By Allah's grace, I becam a Muslim almost 16 years ago, as a 12er Shia Muslim practicing the Jafari Madhab. However, I have great respect for my Sunni Muslim brothers and sisters. I have great respect for Shaykh Hamza Yusuf and will listen to his tapes to get the orthodox Sunni view. We can agree to disagree on our differences. True Sunni Muslims love Ahlul Bayt.
Philip Voerding ALLSunni muslims love &cherish AHL AL BAYT . At least 5 times day we say "May Allah bless Muhammed & His family " every time we finish salah My father comes from HUSSEIN Ibn Ali mymother IS descendent from AlHASSAN Ibn Ali al badawi was hergrandfather one question to you as European Iguess why did you choose to be shia ?do you think a shia imam is infallible ? like ayatollah ?Do you reject the sunna ( you are going to be asked about at the Day of Jugment )do you accept what the say rather they insult the prophet' wife AICHA which means they insult his honor( &that also you will be asked about that I'm afraid ) read the biography of the prophet from sunni scholar books I advise you to know about both sides &YOU decide which is closer to Islamic Teaching
As-Salam Alaikum sister Aicha Belcaid. That is the saying of one Ayatullah. There have been and are multiple Ayatullahs, That is not what my Marja teaches. Intention is the key. There is so much misinformation about 12er Shia Muslims and what we believe that it becomes difficult to address everything. It has been 7 years or so since I recorded this video, and I have learned more about Islam and Muslims since then. I like true Sunni Muslims even more than I did back them. Yet, I am even more convinced now that I ought follow the Prophet and his family and the Jafari Madhab rather than the 4 Madhabs. Did you know both Abu Hanifa and Ibn Malik were students of the 6th Imam Jaffar As-Sadiq, the great grandson of the 3rd Imam Hussein? Yet, the Shafie Madhab is the closest to the Jafari Madhab, with the Maliki Madhab as a close 2nd. In classic times, Abu Hanifa and Hanafi sheikhs used to study with Mutazilite, Zaidi Shia, and 12er Shia Sheikhs? The Gap between Sunnis and Shias has widened since then, which is a shame, because we are all true Muslims! By the way, the first three years I investigated Islam and Muslims, I read Sunni Muslim authors, including Sufis, and the first Quran translation I ever read was a Sunni translation. I studied the 4 Madhabs and still have those books. I have studied Muslim History from several sides (more than just Sunni and 12er Shia groups). Why were 11 of 12 Shia Muslim Imams, all Sayyeds,murdered, and 10 of them by order of the Caliphs? Certainly I don't blame the Sunni Imams who have madhabs named for them for these murders, but fabrication of hadith by the Ummayad Dynasty of Caliphs is well known to both Sunni and Shia scholars. Sister, as for my use of the term "true Sunnis", I use the term because classical Sunni Muslim scholars like Ibn Kathir were Ummayad sympathizers despite living in the the time of the Abbasid Caliphate, write against the 12 Imams. Ibn Kathir wrote that Hussein Ibn Ali ibn Muhammad, our 3rd Imam, the 2nd son of the murdered 4th Caliph Ali Ibn Talib, our 1st Imam, was rightly, yes rightly, beheaded by his father's weapon by Caliph Yazid ibn Muhawiya Ibn Abu Sufyan's soldiers! That is a very well known passage from Ibn Kathir. He is not a true Sunni Muslim like you are, sister, since he believed that Imam Hussein deserved to be beheaded. Wahabis like the Saudis are called Sunnis when they are make fiqh differently than Sunnis do. I do like Imam Ahmed Ibn Hanbal himself, but many of the Hanbali scholars who followed him caused trouble even before Wahabism began. I don't care if the Saudis are considered allies of the USA, I say that is only because of oil money and no other reason. The Saudis, Al-Qaeda, ISIS, the Taliban, the modern Boca Haram ... all these groups are NOT true Sunnis and all are trying to exterminate Shia Muslims. As for Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, I have nothing but respect for him. I have watched many of his videos and bought one of his books. I agree with him that the Sunni-Shia controversy is an old one, and while my investigation of Islam and Muslim groups led me to become a Muslim as a 12er Shia Muslim, I believe true Sunnis are my brothers and sisters. But still, I need to come out on one side, and 12er Shia Muslim Aqeedah and Fiqh make the most sense for me. I believe Allah (SWT) is perfect. The 2nd Root of Religion for 12er Shia Muslims is Divine Justice. Therefore, I believe Allah is always just and never unjust because he is perfect. Even good Sunni scholars, who believe Allah is perfect, will say Allah doesn't have to always be just, but that is like saying He is not always perfect. On spiritual and philosophical grounds I cannot accept their view. Allah provides infallible scriptures, correct? For this reason, I believe Prophets and Messengers are protected by Allah and that protection allows them to be pure and infallible, so we can follow their example and their teaching and the scripture we get from them. If someone claims to be a messenger, but might not be pure and might not be infallible, how can I even trust he will give me Allah's message exactly as it was meant to be given? How can I follow their example if they might sin because they are not pure? They are Prophets and Messengers empowered by Allah, not by themselves, so they would not be pure and infallible with Allah's protection. Now, who rightly interprets Allah's scripture when the Messenger is no longer with us? Those who know. These people, can they make sins and teach heresy? How can I trust them if they are not pure and infallible? Dear Sister, if you can prove to me using Sunni books that all Sahaba were pure and infallible, and that the compilers or the 6 or 7 Sahih hadith books (7 if we include the Muwatta of Ibn Malik) were all pure and infallible, then I will be a Sunni Muslim and follow the Shafie Madhab. I can tell you there will be a problem immediately, because the 4 Imams for whom the Sunni Madhabs are named wrote terrible things about each other. Further, the 6 or 7 Sahih ahadith books have hadith that directly contradict each other. That is why I personally had to become a 12er Shia Muslim. Our 4 classic books of hadith are not considered to all be Sahih. The hadith are of different grades. Later books are compilations of the hadith considered to be authentic. However, the ONLY Shia Muslim hadith book that is considered 100% reliable is the As-Sahifa As-Sajjadiyyah of our 4th Imam Ali Zainul Abideen, the only male survivor of the battle of Karbala, who was later murdered by a Caliph. His prayer book and his Treatise on Rights, which are also used by some Sunnis who are Sufis, is considered fully authentic. The Nahjul Balagha of Imam Ali the 4th Calipj is a close 2nd, though a few things in that book are considered suspect. Those two books are followed by several other later compilations. I don't expect you to become a 12er Shia Muslim just because of what I wrote. I was raised a Christian and attended a Bible School, and did my own research after that. Even after I read the Quran and was pleasantly surprised, and then read Al-Ghazali and Rumi and Sunni books on hadith science and Aqeedah, then looked at what the 12er Shia Muslims had to say, it took me 6 months to actually give Shahada after I was convinced Islam was true. I know Christians who took longer, and some who try to be both Christian and Muslim, or stay Christian and study Muslim books also. But sister, you are already a Muslim, so you don't have to convert/revert to anything. If you do come to a place where you want to follow the two weighty things left by the Prophet: The Quran and his family, as a hadith in Sahih Muslim states, then you should become a 12er Shia Muslim. But sister, you are already a Muslim, and I believe good Sunni Muslims are Moomineen and Moomineena. 12 Patriarchs of Jacob/Israel. 12 Princes of Ishmael. 12 Apostles of Jesus Christ. 12 Imams of Muhammad. Blessings of Allah and Peace be upon all of them! Masalama dear sister.
