If you came to the drugstore in Australia I bet you would leave with nothing! It's so expensive ! That physicians formula bronzer is about 30$, mac skin finish is about 45$ and the loreal lipsticks Are about 27$, the cover girl foundation is about 25$. So count yourself lucky you get those products at those prices!!
In Norway the only drustore Brands we have is maybelline, rimmel, loreal, garnier, Max factor and isadora, and a foundation is 33$ a lipstick is 20$ a mascara is 20$. We dont have benefit, urban dccay, tarte, stila, the balm:) And it's no target, wallmart, ulta, forever 21, victoriassecret, primark. It's rare to fin Mac and if you do it's not mutch of it, it's a LITTLE part of a makeup shop😁
Judy I have to give it to you. Idk how you do it, taking care of a little adorable baby girl, dealing with personal issues, work, marriage, and still devote your time to all of us... Always with a smile on your face at that. I've been watching you for almost a year now, and you are truly an inspiration to be the best me. Thanks Judy & Benji as well!! :) Love, Jocelynn :)
yes it does, it looks orange a few hours later, it oxidizes. It actually makes my face look worse, it brings out the little pimples on my forehead rather than conceal them. I still have the full bottle tucked away in my drawer
I love the canyon stone pallet! I found it in my makeup bag the other day and I have been using the dark brown for my eyebrows! I got it on Clearance a long time ago. Glad to know they still make it!
if you have dryer skin pick revlon, the covergirl outlast is a bit drying but it lasts longer, looks fresher on the skin, and doesnt feel heavy as revlon. ive used both, even the whipped formula but i have to say covergirl blows revlon out the water if youre an oily skin girl.
Wow, it's crazy how different each person's reaction to EOS lip balm is. I love mine. I used it the first night I got it right before bed, and my lips felt amazing the next morning.
whoa that under eye concealer looks great. i clicked on this video and you just looked like you were glowing and i didn't know why until u talked about the concealer
Girl I use the infinity quad too, I love it. My favorite is Autumn Leaves and I keep it in my makeupbag. It was also my first makeup item ever..which I took from my mom when I was in high school lol!
I have fairly oily skin, the Maybelline BB Cream works very well for me. I pair it with Revlon Nearly Naked Powder and it's a nice, light feeling coverage.
I have very oily skin. The Maybelline BB Cream worked out well for me. Though, I did use CoverGirl's oily skin powder, which I totally recommend, I love the BB Cream's coverage.
After watching your Cover Girl 3in1 foundation first impressions video, I had to try it out. I love it! It helps when you mention the color you are wearing so I can choose my collor accordingly! I am also in 840! Love, love, love your first impressions and demo videos!
Me too, it would be interesting to see a comparison video with BB creams ranging from "drug store" to high end, and from Asian BB creams to the European ones. I've seen some other comparison videos but no one elses videos even come close to how helpful and informative Judys videos are.
I've tried it, its an okay product for me. I have oil combo to dry skin, it changes through out the day but anyways, the bb cream doesn't offer much coverage but I think its great to even out the skin tone. It didn't make my skin oily. I honestly think it would be better off as a primer or for days where where you don't need a lot on. I'm traveling in March and I'm defiantly bringing it with me! Oh and Its super light weight.
i also returned the maybelline bb cream. it also made me oily. i'll have to give the CG foundation a try. i ordered two of the elf blush so im anxious to try it out. if i like i might have to get more. :)
i TOTALLY agree w/you about the CG foundation!! i hadn't used liquid in yrs and bought a lancome one to start with. it was ok, but seemed alittlle too sheer. i kept seeing reviews to the CG and decided to try it...omg, its amazing!! i love it so much more than the lancome!! wow
Oh, and I'm SO glad somebody besides me likes the L'Oreal BB cream. I think it's PERFECT for a light look during the weekend when you're out running errands.
Agreed on the EOS -- I tried so hard to love them, but it actually took lot of moisturizing (carmex and blistex) to repair my dry lips after using those.
@alexa b Actually, I know that some stores in the United States will let you return things, even if you have opened it already. If you bought the wrong color for example you can exchange it to another one :)
Ur right about the EOS lip balm. The only reason i bought it is bcuz a lot of youtube guru said they were really moisturizing but when i tried it didnt last long and my $1 chapstick moisterize way longer.
