bhaijan aap bohot e nek kaam Kar rahe hai main Quran ko samajh k nahi padh pati hoon shayad koshish bhi nahi karti hoon padh jab bhi Quran ko leke discussion hota hai main waha zarur concentrate karne ki koshish karti hoon aap pls Quran pe zyada se zyada video banai Khuda aapko mehfuz rakkhe ameen 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Alhamdulillah, very logical and evidence based presentation we are expecting from you a genuine translation of Al Quran in English and Urdu language. May Almighty ALLAH bless u and bless us all and give us light. Thanks for such a beautiful video From your brother Md Atiqur Rahaman from Calcutta, India.
MashaAllah zbrdast me b yehi sochti thi k log space me Safar kr rahen hen or Muslim nikah jinsi baat me ukajh rahe hen sitaron p kama d dalne wale apne hi ifkaar me Safar kr na sake
Good job on clarifying this confusion. These traditional translations are taken entirely from the Y-a-hoodi’s Talmud that have meticulously spelt out many such regulations avoiding, & not even sleeping in the same bed as their wives during these times. Their laws have restricted women to such archaic codes, but the Quran came to dispel these and liberate!
Asa.your point of views are always very amazing and it always turn my mind towards a clear and transparent logical message of Quran.kindly explain the meaning of astaghfar also and the ayats related to this term . Regards and duas
brother if someone understands quran even a little bit then he cant prove u wrong. u explained this very well thank you. i am irfan ahamad farooquis son. this is also a great example for me to learn quran thank you
Salam Moses. I really enjoy these videos and following along with English subtitles. Have you ever considered creating a translation of the Qu'ran? Except for maybe two or three translations (Leila Ahmed, Dr. Shabbir Ahed, and Edip Yuksel) that make up a small minority of circulating qur'ans, I'd say 99% of Muslims only quranic text is one that supports hitting women, amputating hands for theft, promoting slavery/concubinage etc. I know many young muslims out there would deeply appreciate having an honest and sincere rendition of the Qur'an.
Salaam Brother Al Moses, I am eagerly waiting explanation of ayath related to Nikah, Talaq and Inheritance. Kya apne Salath, Saum, Ibadath, Shukr, Tasbeeh, kufr etc per bhi detail me topic wise lecture series banaye Jazakallah khair
Salam, I've talked about tasbeef and kuft off and on. But haven't covered these in great detail. Franky, there is already enough videos/written material on it that I haven't felt the need yet.
I have come across the ayah 65:6 where traditional translations mention pregnancy and breastfeeding. how do u connect your interpretation of 65:4 to 65:6? your understanding of the word Nisa doesn't fit with pregnancy or breastfeeding term, does it? Eagerly waiting for your reply
Before I thought that the traditional translation was right as my lack of understanding of word almuheez and azan. Thank you for such a logical and academic translation of Quran as it deserves. It makes sense and thank you for helping us understanding the Guidance. Do you happen to have any video on Nikah and Zina? What are these boundries as per Quran's guidance?
Asal masla aaj ka yeh hay k Log Allah ki di hoi apni aqal o shawoor ka istamal nahi kerna chahte .... baz auqat woh kafi had tak Ahadees o rewayaton ki khamyan maan bhi jate hain per jo Quran per Dhool, Matti aur sab se bari cheez ki oos per strong kism ka Zang laga dya gaya hay mangharat transalation aur tafseer ki shakal main laga dya gaya hay jisay remove kerna beshak namumkin nahi bauhat mushkil hay....
Bhai 1200 1400 saal se agar sab galat bataya hai tu aj islam itna nahi hota agar aap paka prof ayat ke shat with tarjuma konsi ayat kis per utari q utari kya waje se utari aur us ayat ka amal kiya hai paka prof ke shat de saktai ho nahi de dogai mainai bout topic sunai aap ke aap sirf itana gol gumatai ho ye ke kar ke iska matalb ye nahi hai quran mai pan ye nahi bata tai kabi bhi ke ju matlab nahi hai aap ke hisab se wo kis ke liye hai aur q hai tarjumai ke shat takai pata chalai sab ko
@@mohsinfattajiwala6007 @Mohsin Fattajiwala Salam. Har aik ayaat mein multiple terms hain jin ko samjhanay kay lyay aur ayatain chahyain hoti hain. Yah to hum ghanton baat karain sirf aik aayat pe, ya aik topic pe focus karain. Mera mashwara aap ko yeh hay ke aap khud parhain: na mujh pe rely karain, na kisi aur pe. Khud insaaf say aur honesty say parhain, aur apni aqal pe bharosa karain kay woh aapko sahih rastay pe leke jayay gi.
Much much better and logical interpretation...mujhe samjh nahi aata itni saari baatein aurat mard ke jinsi talluq se Quran me kaise insert ki gayi..kya ye mahaz ek ghalti hai ya kuchh intentions ki gadbad thi...kyunki ye aurton ke maamlo par traditional riwaayate is qadar thoosi gayi hai Islam ke naam par aisa lagta to nahi hai ke ye koi mistake thi.
Bhai quran to bahut aasan banaya he ye kesi aasani he jo aaj tak kisi ki samajh me nahi aai ap ne phd ki he to ap samjhe he to kiya har insan ko phd karni hogi
@@AlMosesPhD still the question remains. Because Quran is already saying ki humne isko aasan banaya hai aur aayaten khol khol kar bayan ki hain to phir aaj tak logon ko samjh kyun samjh nahi aaya?
