When Can You Use Lethal Force For Self Defense In America?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 23

  • @skipdreadman8765
    @skipdreadman8765 8 днів тому +15

    For a minute, I thought there was an expert involved, but as soon as he tried to describe disparity of force without knowing the words, I realized this was a conversation between two amateurs.

    • @mthompson0331
      @mthompson0331 8 днів тому

      haha no but, you're allowed to defend yourself, with nuances in the story ( lol fuckin turds)

  • @AintRealz
    @AintRealz 7 днів тому +1

    Do whatever it takes to protect yourself and loved ones, then let the jury debate your actions later. Don't be distracted by the law when you're in an emergency.

  • @Mark-mm2px
    @Mark-mm2px 8 днів тому +2

    LA cop tells me I am not allowed to defend myself. Yeah no thanks, there's a reason we have the stand your ground law in the free state of Florida.

    • @lukeempty3386
      @lukeempty3386 7 днів тому

      The discussion is about lethal force, not self defence

    • @mishkaulitkin9476
      @mishkaulitkin9476 7 днів тому

      @@lukeempty3386 I wonder what will you do when physically assaulted on your property? "Hold on attacker, I will call police or will grab my pepper spray".

    • @TheIdiotsHaveTakenOver
      @TheIdiotsHaveTakenOver 7 днів тому

      😂😂😂 You're confusing "free" with "fascist," again. Unless, in your tiny mind, you consider the government telling people what they can say, read, and do with their bodies, as freedom. 🤡

    • @TheIdiotsHaveTakenOver
      @TheIdiotsHaveTakenOver 7 днів тому

      ​@@mishkaulitkin9476 What he hell are you even talking about? 😂😂

    • @seven7een993
      @seven7een993 6 днів тому

      You have no Constitutional carry, you arent free for shit.

  • @torengallagher8368
    @torengallagher8368 7 днів тому +1

    general rule of thumb is you need to be placed in reasonable immediate fear of your life and generally you need to use proportional force for the sake of preserving your life this is the limit of what you entitled to. even though this may not be a requirement its certainly something that is taken into account as well as your ability to retreat these are all mitigating factors regardless of where you are. you also intentionally cant put yourself in avoidable danger to provoke self defense this is a common misconception if you do this you will absolutely be charged with a crime and thats what this is he involved himself in an avoidable conflict and participate in the belligerence he displayed intent before the need of self defense arose its a really bad look
    this did look premeditated but the real issue here is the aggravated and negligent nature of it. even if you could justify the first shot (good luck btw) those follow up shots greatly enhance the criminal culpability and really really damages your criminal defense. also people are entitled to speech it wouldnt be reasonable to assume a person is litterally going to kill you if they said something to this effect alone also this enters a he said she said... not a good idea you need more then that also operating a firearm under the influence is a crime

  • @mariafrmdaBX
    @mariafrmdaBX 6 днів тому

    I moved to Texas a year ago and we have a stand your ground law here and although we own weapons, I don’t think I could ever do something so foolish! The reasons we own them are for hunting and hopefully never a home invasion!! this would not be one of those times where you could use it!

  • @mariafrmdaBX
    @mariafrmdaBX 6 днів тому

    2:43 Greg’s right that’s overkill!

  • @someperson5001
    @someperson5001 8 днів тому

    Alcohol establishments, Texas has a 51% rule. If a business makes 51% or more of their income from alcohol sales, they can post a 51% sign at their entrance prohibiting carrying a firearm in the establishment.

  • @nickiecass8808
    @nickiecass8808 7 днів тому

    24:59 preparing a weapon before going into a heated argument look like a premeditated act!

  • @colinjohnston5734
    @colinjohnston5734 7 днів тому

    If someone punches you unprovoked and you get shot it’s 100% justified in many states. Tones of case law. Sure California and NY the DA’s will attempt to prosecute but how no one is talking about it’s a state by state thing.

  • @TheIdiotsHaveTakenOver
    @TheIdiotsHaveTakenOver 7 днів тому

    The guy he's talking about, who was pushed down and shot and killed the guy who pushed him, was convicted of murder.

  • @seven7een993
    @seven7een993 6 днів тому

    First thirty seconds in and one Representative is a Police officer, so i already know everything is gonna be wrong and bootlicked, and from San Diego CA no less.

  • @007Ltaylor
    @007Ltaylor 4 дні тому

    No not justified