I've listened to hochizora orchestra for hours on loop way before this happened, which is why the song is way more off to me. It's not that it's bad but it's hard to be used to such a drastic change after having your brain used to the original, same effect to being used to a cover instead of the original, so the original may sound way off to you, or even playing proseka on a lower speed only to change it to normal. At first it's weird, but after sometime you get used to it, that's why it's listeners are reacting this way.
it sounds like the "new" version is actually a demo version, using digital instruments instead of real live recorded ones :o i wonder how they managed to mess this up lolll
It's fine if people like the new version more, but for me personally I just can't, the reason hoshizora orchestra was my fav Emu comm was because like people said, felt whimsical, it feels like i'm actually in another world and wxs guiding me in it, it fits the peter pan theme as well that I really reaaallyyy love. Maybe I'll warm up to it in the future but honestly I probably won't listen to this version really, hoshizora orchestra is very dear to me as also to other people, so whatever version you like just respect opinions and agree to disagree
eee same c: ive mostly been listening to the colorcoded lyrics of the og full version (before the re-release) this is my favorite emu comm, and the wxs song i stream the most, so this is something that bugs me. i agree with you in the fact that the original upload had a whimsical vibe and this version just seems paler and more dull because of the beta instrumental. this song also means a lot to me c: so its hard to adjust to a version that i like less!
@@cutiesmileharuka yepyep! I do agree with people saying its dull and paler, and the fact that it sounds like a marching band which isn't necessarily a bad thing, it's actually a pretty interesting concept, but with a song that has a whimsical peter pan theme the og is better at conveying it. It's a good thing people archived it already so that people can still listen to the og, it's also nice to see a Haruka fan too:)
I like it yet I hate it at the same time Also something weird that happened, I noticed that they deleted both songs on all streaming services (by both I mean curtain call song, the one we all know was gonna get deleted, and the og hoshizora orchestra) yet for some reason I still have them on my playlist and I can still listen to them without being hit with an error. Same with when the morning glory falls. Pretty weird how it doesn’t affect my playlists at all
Is your playlist on spotify? Or somewhere else? Because i had them in my spotify playlist but they're gone They just unlisted them on youtube and probably on other services too, so if you have the link you can still view them normally
it's a bit better in the rereleased version, it really brings out the fun and joy of emu's personality, y'all gotta stop saying that it's not silly anymore (IT'S STILL SILLY AND CUTE TO ME 😭😭😭)
is it bad that i like the rereleased version more ☹ i hope someone archives it because its honestly easier on the ears (saying that as a wxs oshi that loves all wxs comms 😭)
They did the same thing with peachy key in album version ruined the full sekai version for me, if you compare the virtual singer version on iyowa's channel to whats on the album version you can see what i mean
everyone talking abt which one is better but all I can think about is how this song has always sounded like bandori’s theme song (the one that plays on the loading screen) from the first day i heard it
Bro this is gonna sound so random But this song makes me feel like so sad sometiems like i kinda start tearing up when i hear it bc when i first did it i was having a panick attack and sobbing in my room at 6 am (with no sleep) it was for a number of reasons but i felt like i could do anything and that i couldnt ask or go to anyone for help i felt so alone so i just started doing songs i hadnt done on hard mode (the hardest mode i could do at the time) and came to this one and this one for some reason felt so comforting?? Ig happy but it had a sad hint to it? Like when you look back at your childhood memories and they were so fun and happy but you realize you wont get those times back and that part makes you feel sad anyways now when i hear this song it makes me sad bc i get reminded of that time but it also could be that i feel somewhat comforted which i havent rlly been able to feel like that recently Edit: also that feeling only applies for the original
to y'all saying they took out the joy and whimsy, i get what you're saying, but i think that's kind of the point? the official one sounds _bittersweet,_ which matches the vibe of the event better.
CAN SOMEONE TELL ME IF THEY WILL RELEASE THE ORIGINAL VERSION AGAIN?? I just really prefer the old one and I can't live without it. please I feel like infiltrating sega's company and begging them to give us the og instrumental again. :(
0:14 rereleased ver 0:46 original so you can compare the difference!! (i think the difference is the e-guitar and bass in the bg and i think the drum in the original has more cymbal)
YEAH ITS DIFFERENT i remember listening to the official instrumental version video thinking that it was also different like "where's all the fancy instruments????"
I’m so confundled on how I both love and hate the new version at the same time, it sounds more musical theatre-ish but it also sounds uhhh ??? I have no idea 😭 The difference isn’t THAT big but oh my gosh I got so much whiplash listening to it.
