@@o.k.3485 Yes it may be that yes .. But it shows that it does not require it. As one professional said, autotune is not a bad thing if it is used simply to make the voice sound clearer, but when the singer really has a vocal quality. But when the autotune is the one that does the job of transmitting a good voice but you don't have vocal quality, then that's different. Here you can see that yes, maybe she did use it, but very little, besides, you can see that she is singing completely there ... And you can see that she has vocal quality ... She simply used the autotune to give a little more clarity to the voice .. And the background to give it effect, but there you can see his voice
I can see why RM worked on this collaboration with Younha. She sang so effortlessly. BX and RM have their own ways of rapping, which made me enjoy the performance. I love this song. It's beautiful, especially the intro part. 😍
I guess because the song is a newer one. I'm assuming that it will become an OST, just the amount of time that it came out in. I wouldn't know much, but 5 months is not nearly enough time for a full drama.
This is the first time Younha is performing in Music Bank from a very long time. I think the last time was in 2013, correct me if I am wrong. Thanks fellow Yholics and Army for ur support. It won't happen if fans didn't request her ❄️
@@rozanagrio3252 She's been around for a long time now. Honestly, I think it's only international fans that are starting to appreciate her more now. I think she was already quite well known in Korea already.
So many people disrespect this video by saying why namjoon is not here singing with younha, some other said namjoon is better, i remind you rm is busy at that time with his tight schedule. Bx doing a good job. He is a rookie rapper and have so much potential. Where are you when army said rm feat yuiko is better than epik high feat younha? Lol. Don't be so hypocrite. Everyone know the original singer is better.
they dk that BTS said that they will not appear in anyone mv or who they ft if it isn’t with one whole grp. So basically we won’t see them in any music shows if it’s only them & the person they collaborate
I think same, namjoon think should be proud that now the rookie rappers make a performance of it Just like when NamJoon was just starting out in the kpop industry covering parts of other rappers.
@@deliii395 oh come on! Don't be such a hater ! I'm an army and I'm ashamed to know people like you are exist! He did a great job , and he's only a rookie!!! I'm sure namjoon will love this performance! Just bcz joonie wasn't the one to rap , doesn't mean it's not worthy ! I personally loved this performance! Please stop with the hate .
@@lovelyPhar Because their busy with comeback and being a person and being in a group, being a leader, being a member, being a spokesperson and being himself. He's in one of the biggest group, he probably just couldn't fit flying accross the world to perform one piece and going back all together with world tour etc. into his schedule. Not tryna be mean, but this kind of situation kind of speaks for itself.
Namjoon is too busy to perform because of their comeback. Bx still did a good performance of rapping namjoon’s part. Thank you very much for doing a great job. You earned our respect✊🏻💜
IU is on different level. And she is much bigger than BTS, even Jungkook worships her. So when iu ft suga out, it is blew up like a dynamite. But even if not featuring SUGA, she will be topping the chart. I am not a fan to IU that much, but she has that effect.
@@Princess-di2zx c'mon we all now she is a great singer and has achieved alot she is working when she was so young SHE HAS HER OWN FANDOM TOO BUT U CAN'T COMPARE HER TO BTS .... I think u r new that's why u said that she is bigger than bts but she is not! Sorry!
@@Shruty0809 RM wasnt able to perform this song live because he was having a tight; busy schedule when the song was released, so another rapper performed this song live with younha..
the rapper carried himself so well. im sure he was under immense pressure to replace RM's part and to younha the reason why i have this song on the loop, u impressed me for the hundredth times 💜
Sure, he's covering parts of the group's leader and rapper currently at the top Anyone would feel pressure but despite this BX did very well in his style.
The fact that the rap part was done by BX.. He is the embodiment of RM's rap TT💜 for those who don't know yet, sweet warm-hearted Byounggon (BX) was ex-trainee of 3 years in YG Ent. He was part of silver boys (rumored trainees most likely to debut). Competed on Mixnine and made it into top 9! but they ended up cancelling the debut. Competed again in YG Treasure Box and was constantly discouraged by YG himself, but he made it into finals (top 11) but sadly not into the debuting top 7. Then before YG suprisingly announced a second winner lineup (so total top 13) he already left YG Ent. and joined C9 Ent. (same Ent. as Younha). He waited and waited and was constantly discouraged, he even had a good personality (was always the "mother" figure) but constantly failed to debut. Finally he now can be in CIX, debuted as Leader & Rapper 💙 Our BX bloomed from the harsh winter and constant love from his close friends and family TT💙 Proud Mate here he did a good job with RM's rap 💙 Stan BX guys he's really such a hardworking sweetheart 🥺💙 I loveee Younha too here she makes me have goosebumps 🥺💖 and knew her from RM as an Army 💜 Support all 💖💖
Even though Namjoon can't promote with Younha because of his busy schedule. At least here is CIX Leader/Main Rapper BX doing a really great job for doing Namjoon's rap. ❤ And I hope armys won't hate this baby boy for doing namjoon's rap. 🙏
i'm really amazed her rap skill i don't know who is he before but u wrote her name N now i know N m watching her every video love from army sorry my bad English
Everyone has his own rap style including RM and BX. We used to enjoying RM's rap so no wonder we praise his rap. But as a rookie, BX rap style is amazing, one of the kind and deserve to be loved. So let's support them both and enjoy their rap style. Peace! 🥂
I'll never forgive how the music industry treated Younha. She's one of the most vocally talented individuals to come out of Korea in the last couple decades, but largely overlooked.
yeah, the international media like soompi, allkpop, koreaboo didnt even talk about younha. they just talk about younha when younha release new album or songs. never touch about younha activities as one of the cast in a one of the show in kbs, didnt promote younha new ost (romance 101) , didnt talk about how great younha cover of into the unknown, western sky, one million roses. sometimes i'm angry and anger cannot solve the problem :(
she was really popular when she debuted during that hallyu wave. But as kpop has gotten more global, people like her get forgotten. She's a pioneer in her own right. Her and BoA basically did the same thing but in different styles.