Philip Voerding jaffa as sadique is asunni scholar his mother's name is Aicha Cz I studied ahl bait family tree from my father Shia took hold of his teachings and said falsely he was a Shia at his time there was no shia/sunni but only Muslims as a European u should have an independent free thinking I hope u reconsider u r iman about the 4 madhab in sunna they are rather schools each imam respected his fellow such as ashafie was a student of anas in Malik a well educated Muslim sunni respect all these imams the prophet saws said that Muslims will divided in73 groups only the ones who follow coran and sunna will be saved from hellfire
“O Allah, let Your Blessings come upon Muhammad and the family of Muhammad, as you have blessed Ibrahim and his family. Truly, You are Praiseworthy and Glorious. Allah, bless Muhammad and the family of Muhammad, as you have blessed Ibrahim and his family. Truly, You are Praiseworthy and Glorious”.
I am a direct descendant of the Prophet (SAWS)! THANK YOU INFINITELY, MY INFINITELY BELOVED ALLAH (SWT)! I also love the beloved SAHABAS of our Beloved Prophet (SAWS) ! MAY ALLAH(SWT ) MAKE the ummah an immense benefit for this suffering world
Uyghur Malay , @ Uyghur Malay , It is mostly due to the hundred of thousands of the Sahabas , the taabi3ins, and so forth ,who brought Islam to Southeast Asia ; The AhluBayt numbers was much smaller , to have made a difference!
@@sidibouchrit their number were small, but they give large impact to us, from society, to culture, From A to Z. Our relationship between them are too strong, because of Ahl Bayt, with Allah will, most of our Kings embraced the Islam with helping from them, and due to our loyality towards King, whole kingdom embraced Islam
I am Sunni and I love Ahlul bait especially imam Hussain who stood up against tyrant Yazeed and gave his life. Yazeed did not only order to kill Imam Hussain but also make Madina mubah for his army and attack Mecca. All haters can go and stay with Yazeed on the day of judgement.
Lol i know most of u sunnis dont but i grew in an area surrounded by salafis who refer themeselves as sunnis so i didnt know that many sunnis who hated yazid la
"Fatema A.S is part of me, who angers her angers me and who angers me angers Allah!" Hadith from Bukhari. And Fatema A.S did not talk to Abu Bakr till her death.
Armand Baudouin spreading lies. Fatimah A.S didn't talk to Abu Bakr R.A regarding the inheritance anymore, not in general. true Muslims follow the middle path, love of Ahlul Bayte and the sahaba
It is an obligation to every Muslim .Ahle Sunnah wal Jamat Love and Honor the Pure Ahle Bayt (RadiAllahu Anhum wa Alayhis salaam) as commanded by Allah Ta’ala and The Holy Prophet SalAllahu alayhi wa Aalihi wassallam. Loving the Pure Ahle Bayt is not something that is done by the Shia but rather it is it deeply rooted in the core and essence of Sunni Islam and Aqidah part of our IMAN .
im not shia but i have alot of shia friends, we celebrate the good times of the prophet and his family, the shia celebrate and commemorate the good and bad times of the ahlul bayt, your statement is wrong and biased. shias love the ahlul bayt and sunnis love the companions more!
And maybe thats why your scholars don't like talking about ahlelbayt. They hide so much and is afraid that you become shia. The prophet said: " I leave behind two weighty things and if you hold to them, you wil never go astray. Ghoran and ahlelbayt
@@mightymo7607 Loving Ahl Bayt is a duty for All Muslim, Ahl Bayt spread Islam to Southeast Asia and still exist in society, bringing Sunni doctrine since day 1
i try to find out truth by listening different scholors from differnt sects but where i found peace and love is in the speeches of tahir ul qadri and hamza yusuf
They are try sunni scholars. Also listen to hazzor muffakir e islam pir syed abdul qadir jilani. The master of knowledge in today's world. I'm sure right I'm saying that tahir qadri has also taken knowledge from him and also shakyh syed ninowy
May Allah Bless The Family of The Chosen, Beloved of Allah wherever they are found. Many thanks for the video THIS topic is of immense importance and massively neglected. Wasalaam.
اAHLUL-BAYT IN THE LIGHT OF QURAN Prophet Muhammad (SW) showed his Ahlul-Bayat on the following two occasions:- (a) When the purification clause "Verily Allah intends to keep off from you uncleanness, O you Ahlul Bayt and keep you pure at the apex of purity" (انَّمَا يُرِيدُ ٱللَّهُ لِيُذۡهِبَ عَنڪُمُ ٱلرِّجۡسَ أَهۡلَ ٱلۡبَيۡتِ وَيُطَهِّرَكُمۡ تَطۡهِيرََ )" of verse 33 of Surah Ahzaab was revealed. The occasion, time and place of revelation of subject part of Verse 33 of Surah Ahzaab is narrated by Jabir bin Abdullah (RA) as told to him by Hazrat Fatima (SA). One day when Lady Fatima (SA) was in the house of Hazrat Ummay Salma (RA) the wife of the prophet, the Prophet (SW) told her that He was feeling weakness, therefore, she covered Him with a yamni shawl. Soon after Hazrat Imam Hussain (AS) entered the house and joined the Prophet. Subsequently Imam Hassan (AS), Lady Fatima (SA) and Hazrat Ali (AS) also joined the prophet under the shawl. Later, on Hazrat Ummay Salma's request to join the group also, however, the Prophet told her to remain at her place and that she was at peace. At this juncture Hazrat Jibrail (AS) revealed subject part of Verse 33 (Refer to any Sihah-e-Sitta Book). The purification clause of Verse 33 of Surah Ahzaab "Verily Allah intends to keep off from you uncleanness, O you Ahlul-Bayt and keep you pure at the apex of purity" was placed at subject place in Quran as different parts of the revelations were placed at appropriate place in Quran under Prophet Muhammad (SW) instructions e.g. the first verse “ اقْرَأْ بِاسْمِ رَبِّكَ الَّذِي خَلَقَ” was placed in Surah Al-Alaq the 96th Surah and on second revelation the verses were placed in 68th Surah Al-Qalam of Quran. It should be noted that the arrangement of Quran is not in the order of the verses as they were revealed. Moreover, the purification clause starts with the word إِنَّمَا that is encircling word (kalmay hasar-حصر) used in Arabic language to restrict or encircle the implication of the text meaning to that matter only which follows إِنَّمَا. Therefore, what is stated before the wordإِنَّمَا is excluded and what is stated after إِنَّمَا doesn’t apply to the text about wives of the prophet before the word إِنَّمَا in subject verse. As such, the evidence shows that only those under the blanket are included in Ahlul-Bayat and not the wives of the Prophet as advocated by many scholars. (b) When the deliberations on the birth of Hazrat Eysa (AS) with the Christians of Najran in 9th Hijra did not succeed, Allah commanded in Verse 61 of Surah Aal-e-Imran asking each party to bring their sons, women and men (Nafoos) for invoking Allah's CURSE on the liars (mobyhlah مباہلہ). At that time among others the Prophet had 9 wives and His son Ibrahim was alive but the Prophet took Hazrat Ali (AS), Lady Fatima (SA), Imam Hassan and Hussain (AS) ONLY for mobyhlah. Seeing subject personalities the Christians chief priest Abdul Masih refused to do mobyhlah and accepted to pay nominal tax (Jazia). Allah declared subject incidence as account of truth (Surah Aal-Imran Verse-62). Mobahilah was the contest of truth (sadaqat-صداقت) and Prophet took only those personalities who were considered highly truthful ]sadeeq ((صدیق superlative degree of sadiqصادق) )] in this contest of truth. The Prophet said that my Ahlul-Bayt are like the boat of Hazrat Nuh (AS), who so ever came on board would gain salvation and one who remains astray will drown and perish. He also said, “I am leaving two weighty things: Quran and my itrat-Ahlul Bayt, they will remain enjoined till they meet me at the pool of Kawthar on the Day of Judgment. One who remains associated with them surely will not go astray and one who remains away will perish”. Moreover, He said, Hussain is from me and I am from Hussain (Sihah-e- Sitta).
