Maritime expert: China trying to place PH under its laws with maritime rules; That's unacceptable
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 чер 2024
- Headstart: Karen Davila talks to Professor Jay Batongbacal, the Director for University of the Philippines' Institute for Maritime Affairs and Laws on the Seas, about China's continued aggression in the West Philippine Sea.
Join ANC PRESTIGE to get access to perks:
/ @ancalerts
For more ANC Interviews, click the link below:
• ANC Interviews
For more Headstart videos, click the link below:
• Headstart
For more ANC Highlights videos, click the link below:
• ANC Highlights
Subscribe to the ANC UA-cam channel!
/ ancalerts
Visit our website at news.abs-cbn.com/anc
Facebook: / ancalerts
Twitter: / ancalerts
#Headstart
#LatestNews
#ANC
The AFP budget is P280B while ayuda gets P500B, suspend it for the time being and allow AFP to bulk on what they needed most especially armaments for Afp modernization in order for AFP to be equip with all the requirements needed to be able to defend the country againts these external forces
Slice ayuda of even 10 Billion and everybody in the media will cry.
AYUDA is making Filipinos lazy and dependent on government for every thing . Kapag naririnig ang AYUDA lahat ay excited . Ayuda ay isang way para makagawa ng corruption ang humahawak ng ayuda .
Hahawakan pa kasi yan sa darating na eleksyon
Kahit 10x pa di natin mapantayan arms ng China.Mali strategy.Bakit ibang ASEAN my issue din sa territory di nman mainit ang China.Definitly strategy ntin is not working.
I agree
The Problem is , We are Afraid to Chinaaa ! Since 2016 Tinaataakoot Taayooo sa Chinaaa . We have to Have Guts to Enforce what is Ours .
Bakit pa tayo naging independent country kung hindi pala natin tumayo sa sarili nating mga paa
Kahit anong Law payan...ang china may sariling Law nila!!! Mga buang yng mga yan...
It’s chekwa law we’re not chekwa we have our own law fight for our sovereign right’s.Laban Pilipinas Di Ka Pasisiil 🇵🇭
CORRECT
we fervently hope that our entire government from national to lgu's to please double time to prioritize the abrupt improvement of our strong defense capabilities. Please don't wait 2040 to achieve or complete the badly needed defense capability. Kindly unite us and motivate all our people to be prepared in all aspect and never allow the greedy and evil oppressor to occupy, rob, or destroy our teritory, sovereignty, feeedom, unity, peace, rights, property (our land, seas, and air), God given resources, and our dignity as Godfearing Filipinos. We must never allow them to deceive, manipulate, bribe some of our officials and people, or destroy us in any way by their lies, ambitions, and by their very aggressive actions. We all need to protect and preserve what is ours and for our future generations to come. 🇵🇭🙏
The AFP budget is P280B while ayuda gets P500B, suspend it for the time being and allow AFP to bulk on what they needed most especially armaments for Afp modernization in order for AFP to be equip with all the requirements needed to be able to defend the country againts these external forces
🇨🇿keep barking/crying/keep dreaming _/like little dwarf bbm keep stuttering.like your master keep warning/pledge/🎤🎤🎥🎥 on east side 🌊 is yours,,not scs is 🇨🇳🇨🇳
@@EckonOmyst-jv1ro Does that firmly and clearly attest that the government ay isinakripisyo ang buong nasyon, para lang sa pagbibigay ng ayuda? Anong silbi ng magtayo ng armed forces na walang tama at sapat na armas? Hindi kaya malapit na scrap buong armed forces, para masmaraming ayuda maibigay? Nagtatanong lamang po.
Have allies that can go toe to toe with china coastguards patrol these disputed waters. Grow a spine.
Hahaha, Stupid... You want us to get a spine but you still want us to rely on allies? 😂😂😂
Why waste the time? The Philippines can build its strengths while watching China collapse from within.
Things that I don't agreed in buying warship from foreign shipbuilders, it's expensive, design does not conform to strategy / military doctrine of the customer and No urgency. Philippine, (for now) does not need frigates or destroyers, we need missile boats operating in 4-5 ships per squadron guarding our territory and EEZ. The Design will be a Simple 38.61-meter catamaran hull, armed with the most advanced system and weapon, such as CEROS 200 FCR, Kongsberg NSM 1A stealth anti-ship missiles. Spend-Less on Hull, Spend-More money in Weapon and system. The hull will be designed and build in the Philippines, the ship will have a modular and open architecture. The last time I checked, there were about 115 registered shipyards in the Philippines, only fractions can actually assemble and build 50-meters warships. The rest can contribute by manufacturing parts and components to speed-up the constructions. Give our Engineers, technicians and shipbuilders a chance. Politicians already have their chance, they FAILED.