One day, RM will really be there performing with her. I hope at the MAMA, MMA, or any awards and festival song. Please. I really want to see that happen. 😭💜✨ Good job BX. You really did justice there. Your rap is powerful too! Edit : Thank you for your likes😭😭🙏💕 MAMA and MMA is just around the corner! Let's hope the best for them💜
I still don't understand why there are some armys asking for RM/Namjoon. Guys! You know he Is very busy if they know he's working in the next comeback, the World tour and other projects.
Her voice is so beautiful and those high notes are just perfect. Hope to see her perform with RM one day. Thanks to BX of CIX for helping her, you did great!
That's not called dramatic but facts - her voice truly bring tears because it's just so mesmerizing and breathtaking (and that's because this is my first time hearing this song live and her voice in general)
Her voice is just so amazing. The hairs on my arms stood up when she hit those high notes. It's so beautiful I can't even describe it into words how amazing it is. I've never been so captivated with a female's singing voice but with Younha's it's hard not to be captivated and fascinated. I love how she hit the high notes, they were perfectly executed and flawless. Probably better than the actual music video but both are amazing in themselves
He did justice to rap part ..did not disappoint me good job... Her voice is really beautiful 💜 hope I can see her sing the song with RM once... Let's hope. Omg the likes... What's happening....!! I am bragging about it to my sis and you can imagine the disappointment she has in her face right now 😂😂😂 I am finally getting recocnized... I can at least brag about it to someone. Glad many Army's agree with me 💜
Yeah, I hope RM can squeeze in a performance with Younha. It'd be nice to have the original artists perform after all, even if it's only one time. I'd bet the viewer numbers would skyrocket as well. Besides, RM is a fellow brother of mine. The criteria for being a fellow brother of mine is to either have or previously had a crush on Younha. I wish for him to do the things I am unable to do!
Purple Moon chill. She is just saying Younha should be more popular and I agree. Maybe she is popular in Korea and Japan but not internationally. Personally, I only listened to the song because of RM but ended up loving Younha as well.
Purple Moon look her views ! her followers on insta ! she mean underrated by this way ! she clearly deserves more attention because her voice is pure golf
@@cin2338 so agree. Thru RM I became a fan of hers. I truly pray she & RM can perform live together. I also, wish to sing them sing more together. Release more songs as a collab. He has been her fanboy all these years. But I never took time to really listen to her till this song. The song hits home with me. I miss the "stay" from him in the performance as it was a goosebumps moment. Epic.
Everyone has his own rap style including RM and BX. We used to enjoying RM's rap so no wonder we praise his rap. But as a rookie, BX rap style is amazing, one of the kind and deserve to be loved. So let's support them both and enjoy their rap style. Peace! 🥂
I really miss Joonie's part. Felt weird to hear BX but never mind, he did good. I hope someday I get to hear Younha and Joon perform together. All love xx
For anyone who are amaze on Younha's voice, girlie isn't playing when it comes to vocals. She can resonate up to F#5 and she probably has the healthiest mixed register in entire KPOP. So yeah, vocal queen.
Currently my fave song in 2020....her voice is so nice and it make me feel so relax.......i hope i can see her perform with Rm...though BX is so good.......i love it
why did i just find out that byounggon covered joon's part, props to him to pull it off so well/ ah i'm so proud of my bbs and younha did outstanding, a very impressing well deserving artist indeed
Why is no one talking about how she stood at the same place nd sang entire song looking that beautiful?? I think she is my girl crush now😋 Nd her high notes just killed me.
BX is in CIX as their main rapper (so same company: C9) and is a former trainee of YG entertainment. He was in the survival show Treasure Box (and MixNine I think) anyways, he was one of the most talented trainees but YG let him down but now seeing him here, YG be regretting letting him go :))
Same exact thoughts, now look where he is , doing big things. It's all YG's loss . Later YG be saying he missed a talent like byounggon and regrets it in one of his survival shows .
Actually, thank goodness he's out of there. That company is being investigated by so many things after the Burning Sun case... And also, now I can get to know more about BX music and his group, because I won't be giving my money to YG. Simple like that. 😅
BX was supposed to be in the debut group of mixnine before it got cancelled! and tbh he probably would have made it to treasure13 if someone wasn’t so biased,,
That's CIX's leader BX. CIX and Younha are under the same company and they debuted less than a year ago. You should check them out. I'd recommend their songs Movie star and Numb ❤
he sounds nervous when he said 'nan' but in the end he REALLY DID WELL!i'm glad he's the one who do the rap part..byunggon all the best!been watching you since trainee..