I love my EOS. my lips chap really bad during the winter and I've tried almost everything, I bought the sweet mint EOS and it works wonders! idk about the rest although I have a few others, I only use that mint one.
I absolutely agrees with you about the EOS balms! I thought I was the only one who didn't care for them. I'm just using mine up so that way I don't waste my money!
I was unaware there was a "hype" for the eos lip spheres. I actually love mine in sweet mint. I developed an allergy from Carmex after many years of use. LOVE the Infallible Rouge lipsticks.
Agree with EOS. It's alright and smells nice, but you reapply it every twenty minutes to get any moisture. It seems the strawberry(pink?)it a bit more moisturizing, but I'll take BBW's lip and Burts Bees balms over it any day.
I agree with you on eos and loreal infallible lipstick. Eos is overpriced to me but didn't feel like it moisterized my lips at all, just left it sticky. Infallible is amazing long wearing lipstick!
Nope, ur not the only one that use L'oreal Canyon Stone eye shadow Quad..I actually purchased it about a month ago b/c it was on clearance @Rite Aid..I love it!!
Absolutely agree with you except eos lip balm.... I would have loved them if they didn't smell good....the formula is awesome... Give it a second try Judy....am sure would change ur opinion
Yes! I totally agree, the EOS lip balms did nothing for me. I wanted to love them, but nope. I'll have to order those ELF baked blushes, since they're basically MSFs. Could by any chance compare ELF's baked blushes with Milani's baked blushes?
I saw on Nouveau Cheap that most of Physicians Formula's face makeup is on sale for 50% at CVS, and I'm not talking about BOGO1/2 :) I definitely want to try the bronzer because it will be around $7. Way more affordable.
I bought that new cover girl foundation because of you and i love it! And I've never been a fan of cover girl foundation, I've been using Revlon whipped foundation
last november revlon had a sale at melbourne show grounds, revlon colorstay was just $4.. I only got 2.. they announce those kinds of sale on their FB page, i hope they do it again!
The first makeup brand I used was Revlon & there was no turning back. Their foundation suits my oily/combination skin, eyeliner stays on for a long time & don't get me started on their lip products!
I use that same loreal quad i have had it for years and when i hit pan and tried to buy a new one i was disapointed to see that the color were diferent but then one day in the back of a store i saw two lonely original canyon stone quads in black packaging and bought them both.... never seen anymore again
I love love C V S brand Age Defying Towelettes with Collagen , Vitamin C and E with Retinol they smooth out your face using them daily to remove makeup and before bed. The best part is they only cost 2.99. They are amazing.
I agree with you on the eos lipbalm...nothing special about them in my opinion. Love this video Judy...very helpful as usual! I'm gonna check out those baked blushes from elf!
Yay!!! I'm not the only one that doesn't like the EOS lip balm! I tried it & I hated it. I love my Burt's bees lip balms. I've lived then since high school & that's around 10 yrs ago. :) I'm happy you did this video because I trust your opinions because you actually do video reviews & even without you saying anything the results can speak for themselves!
I totally agree with most of tour recommendations here! Except the elf stuff never tried those blushes before :) I can't wait to try the New CG foundation. It seems to be pretty popular and I think we have the same skintone so I'll be picking up that shade fo sho!
He judy! Can you do a eye liner review. Or your fave eye liners? I haven't seen you do a video like that I'm looking for a great eye liner. Thanks!!!!! You have the best makeup review. I can see how honest you are. Very real!!!!!!
I can't believe you're in natural beige (840) for the covergirl foundation! I just bought one and I'm in soft honey (857), but like.. I'm white you know, haha! I'm a little tan right now, but not that much.. I would've thought your complexion was darker than mine!
The EOS lip balms didn't do much for my lips either! There's tons of other lipbalms out there that are so much better!! I loved your makeup in this video, Judy! I love your videos soooo much! Xxx
Hi Judy thanks for sharing. Makeup in America is so cheap, I wished I lived there just to have access to high end cheap make up. I'm from Perth, Australia, we don't have Sephora and the drug store make up we have is ridiculously expensive. For example the maybelline colour tattoo gel liner is approximately aud$18. Revlon lip butters are about $24 and a revlon pressed powder goes for about $32. Thanks so much for the review!