I am beginning to like this sheikh Hamza a lot. Because he is into Islam deeply and not just superficially and I respect that. He is amazing because he is an Irish American whose family goes all they way down to Revolutionary wars against the British. Somebody up there must have liked him a lot to have guided him and of course he has good genes/blood too. I wonder if Sheikh knows about the deceptions of these so-called Ahle Kitab ppl who had moved to Arabia just to kill the Seal of the Prophets (they knew of his coming from their books) and destroy his religion (this is why they joined the idolatries and atheists/polytheists and provoked them against the monotheist religion (doesn't make sense but...) ) and when they couldn't do it (Because of Imam Ali and others with true faith) they came from within (Munafigh) then after Prophet's death tried to destroy the Prophet's family by attacking His house (with fire) and killing his expecting daughter and her son in process then they tried to distort Quran but when they couldn't do it they shuffled the verses out of order of revelation.... Anyway All divisions in all religions come from that 1 single and evil source.(They destroyed Christianity and invented Catholicism. They divided Islam into 4 branches and then more, up to 72) Why no Moslem today ask why there are so many sects in Islam while the Prophet SA brought 1 religion and 1 book and 1 faith? Also why no one asks why Prophet Muhammad SA is the Last of the Prophets while we now live in this so-called "modern" world and need a lot of guidance?! The prophet sawa predicted this and said his Umma with do exactly as bani israil after him and Islam will be divided into 72 sects, all will be in Fire except 1! Now who do you follow? Ahlul Bayt the source of Prophet or the agents of yahudi leaders? The choice is clear to me. This is why I and ppl like me don't need another prophet to guide us. The prophet's successor is with us! We may not be able to see him but he sees us and God-willing some lucky day soon he shall re-appear!
(Allah wishes only to remove Ar-Rijs from you, O members of the family, and to purify you with a thorough purification.) This is a clear statement that the wives of the Prophet are included among the members of his family (Ahl Al-Bayt) here, because they are the reason why this Ayah was revealed. The context in which this verse occurs makes it manifest that the word ahl al-bait (people of the house) here implies the wives of the Holy Prophet (upon whom be Allah's peace), because the address begins with: "O wives of the Prophet," and they are the addressees in the whole discourse preceding it as well as following it. Moreover, the word ahl al-bait in Arabic is used precisely in the sense in which the word "household" is used in English, which includes both a man's wife and children. No one would exclude the wife from the "household." The Qur'an itself has used this word at two other places besides this, and at both the wife is included in its sense, rather as the most important member of the family. In Surah Hud, when the angels give the Prophet Abraham the good news of the birth of a son, his wife exclaims: "Shall I bear a child now when I have grown too old, and this husband of mine has also become old?" The angels say: What! Are you surprised at Allah's decree, O people of Abraham's household? Allah's mercy and blessings are upon you." In Surah Al-Qasas, when the Prophet Moses reaches the Pharaoh's house as a suckling, and the Pharaoh's wife is in search of a suitable nurse for the child, the Prophet Moses' sister says, "Shall I tell you of a household whose people will bring him up for you and look after him well?" Thus, the Arabic idiom and the usage of the Qur'an and the context of this verse, 'all point clearly to the fact that the Holy Prophet's wives are Ahle Bayt. That is why according to lbn 'Abbas and 'Urwah bin Zubair and `Ikrimah, the word ahl al-bait in this verse (Surah Al Ahzaab verses 32 and 33) implies the wives of the Holy Prophet. [Tafsir Ibn Abi hatim] The Prophet is closer to the believers than their selves, and his wives are (as) their mothers. [Quran 33:6]
He's saying what they claim. He wouldn't know whether or not it's true. I doubt it myself. Not that it is impossible but royal families have alleged lineages from Pharaos, from Romans emperors, some even claim from Prophet Jesus (صلى الله عليه وسلم). Obviously it cannot all be true.
Both Sunni and Shia love the ahlul bayt(a.s). Its just that among the Muslims, division occurs because people are so fond of looking into their differences. Moreover, muslims in general don't like to read books and discuss on important issues pertaining to the muslim ummah. There are Duas taught by the family of the prophet, most people take it for granted.
The prophet Mohammad said :" I leave behind two weighty things and if you hold to them you wil never go astray. Ghoran and ahlelbayt. The muslim scholars have hide it because they are afraid that you may become shia . Thats so sad. They are going to be asked for that inshallah in the day of judgement.
Im sunni. What Saman said is the true hadith. The family are still respected to the utmost level. We love them. Shiaism do have certain misguiding things. Going to extremes like infallibility and beating kneself is too much Saman. Its not necessary. Even we cry when we think abt what happened in karbala. Yazid will suffer in hell fire
While just saying that we are muslim is sufficent their is nothing wrong with ascertaining that you are a member of Ahl as Sunnah wal Jama'ah/Sunni, as this is the group that the Prophet alaihi salaam indicated was the saved group based off the qualities that He outlined that that group would have.
The whole point of the Abbasids was to avenge ahul bayt due to the ummayads persecuting them. Then when the Abbasids got in power, they became Sunnis and began killing ahul bayt.
Generalization is by definition prescribing a quality to a mass- which is what you were doing. You've now changed it to 'your country', next it may be 'your city', or 'family'. The fact is that I never generalized. Rather, I referred in my original comment to my own sunni frame of reference, as opposed to yourself. As an attendee I clarify my previous statement as it is clear you have no understanding for it: Sunnism incorporates ahl-bayt, you simply have to understand it before preaching it.
we do love them BUT wedonot worship them and we do not give them divine prerogatives. I am wondering how a monotheist jew can become a shia . there are so many shirks and heresies in shiism. Do use the link i sent previously and u will become a true muslim
I would disagree strongly. I'm sunni and I have a very powerful love of Ahlul Bayt. So is Sheikh Hamza Yusuf if I'm not mistaken. The fact that I contend to sufism doesn't exempt me from that tradition.
Does the Shaykh know Arabic? As, if does, then how can he call the uncles, nephews etc as members of the ahlul bayt? Qur'an 33:33, please explain based on the Arabic yaah Shaykh
brother i want a non bias view that isnt shia or sunni just general islamic knowledge...just centuries before there were ppl identified as ahlu bayt..alot of sheikh were ahlu bayt like abdulqadir jelani or imam shafi'i etc...you only gave me a cities name i want a big sheikh or a known person(s)....its kinda weird that not one person can be legitimately identified as ahlu bayt...i think theirs a big cover up...allah knows best.
Not sure how Sunnis love ahul bayt when they praise the people who murdered and exiled them like Muwawia who rebelled against the 4th and 5th khalif who were both ahul bayt and murdered the 5th.
@@xtremeownage2 TF you on about. Muhammad ibn abu bakr hated his own father for usurping imam ali position. Because of this him and his sister ayesha never saw eye to eye one was raised by imam ali like a son while the other sibling had deep enimosity toward imam ali. Lastly, there were no sunnis back then there were only shia of ali or shia of abu bakr or other shia following the so called in the futured would come to be called "sunni"
I like hamza yusuf but to use the arguement that the ahlul bayt arent infallible coz 'their human' is wrong! The prophets of allah were human and both sunni and shia believe they were infallible. Also in surah 33:33 allah says that o ahlul bayt i have purified you a thorough purification.. My question is what does that actually mean when all mighty allah swt purifies them a thorough purification?
well you are then exemptions, he was speaking about wast majority of Sunnies who even doesnt know what is Ahly Bayt. I know it, in Sunni mosques Ahly Bayt is never mentioned, let alone respected.