younhas voice is so beautiful 💕💕 i hope army is proud of BX rapping namjoons part because he really did amazing. FIX are so proud of you LEE BYOUNGGON 💙💙💙
It must be hard on this BX person. 😅 Cause we will expect him rapping same as RM. But he's quite good himself 😊 Anyway, i hope she and RM can perform at MAMA and win the award too 😎😍
Rm:Stay Army/stay/moa/buddy:Yes I'm here.(me) Also: Taehyung with txt:Army yereobun! Army/moa/stay/buddy:Yes I'm here Again Taehyung:Moa yereobun Again army/moa/stay/buddy: I say I'm here
let me tell you. IT IS HARD ASF. i’ve been singing since like forever, and the first time i tried this, i actually voice cracked. it’s not easy. I recommend singing it in a lower pitch, then working your way up ( like increasing the pitch until it’s your normal voice? ). tips if you want to sing to this song. i’ve somehow gotten the hang of the notes
These vocals are so rare to find. Studio version and live version are exactly the same. the falsetto was needed, the note is extremely high and it shouldn't be risked, but she did it flawlessly. Great great great! 👍🏽
Her voice is soooooo beautiful. At first I listen to her song bc of RM but damn her voice really is amazing, even though I hope RM will perform this song with younha at least once but this guy who did RM rap part is good, feel different but still amazing 👍👍👍💜💜💜
His name is BX. Leader and main rapper of CIX, a rookie group and also in the same agency with Younha. He is so talented and deserve to be loved. Please support him 💙
BX is looking fine and tall with this style. His rap is on fire and so badass 🔥. He deserves more love. And not forget to Younha. Her angle voice is so incredible. Love you both 💕
I'm started stans her since "Umbrella"-Epik high feat Younha and after that i hear they release a new songs call "we fight ourselves" also Epik high feat younha..I don't know why their collaboration such an amazing..and now Kim namjoon doing collaborates with Younha..I'm proud fans of Epik high,Bts and Younha too🥰 Btw CIX BX such a Great rapper and leader too 🤗
I started following her when she released her second single. So this'll be my 15th year with Younha. There are few who have been a fan for as long as I have. I've sadly been unable to support her as much as I would've liked to, but I do own every single album at least.
This song really means alot to her. You can see and hear it by her voice and her expressions. I'm not happy that i just saw this today, but i'm rlly amazed by her vocals, i listened to this song not just because RM did a collab with her but she is a stunning singer 😭 💞 Plus BX, he's so underrated as well as his other members. I salute them 💛☺
I think we are okay with someone else performing Namjoon's part. Younha can do no wrong here. She is a lovely woman and singer. Her album is so good. We will look forward to the moment when Namjoon can join her on stage. For now, we can appreciate the young talent reaching to fill Joonie's shoes. They have a journey ahead of them, but at least they dream big and aspire to be more than they are right now. I think this is doing what RM intended. We need to see the other talents in the industry, and they need to step up to shine.
Younha is a famous Korean solo singer. Rm is a big fan of her. Because when RM was a student, she was already a very famous and proven singer in Korea.
He Did his Best.. RM must be proud of him... 💜❤... WinterFlower is a Soothing Song and motivational song for me.. ❤💙 Younha & RM voice blended so well together 👌
BX's YG side really shone through during his part. And Younha's vocals are just so captivating. C9 really does have some awesome talent under their belt.
![[4K] Kim SeonYou - Younha 'Winter Flower'](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/18-HCgfm8TA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] Kim SeonYou - Younha 'Winter Flower'](/img/tr.png)
![[MV] YOUNHA(윤하) _ WINTER FLOWER(雪中梅) (Feat.RM)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OcCkAG_LO9Y/mqdefault.jpg)
i need joon to sing this live with her someday . a blessing
michelle but imagine her opening one of the concerts
Legendary
Maybe at the new concerts!
yeah I wish....
@@berri5769 not sure bc they usually had performance list that cannot be changed but yea I'm still hoping😔🙏
Same
I can't believe she is 32 years old. She looks 25 honestly. No joke, look at the album cover. She be looking like a goddess.
Heol, I just know this. So you mean, when I listened to her japanese song long time ago in my childhood, she was still a teenager?? Shame of me 😱😱😱
Realy 32 yrs old whoa she face very young.
@@allaroundyu she is 17 when she sing for bleach ost (houkiboshi) but her looks at that time like a 15 years old girl. 👀
@@nvaav5220 yeah, look young and still cute. ♥️
i did not know she was 32 and now i am so shook
I can hear Joon’s voice in the background
Also, the guy who did Joon’s rap is amazing and Younha has a really good voice
Shanna Clarito he is BX from CIX
Shanna Clarito she said “mics on”
BX From CIX
@@sall.shl_ ⁿ9³835³329ⁿ
Who is he? He's cool
younha doesn't need autotune, autotune needs younha, period.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
For real. Her voice is fire, especially when belting. She sounds the best in the hardest parts, like, OMG what a queen
Auto tune isn't necessarily bad. It is a technique that almost everyone uses. When they overuse it to change someone's voice, then that's a bit.....
..... but here not clear vocal. It's autotune a little bit and prerecord on background
@@o.k.3485 Yes it may be that yes .. But it shows that it does not require it.
As one professional said, autotune is not a bad thing if it is used simply to make the voice sound clearer, but when the singer really has a vocal quality.
But when the autotune is the one that does the job of transmitting a good voice but you don't have vocal quality, then that's different.
Here you can see that yes, maybe she did use it, but very little, besides, you can see that she is singing completely there ... And you can see that she has vocal quality ... She simply used the autotune to give a little more clarity to the voice .. And the background to give it effect, but there you can see his voice
I can see why RM worked on this collaboration with Younha. She sang so effortlessly. BX and RM have their own ways of rapping, which made me enjoy the performance. I love this song. It's beautiful, especially the intro part. 😍
Namjoon have to busy schedule.
And Younha relies on BX from CIX a rookie boy group under the same company than Younha.
Also because Joon has been a long time fan of Younha.
He's really good
guys I can't understand does the original version of this song is a collaboration with RM rapping or what?
@@s.m6336 Yes but it wasn't possible for him to do the live with her so BX did it. I think I like both version
the most surprising part is, why isnt this an ost? literally would be a perfect ost of a drama
So True, I was waiting for it too
So True, I was waiting for it too
If it became the ost for top rating drama, i bet the view would be close to 1 billion 🤔
That's wottttt
I guess because the song is a newer one. I'm assuming that it will become an OST, just the amount of time that it came out in. I wouldn't know much, but 5 months is not nearly enough time for a full drama.
This is the first time Younha is performing in Music Bank from a very long time. I think the last time was in 2013, correct me if I am wrong. Thanks fellow Yholics and Army for ur support. It won't happen if fans didn't request her ❄️
Actually her voice is so unique and very talented though she deserves what is happening to her now❤❤❤
and Fix!
