@@testing_somethinghe is literally signed to columbia records (which he/his team is actively trying to hide to make him look independant) and his manager is one of the best in the game. hes a plant.
Is their a genre name for "meme artists who layer their earnest yet shitty attempts at music with irony in an attempt to deflect and soften criticism"?
Same month kendrick called out drake for being a culture vulture a lot of people let Ian walk on the scene while he openly laughed about how he could get big just because he has the money to throw around.
@kenpatchiramasama1076he doesn’t even have to be a plant. He’s just some white kid from Dallas who decided he wanted to be a rapper. He’s not even trying to fake being legit.
@@joshuaharris5032 a white kid doing rap because he wants to, even if he sucks real bad, is not a culture vulture. Are you implying you have to be black, and likely from some ghetto? The gatekeep is entirely ridiculous at this point in history. He is a culture vulture, he is just a shitty non-artist who isnt even a meme. Nothing more, nothing less.
FD really cooked when he said white rappers that rap alright get a lot of praise when if they were black they would’ve been held to a higher standard next to their contemporaries.
fellow fd enjoyer. his videos made me see this type of shit in a different light. people who are okay with this heap are complicit until it's way past due.
That's true. Unfortunately plenty of trap artists all sound the same and it's hard to distinguish which is better. At least we have newer artists like LaRussell who are having a good time.
wdym dawg. this has literally been said over and over for the last 25 years. the biggest white rapper literally admitted this. this isnt a shocking revelation that you just deeped because fucking ian got popular 😂
its not new news, but people still don't really understand it. so many people say mac miller is a goat contender. and i like mac. faces is a great mixtape. but mac miller is NOT in the goat convo. he is in the white goat convo. and white people get those two convos jumbled up sometimes.
people will claim that the stuff Carti and Yeat do is talentless, but this is what would happen for the vast majority if they ever attempted this style of music
@@runa_7022 the underground fanbase are the ones that make ian blow up (im not saying hes underground anymore) but that whole community is prob about 16 - 21 so you dont rlly know what youre talking bout
"To anyone defending this tape, I promise you and I guarantee you that there are two dudes in your friend group who could poop this tape out in a day" I live for this level of hate
@@ghostylo888 there are many of these dudes floating around in the underground, it was inevitable one would finally find success, not even major success just success,
im getting concerned with the amount of artists recently (ian, lil mabu, etc) who are very blatantly purchasing their way into hiphop success off of twitter advertising. certainly the concept of industry plants isnt anything new to hiphop but its very disheartening to see the amount of people who appear to be fine with this wave of it - especially when theyre more or less just copying artists who are actually pushing the genre forward a la carti & yeat in ian's case
Respectfully my man, just cause u just found out about him doesn’t mean he bought his way into success. I mean yeah he probably used his money to get some help, he doesn’t really hide that, but he has legit fans and has been doing music for years now.
@@polarhero57bro he is literally trying to hide it, hes signed to columbia records and has one of the best managers in the game but him/his team is actively trying to hide it to make him look independant
I know people joke about industry plants a lot, but he genuinely feels like one. You're telling me a guy named Ian O'Neill Smith just all of the sudden blows up in the rap scene? Gets Marshawn Lynch in his first major music video? With music as shit as this? Idk man, smells fishy to me...
It feels very much like one day he was listening to his favorite carti/yeat track and thought I could do this and said “hey dad can you have a studio built in the guest house? “ And now here we are.
When he compared them to carti he is saying that the cadence, delivery and adlib driven trap melodys are directly inspired by carti. When yeat was coming up everyone said he sounded like carti, so if Ian sounds like yeat, and yeat sounds like carti, then ya know.
@@undergroundplug2271you very clearly do not understand my comment. Nor do you understand how widespread musical influence works. It literally doesn’t matter what he said in any interview, carti influenced and help build the entire wave and cadence Ian is ripping off. But im sure your a kid who doesn’t know anything about that, so really your comment is a reach.
@@emilianorodriguez8961 can u name me some carti songs in which Ian could’ve done so for those songs like genuinely curious cuz I been tranna listen to carti
Yeah, this is my real problem with modern music. Music in the TikTok era feels less like artistic expression and more like another avenue to be an influencer type figure, in both the underground and mainstream. Hopefully it changes soon cause I don't wanna sound like a hater.
