Hey Pente Patrol, I absolutely ❤️ your videos, and how your able to come up with all of these amazing and unexpected stories!! I really enjoyed this what if, and can’t wait to see what you have planned next! 😁
Palpatine: It's over Yoda, I have the high ground. Yoda: Then even the ground, I will. Palpatine screaming: DAMN YOU VADER, WHY DIDN'T YOU THINK OF DOING THAT INSTEAD OF OVERESTIMATING YOUR POWER!!!!!!! Yoda: And that is why a member of the Jedi High Council, he is not.
Imagine instead of palp saving anakin on the lava bank, Maul finds him. Gives Anakin better robotic limbs and those 2 join together due to their joint hatred for Obi Wan and plan to ambush him together later on 👀
What if the droids on Grievous's ship in the beginning of Revenge of Sith accidentally self-destruction the ship while Dooku, Palpatine, and Grievous on it?
What if suggestions. 1) What if Wullf Yularen joined the rebellion by forming his own rebel cell with clone war era ships, vehicles and clones who defected from the empire like Captain Howzer 2) What if Tarkin evacuated the Death Star and survive A New Hope 3) What if Admiral Ozzel didn’t come out for hyperspeed to close to Hoth 4) What if Project War-mantle failed and the empire continued using the Jango clone 5) What if Ashoka along with the clones fought Krell on Umbara 6) What if Clone trooper Denal killed Cad Bane
I never got how Admiral Yularen went from that to Col. Yularen ISB. It made no sense to me. I can understand how the war was bad and it bothered him, but old war horses retire with their scars and grandchildren. They don’t go full jackbooted thug pig.
I don't think that Anakin would continue to fight after feeling the death of Palpatine, because at that point he would no longer have a reason to fight. The whole reason why Anakin turned to the Dark Side is because he believed that Palpatine could save Padme from dying in childbirth, and because he felt the Jedi had betrayed him. With Palpatine's death, Anakin's rage would have turned to despair, the despair of a man who's had everything taken away from him.
Impossible. (Canon wise) Sidious was controlling Anakins point of view. He knew his heart would more point to Padmé than the Jedi or the inevitable purge. Kept him looking in the one direction with constant "visions of her death" which Sidious would have to ensure happens to gain his loyal lapdog Darth Vader.
Palpatine: " Execute order ... one moment commander I am receiving another transmissions " Windu : hello chancellor would you answer a question for me what comes after 64 ? Palatine: 65 ?... G.A.R : KNOCK KNOCK CHANCELLOR ! Now thats something I'd like to see you tackle .
What if the Jedi allowed attachments. You can either do this in the past and make it still present now, or start it in current times, maybe as a result of Anakin coming to the temple later in life…
@@WatcherCCGnot really grey knights, more so just a better Jedi order based on having a greater balance and serving the people of the galaxy rather than the senate. Dooku’s main motivations for breaking with the order was their closed off nature to new ideas and bender new to the senate. If dooku left he’d probably focus on creating a balanced order where the main goals would be serving the people of the galaxy and creating responsible force users with a basic understanding of the dark side and how to counter its influence. Small exposure to the dark side in controlled exercises would probably become common for younglings and would better train them as they became Padawans and knights. Dooku would also probably get rid of the separation between the service corps and knights as the old order regulated the service corps for padawan washouts and disgraced Jedi giving it a bad reputation among the knights as a sort of penal force removed from the real glory of the knights. Dooku would seek a more balanced order where every knight would have a basic knowledge of healing, helping crops grow, and aiding civilians with the force on top of their combat skills. The entire padawan-master system would also likely be reformed to prevent padawans from washing out and turning to the dark side or becoming criminals. Jedi would be consistently and rigorously trained in clans until they were deemed ready to go on missions as padawans under knights and masters assigned to them by a council based on force connection and their own interests, allowing for more great knights like obi wan and dooku to appear that just barely avoided reassignment or expulsion. The clone war would probably still happen and I could imagine dooku either avoiding the conflict entirely, or he would take a prominent position in the CIS as the leader of his own order and a separatist politician separate from palpatine. Dooku not being a sith might actually draw a lot of Jedi to his own order over time that may object to the war and disapprove of the Jedi’s political affiliations. I still think palpatine would do some trolling but dooku’s main goals would be either to stay out of the war or lead the CIS to actually overcome the republic to establish a more balanced and sustainable galaxy.
Please do what if dooku killed obi wan on geonosis. I think it would be really interesting. I love how detailed the stories are and how you get pretty much straight to the story. Keep it up
Yes, my friend. This is the best video you've created so far. IF only YODA had actually managed to defeat the Emperor in the actual movie, becuase your version of the story should have been the properly appropriate ending and thus the latter revolving around Imperial leaders ought to have been the focus of the original trilogy.
The problem with Tarkin is that he really was a bad leader in so many ways, the Empire would not have faired well, the Senate would not take well to Tarkin. There were LOTS of plots against Sidious' life, which he defeated via the force, Tarkin could not have done that, and it would have fallen apart quickly.
Shaak Ti's death was confirmed in an episode in season six of the Clone wars. Yoda saw in a vision Shaak Ti stabbed in the back. This death scene originally was supposed to be done by Grievous on his flagship but instead is supposed to be done by Anakin in the Jedi temple either way there's to many legend death scenes for her besides the Canon one to assume there's any possibility she'd be alive.
Ok, This one is going to be amazing, I just know it My ideas… What if Ezra Bridger joined Darth Maul? What if Kanan Jarrus ( Caleb Dume ) somehow survived past the Rebels TV show? What if Feral ( I think that’s his name from the clone Wars ) was chosen by Asajj Ventress instead of Savage Opress? Would he be stronger then Savage, or weaker? What if Depa Billaba survived Order 66 and trained Ezra with Kanan? What if Maul killed Sidious before the Phantom Menace? ( I believe in Legends, Mauls final test was to survive on a planet alone in the wilderness for like a month with no supplies, while being chased by assassin droids… when Maul barely Survived, Sidious taunted him into a fight by saying he was pathetic and unworthy of being a Sith Lord, and Maul in a fit of pure Rage, almost killed Sidious)
Great theory crafting, I'd suggest you consider Grand Admiral Thrawn returning and causing a civil war between his fleet and Tarkins while the Jedi regroup.