@@rozanagrio3252 what happened?
인김휘 she meant the popularity and recognition younha is getting now
@@rozanagrio3252 She's been around for a long time now. Honestly, I think it's only international fans that are starting to appreciate her more now. I think she was already quite well known in Korea already.
So many people disrespect this video by saying why namjoon is not here singing with younha, some other said namjoon is better, i remind you rm is busy at that time with his tight schedule. Bx doing a good job. He is a rookie rapper and have so much potential. Where are you when army said rm feat yuiko is better than epik high feat younha? Lol. Don't be so hypocrite. Everyone know the original singer is better.
As army I think bx is a great Rapper.
Yess!! Plus Namjoon wouldn’t be happy with comments like that.. he would show respect! Army needs to follow
RM a better artist, but the song's focal point is Youhna.
@@anton_lezama_art he did good, compliment him & go, he’s a rookie rapper of course Namjoon is going to be better he has more experience
they dk that BTS said that they will not appear in anyone mv or who they ft if it isn’t with one whole grp. So basically we won’t see them in any music shows if it’s only them & the person they collaborate
Winter Flower and Eight both release this year and imagine her and RM, IU and Suga perform this songs in MMA or MAMA. 💜🤟
Oh shit that will be freaking awesome.
I doubt there will be mama or mma or any other award show this year. It's still risky to hav any concert going on this year.
@@fno1723
I think there will be at least online show without audience.
I(we) hope someday 🥺💗
Ikr these two songs r heaven
Just imagine namjoon so proud to watch them specially when someone sang his part.
I think same, namjoon think should be proud that now the rookie rappers make a performance of it
Just like when NamJoon was just starting out in the kpop industry covering parts of other rappers.
Eve line he didn’t cover parts tho
@@beyoncessidechick3043 He covered the part of mad clown feat soyu.
Namjoon would cover his ears the moment he heard this. This is so not good.
@@deliii395 oh come on! Don't be such a hater !
I'm an army and I'm ashamed to know people like you are exist!
He did a great job , and he's only a rookie!!! I'm sure namjoon will love this performance!
Just bcz joonie wasn't the one to rap , doesn't mean it's not worthy !
I personally loved this performance!
Please stop with the hate .
one of the reason why Namjoon admire Younha for such a long time, she hit every note so effortlessly and BX did a really good job
Is CIX, Bae Jinyoung group ?
@@Ace-qc5dm yes.
But why is namjoon is not here??
Namjoon Deserves this praise!!!
@@lovelyPhar Because their busy with comeback and being a person and being in a group, being a leader, being a member, being a spokesperson and being himself. He's in one of the biggest group, he probably just couldn't fit flying accross the world to perform one piece and going back all together with world tour etc. into his schedule. Not tryna be mean, but this kind of situation kind of speaks for itself.
A petition for RM and Younha to perform this song together someday.
Yes! That would be beautiful!
I really want this too🥺🥺
Yes please
Yes pleae
@@navi3430
I really hope it happens
Her voice is so beautiful. And I miss Joonie’s rap. His “Stay”. Wish to see them perform together at least once.
yooo i like his "stay" too, wish them to perform it next time
Me too
Me too
Yesss!!! That part😭😭😭
Erm at what time was that part ? 😅
Namjoon is too busy to perform because of their comeback. Bx still did a good performance of rapping namjoon’s part. Thank you very much for doing a great job. You earned our respect✊🏻💜
Thnx u for good comment about BX 🥰🥰
Is no namjoon
@@Floresitas149 We know that. He is Lee Byounggon aka BX from CIX. 🥰🥰
He is from yg trainee treasure right?..so good😘
@@Lalaland_130 Nope. Formerly on Mixnine. Then when their debut fell apart, he move to C9 and debut under CIX as their leader and main rapper.
This guy who did namjoonie’s part is so good, we appreciate talent and younha wow she is unreal💜💜
Blue Gon I don’t know how you’re gonna take it but I’m happy that he left yg and surely will check em out💜 Thank you
stan CIX 💜
im kinda sad how this song is so underrated compared to iu and suga's eight :( THEY ALL DESERVE EQUALITY
It's because compared to Younha, UI is a digimon and a much-loved artist in Korea.
Yea in korea but this song top the billboard chart
Yes i agree with u. And the viewers of this song also not much compared with the lyric video made by others..
IU is on different level. And she is much bigger than BTS, even Jungkook worships her.
So when iu ft suga out, it is blew up like a dynamite. But even if not featuring SUGA, she will be topping the chart.
I am not a fan to IU that much, but she has that effect.
@@Princess-di2zx c'mon we all now she is a great singer and has achieved alot she is working when she was so young SHE HAS HER OWN FANDOM TOO BUT U CAN'T COMPARE HER TO BTS .... I think u r new that's why u said that she is bigger than bts but she is not! Sorry!
She really didn’t let us down. I can listen to her voice all day, I really wish to see her and namjoon preform this song live
Its been a year and im still hoping and waiting. ✌
can I ask a question the M/V said feat.RM but what happen at stage right now
@@Shruty0809 RM wasnt able to perform this song live because he was having a tight; busy schedule when the song was released, so another rapper performed this song live with younha..
@@noorbleh ooooh ok i get it now did'nt expect for a reply this fast anyways thank you so much 💜💜💜💜💜💜
@@Shruty0809 ur most welcome ❣
the rapper carried himself so well. im sure he was under immense pressure to replace RM's part
and to younha the reason why i have this song on the loop, u impressed me for the hundredth times 💜
Sure, he's covering parts of the group's leader and rapper currently at the top
Anyone would feel pressure but despite this BX did very well in his style.
Yeah, for real on both! She can sing and he did RM justice!