@@paulg6778 And of course, all musicians are lavishly paid for their craft in the present day. No such thing as a couch surfing musician in today's climate.
@@paulg6778That’s not what OP is saying. They’re saying they’re sick of people who _only_ want to be famous and will just lazily shit out whatever passes as music that will get them there, with little to no regard for artistic expression whatsoever. You can almost always tell when somebody’s doing that, and Ian is a prime example. Yes, that has always been a thing to some extent, but it has undeniably become way easier and more common to get successful off that since TikTok started. They’re taking places that artists with some form of talent could’ve and should’ve had.
@@paulg6778 Listen I’m not being nostalgic for the good old days when those people didn’t exist, people who don’t care for music and just wanna be a musician to be famous have always existed, and they always sucked. If I had to guess why it’s way more prevalent now it’d just be because if you’ve got money, an iPhone and no conscious you can pay for beats and rip artist off way faster.
why does everyone hate on ian but know anything about him just make assumptions. he’s a cool dude everyone who’s hating just hates themselves and don’t appreciate creativity
@@keyscored3710calling it trap music is a stretch. Gucci, Future, Migos and artist of the like are trap. This is a parody if anything and I can’t see why you would play this with a serious face anywhere.
@@codymelchert2681 you have no evidence to support this fact and I will continue to harass online figures I see as non-people due to their presence in the fake space i operate within
As an Ian, I apologize. We’re doing our best to push him out of the Ian Community. He’s dodged our calls and barged out of interventions. It’s a whole thing it’s a real problem we Ian’s are dealing with.
lol a old white dude is not gonna understand this music, an anime nerd won’t either. everyone else is calling this album fire except fantano viewers i wonder why
@@JaMorantBiggerArm i remember yeats first projects which was objectively his prime Fantano gave him a pretty low score and then he switched up because he’s weird. The same thing is going to happen. I genuinely believe everyone who is saying this project is not good just doesn’t understand what Ian is trying to do. It sucks to see so many people spread so much negativity to something that in my eyes is very creative and refreshing in the underground scene
@@prodwazzam How was yeat in his prime when he was just starting? I think fantano "switched up" because yeat genuinely got better and made his own lane. Also, genuine question; care to explain how this is very creative and refreshing in the underground? I feel like I've heard these songs before
@@ImMajinsI have listened to the album and I can conclude that it is bad. I can’t even remember one melody or line off of it because that’s how forgettable it was
@@nathangoodwin6073I do not have time to listen to a trash album more than once. It’s trash and I’m 19, just because you like trash doesn’t mean anyone else has to.
@xch00F I dont like Ian at all, but these comments are right, he is clearly ripping off yeat way more than carti. Whats the point in lying just cause we don't like the music, especially when they aren't even praising it and instead just pointing out how derivative it is. Fantano can be wrong, doesnt mean anyone is coping for the artist. Its like when fantano called MIKE an earl clone and people pointed out its kind of the other way around, its nothing crazy that he gets things wrong sometimes cus anyone reviewing as much music as him is gna say some stuff thats just factually wrong at points.
@xch00F Ok? Ians Music is trash but that doesnt mean we just lie abt it (as i said bf4) bcus that is weird. There are tons of comments on this video saying the same thing and most of those ppl also qualified that they didnt like the album either. Im sorry i didn't shorten my post for you MR Choof, just assumed you wouldn't have have a hard time reading a single paragraph.
@@lavalamp4566because all these guys are immitating carti. Their delivery, flow, beats and even sometimes the way that they dress are all obviously influenced by playboi carti.
@@dabear7822 He literally sounds exactly like Carti on some of these tracks. I definitely hear more Yeat than anyone, but to say his sound has no resemblance to Carti at all is just a lie. He just sounds like every suburban white boys favorite rappers rolled in one.
