You mean, let me understand this ... cuz I ... maybe its me, maybe I'm a little fucked up maybe. I'm funny how, I mean funny, like I'm a clown? I amuse you. I make you laugh? I'm here to fuckin' amuse you? Whattya you mean funny? Funny how? How am I funny? What the fuck is so funny about me?
To me the funny thing was when tommy was telling his stories I was laughing just as much as they were and every time I watched it I laughed like it was the first time I seen this! Give thumbs up if you laugh at the jokes too.
For real! This movie is about 2 and a half hours long and yet it feels like just one hour. Wolf of Wall Street was over 3 hours and felt the same. Scorsese is a master of his craft!
Even The Irishman which is the longest runtime of any Scorsese's movies, it felt really fast, i was very engaged with the characters and it didn't feel like a 3 1/2 hour movie either, amazing indeed. Not too many scenes were slow, it's mostly because Scorsese is very detailed with the story especially in it's build up, he's such a genius
Could be. Like the beginning and middle of Goodfellas and the middle and ending of Casino. Wanted more of Goodfellas and Casino took a while to get started, for me
In my mind, Morrie's murder is the real turning point in the story, because for the first time Henry's authority as a near-omniscient narrator is undermined--he thinks he's saved Morrie, tells the audience this, and in the very next scene Morrie is killed anyway. The narrative, at that point, gets completely away from him as his downward spiral accelerates.
@@guitarreillywell imagine this as gruesome as that scene was in real life a guy like Morrie would have almost certainly shat himself in that car that night after being killed. Imagine the smell…
@@DonFelixGallardoit’s not even a matter of it being a guy like Morrie. Even in The Godfather novel, Puzo describes several characters as voiding their bowels while being garroted. And one fearsome character (avoiding names in the minute chance you haven’t seen the movie or read the book yet) voids while alive and slips on his own excrement, making it harder to him to fight back. Details like that can’t easily make it from page to screen
I agree except Blade Runner. You know that it wasn't well-received when it first came out. I've remained in that category. Even if I didn't, the best sci-fi movie would be either 2001 or Empire Strikes Back, maybe Alien. \m/
Mama Scorsese is such a good actress for someone who wasn’t an actress. I heard that scene was mostly improvised, so her reactions are perhaps genuine, but she contributes the the conversation in a great way. Good work Mrs. Scorsese!
SpicyKumquat yeah? I never said you follow the script. If the actor or director or whoever dont like the scene. They talk it through with the director and actor and try it out. Thats improv. Improv is rarely out of nowhere.
Great movies have great ironies: In Goodfellas we see Henry who adopts his mob family over his real one, but he never truly belongs among the mobsters. He doesn’t have what it takes to be a true gangster: when they kill a made man, Henry is there, but never participates in the actual beating and killing; he only (ironically) does the dirty work of digging the grave. When they have to dig up the corps, Henry literally doesn’t have the stomach for it as he has to stop and vomit, while the other two make jokes about eating peppers and sausages. A stark contrast. Throughout the movie, we see Henry as a thug, but never a true gangster. Among psychotic man, he is always the voice of reason, somehow trying to control a given situation with reason and by doing so, clearly showing that he doesn’t have what it takes in a world where everything is solved with violence. In fact, we never see Henry ever killing anyone, nor even in a fist fight. When everything is said and done, he turns on his family and disappears. He calls the rest of us schmucks, but we see him as the quintessential schmuck. Martin Scorsese, throughout his gangster movies, always demonstrates that the mob are ultimately bozos in a circus who kill or ditch each other on their way down.
The movie shows how the Mafia like to think of themselves as family. But what the young naive Henry mistook for a family was in fact a business. Jimmy wasn't afraid to kill his "family" when it benefitted him, Paulie had no problem abandoning his "family" in their need. It was all about the money. I think that's part of what drove Henry to betray them
Interesting that the only time he uses violence is in his domestic life- against the neighbour or on his wife. Never is he violent in his "professional" life.
in 2002 I was discussing the movie with some colleagues and was astounded to learn that our diminutive Manager had never seen the movie. I lent him a copy, which he held on to for months. Long story short, he became Tommy
Ever notice that when Henry slams the front door at the end of the movie, it doesn't make the sound of a front door? It makes the sound of a prison door slamming shut. I love those little touches in this movie.
This should've been Martin Scorsese's first Oscar win for Best Picture. Glad to see that Joe Pesci had won his for this role. He was truly convincing and his intensity was both funny and terrifying.
The Oscar’s are a pathetic joke. This basically proves it. If they were going to give him one it should have been for taxi driver in the late 70s or raging bull in 80 lol raging bull is literally a masterpiece, it’s literally in the top twenty of greatest films ever. It’s literally perfect, not one editing mistake in that film. Think about that, they gave a cartoon character an Oscar and not Martin Scorsese until the departed which is at the bottom of his films. If that’s not enough for you to wake up and realize the Oscar’s are just friends giving friends little trophy’s, idk what is.
Not just the best 'Gangster' Movie. One of my personal top five favorite movies of all time. Although as far back as I can remember I always wanted to be a Gangster.
I didn't even get the drum roll emphasizing the joke of Henry having a normal job. And that's just one of the things you point out that I missed. Very good film analysis of a great movie!
I love this movie because it shows the reality of the mafia. It’s romanticized in the beginning but then you realized it’s filled with psychopaths and selfish monsters.
