well actually yes the weapons do matter especially if both combatants are equal in skill, because sometimes the victor is determined by whose sword isn't broken, like if your using a sword breaking sword and your opponent isn't
But did any of the dao swords crack. If the person who wield the swords takes good care of their swords, used it correctly or practice their skill often, they could be able to beat other sword yielder. And those Dao yielder didn’t yield it correctly.
@@codyshi4743 keep in mind I said both combatants are equal in skill then that would also mean that they both keep their swords in top shape, if you were to put both swords against each other and both swords are in pristine condition one sword being a katana and the other a dao then the dao would likely outlast the katana because the katana is rigid and the dao flexible, the point is that some swords are built better than others and I should also point out that the quality of the swords is not the only variable in a sword fight
Full of mistake.why the katana guy using traditional Chinese Taoist sittng pose?and those chinese swords man using stage props sword(soft sword).who's gonna use a soft sword to fight?you can only see it in 60-80s Hong kong cinema.but is 21st century guys.not even in the movies now
Katana is shit compared to chinese broad sword, chinese sword was used in battle field in used for cut and break armor, katana will easily break when hit with chinese broad sword
Japanese uses other weapons as well. But when it comes to war in ancient time, of course China has the overwhelming advantage, it was a bigger nation with more resources. However if it was a 1v1 combat battle, it's actually debatable. Practicality asides, Katana does look more cool than Jian. Katana also bares a significant meaning in Japanese culture whereas Jian is nothing more than a tool in Chinese culture; that alone makes a lot of difference.
Many Samurai class Japanese were descended from Ainu and Jomon, they were fierce warriors, I don't think Chinese soldiers could handle them in a close combat fight.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 dont get media or anime blind you, go search the history record, ancient japanese was extremely short, most of the average height of samurai only 5 feet, just imagine fighting with dwarf, ancient China give Japan a name called woguo ,which mean short country, beside the japan is lack of steel, doubt the katana quality can against China weapon
@@stevej1235 Katana is more than that, it bares a significant meaning. Whereas in Chinese culture, any weapon is nothing more than a tool. This makes Chinese culture looks a lot plainer compare to that of Japanese and that alone makes a lot of difference.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 lol, go kiss your katana when can't even defend a heavy strike from China broadsword, every weapon is a tool for war, it's meaningless if your weapon is not efficient
That day you sing in the videos not a real Chinese dao . The down there using is used in wu Shu, for only performance.the real Chinese down will be not so flexible like this sword .and customer is a Vikas word because it is very lengthy and not flexible enough with dao . And the people you are using or not so real
It was a lot of fun I thought. People seem to be taking it as some sort of example of technical swordsmanship. I hope you aren't the kinds of people that watch Kung Fu hustle and expect to be able to do the palm technique ... lol. Or perhaps you criticize the form and historical correctness of the axe gang instead of watching the actual movie? This is very clearly for entertainment and filled with funny stereotypes. It's amusing. Chinese and Japanese swords have very different handling and application. With the weight, balance point and method of use - you'd expect the reach and technical differences to cause quite an awkward battle here. The video showcases the supposed superiority of the Japanese swordsman because of his better skill and experience. A master vs 3 students. Something like Starwars. A knight vs some pesky Padawan's. Don't take it too seriously. The Japanese swordsman here is the big boss and the others not so much. Enjoy it for what its for.
That’s not a chinese sword. A chinese sword is way better than a katana. That is a fact. What you have in this video is some sort of pirate sword. This video shows nothing on China’s true powers, and everyone thinks Japanese weapons are stronger simply because the Japanese is more popular, and that China is facing bad reputation. And you didn’t even spell Chinese right. Also, a Dao sword is much much MUCH more sharper than a katana. A well maintained dao sword can cut through bambo like its air. A katana cannot do that. A dao sword also does not look like a floppy disk.