That one irony poisoned friend everybody has whose only method of interacting with others is showing them annoying memes on his phone is not gonna like this
Just an industry plant who’s label paid every hip hop news outlet and Instagram page to talk about this guy for the last month. I nor most anyone else can even name one song from him
only good thing to come out of my ian listening experience is the line "diamonds on my wrist, i dont know what time it is" because now i'm imagining this rich white frat guy who buys himself an ungodly expensive analog watch while having no idea how to read it
He’s literally just a horrible imitation of carti future gucci mane and lil baby. It’s just nothing music, just cheap imitation devoid of any real substance. Rap doesn’t have to be the most introspective deep stuff but even this music as more chill fun music is just a load of nothing. Just another cog in this machine of “rappers” that are more about their image than anything else
@@sarang8585it angers me that dude did nothing wrong he’s just expressing himself through music and people hate. he’s not putting on a facade, he’s not trying to be something he’s not, he is just being himself. Grow up
It goes to show that even if you aren't talented, even if its not clear whether you actually care about music, if you have wealthy parents then you are gonna be heard.
I don’t understand why people shit on fantanos review of mbdtf so much. From what I understand from my listen, the album is a deep dive into Kanye’s social life. Fantano said that he doesn’t really care about that, and so he gave it a 6. It might just be me, but a 6 seems to be a fair score for an album if you don’t care about the thing the entire album is based around.
If you gonna call ian a ripoff of someone then it has to be Yeat, not carti (I have never listened to ian in my life and just go off what other people are saying)
anthony beefing with ian, never thought I’d see smosh end this way
🔥🔥🔥
lmao
lmao
THIS is what a top comment should be lol
unbelievable
Anthony you cant hate on Ian just because you quit Smosh
This comment is a safe space for boomers
Dude… He rejoined Smosh
i know you thought you were cooking with that one, and guess what, you were right
@@voe8 one of the earliest youtubers I've ever watched and I was borned in 06. Perfect time to experience life
Holy shit that was BARS LMAO 😂😂😂😂
Fantano couldn’t handle the aura of another swagged out white boy on the scene
Swagged out but trash music 😔
@@patrickpinhead9535 the tape is pretty mid but respect never stop and bentayga 🙏
Ian swagged out so hard, Supa Hot decided to plot with Anthony to destroy his career.
for real
goated with the sauce
Ian was never going to match the lyrical and philosophical highs of sexy red
Good comment
But in all seriousness if he scores her album the same as the new Billie or more I’m gonna throw a fit
@@lucidkangaroo8973boo hoo
I mean, sexx red's not good, but this is SIGNIFICANTLY worse imo
Has Sexyy Red become the new overused joke? Did you guys finally get over the dumb MBDTF jokes?
thank god its a two tone flannel
underrated
hey you're the top comment on freaky ty dolla sign
@@bigtomar is this really my legacy now
@@nnitro yeah put that on your tombstone
hey man youre that guy from freaky ty dolla sign
Anthony Fantano the type of guy to listen to music
I’ve yet to see any evidence of this claim
big if true
No way💔💔
No cap
2024 MUSIC
When i'm in an industry plant competition and my opponent is Ian
Blud he was making music for years
@@testing_something he can still be an industry plant tho
@@rynek2993 maybe. Or maybe he just worked hard for a couple years and had a song reach lyrical lemonade
@@testing_something okay??? Changes nothing big dawg
@@testing_somethinghe is literally signed to columbia records (which he/his team is actively trying to hide to make him look independant) and his manager is one of the best in the game. hes a plant.
The thing is, Ian isn’t even quirked up; he’s literally just a white boy. That’s it. That’s his gimmick.
lol so how is it a gimmick. you sound dumb bro can’t even be himself
i’m gonna laugh so hard when fantano switches up in a few years like he always does
@@prodwazzam switches up or an artist gets better?
@@JaMorantBiggerArm the person you replied doesnt understand what you would be talking about
@@xBINARYGODx Ur white
Is their a genre name for "meme artists who layer their earnest yet shitty attempts at music with irony in an attempt to deflect and soften criticism"?
lil dickycore
dickycore
Yung Gravy Inc.
@@z144pidk man i think lil dicky was here first
you will never understand and its okay
Same month kendrick called out drake for being a culture vulture a lot of people let Ian walk on the scene while he openly laughed about how he could get big just because he has the money to throw around.
cuz he has talent who cares.u sound mad lame
mfs dont want anyone whos white to rap
@kenpatchiramasama1076he doesn’t even have to be a plant. He’s just some white kid from Dallas who decided he wanted to be a rapper. He’s not even trying to fake being legit.