What if Depa trained Anakin? what if Master Arca trained Anakin? What if Anakin took Galen Marek as a Padawan, after Ahsoka's departure? What if Revan trained Starkiller? What if Shaak Ti trained Starkiller? What if Obi-Wan & Luminara fell in love? What if Galen Marek & Barriss Offee grew up together, and fell in love? what if Shaak Ti was the Chosen One? What if Barriss was the Chosen One? What if Depa was the Chosen One? What if Galen, Revan & Anakin were brothers? What if Revan & Meetra's Ebon Hawk crews showed up during the clone wars? What if the entire clone army removed their chips, and refused to execute Order 66? What if Ezra met Starkiller on Malachor? What if Galen Marek blew up the Death Star? What if Revan became Mand'alor? What if Senator Chuchi was the Dark Lord of the Sith? What if Vitiate was still alive during the clone wars era? What if Shaak Ti went to investigate Kamino with Obi-Wan, during Attack of the clones? What if Galen Marek fought alongside Revan, on both sides of the Jedi Civil War? What if Maul fell in love with Adi Gallia? What if Obi-Wan met the Bad Batch and Omega during Attack of the clones? what if Ezra Bridger & Sabine Wren fell in love? What if Ahsoka killed The Son, instead of giving him the dagger? What if the Son turned Obi-Wan & Anakin to the dark side at the same time as he did Ahsoka? What if Anakin was split in two like Revan was? What if Depa survived order 66 as well as her Padawan? What if Plo Koon & Shaak Ti fell in love?
-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies?(In the same vain of the Darth JarJar fic you did.) -What if The Rule of Two was abolished after the Clone Wars? -What if the Sith Empire returned during the Galactic Civil War instead of the Clone Wars? -What if Vader lived at the end of RotJ, not redeemed and in charge of the Imperial Remnant? -What if Anakin saved Mace Windu and stayed in the light during Order 66? -What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy? -What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic? -What if Maul was found by the Jedi before Sidious? -What if Vader,Thrawn and Several Imperials started an Imperial Rebellion separate from the Rebels,which really took off around the DS1 destruction? -What if Vader never burned on Mustafar? -What if Grevious was a Republic General but still hated the Jedi? -What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 and later trained the Skywalker Twins? -What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc, basically replacing Vader?
-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies?(In the same vain of the Darth JarJar fic you did.) This could be awesome, but it would also be rather long, I suspect. It's even pretty easy to do, as ignoring Echoes of Oblivion isn't hard, since it was hot garbage! :D
What if the Jedi WERE evil and the Sith were GOOD, like anakin was brought as a kid and really didn’t know a lot about them and those who were raised as Jedi would’ve already been indoctrinated, so the idea is that the sith had to use some extreme methods to fight as they kept getting wiped out and the REALLY BAD things were actually done by the Jedi but framed the sith and anakin really only stared to figure things out as he was brought in later than the others
Look at Yoda,look at Palpatine...Remember how Yoda spoke about the Dark Side...I am convinced there's a possibility that Yoda explored the Dark Side and it withered him physically ,however Yoda was able to come back to the light.i think Yoda's master showed him how using the planet they were on that was saturated with the force..like an anchor..Yoda wasn't just speaking about Darth and others who went to the Dark Side..this is why Yoda was so revered and respected and why his position on the council
This is amazing! Where is Disney and Lucasfilm? They need to hire you PRONTO so you can write up their next "What - If" Series based in the Star Wars universe. I'm telling ya, this video of yours and others you've made should be used as the basis for an entire TV series of what if Star Wars scenarios! The Fans would eat it up!!
Grievous DIDN’T know, the only reason he didn’t kill Palpatine was because Dooku told him not too on Sidious orders, Grievous saw this as stupid but knew better than to question Dooku and even more so Sidious.
this is why i wish the originals werent the originals, then we could have it be like this instead. im still waiting for them to do a what if starwars series
Yoda: Die you must, creepy incest kissing and green space walrus milking It shall prevent. Palpatine: None of what you are saying makes any se- (Palpatine peers into the future, all becomes clear.) Light saber nunchucks.... Yoda: Indeed. Palpatine: Give me the saber....
Sorry I was unable to see the video when it drop. *Inconveniences events* forced me to miss this beauty when it came out but I'm back now, babes, and could finally watch this amazing video.
Hey PPSW! Thank you for always pumping out content like this, it's always interesting listening to these what if scenarios whenever I'm bored or doing work :> Here's a suggestion too, albeit a farfetched one: What If Cal Kestis somehow defeated/killed Darth Vader at the end of Fallen Order? It'd be interesting to see how you tackle this one if possible :]
I want this to be a new movie series. I want to see your creativity into how this would play out. New foes, maybe a chiss empire? It can be taken so many ways. I want to see you continue this with Obi-Wan teaching Luke and Leia, with the guidance of Yoda over them and how they would adapt to a new galactic situation like this.
I like the videos you made on how any other master training obi wan leads to Anakin not turning to the dark side. However, I'd like to see some videos of other masters training him and things somehow ended up much worse for the galaxy.
18:33 My hopes were too high I thought Anakin was about to go beast mode in trying to save his own life but I guess not, but honestly a video like that he can really do is what is Anakin was able to defeat Obi-Wan
What if the emperor told Luke he was his grandfather? What if lei and Luke dated? What if Chewbacca farted while they played the board game in new hope?