Thank you for addressing that NY Post article, I thought it was absolutely ridiculous! I am a woman and Goodfellas and Casino are my favorite films of all time! I love Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci's characters! I behave very similar to Tommy (I share his temper) and I able to identify with his character. That scene where Tommy, Henry and the rest of the crew are laughing, discussing their problems, is very similar to how I hang out out with my best friends, whom are also female. Also, I LOVE the soundtrack!!!!!
Word of advice It’s not the best idea when making a point to say something like “he also says,” followed by nine seconds of muted footage... Just sayin’
Just a little trivia about the little girl who listened to Henry and Karen's fight. She was actually Lorraine Bracco's daughter. Also the toddler in the prison scene was her younger daughter. Being they were the correct age for the time sequence Lorraine suggested they use them and Scorsese agreed. I don't know if either ended up in acting but what a hoot to be in a few scenes with their Mom in a classic movie.
dfss csss yea i got a better one first five minutes of the movie when they stab billy bats and Jimmy shots him the gun doesn't go off but you hear the trigger
I mean one time the flash doesn't come on but what you said is interesting the only reason spider aka christopher from the sopranos got hired was from that little scene and Karen was offered to play tonys wife but said fuk that i did that already I'm be a therapist
That wasn’t a question, the statement was “Why GoodFellas is the BEST gangster movie of all time” and you forgot a word in your second sentence lol. “Oh g I don’t”
Thanks for the title... I always though it symbolized Billie Batts sleeping with the fishes... When they sing 'way down below the ocean'... very morbid scene when mixed with the music
Pesci was great in this film but was more deserving of an Academy Award for his performance in JFK. Also, Spider didn't play a prank on Tommy (at least not in the scene he is shot in the foot) If you watch the scene, several guys tell Spider what they want to drink, one guy says "I'm fine" Spider thinks Tommy says that and that why he doesn't bring him anything to drink which in turn starts all the trouble. I'm not trying to nitpick. Excellent analysis.
This some brilliance that shows the difference of detail from Goodfellas and the godfather the whole wedding sequence is longer than Henry's childhood sequence
"And all of their daughters were named Marie". This film is one of the greatest of all time; from the music to narration to cinematography, I love this movie. The movie did the book "Wiseguys" justice, painting a picture that not everything is not what it seems. The glorified violence, pious greed, and merciful theft sucked me in. I'm right there with the action getting sucked into the nuanced music placement per scene and the carefulness of each scene. Martin should have won this back in 1990 but I was only 3 when this movie came out. I appreciated this film sometime as a teenager and I can recite lines from the film from the film. It's obvious that you deserve what you get when you get what you deserve. This is not a negative or positive critique. However, it shows the lengths of obtaining what we want most in our lives only coming close to really deserving it. Are we ever deserving of the lifestyle we deem worthy of obtaining? I think this is one trope that is missed often (the narrator of this video touches upon it briefly in the beginning when Henry is a teen). We feel for Henry because we think/know he deserves the American Dream that ultimately becomes his American Nightmare. The feeling of belongingness closes the gap of this deservedness. It is this reason among many others that I love this movie. It examines so much of our own capacity, capability, and culpability with the people we most associate.
Henry was laughing at maury getting chocked out because before that scene the commercial says his wigs can handle hurricane winds but jimmy easily knocks it off by putting a chord on his neck xD
The music in this movie. My man. But then I'm 38, and grew up listening to the music of my Mother. Not that I don't love the Grunge of the 90's, or other things from the Dresden Dolls to The Airborne Toxic Event or George Watsky, but nothing is as pure as these 'Oldies'.
Henry Hill was a always smashed near the end of his life. He was a frequent guest on the Howard Stern show and they always made him look like a drunken fool.
Good review! Another crumbling moment was when Karen secretly visited Jimmy in the third act and he tried to have her killed, but she caught on to that. It seemed as such a naive move, but goes to show how little he thinks of this woman, trying the bare minimum to take her out. He underestimated her, and kept playing this fake role to his demise.
For the people watching the video and wondering why half of the audio is missing is likely bc the video was likely claimed so he had to edit out the audio. He should of added subtitles though.
"1) Never rat on your friends, and 2) Always keep your mouth shut." Yeah? What about "Never murder all your friends", huh, Conway? Also, "Never murder a made man, never help your psycho friend murder a made man, just because he hurled a mortal insult by telling him to go home to get his fucking shine box." All these people have the emotional intelligence of a 2-year old. Stunted, with real guns!
Thats the whole point of the movie, Gangsters pretend to have rules only to break them as they see fit. They see rules as justification for their poor behaviour and life choices.
Yeah whatever. It's all BS anyway. Give me a break. What are they going to tell you? If you get caught tell the cops everything and make a deal so you do less time? And all that advice to Henry did no good whatsoever. He ratted on everyone because he was facing a very long prison sentence.
Yes. There is an important earlier scene where Club Owner asks Paulie for ‘help’ and they become ‘partners’. To call him a ‘waiter’ is a bad miss by the reviewer.
@@JacksMovieReviews though it didn't happen in reality, it would be twice as scary if the Guy was built like he was in reality Tommy Desimoni was actually 6.2ft and was built like Rocky.
Thank you! I actually just did a video on The Departed and try and put some time in between looking at the same directors work. Here's that video if you haven't seen it. ua-cam.com/video/xLqFQV6Mno4/v-deo.html
Beyond doubt. One of the greatest ever American gangster films ever produced. Liotta,Pesci and de Niro chemistry is sublime. Up there with the first two Godfather films. That's for sure. 😊👍❤
There are many good points here but the one biggest problem i could see is when you state that Henry is is losing his love for the Mafia, but this simply isnt true because Henry states that his biggest problem when leaving the life is that he didnt want to leave the life, he still loved the life. But over all this is a good essay on this film, One of my favorite things about this film is how many different ways it can be interpreted. Ive watched this film to many times to count and i still get the same feeling of wow everytime i watch it.