@@thestealth2448 for you anyone who says that is a rafidi. And for your information bhukari was the biggest rafidi since he rejected so many hadiths that he changed them took out certain people names and distorted Hadith from the truth. So mashallah biggest rafidi against the truth. I'm proud to be rafidi against batil aqida of yours.
I never said 'we sunnis'. I was referring to myself and my peers- As mistaken as your remarks are, you still haven't presented any factual evidence for your statement in the least. Saying 'I know that today Sunnism is not what it is suppose to be' - apart from the grammatical errors - is extremely cowardly and unprovoked by any measure of understanding. So I repose my quandry so that you might understand it: What proof do you have that Sunni's are weak in their love for Ahlul Bayt?
Shaykh you are very close. You're mentioning all the ayats in Quran about Ahlulbayt. Have you ever tried to connect these facts with the Shias belief according to the hadith of Kisa' that these ayats specifically in the aya tat'heer that Allah only aims those under Prophet (saw)'s cloak who are namely Fatima (as), Imam Ali (as) and Imam Hassan and Hussain (as) and 9 of Imam Hussain's (as) descendants last of them being Imam Mahdi? You are denying infallibility of Shia Imams as "gholou" while the aya tat'heer you've mentioned is the proof of their infallibility.
Loving of ahlubaith is a good thing. But among ahlubaith there is a section who exploit their ahlubaith status. Muslim need to cautious regarding that. Mir jafer who betrayed India to british was from ahlubaith. Kerala bidath activity started with sanaulla thangal. Hashemetes who sided with British was reason of collapse of khilafat and creation of Israel. Biggest rape scandal ajmer rape case was conducted by khadimsof ajmer sheriff. It is time to draw what is privillage of ahlubaith and their restriction. Or else entire Muslim community going to pay hefty price.
read the history of Islam, and what has Ahly Bayt suffered for last 1400 years. reading would be suffice to you, as a proof. I have so much evidence in my mosques, where I go, I hear and watch what people say, and Imams, go to islamic sunni forums, and except of praising Yazid and Muawiya, I dont see any respect and love for Ahly Bayt. What you and your peers do, I dont care. . Just read comments here on youtube on videos of Habib Ali Jifri, Ninowy, Yakoubi, and you will see what I mean.
A true Sunni will praise both the ahyle bayt and also the Sahaba. We know right to speak ill of anyone regardless of their actions. Thats the aqeeda of a true Sunni
As much as I love Shaikh Hamza (May God give him long life and health and sincerity to Allah SWT and increase his knowledge), I disagree with him here. I wish I have the opportunity to talk to him about this.
Judging Islam by the bad muslims is the same as judging Shia by the practices of some. For once, discuss the Nahjul al Balagha Hamza. Or are you able to read it? I would love to appreciate your work but you are prosletyzing up the wrong family tree. There is a very important event that you have never addressed and probably are unable to. If it is the case that the Shia are incorrect then explain why it is that the one person that spent his ENTIRE life in the presence of the prophet (Ali ibn Abi Taleb, peace upon the Commander of the Faithful) is not mentioned in Bohkhari? Or Fatima! Peace be upon one of the only four women of Paradise (not Aisha, pbuh who fought the Ahl Bayt and the hounds howled at her in Hawab and she knew it!). Yet you do not know. You indulge in a serious amount of superstition by saying you know these sillly things. Stop already.
I know what I am talking about. Dont be stubborn in your innacuracy. Youre telling me not to generalize, and you do the same thing..... I am saying that in in Sunni mosques in my country NEVER has been talk about Ahly Bayt. I go to mosques for long time, and know what I am talking about. Even on mawlid of Prophet aleyhiselam, Ahly Bayt is rarely mentioned.
............. So by saying "we Sunnies" is not generalization? You said "we". That probably means you and your self... I understand sunnism much better then you think, and I know that today Sunnism is not what it is suppose to be. I stand behind it, and I know what I am talking about.
how can one be a sunni and say they love AHLUL BAYT and IMAM HUSAYN? because if you knew the true history of the AHLULBAYT and IMAM HUSAYN you would leave sunnism in a blink of an eye.
why don't you concentrate on your own ahadith books, and last time i checked tabari was a sunni source which sunnis agree upon. 300 years after hijra , yea your right so what as long as it can be verified. we do not call our ahadiths sahih. big mistake by you guys
Quran 2:124 " ALLAH said surely I am going to make you an Imam for men." Ibrahim said - and of my offspring ? He said: my covenant will not include the unjust. Quran 17:71 - one day we shall call every group of people by their respective Imams.
So you can know, ALLAH chooses the Imams and they cannot be unjust. I know who my Imam is and i thank ALLAH that he guides me to him. I will no longer respond to you Nknana, peace.
Noooo Shia don't love Maula Ali R.A because they are deviants and go against their teachings and insult the Beloved Companions of Rasool'ALLAH Sallalahu Alayhi Wa Ala Aleyhi Wa Sallim (don't abbreviate Durood Shareef) & the Yazeedi the ugly jahanami lanat on him and his followers was a deviant Shia and to harm yourself and follow yur version of the Deen rejecting the Ahadith doesn't make you amongst the Ummah Of Rasool'ALLAH Sallalahu Alayhi Wa Ala Aleyhi Wa Sallim because Hadhrat ALI r.a themself said they wud lash a person 80 times if they went against Hadhrat Abu Bakr Siddique r.a Do not say you're lovers of the Panjtan Paak when you don't even follow their teachings !!
You are misguided. Shia are misguided and have historically been enemies to the Ahlul Bayth. Imam Jafar As Sadiq (Rad) was Sunni, was descended from Hazrat Abu Bakr (Rad) from his mother's side and married his kids to Sunnis.
By Allah's grace, I becam a Muslim almost 16 years ago, as a 12er Shia Muslim practicing the Jafari Madhab. However, I have great respect for my Sunni Muslim brothers and sisters. I have great respect for Shaykh Hamza Yusuf and will listen to his tapes to get the orthodox Sunni view. We can agree to disagree on our differences. True Sunni Muslims love Ahlul Bayt.
Philip Voerding ALLSunni muslims love &cherish AHL AL BAYT . At least 5 times day we say "May Allah bless Muhammed & His family " every time we finish salah My father comes from HUSSEIN Ibn Ali mymother IS descendent from AlHASSAN Ibn Ali al badawi was hergrandfather one question to you as European Iguess why did you choose to be shia ?do you think a shia imam is infallible ? like ayatollah ?Do you reject the sunna ( you are going to be asked about at the Day of Jugment )do you accept what the say rather they insult the prophet' wife AICHA which means they insult his honor( &that also you will be asked about that I'm afraid ) read the biography of the prophet from sunni scholar books I advise you to know about both sides &YOU decide which is closer to Islamic Teaching
As-Salam Alaikum sister Aicha Belcaid. That is the saying of one Ayatullah. There have been and are multiple Ayatullahs, That is not what my Marja teaches. Intention is the key. There is so much misinformation about 12er Shia Muslims and what we believe that it becomes difficult to address everything. It has been 7 years or so since I recorded this video, and I have learned more about Islam and Muslims since then. I like true Sunni Muslims even more than I did back them. Yet, I am even more convinced now that I ought follow the Prophet and his family and the Jafari Madhab rather than the 4 Madhabs. Did you know both Abu Hanifa and Ibn Malik were students of the 6th Imam Jaffar As-Sadiq, the great grandson of the 3rd Imam Hussein? Yet, the Shafie Madhab is the closest to the Jafari Madhab, with the Maliki Madhab as a close 2nd. In classic times, Abu Hanifa and Hanafi sheikhs used to study with Mutazilite, Zaidi Shia, and 12er Shia Sheikhs? The Gap between Sunnis and Shias has widened since then, which is a shame, because we are all true Muslims!