Your comment tells me that u clearly do not understand Japanese culture! First of all, Katana is mainly used for slicing flesh and u Chinese are underestimating the Samurais!
im starting to see alot of obvious endings. most of the films on this outside of asia, the katana always wins. most of the films IN asia (cept japan mostly) especially in hong kong and china, the Dao wins
Tbf it actually depends upon the skill of the master and same goes for swordsmenship. The person with the better skill will usually win 7/10 times no matter the equipment. As long as ome side doesn't have more technological advantages then the person then they will usually win. An expert Muey Thai fighter or Karate fighter will generally beat a moderate or average Kung Fu fighter and same goes Vice versa honestly you guys need to stop criticising everything due to pop culture.
This only shows the individual powers of the sword man, has nothing to do with which kind of sword is better. But in fact Chinese swords and martial arts are the ancestors of Japanese swords and martial arts.
You better provide solid evidence to back up ur claim, not making a baseless claim. The martial arts part is debatable. But Katana is actually derived from Warabiteto (it's stated on online articles). Tang Dao theory is controversial.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 yea and warabiteto is based off of Han dynasty swords from China. Japan crossed over in both Han and Tang Dynasty to study the culture and technologies. Not only swords, most of the famous Japanese culture are adopted from Tang, such as their armor, tea, building designs, and Sakura. U know, at that time Sakura was Tang Dynasty’s national flower, not Japanese
Hmm I read the comments alittle Starclan forgive meh for that...(¬_¬) anyway...i personally believe The Katana blade is more effective mostly because it's not just a cutting edge sword weapon For it can be used in many ways Much like how it was shown here Though considerately I like both Forms of style of the swords The only rlly thing I dislike The katana for is it's two held handling yh u'll be getting more Of a powerful strike holding it Properly but I'm a guy that would Be one handed I dunno why but that's how I would like welding It I can see the two hand gripping Being effective for good one slice kills in a instant but like Someone else already mentioned It rlly depends on the welder Of the sword rather thnn the Weapon itself for if ur technique Is flawless and perfect so will the Sword will become....imo...
A dao sword can legit cut through bambo like it’s air, and China recently found a well maintained sword that’s so sharp, you can stab through 3 sets of medieval armor
@@subhendusaha3629 like it or not katana are Chinese tech. Now chinese industry is putting Japanese industry out of service. While India can't even make toilet. So why you speak So loud. Lol. Nobody cares about your low IQ respect.
@@sharketm7655 ya Chinese are known to copy and paste.. a good xerox machine you are indeed. It's sad to know that a xerox machine feels proud about itself.
When in a sword fight, your movements are very important. You guys were just being too flashy, do not get me wrong. Katana dominates the Chinese blades. It's just how it is and if these guys were Bandits as it looks to be and they were taking on someone of a skilled Warrior like a samurai they would not come out of it a lot of that is very true. However exaggeration leads to your downfall, and downfall equals Death. So the next time you guys make a movie like that make the movements more believable.
"Katana dominates the Chinese blades" this tells me here you know nothing about martial arts or sword fighting and are biased for the Japanese blades. A Chinese swordsman can beat a Samurai and vice versa it doesn't matter on the blade.
I think u better do a proper research before u make any comment. Katana is actually derived from Warabiteto, maybe it did added some elements from Tang Dao.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 the earliest linage katana shape weapon is from Han dynasty huanshou dao which later influences Chinese tang dao also Korea and Japanese weapons. No matter what you think. Katana indeed have multiple Chinese linage sources. Japan has preserved some very good tang dao, they got from Tang Dynasty. That date way back before katana is invented.
@@ozimandias7866 no Gautama taught shaolin monks. Shaolin is just one type of Kung fu. Chinese martial arts date back to qin dynasty, before Buddhism arrived China. Most Chinese martial art has nothing to do with shaolin
Why am I watching this
good question
Good
Because of curiosity?
His childhood dream of becoming action hero came true on UA-cam.
Why is everyone hatin'? It's campy and cheesy and actually has some cool moves
because these katana weeb usually look down on Chinese and European swordmanship. For them katana is god
This is a bit bias. When it comes to sword, what matters is the person who yield it not the weapons itself.
well actually yes the weapons do matter especially if both combatants are equal in skill, because sometimes the victor is determined by whose sword isn't broken, like if your using a sword breaking sword and your opponent isn't
But did any of the dao swords crack. If the person who wield the swords takes good care of their swords, used it correctly or practice their skill often, they could be able to beat other sword yielder. And those Dao yielder didn’t yield it correctly.