If you’ve noticed an uptick in views, that’s me watching this video at least three times a week. (Currently working on my own crime screenplay.) Great work!!
I interpret that last scene where Tommy fires a gun into the camera a little differently. I interpret it as Henry reminiscing the life he had as a Mafia gangster, his "rockstar days". Henry doesn't really display an expression of fear, so much as one of nostalgia if that's possible to express.
What a great film review/analysis! Your video is both straightforward and comprehensive, and it also highlights some aspects that I definitely missed while rewatching this masterpiece.
Great video. I especially like the parts from the movie being presented in order to clarify key points of the analysis. Like when Ray Liota says: "_______________ " and Joe Pesci replies: " __________ " And then DeNiro enters the scene: "_______________" Man, really great lines
@@manuharter6382 Well, when he first uploaded the video, you could hear the tracks. But then UA-cam probably cut them off. And the uploader did not re-upload with subtitles afterwards
Great review, I learned a lot. I'm sure you were forced to remove the dialogue but if you could put subtitles in it would prevent this issue ruining the context.
Best commentary I have ever seen on this movie. A classic review for a classic movie. In as many times as I have seen the movie, I never noticed the methodology of the soundtrack as well as the shot lengths (other than the Copa scene).
Really well done analysis mate hats off to you. Goodfellas is my favourite film and love listening to others peoples take on what transpires in the movie. Some minor corrections that I feel I have to make however.... The man who approaches pauly about needing help in the resteraunt isn't a waiter, he likely owns the place or is involved heavily in its management. In the scene where Jimmy is attacking Maurey asking for his money, Henry isn't laughing because he genuinely enjoys the violence, but as a conpensatory factor to appear unfazed by it in the eyes of Jimmy, he wishes to be seen as someone who is impressed by the violence, but the character inherently is different from the others and sees violence as a part of the lifestyle, not as something he finds funny or enjoyable. Lastly spider isn't playing a prank on Tommy, he clearly is just simple minded and got confused with the guys orders.... Other than that great job mate really impressed! Keep it up!
Cameron MacRury I really appreciate that, but my channel has been growing faster than it ever has in the past few months, so I'm looking forward to the future
That's great! You've gained a new sub, keep up the content and you will continue to grow, you should do some more Scorsese films would like to hear what you have to say
Cameron MacRury You may like my video about Hugo, I looked at that and a lot of his other films that inspired it. I also did a video on The Wolf of Wall Street that may interest you
That's your opinion, I like Godfather better, that movie is just out of the world, keep in mind that's like the first classic I watched, but I ain't going to lie the first time I watched it was slow but the second time it was amazing.
I read the book "Wiseguy" before the movie came out, it was a very good book and I feared the movie would not live up to it, I was presently surprised. The book has much more detail, worth a read.
I think the drugs is the turning point in the movie. Without that cash, jimmy might have killed him off also. The money was just too good to pass up. But in doing that, he was doomed to failure. He would eventually get hooked and get caught. It saved his life by giving him a choice later: rat on his friends or die. The only person jimmy would have let live without that is tommy. What I never understood was paulie allowing jimmy to kill them all off. Isn't that a huge waste of manpower? Did paulie end up telling jimmy that they had to seem legit so to tie up loose ends? I also feel bad that tutti ends up vanishing in the movie. The movie has so much conflict on varying levels. It's incredible.
Jimmy wacked all those guys because of them possibly being rats, but also because he wanted the money all to himself. I'm not sure if the real Jimmy even asked for permission to wack all the robbers as most or all of them were only Lucchese associates. I have read stories of people claiming Jimmy had Tommy wacked which is ridiculous because according to Henry the only time he saw Jimmy cry was when they got the news Tommy got wacked.
Yeah whatever. Gotti was dealing drugs. That's why he killed Paul Castellano. He realized that Paul was going to find out what he was doing, so he figured he would kill him first before Paul had him killed.
I always liked how he used colours in this movie - notice 05:07 - they EAT from a table that has a very peculiar red almost "glowing" - exactly the same "glowing red" of the first scene, when they stab "Batts", and - AGAIN the same red "glow" when they dig him up back again after 6 months - i.e: they live and sustain themselves, from murder and the misery of other people.
Joe Pesci is a funny guy.
You mean, let me understand this ... cuz I ... maybe its me, maybe I'm a
little fucked up maybe. I'm funny how, I mean funny, like I'm a clown? I
amuse you. I make you laugh? I'm here to fuckin' amuse you? Whattya you
mean funny? Funny how? How am I funny?
What the fuck is so funny about me?
Funny how?
Don't Max he knows what he said, he's a big boy...
To me the funny thing was when tommy was telling his stories I was laughing just as much as they were and every time I watched it I laughed like it was the first time I seen this! Give thumbs up if you laugh at the jokes too.
Sany funny how?
Martin Scorsese’s pacing in his movies are amazing! It doesn’t feel like your watching an almost 3 hour movie.
For real! This movie is about 2 and a half hours long and yet it feels like just one hour. Wolf of Wall Street was over 3 hours and felt the same. Scorsese is a master of his craft!
true, its all wonderfully shot. This and pulp fiction are my favorite gangster movies.
