Red Tape and Corruption from an Unplanned Lock-down
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- This week Sucheta Dalal talks about India under lockdown, detailing the corruption and needless red tape obligations.
For more read: www.moneylife....
For more information visit our website : www.moneylife.in/
Register : www.moneylife.i...
Follow us on Facebook : / moneylifedailyclinics
Follow us on Twitter : / moneylifef
Sucheta, you can blame me too. I sheepishly kept quiet, when my poor fellow citizens were deprived of food, water & transportation. My society goons called in the police, when I fed 2 poor guys in my house.
MAM THIS COUNTRY GOES ON BECAUSE PEOPLE LIKE YOU EXIST HERE..
We need more hospitals less statues. Come on government build hospitals not statues.
I had great difficulty in getting blood for transfusion for my thalassemic child.
It seems few companies with manufacturing units in india will soon be exiting while the govt is chest thumping about bringing companies from china....infact a very few has commented that china may get more investments...it seems thats what gona happen & we may again miss the bus....sad reality
Hey Moron was there any kits available globally or PPE Kits masks etc. The global hub of manufacturing CHINA had to Import. without lockdown was there any other way this mass pandemic could have been stopped. In a country so vast and varied with so much poverty and assholes like you who instead of taking the realistic account of situation just rant and find faults. There would have been mountains of dead bodies which would have posed another difficulty of disposing them.
Thank you Ma'am for such an invigorating session.
Covid-19 has ripped from top to bottom the entire government structure formed on an illusion of democratic, republic and independent India. As a sovereign nation State we've failed to afford basic amenities to our citizens owing to our (citizens) colonial mindsets. We've not realised that the hitherto subjects became the power-givers under the Indian Constitution, and thus continued to be at the mercy of our political masters.
I'm sure this crisis will SHAKE all of us to the core and bring us to our senses.
I hope people will now ask for good public health infrastructure from their political leadership and not waste this unprecedented crisis as one more aberration.
And where will the money come from? Your Mame? Or will 20% suddenly pay taxes? Or will congress return the loot? Sophomoric and uninformed attempt to grab fame.
Hey Moron was there any kits available globally or PPE Kits masks etc. The global hub of manufacturing CHINA had to Import. without lockdown was there any other way this mass pandemic could have been stopped. In a country so vast and varied with so much poverty and assholes like you who instead of taking the realistic account of situation just rant and find faults. There would have been mountains of dead bodies which would have posed another difficulty of disposing them.
Cement prices are up by 35%...how they can construct? How will they get back jobs?
There is a "swabhav" (characteristic) of the govt that becomes clearer with each and every "sweeping change"
1.Lack of consultation
2. Desire for "optics" rather than substance - 56", aatm nirbhar, thali, Diya, blackmoney, one nation one tax
3. Lack of regard for citizens (no skin in the game so damn them)
4. Misleading by rearranging - inflation rate, year on year statistics, stimulus package is aggregation of existing schemes repackaged or putting your own money under a label
5. Creating a narrative around a persona - tears, bear grylls
6. Misuse of power to enrich businesses
7. Changing legislation to ensure perpetuation of his party.
A very incisive and thorough analysis of the prevailing situation in our country. Regrettably no corrective action will be take and things will go only from worse to the worst. One thing Ms.Dalal left out was the pathetic manner in which the shramik expresses are "lost" en-route; end up in faraway destinations and the harrowing survival-tales of the migrant-passengers, which adds another sad chapter to the lock down.
"Stupid is as stupid does"
- Forrest Gump
Hey Moron was there any kits available globally or PPE Kits masks etc. The global hub of manufacturing CHINA had to Import. without lockdown was there any other way this mass pandemic could have been stopped. In a country so vast and varied with so much poverty and assholes like you who instead of taking the realistic account of situation just rant and find faults. There would have been mountains of dead bodies which would have posed another difficulty of disposing them.
How was it any different earlier?
Though I agree to many points discussed here, opening or closing of airlines is an independent decision and has no relevance to poor migrants' struggle. Also the air traveller is allowed to travel only for the genuine reason and certainly not for a fun ride. If you want to bring the industry back it its activity, the entrepreneurs will naturally need this facility open.
Insightful and the TRUTH! Wish we could imprison all these crooks - no matter who they are - and free the country of thugs!
Very True and so well expressed. It seems that because of selective opinions which are made even more dangerous by the unlimited power they can draw upon, the country has had to pay, and is still paying a massive price in terms of Jaan and Jahaan.