"Underground Office" *Looks over Palpy's shoulder to all the building towers outside the window.* Erm... you sure about that? It's under the Senate floor sure, but I don't think it's underground. :)
Hey Pente, you've mentioned before you don't have alot of knowledge about star wars legends, I read a few books myself back in the day, I only remember the stories I loved. I've noticed you also use only the movies and shows as cannon guides for your what ifs, you should add to your team people with knowledge of the cannon novels like Queen's peril which goes into Padme's shadows Sabe and other hand maidens and Leia princess of alderean which goes into Leia's introduction to the rebel alliance (especially Mon Motha) there are more novels and other media who have some interesting characters like Dr aphra and others, I WOULD LOVE TO SEE WHAT YOU COULD DO WITH NEW CHARACTERS AND NEW STORY LINES. Please give it some thought
What if Anakin Skywalker fell in love with Ahsoka Tano What if starkiller survived What if luke and leia were both raised on alderann What if luke and leia could communicate through the force as children What if padme was a jedi What if obi wan and Satine had a child
Lmao, not the 1st one 😂 Although I believe the only Galen Marek ( Starkiller ) video I’ve seen on his channel was “ What if Mace Windu Trained Galen Marek “ I think Starkiller is either the Dark Side option of the Unleashed games, or I believe maybe Darth Starkiller?
All I’m going to say if maul survived being cut in half, sustained by his hatred of obi wan, I think anakin could do the same. Other than that, interesting take.
Yoda fought from the heart which attracted positive force energy to Yoda...each one knowing their enemy when you know what lengths love and hate will go to... the battle is a deadlocke.
I cannot believe I just sat here and listened to you basically narrate what happened in the movie from 11:40-16:30. I thought there'd be a different take. For anyone reading this, I'm sure you've watched the movie, just skip ahead.
What if the CIS leaders killed Anakin and kept the droid factories open ? What if vader and anakin were two different people ? What if Obi wan hired Hondo instead of Han to get him to Alderan?
The most logical ending for this story would be for Yoda and Obi-Wan to go to Tython like the Mandalorian and Grogu did. Then their call to other Jedi would be answered by Quinlan Vos, who along with masters Tholme and T'ra Saa, were hiding on Kashyyyk. Also masters K'kruhk and Zao who met up after Order 66 and with whom now guarded a whole group of Jedi younglings K'kruhk had helped save after Master Jeisels sacrifice. This would allow for them to restart the order with the now seven masters training the younglings. Besides them there also Coleman Kcaj, Jocasta Nu, Tera Sinube, Dass Jennir, Kai Hudorra, and even maybe Eeth Koth and Ahsoka who could show up. In fact, Master Gira would be able to bring the group of younglings he saved as well since with Vader gone him and the younglings would never be found by the Empire. This would bring their numbers from anywhere from thirty to sixty members.
Wouldn't Thrawn have stepped in? *What if* Thrawn found Anakin and took over the empire? *What if* Yoda was so hurt by the death of the order that he turned to the dark side and went on a rampage? Perhaps Kenobi would flee with the twins and they would one day come back to fight him?
Here are my ideas. 1. What if Zam Wessel killed the Real Padme instead of a decoy? 2. What if Anakin and Padme broke up after he beat up Rush Clovis? 3. What if Obi-wan never followed Padme to Mustafar?
Tbh I know that obi won did that in cannon but I’ve always thought despite what anikin did he shouldn’t have been left to burn like that I wouldn’t leave my worsed enemy to die like that ether kill him quickly or pull him out let him stand trial or maybe in his case sit trial seeing as he had no arms or legs lol
About the Cal Kestis idea… I think Cal was 12-13 during Order 66, ( which is the age that most young kings become Padawans ) so would Obi-Wan train him AFTER order 66 on Tatooine, or would Cal maybe find him along with Cere and Greez?
Ok I really appreciate the time and effort that you put into this but major hole in your story is if Palatine died there would’ve another election and I don’t think that the senate would easily allow Tarkin to take his place. Tarkin may have been familiar with Palatine but not the senate which still had power.
“What If” - What if Ashoka travels through the World Between Worlds, grabs Anakin & returns him into the Portal to show Anakin he becomes Vader so Anakin enters the portal an Duels himself Anakin v Vader…I need this - in Return of The Jedi when Luke removed Vader’s helmet Leia was also Present to see her father.
Legends’da Darth Plagueis bile üniversite öğrencisi olan Palpatine’in güçteki varlığını hissedemiyor bilerek hissetmeye çalıştığı halde. Yani Palpatine istemeden bile sith olmadan önce bunu yapma yeteneği doğal olarak var. Daha sonrasında Force Mask ve Force Cloud tekniklerini öğrenince tamamen ustalaşıyor.
A good what if. During Star Wars A New Hope Motti was trying to convince Tarking to take over the Death Star and challenge Palpatine. What if the Death Star destroyed the rebel base and survived and Tarkin did indeed challenge Palpatine. Two paths - if Tarkin knew where Palpatine was, it is possible he could just show up and destroy the planet OR he could try to challenge Palpatine who would then force choke Tarkin. But what of Vader?
What if Anakin was picked up on on his home world by a mandalorian or duchess Satine instead not because hes the chosen one but that hes a smart kid has grit and amazing instincts how would he be as a madadlrian and what would his interactions with obi one be like when he see not just duchess satine but a young mandalorian with a powerful presents in the force and would ankin get the dark saber. Please make a what if have to know what could happen
Hey I Really liked the video but I feel like you forgot about the inquisitors, I know there wouldn't have been many of them but the grand inquisitor turned on the other jedi during order 66 at the temple, I feel like he might have either join tarkin or tried to become emperor himself, just a thought.
I respect the commentary at the end. You didn’t just do a big fight and end it there. It’s way more interesting and more integral to real Star Wars to have the politics so involved in the story.
