T&S: Umpire Vic Carapazza should be punished by the MLB
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 лип 2024
- Tim and Sid revisit Friday's Indians/Jays game and the controversy caused by Umpire Vic Carapazza's questionable strike-zone which resulted in the ejection of Encarnacion, Martin and Gibbons.
----------------------------------------------
Subscribe to Sportsnet on UA-cam - sprtsnt.ca/YTSub
Follow Sportsnet online - www.sportsnet.ca
Follow Sportsnet on Facebook - sprtsnt.ca/YTFB
Follow Sportsnet on Twitter - sprtsnt.ca/YTTWTR
Follow Sportsnet on Instagram - sprtsnt.ca/YTINST
Follow Sportsnet on Snapchat - sprtsnt.ca/YTSNAP - Спорт
I am not a Blue Jays fan (nor Indians, either). I am a baseball fan, so I had the last 12-13 innings on (the MLB TV network). Your comments on Carapazza here are spot-on. What a disgrace. In this year of terrible umpiring, this was the apex. BTW, it was 12 called out on strikes -- 11 of those 12 on Toronto players. I didn't see the Encarnacion/Gibbons ejections, but did see the Martin ejection, and Carapazza clearly initiated it. It was the end of an inning, and as Martin slowly walked toward his dugout, Carapazza FOLLOWED him (rather than walking to the mound, to the Cleveland bench -- to anywhere but to escalate a situation where he knew that he'd get his chance to toss Martin)! I've already written MLB. I expect zero response, but if you media types stay with it, maybe something positive can occur. Especially with these guys that apparently want the spotlight (not just Carapazza; see "Cowboy" Joe West, e.g.), a relegation-type system might just work. Keep paying them their usual salary, so their union will have trouble adequately complaining, but demote them to triple-A (and promote good umps from that level). Repeat issues? Double-A and Single-A are available. I believe that we're seeing more poor umpiring and grudge attitudes because these umps are angry at being reversed so often on video appeal.Frankly, giving Carapazza a seat for a couple weeks -- without public explanation -- might get the message across to him and his brethren. Hell, they might even try to retrain him some during the time he sits?
Take Angel Hernandez & Joe West with him.
fhfs joe west isn't that bad, but angel Hernandez is on a whole another level. He doesn't pay enough attention to make conclusive decisions on balls and strikes, and on the bases. Guys like Angel Hernandez, and Vic Carripaza need to get terminated from the mlb
+fhfs as well as Ron Kulpa, Bob Davidson, and Will Little
Substitute C.B. Bucknor for Joe West.
Did Sid just call Carapazza a Deusche bag?👏🏻Good for him! 👍🏻I completely agree with what Tim says. Carapazza should be booted from baseball! 👂🏻I heard stories that 🤔Major League Baseball is considering suspending Carapazza. I really hope he does get suspended and for an extremely long time!
yeah carapazza is a jerk
Yah I'm 1 3rd German. My maternal Grandmother comes from Berlin. Did you know that Deusche means Body in German? So roughly translated Carapazza is a body bag.
Excuse me? There is more than one way to say the word Deusche. You can also say Deusche in German which translates to body in English. Trust me, my mother is half German. Don't believe me? Just go to Germany and look at the body wash bottles in the drug store or just ask my mom and grandma.
DOUCHE ya douche
his cousin is Rich Garcia
I umpire myself so I usually dont like to hear people bash the umpires, but you guys did it in a funny way so thumbs up.
Carapazza let the game into extras because he heard that it's time and a half pay on Canada Day
***** dude, it's a joke and you missed the joke completely. So, let me explain:
July 1st is Canada Day and people get their hourly pay 1.5x, so by having the game extended, people, like this umpire, got paid more.
All this other stuff you're arguing back, i never brought up. A
Also, you wait almost 3 months to make this comment?
Umpires are rated each game plate work and base. if their work is poor and doesn't improve over time (yrs) they will be fired
jon leonard when was the last time u heard of an umpire being fired? I haven't in years
My friend angel campus did work minor league from A level to triple A baseball for seven years. And was a pro umpire for about 6-7 years and in 2014 was released. So their are umpires who get released and many who work as fill-in umpires for vacations, injuries. These umpires are rated and some get jobs but many do not.