And when I say biased. Just look at it. In the beginning much of the Dao user were Kick in the butt in the beginning with out a swords fighter.
@@codyshi4743 keep in mind I said both combatants are equal in skill then that would also mean that they both keep their swords in top shape, if you were to put both swords against each other and both swords are in pristine condition one sword being a katana and the other a dao then the dao would likely outlast the katana because the katana is rigid and the dao flexible, the point is that some swords are built better than others and I should also point out that the quality of the swords is not the only variable in a sword fight
Interesting.
The best are the sound effects! Intro was also cool with the bamboo flute...
Even tho those is slapstick and comedic it's still decent form
The Kahana in some instances can be considered a two handed liuyedao but all on all a good video in the humoristic sense
in China only "Xiu Chun Dao" can fight katana.【绣春刀】
Isn't it called Miao Dao? It's actually based on Katana, its design is almost identical to that of Odachi.
Обалдеть)) Это место где мы рисовали раньше... Я там жил с рождения в паре км )))))
Жаль что сейчас все снесли
You know a lot about Japan, you know too little about China
Its just a couple of boys swordfighting in the woods, harmless
Улыбнуло)) Очень круто) видно что с душой снято)) молодцы, давайте в том же духе)
Full of mistake.why the katana guy using traditional Chinese Taoist sittng pose?and those chinese swords man using stage props sword(soft sword).who's gonna use a soft sword to fight?you can only see it in 60-80s Hong kong cinema.but is 21st century guys.not even in the movies now
When you did one fee day of martial arts
Katana is shit compared to chinese broad sword, chinese sword was used in battle field in used for cut and break armor, katana will easily break when hit with chinese broad sword
Japanese uses other weapons as well. But when it comes to war in ancient time, of course China has the overwhelming advantage, it was a bigger nation with more resources. However if it was a 1v1 combat battle, it's actually debatable.
Practicality asides, Katana does look more cool than Jian. Katana also bares a significant meaning in Japanese culture whereas Jian is nothing more than a tool in Chinese culture; that alone makes a lot of difference.
Many Samurai class Japanese were descended from Ainu and Jomon, they were fierce warriors, I don't think Chinese soldiers could handle them in a close combat fight.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 dont get media or anime blind you, go search the history record, ancient japanese was extremely short, most of the average height of samurai only 5 feet, just imagine fighting with dwarf, ancient China give Japan a name called woguo ,which mean short country, beside the japan is lack of steel, doubt the katana quality can against China weapon
@@stevej1235 Katana is more than that, it bares a significant meaning. Whereas in Chinese culture, any weapon is nothing more than a tool. This makes Chinese culture looks a lot plainer compare to that of Japanese and that alone makes a lot of difference.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 lol, go kiss your katana when can't even defend a heavy strike from China broadsword, every weapon is a tool for war, it's meaningless if your weapon is not efficient
Katana vs Tang dao,miao dao,dandao,wodao and dadao
F
Looks like somebody prefers Japanese form or Chinese form
Katana is the noob in the world Chinese sword is the pro
when a weeboo call upon the power of anime
Atleast stop mocking chinese culture
I'm a fan of japanese swords but lets be realistic here,
Dual wielding is superior
I want chinese butterfly sword wing chun
So very incorrect
why?
The way they fight is not the real style.
@@mariasanchezm.364 Katanas suck ass
The MOST awesome Cheetos commercial ever cause its the most cheese you can get!
Not hate, humor. You sound like the h8 is cuming from u. @@pootonz5810
Luas Martinez LoL
it is rude to use the katana as a stick to stand up
Katana fanboys detected
Weaboo
Wtf am I watching
I recognize the music.. Command and Conquer Generals.. Chinese faction
That day you sing in the videos not a real Chinese dao . The down there using is used in wu Shu, for only performance.the real Chinese down will be not so flexible like this sword .and customer is a Vikas word because it is very lengthy and not flexible enough with dao . And the people you are using or not so real
It was a lot of fun I thought. People seem to be taking it as some sort of example of technical swordsmanship. I hope you aren't the kinds of people that watch Kung Fu hustle and expect to be able to do the palm technique ... lol. Or perhaps you criticize the form and historical correctness of the axe gang instead of watching the actual movie? This is very clearly for entertainment and filled with funny stereotypes. It's amusing.