Judy I love that L'Oreal quad too!!! I have looked at the new one and the colors are similar but are more of a satin finish vs. the mattes in this one. I found another one similar but it more of a cool taupey matte palette & that burnt orange color is the one I love the most that I can't seem to find a dupe for. ):
I had the cover girl foundation ITS AMAZING except I got a bit paler and I gave it to my sister because it was getting a little dark for me but its fabulous and so natural looking
Omg! Im frm the PH and im planning to try out the eos lip balms bec a lot are saying that its moisturizing. I have prettty dry lips. Thanks for the feedback though! Might as stick with my same o'l chapstick
Have you ever done a video comparison about 2 step long lasting lipsticks, like loreal infaliable (benji's pronounciation) vs maybelline superstay vs revlon colorstay vs covergirl (whatever it is) and even vs revlon lip stain with the balm. It'd be interesting to know which you like best and why you seem to like loreal infaliable better than the other two step long lasting products.
I 100% agree on the eos lip balms. They don't do much at all for me. And some smell really good but taste bad. I bought two one day to try them out because everyone loved them and then I hated them as have them to my sister because she claims she likes them. I think she just likes that they are so popular.
I need to check out that gel eyeliner by L'Oreal cause I, too, have a Bobbi Brown eyeliner and as much as I LOVE it, I don't want to use it up cause of the price. How do you feel about Mac's Fluidline? I love theirs as well. Never tried Physician's Formula cause of price (that's sad) and you are so right about EOS balms. Smell great but can't moisture for jack! I've bought about 5 of them, thinking different ones would do the job, and all have failed.
I agree, the EOS didn't really moisturized :\ I prefer the Burt's bee lip balm instead >.<
thanks!! Revlon Matte lipstick in Pink Pout and Loreal infallible legloss in Pretty Precious
If you came to the drugstore in Australia I bet you would leave with nothing! It's so expensive ! That physicians formula bronzer is about 30$, mac skin finish is about 45$ and the loreal lipsticks Are about 27$, the cover girl foundation is about 25$. So count yourself lucky you get those products at those prices!!
Omg :o
Your wages are almost double what ours are though. Consider yourself lucky that you get paid so much!
In Norway the only drustore Brands we have is maybelline, rimmel, loreal, garnier, Max factor and isadora, and a foundation is 33$ a lipstick is 20$ a mascara is 20$. We dont have benefit, urban dccay, tarte, stila, the balm:)
And it's no target, wallmart, ulta, forever 21, victoriassecret, primark.
It's rare to fin Mac and if you do it's not mutch of it, it's a LITTLE part of a makeup shop😁
Judy I have to give it to you. Idk how you do it, taking care of a little adorable baby girl, dealing with personal issues, work, marriage, and still devote your time to all of us... Always with a smile on your face at that. I've been watching you for almost a year now, and you are truly an inspiration to be the best me. Thanks Judy & Benji as well!! :)
Love, Jocelynn :)
I'm watching this in 2015 ... You're so cute Judy .. Different in a good way 👌🏼
I found for me ive tried like 3 different eos balms, and the one that works really good and keeps moisture is the Pomegranate one.
I dont mean to compare but i watch judy more than michelle phan :) i just find judy more convincing than the other one :)
I agree, the L'Oreal Infallible lipsticks are amazing! I love the pigmentation, texture, and how long they stay on the lips. Great product!
i hate the covergirl 3 in 1 outlast foundation. everyone loves them
mee 2, it looks cakey on me
yeah it looked so cakey and orange on me. it also weared off so quickly. by the end of the day, all my makeup was gone.
yes it does, it looks orange a few hours later, it oxidizes. It actually makes my face look worse, it brings out the little pimples on my forehead rather than conceal them. I still have the full bottle tucked away in my drawer
95klopez A little goes a long way with that foundation and if you put a loose powder on before your foundation, it looks great!
yes definitely! and I never thought of that, I usually put powder on top because of my oily T-zone
I love the canyon stone pallet! I found it in my makeup bag the other day and I have been using the dark brown for my eyebrows! I got it on Clearance a long time ago. Glad to know they still make it!
i like the fact that you are a bargain hunter your simplicity and your honesty. Thanks so much judy I love your videos....
if you have dryer skin pick revlon, the covergirl outlast is a bit drying but it lasts longer, looks fresher on the skin, and doesnt feel heavy as revlon. ive used both, even the whipped formula but i have to say covergirl blows revlon out the water if youre an oily skin girl.
