have come up?
@nittygritty7503 not necessarily. A lot of times, this type of situation, without the cameras, would make the cops get tunnel vision and hone in on him. He could've 100% been charged and probably convicted.
@@kimberlyhayes6006 He wouldn't have been convicted or even charged for that matter. As soon as they ran the DNA that was found under her fingernails, that alone *should* clear him.
No crime is complete, her fingers has his DNA, she was fighting the killer, and the other proofs, the ring made everything easy to recognize the killer
He looks like he’s enjoying the jail food.
Caller: "Somebody just attacked my room-mate and she is there upstairs, screaming."
911 : "Is she screaming for help?"
That's the most disturbing thing I have ever heard since 19 December 2002, it was on a Friday.
Was the last thing that disturbed you as much the announcement of imminent US invasion of Iraq?
Smoked weed? Mustve known how to poison someone!
Yeah anyone whose been around stoners knows they are mellow, but alcohol can have different effects
When I smoke I just watch true crime and play games lol
@@Quzga nah I bet you are plotting murders and experimenting with poisons
@@Quzgayeah rn i be playing sparking zero not trying to kill my gf wtf 😭
@@Walker-ow7vj haha ikr man.
I can’t imagine having such an intimately horrifying part of my life uploaded to youtube
Did you make sure to cover your ears and close your eyes?
wait are you really?
That defense was absolutely ridiculous. "Ahhh yes, she was just scared and fell off the balcony.". Honestly, kudos for that lawyer for not trying very hard...
Crazy part is she probably had the male roommate for safety. It didnt help.
She should have picked a alpha male, not beta male who screams like a girl.
What i was thinking! He was terrified & called the police....
@@melissa7245if you think your life is threatened get a bodyguard not a roommate...
Don’t get a gay male roommate for safety. Guy was an absolute coward
@@24sumo The 'new' definition of masculinity. Beyond stupid.
Michael is so sweet. He didn’t seem guilty at all. Rwg to her & happy he’s free ❣️
Love how the cops are such good detectives. They assumed it's the roomate. 😂
You can feel the shock and disbelief in that moment. It's a chilling reminder of how fragile life can be. Truly heartbreaking.
It's a reminder that we don't just have the Right to bear arms and to defend ourselves and those around us... but the Duty to do so. He literally cowered on the phone while she was being murdered, because he didn't even have the basic tools that were available to him. No he's going to have to remember that for the rest of his life. His roommate was murdered, because he didn't save her.
I'm glad Michael was cleared. He seemed genuine enough.
10:22 I’m confused… in the body cam, he had said that he was sleeping and the narrator says that “he came home and heard screams.”
Not only that but again in the body cam, it seemed like he just found Amie on the ground along with the cops and on the 911 call, he didn’t mention finding her… but the narrator says that Michael was giving her CPR while cops came?? What?
Either you didn’t get the story straight or maybe the way the story was presented in the video is confusing 😅
He killed her because he was so jelous of her,that she was smart, Beautiful,successful and famous,she was all what he wanted to be, that's why he was asking his losers friends to make a Book about him. What an envious loser
They immediately went in treating the roommate like a fucking murderer. Thats so fucked up.
Why? Everyone’s a suspect till they’re not. Especially a MALE roommate with an attractive dead woman. The police were just trying to get up to speed (imo) at the scene and didn’t know what they had. Just my take anyways
@@mc-gn2rtfreedom of fair trial, innocent until proven guilty
Then they checked all the evidence and realised he wasn't. Hard call to make but you can't just let someone walk away from a murder scene if they're covered in blood spatter.
Jfc you're slow @mc-gn2rt
@da1uheardabt that's right have 0 argument against what he said so you just call him dumb for disagreeing with you. What do you expect the guy was the last person to see her alive obviously he'd be a suspect?
Judge that gave him a BOND to be allowed out of custody SHOULD be sentenced to 6 months in Jail. That is absolutley BS that he was given a CHANCE to ESCAPE his murder charges!!! That is NOT OK! HOW? HOW? HOW IS THAT EVEN POSSIBLE!!! 😮
A family and relationship therapist with a series of bad, abusive relationships makes no sense.