Yes he is so amazing
Younha's vocals are incredible. Her voice draws you in like honey then crashes against you like a storm in perfect harmony.
Well said.
couldnt have said it any better
와 이게 라이브가 되네 와..... 진짜 속시원해 돌아왔구나 윤하ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
how does she hit those high notes so naturally like,, i sound like a frikin goat;-;
Its higher than my grades ;((
Into the unknOooown
@@Ali-ff8te id really love her and joon to have a stage duet togetherr;
Lol im laughing so hard right now 😂 When u mentioned the goat thing, all I could hear was a goat screaming
I tried singing the high note and my younger sister tild me i sound like a dying cat.... Hahahahah
I can't believe she's the same person who sung houkiboshi, ending theme song for bleach anime.. 😱
What?? Which theme song??? I'm a huge bleach fan
bleach theme? i need to know fam pls
@@ismailjiwa776 didn't that person say its houkiboshi?
Houkiboshi
WHATTT
that boy must had a huge pressure on his shoulders because he was going to do RM's part. But still did an amazing job, he's a person to admire.
Hyesun Kim it 169 I don’t want to mess it up
hes BX from CIX!! they are really amazing you should check them out
I agree. he has done alright. But I wished RM was doing his own part. But I know he stays extremely busy.
YASSSS STAN CIX FOR CLEAR SKIN
true
The fact that the rap part was done by BX.. He is the embodiment of RM's rap TT💜 for those who don't know yet, sweet warm-hearted Byounggon (BX) was ex-trainee of 3 years in YG Ent. He was part of silver boys (rumored trainees most likely to debut).
Competed on Mixnine and made it into top 9! but they ended up cancelling the debut. Competed again in YG Treasure Box and was constantly discouraged by YG himself, but he made it into finals (top 11) but sadly not into the debuting top 7. Then before YG suprisingly announced a second winner lineup (so total top 13) he already left YG Ent. and joined C9 Ent. (same Ent. as Younha). He waited and waited and was constantly discouraged, he even had a good personality (was always the "mother" figure) but constantly failed to debut.
Finally he now can be in CIX, debuted as Leader & Rapper 💙 Our BX bloomed from the harsh winter and constant love from his close friends and family TT💙
Proud Mate here he did a good job with RM's rap 💙 Stan BX guys he's really such a hardworking sweetheart 🥺💙 I loveee Younha too here she makes me have goosebumps 🥺💖 and knew her from RM as an Army 💜 Support all 💖💖
Dela Aryanti proud MATE💙 and FIX 🌱💙
did he leave yg in the start of this year
@@izyeaa No, He left YG E after YGTB program end. Among 2018 - early 2019
He did great on this. But maybe even better if they rerecorded the background vocals with him as well.
wow hello there multi! I see you're also a stay from yr name ^^
Her voice is so powerful. This song can be use as an OST to a drama.
Agreed. This type of song can be ost for kdrama like skycastle
Yeah , goblin
love alarm
Well she does sing some amazing OSTs already
Mona Lisa
- Frozen 2 announced
- Taeyeon chosen to sing 'Into the Unknown' in korean
- Dahyun cosplaying Elsa
- Younha released 'Winter Flower'
Then there's mcnd debuting with ice age
@@maritzazachragunasenjaya1131 dkjfkddk
We found new Elsa-
That doesn't make any sense idiot .....Bangtan FOREVER!!
《 DIFRIN 》 tf? what doesn’t make any sense
Even though Namjoon can't promote with Younha because of his busy schedule. At least here is CIX Leader/Main Rapper BX doing a really great job for doing Namjoon's rap. ❤
And I hope armys won't hate this baby boy for doing namjoon's rap. 🙏
i'm really amazed her rap skill
i don't know who is he before but u wrote her name N now i know N m watching her every video love from army sorry my bad English
Army don't hate anyone, we love peace 💜
@@karmilarahma That's true for the vast majority... but damn, when you're out to get someone, that shit gets scary.
We sp to them 💜
Everyone has his own rap style including RM and BX. We used to enjoying RM's rap so no wonder we praise his rap. But as a rookie, BX rap style is amazing, one of the kind and deserve to be loved. So let's support them both and enjoy their rap style. Peace! 🥂
I'll never forgive how the music industry treated Younha. She's one of the most vocally talented individuals to come out of Korea in the last couple decades, but largely overlooked.
yeah, the international media like soompi, allkpop, koreaboo didnt even talk about younha. they just talk about younha when younha release new album or songs. never touch about younha activities as one of the cast in a one of the show in kbs, didnt promote younha new ost (romance 101) , didnt talk about how great younha cover of into the unknown, western sky, one million roses. sometimes i'm angry and anger cannot solve the problem :(
she was really popular when she debuted during that hallyu wave. But as kpop has gotten more global, people like her get forgotten. She's a pioneer in her own right. Her and BoA basically did the same thing but in different styles.
No worry her song "Event horizon" is charting at 1 rn in melon
One day, RM will really be there performing with her. I hope at the MAMA, MMA, or any awards and festival song. Please. I really want to see that happen. 😭💜✨ Good job BX. You really did justice there. Your rap is powerful too!
Edit : Thank you for your likes😭😭🙏💕 MAMA and MMA is just around the corner! Let's hope the best for them💜
Yeah, i'm wishing for it. Army realky appreciates her talent. I wish for more collab of her and BTS.
yes I hope so too. ur pfp is amazing
yes baby. I cant wait for that.. 😭😭
@@aishanibasu6159 eh? Your pfp is amazing too. Sexy huhu!
Los MAMA Y AMA ya pasaron
Damn... Her vocals....... 💯 She's the second female singer tht gves me goosebumps bcs of her voice. The first one was Ailee.
RIGHT LIKE SHE IS SOOOO STABLE
Yes's Ailee is really good.