Even The Irishman which is the longest runtime of any Scorsese's movies, it felt really fast, i was very engaged with the characters and it didn't feel like a 3 1/2 hour movie either, amazing indeed. Not too many scenes were slow, it's mostly because Scorsese is very detailed with the story especially in it's build up, he's such a genius
There was literally a one hour prologue what are you talking about?
Ik this ain’t goodfellas but after the first viewing, every repeat of the Irishman goes from 3 and half hours to about 2 hours.
I’m gonna go get the paper get the paper
Papers*
You’re doing it wrong
Pay-piz
@@donnastitz1497 Actually its JIMMY! 1 and a half times... believe me, I've seen the movie 701 times
@@donnastitz1497 You my friend. are donna sititz
I feel like goodfellas is the reason casino is really really REALLY underrated
Could be. Like the beginning and middle of Goodfellas and the middle and ending of Casino. Wanted more of Goodfellas and Casino took a while to get started, for me
Cristian Saucedo casino is better
@@37H662 Wow. Feel like people would say Goodfellas is better. Why do you think Casino is better?
Complex Outlaw i agree mainly bc it’s more flashy. goodfellas is more gritty imo
Goodfellas was definitely more animated, action packed while Casino seemed to mirror true events regarding Vegas and its start.
In my mind, Morrie's murder is the real turning point in the story, because for the first time Henry's authority as a near-omniscient narrator is undermined--he thinks he's saved Morrie, tells the audience this, and in the very next scene Morrie is killed anyway. The narrative, at that point, gets completely away from him as his downward spiral accelerates.
Good eye.
Great point
Great point I also think it's the most brutally violent scene I've ever seen. It's absolutely disgusting and hard to think about
@@guitarreillywell imagine this as gruesome as that scene was in real life a guy like Morrie would have almost certainly shat himself in that car that night after being killed. Imagine the smell…
@@DonFelixGallardoit’s not even a matter of it being a guy like Morrie. Even in The Godfather novel, Puzo describes several characters as voiding their bowels while being garroted. And one fearsome character (avoiding names in the minute chance you haven’t seen the movie or read the book yet) voids while alive and slips on his own excrement, making it harder to him to fight back. Details like that can’t easily make it from page to screen
Best gangster movie: Goodfellas
Best mafia movie: The Godfather
Best thug/hood movie: Boyz 'n' the Hood
I agree except Blade Runner. You know that it wasn't well-received when it first came out. I've remained in that category. Even if I didn't, the best sci-fi movie would be either 2001 or Empire Strikes Back, maybe Alien.
\m/
link biff i agree with 2001 but not alien and definitely not TESB.
link biff nahh menace 2 society is way better
Boyz in the hood is the godfather. Menace II society is goodfellas. Menace is a better, more realistic movie.
It's not a "thug" movie, its called a "hood" movie. If they are thugs so are Henry, Jimmy, and Tommy
Mama Scorsese is such a good actress for someone who wasn’t an actress. I heard that scene was mostly improvised, so her reactions are perhaps genuine, but she contributes the the conversation in a great way. Good work Mrs. Scorsese!
Yeah shes brilliant, and in casino as well where she stares straight at the camera!! 10/10
Both his parents were in his movies till they passed. Pops was the cook in jail
@Age Restrictions they are always really eating in movies. I wouldn't be surprised if they were really breathing
Which character did she play
@@Cashcash69 I’m Goodfellas, Tommy’s mom
"Always keep your mouth shut"
Proceeds to blurt out his entire freaking life story
Character development!
And rat his every friend
because he was narrating after he ratted all his friends out and was under witness protection so it was fine if he told his life story
He’s talking about his life in like a book.
After he left. It’s a story lol
@@mrmhj9925 nope, he told the story to the judges
Pesci improvised the "funny how" scene. Brilliant
Mike Riley he didnt improvise it but it was his idea that he brought up to scorsese
@@SpicyKumquat yeah thats kind of what improvising is. You dont just out of nowhere start going off line. You bring it up with the director.
@@elmarsadigov2537 Writing a scene and then performing that scene with what you wrote is the exact opposite of what improvising is lol
SpicyKumquat yeah? I never said you follow the script. If the actor or director or whoever dont like the scene. They talk it through with the director and actor and try it out. Thats improv. Improv is rarely out of nowhere.
@@elmarsadigov2537 He brought it up to Scorsese and Scorsese had him write the scene and come back with it. It wasn't improvised
Great movies have great ironies: In Goodfellas we see Henry who adopts his mob family over his real one, but he never truly belongs among the mobsters. He doesn’t have what it takes to be a true gangster: when they kill a made man, Henry is there, but never participates in the actual beating and killing; he only (ironically) does the dirty work of digging the grave. When they have to dig up the corps, Henry literally doesn’t have the stomach for it as he has to stop and vomit, while the other two make jokes about eating peppers and sausages. A stark contrast. Throughout the movie, we see Henry as a thug, but never a true gangster. Among psychotic man, he is always the voice of reason, somehow trying to control a given situation with reason and by doing so, clearly showing that he doesn’t have what it takes in a world where everything is solved with violence. In fact, we never see Henry ever killing anyone, nor even in a fist fight. When everything is said and done, he turns on his family and disappears. He calls the rest of us schmucks, but we see him as the quintessential schmuck. Martin Scorsese, throughout his gangster movies, always demonstrates that the mob are ultimately bozos in a circus who kill or ditch each other on their way down.
He beat that guy up. He used violence. You said he didn't.
It was an extremely complicated performance. Insane that Ray Liotta wasn't even nominated for an oscar.