@@superbguy8709 'Zikr' ko yassar kya gaya. 1,200 saal say humarai programming Quranic terms say different hay. That's why yeh mushkil dikhta hay shuro mein
@@superbguy8709 sirprisingly Allah also had no idea that it will be mistranslated for so long and he lets so many muslims read and follow the wrong translations .. surprising .
So what does this ayat actually means? Who are these mushrik? And what does it mean to stay away from them for 3 months....what will happen after 3 months?
@@khayalie_pulao 65 is a small surah, no harm reading it too. Just try that without the prejudice of what rijal / zakar /untha / nisaa / mushrik mean and you'll see what is being talked about
@@sarahriaz2069 Tayib are usually good, nice things. Often left to us to interpret acccording to our times. Thr = Something filtered, cleaned. Often connected with quloob
I know of that understanding. But in the context, Nisaa make sense as those mushrikeen just before this ayah. When God tells us Himself that al-maheez IS azan, that seals the deal for me.
السلام علیکم، چونکہ آپ نے المحیض کا ترجمہ نہیں کیا تو ابھی اس آیت کریمہ پر بات کرنا تھوڑا مشکل ہوگا۔ خیر الفاظ کے معنوں کی بحث میں پڑے بغیر صرف دو چیزوں پر آپ کی توجہ مبذول کرنا چاہتا ہوں۔ ۱- جیسا کہ آپ نے کہا المحیض = اذن اور جن النِسا کے اذن چھوڑ دینے میں شک ہو تو تین ماہ کا انتظار۔ ۲- اور آپ نے لکھا ہے “ جنھوں نے ابھی تک اذن نہیں دی یا ابھی تک حمل اٹھاۓ ہوۓ ہیں” تو ان کا انتظار شرک کے خاتمے تک کیا جائیگا۔ سوال یہ ہے کہ جس النِسا نے اذن (ذہنی تکلیف) دی ہی نہیں تو ان سے سماجی /بزنس تعلقات کیوں منقطع کیے جائیں؟ کیوں پہلے ان کے اذن دئے جانے کا انتظار اور پھر اس اذن کو ختم کردینے کا انتظار کیا جاۓ؟ کیا یہ لوجیکل انالوجی ہوگی؟ دوسرے یہ کہ سورہ طلاق آیت ۴ کے پہلے جز میں یئسن من المحیض من نسائکم کہا گیا یعنی بقول آپ کے فہم کے اس کا مطلب کچھ یوں ہوگا۔ وہ جن کے ایمان میں کمی ہے ان میں سے جو المحیض = اذن سے دور نہیں ہو پا رہے ہیں (ان کی شرک سے دوری مایوس کن/ناممکن ہے) تو مومنین ان سے فعدتہن ثلثتہ اشہر کر لیں یعنی تین ماہ تعلقات منقطع کر لیں۔ جن کی اسلام میں واپسی سے مکمل مایوسی ہے ان کے ساتھ تین ماہ کا قطع تعلق اور جو المحیض = اذن میں ابھی تک مبتلا نہیں ہوۓ ان کے ساتھ بھی تین ماہ کا قطع تعلق کیا معنی رکھتا ہے؟
Salam, Aap kay ghor talab comment lay lyay shukrya. Tarjamay kay time pe mujhay mafhoom aur clearly likhna chahyay tha. 1- 3 months un kay lyay jin pe shak ho 2- hukum aaya hay aitzaloo ka. Yeh samaji talaq say zyada shirkya cheezon say dur hatnay ka hay. Samaji talaq us cheez ka hisa ho saktay hain, lekin mein cheez nahi. Lehaza, hatta kay woh eeman mein kamzor log jinhon nay azan nahi dya, unsay shirkya cheezeon mein aitzaal karo. 3- nisaa-kum kaha gaya hay surah talaq mein. Agar aap surah baqarah mein 221 dekhain to wahan 'nikah' ki baat ki gayi hay 'nisa' say (woh jo eeman mein peechay hain). Nikah kay baad ye nissaakum hain.t Hopefully, thori clarification ab ap ko mili ho gi.
@@UbaidSalfi mein surah talaq inshallah puri cover karun ga jab talaq ka topic shuroo hoga. Tarjma kay bajayay apna mafhum share karun ga, kyon ke--jese ke apko idea hay--complete 100% tarjama mumkin nahi
@@AlMosesPhD Sir aapne al nisa ka tarjuma “females” nahi kiya kyunki tawwabeen orr mutatahhireen mein zamair masculine istemal hua hai lekin “walaa taqraboohunna hattaa yathurna fa izaa tatahharna fatoohunna “ mein zamair feminine kyun istemal huay hn” Ye explain kijye sir
Mere bhai ye mere khula challange hay tamam muslims ko k koi bhi ek aisa muslim insan (jo khud ko musalman kehta ho chahe woh kisi bhi sect se taluq rakhta ho) bashart k woh aqal o shawoor rakhta ho inkar nahi kersakta k oos k dimagh main question na uthti hon aur wo oos ka jawab na chahta ho un tamam Ahadees/Rewayaton aur un hi Ahadees/Rewayaton ki madad se jo Quran ki translation aur tafseer ki gai hay oos k against .... sab k dimagh main sawalaat aatay hain per yeh soch ker insan khud ko akser rok leta hay k log kya kahenge pagal kahenge, bura man jayenge, akser so called ulma movli dra dete hain sath hi daant bhi dete hain aur sath sath logon ki tanqeeden bhi sunne ko mil jati hain k pagal hogaya bhatak gaya hay yeh is ka dimagh phir gaya murtid ho jaoge deen-e-islam se nikal jaoge bla bla .. dekho yeh khud se Quran perhne aur samajhne ki koshsih ker raha hay jabhi ye aisi behki behki baatain ker raha hay ... falan banday ne aisa kya to dekho aaj woh murtid ya kaafir ban gaya etc ... phir oos k gher walay plus khandan walay society walay alag tanqeed ka nishana banate hain ..... in sab k sath sath sometime banda yeh keh ker bhi un sawalat se khud ba khud jan chura leta hay k aray choro ye sab zehan ka fatoor hay shetani was wasa hay werna yeh sab to humaray baap dada aur Allah k Rasool aur Sahaba k daur se chalay arahe hain etc. Conclusion yahi hay k sawalat har aqal mand insan k dimagh main paida hote hain per aksariat insan un sawalat se khud mou pher leta hay .... Per Alhamdulillah maine un tamam sawalat beshak har kisi se share nahi kya per oosay apnay dil o dimagh main zinda zeroor rakha aur Alhamdulillah un k jawabat aaj milte ja rahe hain.