@ruffo coyote That pitch was actually off the plate, the indepth analysis at Brooks baseball and the UEFL had the pitch outside. Sorry for being 3+ years late
I love these guys so much! I agree with what they are saying!
Ricky J Sports same
Me too
Ricky J Sports same here
Booting carapazza? I'm in
show video of the umps calls
Give Vic some glasses!
MLB has the most unprofessional, egotistical umpires in sports. There are disagreements between players and officials in every sport but at the very least, the refs in basketball and hockey, as well as football all communicate with the players and try to reason with them instead of trying to get back at them for ''showing them up''.
Sid boutta hit the biggest roast of 2016 in that thumbnail
It is not fair to compare baseball umpires to other sport officials when it comes to calling balls & strikes... You see well over 100 pitches and expected to get them all right which is hardest thing to do as Any sport official...
It's how they handle situations that makes them the worst. Umpires still get easy calls that other league officials get right. MLB has the most unprofessional, egotistical umpires in sports. There are disagreements between players and officials in every sport but at the very least, the refs in basketball and hockey, as well as football all communicate with the players and try to reason with them instead of trying to get back at them for ''showing them up''. Here's a ranking of all sports officials from best to worst:
1. NHL
2. NFL
3. NBA
4. MLB
@@thecaynuck4694 YOUR SO WRONG....
@@clachapelle NOPE. Just speaking the truth. Umpires are inconsistent and stupid as hell. Just former terrible players who never were good enough, so they take all their insecurities out on better players. Umpires are also so fat and obese, which juxtaposes the healthy nature of sports.
@@thecaynuck4694 YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I wonder if Carapazza watched this show & thought about calling his lawyers & file a slander lawsuit. The one brought up punishment for umpires who blow calls like suspension's & fines in Japan the umpire if he blows a call has to take a microphone & apologize to the fans for dishonoring the game
Carapazza has the shortest leash of all umps but basbeball coverage in U.S doesn't make that big of a deal out of it
Instead of booting him from the game, they are letting him call a playoff game. And guess who's playing, THE INDIANS! This guy is 1 inning in doing the same thing to the Yankees he did to the Blue Jays. What a disgrace by the MLB.
A year later, he did it again with Pete Walker in a Jays-Indians matchup. Vic has a bias and loves blowing games in favor of the racist-named Indians.
@@thecaynuck4694 one there name wasn’t that bad2 he just heated the blue jays lol
@thecaynuck4694 offended wokester.
100% agreed! Umps are just trying to do their jobs, but this guy needs to be held accountable just like players are.
And today Ejected Shoemaker and Montoyo today for no reason Carapazza needs to be fired
ANY "close pitch" goes to the pitcher.
IF THE UMP IS CONSISTENT,
then the batters can adjust.
The ump wasn't consistent.
Umps need a reality check!!!
im a jays fan and I say kick him out
Even when he did that to Tulowitzki last playoffs
Because umpires can instigate bully antagonize and do whatever else they want to do because they carry around that little badge and where that little costume once again an Empire using his authority to exert his revenge on a team or individual player. typical .the major league actually umpires all levels really disappoint me my son is 16 and plays National level travel ball I have coached for over 12 years and been a baseball fan my entire life the state of umpires makes me sad the fact that the umpires are allowed to behave anyway they want but yet they hold the players and the coaches to set a high standard
And a year later he is one sided for the indians and is a horrible ump for the Yankees
I miss Tim & Sid. Both the radio and tv show.
T & S were right on. This was the first 6 min. of the show that I watched since Sept 21st 2016 when they cut off the Jays/Mariner game to cover a sport that was not being played and proved they could show the game by giving us a 30 sec clip.
Lmao “Are you gonna stand there like an asshat”
Circumstances
Anything ever happen from this?
suggesting umpire bet....without any way to validate....way worse than maybe missing 10 of 200 calls.....hope he sues........
The blue jays should have sued him for beating on the game
Tim and Sid...learn the game
They know the game. They rightly exposed a well-known corrupt umpire in Vic Carapazza, one of the worst umpires ever.
6 years later... No change at all
0:29- Really?
What annoys me is when a batter goes ballistic over a called strike when pitch track shows the ball clearly within the zone.
The call according to analysis of the zone was incorrect, dude.