Really appreciate... We should have courage to speak loudly.... It's really unplanned Act having no plan even after declaration of lockdown... There was no action for more than a month to provide Medical facility support even today it's not sufficient... The facts and figure are unclear and matter of questions.... At the same time you rightly said it's like License Raj again for every movement... There is no security of people and no support for those who are really suffering.... Let's appreciate them who are volunteer, doing good cause to serve needy on the street...
Hey Moron was there any kits available globally or PPE Kits masks etc. The global hub of manufacturing CHINA had to Import. without lockdown was there any other way this mass pandemic could have been stopped. In a country so vast and varied with so much poverty and assholes like you who instead of taking the realistic account of situation just rant and find faults. There would have been mountains of dead bodies which would have posed another difficulty of disposing them.
I regularly lessen yr videos. What happened to the Vadodra based Parma company who cheated bank and ran away ?? Please give some update.
Aftermath everybody seems to be intelligent
Thank you for the Voice.......for us......
N95 masks are sold at ₹350 here at Tamil Nadu.
This is how Indians act! No reason to get surprised.
Feku is the PM of India we have been fooled...... it's JUMLA.
@Herschey's options were like that at that time but can't be fooled 4 lifelong. Ahankar ke briksh pe binash ka fal ata hain rajan.
Hey Moron was there any kits available globally or PPE Kits masks etc. The global hub of manufacturing CHINA had to Import. without lockdown was there any other way this mass pandemic could have been stopped. In a country so vast and varied with so much poverty and assholes like you who instead of taking the realistic account of situation just rant and find faults. There would have been mountains of dead bodies which would have posed another difficulty of disposing them.
2 lakhs of N95 masks are produced per day as per the 17 May '20 8pm report for the last 2 months. Where are they going?
What is the meaning of "global expert"?
Sad
Post facto, everyone is intelligent.
Well said. State is weak financially as run mostly of deficits and whatever it intends to do is corroded by corruption and inefficiency.
Creating "event"in the name of public health ,life, vulnerable r left to die, hope the "Bhakts" open their eyes, we have to develop leadership amongst us , people of India
Hey Moron was there any kits available globally or PPE Kits masks etc. The global hub of manufacturing CHINA had to Import. without lockdown was there any other way this mass pandemic could have been stopped. In a country so vast and varied with so much poverty and assholes like you who instead of taking the realistic account of situation just rant and find faults. There would have been mountains of dead bodies which would have posed another difficulty of disposing them. So what if world & WHO praised it, but we should listen to one moron on youtube.
Sucheta Dalal must be congratulated for this lucid and insightful video. 👍🏾
Rich will get Richer...poor will die.... Middle class is wiped out.... No demand... 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
you are always...great.. madam... a voice for nothing but truth
Dear Madam
Also please explain the 20 lakh core package
Yes, i want that too.
Mam your delibration says that 24×7 that mr modi should have dreamt coronavirus and should have arrangements dro everybody
How is IDFC First able to give 7% on savings account without parking the funds in a FD? Is this another YES bank? Please can you cover banks that are now giving higher rates and whether it is safe for depositors. You will save a few lives!
IDFC first bank is in the hands Mr Vaidyanathan and not some crooks. You may check his professional career of how he managed Capital First Limited. It got merged with IDFC bank to get banking license. The health of IDFC bank was not good. So Its like starting from a scratch.
At present they want to increase the casa ratio so they are drawing more deposits from Public at present. And Bank is shifting business to retail loans from corporate loans as retail loans are less risky and generate more constant revenue streams.
Even Kotak Bank used to give higher interest till now on deposits.
So it's all on how is the management of the bank. Not all high interest paying banks will turn into Yes Banks
For India Lockdown is needed to be enforced because there is dearth of public facilities. We have to buy from corner shops for essentials, where you have to gaunt amidst the bags of rice, lentils, sugars and stretch ourselves to pay the owners. And then usually no toilets at many places like the bus station, the hospital, the markets, the list goes on. It's very common to see desperate people just shoot quickly at some stinking corner and the women let go through the underwear while standing.
And our sarkari adminstration that just panicked or dying to impress. They just emptied the civil hospital and within the minutes with a signage converted the essential institute into a covid19 center. As if opd for accidents and other life saving functions are no more important.
Mumbai's Dharavi has set a sad and sorry record of infection and death. Several plans for redevelopment
were considered but none accepted. Politicians or bureaucrats responsible must be identified and debarred from decision-making. The Syedna's initiative in re-housing the Bohris off Mohamedali Road provides a shining example of planning and execution. We are short of hospitals. We must make it mandatory that all memorials in the city, such as for Shivaji and Thackeray, should be in the form of hospitals. And slums should be banned. Much needed facilities will increase and corruption will decrease.