I always laugh at how people try to justify Kenobi just letting Anakin burn to death as compassion or something.. "He looked down and all he saw was the little boy he trained." .. So instead of finishing it or outright helping him, he chose the worst option: just let him lay there in horrible pain and eventually die from his severe burns. Good one, Obi-Wan. 👌
Hard to tell how the aftermath would play out, but at the very least, with Palpatine dead, no one would come o save Anakin, thus he'd die anyway on Mustafar. The Sith would finally be defeated, but the Jedi would be devastated. With Order 66 still active in the Clones it would still be unsafe for the Jedi t reassemble. But the story would simply go on to be about whether the Empire still continues or if the Senate decoded to restore the Republic, either way the galaxy will be in chaos for a bit as it's galactic leaders try to sort out what to do next. The thing I love about Revenge of the Sith what ifs is that so much change happens in the span of the film over just a few days, so much that a change to any of it could spawn very interesting ideas of how alternate events play out. Such as Anakin not turning dueling the film means Order 66 and the final duels are different, killing Palpatine at a certain point can change so much. It's why EP 3 is one of my favorite Star Wars films, I consider it the middle film as it's this film's events where much of the shape of the future rides upon, so much change that the OT era is considered to happen after Ep 3.
Let's just say order 66 would have never been issued, & all of those cute little Jedi padawans will continue to live a happy life being adorable in every way.
Since Windu and Yoda were able to defeat Sidious in a lightsaber duel, is it safe to say that Dooku is also able to defeat him strictly in a lightsaber duel?
No… yoda didn’t defeat him, and windu only won because his form utilized sidious rage and compounded his strength, dooku may have been the better duelist but it’s also believed he let windu win so anakin would fall to the dark. I’d say dooku would be very closely matched to sidious but might lose still, palpatine has every form mastered and is incredibly fast with sith speed as well
@@somethingsomething2100 wrong, both Yoda and Windu defeated Sidious in a lightsaber duel. Yoda disarmed him, that's why he resorted to using force powers against Yoda. And there's no evidence to suggest that he let Windu win their lightsaber duel. The only evidence that support him of pretending to lose so that Anakin will turn to the darkside is when he was acting to be weaken and close to being killed, which was when he was using force lightening against Windu. A lost due to being lesser in skill, arrogance, or not having the high ground, is still a lost.
Yoda didn't win, the novelisation explicitly states Yoda could have never won against Palpatine. Palpatine merely threw the lightsaber duel because he wanted to toy with Yoda using the true power of the Dark Side, but he could bear him. Mace "won" by exploiting Vapaad, and even then Palpatine let himself be beat because he knew Anakin was coming and that his probable death would be enough to turn him into Vader. Dooku could not win in a lightsaber match against Palpatine. Dooku was not a match to Yoda or Mace, he was the next in line (around the same skill as Obi-Wan, which is nothing to scoff at), but he could never beat Sidious. The only man who could actually beat Sidious in a proper lightsaber duel he didn't throw to use Force Lightning was Anakin/Vader.
Subscribe and Share
What if anakin never burned when obiwan cut him in half and he never lost his arm same video
What if Pong Krell either escaped or killed the 501st and went to join Dooku as he said he would.
You already know what I’m gonna say: what if Vader/Anakin turned back to the light in episode six of Kenobi?!
Hey Pente Patrol, I absolutely ❤️ your videos, and how your able to come up with all of these amazing and unexpected stories!! I really enjoyed this what if, and can’t wait to see what you have planned next! 😁
What if Ashoka was in the Siege of Mandalore with Obi-Wan and Anakin?
Palpatine - it’s over Yoda I have the high ground
Yoda - underestimate my power you have
Palpatine: It's over Yoda, I have the high ground.
Yoda: Then even the ground, I will.
Palpatine screaming: DAMN YOU VADER, WHY DIDN'T YOU THINK OF DOING THAT INSTEAD OF OVERESTIMATING YOUR POWER!!!!!!!
Yoda: And that is why a member of the Jedi High Council, he is not.
@@shawn092182Ah, I get it. HIGH council, HIGH ground! Clever.
@@shawn092182Palpatine: “I have the high ground master Yoda.”
Yoda: fucking floats upwards, “care I do not.”
Imagine instead of palp saving anakin on the lava bank, Maul finds him. Gives Anakin better robotic limbs and those 2 join together due to their joint hatred for Obi Wan and plan to ambush him together later on 👀
such a good idea
What if the droids on Grievous's ship in the beginning of Revenge of Sith accidentally self-destruction the ship while Dooku, Palpatine, and Grievous on it?
space magic, clones, part of humorously elaborate Palpatine plot
@Chunkopops star peace, great idea, terrible Yoko Ono album.
This is desperately needed
Lmao.
Time to abandon ship
What if suggestions.
1) What if Wullf Yularen joined the rebellion by forming his own rebel cell with clone war era ships, vehicles and clones who defected from the empire like Captain Howzer
2) What if Tarkin evacuated the Death Star and survive A New Hope
3) What if Admiral Ozzel didn’t come out for hyperspeed to close to Hoth
4) What if Project War-mantle failed and the empire continued using the Jango clone
5) What if Ashoka along with the clones fought Krell on Umbara
6) What if Clone trooper Denal killed Cad Bane
1st idea is pretty badass
I never got how Admiral Yularen went from that to Col. Yularen ISB. It made no sense to me. I can understand how the war was bad and it bothered him, but old war horses retire with their scars and grandchildren. They don’t go full jackbooted thug pig.
7) hotel? Trivago.
In my current Star Wars Rebels fanfiction Yularen became a rebel in season 4 as a Fulcrum Agent.
@@backtothefutureman1what’s the name of the fanfiction
I don't think that Anakin would continue to fight after feeling the death of Palpatine, because at that point he would no longer have a reason to fight. The whole reason why Anakin turned to the Dark Side is because he believed that Palpatine could save Padme from dying in childbirth, and because he felt the Jedi had betrayed him. With Palpatine's death, Anakin's rage would have turned to despair, the despair of a man who's had everything taken away from him.
He couldn’t interpret what happened, just that some thing happened
What if anakin had vision of order 66 instead of padme dying of childbirth?