Wow, it's crazy how different each person's reaction to EOS lip balm is. I love mine. I used it the first night I got it right before bed, and my lips felt amazing the next morning.
whoa that under eye concealer looks great. i clicked on this video and you just looked like you were glowing and i didn't know why until u talked about the concealer
Girl I use the infinity quad too, I love it. My favorite is Autumn Leaves and I keep it in my makeupbag. It was also my first makeup item ever..which I took from my mom when I was in high school lol!
Judy and people that dont like the eos lip balm i saw that first but i keep trying more and the meditated tangerine one is a lot more moisturizing!!!!
I have fairly oily skin, the Maybelline BB Cream works very well for me. I pair it with Revlon Nearly Naked Powder and it's a nice, light feeling coverage.
I have very oily skin. The Maybelline BB Cream worked out well for me. Though, I did use CoverGirl's oily skin powder, which I totally recommend, I love the BB Cream's coverage.
After watching your Cover Girl 3in1 foundation first impressions video, I had to try it out. I love it! It helps when you mention the color you are wearing so I can choose my collor accordingly! I am also in 840! Love, love, love your first impressions and demo videos!
I Have eos lipbalms. And yeah they dont moisturize well specially in winter. But smells so good and its still nice to use under colored lipsticks.
Me too, it would be interesting to see a comparison video with BB creams ranging from "drug store" to high end, and from Asian BB creams to the European ones. I've seen some other comparison videos but no one elses videos even come close to how helpful and informative Judys videos are.
I've tried it, its an okay product for me. I have oil combo to dry skin, it changes through out the day but anyways, the bb cream doesn't offer much coverage but I think its great to even out the skin tone. It didn't make my skin oily. I honestly think it would be better off as a primer or for days where where you don't need a lot on. I'm traveling in March and I'm defiantly bringing it with me! Oh and Its super light weight.
i also returned the maybelline bb cream. it also made me oily. i'll have to give the CG foundation a try. i ordered two of the elf blush so im anxious to try it out. if i like i might have to get more. :)
Yes! ,I just purchased Cover Girls Stay Fabulous 3 in 1 foundation and i love it! So exited that this made your "favorite" list..,
i TOTALLY agree w/you about the CG foundation!! i hadn't used liquid in yrs and bought a lancome one to start with. it was ok, but seemed alittlle too sheer. i kept seeing reviews to the CG and decided to try it...omg, its amazing!! i love it so much more than the lancome!! wow
Oh, and I'm SO glad somebody besides me likes the L'Oreal BB cream. I think it's PERFECT for a light look during the weekend when you're out running errands.
Agreed on the EOS -- I tried so hard to love them, but it actually took lot of moisturizing (carmex and blistex) to repair my dry lips after using those.
@alexa b Actually, I know that some stores in the United States will let you return things, even if you have opened it already. If you bought the wrong color for example you can exchange it to another one :)
I really like the sweet mint EOS lip balm, but not the other ones... It has a cooling feeling and actually seems more hydrating unlike the others.
Ur right about the EOS lip balm. The only reason i bought it is bcuz a lot of youtube guru said they were really moisturizing but when i tried it didnt last long and my $1 chapstick moisterize way longer.
Definitely agree about the EOS lip balms. They're cute to carry around but are not the greatest for moisturizing the lips, at all.
I love my EOS. my lips chap really bad during the winter and I've tried almost everything, I bought the sweet mint EOS and it works wonders! idk about the rest although I have a few others, I only use that mint one.
I absolutely agrees with you about the EOS balms! I thought I was the only one who didn't care for them. I'm just using mine up so that way I don't waste my money!
I was unaware there was a "hype" for the eos lip spheres. I actually love mine in sweet mint. I developed an allergy from Carmex after many years of use. LOVE the Infallible Rouge lipsticks.
I definitely have that Loreal Quad.. and I'm not one to mess around with eye shadow too much, but it's my go-to easy choice. :)
I completely agree about the EOS lip balms. I have several of them. They are very cute, but I don't find them to be very moisturizing......
revlon colorstay
Most stores allow that. If you have the receipt you can definitely do that and some stores give you a store credit if you do not have the receipt.
I also wear the Loreal wear infinity quads...they're great! I have some pretty old ones, too. I still wear them.