By the way, the first three years I investigated Islam and Muslims, I read Sunni Muslim authors, including Sufis, and the first Quran translation I ever read was a Sunni translation. I studied the 4 Madhabs and still have those books. I have studied Muslim History from several sides (more than just Sunni and 12er Shia groups). Why were 11 of 12 Shia Muslim Imams, all Sayyeds,murdered, and 10 of them by order of the Caliphs?
Certainly I don't blame the Sunni Imams who have madhabs named for them for these murders, but fabrication of hadith by the Ummayad Dynasty of Caliphs is well known to both Sunni and Shia scholars.
Sister, as for my use of the term "true Sunnis", I use the term because classical Sunni Muslim scholars like Ibn Kathir were Ummayad sympathizers despite living in the the time of the Abbasid Caliphate, write against the 12 Imams. Ibn Kathir wrote that Hussein Ibn Ali ibn Muhammad, our 3rd Imam, the 2nd son of the murdered 4th Caliph Ali Ibn Talib, our 1st Imam, was rightly, yes rightly, beheaded by his father's weapon by Caliph Yazid ibn Muhawiya Ibn Abu Sufyan's soldiers! That is a very well known passage from Ibn Kathir. He is not a true Sunni Muslim like you are, sister, since he believed that Imam Hussein deserved to be beheaded. Wahabis like the Saudis are called Sunnis when they are make fiqh differently than Sunnis do. I do like Imam Ahmed Ibn Hanbal himself, but many of the Hanbali scholars who followed him caused trouble even before Wahabism began. I don't care if the Saudis are considered allies of the USA, I say that is only because of oil money and no other reason. The Saudis, Al-Qaeda, ISIS, the Taliban, the modern Boca Haram ... all these groups are NOT true Sunnis and all are trying to exterminate Shia Muslims.
As for Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, I have nothing but respect for him. I have watched many of his videos and bought one of his books. I agree with him that the Sunni-Shia controversy is an old one, and while my investigation of Islam and Muslim groups led me to become a Muslim as a 12er Shia Muslim, I believe true Sunnis are my brothers and sisters. But still, I need to come out on one side, and 12er Shia Muslim Aqeedah and Fiqh make the most sense for me.
I believe Allah (SWT) is perfect. The 2nd Root of Religion for 12er Shia Muslims is Divine Justice. Therefore, I believe Allah is always just and never unjust because he is perfect. Even good Sunni scholars, who believe Allah is perfect, will say Allah doesn't have to always be just, but that is like saying He is not always perfect. On spiritual and philosophical grounds I cannot accept their view. Allah provides infallible scriptures, correct? For this reason, I believe Prophets and Messengers are protected by Allah and that protection allows them to be pure and infallible, so we can follow their example and their teaching and the scripture we get from them. If someone claims to be a messenger, but might not be pure and might not be infallible, how can I even trust he will give me Allah's message exactly as it was meant to be given? How can I follow their example if they might sin because they are not pure? They are Prophets and Messengers empowered by Allah, not by themselves, so they would not be pure and infallible with Allah's protection. Now, who rightly interprets Allah's scripture when the Messenger is no longer with us? Those who know. These people, can they make sins and teach heresy? How can I trust them if they are not pure and infallible? Dear Sister, if you can prove to me using Sunni books that all Sahaba were pure and infallible, and that the compilers or the 6 or 7 Sahih hadith books (7 if we include the Muwatta of Ibn Malik) were all pure and infallible, then I will be a Sunni Muslim and follow the Shafie Madhab. I can tell you there will be a problem immediately, because the 4 Imams for whom the Sunni Madhabs are named wrote terrible things about each other. Further, the 6 or 7 Sahih ahadith books have hadith that directly contradict each other. That is why I personally had to become a 12er Shia Muslim. Our 4 classic books of hadith are not considered to all be Sahih. The hadith are of different grades. Later books are compilations of the hadith considered to be authentic. However, the ONLY Shia Muslim hadith book that is considered 100% reliable is the As-Sahifa As-Sajjadiyyah of our 4th Imam Ali Zainul Abideen, the only male survivor of the battle of Karbala, who was later murdered by a Caliph. His prayer book and his Treatise on Rights, which are also used by some Sunnis who are Sufis, is considered fully authentic. The Nahjul Balagha of Imam Ali the 4th Calipj is a close 2nd, though a few things in that book are considered suspect. Those two books are followed by several other later compilations.
I don't expect you to become a 12er Shia Muslim just because of what I wrote. I was raised a Christian and attended a Bible School, and did my own research after that. Even after I read the Quran and was pleasantly surprised, and then read Al-Ghazali and Rumi and Sunni books on hadith science and Aqeedah, then looked at what the 12er Shia Muslims had to say, it took me 6 months to actually give Shahada after I was convinced Islam was true. I know Christians who took longer, and some who try to be both Christian and Muslim, or stay Christian and study Muslim books also. But sister, you are already a Muslim, so you don't have to convert/revert to anything. If you do come to a place where you want to follow the two weighty things left by the Prophet: The Quran and his family, as a hadith in Sahih Muslim states, then you should become a 12er Shia Muslim. But sister, you are already a Muslim, and I believe good Sunni Muslims are Moomineen and Moomineena.
12 Patriarchs of Jacob/Israel. 12 Princes of Ishmael. 12 Apostles of Jesus Christ. 12 Imams of Muhammad. Blessings of Allah and Peace be upon all of them!
Masalama dear sister.
Philip Voerding jaffa as sadique is asunni scholar his mother's name is Aicha Cz I studied ahl bait family tree from my father Shia took hold of his teachings and said falsely he was a Shia at his time there was no shia/sunni but only Muslims as a European u should have an independent free thinking I hope u reconsider u r iman about the 4 madhab in sunna they are rather schools each imam respected his fellow such as ashafie was a student of anas in Malik a well educated Muslim sunni respect all these imams the prophet saws said that Muslims will divided in73 groups only the ones who follow coran and sunna will be saved from hellfire
Philip Voerding Masya Allah, may Allah bless you Akhi
Thank you! And may Allah bless you and your, too.
I leave behind me two things, if you hold on to those thing you will never go astray, Al Quraan, and Ahlul Bayt.
-Sahih Muslim.
sunnah
It's Quransharif & Sunnah.
@@syedsuhaibhasan4003 sahih muslim brother???? Where is sunnah mentioned in 6 books of hadith???
Peace and Blessings of Allah be upon Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and his family.
اللهم صل وسلم على محمد وعلى آل محمد
“O Allah, let Your Blessings come upon Muhammad and the family of Muhammad, as you have blessed Ibrahim and his family. Truly, You are Praiseworthy and Glorious. Allah, bless Muhammad and the family of Muhammad, as you have blessed Ibrahim and his family. Truly, You are Praiseworthy and Glorious”.
I am a direct descendant of the Prophet (SAWS)! THANK YOU INFINITELY, MY INFINITELY BELOVED ALLAH (SWT)!
I also love the beloved SAHABAS of our Beloved Prophet (SAWS) ! MAY ALLAH(SWT ) MAKE the ummah an immense benefit
for this suffering world
Allahumma Salli Alaa Sayyidina Muhammad
Southeast Asia have been Muslim, thanks to Ahl Bayt that spread Islam here
Uyghur Malay , @ Uyghur Malay , It is mostly due to the hundred of thousands of the Sahabas , the taabi3ins, and so forth ,who brought Islam to Southeast Asia ; The AhluBayt numbers was much smaller , to have made a difference!