Tbh if I were to describe the difference between hoshizora no orchestra’s first release and rerelease without dissing the song it went from whimsical dreamy jazz number to… just a jazz number, if that makes any sense…
I've heard it and you're right, it sounds different... Well compared to what we hear now, i think that's the final one since the beta version sounds like too loud
Ahhhh so that’s what it was! I think the rereleased one is fine while I still prefer the actual version, so hopefully they notice and rererelease(??) it
When I did saw the trailer, I thought that the song was a bit different than the release of what the song was like now but I can’t put my finger on it until I saw this video and turns out that was not originally with the song was a post to be like by the way, where did you get that version with the song was supposed to be like because I want to hear it
for this video i used the game cut version since its the same as the final version and for the video im about to make i already had the original downloaded on my phone
so it's a minor difference in the instrumental? anyways thanks for this! ^^ i have been listening to jpop idol groups lately and i can't find hoshizora orchestra on my own spotify
if its the wrong/beta version, are they gonna rerelease it again or are they just gonna leave it ? im hoping they do rerelease with the correct version bc accidentally releasing the beta version instead of the in game one is a huge oversight on colopals end 💀
This sound hella more marching band LMAOOO
IT DOESSSSS 😭
IM A PART OF ONE AND IT SOUNDS LIKE IT HAS MORE PERCUSSION
@@Jellyshark39SAME... I DIDNT EVEN REALISED IT STOP
They took out all the joy and whimsy 💔
they took out the silly
I knew something sounded a bit different!! (Im totally sane about this song and totally did not immediately notice the difference)
I still love both versions. Don't get me wrong, it's just I immediately noticed the difference when I first listened to it
I noticed at emu's first line, the "wonderland yume ni" THE DRUMS WERE GONE :CCC
WHERE'S THE FUN AND WHIMSY.... WHERES THE SILLY ☹️
shit, if i was released on the same single as a criminal's song, i wouldn't be feeling very silly or whimsical, thats for sure 😟
@@loop-sie1121 fair enough
Perhaps because of sad news?
It's like WS, no "X"
All starts from missing "X" in Rui trailer event and we ended up here.
Y’all so dramatic omg “took out all the joy!!” They both sound fine one was just the wrong version. Ain’t even sound too different imo
The beta version sounds a little more flat to me, and that's the only difference I can discern tbh
Nah fr smh
I've listened to hochizora orchestra for hours on loop way before this happened, which is why the song is way more off to me.
It's not that it's bad but it's hard to be used to such a drastic change after having your brain used to the original, same effect to being used to a cover instead of the original, so the original may sound way off to you, or even playing proseka on a lower speed only to change it to normal.
At first it's weird, but after sometime you get used to it, that's why it's listeners are reacting this way.
As a person who barely listens to “Hoshizora Orchestra”, the instrumentals sound more lively in the second part (first release)
no but they did it’s so flat and plain…
it was my favorite song it’s so empty…
That song is back to normal! It’s sounds so wonderhoy again! ^^
it sounds like the "new" version is actually a demo version, using digital instruments instead of real live recorded ones :o i wonder how they managed to mess this up lolll
it was my fav cover WHAT IS THAT.
I KNEW I WASNT GOING CR詠ZY SOMETHING WAS OFF WHEN THEY REUPLOADED IT 😭😭
crazy** mb
I Like both versions the one the beta one sounds more calm and relaxing
I FREAKING CRIED when the og one got removed (not kidding, its my comfort song)
Is it weird that I actually kind of like it? It sounds so chipper and bouncy to me. I love the marching band feel to it.
it sounds better ngl its more realistic to musical theatre 😭
W opinion I agree
I ACTUALLY LIKE IT
it’s sad because it had to be rereleased on it own (for good reasons)
It's fine if people like the new version more, but for me personally I just can't, the reason hoshizora orchestra was my fav Emu comm was because like people said, felt whimsical, it feels like i'm actually in another world and wxs guiding me in it, it fits the peter pan theme as well that I really reaaallyyy love.
Maybe I'll warm up to it in the future but honestly I probably won't listen to this version really, hoshizora orchestra is very dear to me as also to other people, so whatever version you like just respect opinions and agree to disagree
eee same c: ive mostly been listening to the colorcoded lyrics of the og full version (before the re-release) this is my favorite emu comm, and the wxs song i stream the most, so this is something that bugs me. i agree with you in the fact that the original upload had a whimsical vibe and this version just seems paler and more dull because of the beta instrumental. this song also means a lot to me c: so its hard to adjust to a version that i like less!