Vijay Menon
9820145529
What was the vested interest behind the "international article", don't TRUST anything at face value.
I follow this lady's advise when she speaks about the government's failure in handling the migrant workers, poor people and also the way private hospitals are looting the common man but one very important point she has missed. When she said that the casualty rate in india due to Covid19 is very less as compared to other countries and so she says Covid19 could have been treated as a mild sickness not requiring a hard lockdown. But one important factor she missed out of the equation is the lockdown itself. The hard lockdown itself is a major reason that India is having a very low casualty rate. We don't know what it would had been if a hard lockdown was not enforced but there are predictive reports saying that the death rate could have gone past 54000 by the end of April.
The elite will suffer when they need to get their car needs to be mended, barbers for a haircut, etc
Economy can be regained but not human life
Corona came from China 🇨🇳 and now everyone is suffering. Don’t let people rip you off by scaring you.
Numbers please madam, no one line generalizations. How many migrants have been ferried through the government efforts. Zero?
This is called critic’s wisdom in hindsight.
What would she have done on 24 th of March.
Transport 120 million migrants to their home villages in 5 days.
One train carries 1200 passengers. A bus -60 odd passengers.
1 lakh trains in 5 days. Impossible.
More important how many from where to where?
What happened to the migrants is tragic. But Ms Dalal’s tirade is that of a person who has never run large organisations.
An armchair critic
Salil
We could have opened up industries n factories in all those labour filled states just after the second Ist lockdown to ensure that their movement could be stopped n they would work happily there for food n livelihood..In this way,we could have monitored them as well...But we failed n demonetization like situation..
Agree with everything but the first part. Govt. cannot be blamed in retrospect. In the beginning the lockdown for a couple of weeks was fine. But once it was apparent that lockdown isnt stopping it. They should have changed tact. They froze instead.
Sorry I am getting online purchase from Amazon without delay madam
So am I. But what was your point, Sir?
What was the solution according to you ???
Labourers are the worst affected and top class people just rule with so much politics..
Earlier it was urbanisation ,now its ruralisation...
I have been following your channel on youtube and absolutely impressed with your content.
Am reaching out you with regards to a issue i recently faced, where my prospective employer teleperformance was insisting that i furnish my aadhaar details. I wanted to know if there is anyway you can help me or possibly refer me to a pro bono lawyer, that can help me.
Please let me know you would like to understand the details of my issue
Best Regards,
Sudhir Maganti
In hindsight, your views may be correct. While we all agree that the shutdown could have been more planned and measured, you have totally ignored the circumstances which existed when the decision of lockdown were taken during various stages. In fact, most of us were frightened with the development in certain parts of the world during the first and second phase. It would be good if you can publish a separate video on what you as on organization have done throught the lockdown, rather than throwing dirt everywhere.
Who stopped a discussion and consultation before the closed down.Nethas living in ivory tower
Nearly impossible for a person of my little understanding to segregate "signal" from "noise" from various international studies.
Covid scare seems to be going the "Climate Change" way, I am not sure.
Science and Scientologist are very hard to distinguish.
Don't know the Truth.
Ma'am please come up with more stories on the economy. We have a dearth of online economic news platform. You should also try reporting the programme in hindi and english, like The Print, and in doing so you will gain more sbscribers
Hey Moron was there any kits available globally or PPE Kits masks etc. The global hub of manufacturing CHINA had to Import. without lockdown was there any other way this mass pandemic could have been stopped. In a country so vast and varied with so much poverty and assholes like you who instead of taking the realistic account of situation just rant and find faults. There would have been mountains of dead bodies which would have posed another difficulty of disposing them. So what if world & WHO praised it, but we should listen to one moron on youtube.
Hindsight is 20/20
its true PM Modi has NO EXIT STRATEGY in any of his so called smart and bold decisions. He follows a concept of "CARELESS DEKHAJAYEGA". For Demo also, PM Modi left it to RBI and Banks to clean the demonetisation mess. Also he even campaigned in London about his surgical strikes on Pak but today also Terrorist are gunning down Indian Jawans in 1: 13 ratio like sitting Ducks as PM has NO CLUE now what to do with Pak's low profile war on India. Also his Neighbour First policy failed with Nepal and soon Maldives going the China and only Bangladesh and SL are still good listeners to PM Modi. This time PM Modi in his habitual manner implemented the lockdown overnight but final with NO EXIT STRATEGY , He has left it to incompetent and scary CMs, and this way PM has taken this chance of him is trying to showcase his federal obedience, and with no exit strategy once again resulting in DEATHS of the POOR like Demo, Like Pulwama and unfortunately now we are heading into a very very long recession period and I hope its not depression.