You dint see half the calls my guy
Agree
When is someone going to scrutinize umpire backgrounds behind the scenes for any financial gain. I'm the realm of people getting monetary benefit start following the money for umpires and their families. Remember Occam's Razor - All variables being equal the simplest answer is typically the right one. It's my opinion, but these continuously outrageous calls are running rampant. Follow the money.
I saw this game..... Vic Carpazza sucks...
My worst nightmare is next year My Mets getting to The World Series next post season and Angel Hernandez being one of the umps. He is their Vic Carapazza
Ok, I do have to ask if you think that you can do a better than job than he did the try it! And yes I'm an umpire, and have been since 1990! Do people think that if you have a bad show you should be suspended?
Vic Carapazza should be punished. But, on the same token, You will NEVER be allowed to argue balls and strikes. Carapazza would say, If you argue a ball or a strike, you will get thrown out IMMEDIATELY. His father-in-law was a FORMER umpire. His name was Rich Garcia.
Yes I think we all understand that you get thrown out for arguing balls and strikes. That kinda goes without saying...That said, sometimes you gotta stick up for yourself and let the umpire know how wrong he is!
I know him as the guy who failed to call a blatant fan interference that gave the Yankees a home run.
I don't give a crap about the Blue Jays, but I LOVE watching umpires get reamed.
If he is consistent. Who cares?
He wasn't consistent and was getting calls wrong all night.
Those were good ejections...boo hoo
No they weren't, Vic baited both Edwin and Martin on that day. Also, his calls were wrong.
@@thecaynuck4694 You are the most clueless baseball fan I've ever seen. Stop trying, you don't know the game
@@thecaynuck4694 He didn't bait either one of them, it was handled textbook. This was over 3 years ago...get over it
@@zgaviation6481 I do know the game and all its rules, I'm actually a former umpire and player myself and also managed some teams. Truth be told, Vic's a terrible umpire who botches calls then lets his ego get to him, just like Ron Kulpa, the two incompetent smugass power-hungry umps. They're the sport equivalent of racist cops.
@@zgaviation6481 You blind? Martin walked away, while Vic kept shouting and baiting him, looking to throw another player. As the situation resolved, Vic was seen smirking and earlier highfived Lindor, which shows clear bias. I don't care if it was years ago, it shows how corrupt umpires can be. You sound like the racist who claims racism isn't a big deal since slavery was 200_ years ago.
second
Family guy brought me here
The Blue Jay's are next to last in their division!
As brass as Sid is, kinda miss seeing him on Tim and Sid. Not as entertaining anymore lol
You have no evidence, you should be ashamed of yourself!
God I hate talk radio. "Got to talk just to talk because that is what I'm paid for." These guys are full of s*^% just like the entire industry they are a part of. Thumbs down.
These guys have a solid point and are more successful than you. Your view just helps these. No one cares if you dislike, does nothing. You can't handle the truth that they show.
Who are these nitwits?
Truthful analysts. MLB has the most unprofessional, egotistical umpires in sports. There are disagreements between players and officials in every sport but at the very least, the refs in basketball and hockey, as well as football all communicate with the players and try to reason with them instead of trying to get back at them for ''showing them up''.
these guys are just talking as fans. see the strike zone with your eyes not with your heart.
They're not wrong but the problem is they're defending the Blue Jays, some of the biggest instigators in the game. They'll get little sympathy.
The Blue Jays are not the biggest instigators. This was Canada Day and it was obvious Vic had a vendetta.
THESE GUYS NEVER UMPIRED A DAY IN THEIR LIVES! UMPIRES HAVE A BAD DAY AND A GOOD DAYS UMPIRE DO NOT CHEAT FOR ONE TEAM OR ANOTHER. THESE GUYS NEED TO GO BACK TO BROADCASTING SCHOOL
carapazaa has a quick fuze look it up
Michael Heathman stop......clearly it was a joke & clearly carapaaza has an issue with the blue jays
All caps and an exclamation mark. You must have eaten paint chips as a child.
MLB has the most unprofessional, egotistical umpires in sports. There are disagreements between players and officials in every sport but at the very least, the refs in basketball and hockey, as well as football all communicate with the players and try to reason with them instead of trying to get back at them for ''showing them up''.
These bad umps remind me of the democrats...they do what they want and face no consequences
And you remind me of a republican: not having a single clue about what is going on here