I love her highnote and yunha remaind me of her
YES AILEEE
Her voice fr has become one of my favourites 😍
I still don't understand why there are some armys asking for RM/Namjoon.
Guys! You know he Is very busy if they know he's working in the next comeback, the World tour and other projects.
Eve line most people are only saying they hope that we will one Day see Them performing this song together though..
@@Marie-tl4pw I say some.
Eve line she said most
@@letchugooo8502 yes thank you very much
Corona Virus says no thanks not anymore
난 이노래 모든 사람들이 들었으면 좋겠음 겨울이 시작 할 때 쯤 햇빛이 있으면서도 날씨는 서늘할때부터 겨우내내 듣는 띵곡인데ㅜㅜ
Her voice is so beautiful and those high notes are just perfect. Hope to see her perform with RM one day. Thanks to BX of CIX for helping her, you did great!
His jaw line cut me in half
@@Tae_B831 yessshhhh
Yes, omg that would be so cute.
I would scream😂😂
But yh BX did *amazing!!!*
Not to be dramatic, but i'm shedding tears over her voice, I love it.
Um same
Same girl 😭😭😭😭😭
me too😭😭😭
That's not called dramatic but facts - her voice truly bring tears because it's just so mesmerizing and breathtaking (and that's because this is my first time hearing this song live and her voice in general)
goosebumps from head to toe
Her voice is just so amazing. The hairs on my arms stood up when she hit those high notes. It's so beautiful I can't even describe it into words how amazing it is. I've never been so captivated with a female's singing voice but with Younha's it's hard not to be captivated and fascinated. I love how she hit the high notes, they were perfectly executed and flawless. Probably better than the actual music video but both are amazing in themselves
Younha is the powerful female vocalist I've ever seen.
Me too
This is not a thing compare to younha 2012-2014 version. That younha is the best younha in live performance
@@rausyansafwan9720 can u recommend some of her songs to me? So far I have only listened to this one and dark cloud
@@nithyuh On a Rainy Night, Supersonic, Password 486.. Actually all her b tracks are worth listening
@@뚕-p6w Thanks I'll check em out. She's probably my favorite female kpop artist.
He did justice to rap part ..did not disappoint me good job... Her voice is really beautiful 💜 hope I can see her sing the song with RM once... Let's hope.
Omg the likes... What's happening....!!
I am bragging about it to my sis and you can imagine the disappointment she has in her face right now 😂😂😂
I am finally getting recocnized... I can at least brag about it to someone.
Glad many Army's agree with me 💜
Yeeees omg
Yeah, I hope RM can squeeze in a performance with Younha. It'd be nice to have the original artists perform after all, even if it's only one time. I'd bet the viewer numbers would skyrocket as well. Besides, RM is a fellow brother of mine. The criteria for being a fellow brother of mine is to either have or previously had a crush on Younha. I wish for him to do the things I am unable to do!
@@CottidaeSEA really?
@@jjkowalski6088 Really what?
@@CottidaeSEA ignore that antis
She makes her high notes look so effortless. Holy crap, she’s amazing!
She's so underrated! It's criminal! Gosh! Her voice gave me chills!
underrated? who are you talking about? Younha is a well established solo artist in korea and japan. she has many anime theme songs.
Purple Moon chill. She is just saying Younha should be more popular and I agree. Maybe she is popular in Korea and Japan but not internationally. Personally, I only listened to the song because of RM but ended up loving Younha as well.
chitra singh exactly
Purple Moon look her views ! her followers on insta ! she mean underrated by this way ! she clearly deserves more attention because her voice is pure golf
@@cin2338 so agree. Thru RM I became a fan of hers. I truly pray she & RM can perform live together. I also, wish to sing them sing more together. Release more songs as a collab.
He has been her fanboy all these years. But I never took time to really listen to her till this song. The song hits home with me.
I miss the "stay" from him in the performance as it was a goosebumps moment. Epic.
Winter flower 언젠가는 매우 유명해질 수밖에 없다고 생각합니다. 윤하 님 응원합니다!
Her vocals are no joke. So amazing and certainly didn’t disappoint. Hopefully one day, she and RM can perform this song together ☺️
Am I the only one who miss Namjoon's *Stay* ?... I'm emo ... Her voice is so beautiful
Me too 😭😭😭
Anulu Nienu me tooo omg
Whenever I hear this beautiful song, his "stay" literally gives me goosebumps and shivers every time I hear it..... Who knew one word could do that..
@@KC-ck1mz Kim Namjoon being the best man periodt
Miss joon's voice.. but BX did justice to the song as well..
This song is underrated! Many armys don't even know that this masterpiece exist :"(
I listen to this song daily and it's just soo good😔🤷
Yeah even I didn't know as I was a new army I got to know this song was there yesterday by another army , we have to spread it "fighting "
Yes. I played this video so many times. It's so beautiful
I found it today 😭
Kill me 😭😭💜
This is a Masterpiece 😭🔥🔥🔥🔥
This masterpiece is really underrated, i think talented singers like Younha still deserve much love and support from the fandom! 🥺❤️
Younha is such a queen, geez. Those vocals.
Also BX, my dude, goddamn, are you trying to make me a stan!?
Missing Joonie's voice
STAN CIX :')
the dislikes are from the people who wish they can sing like younha
yea, haters gonna hate
lucky for me, I liked it and can also sing decently alike😌🤚🏻
I really want to sing like her, but i can't dislike
D-dad?