Salam, Hum sab ko Aqal use karnay ka hukam Khuda nay dya. Jab insan aqal use karta hay, to sawal buhat hotay hain, jawab kam. Agar insan sochna chor day, to jawab 0 hotay hain, lekein sawal phir bhi atay rehtay hain. Keep thinking.
Arsad alam bhai. Moses bhai ko khali itana bolo pora quran tarjhuma kar ke bata de konsi ayat kiske liye utri hai aur q allha nai utari hai. Ye sirf itana bata tai hai quran mai iska matalab ye nahi. Ye nahi walai ka pora tarjuma kabhi nahi bata tai takai pata chalai ke ye ayat kisliye utri hai
@@mohsinfattajiwala6007 Salam. Har aik ayaat mein multiple terms hain jin ko samjhanay kay lyay aur ayatain chahyain hoti hain. Yah to hum ghanton baat karain sirf aik aayat pe, ya aik topic pe focus karain. Mera mashwara aap ko yeh hay ke aap khud parhain: na mujh pe rely karain, na kisi aur pe. Khud insaaf say aur honesty say parhain, aur apni aqal pe bharosa karain kay woh aapko sahih rastay pe leke jayay gi.
@@mohsinfattajiwala6007 mere pyare Bhai mujhe aap k bachkana sawalat per hansi arahi hay Jo k wahi jhooti rewayat pasandon k sawalat aur soch se 100% relate Ker Raha hay .... Jaise jahil rewat Pasand jhootay Molvi fermate Hain k Hazrat Umer R.A k aitraz per sur woh aitraz aurton ka gher se akele Baher mikalnay per tha woh bhi masakid Jane k lye ziada ter ... Umer k oos aitraz per nauzbillah Allah ko hosh Aya aray is ka to Maine ab tak solution hi nahi dya main Allah ho Ker Bhool gaya tha ek Kafir se Musalman hone wala basher ne mujhe yaad dilaya baray bharam k sath ... Allah maaf karay aisa hi mafhoom banta hay oos Ghaleez Riwayat se .... Aur phir Un molviyon aur aap jaison k Allah ne jaldi se parday ki ayat aurton k lye nazil Ker di .... Jab k Quran ka Allah sari qul kainat ka Allah Kuch nahi bhoolta oosay kisi k mashweray ya remind karane ki zeroorat nahi ... Mere pyare Bhai pehle riwayaton ko aur rewayat Pasand molvion ki jhooti aur Gandi jahilana taleemat ko apnay Ander se Nikal Ker Quran per khud se ghaur o fiker, research means Tadabbur o Tafakkur Karen ... Quran ko Quran ki Roshni main samajhne ki Koshish Karen phir aap ko sab Kuch khud ba khud samajh main ana shuru ho jayega.
Dear Moses: (الْمَحٖيضِ = اَذًى) in urdu (اَذًى = ایذا = تکلیف) in English (اَذًى = trouble). Secondly کیا آیت 2/222 کی ترتیل آیت 5-65/4 میں کی جائے گی؟ - کیا اس ہی کو ترتیل کہتے ہیں؟ النساء is a proper noun) The Quran is a complete guidance.
God had no other way to create a human being except by torturing women by giving her lifelong periods? Shedding of blood is what he choose.? This is his honour and love for women? Monthly pain and grief?
Men lose their hair while women keep theirs. Men suffer more heart attacks and parksinson's than women. Physical differences between genders even out over time.
@@AlMosesPhD Dear friend i am not saying that why he gave this to women and why didnt gave to men. I am saying he would have created human beings without torturing women with menstruation. Almighty god who is the most greatest our of our imagination he decided PERIODS for women.? That too every month .. tell me which women in this World is happy with this?She cannot even reject this.. My friend how are u comparing hair problem and heart attack with periods? U can avoid heart attack u can get your hair back with surgeries.....
@@rubina5079 Hmm. I am not trivializing periods. Merely pointing out that there are a lot of medical papers out there that compare physiological/psychological makeups of men and women, and suggest that despite 'periods' women are not overall worse off than men. It leads to the real question. Why are some born with certain gifts versus others and the fariness in that.