@kenpatchiramasama1076he’s not exempt from being criticized as a culture vulture just cause he’s open about it
@@joshuaharris5032 a white kid doing rap because he wants to, even if he sucks real bad, is not a culture vulture. Are you implying you have to be black, and likely from some ghetto? The gatekeep is entirely ridiculous at this point in history. He is a culture vulture, he is just a shitty non-artist who isnt even a meme. Nothing more, nothing less.
FD really cooked when he said white rappers that rap alright get a lot of praise when if they were black they would’ve been held to a higher standard next to their contemporaries.
fellow fd enjoyer. his videos made me see this type of shit in a different light. people who are okay with this heap are complicit until it's way past due.
That's true.
Unfortunately plenty of trap artists all sound the same and it's hard to distinguish which is better.
At least we have newer artists like LaRussell who are having a good time.
wdym dawg. this has literally been said over and over for the last 25 years. the biggest white rapper literally admitted this. this isnt a shocking revelation that you just deeped because fucking ian got popular 😂
its not new news, but people still don't really understand it. so many people say mac miller is a goat contender. and i like mac. faces is a great mixtape. but mac miller is NOT in the goat convo. he is in the white goat convo. and white people get those two convos jumbled up sometimes.
people will claim that the stuff Carti and Yeat do is talentless, but this is what would happen for the vast majority if they ever attempted this style of music
They are less than 1% worse than yeat or carti?
@@mckinleyostvig7135 I mean if youre deaf than yeah
@Jiiggy-dn8fd yes, no talent, anyone can make the music they make, you should try it out! Ill see you on rap caviar next year buddy!
@Jiiggy-dn8fdwhoa you’re so cool you only listen to lyrical miracle rappers wow bro
@Jiiggy-dn8fdyou don’t have a pfp your cringe
The 14 year olds will not like this Mr. Melon
bro what are you talking about💀 no 14 year old is listening to ian you dont even know his fanbase
@@logy2720alright 12 year olds happy?
Dude his fanbase is like a grown ass college kid or sophomore junior highschooler
@@logy2720did u just turn 14 today?
@@runa_7022 the underground fanbase are the ones that make ian blow up (im not saying hes underground anymore) but that whole community is prob about 16 - 21 so you dont rlly know what youre talking bout
This album sounds like you asked AI to generate a yeat album
LMAOO
so true
these aren't even yeat type beats the beats on this are closer to check by gucci mane than sorry bout that 😭😭😭😭
With gucci mane beats somehow
yea right lmao
album cover might as well have been him doing a t pose in front of his high school band class in terms of redditness
Based pfp
def not the same "in terms of redditness" and that phrase in itself is very reddit btw
@@kr1t704 what
@@corncake4677are you not able to read
@@Gael-xs8cp im not able to understand retarded points
Anthony Fantano is Bald
but also…. my lover
most creative fantano hater
lies
Proof????
the sky is blue
lil mabu as yeat
best comparison
Eww 🤢
Hello Colin
ian i like purple
Facts
"To anyone defending this tape, I promise you and I guarantee you that there are two dudes in your friend group who could poop this tape out in a day"
I live for this level of hate
it’s not hate tho it’s facts
@@omgryannn where the dudes then
@@ghostylo888 me
@@ghostylo888 there are many of these dudes floating around in the underground, it was inevitable one would finally find success, not even major success just success,
ian fans would be really mad right now if they could read
this a video
Sorry I like having fun
@@mastersoftodayhe ironically made himself look dumber than any Ian fan 💀
im getting concerned with the amount of artists recently (ian, lil mabu, etc) who are very blatantly purchasing their way into hiphop success off of twitter advertising. certainly the concept of industry plants isnt anything new to hiphop but its very disheartening to see the amount of people who appear to be fine with this wave of it - especially when theyre more or less just copying artists who are actually pushing the genre forward a la carti & yeat in ian's case
Respectfully my man, just cause u just found out about him doesn’t mean he bought his way into success. I mean yeah he probably used his money to get some help, he doesn’t really hide that, but he has legit fans and has been doing music for years now.
@@polarhero57bro he is literally trying to hide it, hes signed to columbia records and has one of the best managers in the game but him/his team is actively trying to hide it to make him look independant
he is simply an industry plant @@polarhero57
@@GodTalkinShhh in damn near every video he posts he shows how much money he and his family have. he never tried to say he came from nothing.