@@jikooksdaughter5422 D-Daughter?
yOUNHA'S VOıCE AHH also he did so well. Giving justice to RM’s rap
His dream was came true
Everyone has his own rap style including RM and BX. We used to enjoying RM's rap so no wonder we praise his rap. But as a rookie, BX rap style is amazing, one of the kind and deserve to be loved. So let's support them both and enjoy their rap style. Peace! 🥂
I thought she is 23 lol 😂
And when I searched on google, I can’t believe what I see, she is *32* WTF
She looks beautiful and young 🥰
Vocal Hunter yeah😍
This korea girl hahhaha
I missed rm’s “stay” part but still such an AMAZING performance
Me too, I live for it. It's so full of yearning
she really is so beautiful. this song is so beautiful istg
I really miss Joonie's part. Felt weird to hear BX but never mind, he did good. I hope someday I get to hear Younha and Joon perform together. All love xx
HE'S AWESOME with it. and i hope joonie will performe that someday with younha
For anyone who are amaze on Younha's voice, girlie isn't playing when it comes to vocals. She can resonate up to F#5 and she probably has the healthiest mixed register in entire KPOP. So yeah, vocal queen.
For those who don’t know the guy he is from a group called CIX 😌✌🏽his name is Bx
That kinda rhymes lol
Byounggon is his real name born in ‘98 which makes him 21 years old atm turning 22 soon. He’s SUCH AN AMAZING RAPPER AND LEADER. HIS SMILE IS BLINDING
I was so shocked when I saw him like YES he deserves to shine
I love CIX. ~mulitfan~
He is ex trainee in YG :) i watched him in survival program Mixnine
Currently my fave song in 2020....her voice is so nice and it make me feel so relax.......i hope i can see her perform with Rm...though BX is so good.......i love it
Same
why did i just find out that byounggon covered joon's part, props to him to pull it off so well/ ah i'm so proud of my bbs and younha did outstanding, a very impressing well deserving artist indeed
he really grew well away from yg
He was really awesome!! I think every army liked a lot, he wasn't trying to rap like Nam, he did it on his own way👏👏
BX rapping RM's part flawlessly and Youha with perfect vocals. They both did amazing this song is so beautiful live and recorded
That cute boy deserves all love of the armys he managed everything with so ease
Why is no one talking about how she stood at the same place nd sang entire song looking that beautiful?? I think she is my girl crush now😋
Nd her high notes just killed me.
You will fall in love with her voice and vocal performance if you watch her in i am a singer 2.
Army ???💜
@@ranjithnavarathne9773 yupp💜
Damn, but she like 32 F 😔
@@sarvottmasanghmitra1084 🤪💜️💜️💜️💜️
ARMY like BX'rap.. hope CIX will succeess in their future..
Thank u 🤧
STAN CIX
So bx is his name? What is his real name?
@@patriciaalfiona7542 Lee Byounggon
@@patriciaalfiona7542 hes Real name is Lee Byounggon from CIX
STAN CIX
가슴이 먹먹해지는 기분이 드는데 또 뭔가 힘내게되는 신기한 노래..
BX is in CIX as their main rapper (so same company: C9) and is a former trainee of YG entertainment. He was in the survival show Treasure Box (and MixNine I think)
anyways, he was one of the most talented trainees but YG let him down but now seeing him here, YG be regretting letting him go :))
Same exact thoughts, now look where he is , doing big things. It's all YG's loss . Later YG be saying he missed a talent like byounggon and regrets it in one of his survival shows .
Actually, thank goodness he's out of there. That company is being investigated by so many things after the Burning Sun case... And also, now I can get to know more about BX music and his group, because I won't be giving my money to YG. Simple like that. 😅
BX was supposed to be in the debut group of mixnine before it got cancelled! and tbh he probably would have made it to treasure13 if someone wasn’t so biased,,
the guy who did Joon's part is so cool
That's CIX's leader BX. CIX and Younha are under the same company and they debuted less than a year ago. You should check them out. I'd recommend their songs Movie star and Numb ❤
I know right. Handsome and cool
yééé 9ahbaa
@@deukae-mentary958 y frera
he sounds nervous when he said 'nan' but in the end he REALLY DID WELL!i'm glad he's the one who do the rap part..byunggon all the best!been watching you since trainee..
"I will take it away before you stumble" that part is awsome... I like this song in 5 seconds.. Rm's voice "hold on" is awsome..
younhas voice is so beautiful 💕💕
i hope army is proud of BX rapping namjoons part because he really did amazing.
FIX are so proud of you LEE BYOUNGGON 💙💙💙
Of course we proud. Thanks to him sing our leader rap so good 😀
The real army will be always proud💜
@@sammy011 thank you 💙
Im proud of him as a fix and army
@@missjhaycee7636 he did great...😉
Ok but the guy who rapped Namjoons part was hot 👀
his name is BX he’s the leader of CIX!! they’re an amazing group you should check them out 🥺
justsona sorry I’m late but will do ☺️
@@jimin4537 omg I didn't know he was the leader of cix, I don't know them but i love their song moviestar
Yes, he's idol so no wonder. I really thankful to him such a talented boy >
Its BX from CIX
This's why RM really like younha. Her voice humttt
She is like the pure winter to her fan club "holics" 😊. As the glober singer...
It must be hard on this BX person. 😅 Cause we will expect him rapping same as RM. But he's quite good himself 😊
Anyway, i hope she and RM can perform at MAMA and win the award too 😎😍
isnt he from CIX? former trainee from yg and was one of the contestants on treasure box yg
@@traceynguyen7790 yes he is bx the rapper of cix
Me too OMG i hope so
I got chills 3 to 4 times when she was singing. She has such an amazing voice and I love her new album.
The whole comments section:
Vocals? Slayed.
RM? "Stay".
Damn gurlll🔥🔥
Rm:Stay
Army/stay/moa/buddy:Yes I'm here.(me)
Also:
Taehyung with txt:Army yereobun!
Army/moa/stay/buddy:Yes I'm here
Again Taehyung:Moa yereobun
Again army/moa/stay/buddy: I say I'm here
Hotel? Trivago.