Alright sir. we can do that after 30 years. 😂😂😂
@@user-jn2jo4sv7g Phil. built gunboats (warships) for Spanish and were captured and used by American. 3 were built in the late 1800. You can see the pain in designing warship at that time. Engineers are just using paper and pencil, machining don't have micro-inch tolerances.
Now, powerful computers with software developed for hydrodynamics and ship buildings are available to anyone. In 2018, Philippine built one of the largest container ship in the world 400 meters in length. To compare the Nimitz Class aircraft carrier is 333 meters in length. Again P.N. don't need (for now) destroyers, frigates not even corvettes. What P.N. need are missile boats (simple catamaran-hull) arm with the most modern weapon and system. This missile boats operate in squadron of 4-5 ships.
These poor filipinos are always wasting their time using fast boats to re-supply that old rusty ship. I've been telling here on my many comments suggesting to PCG or Navy to use transport helicopter 🚁. It would be quicker, faster, and right on the spot for the helicopter to hover above and drop the supplies. Do not use any more fast boats or rubber boats. Use air resources, and let's see if China 🇨🇳 will resort to another military maneuver.
Filipinos used your brain this time to change the tactics. And do it on your own. Because America 🇺🇸 will not act based on the mutual defense treaty unless an "invasion" happens.
Besides, America is just watching the Philippine government on what the Filipinos, the President , and the military the best strategy to do and achieve its goal in guarding its sovereignty in the SCS.
THEY ARE NOT USING THERE BRAINS.
They are using planes to drop supplies, but Chinese cost guards take the supply also. There's news about that resupply plane, so don't tell the Philippine navy they are not using their brains.
just admit it, chinese just don’t respect us Filipinos
Only Judge Carpio is making sense…. honestly.
Makikinabang si Carpio dahil sya lawyer ng consortium na gustong sumipsip ng langis sa WPS.Got it?!!
@@emiconstantino5434 Assuming your info is true, Judge Carpio’s opinion is still the closest to reason and is never invalidated by his connection to any consortium, incidental or not. e.g. That the Pope is a Catholic is not a lie even if told by a liar. Got it?!
Karen question is correct! Lagi na lang ba ganito?
Ano gagawin? Bigay nalang?
It's hard to be a Philippine soldier right now because their chain of command including PBBM doesn't want you to fight as a soldier. I pity the soldiers who got hurt previously and recently because their hands are tied for depending themselves. China is using deadly tactics to our soldiers and what they do is just to accept it without retaliation. In the future, no one will enlist in the AFP or even Coast Guard if the instructions for our soldiers are just to accept what the Chinese give them and not retaliate. The AFP should use their special force (martial art experts) to deliver the goods to BRP Sierra Madre in order to depend themselves without using force (if that's what PBBM wants). Or have a BRP ship with helipad to deliver it straight to BRP Sierra Madre to avoid sabotage in the water. Soon BRP Sierra Madre needs to be fixed or a solid structure needs to replace her. We are just delaying the war with China because eventually they will not like us to fix BRP Sierra Madre or even build solid structure there. Once they own whole SCS then they will annex Taiwan on the equation. PBBM, the whole country especially AFP is running out of options here.
You need to decide and the United States asap. For next RP president, it needs to be continued and sustained our WPS mission. Otherwise, we will be insulted by the Chinese for our inconsistent actions in WPS. We need to be UNITED on this issue!
id**t. so from what you are saying you want war? i think you are the one of 73% idiot want war lol. you dont want status quo from duterte so expect that. The US just use the philippines for their own agenda. US didnt even want to have war of china because they are nuclear nation and they are not goat herders
nagsasayang lang nang laway at oras parati naman ganyan.
Gusto ituloy ang Province of china offer ni ddirty 😅
Philippines needs to be able to fight on its own if need be. Will they win against China most likely not everyone knows that. But their goal if not able to win is to make it very costly for China to attack.
TROOP STATION??? do you mean the deliberatly brokendown stranding ship in 1995 after United States/nato bombing of the Chinese embassy in Belgrade？
Uu duwag kasi gumawa ng action eh
@@sed9406?????
@@algrand52 that is the origin of the stranding ship
wag na tau umasa sa duwag na Navy at PCG. hanggang tingin lng sila. kahit marami tau kaalyado walang mangyayari
Bkit.pinabayaan.makasampa.sa ating vessel at kinuha ang mga.baril at nasugatan ba ang isa nating sundalo. Kun.hindi tyo lalaban lalo tyo i bully ng China.