@@cutiesmileharuka yepyep! I do agree with people saying its dull and paler, and the fact that it sounds like a marching band which isn't necessarily a bad thing, it's actually a pretty interesting concept, but with a song that has a whimsical peter pan theme the og is better at conveying it.
It's a good thing people archived it already so that people can still listen to the og, it's also nice to see a Haruka fan too:)
I was wondering why it sounded weird 😭😭
people looking for the fun and silly but this was an eye opening event for their "eventual looming disband"--
they fixed it!!!
I like it yet I hate it at the same time
Also something weird that happened, I noticed that they deleted both songs on all streaming services (by both I mean curtain call song, the one we all know was gonna get deleted, and the og hoshizora orchestra) yet for some reason I still have them on my playlist and I can still listen to them without being hit with an error. Same with when the morning glory falls. Pretty weird how it doesn’t affect my playlists at all
Is your playlist on spotify? Or somewhere else? Because i had them in my spotify playlist but they're gone
They just unlisted them on youtube and probably on other services too, so if you have the link you can still view them normally
Had to repeat the new and in-game ver to find the difference
WHERES THE ENTHUSIASM WHYD THEY KILL IT
WHERE DID THE SILLINESS AND HAPPINESS GO
Its a good thing the lyric channels kept a copy of the original version
I thought i was going insane when i listened to the new upload on Spotify 😭
it's a bit better in the rereleased version, it really brings out the fun and joy of emu's personality, y'all gotta stop saying that it's not silly anymore (IT'S STILL SILLY AND CUTE TO ME 😭😭😭)
Just checked, seems fixed/ back to normal!
no wonder it sounded so different i love hoshizora orcehstra so muchc
thank god I avoid WxS songs like the plague so I never noticed anything
i acfually like it though
Oh my God I LOVE the demo version
ive only listened to hoshizora orchestra like 5 times but theres a definite difference
FINALLY SOMEBODY WHO NOTICED!!!when i first heard the rereleased version of it it sounded like it was missing some instruments to me…
cloudy sky marching band
is it bad that i like the rereleased version more ☹ i hope someone archives it because its honestly easier on the ears (saying that as a wxs oshi that loves all wxs comms 😭)
Yeah
(I didnt read the first part 😭)
@@K17_04 ☹‼
Hi, the project sekai fandom wiki has both versions, so you can check on there :)
@Useiproject do not fret kids for captain no fun is here! I bet your fun at parties
@@lainmaxxerit’s just their opinion why are you so butthurt
They did the same thing with peachy key in album version ruined the full sekai version for me, if you compare the virtual singer version on iyowa's channel to whats on the album version you can see what i mean
The song you used in background is real nice, can you tell what is it called?
"strange school" from the persona q soundtrack
everyone talking abt which one is better but all I can think about is how this song has always sounded like bandori’s theme song (the one that plays on the loading screen) from the first day i heard it
WHY DID THEY TAKE THE ORCHESTRA OUT OUT HOSHIZORA ORCHESTRA.
listen closely to the new chorus, i think they took out the longer chords
Bro this is gonna sound so random
But this song makes me feel like so sad sometiems like i kinda start tearing up when i hear it bc when i first did it i was having a panick attack and sobbing in my room at 6 am (with no sleep) it was for a number of reasons but i felt like i could do anything and that i couldnt ask or go to anyone for help i felt so alone so i just started doing songs i hadnt done on hard mode (the hardest mode i could do at the time) and came to this one and this one for some reason felt so comforting?? Ig happy but it had a sad hint to it? Like when you look back at your childhood memories and they were so fun and happy but you realize you wont get those times back and that part makes you feel sad anyways now when i hear this song it makes me sad bc i get reminded of that time but it also could be that i feel somewhat comforted which i havent rlly been able to feel like that recently
Edit: also that feeling only applies for the original
i thought the ingame version is supposed to be slightly different, like it was with zamuza? (it's especially noticeable at the "zukizukizuki" parts)
also imho the "wrong" version sounds better
I was hoping somebody noticed it, too. I’m not really not a fan. Something is just missing…
to y'all saying they took out the joy and whimsy, i get what you're saying, but i think that's kind of the point? the official one sounds _bittersweet,_ which matches the vibe of the event better.