Chinese and Japanese swords have very different handling and application. With the weight, balance point and method of use - you'd expect the reach and technical differences to cause quite an awkward battle here. The video showcases the supposed superiority of the Japanese swordsman because of his better skill and experience. A master vs 3 students. Something like Starwars. A knight vs some pesky Padawan's. Don't take it too seriously. The Japanese swordsman here is the big boss and the others not so much. Enjoy it for what its for.
It's a pleasure to meet understanding. Thank you
Ay....the guy with the dao didnt shout WU NAN TIAN DI
This is untrue double dao/ dao has more potential than that this is an insult to Kung fu
That’s not a chinese sword. A chinese sword is way better than a katana. That is a fact. What you have in this video is some sort of pirate sword. This video shows nothing on China’s true powers, and everyone thinks Japanese weapons are stronger simply because the Japanese is more popular, and that China is facing bad reputation. And you didn’t even spell Chinese right. Also, a Dao sword is much much MUCH more sharper than a katana. A well maintained dao sword can cut through bambo like its air. A katana cannot do that. A dao sword also does not look like a floppy disk.
Your comment tells me that u clearly do not understand Japanese culture! First of all, Katana is mainly used for slicing flesh and u Chinese are underestimating the Samurais!
im starting to see alot of obvious endings. most of the films on this outside of asia, the katana always wins. most of the films IN asia (cept japan mostly) especially in hong kong and china, the Dao wins
bruh hong kong IS in China
Whip chain vs katana
Karate still can’t beat kung fu
Tbf it actually depends upon the skill of the master and same goes for swordsmenship. The person with the better skill will usually win 7/10 times no matter the equipment. As long as ome side doesn't have more technological advantages then the person then they will usually win. An expert Muey Thai fighter or Karate fighter will generally beat a moderate or average Kung Fu fighter and same goes Vice versa honestly you guys need to stop criticising everything due to pop culture.
you guys know on what weapon the Katana is based, do you?
Horst Nasenblut the one handed liuyedao
@@velazquezarmouries yep. Someone that knows it!
Horst Nasenblut there are a lot of dao varieties that the katana is a carbon copy of
Horst Nasenblut also the steel of which a dao might be made of its harder than some katanas of the epoca
@@velazquezarmouries ok thanks i didn't known this. Thanks for the information
Do you not know how to spell chinese
This only shows the individual powers of the sword man, has nothing to do with which kind of sword is better. But in fact Chinese swords and martial arts are the ancestors of Japanese swords and martial arts.
You better provide solid evidence to back up ur claim, not making a baseless claim.
The martial arts part is debatable. But Katana is actually derived from Warabiteto (it's stated on online articles). Tang Dao theory is controversial.
Yes large part of Japanese culture has sino root. But Japanese basically developed their culture in isolation. There's still a difference.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 yea and warabiteto is based off of Han dynasty swords from China. Japan crossed over in both Han and Tang Dynasty to study the culture and technologies. Not only swords, most of the famous Japanese culture are adopted from Tang, such as their armor, tea, building designs, and Sakura. U know, at that time Sakura was Tang Dynasty’s national flower, not Japanese
@@YAOZII men I love their cherry bloosom
que malo
It's Chinese not chenese
Katana vs cheese swords
So u compare the two different disciplines in swords with a parody ? Wat a joke.
Wow
喜欢❤
神经视频
Ta pensando q um sabre chinês autêntico e brincadeira é???!!!