Just expedite all the military upgrades, maawa kayo sa mga sundalo jusmiyo.
He is trying to give political answer? She is straight to the point
When push comes to shove, u must stand ur ground. Wag aasa k kuya.
The only way we can at least stand against China’s bullying and aggression is to strengthen our military and coast guard all the more. We cannot rely on international community even US as they are afraid of Beijing in some ways.
That true one of the MDT Article, states that declaration of war to defend one a member must be ratified by the congress. in this case the US congress. Everyone must understand that China invests in many US states, from agriculture to meat-processing, etc. and this decision will bog-down. Why would a US congressman vote in favor of "war declaration" to defend the Philippines, if China has millions of dollars invested in his State?
The AFP budget is P280B while ayuda gets P500B, suspend it for the time being and allow AFP to bulk on what they needed most especially armaments for Afp modernization in order for AFP to be equip with all the requirements needed to be able to defend the country againts these external forces
The efforts of some ASEAN countries to position theouth China Sea conflict as a case of China-US competition is both dangerous and wrong. It is a case of China wanting to own the entire South China Sea and that will affect the entire ASEAN and all countries that use the South China Sea for trade and commerce passageway.
ASEAN neighbors can't do anything. Not even call out china since their economies were significantly tied to china. They became enablers. The very same reason why the invaders have the guts to disrespect us in our own territory.
Please naman palayasin nyo na ang Ambassador Ng China sa Pilipinas! And invoke na ang Mutual Defense Treaty with the USA. Invoking MDT does not mean going to war. It can provide escorts of US destroyers to PH supply boats.
Hihintayin nyo pabang akyatin ang BRP Sierra Madre? Puro maximum tolerance at diplomatic protest nalang ba tayo.
小猴子还想操控美国爹😂别忘了玉通之战,bro😅
Sige nga, ano bang requirements para ma-invoke mo MDT? Stupid... 😂😂😂
Philippine territory is OURS, our law must prevail!
Sa facebook ang ibang mamamayang Chinese grabe tawa sa mga sundalo natin KAWAWA NAMAN DAW SUNDALO NG PILIPINAS sabay hagalpak tawa ohh hindi kayo nahihiya?
Investigate these chinese possible illegals and criminal communists Deport Now!
PH - have a few boats that are especially designed for resupply missions. The body of the boat have spikes meaning ramming is dangerous. Have water cannon capability to counter Chinese aggression. Have strong men capable of teaching China a lesson in case of an physical encounter.
For myself I strongly recommending invocation of MDT. ASAP
Tama, Ms. Karen? What can we do?
Palayasin ung AMBASSADOR NA CHECKWA!
Totoo ba talaga ang “ Lupang Hinirang, duyan ka ng magiting
Sa manlulupig, di ka pasisiil”
Kawawang Pilipino, utusan ng ibang lahi sa kanilang bayan at hanggang sa sarili nating bansa tayo ay inaagawan ng ating kayaman at sinasaktan. Sobrang nakakaiyak dahil sa mga nangyayari at pati ang mga sariling kababayan ay pumapanig sa manlulupig na mga intsik. Kawaan sana tayo ng Diyos na maykapal.
Ugaling ibenta ang kasama? Ugaling isakripisyo ang kasama, makaangat kamang? Ano yan?!!!!!!!!
Dapat hndi na iniinterview yang mga nagpapakilalang mga expert kuno halos sila sila magkakasalungat ng mga sinasabi.nakakagulo lang.
Tama grabi ang kadadakdak dapat sekrito
Batongbacal tumigil kana sa pagbibigay ng information
WE SHOULD NOT BE AFRAID OF WAR.IF WE WANT TO LIVE IN PEACE.
Tama ka bro
We have to utilize our 115 registered shipyards to build warships and designed it for war. Put money to this builders. It is high time to utilize our talents.
Tayo naman ang gumawa ng batas na huhullihin naman natin ang sino mang papasok lalo na ang mga manghaharass sa mga pinoy sa loob ng nasasakupan natin. Namimihasa kasi. At seryoso na ipatupad ng batas. Hulihin talaga ang aino mang apasok
nakakahiya kayo, usap usapan na sa japan, SK at australia ka duwagan nang AFP. natalo nang coast guard gamit lang kutsilyo at sticks. grabe sabi pa nila lakas daw nang loob natin mamalimos nang tulong, di naman pala kayang lumaban. grabe magresign n dapat si brawner at tariella
Dapat lahat ng budget ng mga senado at kongreso bawasan,ilaan sa mga army equipments ung budget,kung pwede nga lang ung sweldo nila ang ibigay eh lahat ng budget itapal lahat sa army equipments pra nman dumami ung mga pandigmang pandagat,pandigmang panghimpapawid,at pangdigma sa lupa,pati mga police natin buhusan ng budget para pambili rin ng mga armas,lahat ng reserved at sibilyan armasan tutal my pagawaan nman ng armas dyan sa Pilipinas,ihire ng gobyerno mga pagawaan ng armas pra gumawa sila,gumawa rin tayo ng bomba.