The movie shows how the Mafia like to think of themselves as family. But what the young naive Henry mistook for a family was in fact a business. Jimmy wasn't afraid to kill his "family" when it benefitted him, Paulie had no problem abandoning his "family" in their need. It was all about the money. I think that's part of what drove Henry to betray them
Interesting that the only time he uses violence is in his domestic life- against the neighbour or on his wife. Never is he violent in his "professional" life.
Zeke Thomas but he didn’t kill him
"entertaining group, entertaining group" I see what you did there
@Leo Kay they call one of the dudes in that scene two time because he says everything twice lol
Making a reference to Jimmy Two Times who of course said everything twice
I'm glad you get it, I'm glad you get it
Jimmy 2 times.
lmao...lmao
"as far back as I can remember I wanted to be a gangster" That line is etched into my brain
Recently got voted as the greatest opening line in cinema :)
*Always
in 2002 I was discussing the movie with some colleagues and was astounded to learn that our diminutive Manager had never seen the movie.
I lent him a copy, which he held on to for months.
Long story short, he became Tommy
😂
You probably figured that out when he cracked a joke in staff meeting and a poor temp said, 'Man, you're funny!'
@@guibox3 funny how
Was he a funny guy?
He was killed when he was told he was promoted? Damn
Ever notice that when Henry slams the front door at the end of the movie, it doesn't make the sound of a front door? It makes the sound of a prison door slamming shut. I love those little touches in this movie.
The Godfather plays like a dream, Goodfellas plays like a nightmare.
If you read the book he says Godfather was a fairy tale to them.
The Godfather is how the Mafia wanted to be portrayed. Goodfellas is how the mafia was.
Vince Gonzalez copied mate
@@vincegonzalez2171 no
@@uncleiroh9134 Wow, that was a well thought out and well-articulated response! Very impressive.
This should've been Martin Scorsese's first Oscar win for Best Picture. Glad to see that Joe Pesci had won his for this role. He was truly convincing and his intensity was both funny and terrifying.
100% should’ve won for best picture. Not saying dances with wolves wasn’t a worthy competitor but this should’ve won
@@neonnoodle1169 Dances With Wolves was awesome, i love that movie but Goodfellas was clearly superior in just about every way
The Oscar’s are a pathetic joke. This basically proves it. If they were going to give him one it should have been for taxi driver in the late 70s or raging bull in 80 lol raging bull is literally a masterpiece, it’s literally in the top twenty of greatest films ever. It’s literally perfect, not one editing mistake in that film. Think about that, they gave a cartoon character an Oscar and not Martin Scorsese until the departed which is at the bottom of his films. If that’s not enough for you to wake up and realize the Oscar’s are just friends giving friends little trophy’s, idk what is.
Taxi Driver is still Scorsese's best film
Not just the best 'Gangster' Movie. One of my personal top five favorite movies of all time. Although as far back as I can remember I always wanted to be a Gangster.
Not after watching the film i hope.
*Rags to Riches starts playing*
RIP Paul Sorvino and Ray Liotta... amazing actors in an amazing movie
Don't forget RIP Nicolas Pileggi who wrote the book and co-wrote the movie
I didn't even get the drum roll emphasizing the joke of Henry having a normal job. And that's just one of the things you point out that I missed. Very good film analysis of a great movie!
I love this movie because it shows the reality of the mafia. It’s romanticized in the beginning but then you realized it’s filled with psychopaths and selfish monsters.
The sound from the actual movie cuts out just so you know for next time.
AC MM Its weird, if you listen in headphones its there
No it isn't. I'm wearing headphones right now
Nathan Spradlin yeah it is idiot
@@nathanspradlin8570
Headphones fixed the problem for me.
If your headphones are in mono you can’t hear it
It also spawned the great Pesci's immortal rap song "wiseguy"
Thank you for addressing that NY Post article, I thought it was absolutely ridiculous! I am a woman and Goodfellas and Casino are my favorite films of all time! I love Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci's characters! I behave very similar to Tommy (I share his temper) and I able to identify with his character. That scene where Tommy, Henry and the rest of the crew are laughing, discussing their problems, is very similar to how I hang out out with my best friends, whom are also female. Also, I LOVE the soundtrack!!!!!
Thanks Mel! I read that article, thought it was ridiculous, and made the video a few weeks later!
Word of advice
It’s not the best idea when making a point to say something like “he also says,” followed by nine seconds of muted footage...
Just sayin’
"Entertaining group, entertaining group"
Only a hardcore fan of Scorsese can understand this reference!
Just a little trivia about the little girl who listened to Henry and Karen's fight. She was actually Lorraine Bracco's daughter. Also the toddler in the prison scene was her younger daughter. Being they were the correct age for the time sequence Lorraine suggested they use them and Scorsese agreed. I don't know if either ended up in acting but what a hoot to be in a few scenes with their Mom in a classic movie.
Tonithenightowl never new that thank you
dfss csss yea i got a better one first five minutes of the movie when they stab billy bats and Jimmy shots him the gun doesn't go off but you hear the trigger
And if you watch that part about the jail karen passes up all the black chicks lol not being racist or anything
I mean one time the flash doesn't come on but what you said is interesting the only reason spider aka christopher from the sopranos got hired was from that little scene and Karen was offered to play tonys wife but said fuk that i did that already I'm be a therapist
And Tommy's mother in the movie is Scorsese mother and she ironed all the clothes to give it that look
Hands up if you look at GoodFellas in 2019?.
Make sure you have in your DVD or BluRay collection.
Masterpieces don't get much better than this!.
"the most important line in the movie, when Tommy says: 🔇📵📴🙉❌❌❓❓❔❔🕒🕞🕓"
english please
Robert Cabral 😂😂😂
What?