@@sidibouchrit their number were small, but they give large impact to us, from society, to culture, From A to Z. Our relationship between them are too strong, because of Ahl Bayt, with Allah will, most of our Kings embraced the Islam with helping from them, and due to our loyality towards King, whole kingdom embraced Islam
@@sidibouchrit also, there's no deny that some of traders from Arabia and Indian Subcontinent also give the contribution, but not too wide spread
@@sidibouchrit how do you know if you descended from him?
I am Sunni and I love Ahlul bait especially imam Hussain who stood up against tyrant Yazeed and gave his life. Yazeed did not only order to kill Imam Hussain but also make Madina mubah for his army and attack Mecca. All haters can go and stay with Yazeed on the day of judgement.
Glad to see a sunni who does not say " yazeed (ra)"
Lol i know most of u sunnis dont but i grew in an area surrounded by salafis who refer themeselves as sunnis so i didnt know that many sunnis who hated yazid la
ali said am a sunni ahlulbayt and I hate yazeed
"Fatema A.S is part of me, who angers her angers me and who angers me angers Allah!" Hadith from Bukhari. And Fatema A.S did not talk to Abu Bakr till her death.
Armand Baudouin
spreading lies.
Fatimah A.S didn't talk to Abu Bakr R.A regarding the inheritance anymore, not in general. true Muslims follow the middle path, love of Ahlul Bayte and the sahaba
I am Muslim from Egypt, and I have a strong love for Ahul-Bayt - Allahhu masaly ala sayidna Muhammad wa ala aly sayidnah Muhammad
It is an obligation to every Muslim .Ahle Sunnah wal Jamat Love and Honor the Pure Ahle Bayt (RadiAllahu Anhum wa Alayhis salaam) as commanded by Allah Ta’ala and The Holy Prophet SalAllahu alayhi wa Aalihi wassallam. Loving the Pure Ahle Bayt is not something that is done by the Shia but rather it is it deeply rooted in the core and essence of Sunni Islam and Aqidah part of our IMAN .
im not shia but i have alot of shia friends, we celebrate the good times of the prophet and his family, the shia celebrate and commemorate the good and bad times of the ahlul bayt, your statement is wrong and biased. shias love the ahlul bayt and sunnis love the companions more!
And maybe thats why your scholars don't like talking about ahlelbayt. They hide so much and is afraid that you become shia. The prophet said: " I leave behind two weighty things and if you hold to them, you wil never go astray. Ghoran and ahlelbayt
@@mightymo7607 Loving Ahl Bayt is a duty for All Muslim, Ahl Bayt spread Islam to Southeast Asia and still exist in society, bringing Sunni doctrine since day 1
i try to find out truth by listening different scholors from differnt sects but where i found peace and love is in the speeches of tahir ul qadri and hamza yusuf
They are try sunni scholars. Also listen to hazzor muffakir e islam pir syed abdul qadir jilani. The master of knowledge in today's world.
I'm sure right I'm saying that tahir qadri has also taken knowledge from him and also shakyh syed ninowy
@@srxxx1326 yes he's also of the strongest scholars/syeds of the subcontinent
May Allah Bless The Family of The Chosen, Beloved of Allah wherever they are found.
Many thanks for the video THIS topic is of immense importance and massively neglected.
Wasalaam.
No imane for those who don't love Ahlul-Bayt r.t.a.
A.s*
اAHLUL-BAYT IN THE LIGHT OF QURAN
Prophet Muhammad (SW) showed his Ahlul-Bayat on the following two occasions:-
(a) When the purification clause "Verily Allah intends to keep off from you uncleanness, O you
Ahlul Bayt and keep you pure at the apex of purity" (انَّمَا يُرِيدُ ٱللَّهُ لِيُذۡهِبَ عَنڪُمُ ٱلرِّجۡسَ أَهۡلَ ٱلۡبَيۡتِ وَيُطَهِّرَكُمۡ تَطۡهِيرََ )" of verse 33 of Surah Ahzaab was revealed. The occasion, time and place of revelation of subject part of Verse 33 of Surah Ahzaab is narrated by Jabir bin Abdullah (RA) as told to him by Hazrat Fatima (SA). One day when Lady Fatima (SA) was in the house of Hazrat Ummay Salma (RA) the wife of the prophet, the Prophet (SW) told her that He was feeling weakness, therefore, she covered Him with a yamni shawl. Soon after Hazrat Imam Hussain (AS) entered the house and joined the Prophet. Subsequently Imam Hassan (AS), Lady Fatima (SA) and Hazrat Ali (AS) also joined the prophet under the shawl. Later, on Hazrat Ummay Salma's request to join the group also, however, the Prophet told her to remain at her place and that she was at peace. At this juncture Hazrat Jibrail (AS) revealed subject part of Verse 33 (Refer to any Sihah-e-Sitta Book). The purification clause of Verse 33 of Surah Ahzaab "Verily Allah intends to keep off from you uncleanness, O you Ahlul-Bayt and keep you pure at the apex of purity" was placed at subject place in Quran as different parts of the revelations were placed at appropriate place in Quran under Prophet Muhammad (SW) instructions e.g. the first verse “ اقْرَأْ بِاسْمِ رَبِّكَ الَّذِي خَلَقَ”
was placed in Surah Al-Alaq the 96th Surah and on second revelation the verses were placed in 68th Surah Al-Qalam of Quran. It should be noted that the arrangement of Quran is not in the order of the verses as they were revealed. Moreover, the purification clause starts with the word إِنَّمَا that is encircling word (kalmay hasar-حصر) used in Arabic language to restrict or encircle the implication of the text meaning to that matter only which follows إِنَّمَا. Therefore, what is stated before the wordإِنَّمَا is excluded and what is stated after إِنَّمَا doesn’t apply to the text about wives of the prophet before the word إِنَّمَا in subject verse. As such, the evidence shows that only those under the blanket are included in Ahlul-Bayat and not the wives of the Prophet as advocated by many scholars.
(b) When the deliberations on the birth of Hazrat Eysa (AS) with the Christians of Najran in 9th Hijra did not succeed, Allah commanded in Verse 61 of Surah Aal-e-Imran asking each party to bring their sons, women and men (Nafoos) for invoking Allah's CURSE on the liars (mobyhlah مباہلہ). At that time among others the Prophet had 9 wives and His son Ibrahim was alive but the Prophet took Hazrat Ali (AS), Lady Fatima (SA), Imam Hassan and Hussain (AS) ONLY for mobyhlah. Seeing subject personalities the Christians chief priest Abdul Masih refused to do mobyhlah and accepted to pay nominal tax (Jazia). Allah declared subject incidence as account of truth (Surah Aal-Imran Verse-62). Mobahilah was the contest of truth (sadaqat-صداقت) and Prophet took only those personalities who were considered highly truthful ]sadeeq ((صدیق superlative degree of sadiqصادق) )] in this contest of truth. The Prophet said that my Ahlul-Bayt are like the boat of Hazrat Nuh (AS), who so ever came on board would gain salvation and one who remains astray will drown and perish. He also said, “I am leaving two weighty things: Quran and my itrat-Ahlul Bayt, they will remain enjoined till they meet me at the pool of Kawthar on the Day of Judgment. One who remains associated with them surely will not go astray and one who remains away will perish”. Moreover, He said, Hussain is from me and I am from Hussain (Sihah-e- Sitta).
I am beginning to like this sheikh Hamza a lot. Because he is into Islam deeply and not just superficially and I respect that. He is amazing because he is an Irish American whose family goes all they way down to Revolutionary wars against the British.
Somebody up there must have liked him a lot to have guided him and of course he has good genes/blood too.