This is a topic that is new to me
Impossible. (Canon wise)
Sidious was controlling Anakins point of view. He knew his heart would more point to Padmé than the Jedi or the inevitable purge. Kept him looking in the one direction with constant "visions of her death" which Sidious would have to ensure happens to gain his loyal lapdog Darth Vader.
Literally can't happen
He had visions because that's what Palpatine wanted him to see
The Force is kind of like God. All-powerful, all-knowing, and really, really stupid. 👌
I like the twist with obi wan Kenobi and Yoda being victorious and the Jedi still defeated. Good premise and story flow.
Palpatine: " Execute order ... one moment commander I am receiving another transmissions "
Windu : hello chancellor would you answer a question for me what comes after 64 ?
Palatine: 65 ?...
G.A.R : KNOCK KNOCK CHANCELLOR !
Now thats something I'd like to see you tackle .
What if the Jedi allowed attachments. You can either do this in the past and make it still present now, or start it in current times, maybe as a result of Anakin coming to the temple later in life…
What if Dooku formed his own order after he left instead of falling to the dark side
Any what-if that results in the creation of the Grey Knights is a good scenario to ponder.
@@WatcherCCG no gray knights are stupid
@@jasonskeans3327 why
@@WatcherCCGnot really grey knights, more so just a better Jedi order based on having a greater balance and serving the people of the galaxy rather than the senate. Dooku’s main motivations for breaking with the order was their closed off nature to new ideas and bender new to the senate. If dooku left he’d probably focus on creating a balanced order where the main goals would be serving the people of the galaxy and creating responsible force users with a basic understanding of the dark side and how to counter its influence. Small exposure to the dark side in controlled exercises would probably become common for younglings and would better train them as they became Padawans and knights. Dooku would also probably get rid of the separation between the service corps and knights as the old order regulated the service corps for padawan washouts and disgraced Jedi giving it a bad reputation among the knights as a sort of penal force removed from the real glory of the knights. Dooku would seek a more balanced order where every knight would have a basic knowledge of healing, helping crops grow, and aiding civilians with the force on top of their combat skills. The entire padawan-master system would also likely be reformed to prevent padawans from washing out and turning to the dark side or becoming criminals. Jedi would be consistently and rigorously trained in clans until they were deemed ready to go on missions as padawans under knights and masters assigned to them by a council based on force connection and their own interests, allowing for more great knights like obi wan and dooku to appear that just barely avoided reassignment or expulsion. The clone war would probably still happen and I could imagine dooku either avoiding the conflict entirely, or he would take a prominent position in the CIS as the leader of his own order and a separatist politician separate from palpatine. Dooku not being a sith might actually draw a lot of Jedi to his own order over time that may object to the war and disapprove of the Jedi’s political affiliations. I still think palpatine would do some trolling but dooku’s main goals would be either to stay out of the war or lead the CIS to actually overcome the republic to establish a more balanced and sustainable galaxy.
Please do what if dooku killed obi wan on geonosis. I think it would be really interesting. I love how detailed the stories are and how you get pretty much straight to the story. Keep it up
Yes, my friend. This is the best video you've created so far. IF only YODA had actually managed to defeat the Emperor in the actual movie, becuase your version of the story should have been the properly appropriate ending and thus the latter revolving around Imperial leaders ought to have been the focus of the original trilogy.
The problem with Tarkin is that he really was a bad leader in so many ways, the Empire would not have faired well, the Senate would not take well to Tarkin. There were LOTS of plots against Sidious' life, which he defeated via the force, Tarkin could not have done that, and it would have fallen apart quickly.
Shaak Ti's death was confirmed in an episode in season six of the Clone wars. Yoda saw in a vision Shaak Ti stabbed in the back. This death scene originally was supposed to be done by Grievous on his flagship but instead is supposed to be done by Anakin in the Jedi temple either way there's to many legend death scenes for her besides the Canon one to assume there's any possibility she'd be alive.
Ok, This one is going to be amazing, I just know it
My ideas…
What if Ezra Bridger joined Darth Maul?
What if Kanan Jarrus ( Caleb Dume ) somehow survived past the Rebels TV show?
What if Feral ( I think that’s his name from the clone Wars ) was chosen by Asajj Ventress instead of Savage Opress? Would he be stronger then Savage, or weaker?
What if Depa Billaba survived Order 66 and trained Ezra with Kanan?
What if Maul killed Sidious before the Phantom Menace? ( I believe in Legends, Mauls final test was to survive on a planet alone in the wilderness for like a month with no supplies, while being chased by assassin droids… when Maul barely Survived, Sidious taunted him into a fight by saying he was pathetic and unworthy of being a Sith Lord, and Maul in a fit of pure Rage, almost killed Sidious)
Great theory crafting, I'd suggest you consider Grand Admiral Thrawn returning and causing a civil war between his fleet and Tarkins while the Jedi regroup.
What if Depa trained Anakin?
what if Master Arca trained Anakin?
What if Anakin took Galen Marek as a Padawan, after Ahsoka's departure?
What if Revan trained Starkiller?
What if Shaak Ti trained Starkiller?
What if Obi-Wan & Luminara fell in love?
What if Galen Marek & Barriss Offee grew up together, and fell in love?
what if Shaak Ti was the Chosen One?
What if Barriss was the Chosen One?
What if Depa was the Chosen One?
What if Galen, Revan & Anakin were brothers?
What if Revan & Meetra's Ebon Hawk crews showed up during the clone wars?
What if the entire clone army removed their chips, and refused to execute Order 66?
What if Ezra met Starkiller on Malachor?
What if Galen Marek blew up the Death Star?
What if Revan became Mand'alor?
What if Senator Chuchi was the Dark Lord of the Sith?
What if Vitiate was still alive during the clone wars era?
What if Shaak Ti went to investigate Kamino with Obi-Wan, during Attack of the clones?
What if Galen Marek fought alongside Revan, on both sides of the Jedi Civil War?
What if Maul fell in love with Adi Gallia?