@@AlMosesPhD i dont know from where men came in between. My question was something else.. But its okay.. My question was how come a God who claims he is merciful, most intelligent, most loving (etc) can GIVE such THINGS.... What we see from our eyes is something else than what is been written by human BEINGS in holy books about their god/. . I know the holy books doesn't answer such questions.. Anyways... Thank you for replying to my comment 👍
Please save ourselves from the Sectarian mindset coz you are advised to keep away from those who divide into Sects. Check this verse: //Quran 6.159 Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - you are not with them in anything. Their affair is only [left] to Allāh; then He will inform them about what they used to do.//
Im not a blind hadees follower but I still find conventional translation of these verses for the most part.. Firstly I don't think its a big deal if topics like menstruation or sex are mentioned in quran..like we shouldn't approach the Quran with such a mindset that omG how can God talk about such stuff, these words MUST mean something else...may be they're tabooed or shame is attached to them in our culture but honestly these are normal and natural phenomenons. secondly, how I understand the conventional translation is: they ask about menstruation, tell them its a painful condition. so refrain from sexually approaching those women in such a painful condition, and approach them as has God commanded you when they have cleansed themselves. you asked, where do we find how God has instructed to approach our spouse , my understanding is that there are various instances in Quran where God commands us to deal with our spouse with dignity, gentleness , goodness ...perhaps those are the principles we must keep in mind.. God loves those who purify themselves.. why its masucline? perhaps masculine plural nouns include both male and female and what could mean is that menstruation is an unhygienic condition for women and men must also keep themselves clean by not approach them in that condition.. my understanding is that its not women who are being condemned for being unclean, its simply the process of menstruation where a human is literally bleeding.. even if a man is bleeding a certain amount of blood his wudhu and roza is considered makruh as well..
Doing pieces of an ayat and combining with an other to from some thing different trying to say Allah doesn’t know how the verse should have revealed Another Abrahamic Locution person
آدھ گھنٹہ ضائع کرنے سے بھی بات سمجھ نہیں آئی ۔۔ غامدی صاحب بھی اسی طرح اپنی عقل کے گھوڑے دوڈاتے ھیں۔۔ ھر بندہ اپنی عقل کے مطابق الفاظ کے معنی بنا لیتا ھے۔۔
Apni behnon, mayon, betyon, behnon kay sath yeh videos zarur share kijyay!
"Quran aur aurat" series sirf hum mardon kay lyay nahi!
bhaijan aap bohot e nek kaam Kar rahe hai main Quran ko samajh k nahi padh pati hoon shayad koshish bhi nahi karti hoon padh jab bhi Quran ko leke discussion hota hai main waha zarur concentrate karne ki koshish karti hoon aap pls Quran pe zyada se zyada video banai Khuda aapko mehfuz rakkhe ameen 🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@fairoozsadaf3450 jo aap kay lyay asaan hay, utna Quran parhyay
Allah aapko himmath de Sahi bath Quran ka sahi ilm jo aap phaelane ki try kar rahe haen AllAh thala barkath atha kare Aameen
Mashaallah Jazakallah qair keep it up
Wow excellent
قرآن کے نزول کے بعد سے آج تک کس نے اس مفہوم سے سمجھا ہے ؟
Alhamdulillah, very logical and evidence based presentation we are expecting from you a genuine translation of Al Quran in English and Urdu language. May Almighty ALLAH bless u and bless us all and give us light.
Thanks for such a beautiful video
From your brother Md Atiqur Rahaman from Calcutta, India.
Thanks. I have no plans of any translations though. Keep learning :)
Aap mind blowing kar detay hen. Bohat achhi tarah samjhaatay hen ... Good job.....
Once again congrats on your other successful episode! 💝💝💝
Shukrya Mughal bhai
Allah ap ko aur himatt aur istaqamat atta karay
Shukrya
Amazing explained brother ❤
MashaAllah zbrdast me b yehi sochti thi k log space me Safar kr rahen hen or Muslim nikah jinsi baat me ukajh rahe hen sitaron p kama d dalne wale apne hi ifkaar me Safar kr na sake
hamari soch ko jins tak mahdood kar dya gaya hay
Excellent job
Do share with the ladies of your family
Ji ha zaroor Musa bhai
Sukriya Mosa bhai
Alhamdulillah
Very nice. May Allah give you more strength and Ilm.
shukrya
Kia widow n idat k bare me he he or prperti me ourat Ka Acha hisa he is p video send Karen plz
Good job on clarifying this confusion. These traditional translations are taken entirely from the Y-a-hoodi’s Talmud that have meticulously spelt out many such regulations avoiding, & not even sleeping in the same bed as their wives during these times. Their laws have restricted women to such archaic codes, but the Quran came to dispel these and liberate!
bhai agr koi thoda bhi quran smghta hoga aur quran pe tadbbur tafkkur krta hoga vo aapki bat ko inkar nhi kr skta .mehrbani sukriya mere bhai
Alhamdulillah
Much appreciation for your efforts - may the Almighty grant you the best.
:-))
Thanks
Allahu Akbar allahu Akbar Allah apko salamat rakhe bhot hi behtreen wajahat ki apne bhot ahsan apka❤️
Alhamdulillah
MashaAllha
Shukrya
Bhai surh Noor 24,58 ki wazahat kijiye.aur Quran mein numbers ka Kya matlab hai please bataye.
Ma malakat aymanukim 'Quran aur Aurat' series me cover karoon ga inshallah
Asa.your point of views are always very amazing and it always turn my mind towards a clear and transparent logical message of Quran.kindly explain the meaning of astaghfar also and the ayats related to this term .
Regards and duas
Salam,
Astaghar = I turn and connect with God.
@@AlMosesPhD
Thanks but in future explain it's related ayats pz
@@sarwatwaseem1536 inshallah.
brother if someone understands quran even a little bit then he cant prove u wrong. u explained this very well thank you. i am irfan ahamad farooquis son. this is also a great example for me to learn quran thank you
We should all keep learning.
Never stop :)
@@AlMosesPhD sukriya bhai mujhe to english nhi aati .mera bete se english lecture smghta hu.