Agree with EOS. It's alright and smells nice, but you reapply it every twenty minutes to get any moisture. It seems the strawberry(pink?)it a bit more moisturizing, but I'll take BBW's lip and Burts Bees balms over it any day.
I agree with you on eos and loreal infallible lipstick. Eos is overpriced to me but didn't feel like it moisterized my lips at all, just left it sticky. Infallible is amazing long wearing lipstick!
i agree with eos balms they look cute and people ask what is it but they suck they dont do anything for mosturizing the lips at all, loved this video!
That L'oreal quad is amazing...I remember there were my first eyeshadows :) the package has changed but the colors are the same :)
I love, love, the elf blush!! I just wish they had them at stores. I have to wait and save to buy from the website, so the shipping is worth it.
I have had a 2 day marathon of your videos Judy lol I find your videos informative and comforting to watch :) never stop!!!! Xoxox Kate
I have that Loreal Wear Infinity Palette. It has the same physical packaging but the name on it is a bit different. I LOVEEEE IT!
I agree with the maybelline bb cream! It did not give me any coverage at all :( more like a tinted moisturizer
Nope, ur not the only one that use L'oreal Canyon Stone eye shadow Quad..I actually purchased it about a month ago b/c it was on clearance @Rite Aid..I love it!!
Absolutely agree with you except eos lip balm.... I would have loved them if they didn't smell good....the formula is awesome... Give it a second try Judy....am sure would change ur opinion
I love the eos. You have to try the one with Shea butter, it helps with dryness.
I love the Loreal infinity wear eyeshadows too! I have two that I use faithfully. I think one is the same as you.
love the elf products
Yes! I totally agree, the EOS lip balms did nothing for me. I wanted to love them, but nope. I'll have to order those ELF baked blushes, since they're basically MSFs. Could by any chance compare ELF's baked blushes with Milani's baked blushes?
Your lighting and foundation is amazing, you're glowing
I saw on Nouveau Cheap that most of Physicians Formula's face makeup is on sale for 50% at CVS, and I'm not talking about BOGO1/2 :) I definitely want to try the bronzer because it will be around $7. Way more affordable.
I bought that new cover girl foundation because of you and i love it! And I've never been a fan of cover girl foundation, I've been using Revlon whipped foundation
last november revlon had a sale at melbourne show grounds, revlon colorstay was just $4.. I only got 2.. they announce those kinds of sale on their FB page, i hope they do it again!
omg that l'oreal palate was my very very first eyeshadow palate and i still love it five years later
i SOOOO AGREEEEE... the maybelline's bb cream is oily for me and eos is moistirizing for like 5 mins!!!
The first makeup brand I used was Revlon & there was no turning back. Their foundation suits my oily/combination skin, eyeliner stays on for a long time & don't get me started on their lip products!
I use that same loreal quad i have had it for years and when i hit pan and tried to buy a new one i was disapointed to see that the color were diferent but then one day in the back of a store i saw two lonely original canyon stone quads in black packaging and bought them both.... never seen anymore again
I feel the same way about the Eos. It wasn't all that to me. I really want to try the ElF bakes blushes I think I'll order those!
I love love C V S brand Age Defying Towelettes with Collagen , Vitamin C and E with Retinol they smooth out your face using them daily to remove makeup and before bed. The best part is they only cost 2.99. They are amazing.
the new setup and lighting of your videos are so much better than the previous ones. :)
Totally agree about the maballine bb cream. It's soo oily, I used mine once and now it's sitting somewhere in the back of my bathroom cupboard
i recently bought that too. along with that I bought babylips.... which i like much better than colour whisper, even though it was half the price.
I agree with you on the eos lipbalm...nothing special about them in my opinion. Love this video Judy...very helpful as usual! I'm gonna check out those baked blushes from elf!
Judy please do a review on the H&M makeup line, especially the nude eyeshadow palettes!
i agree with you judy, i dislike the EOS stuff for lips...it's a negative for me because it doesn't moisture my lips at all, thanks for the video
I bought the new Covergirl foundation because of your review. It was such a nice detailed review. So I am excited to try it.
It is. She was saying that the loreal eyeliner was a drugstore dupe for the high end bobbi brown one. =)
Love how I can practically predict what Judy's favorites are just by watching her vlogs everyday :D
Yay!!! I'm not the only one that doesn't like the EOS lip balm! I tried it & I hated it. I love my Burt's bees lip balms. I've lived then since high school & that's around 10 yrs ago. :) I'm happy you did this video because I trust your opinions because you actually do video reviews & even without you saying anything the results can speak for themselves!
try Ecotools, you can find them at any drugstore or walmart. they are super soft and i still use mine to this day!