He's signifying through hipster emoji bullshit that it was hard to hear what Tommy said, even though it wasn't that difficult to make it out.
Lol he said “I didn’t want to get blood on your floor”
“Why is goodfellas the greatest gangster movie ever made”
Oh gee I don’t know maybe because it’s just that fucking great
That wasn’t a question, the statement was “Why GoodFellas is the BEST gangster movie of all time” and you forgot a word in your second sentence lol.
“Oh g I don’t”
The song "Atlantis" that plays as Billy Batts is "murdered" is a song about someone's yearning to be somewhere else -- just like Henry.
Thanks for the title... I always though it symbolized Billie Batts sleeping with the fishes... When they sing 'way down below the ocean'... very morbid scene when mixed with the music
The 2 godfather movies (3 should be forgotten) and goodfellas are near perfect movies
Can you fix the audio of the movie
Seems to be working fine for me.
Jack's Movie Reviews I can't hear anything from the movie,I can hear your voice
ho weijian
That is bizarre, maybe try it with or without headphones in.
Jack's Movie Reviews I agree,each time u say something important,your voice gets muted
ho weijian happens with me too
Pesci was great in this film but was more deserving of an Academy Award for his performance in JFK. Also, Spider didn't play a prank on Tommy (at least not in the scene he is shot in the foot) If you watch the scene, several guys tell Spider what they want to drink, one guy says "I'm fine" Spider thinks Tommy says that and that why he doesn't bring him anything to drink which in turn starts all the trouble. I'm not trying to nitpick. Excellent analysis.
Christopher G. His performance in Raging Bull was the best out of all the Scorsese films he was in.
He wasn't a waiter, he was the proprietor.
This some brilliance that shows the difference of detail from Goodfellas and the godfather the whole wedding sequence is longer than Henry's childhood sequence
The muted audio might be the youtube copyright algorithm in action.
Weird enough, it is only muted on speakers (on phone at least)
Is just poor edition
"And all of their daughters were named Marie".
This film is one of the greatest of all time; from the music to narration to cinematography, I love this movie. The movie did the book "Wiseguys" justice, painting a picture that not everything is not what it seems.
The glorified violence, pious greed, and merciful theft sucked me in. I'm right there with the action getting sucked into the nuanced music placement per scene and the carefulness of each scene. Martin should have won this back in 1990 but I was only 3 when this movie came out. I appreciated this film sometime as a teenager and I can recite lines from the film from the film.
It's obvious that you deserve what you get when you get what you deserve. This is not a negative or positive critique. However, it shows the lengths of obtaining what we want most in our lives only coming close to really deserving it. Are we ever deserving of the lifestyle we deem worthy of obtaining? I think this is one trope that is missed often (the narrator of this video touches upon it briefly in the beginning when Henry is a teen). We feel for Henry because we think/know he deserves the American Dream that ultimately becomes his American Nightmare. The feeling of belongingness closes the gap of this deservedness.
It is this reason among many others that I love this movie. It examines so much of our own capacity, capability, and culpability with the people we most associate.
Henry was laughing at maury getting chocked out because before that scene the commercial says his wigs can handle hurricane winds but jimmy easily knocks it off by putting a chord on his neck xD
"And then he kissed me" best use of a song in a scene in any movie ever... Anyone agree????
This movie particularly the first third is full of staggeringly good utilization of music
Agreed. It went so well with that scene.
That “funny guy scene” was not scripted. That’s what makes it so great, shows how genius Pesci is at playing a mafia man.
Well Pesci told Scorsese that story that happened to him in real life and Marty told him to put that in the scene.
The music in this movie. My man. But then I'm 38, and grew up listening to the music of my Mother.
Not that I don't love the Grunge of the 90's, or other things from the Dresden Dolls to The Airborne Toxic Event or George Watsky, but nothing is as pure as these 'Oldies'.
It's so fast paced and kinetic, dialogue and chemistry between the characters, musical choices are perfect and really set the mood of each scene
Henry Hill was a always smashed near the end of his life. He was a frequent guest on the Howard Stern show and they always made him look like a drunken fool.
Good review!
Another crumbling moment was when Karen secretly visited Jimmy in the third act and he tried to have her killed, but she caught on to that. It seemed as such a naive move, but goes to show how little he thinks of this woman, trying the bare minimum to take her out. He underestimated her, and kept playing this fake role to his demise.
Thanks for playing the soundtrack throughout the video! Made it feel like watching the movie
enjoyed the little joke at 4:50
:)
Chris Charalambous
Jimmy 2 times :)
Chris Charalambous I got it
get the papers get the papers
Chris Charalambous Jimmy two times- “entertaining group... entertaining group”
For the people watching the video and wondering why half of the audio is missing is likely bc the video was likely claimed so he had to edit out the audio. He should of added subtitles though.
"1) Never rat on your friends, and 2) Always keep your mouth shut."
Yeah? What about "Never murder all your friends", huh, Conway?
Also, "Never murder a made man, never help your psycho friend murder a made man, just because he hurled a mortal insult by telling him to go home to get his fucking shine box."
All these people have the emotional intelligence of a 2-year old. Stunted, with real guns!
Thats the whole point of the movie, Gangsters pretend to have rules only to break them as they see fit. They see rules as justification for their poor behaviour and life choices.
👍👍👍👍👍👍!.
@@punjabilaundde9893 The movie WITNESS TO THE MOB proves that. NO LOYALTY!