CAN SOMEONE TELL ME IF THEY WILL RELEASE THE ORIGINAL VERSION AGAIN?? I just really prefer the old one and I can't live without it. please I feel like infiltrating sega's company and begging them to give us the og instrumental again. :(
all hoshizora no orchestra 😞
0:14 rereleased ver
0:46 original
so you can compare the difference!! (i think the difference is the e-guitar and bass in the bg and i think the drum in the original has more cymbal)
the strings (i think that's what they're called?) are missing too
i REALLY hope they fix quickly 😭😭😭😭
YEAH ITS DIFFERENT
i remember listening to the official instrumental version video thinking that it was also different like "where's all the fancy instruments????"
It's cool that you noticed, but I personally don't really mind the difference since I can't hear it too well.
i want this song to be on spotify again cause it‘s one of my favourite wxs songs…😔
GIVE IT BACK, GIVE THE OLD VERSION BACK 😭
I KNEW SOMETHING SOUNDS DIFFERENT 😭
Well, what sort of ending were you wishing for?
Now that I see this, I just realized my playlist is missing Hoshizora Orchestra. At least they're trying to fix it.
WHAT OERSONA Q MUSIC WHAT OMG OMGAJAYSJAHSIS
HELPP YES I LVOE PERSONA AND PERSONA Q
I’m so confundled on how I both love and hate the new version at the same time, it sounds more musical theatre-ish but it also sounds uhhh ??? I have no idea 😭 The difference isn’t THAT big but oh my gosh I got so much whiplash listening to it.
I think Sega is in charge of this stuff, I think Colorful Pallete is just contracted to do the games illustrations
Tbh if I were to describe the difference between hoshizora no orchestra’s first release and rerelease without dissing the song it went from whimsical dreamy jazz number to… just a jazz number, if that makes any sense…
Did these songs only got removed on the jp server? Cuz every time I check on these, they always end up still in the game
im pretty sure that the old instrumental for Mirai is used in the original Miku version of the song
wasnt this the same one in tiktok? it was before the donketsu thing and i thought it sounded weird
I've heard it and you're right, it sounds different...
Well compared to what we hear now, i think that's the final one since the beta version sounds like too loud
I'm actually so sad they changed it :'
ITS KINDA DIFFERENT
GUYS I ACTUALLY LIKE THE RELEASED MORE??? It makes me calm and happy :)
Uh what crime did he commit
@@RmationYT attempted murder
@@cutiesmileharuka 😨
It oddly sounds nice, I’m not sure why
NOOO THEY TOOK THEIR SILLIES:((((
the song is not on spotify anymore like i can't find it anywhere 😭
I hate this change and am definitely using lyric videos 😓
NOOOO THE ORIGINAL IS SO MUCH MORE FUN AND CUTE… NONONONONONO
The rereleased sounds pretty meh honestly, there was a big change but it feels so weird.
They forgot to add what made the song more cute and wholesome
Ahhhh so that’s what it was! I think the rereleased one is fine while I still prefer the actual version, so hopefully they notice and rererelease(??) it
The chorus in the rerelease version sounds like a bit more empty? idk how to explain it
They both sound good but I miss the hype band feeling, I still love hoshizora though
Its jazzy
awww it sounds adorable tho wdym they took out the whimsy i like both versions
When I did saw the trailer, I thought that the song was a bit different than the release of what the song was like now but I can’t put my finger on it until I saw this video and turns out that was not originally with the song was a post to be like by the way, where did you get that version with the song was supposed to be like because I want to hear it
for this video i used the game cut version since its the same as the final version and for the video im about to make i already had the original downloaded on my phone
so it's a minor difference in the instrumental? anyways thanks for this! ^^
i have been listening to jpop idol groups lately and i can't find hoshizora orchestra on my own spotify
i actually like the released more it makes me happy lol
if its the wrong/beta version, are they gonna rerelease it again or are they just gonna leave it ? im hoping they do rerelease with the correct version bc accidentally releasing the beta version instead of the in game one is a huge oversight on colopals end 💀
Where's the love, bro..? 😔
I actually like both versions I don’t mind
WHERE IS DA LOVE AND SILLINESS
I wonder if it’s possible to report it to them somehow in case they really weren’t aware?
Can someone explain the difference??
@@Tsvkito i have a second video that has it, its linked in the description
am i the only one who it sounds exactly the same???? can u upload a comparison
i made a comparison vid for u
@@cutiesmileharuka I OVE YOU
What are y'all complaining about? I prefer this version.
nvm i hâte it
i like it more ITS MORE FUN AND WHIMSY SHUT UP EVERYONE
No
to me the original sounded slightly sad but this version sounds a lot happier........
why..
Sounds okay, all I notice is a pitch difference
NOOO
Sounds the same…
They ruined it what is this it sounds so soulless
old one better :3
dont matter bro yuno miles better
indiana jones
this sounds like shit 😢