Allah se yahi ilteja hai hum sabhi k liye aasaani faraham karein
Quran ko lafz ba lafz samajhne ki taufique ata farmaye
@@aryaankhan7025 ji insaAllah bhai
Salam Moses. I really enjoy these videos and following along with English subtitles. Have you ever considered creating a translation of the Qu'ran? Except for maybe two or three translations (Leila Ahmed, Dr. Shabbir Ahed, and Edip Yuksel) that make up a small minority of circulating qur'ans, I'd say 99% of Muslims only quranic text is one that supports hitting women, amputating hands for theft, promoting slavery/concubinage etc. I know many young muslims out there would deeply appreciate having an honest and sincere rendition of the Qur'an.
Salam, sorry I am not doing a whole translation.
Rather, I encourage people to do their own thinking.
Salaam
Brother Al Moses, I am eagerly waiting explanation of ayath related to Nikah, Talaq and Inheritance.
Kya apne Salath, Saum, Ibadath, Shukr, Tasbeeh, kufr etc per bhi detail me topic wise lecture series banaye
Jazakallah khair
Salam,
I've talked about tasbeef and kuft off and on. But haven't covered these in great detail. Franky, there is already enough videos/written material on it that I haven't felt the need yet.
Salamun Alaikum dear brother
Can you please explain/interpret ayah 118 of surah tauba.
Sincerely
وَّ عَلَی الثَّلٰثَۃِ الَّذِیۡنَ خُلِّفُوۡا ؕ حَتّٰۤی اِذَا ضَاقَتۡ عَلَیۡہِمُ الۡاَرۡضُ بِمَا رَحُبَتۡ وَ ضَاقَتۡ عَلَیۡہِمۡ اَنۡفُسُہُمۡ وَ ظَنُّوۡۤا اَنۡ لَّا مَلۡجَاَ مِنَ اللّٰہِ اِلَّاۤ اِلَیۡہِ ؕ ثُمَّ تَابَ عَلَیۡہِمۡ لِیَتُوۡبُوۡا ؕ اِنَّ اللّٰہَ ہُوَ التَّوَّابُ الرَّحِیۡمُ ﴿۱۱۸
SA, one day I'll do the whole surah
I have come across the ayah 65:6 where traditional translations mention pregnancy and breastfeeding. how do u connect your interpretation of 65:4 to 65:6? your understanding of the word Nisa doesn't fit with pregnancy or breastfeeding term, does it? Eagerly waiting for your reply
محیض اور اذن ایک مفہوم رکھتے ہیں تو یہ دو الفاظ کیوں استعمال ہو ۓ ہیں
النسا۶ اور رجال مرد اور عورتیں ہیں تو دو الفاظ استعمال کیوں کۓ گۓ ؟
U didn't translate Muheez
Before I thought that the traditional translation was right as my lack of understanding of word almuheez and azan. Thank you for such a logical and academic translation of Quran as it deserves. It makes sense and thank you for helping us understanding the Guidance. Do you happen to have any video on Nikah and Zina? What are these boundries as per Quran's guidance?
Nikah and Talaq are topics I am going to cover inshallah.
Zina is not quite in the 'Quran and Aurat' series so probably some ways off.
@@AlMosesPhD Thanks for a quick reply
Asal masla aaj ka yeh hay k Log Allah ki di hoi apni aqal o shawoor ka istamal nahi kerna chahte .... baz auqat woh kafi had tak Ahadees o rewayaton ki khamyan maan bhi jate hain per jo Quran per Dhool, Matti aur sab se bari cheez ki oos per strong kism ka Zang laga dya gaya hay mangharat transalation aur tafseer ki shakal main laga dya gaya hay jisay remove kerna beshak namumkin nahi bauhat mushkil hay....
Ji han buhat muskhil hay.
Lekin na mumkin nahi jesay apnay kaha
Bhai 1200 1400 saal se agar sab galat bataya hai tu aj islam itna nahi hota agar aap paka prof ayat ke shat with tarjuma konsi ayat kis per utari q utari kya waje se utari aur us ayat ka amal kiya hai paka prof ke shat de saktai ho nahi de dogai mainai bout topic sunai aap ke aap sirf itana gol gumatai ho ye ke kar ke iska matalb ye nahi hai quran mai pan ye nahi bata tai kabi bhi ke ju matlab nahi hai aap ke hisab se wo kis ke liye hai aur q hai tarjumai ke shat takai pata chalai sab ko
@@mohsinfattajiwala6007 @Mohsin Fattajiwala Salam. Har aik ayaat mein multiple terms hain jin ko samjhanay kay lyay aur ayatain chahyain hoti hain.
Yah to hum ghanton baat karain sirf aik aayat pe, ya aik topic pe focus karain.
Mera mashwara aap ko yeh hay ke aap khud parhain: na mujh pe rely karain, na kisi aur pe.
Khud insaaf say aur honesty say parhain, aur apni aqal pe bharosa karain kay woh aapko sahih rastay pe leke jayay gi.
Much much better and logical interpretation...mujhe samjh nahi aata itni saari baatein aurat mard ke jinsi talluq se Quran me kaise insert ki gayi..kya ye mahaz ek ghalti hai ya kuchh intentions ki gadbad thi...kyunki ye aurton ke maamlo par traditional riwaayate is qadar thoosi gayi hai Islam ke naam par aisa lagta to nahi hai ke ye koi mistake thi.
Alhamdulillah
Dear Mossess bhai, how could I learn Arabic?
Watch 'Quran kese samjhain'
almaheedi... if it was menstruation it wouldn't be stated with 'AL'... that is The Menstruation ? Thanks Moses.