I can even observe the impatience from the face of Ms Karen while asking the questions. As per my assessment, Ms. Karen and many Filipinos are waiting from the subject experts and from our government to say that this is now the right time to invoke the MDT. That’s understandable because most of us are losing our marbles with this issue however, since CCG were brainwashed by CCP and threatened that they will not eat if they’re not going to show their barbarism to our people then CCG doesn’t have any choice but at the same time PH government should also shown some muscles like Mr. Orly Mercado in his separate interview.
Tsekwa means TUSO, SINUNGALING,AT WALANG DIYOS
Why dont you tell NSC, DND, PCG, BFAR, and AFP that they are acting like fools and cowards and NOT ACT as authorities of a Sovereign Nation defending her own territorial integrity????
Let the doodurty jetski escort the esupply missions
I salute you sir Jay Batongbacal
well it might happen soon if the government keep let the chinese do whatever they want to do .
TUMULONG TAYO HUWAG TANGKILIKIN ANG MGA NEGOSYONG CHINESE
TULAD NG GCASH ( ALIPAY NA), CHINA BANK, UNION PAY CREDIT CARD AT IBA PANG CHINA BUSINESSES SA ATING BANSA
Our Navy was Boarded, harassed and its weapons confiscated.🤣
Kahit tirador lalaban ka kung mahalaga sayo ang dangal. Kahit gaano kaganda ang armas kung hindi ka lalaban sayang lang.
We do not have enough armaments to fight back with Chinese who had been prepared on war long time ago. Although malakas ang loob ng mga Pinoy at matatapang.. Anong magagawa natin kung wala naman tayong armaments for war. Sasaluhin ba lang natin ang bala?
meron tyaung mga tikbalang enkanto meron din tyaung tulfo brothers meron din tayung mga aswang mambabarang pa at meron din mga ermetanyo na me anting anting
If UNCLOS is a retroactive law, anyone can create newer laws to override the not so new laws.
still no moves in our side bakit?
Ingat palage sir tap wan.
The lady is great she is asking great questions.
Much better to solve the problem by force if not solve by peacefully means no matter we lose or win rather than we lose w/ out fight
Bla bla bla bla bla. EXPERT?
Philippines government must make a way to figh for our rights against china this is our territory .
you appear to be an expert in maritime law can you not suggest the best alternative course of action the govt should undertake? we shun the chinese of wat they are doing and yet we nwver heard from the expert wat should be done to resolve this dangerous dispute in a manner that it would not escalate into something destructive. ang tatapang ntn sabihin atin yan.
Dapat bigyan na ng ultimatum ang ginagawa ng mga tsekwa na yàn sobra na ang pangbabraso nila dto pa sa loob ng teritoryo natin..
Sa sitwasyon ngayon kailangan talaga natin mga kaalyado , hindi totoo kaya natin itayo sarili kitangkita sa nangyare ngayon paano tayo inapi ng china kinayakaya tayo kahit dito mismo sa loob ng ating t
Ask US NAVY to help Philippines NOW.
matanong lng prof kung nasa MDT ba ang automatic US defense if ever ang phil ay inatake ng china? o kelangan pa ng go signal ng american congress? ano kaya ang pwede mangyari kung may pagbabago da liderato ng america?
Kung mga Phil navy coastguard walang magawa laban s Chinese coastguard mga mangingisda pakaya natin??
she ask what can we do? absolutely nothing. and its sad. becouse we are so proud of our countrys elected.
While drillng gas get the 30 sec the post in order look for the chinese to move a wrong doing
China attacked the Philippine Coast Guard. US should send warships just like what they do to protect Taiwan ...
🙏🙏🙏
Why china singling out the philippines? If they claim all of south China sea why not apply its laws to other trespassers?
Because Filipinos dare not stand their ground. The Chinese know that PH never retaliates.... always back down and cry "Help !!! Help !!!"
Huwag na silang mag palayag ng mangingisda sundalo nga lang wala ng nagawa magpapalayag pa
Iwas ng iwas tayo ng gulo sa tsina sunod ng sunod naman ang tsina para udyukan tayo para saktan.
China has also plan to expand their fishponds/ fish cages to the South China Sea including West Philippine Sea.