What if Obi-Wan met the Bad Batch and Omega during Attack of the clones?
what if Ezra Bridger & Sabine Wren fell in love?
What if Ahsoka killed The Son, instead of giving him the dagger?
What if the Son turned Obi-Wan & Anakin to the dark side at the same time as he did Ahsoka?
What if Anakin was split in two like Revan was?
What if Depa survived order 66 as well as her Padawan?
What if Plo Koon & Shaak Ti fell in love?
-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies?(In the same vain of the Darth JarJar fic you did.)
-What if The Rule of Two was abolished after the Clone Wars?
-What if the Sith Empire returned during the Galactic Civil War instead of the Clone Wars?
-What if Vader lived at the end of RotJ, not redeemed and in charge of the Imperial Remnant?
-What if Anakin saved Mace Windu and stayed in the light during Order 66?
-What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy?
-What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic?
-What if Maul was found by the Jedi before Sidious?
-What if Vader,Thrawn and Several Imperials started an Imperial Rebellion separate from the Rebels,which really took off around the DS1 destruction?
-What if Vader never burned on Mustafar?
-What if Grevious was a Republic General but still hated the Jedi?
-What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 and later trained the Skywalker Twins?
-What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc, basically replacing Vader?
-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies?(In the same vain of the Darth JarJar fic you did.)
This could be awesome, but it would also be rather long, I suspect. It's even pretty easy to do, as ignoring Echoes of Oblivion isn't hard, since it was hot garbage! :D
If that did happened, then we would know who was truly the most powerful Sith emperor.
"F around you have, find out you will."
What if Quin Lin Vos found out about order 66 when he was infiltrating Dooku’s cobal of dark siders
What if the cut plot line where the droids in Attack of the Clones get phantom menaced happened
What if the Jedi WERE evil and the Sith were GOOD, like anakin was brought as a kid and really didn’t know a lot about them and those who were raised as Jedi would’ve already been indoctrinated, so the idea is that the sith had to use some extreme methods to fight as they kept getting wiped out and the REALLY BAD things were actually done by the Jedi but framed the sith and anakin really only stared to figure things out as he was brought in later than the others
I can get behind a episode on this topic
Look at Yoda,look at Palpatine...Remember how Yoda spoke about the Dark Side...I am convinced there's a possibility that Yoda explored the Dark Side and it withered him physically ,however Yoda was able to come back to the light.i think Yoda's master showed him how using the planet they were on that was saturated with the force..like an anchor..Yoda wasn't just speaking about Darth and others who went to the Dark Side..this is why Yoda was so revered and respected and why his position on the council
What if Anakin fell with Dutchess Satine or Sabe. Also what if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Alayua Secura
This is amazing! Where is Disney and Lucasfilm? They need to hire you PRONTO so you can write up their next "What - If" Series based in the Star Wars universe. I'm telling ya, this video of yours and others you've made should be used as the basis for an entire TV series of what if Star Wars scenarios! The Fans would eat it up!!
Never thought about how it happened
a cool what-if is what if grevious didnt know palpatine was the sith lord and ended up killing him over the battle of courasaunt
Grevious would get a reduced for killing Sidious believing it was the Chancellor
Grievous don't know that palpatin is the sith lord.
Grievous DIDN’T know, the only reason he didn’t kill Palpatine was because Dooku told him not too on Sidious orders, Grievous saw this as stupid but knew better than to question Dooku and even more so Sidious.
this is why i wish the originals werent the originals, then we could have it be like this instead. im still waiting for them to do a what if starwars series
Yoda should rule the galaxy and restore order and then give power back to a reformed Senate
Yoda: Die you must, creepy incest kissing and green space walrus milking It shall prevent.
Palpatine: None of what you are saying makes any se- (Palpatine peers into the future, all becomes clear.) Light saber nunchucks....
Yoda: Indeed.
Palpatine: Give me the saber....
Sorry I was unable to see the video when it drop. *Inconveniences events* forced me to miss this beauty when it came out but I'm back now, babes, and could finally watch this amazing video.
I like this video and Anakin dying alone is sad. Glad to see Tarkin get his never liked the dude. Tarkin is no Palpatine that is for sure
This is gonna be a good one I can't wait
Hey PPSW! Thank you for always pumping out content like this, it's always interesting listening to these what if scenarios whenever I'm bored or doing work :>
Here's a suggestion too, albeit a farfetched one: What If Cal Kestis somehow defeated/killed Darth Vader at the end of Fallen Order? It'd be interesting to see how you tackle this one if possible :]
What if Jolee Bindo told Revan his real identity prior to the Jedi enclave on Dantooine being destroyed/before Malak captured the Ebon Hawk?
What if Order 65 as executed before Palpatine had the chance to execute Order 66?
What if it was after Order 66?
What if old Dahka saw the end of the nightsisters in a vision.
You put so much effort into these
I want this to be a new movie series. I want to see your creativity into how this would play out. New foes, maybe a chiss empire? It can be taken so many ways. I want to see you continue this with Obi-Wan teaching Luke and Leia, with the guidance of Yoda over them and how they would adapt to a new galactic situation like this.
What if Barris targeted the chancellors office to bomb instead of the Jedi temple and killed sidious
That would be a cool what if.
This is a Star Wars story that I can bring myself to like.
To be honest, I truly expected Palpy to come out at the end revealing he faked his death and was manipulating events from behind the scenes.
I like the videos you made on how any other master training obi wan leads to Anakin not turning to the dark side. However, I'd like to see some videos of other masters training him and things somehow ended up much worse for the galaxy.
18:33 My hopes were too high I thought Anakin was about to go beast mode in trying to save his own life but I guess not, but honestly a video like that he can really do is what is Anakin was able to defeat Obi-Wan
Yoda the GOAT! Good job! Also attempt 33 of what if Anakin Skywalker and Galen Marek were rivals and trained together.
What if the emperor told Luke he was his grandfather?
What if lei and Luke dated?
What if Chewbacca farted while they played the board game in new hope?