Bhai quran to bahut aasan banaya he ye kesi aasani he jo aaj tak kisi ki samajh me nahi aai ap ne phd ki he to ap samjhe he to kiya har insan ko phd karni hogi
Aik purani ghalt cheez ko 'unlearn' karna kisi bhi insan kay lyay asan nahi.
@@AlMosesPhD still the question remains. Because Quran is already saying ki humne isko aasan banaya hai aur aayaten khol khol kar bayan ki hain to phir aaj tak logon ko samjh kyun samjh nahi aaya?
@@superbguy8709 'Zikr' ko yassar kya gaya.
1,200 saal say humarai programming Quranic terms say different hay. That's why yeh mushkil dikhta hay shuro mein
@@superbguy8709 sirprisingly Allah also had no idea that it will be mistranslated for so long and he lets so many muslims read and follow the wrong translations .. surprising .
@@sadiqakhan277 no.
Allah is allamulghuyoob
All knowing he is testing us
He gave free will to mankind.
Its Al-Maheedi. Al suggests something specific. So yes, makes sense, Al-Maheedi.... The Menstruation does not make sense..
So what does this ayat actually means?
Who are these mushrik? And what does it mean to stay away from them for 3 months....what will happen after 3 months?
Give it a go. Read from the page before to see what's the context
@@AlMosesPhD should I check surah 2 context or surah 65 context?
@@khayalie_pulao 65 is a small surah, no harm reading it too.
Just try that without the prejudice of what rijal / zakar /untha / nisaa / mushrik mean and you'll see what is being talked about
Difference between طھر and طیب??
Quran uses them differently.
If you look at the verses, you'll see one of them is dedicated to the qalb/nafs
@@AlMosesPhD means both are not related to nafs ki purity?
@@sarahriaz2069 Tayib are usually good, nice things. Often left to us to interpret acccording to our times.
Thr = Something filtered, cleaned. Often connected with quloob
In one translation,I read alMuheez as " bloodletting or bloodshed by weaker masses". Do you think it is logical here?
I know of that understanding.
But in the context, Nisaa make sense as those mushrikeen just before this ayah.
When God tells us Himself that al-maheez IS azan, that seals the deal for me.
@@AlMosesPhD ok...but what kind of azan?
Does it mean some taunting words or threats?
Anything non-physical--ugly words, taunts, mental pressure, etc.
@@AlMosesPhD How Nisaa here means mushrikeen?
Weaker mushrikeen??
@@sarahriaz2069 because they are lacking in eeman.
You can rewatch the video on 'Rijal / Nisa'
3;186 follow
Dear Musa, I hope that Sura Nisa doesn't mean what we all know, Can you just let me know what is the meaning of this Sura (name)?
Nisa = people who are deficient/late/behind or things that are still to come
Aallahne male aur female may koi fark nahi kiya. Donoka darja same to same hai. Mazhabne ye bimari paida ki hai
Durust, mard aur aurat ka faq nahi
السلام علیکم، چونکہ آپ نے المحیض کا ترجمہ نہیں کیا تو ابھی اس آیت کریمہ پر بات کرنا تھوڑا مشکل ہوگا۔ خیر الفاظ کے معنوں کی بحث میں پڑے بغیر صرف دو چیزوں پر آپ کی توجہ مبذول کرنا چاہتا ہوں۔
۱- جیسا کہ آپ نے کہا المحیض = اذن اور جن النِسا کے اذن چھوڑ دینے میں شک ہو تو تین ماہ کا انتظار۔
۲- اور آپ نے لکھا ہے “ جنھوں نے ابھی تک اذن نہیں دی یا ابھی تک حمل اٹھاۓ ہوۓ ہیں” تو ان کا انتظار شرک کے خاتمے تک کیا جائیگا۔
سوال یہ ہے کہ جس النِسا نے اذن (ذہنی تکلیف) دی ہی نہیں تو ان سے سماجی /بزنس تعلقات کیوں منقطع کیے جائیں؟ کیوں پہلے ان کے اذن دئے جانے کا انتظار اور پھر اس اذن کو ختم کردینے کا انتظار کیا جاۓ؟ کیا یہ لوجیکل انالوجی ہوگی؟
دوسرے یہ کہ سورہ طلاق آیت ۴ کے پہلے جز میں یئسن من المحیض من نسائکم کہا گیا یعنی بقول آپ کے فہم کے اس کا مطلب کچھ یوں ہوگا۔ وہ جن کے ایمان میں کمی ہے ان میں سے جو المحیض = اذن سے دور نہیں ہو پا رہے ہیں (ان کی شرک سے دوری مایوس کن/ناممکن ہے) تو مومنین ان سے فعدتہن ثلثتہ اشہر کر لیں یعنی تین ماہ تعلقات منقطع کر لیں۔ جن کی اسلام میں واپسی سے مکمل مایوسی ہے ان کے ساتھ تین ماہ کا قطع تعلق اور جو المحیض = اذن میں ابھی تک مبتلا نہیں ہوۓ ان کے ساتھ بھی تین ماہ کا قطع تعلق کیا معنی رکھتا ہے؟
Salam,
Aap kay ghor talab comment lay lyay shukrya. Tarjamay kay time pe mujhay mafhoom aur clearly likhna chahyay tha.
1- 3 months un kay lyay jin pe shak ho
2- hukum aaya hay aitzaloo ka. Yeh samaji talaq say zyada shirkya cheezon say dur hatnay ka hay. Samaji talaq us cheez ka hisa ho saktay hain, lekin mein cheez nahi. Lehaza, hatta kay woh eeman mein kamzor log jinhon nay azan nahi dya, unsay shirkya cheezeon mein aitzaal karo.