Yeah whatever. It's all BS anyway. Give me a break. What are they going to tell you? If you get caught tell the cops everything and make a deal so you do less time? And all that advice to Henry did no good whatsoever. He ratted on everyone because he was facing a very long prison sentence.
I wish the “good times” part of goodfellas was longer, but I understand the story necessitated it
"Reads the tittle*
*hits like inmediately after*
Dany Osuna speling is hawd.
English is my third language so I struggle with it sometimes, ty for the feedback tho
My Favorite Movie ......I Have Seen it at Least 50 Times and Never put Some of Those Links Together .......Good Video man .......
Awesome! Glad you enjoyed!
My favorite too
Something to note is that no one except Paulie in Henry’s crew is actual mafia and Tommy was being made a soldier.
Just one correction, I believe that is the club owner, not just a waiter (i.e. an employee) that Tommy berates and beats over the tab.
Yep-you are totally right he is the club owner. It makes Tommy a bit more intimidating!
Glenn Highcove, yea! I noticed that!
Yes. There is an important earlier scene where Club Owner asks Paulie for ‘help’ and they become ‘partners’. To call him a ‘waiter’ is a bad miss by the reviewer.
@@JacksMovieReviews though it didn't happen in reality, it would be twice as scary if the Guy was built like he was in reality Tommy Desimoni was actually 6.2ft and was built like Rocky.
Whenever I hear Joe Pesci, my brain automatically reminds me the Greatest comedian I have yet seen George Carlin!
"I pray to Joe Pesci." I remember that joke too.
I can't hear the dialogue from the film.
Try it without headphones or with different headphones-it works fine for me.
Doesn't work for me.
Jack's Movie Reviews yeah from about 8:00 on the movie audio is silent...before 8:00 is fine tho
fantastic analysis! keep up the good work
+swagmasta Thank you-I'm glad you enjoyed!
Dying from heart attack at 69 might not have much to do with drugs
Holy shit nice profile pic, CRX fan?
Eirik holy shit nice profile pic! Are you a llama?
@@eirikmelum Haha dude in my pic is an old family friend. he's indian :)
AlwaysMad holy shit nice profile pic! Are you a former member of a Mexican cartel?
@Football Highlights Holy shit nice profile pic! Are you a MaximilianMus?
Splendid! Thank you so much for your work!
Would be really nice to see review of Scorsese's CASINO!!
Thank you! I actually just did a video on The Departed and try and put some time in between looking at the same directors work. Here's that video if you haven't seen it. ua-cam.com/video/xLqFQV6Mno4/v-deo.html
Saw already! When there gonna be time, will wait for more. Well done! ;)
Beyond doubt. One of the greatest ever American gangster films ever produced. Liotta,Pesci and de Niro chemistry is sublime. Up there with the first two Godfather films. That's for sure. 😊👍❤
As far back as I can remember, I always wanted to be a Goodfeather.
Man, the jokes and references you never got as a kid.
you mean gangster
@@jessicapinkman-hd4bw Nope. I intentionally was quoting Animaniacs.
One of the greatest movies ever made!! I always watch it whenever its on TV.
There are many good points here but the one biggest problem i could see is when you state that Henry is is losing his love for the Mafia, but this simply isnt true because Henry states that his biggest problem when leaving the life is that he didnt want to leave the life, he still loved the life. But over all this is a good essay on this film, One of my favorite things about this film is how many different ways it can be interpreted. Ive watched this film to many times to count and i still get the same feeling of wow everytime i watch it.
My favourite line from the movie is ‘hey henry heres a wing!’ Makes me laugh every time
If you’ve noticed an uptick in views, that’s me watching this video at least three times a week. (Currently working on my own crime screenplay.) Great work!!
you will get a 5+star for tremendous work excellent....
+Jorge Gaytan Thanks Jorge! I'm putting out another one this Saturday, I hope you check that out!
+Jacks Movie Reviews look forward to it ...thank s a bunch.. keep up the great work partner
Jorge Gaytan
Will do, thanks for the support!
🌟 🌟 🌟🌟🌟
One of my favorite movies. The acting, soudn design, music, heck, all of it. Martin's one of my favorite directors. I'm a film buff, and I'm blind.
No. It's not the best gangster movie of all time.
It's the best MOVIE of ALL TIME -- barnone.
Behind "The Godfather"... LOVE both, for entirely different reasons...
Awh man, I was getting ready to slap a punk. Then I read the second line...
BOOOM!!! Somebody had to say it!!!!!!!!!!
thatonedrewguy the good the bad and the ugly
Zero Cool. That is a great one!!
Who's excited for 'The Irishman' ?
Jeremy Nothing it was amazing!
I interpret that last scene where Tommy fires a gun into the camera a little differently. I interpret it as Henry reminiscing the life he had as a Mafia gangster, his "rockstar days". Henry doesn't really display an expression of fear, so much as one of nostalgia if that's possible to express.
Wow, this video made me appreciate this film to an even greater extend! An absolute must watch!
Good ole Henry Hill, his late-life notoriety was mostly Howard Stern's doing.
The “Layla” scene gives me goosebumps every single time.
This is literally a breakdown of the film. You should change the title
Check One he is breaking it down and explaining why it is the best . . .
How else is he going to elaborate idiot?
You change your name to idiot.
You mean to tell me he broke down the film to show how it’s the best gangster movie of all time. What a HUGE surprise.