What kind of what ifs are these.
What if Mace Windu joined Palpatine instead of arresting him?
In the name of the galactic senate of the republic, we wish to join you chancellor.
"Underground Office" *Looks over Palpy's shoulder to all the building towers outside the window.* Erm... you sure about that? It's under the Senate floor sure, but I don't think it's underground. :)
Hey Pente, you've mentioned before you don't have alot of knowledge about star wars legends, I read a few books myself back in the day, I only remember the stories I loved. I've noticed you also use only the movies and shows as cannon guides for your what ifs, you should add to your team people with knowledge of the cannon novels like Queen's peril which goes into Padme's shadows Sabe and other hand maidens and Leia princess of alderean which goes into Leia's introduction to the rebel alliance (especially Mon Motha) there are more novels and other media who have some interesting characters like Dr aphra and others, I WOULD LOVE TO SEE WHAT YOU COULD DO WITH NEW CHARACTERS AND NEW STORY LINES. Please give it some thought
What if Anakin Skywalker fell in love with Ahsoka Tano
What if starkiller survived
What if luke and leia were both raised on alderann
What if luke and leia could communicate through the force as children
What if padme was a jedi
What if obi wan and Satine had a child
They have done most of these you've commented, look them up. They are great video's!
All of them except for the first one. Do not do the first one.
Yeah- not the first one. Just no
Lmao, not the 1st one 😂
Although I believe the only Galen Marek ( Starkiller ) video I’ve seen on his channel was “ What if Mace Windu Trained Galen Marek “
I think Starkiller is either the Dark Side option of the Unleashed games, or I believe maybe Darth Starkiller?
Not the first one
What if Padme didn’t get pregnant from anakin and anakin had no night terrors from her dying in childbirth
One of Your BEST Videos!!! Kudos!!!
All I’m going to say if maul survived being cut in half, sustained by his hatred of obi wan, I think anakin could do the same. Other than that, interesting take.
This would make a GREAT What If alternative reality movie.
Yoda fought from the heart which attracted positive force energy to Yoda...each one knowing their enemy when you know what lengths love and hate will go to... the battle is a deadlocke.
I cannot believe I just sat here and listened to you basically narrate what happened in the movie from 11:40-16:30. I thought there'd be a different take. For anyone reading this, I'm sure you've watched the movie, just skip ahead.
The Thumbnail picture is amazing.
Amazing progress PPSW !
What if the CIS leaders killed Anakin and kept the droid factories open ?
What if vader and anakin were two different people ?
What if Obi wan hired Hondo instead of Han to get him to Alderan?
Mr Pente patrol sir I need to talk to you tomorrow - to thank for this immensely good video and to share my counsel with you. 😬
The most logical ending for this story would be for Yoda and Obi-Wan to go to Tython like the Mandalorian and Grogu did. Then their call to other Jedi would be answered by Quinlan Vos, who along with masters Tholme and T'ra Saa, were hiding on Kashyyyk. Also masters K'kruhk and Zao who met up after Order 66 and with whom now guarded a whole group of Jedi younglings K'kruhk had helped save after Master Jeisels sacrifice. This would allow for them to restart the order with the now seven masters training the younglings. Besides them there also Coleman Kcaj, Jocasta Nu, Tera Sinube, Dass Jennir, Kai Hudorra, and even maybe Eeth Koth and Ahsoka who could show up. In fact, Master Gira would be able to bring the group of younglings he saved as well since with Vader gone him and the younglings would never be found by the Empire. This would bring their numbers from anywhere from thirty to sixty members.
Wouldn't Thrawn have stepped in? *What if* Thrawn found Anakin and took over the empire? *What if* Yoda was so hurt by the death of the order that he turned to the dark side and went on a rampage? Perhaps Kenobi would flee with the twins and they would one day come back to fight him?
Here are my ideas.
1. What if Zam Wessel killed the Real Padme instead of a decoy?
2. What if Anakin and Padme broke up after he beat up Rush Clovis?
3. What if Obi-wan never followed Padme to Mustafar?
you should do one on What if the black wing spread to the galeaxy
"F*ck around you did, find out you will. Yes." (©Grandmaster *Forse Balls* Yoda)
Tbh I know that obi won did that in cannon but I’ve always thought despite what anikin did he shouldn’t have been left to burn like that I wouldn’t leave my worsed enemy to die like that ether kill him quickly or pull him out let him stand trial or maybe in his case sit trial seeing as he had no arms or legs lol
Here's a What If I have never seen requested. What if Qui-Gon was the Sith Lord?
What if Obi wan trained Cal Kestis
What if Ahsoka trained Ezra Bridger, he learns what she learned on her own and from Anakin, a grand adventure
About the Cal Kestis idea… I think Cal was 12-13 during Order 66, ( which is the age that most young kings become Padawans ) so would Obi-Wan train him AFTER order 66 on Tatooine, or would Cal maybe find him along with Cere and Greez?
Either idea could work but I'd say after order 66
Hard to imagine Yoda actually winning a duel with Sidious because of the movies and series
Hat off to you. I really enjoyed that story.
Ok I really appreciate the time and effort that you put into this but major hole in your story is if Palatine died there would’ve another election and I don’t think that the senate would easily allow Tarkin to take his place. Tarkin may have been familiar with Palatine but not the senate which still had power.
I have a good one:
What if Luke Skywalker was born in the Old Republic?
For that to happen you would have to have Anakin Skywalker Born back then also
@@thermslusitania1151 that also exists. Fantasy Folklore made a video about it.
Enchanting music, love it!
“What If”
- What if Ashoka travels through the World Between Worlds, grabs Anakin & returns him into the Portal to show Anakin he becomes Vader so Anakin enters the portal an Duels himself
Anakin v Vader…I need this
- in Return of The Jedi when Luke removed Vader’s helmet Leia was also Present to see her father.
This thumbnail is so good !