Absolutely true. You nailed it perfectly. May the govt listen atleast now instead of blowing its own trumpet.
@Herschey's it seems u r bhakt, no eyes, ears, toung, skin, lund only base lase , illogical bhakti. Change your name herschey's to ch.du.
Truth & only Truth. Thanks
I am fan of Sucheta Dalals articles she had in this segment had touched upon points which we had never even thought of her utterance that wr are hurtling towards License raj is Prophetic if only our Juggadu P.M listens to such saner voices of Rajiv Bajaj or Ratan Tatas advices this pandemic & our P.Ms Quixotic attempt tofight is going to cost him & his party in coming elections once again people will handover Power to equally clueless corrupt party Congress
You are right maam
Bold post, but here we to differ.
If we didn't have lockdown curve would not have been flat and we would've seen death like in Italy which has just 6 crores of population unlike 100 crores of India and would've been grave public issue, but lines would've been same "if we would've given us some lockdown, it could've save life of poor, but our strong PM because of elite industrialist pressure haven't done that, he has succumbed to the pressure of big, and poor are dying of disease because of it"
Completely agree, we should work on healthcare system of India. It sucks really hard, but then I ask questions to myself, we are in democracy not communism here we as citizens to work on system. We should hold government for putting rules and regulations and compliance in-place not for running industries be at any hospitality or healthcare. It sucks and has no business to be in business. It should be us. If rules, regulations, compliances are bad it's them else it us.
Imagine 500/- Fine for not wearing a mask in TN. Height of bureaucratic arrogance.
It is RS 1000 in Telangana
Just loved your concern....India needs many activists like you mam
Modi has mastered populism. Even if he ruins India, people wont blame him.
Very informative video. Thanks for sharing. Our maid had to leave to her home in Aurangabad from pune and for it her family had to pay rs. 25k to a private cab driver. I have a question here. What happens to the money which central govt gives to state? Does it ever reach people? Do they ever audit it?
u can never have perfect plan even for projects, like Mangal yaan or chanderyaan .. like perfect crime it is chimera
Don't listen to macro economists, Nasim Taleb.
True
The resistance
Great women please reply mam
It started well, but lost lecturing people.
sorry beg to differ corona doesn't discriminate poor people would have been hit the hardest
Wwah wat a conspiracy theory..
There is some one bad who always want poor to suffer..n he gets lacks of corors f money from elite.. But why elite will pay..ohh they enjoy seeing poor suffer... Come out of movies
There are two type of employees achievers who performers..n idealists who keep on finding mistakes..
This period will go down in history as the darkest period of free India when our own politicians & police turned against the poor, the weak, the old & disabled.
In the final tally more people would have died due to hunger, dehydration, accidents, police atrocities than covid-19.
Very sorry & sad state of affairs where the educated & powerful in our country are silent and their silence is killing the masses 😭😭😭
WAKE UP MY INDIA NOW & SAVE OUR MOTHERLAND FROM THE VULTURES & CROCODILES
🇮🇳 JAI 🇮🇳 HIND 🇮🇳
A concerted effort by every individual to bring pressure on the government is the way forward. After a lot of bloodshed. People will revolt like any other revolutions in the past.the situation certainly will not be the same
@Herschey's As a way forward, first people should remove their ideological blinkers & be objective.
It easy to respectively say something. Recent raise in number due to relaxation.. absolutely no logic of arguments .. sorry to say you disappointed with video
For the first time, Sucheta ma'am is confused in what actually she wants to say and make point. Remember, it's always easy to find faults in everything & doing a rich poor comparison as it will always find attraction among people.
Hard lock down turned out to be great joke
Back to colonial days.
Stupid report I have ever come across after a long time
I am not sure how one can compare it with license raj.
On the contrary labour laws have been suspended in many states and the economic package is not for the common man but for these Industries.
Industrialists should not be whining about lockdown because the situation is more or less same across the globe.
The common man hu and especially migrant workers are the worst sufferers.
Love from Kashmir
Let me be clear no poor were effected during demonetization in fact you were effected with your black money. You are talking nonsense and active working agent for Antonia Maino.
Have you spent single penny to help migrant. Plz stop this nonsense.
All negative no positives u r becoming negativist stop it
Thuth lies!
Negative thoughts, afterthoughts. Not good. We will receive as the core valuw system of our people is.
Sucheta Dalal how are you qualified?
Darling at least read the brief with a more believable speak.
Don't know her qualification. However qualification immaterial.
You need a heart to feel for the less privileged people.
This entire misadventure was a bothched up public policy coupled with criminal negligence.
These have been the trade marks of this government.