Check GS because you can’t really just say it’s the best with no defence and no breakdown? goddamn idiot
What a great film review/analysis! Your video is both straightforward and comprehensive, and it also highlights some aspects that I definitely missed while rewatching this masterpiece.
one of my faves
Great video. I especially like the parts from the movie being presented in order to clarify key points of the analysis. Like when Ray Liota says: "_______________ "
and Joe Pesci replies: " __________ "
And then DeNiro enters the scene: "_______________"
Man, really great lines
Is that a bug or is that on purpose
@@manuharter6382 They have cut out the audio tracks of the film due to copyright protection
@@nikosalexopoulos6542 i mean, you could try and slap subtitles under that
@@manuharter6382 Well, when he first uploaded the video, you could hear the tracks. But then UA-cam probably cut them off. And the uploader did not re-upload with subtitles afterwards
@@nikosalexopoulos6542 well, well. UA-cam does how youtube wants.
Thanks for this great analysis of this five star movie.
Great job on the review, the Hitchcock shots never occurred to me before.
This movie is on par with both godfather movies
I think Goodfellas is better than The Godfather tbh
@@joyasaxena9976no Godfather is far better
Great review, I learned a lot.
I'm sure you were forced to remove the dialogue but if you could put subtitles in it would prevent this issue ruining the context.
Such an amazing film and great review
Thanks Ramsey, very much appreciated. Nice profile picture BTW
such an amazing album..
Best commentary I have ever seen on this movie. A classic review for a classic movie. In as many times as I have seen the movie, I never noticed the methodology of the soundtrack as well as the shot lengths (other than the Copa scene).
You forgot to talk about that "what is life" by the great Harrison
This has been a favourite of mine for years. I first saw it when I was eleven and I've loved it ever since.
Technically Henry Hill was never in the Mob , he was associated with them but he was never a made man
A fantastic dissection of one hell of a movie. Well done mate
Im gonna get da papers, get da papers
I just watched goodfellas for the hundredth time a few weeks ago and now I wanna watch it again...DAMN
damn the editing in this is appalling! I kept thinking something was wrong with my speakers
Really well done analysis mate hats off to you. Goodfellas is my favourite film and love listening to others peoples take on what transpires in the movie. Some minor corrections that I feel I have to make however.... The man who approaches pauly about needing help in the resteraunt isn't a waiter, he likely owns the place or is involved heavily in its management. In the scene where Jimmy is attacking Maurey asking for his money, Henry isn't laughing because he genuinely enjoys the violence, but as a conpensatory factor to appear unfazed by it in the eyes of Jimmy, he wishes to be seen as someone who is impressed by the violence, but the character inherently is different from the others and sees violence as a part of the lifestyle, not as something he finds funny or enjoyable. Lastly spider isn't playing a prank on Tommy, he clearly is just simple minded and got confused with the guys orders.... Other than that great job mate really impressed! Keep it up!
+Cameron MacRury Thanks Cameron, and great insights by the way, thanks for pointing them out!
No problem man, just looking through some of your other videos... Some really good stuff mate, you should have a lot more subscribers
Cameron MacRury
I really appreciate that, but my channel has been growing faster than it ever has in the past few months, so I'm looking forward to the future
That's great! You've gained a new sub, keep up the content and you will continue to grow, you should do some more Scorsese films would like to hear what you have to say
Cameron MacRury You may like my video about Hugo, I looked at that and a lot of his other films that inspired it. I also did a video on The Wolf of Wall Street that may interest you
More realistic and in my opinion better than the Godfather
True. The godfather was still great, but it felt more pretentious.
Period
That's your opinion, I like Godfather better, that movie is just out of the world, keep in mind that's like the first classic I watched, but I ain't going to lie the first time I watched it was slow but the second time it was amazing.
@@cs-ke1byhow was it pretentious?
Great work buddy, very thorough and spot on about the music.
Goodfellas, Scarface, The Godfather are all amazing. I could never put one of them above another.
NO
Joe Howgego ?
I read the book "Wiseguy" before the movie came out, it was a very good book and I feared the movie would not live up to it, I was presently surprised. The book has much more detail, worth a read.
I'm gonna go get the papers, get the papers!
The Jimmy two-times reference got you a sub. Great little detail lol
Russell Westbrook looking for a comment that pointed that out 🔥
Wasn’t a waiter, he was the owner of the joint
this is a great analysis of the movie
I think the drugs is the turning point in the movie. Without that cash, jimmy might have killed him off also. The money was just too good to pass up. But in doing that, he was doomed to failure. He would eventually get hooked and get caught. It saved his life by giving him a choice later: rat on his friends or die. The only person jimmy would have let live without that is tommy. What I never understood was paulie allowing jimmy to kill them all off. Isn't that a huge waste of manpower? Did paulie end up telling jimmy that they had to seem legit so to tie up loose ends? I also feel bad that tutti ends up vanishing in the movie. The movie has so much conflict on varying levels. It's incredible.
Jimmy wacked all those guys because of them possibly being rats, but also because he wanted the money all to himself. I'm not sure if the real Jimmy even asked for permission to wack all the robbers as most or all of them were only Lucchese associates. I have read stories of people claiming Jimmy had Tommy wacked which is ridiculous because according to Henry the only time he saw Jimmy cry was when they got the news Tommy got wacked.
Tutti whacks Tommy.
Yeah whatever. Gotti was dealing drugs. That's why he killed Paul Castellano. He realized that Paul was going to find out what he was doing, so he figured he would kill him first before Paul had him killed.
I always liked how he used colours in this movie - notice 05:07 - they EAT from a table that has a very peculiar red almost "glowing" - exactly the same "glowing red" of the first scene, when they stab "Batts", and - AGAIN the same red "glow" when they dig him up back again after 6 months - i.e: they live and sustain themselves, from murder and the misery of other people.