He will either last or not, memes die, legends never does
I know people joke about industry plants a lot, but he genuinely feels like one. You're telling me a guy named Ian O'Neill Smith just all of the sudden blows up in the rap scene? Gets Marshawn Lynch in his first major music video? With music as shit as this? Idk man, smells fishy to me...
he is a straight up industry plant, he's been signed to columbia for years
He’s not, I know him personally. I understand your skepticism because it makes sense, but sad to see rumors about him yk
how is his music bad? are you just stupid? its on par with his inspo like future and thug, you are just a weird poser
@@beckettgonzales6754🤥
No matter what the dude sucks
He’s ripping off Yeat not Carti lol. Nothing he does sounds like Carti at all
he’s ripping off multiple artists in that soundscape. how does he not sound like Carti? how can people not hear that, it’s so blatant
@@KUAMAPlease explain in what way he doesn’t even use the same type of beats or flow 😭😭
.. yes he does. Objectively
@@nodical802 Objectively means nothing anymore bruh explain how he sounds like Carti
@@slatwalter4121 its the exact same vocal inflection
TikTok won’t like this..
old fart
Good.
VERY GOOD.
What’re they gonna do, be *_more white_* at him?
more like Twitter or X whatever you wanna call it
It feels very much like one day he was listening to his favorite carti/yeat track and thought I could do this and said “hey dad can you have a studio built in the guest house? “ And now here we are.
😂😂
sounds good tho so who cares how it was made just enjoy the music
that would be fine if I enjoyed the music @@jordanknight1235
How dare he have a loving parent with disposable income
Here after Tyler called his music sh*t 💀
ian so dog 😭😭
@@interjoshian tuff, but every artist will have a group of haters
@@leftright8833he's tuff to listen to that album was the worst 20 minutes of my life
@@de1etion96 that’s your opinion
@@leftright8833And it's the right one. Enjoy listening to that basic unseasoned chicken wannabe gangsta boy
I agree with the rating but you really have to stop comparing every underground rapper to carti. He rips off of yeat 10x more than he rips off carti
When he compared them to carti he is saying that the cadence, delivery and adlib driven trap melodys are directly inspired by carti. When yeat was coming up everyone said he sounded like carti, so if Ian sounds like yeat, and yeat sounds like carti, then ya know.
@@emilianorodriguez8961you should watch sxpranos interview 😂😂😂 he isn’t even inspired by carti so your comment on the melodies is a reach
@@undergroundplug2271you very clearly do not understand my comment. Nor do you understand how widespread musical influence works. It literally doesn’t matter what he said in any interview, carti influenced and help build the entire wave and cadence Ian is ripping off. But im sure your a kid who doesn’t know anything about that, so really your comment is a reach.
yeat himself is a carti rip off stop talking
@@emilianorodriguez8961 can u name me some carti songs in which Ian could’ve done so for those songs like genuinely curious cuz I been tranna listen to carti
I don’t have any time for music made by people who wanna be famous, rather than people who have a passion for music, it’s fucking everywhere now man
Yeah, this is my real problem with modern music. Music in the TikTok era feels less like artistic expression and more like another avenue to be an influencer type figure, in both the underground and mainstream. Hopefully it changes soon cause I don't wanna sound like a hater.
Yes, I too long for the 70s, 80s, 90s, 2000s and 2010s, when there was no fame or money in music
@@paulg6778 And of course, all musicians are lavishly paid for their craft in the present day. No such thing as a couch surfing musician in today's climate.
@@paulg6778That’s not what OP is saying. They’re saying they’re sick of people who _only_ want to be famous and will just lazily shit out whatever passes as music that will get them there, with little to no regard for artistic expression whatsoever. You can almost always tell when somebody’s doing that, and Ian is a prime example.
Yes, that has always been a thing to some extent, but it has undeniably become way easier and more common to get successful off that since TikTok started. They’re taking places that artists with some form of talent could’ve and should’ve had.
@@paulg6778 Listen I’m not being nostalgic for the good old days when those people didn’t exist, people who don’t care for music and just wanna be a musician to be famous have always existed, and they always sucked. If I had to guess why it’s way more prevalent now it’d just be because if you’ve got money, an iPhone and no conscious you can pay for beats and rip artist off way faster.