Whaaaaat? the eos lipbalms are my favorite! I'm a huge chapstick person and in my opinion those are by far the best!
I totally agree with most of tour recommendations here! Except the elf stuff never tried those blushes before :) I can't wait to try the New CG foundation. It seems to be pretty popular and I think we have the same skintone so I'll be picking up that shade fo sho!
Omg Judy I'm the same with the EOS lip balm!! It must be a Seattle thing!! (:
Your room actually does look nice with the pink and gold your dresser is really nice btw!
He judy! Can you do a eye liner review. Or your fave eye liners? I haven't seen you do a video like that I'm looking for a great eye liner. Thanks!!!!! You have the best makeup review. I can see how honest you are. Very real!!!!!!
I can't believe you're in natural beige (840) for the covergirl foundation! I just bought one and I'm in soft honey (857), but like.. I'm white you know, haha! I'm a little tan right now, but not that much.. I would've thought your complexion was darker than mine!
I always wish you would put the products you're wearing in your info section. Your lipstick is to die for!
The EOS lip balms didn't do much for my lips either! There's tons of other lipbalms out there that are so much better!! I loved your makeup in this video, Judy! I love your videos soooo much! Xxx
Hi Judy thanks for sharing. Makeup in America is so cheap, I wished I lived there just to have access to high end cheap make up. I'm from Perth, Australia, we don't have Sephora and the drug store make up we have is ridiculously expensive. For example the maybelline colour tattoo gel liner is approximately aud$18. Revlon lip butters are about $24 and a revlon pressed powder goes for about $32. Thanks so much for the review!
Can you please do another video just like this but this years favorites ? Please please please !!!!
Judy I love that L'Oreal quad too!!! I have looked at the new one and the colors are similar but are more of a satin finish vs. the mattes in this one. I found another one similar but it more of a cool taupey matte palette & that burnt orange color is the one I love the most that I can't seem to find a dupe for. ):
I agree, the EOS lip balms are far from my favorite. Another great video Judy! :)
I just love all your videos judy! they are so funny, informative, and you are just the sweetest youtuber
I had the cover girl foundation ITS AMAZING except I got a bit paler and I gave it to my sister because it was getting a little dark for me but its fabulous and so natural looking
I completely agree with the EOS! They smell great, they're cute, but def sucked for me bc it just felt like it sat on my lips & not moisturize.
Didn't like EOS either. I always bought one because they were cute, but didn't do much moisturizing. I'd always had to re-apply and peel my lips alot.
I am sooo glad to hear someone say that the EOS balms aren't worth it. They really don't moisturize at all!! or do what a balm is supposed to do! lol
Omg! Im frm the PH and im planning to try out the eos lip balms bec a lot are saying that its moisturizing. I have prettty dry lips. Thanks for the feedback though! Might as stick with my same o'l chapstick
Have you ever done a video comparison about 2 step long lasting lipsticks, like loreal infaliable (benji's pronounciation) vs maybelline superstay vs revlon colorstay vs covergirl (whatever it is) and even vs revlon lip stain with the balm. It'd be interesting to know which you like best and why you seem to like loreal infaliable better than the other two step long lasting products.
can you please do a makeup tutorial of the eye look you have on? i love that its a natural look!
I 100% agree on the eos lip balms. They don't do much at all for me. And some smell really good but taste bad. I bought two one day to try them out because everyone loved them and then I hated them as have them to my sister because she claims she likes them. I think she just likes that they are so popular.
@itsjudylife, I like the EOS medicated balm the best
I love it when Ingrid and Judy say each others' names. my two faves (":
As a Filipina, I am in awe at how you explained this maginificently.
I really like the baked blush. Is there BB cream for darker skin?
I need to check out that gel eyeliner by L'Oreal cause I, too, have a Bobbi Brown eyeliner and as much as I LOVE it, I don't want to use it up cause of the price. How do you feel about Mac's Fluidline? I love theirs as well. Never tried Physician's Formula cause of price (that's sad) and you are so right about EOS balms. Smell great but can't moisture for jack! I've bought about 5 of them, thinking different ones would do the job, and all have failed.