I wonder if Sheikh knows about the deceptions of these so-called Ahle Kitab ppl who had moved to Arabia just to kill the Seal of the Prophets (they knew of his coming from their books) and destroy his religion (this is why they joined the idolatries and atheists/polytheists and provoked them against the monotheist religion (doesn't make sense but...) )
and when they couldn't do it (Because of Imam Ali and others with true faith) they came from within (Munafigh) then after Prophet's death tried to destroy the Prophet's family by attacking His house (with fire) and killing his expecting daughter and her son in process then they tried to distort Quran but when they couldn't do it they shuffled the verses out of order of revelation.... Anyway All divisions in all religions come from that 1 single and evil source.(They destroyed Christianity and invented Catholicism. They divided Islam into 4 branches and then more, up to 72) Why no Moslem today ask why there are so many sects in Islam while the Prophet SA brought 1 religion and 1 book and 1 faith? Also why no one asks why Prophet Muhammad SA is the Last of the Prophets while we now live in this so-called "modern" world and need a lot of guidance?! The prophet sawa predicted this and said his Umma with do exactly as bani israil after him and Islam will be divided into 72 sects, all will be in Fire except 1!
Now who do you follow? Ahlul Bayt the source of Prophet or the agents of yahudi leaders? The choice is clear to me. This is why I and ppl like me don't need another prophet to guide us. The prophet's successor is with us! We may not be able to see him but he sees us and God-willing some lucky day soon he shall re-appear!
Subhanallah ♥
(Allah wishes only to remove Ar-Rijs from you, O members of the family, and to purify you with a thorough purification.) This is a clear statement that the wives of the Prophet are included among the members of his family (Ahl Al-Bayt) here, because they are the reason why this Ayah was revealed.
The context in which this verse occurs makes it manifest that the word ahl al-bait (people of the house) here implies the wives of the Holy Prophet (upon whom be Allah's peace), because the address begins with: "O wives of the Prophet," and they are the addressees in the whole discourse preceding it as well as following it. Moreover, the word ahl al-bait in Arabic is used precisely in the sense in which the word "household" is used in English, which includes both a man's wife and children. No one would exclude the wife from the "household." The Qur'an itself has used this word at two other places besides this, and at both the wife is included in its sense, rather as the most important member of the family. In Surah Hud, when the angels give the Prophet Abraham the good news of the birth of a son, his wife exclaims: "Shall I bear a child now when I have grown too old, and this husband of mine has also become old?" The angels say: What! Are you surprised at Allah's decree, O people of Abraham's household? Allah's mercy and blessings are upon you."
In Surah Al-Qasas, when the Prophet Moses reaches the Pharaoh's house as a suckling, and the Pharaoh's wife is in search of a suitable nurse for the child, the Prophet Moses' sister says, "Shall I tell you of a household whose people will bring him up for you and look after him well?" Thus, the Arabic idiom and the usage of the Qur'an and the context of this verse, 'all point clearly to the fact that the Holy Prophet's wives are Ahle Bayt.
That is why according to lbn 'Abbas and 'Urwah bin Zubair and `Ikrimah, the word ahl al-bait in this verse (Surah Al Ahzaab verses 32 and 33) implies the wives of the Holy Prophet. [Tafsir Ibn Abi hatim]
The Prophet is closer to the believers than their selves, and his wives are (as) their mothers. [Quran 33:6]
Salam alayka ya rasulAllah ya habibAllah ya The chosen, the blessed one.
Salaaat upon you ya Nabi
@4:50 "Muslims have lost adab " so true at this time
Hamza Yusuf is wrong. Queen Elizabeth has lineage from Yazeed NOT the Prophet (SAW) according to the data.
He's saying what they claim. He wouldn't know whether or not it's true. I doubt it myself. Not that it is impossible but royal families have alleged lineages from Pharaos, from Romans emperors, some even claim from Prophet Jesus (صلى الله عليه وسلم). Obviously it cannot all be true.
Qul laa as alukum ajra illa mawaddata fil qurbaa.allahu mma swalli alaa muhammad wa aali muhammad
My great grandfather is a direct descendent of aqil ibn talib
Both Sunni and Shia love the ahlul bayt(a.s). Its just that among the Muslims, division occurs because people are so fond of looking into their differences. Moreover, muslims in general don't like to read books and discuss on important issues pertaining to the muslim ummah. There are Duas taught by the family of the prophet, most people take it for granted.
that website's a treasure lol jazakAllah khairan!
The prophet Mohammad said :" I leave behind two weighty things and if you hold to them you wil never go astray. Ghoran and ahlelbayt.
The muslim scholars have hide it because they are afraid that you may become shia . Thats so sad. They are going to be asked for that inshallah in the day of judgement.
Im sunni. What Saman said is the true hadith. The family are still respected to the utmost level. We love them. Shiaism do have certain misguiding things. Going to extremes like infallibility and beating kneself is too much Saman. Its not necessary. Even we cry when we think abt what happened in karbala. Yazid will suffer in hell fire
What is "ghoran"
Nice video. Thanks Dawud.
While just saying that we are muslim is sufficent their is nothing wrong with ascertaining that you are a member of Ahl as Sunnah wal Jama'ah/Sunni, as this is the group that the Prophet alaihi salaam indicated was the saved group based off the qualities that He outlined that that group would have.
Assalamu aleykum warahmatullahi wabarakatuhu. Does Somebody know where to get the full lecture please?
what is the book did Shaykh Hamza mentioned by Abu al-Faraj al-Isfahani?
The whole point of the Abbasids was to avenge ahul bayt due to the ummayads persecuting them. Then when the Abbasids got in power, they became Sunnis and began killing ahul bayt.
Generalization is by definition prescribing a quality to a mass- which is what you were doing. You've now changed it to 'your country', next it may be 'your city', or 'family'. The fact is that I never generalized. Rather, I referred in my original comment to my own sunni frame of reference, as opposed to yourself.
As an attendee I clarify my previous statement as it is clear you have no understanding for it: Sunnism incorporates ahl-bayt, you simply have to understand it before preaching it.
Salaam
what was that book Shaykh mentioned at 11:50? and would you happen to know of an English translation that may be available?
I looked for it, but couldn't find it...there are some similar sunni books on scribd.com. check it out.
we do love them BUT wedonot worship them and we do not give them divine prerogatives. I am wondering how a monotheist jew can become a shia . there are so many shirks and heresies in shiism. Do use the link i sent previously and u will become a true muslim
@DawudIsrael1
Do you know what is in the harts?
I would disagree strongly. I'm sunni and I have a very powerful love of Ahlul Bayt. So is Sheikh Hamza Yusuf if I'm not mistaken. The fact that I contend to sufism doesn't exempt me from that tradition.
Assalamualaykum shayk.
Is someone a syed if his mother is syeda and a non syed father?
A person in known by his father's lineage
where are the legimate ahlu bayt now...did they just disappear ?? plz someone explain to me ??
Does the Shaykh know Arabic? As, if does, then how can he call the uncles, nephews etc as members of the ahlul bayt? Qur'an 33:33, please explain based on the Arabic yaah Shaykh
He says that because of the hadith that includes them all
Salman farsi ra was also ahlul bait
❤
DEEN AST HUSSAIN ..................SHA AJMARI
brother i want a non bias view that isnt shia or sunni just general islamic knowledge...just centuries before there were ppl identified as ahlu bayt..alot of sheikh were ahlu bayt like abdulqadir jelani or imam shafi'i etc...you only gave me a cities name i want a big sheikh or a known person(s)....its kinda weird that not one person can be legitimately identified as ahlu bayt...i think theirs a big cover up...allah knows best.
Not sure how Sunnis love ahul bayt when they praise the people who murdered and exiled them like Muwawia who rebelled against the 4th and 5th khalif who were both ahul bayt and murdered the 5th.
Imam Jafar As Sadiq (Rad) was descended from Hazrat Abu Bakr (Rad) from his mother's side and was a Sunni and married his children to Sunnis.