Not only Philippines they want to implement their government laws in the world 😂😂
She asks good questions
Go 🇨🇿📣🎤🎤 crying /barking more ....
And Our Military Can't do anything.🤣
Our military might surrender all their weapons to Chekwa. Today it's 7 rifles....Next time it might be all weapons.
My naputulan ng daliri na ,di po ba sbi ibang usapan na pag my nasaktan na.
Dala po palagi ng mga pana pangisda para kapag ginipit ng rubber boats- sigurado tatamaan ng butas yan.
😅
Ewan ko lang kung di maki paawa mga yan na sasampa sa bangka ng mga fisherfolks
Bakit kasi ayaw pa ninyo pasamahin ang US coast guard sa provisioning or resupply dyan sa Barko natin.
takot eh ano magagawa natin
@@eegt628 That's embarrasing because Filipino commenters look brave on the internet against China.
Bakit mo i-aasa sa US. May kakayanan ang Phil Navy mag escort sa pag-resupply.
China is testing the Philippines and they now know if they push and even board their inflatable and take weapons and cut the rubber floats on inflatables no defense is given. So of course China has nothing to worry about. The behavior from China will continue. They can take candy from candy jar and not get their hand slapped or have to pay for it. So China can continue to bully..
There’s difference. The same no reaction from BBM over and over indefintely. Waaaaa!
Sob, sob! Pilipinos just cry alone. No need to depend on BBM for a change! Ayayay.
Mnga kaalyado naghintay lang ng umpisan ng pilipinas.
Philippines is the next TIBET !!! The next MANCHURIA !!! The next XINJIANG !!!
This is what filipinos are good at...blah blah blah....
Help stop corruption and purchase modern and sophistecated military armaments.
to the chinese bots please google what "Phyrric victory" means.
Edit. Oh i forgot you have to ask permission first before you can use the internet like a normal human being 😂
Isa n lng ang magagawa ng pilipinas pag hndi tumigil ng prc s pananakip s pilipinas.. tulungan ang taiwan lusubin ang prc ng maibalik s roc ang pamumuno pra magbago ang mundo!!!!
The us is just show and always talking and doing nothing to really help the country
The MDT will only kick-in if there is a shooting war. The US cannot do anything in this minor incident.
Miss Karen you always interupt your guest when he is still explaining.❤ sorry.
Karen Davila and ProfessorBatongbacal - both of you have a lot more to lose than many filipinos and those leaders/public officials and their families who helped bring us to this situation are not safe and secure and have a lot more to lose than most of us. The fruits of their corruption wont buy them security. KAWAWA KAMI PERO MAS KAWAWA KAYO - POOR FILIPINOS HAVE HAD IT BUT IF WE DIE SO WOULD YOU- THAT IS JUSTICE.
It's gonna be the new normal.
It will be the new normal and more. Filipino fishermen will need a permit from Beijing to go there to fish.
Api apihan na lang palagi😢bakit ayaw nyong palagan. Patay kung patay… habambuhay na lang ba ganyan ang sitwasyon?
This Expert don't know how to resolve the conflict, emotion first, before brain.. conflict analysis, and solution in this multi polar situation.. Philippines is about to be oust in ASEAN at a member..
Greed of power is an evil
Napaka cool naman ni Sir Jay❤
Tatay bakit pinahamak mo ang sailing mong bansa sa China.
nawala si BARBERS🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Kelan tayo lalaban sa China kong palaging ganyan tuwing mag resupply babaragin tayo. Ng China. Useless lang iyang interview Mo sa expert na iyan. Probably he does not even know the Port and starboard side of the ship.
Minalas yon mga nadal e na saeman nakuha ang baril na issue at cellphone sinera pa aang soeed boat dapat bayaran ng chinese
Maritime expert! Pag matuloy ang giyera please kaw mauna ha. Wag ka atakbo.
Na Lawko na ang CHINA 🇨🇳😭😢😂
bring it on and feel the filipino might😮
Tama ng mga daldal,
Expert ha?Hindi tama yung puro salita lang ng nagki-claim na expert.
Kala ko ba expert ka sa maritime batongbacal
May mga armas, piru pinayagan nila, pumasok sa kanilang banka!at kunin pa kagamitan nila, then what is the use of your patrolling?hayagan Pangbubully..tayo ba ang susunod sa mga dayuhan,?how can we protect our very own TERRITORY?nasaan na ang LUPANG HINIRANG?
pilipino should figrh for our territory. we should not allow to be bullied by thrm.
TROOP STATION??? do you mean the deliberatly brokendown stranding ship in 1995 right after United States/nato illegal bombing of the Chinese embassy in Belgrade？