Speaking outside of his music... He gives me "My dad will sue your dad" vibes.
this is, literally, the joke
@@zhernandoz43ok
why does everyone hate on ian but know anything about him just make assumptions. he’s a cool dude everyone who’s hating just hates themselves and don’t appreciate creativity
@@prodwazzamI know you’re probably like 13 and haven’t actually listened to enough music to understand this yet, but there’s no creativity here
@@prodwazzamCan you like... Say less snowflake stuff?
If it was called "To pimp a valedictorian" you would've given it a 10
It’s crazy how you can just put zero effort into your music and people on the internet will still treat it like high art.
Typical no IQ fans: nah y'all buggin blud fr fr 😂😂
No one's really treating this album as high art, it's just silly trap music that people will bump in their car
@@keyscored3710calling it trap music is a stretch. Gucci, Future, Migos and artist of the like are trap. This is a parody if anything and I can’t see why you would play this with a serious face anywhere.
@@keyscored3710silly suburban hip hop imitation music*
i played this whole album while doing errands this morning and it was a fun listen nothing crazy but it has one liners and cool flows
that isn’t how you spell twenty one pilots
this is completely a joke
@@thetragedyofcommons delete this
@@codymelchert2681 this is just a joke about the new twenty one pilots album being not good (which isn’t even true)
@@codymelchert2681 you have no evidence to support this fact and I will continue to harass online figures I see as non-people due to their presence in the fake space i operate within
@@codymelchert2681Mfs try not to see things by face value challange(99%FAIL)
As an Ian, I apologize. We’re doing our best to push him out of the Ian Community. He’s dodged our calls and barged out of interventions.
It’s a whole thing it’s a real problem we Ian’s are dealing with.
Lmao
The only honest reviewer of this album
lol a old white dude is not gonna understand this music, an anime nerd won’t either. everyone else is calling this album fire except fantano viewers i wonder why
@@prodwazzam He gave yeat an 8 and die lit a 7 (which he said grew on him so basically 8). This is just an uninspired album
@@JaMorantBiggerArm i remember yeats first projects which was objectively his prime Fantano gave him a pretty low score and then he switched up because he’s weird. The same thing is going to happen. I genuinely believe everyone who is saying this project is not good just doesn’t understand what Ian is trying to do. It sucks to see so many people spread so much negativity to something that in my eyes is very creative and refreshing in the underground scene
@@prodwazzam How was yeat in his prime when he was just starting? I think fantano "switched up" because yeat genuinely got better and made his own lane. Also, genuine question; care to explain how this is very creative and refreshing in the underground? I feel like I've heard these songs before
d riding like crazy
If you were 14 and played Fortnite you would give it a 10
Tyler hates Ian too lmao
A first NOT GOOD after 3 months. Good job, Anthony 🙏
You would've given this a 10 if it was made by Nettspend and I would too
nettspend is shit
ian js miles ahead of nett 😂😂😂
the last thing i thought of when bumping the tape was "he sound like carti"
he sounds like yeat
@@skylersopwho got his style from carti lmao
@@gotworcwow it’s almost like people take inspiration from others
bumped the tape too but even i gotta admit his adlibs & raspy voice sounds like music era carti
You know it's rough when Filthy Frank perfected the "white boy rapper" joke 9 years before you in a 3 minute skit instead of a full ass album.
this happening like 2 weeks after kendrick calling drake a colonizer is so ironic
Dave getting a stray is wild 💀
Nah for real 😂😂
He sounds more disgusted than he did in the Vultures video. I’m impressed by how bad this album is
make your own opinion
@@ImMajinsI have listened to the album and I can conclude that it is bad. I can’t even remember one melody or line off of it because that’s how forgettable it was
@@emilianorodriguez8961”I listened once and it’s bad” ok. Fantanos fan base is getting old. I swear yall don’t even listen to music
@@nathangoodwin6073I do not have time to listen to a trash album more than once. It’s trash and I’m 19, just because you like trash doesn’t mean anyone else has to.
@@emilianorodriguez8961 nobody said you had to
lyrical lemonades brand of hiphop is white
Their most popular artists that worked with them are black though (lil yachty, famous dex, ski mask and last of all juice wrld
@@ALIEN-DUDEbut their fanbases are 95% suburban white kids
ur so stupid for saying that yk that right
lyrical mayonaise
The lyrical lemonade fall off is insane
his adlibs sound kinda like yeat and the beats are like 06' Gucci Mane
He also sounds nothing like Carti
Seriously
Legit fantano has zero point of references with this one.