Legends’da Darth Plagueis bile üniversite öğrencisi olan Palpatine’in güçteki varlığını hissedemiyor bilerek hissetmeye çalıştığı halde. Yani Palpatine istemeden bile sith olmadan önce bunu yapma yeteneği doğal olarak var. Daha sonrasında Force Mask ve Force Cloud tekniklerini öğrenince tamamen ustalaşıyor.
A good what if. During Star Wars A New Hope Motti was trying to convince Tarking to take over the Death Star and challenge Palpatine. What if the Death Star destroyed the rebel base and survived and Tarkin did indeed challenge Palpatine. Two paths - if Tarkin knew where Palpatine was, it is possible he could just show up and destroy the planet OR he could try to challenge Palpatine who would then force choke Tarkin. But what of Vader?
This would make an Amazing Comic.
What if Anakin was picked up on on his home world by a mandalorian or duchess Satine instead not because hes the chosen one but that hes a smart kid has grit and amazing instincts how would he be as a madadlrian and what would his interactions with obi one be like when he see not just duchess satine but a young mandalorian with a powerful presents in the force and would ankin get the dark saber. Please make a what if have to know what could happen
Hey I Really liked the video but I feel like you forgot about the inquisitors, I know there wouldn't have been many of them but the grand inquisitor turned on the other jedi during order 66 at the temple, I feel like he might have either join tarkin or tried to become emperor himself, just a thought.
What if Yoda And Sidious both tried to convert each other to the light or the dark?
You should do the same story this story but with what if Anakin turned back to the light with Yoda and Obi-Wan killing sidious
Yoda tapped into the dark side of the force and used a forbidden technique, Shun Goku Satsu
I respect the commentary at the end. You didn’t just do a big fight and end it there. It’s way more interesting and more integral to real Star Wars to have the politics so involved in the story.
Greetings emperor. Here to chew bubblegum and kick ass I am, &bubble gum I am all out of.
What is Anakin dipped Lucifer, and said, nope screw that and just dipped like leaving Obi-Wan behind maybe just robbing Padme the process and
The 501st was off world subjecting still loyal separatist planets
30 sec later he didn't want to sluater the 501st
Which actully happened
What if jar jar knocked over one off palpatines vases in front of the Jedi and it revealed palpatines lightsaber.
Wonder what’ll happen to Vader/Anakin. This’ll be good.
Jeez bro, ya had me at first when ya described how Yoda was feeling and then ya kept saying the same thing for several minutes
I always laugh at how people try to justify Kenobi just letting Anakin burn to death as compassion or something.. "He looked down and all he saw was the little boy he trained." .. So instead of finishing it or outright helping him, he chose the worst option: just let him lay there in horrible pain and eventually die from his severe burns.
Good one, Obi-Wan. 👌
What if the Federation and the Alpha quadrant came into contact with the empire at its height during the Dominion war? Crossover!
Hard to tell how the aftermath would play out, but at the very least, with Palpatine dead, no one would come o save Anakin, thus he'd die anyway on Mustafar. The Sith would finally be defeated, but the Jedi would be devastated. With Order 66 still active in the Clones it would still be unsafe for the Jedi t reassemble. But the story would simply go on to be about whether the Empire still continues or if the Senate decoded to restore the Republic, either way the galaxy will be in chaos for a bit as it's galactic leaders try to sort out what to do next. The thing I love about Revenge of the Sith what ifs is that so much change happens in the span of the film over just a few days, so much that a change to any of it could spawn very interesting ideas of how alternate events play out. Such as Anakin not turning dueling the film means Order 66 and the final duels are different, killing Palpatine at a certain point can change so much. It's why EP 3 is one of my favorite Star Wars films, I consider it the middle film as it's this film's events where much of the shape of the future rides upon, so much change that the OT era is considered to happen after Ep 3.
i want a star wars what if movies like this much better then some of the things they have done
Let's just say order 66 would have never been issued, & all of those cute little Jedi padawans will continue to live a happy life being adorable in every way.
43: what if master FAY trained Anakin Skywalker
Masso2010 I toke your coment
Your coment is mine
What If the Giant Neebrays Attacked The Malevolence?
Since Windu and Yoda were able to defeat Sidious in a lightsaber duel, is it safe to say that Dooku is also able to defeat him strictly in a lightsaber duel?
No… yoda didn’t defeat him, and windu only won because his form utilized sidious rage and compounded his strength, dooku may have been the better duelist but it’s also believed he let windu win so anakin would fall to the dark. I’d say dooku would be very closely matched to sidious but might lose still, palpatine has every form mastered and is incredibly fast with sith speed as well
@@somethingsomething2100 wrong, both Yoda and Windu defeated Sidious in a lightsaber duel. Yoda disarmed him, that's why he resorted to using force powers against Yoda. And there's no evidence to suggest that he let Windu win their lightsaber duel. The only evidence that support him of pretending to lose so that Anakin will turn to the darkside is when he was acting to be weaken and close to being killed, which was when he was using force lightening against Windu. A lost due to being lesser in skill, arrogance, or not having the high ground, is still a lost.
@@shawn092182 George Lucas himself said mace won fair and square, and we all saw Yoda disarm palps.
Yoda didn't win, the novelisation explicitly states Yoda could have never won against Palpatine. Palpatine merely threw the lightsaber duel because he wanted to toy with Yoda using the true power of the Dark Side, but he could bear him. Mace "won" by exploiting Vapaad, and even then Palpatine let himself be beat because he knew Anakin was coming and that his probable death would be enough to turn him into Vader.
Dooku could not win in a lightsaber match against Palpatine. Dooku was not a match to Yoda or Mace, he was the next in line (around the same skill as Obi-Wan, which is nothing to scoff at), but he could never beat Sidious. The only man who could actually beat Sidious in a proper lightsaber duel he didn't throw to use Force Lightning was Anakin/Vader.
@@tragedyplustime8271 No, that's not what the novelization states.
Hi if possible in the future could you pls add a story about the clones because i notice clones dont often play an important role