ROFLMAO
Right!! Who'd have guessed? All that psycho babble BS!!
😂 it's the norm. Just like the majority of marriage counselors are divorced bittr wmen 😂
I'd trust someone who suffered from abuse better to help me than someone who has always been out of that loop, bc they understand better what the bottom of the barrel look like and help you climb back out just as good
@@Chillaxpepper She would have to have it figured out first. Which means she would manage to form healthy relationship herself before trying to help others achieve it.
How is that remotely her fault? Men are abusive shitheads; take it up with them, not the women they abuse. "Oh she didn't immediately read this lunatics mind and find out he was gonna murder her; boo it's her fault". Save the life of a future woman; maybe don't raise any kids. You don't have the mindset conducive to healthy, stable relationships.
In all fairness the first one to discover the body is almost always the first suspect.
She doesn’t have enemies, except that guy she has reported for stalking and abuse for years and had a restraining order on. But her roommate is a suspect.
How come he got a bond when he murdered someone? Is that how it works in the US? Someone can bribe a murderer? Please someone explain to me
It is pretty messed up but I would assume it has something to do with "innocent until proven guilty" and the nature of the crime. A mass murder suspect wouldn't get bail.
Time to do some rewriting ...
@@The-House-Cat-777 nah thats ouyr right as americans no rewriting needed bc the false conviction rate would sky rocket how can u be so incompetent?
I guess they didnt have enough evidence to held onto him. They did have several suspects
@@The-House-Cat-777 hahahaha ur incompetent
Cannabis User = Psychopath Killer
By far the dumbest logic I’ve heard. Poor dude.
when in the video do the cops communicate that logic?
They're probably using someone to write the script that lives in a country where cannabis has those stereotypes
And yet defendants have used it as a reason to get them off, cannabis induced psychosis. You can't have it both ways.
To be obsessed for 10 years is insane. He had a full decade to move on. Rip to her 🕊️
It doesn't even take me 10 days to move on from a woman... people are so weak.
His Hershey's joke sucked.
And this is why his career in comedy fell flat on its face...
I was gonna comment that. Bro must think he the joker
comedians are a little depressed or have some odditys but this dude was straight up messed up in the head thats why he wasn't funny. If he focused on his jokes rather than stocking he probably would've done better for himself smh
👛 🏠!
You should check him out in Kill Tony 🤦♂️
I remember seeing the lengthy version of this, one other person who was engaged to her and got questioned was Drew Carey. They had many suspects.
WHAT😮😮
@@Mike-es2ygyeah drew and her were on and off
The urgency of the response and the cops on scene was so casual, there was an attack in progress for crying out loud! I wonder if they had responded quicker, went in immediately with paramedics they might have been able to save her.
if i meet a dude & he says he only does shrooms & weed
i trust him with my life
Guess u won’t be around much longer
after 2 weeks you find out hes a former crack user and your stuff already in a pawn shop
@@strexpillsformer crack user that only smokes weed… still got time to delete your comment
@@whiskerstars yea, people also mix drugs ups and downs...
That's what a lot of junkies say.
If there wasn't a Ring doorbell....... Poor Michael
Nothing would have happened? There was DNA. Years of texts , stalking with protective orders… he had an alibi?
Her roommate is so lucky those cameras exonerated him.
Major ego couldn't take rejection, even though he was physically abusing her. Years of seething revenge from someone you casually dated. Imagine having children with such a narcissist.
As long as the the ones that raise them aren’t held accountable, it’ll keep happening..
My sisters x husband (she had a daughter with) cheated on her several times and was having a relationship with at least one other woman when my sister decided to leave him... so he ended up stabbing her. She's okay now and he's still wanted by the state of NY and the FBI... but it just goes to how what kind of person it takes to be like that. Just the mere suspicion (without any evidence) that she was cheating on him threw him into a fit, as he was literally having sex with other women. Then when she decided to leave him it was the last straw for him. He was a narcissist and a coward and he couldn't handle the consequences of his own actions.
FDJT
@@deucedeuce1572 sorry that happened to your sister, but i mean, she chose him...if the guy was an angel with no criminal record, that's one thing. If he was a known pos, that's another thing. Women, choose better men!