3- nisaa-kum kaha gaya hay surah talaq mein. Agar aap surah baqarah mein 221 dekhain to wahan 'nikah' ki baat ki gayi hay 'nisa' say (woh jo eeman mein peechay hain). Nikah kay baad ye nissaakum hain.t
Hopefully, thori clarification ab ap ko mili ho gi.
@@AlMosesPhD اگر آپ سورہ طلاق کی آیت چار کا مکمل ترجمہ یا فہم بتا سکیں تو سمجھنا شاید آسان ہو سکے۔ جزاک اللہ
@@UbaidSalfi mein surah talaq inshallah puri cover karun ga jab talaq ka topic shuroo hoga.
Tarjma kay bajayay apna mafhum share karun ga, kyon ke--jese ke apko idea hay--complete 100% tarjama mumkin nahi
Please explain pronouns in these words "تقربوهُنَّ، يطهُرنَ and تطهَّرنَ"
Depends on the aayat's context
@@AlMosesPhD
2:222
@@AlMosesPhD
Al-Baqarah 2:222
وَيَسۡـَٔلُونَكَ عَنِ ٱلۡمَحِيضِۖ قُلۡ هُوَ أَذًى فَٱعۡتَزِلُواْ ٱلنِّسَآءَ فِى ٱلۡمَحِيضِۖ وَلَا تَقۡرَبُوهُنَّ حَتَّىٰ يَطۡهُرۡنَۖ فَإِذَا تَطَهَّرۡنَ فَأۡتُوهُنَّ مِنۡ حَيۡثُ أَمَرَكُمُ ٱللَّهُۚ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ يُحِبُّ ٱلتَّوَّٰبِينَ وَيُحِبُّ ٱلۡمُتَطَهِّرِينَ
@@shamoodafatimashams5940 kya isi vid mein answer nahi
@@AlMosesPhD
Sir aapne al nisa ka tarjuma “females” nahi kiya kyunki tawwabeen orr mutatahhireen mein zamair masculine istemal hua hai lekin “walaa taqraboohunna hattaa yathurna fa izaa tatahharna fatoohunna “ mein zamair feminine kyun istemal huay hn” Ye explain kijye sir
Mere bhai ye mere khula challange hay tamam muslims ko k koi bhi ek aisa muslim insan (jo khud ko musalman kehta ho chahe woh kisi bhi sect se taluq rakhta ho) bashart k woh aqal o shawoor rakhta ho inkar nahi kersakta k oos k dimagh main question na uthti hon aur wo oos ka jawab na chahta ho un tamam Ahadees/Rewayaton aur un hi Ahadees/Rewayaton ki madad se jo Quran ki translation aur tafseer ki gai hay oos k against .... sab k dimagh main sawalaat aatay hain per yeh soch ker insan khud ko akser rok leta hay k log kya kahenge pagal kahenge, bura man jayenge, akser so called ulma movli dra dete hain sath hi daant bhi dete hain aur sath sath logon ki tanqeeden bhi sunne ko mil jati hain k pagal hogaya bhatak gaya hay yeh is ka dimagh phir gaya murtid ho jaoge deen-e-islam se nikal jaoge bla bla .. dekho yeh khud se Quran perhne aur samajhne ki koshsih ker raha hay jabhi ye aisi behki behki baatain ker raha hay ... falan banday ne aisa kya to dekho aaj woh murtid ya kaafir ban gaya etc ... phir oos k gher walay plus khandan walay society walay alag tanqeed ka nishana banate hain ..... in sab k sath sath sometime banda yeh keh ker bhi un sawalat se khud ba khud jan chura leta hay k aray choro ye sab zehan ka fatoor hay shetani was wasa hay werna yeh sab to humaray baap dada aur Allah k Rasool aur Sahaba k daur se chalay arahe hain etc.
Conclusion yahi hay k sawalat har aqal mand insan k dimagh main paida hote hain per aksariat insan un sawalat se khud mou pher leta hay .... Per Alhamdulillah maine un tamam sawalat beshak har kisi se share nahi kya per oosay apnay dil o dimagh main zinda zeroor rakha aur Alhamdulillah un k jawabat aaj milte ja rahe hain.
Salam,
Hum sab ko Aqal use karnay ka hukam Khuda nay dya.
Jab insan aqal use karta hay, to sawal buhat hotay hain, jawab kam.
Agar insan sochna chor day, to jawab 0 hotay hain, lekein sawal phir bhi atay rehtay hain.
Keep thinking.
Arsad alam bhai. Moses bhai ko khali itana bolo pora quran tarjhuma kar ke bata de konsi ayat kiske liye utri hai aur q allha nai utari hai. Ye sirf itana bata tai hai quran mai iska matalab ye nahi. Ye nahi walai ka pora tarjuma kabhi nahi bata tai takai pata chalai ke ye ayat kisliye utri hai
@@mohsinfattajiwala6007 Salam. Har aik ayaat mein multiple terms hain jin ko samjhanay kay lyay aur ayatain chahyain hoti hain.
Yah to hum ghanton baat karain sirf aik aayat pe, ya aik topic pe focus karain.
Mera mashwara aap ko yeh hay ke aap khud parhain: na mujh pe rely karain, na kisi aur pe.
Khud insaaf say aur honesty say parhain, aur apni aqal pe bharosa karain kay woh aapko sahih rastay pe leke jayay gi.