@@xtremeownage2 TF you on about. Muhammad ibn abu bakr hated his own father for usurping imam ali position. Because of this him and his sister ayesha never saw eye to eye one was raised by imam ali like a son while the other sibling had deep enimosity toward imam ali. Lastly, there were no sunnis back then there were only shia of ali or shia of abu bakr or other shia following the so called in the futured would come to be called "sunni"
Not all sunnis praise muawiyah and abu yazeed
I like hamza yusuf but to use the arguement that the ahlul bayt arent infallible coz 'their human' is wrong! The prophets of allah were human and both sunni and shia believe they were infallible.
Also in surah 33:33 allah says that o ahlul bayt i have purified you a thorough purification..
My question is what does that actually mean when all mighty allah swt purifies them a thorough purification?
@syedlovesAllah Because Sunnis are weak in their love for Ahlul Bayt, we rarely discuss it.
@Zulkar9 Excerpt from a bigger talk. Its an important topic I feel needs to get out there.
well you are then exemptions, he was speaking about wast majority of Sunnies who even doesnt know what is Ahly Bayt. I know it, in Sunni mosques Ahly Bayt is never mentioned, let alone respected.
Not true. They are mentioned
You see those Shia wearing black turbans and the ones wearing white turbans? The ones wearing Black ones are suppose to be ahul bayt
No one in the comment section is a scholar so stop quoting bukhari and don't give your opinion
neither was bhukari a scholar lol
Agent313 he was, your only saying that because your a rafidi😉
@@thestealth2448 for you anyone who says that is a rafidi. And for your information bhukari was the biggest rafidi since he rejected so many hadiths that he changed them took out certain people names and distorted Hadith from the truth.
So mashallah biggest rafidi against the truth.
I'm proud to be rafidi against batil aqida of yours.
@Ike Dakhlallah just shut the fuck up you dumbass. sunnism is hypocritcal religion made for slaving people its not islam period.
@@Agent.313 You're insulting people like Al-ghazali too?
I never said 'we sunnis'. I was referring to myself and my peers- As mistaken as your remarks are, you still haven't presented any factual evidence for your statement in the least.
Saying 'I know that today Sunnism is not what it is suppose to be' - apart from the grammatical errors - is extremely cowardly and unprovoked by any measure of understanding. So I repose my quandry so that you might understand it: What proof do you have that Sunni's are weak in their love for Ahlul Bayt?
Shaykh you are very close. You're mentioning all the ayats in Quran about Ahlulbayt. Have you ever tried to connect these facts with the Shias belief according to the hadith of Kisa' that these ayats specifically in the aya tat'heer that Allah only aims those under Prophet (saw)'s cloak who are namely Fatima (as), Imam Ali (as) and Imam Hassan and Hussain (as) and 9 of Imam Hussain's (as) descendants last of them being Imam Mahdi? You are denying infallibility of Shia Imams as "gholou" while the aya tat'heer you've mentioned is the proof of their infallibility.
dawud israel ??
Loving of ahlubaith is a good thing. But among ahlubaith there is a section who exploit their ahlubaith status. Muslim need to cautious regarding that. Mir jafer who betrayed India to british was from ahlubaith. Kerala bidath activity started with sanaulla thangal. Hashemetes who sided with British was reason of collapse of khilafat and creation of Israel. Biggest rape scandal ajmer rape case was conducted by khadimsof ajmer sheriff. It is time to draw what is privillage of ahlubaith and their restriction. Or else entire Muslim community going to pay hefty price.
read the history of Islam, and what has Ahly Bayt suffered for last 1400 years. reading would be suffice to you, as a proof. I have so much evidence in my mosques, where I go, I hear and watch what people say, and Imams, go to islamic sunni forums, and except of praising Yazid and Muawiya, I dont see any respect and love for Ahly Bayt. What you and your peers do, I dont care. . Just read comments here on youtube on videos of Habib Ali Jifri, Ninowy, Yakoubi, and you will see what I mean.
A true Sunni will praise both the ahyle bayt and also the Sahaba. We know right to speak ill of anyone regardless of their actions. Thats the aqeeda of a true Sunni
Not true in the least, we discuss is often and lovingly. You would do wise not to generalize.
As much as I love Shaikh Hamza (May God give him long life and health and sincerity to Allah SWT and increase his knowledge), I disagree with him here. I wish I have the opportunity to talk to him about this.
what do you disagree with exactly
Judging Islam by the bad muslims is the same as judging Shia by the practices of some. For once, discuss the Nahjul al Balagha Hamza. Or are you able to read it? I would love to appreciate your work but you are prosletyzing up the wrong family tree. There is a very important event that you have never addressed and probably are unable to. If it is the case that the Shia are incorrect then explain why it is that the one person that spent his ENTIRE life in the presence of the prophet (Ali ibn Abi Taleb, peace upon the Commander of the Faithful) is not mentioned in Bohkhari? Or Fatima! Peace be upon one of the only four women of Paradise (not Aisha, pbuh who fought the Ahl Bayt and the hounds howled at her in Hawab and she knew it!). Yet you do not know. You indulge in a serious amount of superstition by saying you know these sillly things. Stop already.
I know what I am talking about. Dont be stubborn in your innacuracy. Youre telling me not to generalize, and you do the same thing..... I am saying that in in Sunni mosques in my country NEVER has been talk about Ahly Bayt.
I go to mosques for long time, and know what I am talking about. Even on mawlid of Prophet aleyhiselam, Ahly Bayt is rarely mentioned.
............. So by saying "we Sunnies" is not generalization? You said "we". That probably means you and your self... I understand sunnism much better then you think, and I know that today Sunnism is not what it is suppose to be. I stand behind it, and I know what I am talking about.
google karbala
Darn apologeticcxxxxx
Apologetic? U dont love the ahlul bayt? U dont love Hassan and Hussein and Fatima? How can u call urself a sunni muslim?
how can one be a sunni and say they love AHLUL BAYT and IMAM HUSAYN? because if you knew the true history of the AHLULBAYT and IMAM HUSAYN you would leave sunnism in a blink of an eye.
why don't you concentrate on your own ahadith books, and last time i checked tabari was a sunni source which sunnis agree upon. 300 years after hijra , yea your right so what as long as it can be verified. we do not call our ahadiths sahih. big mistake by you guys
Quran 2:124 " ALLAH said surely I am going to make you an Imam for men." Ibrahim said - and of my offspring ? He said: my covenant will not include the unjust. Quran 17:71 - one day we shall call every group of people by their respective Imams.
So you can know, ALLAH chooses the Imams and they cannot be unjust. I know who my Imam is and i thank ALLAH that he guides me to him. I will no longer respond to you Nknana, peace.
Noooo Shia don't love Maula Ali R.A because they are deviants and go against their teachings and insult the Beloved Companions of Rasool'ALLAH Sallalahu Alayhi Wa Ala Aleyhi Wa Sallim (don't abbreviate Durood Shareef) & the Yazeedi the ugly jahanami lanat on him and his followers was a deviant Shia and to harm yourself and follow yur version of the Deen rejecting the Ahadith doesn't make you amongst the Ummah Of Rasool'ALLAH Sallalahu Alayhi Wa Ala Aleyhi Wa Sallim because Hadhrat ALI r.a themself said they wud lash a person 80 times if they went against Hadhrat Abu Bakr Siddique r.a
Do not say you're lovers of the Panjtan Paak when you don't even follow their teachings !!
You are misguided. Shia are misguided and have historically been enemies to the Ahlul Bayth. Imam Jafar As Sadiq (Rad) was Sunni, was descended from Hazrat Abu Bakr (Rad) from his mother's side and married his kids to Sunnis.
This is nauseating.