@@speedfreak8200what? You ok?
His “friends” are ballsy showing their faces and laughing with a murderer.
And imagine before ring cameras, how many innocent people are still in prison or died?
Wait a minute… I thought it was said that the guy (roommate) locked himself out and couldn’t get back over the fence or something to that effect… but in the video, it says that he found the front door open and her body and gave her CPR until the ambulance arrived… he never mentioned that on the 911 call. Am I completely missing something? I mean, the video clearly shows him discovering her the same time that the police did???
He also told the cops he had been sleeping all night probably on cocaine
@@Brian-zp1dfsleeping on cocaine? That keeps you awake
That confused me too. He made it seem like he didn’t know if she was in danger but apparently had already discovered her body. Maybe it was edited weird. So I’m guessing he heard screaming, called 911 but didn’t want to check on her because he feared there was a weapon involved, eventually went down and found her, went for help but locked himself out, tried scaling the fence but injured himself, cops arrive and they successfully go over the fence, and maybe the shock we’re hearing is witnessing her having a seizure?
I think he lied about him doing CPR bc when you see him walk up with the police you can tell it was his first time seeing her in that state..
The fact that his two friends could laugh at the joke of a murderer... what the fuck.
bro let himself go when he got to prison lol
"women are too emotional and irrational". 😮💨😮💨😮💨yet, stories like this are too common smh
These stories are not "common" unless you watch true crime all the time.
Most of you women refuse to learn self defense and that's on yall
@@dawgpost90no thier still very much common in the middle east😂
@@dawgpost90derp… soooo they’re fuckin common. Shove your bias, you don’t know shit 💋
yeah you blue haired demon
I don't understand how we are still thinking that a piece of paper is going to keep someone away ... Do y'all know how many people end up dead by the people who have a restraining order? It's something we need to look into and fix
I’ve never been in this situation before but damn, Im pretty confident I’d be going inside that house to help my friend if I heard them screaming.
Right? Im still confused about where he was when he heard that.. he said he was alseep and some other stuff, but confusing..
If it werent for those cameras😮😮😮😮😮😮
He smokes weed. That can make some people paranoid. Also does he look like the type of guy that can fight? Probably feels guilty about it now. Also who knows if he would've been killed too. Don't forget what happened to Nicole Brown Simpson & Ron Goldman.
Sound good but that's not how it works
She’s not his mom for him to risk his life for her
Thank God that ring camera video existed. I remember when this happened. That poor young lady did not deserve to have this happen to her.
i did NOT expect dave navarro to be on this suspect list lolol
Seeing someone convulse from brain trauma is extremely disturbing I saw it before…
So they bonded out a murderer? Interesting.
blame the constitution for mandating bond
California.
@@mikeydude750 The Constitution doesn't mandate bail/bond and many people are denied bail/bond when the evidence against them is strong and it's a bad enough crime. You also shouldn't speak as if you know the law when you so clearly know Nothing at all.
@@jilliegirliecultural marxism
@@WilliamMartins-ci6evjust privileged if that man was black they would not have let him bond like that with all that damn initial evidence 🤦🏾♀️
It's shocking that no one said how the cop are just looking at her as shes dying
Why would someone on a murder charge get bonded out at all.
Because California…
that police behavior makes you think twice to do the right thing
What behavior? All they did was question him and cleared him? What if they do besides think logically? They see a blood man and a dead woman. Should they not question that person? When 99% of the time it’s the person you live with that kills you.. I don’t get what they did that’s so awful.
Bro, your beautiful female roommate is screaming bloody murder you hear a scuffle and you dont go to the rescue? Unreal cowardice!
don't have gay or potheads or gay potheads as roommate to defend you
You can’t ways read a persons emotional response to trauma. I was definitely impulsive to who appeared to be the culprit through the initial body cams. Also, huge respect to the officers who walk up to this.
okay im only 3 minutes in but why tf are the cops just standing there and walking slowly ??
I know this is a true crime channel so there's a ton of bootlicking, but it's mostly because the police are pretty bad at their jobs