Sorry I had to
@@minyoongistonguetechnology6389 I was gonna write that myself😂😂😂
i thought stay word hit only me hard😂vocals superb...stay,rm nailed it
진짜 폭설 내리는 가혹한 추위에 꾿꾿히 홀로 피는 하얀 백합꽃 같다 ㅎㅎ
Imagine she perform this on end year award show , then joon surprise us with the collab . that ‘ Stay ‘ ...
btw bx do a good job too .
I can see why RM worked with her. Her voice and singing ability is impressive and RM made a wonderful song so proud
She should stop making those high notes look easy when they’re NOT!
Its easy for her.
@@rausyansafwan9720 it's difficult for everybody, even for her :). Her voice is amazing
A freaking G5 i can't even sing it a octave lower
@@hungphamviet3543 Me neither😂😂😂
let me tell you. IT IS HARD ASF. i’ve been singing since like forever, and the first time i tried this, i actually voice cracked. it’s not easy. I recommend singing it in a lower pitch, then working your way up ( like increasing the pitch until it’s your normal voice? ). tips if you want to sing to this song. i’ve somehow gotten the hang of the notes
이토록 장르 다양하게 부르는 귀한 가수가 또 어디있을까 우리 윤하 너무 멋지다
These vocals are so rare to find. Studio version and live version are exactly the same. the falsetto was needed, the note is extremely high and it shouldn't be risked, but she did it flawlessly. Great great great! 👍🏽
I know right! I got goosebumps when I first listened to this song, I thought her voice was too good to be real, and it still seems ethereal to me!
oh younha’s an amazing vocalist, you should check out some of her other lives
SHE'S SO BEAUTIFUL, HER VOICE IS SO BEAUTIFUL.
The guy did justice to joon's rap..
Younha's voice takes me to another dimension. And Baby Gon (BX) did so well with his attractive low tone and awesome flow! 💙💙💙💙💙
Looks like she poured her heart through the masterpiece...
Each feeling that was pressed now came alive...love u both
this song hits different like a ost
7 jxmin
Ikr
Her voice is soooooo beautiful. At first I listen to her song bc of RM but damn her voice really is amazing, even though I hope RM will perform this song with younha at least once but this guy who did RM rap part is good, feel different but still amazing 👍👍👍💜💜💜
His name is BX. Leader and main rapper of CIX, a rookie group and also in the same agency with Younha. He is so talented and deserve to be loved. Please support him 💙
feby mariana Thank youuuu. I'll absolutely check their song. I like his voice😊💜
I got goosebumps while listening her vocals and high notes..and BX man u r fabulous juust amazing !!
Repeat after me, Younha is a QUEEN.
BX is looking fine and tall with this style. His rap is on fire and so badass 🔥. He deserves more love. And not forget to Younha. Her angle voice is so incredible. Love you both 💕
I'm started stans her since "Umbrella"-Epik high feat Younha and after that i hear they release a new songs call "we fight ourselves" also Epik high feat younha..I don't know why their collaboration such an amazing..and now Kim namjoon doing collaborates with Younha..I'm proud fans of Epik high,Bts and Younha too🥰
Btw CIX BX such a Great rapper and leader too 🤗
random fans I will go check those out! I used to follow Epik high back in the day but I can only remember 1-2 songs
I started following her when she released her second single. So this'll be my 15th year with Younha. There are few who have been a fan for as long as I have. I've sadly been unable to support her as much as I would've liked to, but I do own every single album at least.
This song really means alot to her. You can see and hear it by her voice and her expressions. I'm not happy that i just saw this today, but i'm rlly amazed by her vocals, i listened to this song not just because RM did a collab with her but she is a stunning singer 😭 💞 Plus BX, he's so underrated as well as his other members. I salute them 💛☺
Younha always had a good emotion while singing. Thats why sometimes people call her emotional vocalist.
Her high notes literally giving goosebumps
Her outfit giving me ‘Anna’ vibe, one of character from Frozen.
Omg u are right. The funny thing is she already cover Into the Unknown ❄️🎤
Omg I see it now 🤣
I think we are okay with someone else performing Namjoon's part. Younha can do no wrong here. She is a lovely woman and singer. Her album is so good. We will look forward to the moment when Namjoon can join her on stage. For now, we can appreciate the young talent reaching to fill Joonie's shoes. They have a journey ahead of them, but at least they dream big and aspire to be more than they are right now. I think this is doing what RM intended. We need to see the other talents in the industry, and they need to step up to shine.
the guy covering namjoon’s rap did so well omg
He's name is BX from CIX
Younha is a famous Korean solo singer. Rm is a big fan of her. Because when RM was a student, she was already a very famous and proven singer in Korea.
He Did his Best.. RM must be proud of him... 💜❤...
WinterFlower is a Soothing Song and motivational song for me.. ❤💙
Younha & RM voice blended so well together 👌
Her voice is no joke, the way every high note she hits look so effortless, is amazing!
I'm glad that they have him to rap Namjoon's part and that it is performed live. Not just played his rap as background
Younha has a kind of serious-cuteness, looks really dignified but sweet at the same time...lovely..
BX's YG side really shone through during his part. And Younha's vocals are just so captivating. C9 really does have some awesome talent under their belt.
I hope BX becomes a Yg's biggest loss, now hes in C9 where receives the treatment he DESERVES and surrounded by goods artist like Younha.
갓..레전드!
윤하의 음색이 창연한 겨울 창공을 날아올라 피어나네요...💞
뭐래는거야
@@이지후-p3n OMG..Legend!
이젠 이해가 될런지?
@@이지후-p3n ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@rl1218 굿굿 ㅋㅋ
came here for my man, namjoon but ended up falling in love with bx
You should definitely check out CIX. He's the leader and main rapper
Sameee lol, in love with him
STAN CIX
Don't cheat on NAMJOON Daddy
I just wanna say, I'm seriously listening to her for the first time and m already in love with younha, I mean she's amazing..and wayy too underrated.