@xch00F I dont like Ian at all, but these comments are right, he is clearly ripping off yeat way more than carti. Whats the point in lying just cause we don't like the music, especially when they aren't even praising it and instead just pointing out how derivative it is. Fantano can be wrong, doesnt mean anyone is coping for the artist. Its like when fantano called MIKE an earl clone and people pointed out its kind of the other way around, its nothing crazy that he gets things wrong sometimes cus anyone reviewing as much music as him is gna say some stuff thats just factually wrong at points.
@xch00Fshi i was playing whole album in my car so much energy going on if u don’t get it u got a lizard brain and don’t like turning up
@xch00F Ok? Ians Music is trash but that doesnt mean we just lie abt it (as i said bf4) bcus that is weird. There are tons of comments on this video saying the same thing and most of those ppl also qualified that they didnt like the album either. Im sorry i didn't shorten my post for you MR Choof, just assumed you wouldn't have have a hard time reading a single paragraph.
Y’all thinking someone saying they don’t like something automatically means hating. Soft…
weird of you to say that he’s the third greatest white rapper, only behind tom macdonald and half of logic, but i still enjoyed the video
He's actually right about this. Rare Anthony W.
if this album was called valedictorian, you would have gave it a not good
The funniest thing is he doesn’t sound like carti or lil baby at all
Yeah ur tweakin he definitely sounds like old carti
@@elijahwhite7901 Sounds like yatchy to me
The funniest thing is that he’s still garbage regardless
Fantano also used to say Lil baby was a carbon copy of young thug if I remember correctly lol
@@elijahwhite7901 no
I just listened to the mixtape and I have to say I think it was made for the "I don't normally listen to rap music..." crowd.
ok justin simpson
@@SwiggleWas19 I didn't say I liked it.
Its funny i went to high school in tampa with the original had to do it to em guy, this album is entirely what he was in high school
Ian is saving the summer
He not ripping off carti and baby if anything it’s Yeat
Fantano just says that any underground artist he doesnt like is a carti copy
@@lavalamp4566because all these guys are immitating carti. Their delivery, flow, beats and even sometimes the way that they dress are all obviously influenced by playboi carti.
carti is yeats father
@@SeshiAthukam No thug is
As a Dallas native I’m sorry we let him happen
If I don’t know them, they aren’t Dallas lol
You’re in luck because he’s not from Dallas.. ST. Louis
this guy compares every up and coming rapper to playboi carti. ian sounds nothing like carti
Exactly 💀💀 i’m a massive carti fan and this sounds nothing like any carti era
he sounds more similiar to yeat than carti
He absolutely sounds like Carti on some songs
@@TheIntenseLime me when i’m deaf:
@@dabear7822 He literally sounds exactly like Carti on some of these tracks. I definitely hear more Yeat than anyone, but to say his sound has no resemblance to Carti at all is just a lie. He just sounds like every suburban white boys favorite rappers rolled in one.
Now we got culture vultures giving all Ian’s a bad name??? Anthony, this guy does not speak for me and other Ian’s everywhere.
Youre on a culture vultures channel bozo
If it was called to Val a dictorian you would have given it a 10
you dont recognize the bangers
new glo is the wave the beats on this are so fire
Ian is to rap what Nickelback is to rock.
That one irony poisoned friend everybody has whose only method of interacting with others is showing them annoying memes on his phone is not gonna like this
most chronically online comment section of all time 😂
BRO THIS GUY WENT TO MY HIGHSCHOOL HOW TF IS HE ON NEEDLE DROP
WHO IS IAN??? why do people keep acting like i should have known who this guy was before listening to this?
He’s raps new fanbase astroturfing world champion
Just an industry plant who’s label paid every hip hop news outlet and Instagram page to talk about this guy for the last month. I nor most anyone else can even name one song from him
Nobody can ever be objective, everything gets turned to race or just hate..
Couldn’t handle his aura
If this album was named sexyyy valedictorian you would've given it an 8
I REALLY DISAGREE WITH YOUR OPINION!