Quero ver se brinca com a mio dao
Hmm I read the comments alittle
Starclan forgive meh for that...(¬_¬) anyway...i personally believe
The Katana blade is more effective mostly because it's not just a cutting edge sword weapon
For it can be used in many ways
Much like how it was shown here
Though considerately I like both
Forms of style of the swords
The only rlly thing I dislike
The katana for is it's two held handling yh u'll be getting more
Of a powerful strike holding it
Properly but I'm a guy that would
Be one handed I dunno why but that's how I would like welding It
I can see the two hand gripping
Being effective for good one slice kills in a instant but like
Someone else already mentioned
It rlly depends on the welder
Of the sword rather thnn the
Weapon itself for if ur technique
Is flawless and perfect so will the
Sword will become....imo...
A dao sword can legit cut through bambo like it’s air, and China recently found a well maintained sword that’s so sharp, you can stab through 3 sets of medieval armor
This sword can shatter a katana, and dao swords aren’t floppy plastic disks
No Chinese sword can do everything katana does. Stop weebing
Q palhaçada .a espada japonesa e de verdade as chinesas só p apresentação
Por quê?
Porque elas envergam quando tu movimenta elas rápido?
Nice video
Thank you!
Katana is not a sword
It is a masterpiece
Yes learn from the Chinese Tang Danysty. Japanese made it curve only. like everything in Japanese traditional culture.
@@sharketm7655 curved or straight they are respected all over the world for their art and technology. That is not the case about China .
@@subhendusaha3629 like it or not katana are Chinese tech.
Now chinese industry is putting Japanese industry out of service. While India can't even make toilet. So why you speak So loud. Lol.
Nobody cares about your low IQ respect.
@@sharketm7655 ya Chinese are known to copy and paste.. a good xerox machine you are indeed. It's sad to know that a xerox machine feels proud about itself.
@@subhendusaha3629 Why you talk so much.
US is India "best friend" and you can even copy their toilet!
Would be cool if they really were asians
По сути постановка боев не плохая,просто надо чуть быстрее
haha some bs
need some blood
this is bs and would would never happen
today they use uzi's
Se tivesse mio dao e wo dao
日本刀根本無法承受古中國那種砍刀的劈砍，會直接砸斷日本刀。日本刀太脆弱了，甚至切到骨頭都會導致崩刃，結果是整把刀都報廢
無法理解這個片想表達什麼，從頭到尾都是錯的
认真就输了
乡民😂😂
Интересный факт: китайский дао и японский катана пишутся одним иероглифом.
А именно - 刀
Так что если называть китайский дао катаной, вы не ошибетесь.
When in a sword fight, your movements are very important. You guys were just being too flashy, do not get me wrong. Katana dominates the Chinese blades. It's just how it is and if these guys were Bandits as it looks to be and they were taking on someone of a skilled Warrior like a samurai they would not come out of it a lot of that is very true. However exaggeration leads to your downfall, and downfall equals Death. So the next time you guys make a movie like that make the movements more believable.
"Katana dominates the Chinese blades" this tells me here you know nothing about martial arts or sword fighting and are biased for the Japanese blades. A Chinese swordsman can beat a Samurai and vice versa it doesn't matter on the blade.
Looks like that 98 Chinese did not like this! :D
Lol good 😁
Sure why not. I’m just saying.
Anyway, katala has an ancestor who is the "tang dao" origin from china !!! I like it !!!!!
Gautam Buddha came from india and taught martial arts so 🤷🏾♂️🤷🏾♂️🤷🏾♂️
I think u better do a proper research before u make any comment. Katana is actually derived from Warabiteto, maybe it did added some elements from Tang Dao.
@@jackjackyphantom8854 the earliest linage katana shape weapon is from Han dynasty huanshou dao which later influences Chinese tang dao also Korea and Japanese weapons. No matter what you think. Katana indeed have multiple Chinese linage sources. Japan has preserved some very good tang dao, they got from Tang Dynasty. That date way back before katana is invented.
@@ozimandias7866 no Gautama taught shaolin monks. Shaolin is just one type of Kung fu. Chinese martial arts date back to qin dynasty, before Buddhism arrived China. Most Chinese martial art has nothing to do with shaolin
@@papercat2599 But the existence of Warabiteto is a contradiction to the Tang Dao theory. In most sources, Warabiteto thesis is more accepted.