@@mohsinfattajiwala6007 mere pyare Bhai mujhe aap k bachkana sawalat per hansi arahi hay Jo k wahi jhooti rewayat pasandon k sawalat aur soch se 100% relate Ker Raha hay .... Jaise jahil rewat Pasand jhootay Molvi fermate Hain k Hazrat Umer R.A k aitraz per sur woh aitraz aurton ka gher se akele Baher mikalnay per tha woh bhi masakid Jane k lye ziada ter ... Umer k oos aitraz per nauzbillah Allah ko hosh Aya aray is ka to Maine ab tak solution hi nahi dya main Allah ho Ker Bhool gaya tha ek Kafir se Musalman hone wala basher ne mujhe yaad dilaya baray bharam k sath ... Allah maaf karay aisa hi mafhoom banta hay oos Ghaleez Riwayat se .... Aur phir Un molviyon aur aap jaison k Allah ne jaldi se parday ki ayat aurton k lye nazil Ker di .... Jab k Quran ka Allah sari qul kainat ka Allah Kuch nahi bhoolta oosay kisi k mashweray ya remind karane ki zeroorat nahi ... Mere pyare Bhai pehle riwayaton ko aur rewayat Pasand molvion ki jhooti aur Gandi jahilana taleemat ko apnay Ander se Nikal Ker Quran per khud se ghaur o fiker, research means Tadabbur o Tafakkur Karen ... Quran ko Quran ki Roshni main samajhne ki Koshish Karen phir aap ko sab Kuch khud ba khud samajh main ana shuru ho jayega.
Otherwise mere Bhai aap ko Jo behter Lage woh Karen then aap aur Allah k dermyan k maamlat honge .... Per dosron ko disturb Kerne se gurez kijyega
Dear Moses: (الْمَحٖيضِ = اَذًى) in urdu (اَذًى = ایذا = تکلیف) in English (اَذًى = trouble). Secondly
کیا آیت 2/222 کی ترتیل آیت 5-65/4 میں کی جائے گی؟ - کیا اس ہی کو ترتیل کہتے ہیں؟ النساء is a proper noun)
The Quran is a complete guidance.
God had no other way to create a human being except by torturing women by giving her lifelong periods? Shedding of blood is what he choose.? This is his honour and love for women? Monthly pain and grief?
Men lose their hair while women keep theirs. Men suffer more heart attacks and parksinson's than women.
Physical differences between genders even out over time.
@@AlMosesPhD Dear friend i am not saying that why he gave this to women and why didnt gave to men.
I am saying he would have created human beings without torturing women with menstruation. Almighty god who is the most greatest our of our imagination he decided PERIODS for women.? That too every month .. tell me which women in this World is happy with this?She cannot even reject this..
My friend how are u comparing hair problem and heart attack with periods?
U can avoid heart attack u can get your hair back with surgeries.....
@@rubina5079 Hmm. I am not trivializing periods. Merely pointing out that there are a lot of medical papers out there that compare physiological/psychological makeups of men and women, and suggest that despite 'periods' women are not overall worse off than men.
It leads to the real question. Why are some born with certain gifts versus others and the fariness in that.
@@AlMosesPhD i dont know from where men came in between. My question was something else..
But its okay..
My question was how come a God who claims he is merciful, most intelligent, most loving (etc) can GIVE such THINGS.... What we see from our eyes is something else than what is been written by human BEINGS in holy books about their god/. . I know the holy books doesn't answer such questions..
Anyways... Thank you for replying to my comment 👍
@@rubina5079 That is a very good question.
And I'll get around to it one day inshallah.
Ap qadyani ho ya nhi or agr nhi to apka kya moaqiff h qadiyaniyo pe
Ummat ko jodne k kam krey na k todne...sory to say
Please save ourselves from the Sectarian mindset coz you are advised to keep away from those who divide into Sects.
Check this verse:
//Quran 6.159
Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - you are not with them in anything.
Their affair is only [left] to Allāh; then He will inform them about what they used to do.//
Im not a blind hadees follower but I still find conventional translation of these verses for the most part..
Firstly I don't think its a big deal if topics like menstruation or sex are mentioned in quran..like we shouldn't approach the Quran with such a mindset that omG how can God talk about such stuff, these words MUST mean something else...may be they're tabooed or shame is attached to them in our culture but honestly these are normal and natural phenomenons.
secondly, how I understand the conventional translation is: they ask about menstruation, tell them its a painful condition. so refrain from sexually approaching those women in such a painful condition, and approach them as has God commanded you when they have cleansed themselves. you asked, where do we find how God has instructed to approach our spouse , my understanding is that there are various instances in Quran where God commands us to deal with our spouse with dignity, gentleness , goodness ...perhaps those are the principles we must keep in mind.. God loves those who purify themselves.. why its masucline? perhaps masculine plural nouns include both male and female and what could mean is that menstruation is an unhygienic condition for women and men must also keep themselves clean by not approach them in that condition..
my understanding is that its not women who are being condemned for being unclean, its simply the process of menstruation where a human is literally bleeding..
even if a man is bleeding a certain amount of blood his wudhu and roza is considered makruh as well..
Doing pieces of an ayat and combining with an other to from some thing different trying to say Allah doesn’t know how the verse should have revealed
Another
Abrahamic Locution person
Hmm.
Quran ka hukm hay ke us pe tafakkur aur tartil say parho.
Is cheez ko maana ya na maana har kisi ki apni marzi hay.
@@AlMosesPhD
Nothing wrong with tafakkur
Got to stay within the verse
Can get all the references but can’t dissect and patch
It's alright.
I see clear links but other can choose to use another methodology.
آدھ گھنٹہ ضائع کرنے سے بھی بات سمجھ نہیں آئی ۔۔
غامدی صاحب بھی اسی طرح اپنی عقل کے گھوڑے دوڈاتے ھیں۔۔
ھر بندہ اپنی عقل کے مطابق الفاظ کے معنی بنا لیتا ھے۔۔