Rap for Tiktok obsessed surburban white kids that like Yeat .
only good thing to come out of my ian listening experience is the line "diamonds on my wrist, i dont know what time it is" because now i'm imagining this rich white frat guy who buys himself an ungodly expensive analog watch while having no idea how to read it
“can’t give em the time of day, really not here to impress nobody”
we can tell
He’s literally just a horrible imitation of carti future gucci mane and lil baby. It’s just nothing music, just cheap imitation devoid of any real substance. Rap doesn’t have to be the most introspective deep stuff but even this music as more chill fun music is just a load of nothing. Just another cog in this machine of “rappers” that are more about their image than anything else
Bro you prolly listen to Eminem I can’t blame you
@@snake999again I don’t tho, I love new rap music but there’s this awful shit that keeps seeping through that is just awful
@@snake999againeminem at his worst is better than ian at his best just so you know
This man don’t sound 💩 like future you guys are crazy lol he definitely trash though
@@coachkai45 that’s why it’s just a shit copy
0:35 bros stuck in 2018
You gave Sexyy Red a positive review, and for that your takes will forever be null and void good buddy 👍🏾.
That’s a very closed minded and idiotic way to think
if it was called "The Valedictorian", Fantano would have cried and given it a 10 on the spot.
Even the album cover is ripped off 😭
didn’t know skeletron was a fan of fantano
@@toasttttttttttttq what do you think I do in the dungeon all day 💀
This review is so brief, I think Anthony only played the first 5 seconds of each song and realized he couldn’t take anymore 😂
No matter the artist/genre I will always watch a ‘Not Good’
No Ian slander
Thanks for the review, I learned Ian is from Dallas. Love this artist!
We already got 2 great whiteboi rage albums with 2093 and Cold Visions.
anthony, you can't judge him because you're a salutitorian.
Fantano is not trusting what’s going on inside his gut 😔
carti and lil baby?? no sound?? LMFAOOO wtf are u talking abt dawg.. u are so clueless...
I swear that shit caught me off gaurd when he said 🤣
not all the new comments trying to defend Ian’s music lol
Of all underground artists fantano could've given attention to, it's egregious he even bothered to give this a negative review.
Lil dicky + dollar store Yeat = ian
“i’m just tryna be myself, I got everybody mad at me for it”
dude is not tryna be himself.
@@sarang8585it angers me that dude did nothing wrong he’s just expressing himself through music and people hate. he’s not putting on a facade, he’s not trying to be something he’s not, he is just being himself. Grow up
@@sarang8585 whos he tryna be?
@@sarang8585 yea cuz you would know
If it was called hottest hood Valedictorian, you would have gave it an 8
the real diss is making this review just 3 minutes.
It goes to show that even if you aren't talented, even if its not clear whether you actually care about music, if you have wealthy parents then you are gonna be heard.
how did his parents help at all with his blowup 😭
making up shit for fun 😂
Will we ever see another 'Not Bad' is the real question 🤔
bruh i actually thought it was ian from smosh who tf is this kid😭
Remember this is the same dude that gave Sexy Red an 8 and MBDTF lower than that💀 bro wants his chocolate wife back so bad
I don’t understand why people shit on fantanos review of mbdtf so much. From what I understand from my listen, the album is a deep dive into Kanye’s social life. Fantano said that he doesn’t really care about that, and so he gave it a 6. It might just be me, but a 6 seems to be a fair score for an album if you don’t care about the thing the entire album is based around.
He gave a black guy "kanye" a mid review, what does his wife have to do with anything you're being hurt from a review go outside
U really going to war for Ian💀
instead of actively hating on this guy it would be better to just let him fade into obscurity quicker since that's where he's headed anyway
BREAKING NEWS: Ian just spun Anthonys suburb with waterballons!
Coulda reviewed Vince but we get random whiteboy instead 😢
I know a guy who likes ian and thinks MF DOOM is trash
we know each other?
@@qmaineotcg you’re a grown ass man
@@djk1563 facts but not old enough to like lyrical shmerical bullshit
I’m tryna kick it w that guy
@@qmaineotcg literal brain issue lmao
If you gonna call ian a ripoff of someone then it has to be Yeat, not carti (I have never listened to ian in my life and just go off what other people are saying)
If it was “kids see Ian’s” he would’ve given it a 10
Already mentioned pooping out things involving music. Meat Canyon wasn't joking.
yeat wipes