IM used to be a roadie for the teardrop explodes and his nickname was Duke ⚡ also the chap who died in a motorbike accident Stewart desomething was the boyfriend of a girl I know and seven seas is their best song 😜
Amazing can watch indoors on a phone 📱 computer if have one. Thanks for recording pretend there. Sure other songs I know loved so much in the 80s. Yearning, oh & I worked for MTV in a past life. Love music 🎶
I saw them twice a couple of years ago, Manchester and Leeds, close enough to hand him a crucifix, snd i must say his act is cleaner. Especially Leeds as it was an extra gig to pay back for a lumbago shortened original. That night he eas gentle snd genuine and despite the spiky blather between songs, he came across as just a man bewlidered and delighted that life had let hom make s living travelling the world and singing great songs with a band of brilliant players. God bless y Macca.
Ian doesn't have the strength to sing anymore, this sounds like the meow of a hungry cat. I don't understand the comments of people who are amazed at how it sounds. Is it enough just to appear on stage for us to be happy? It's not for me.
Don't know a word, but he thinks he's the coolest thing to ever walk the planet, a king on a throne and you have no permission to approach, shades, etc.; he's got to keep a barrier between himself and everyone, the guy can't have relationships of meaning this way.
Wow, really? Wow.. cashing in just retire it was a brilliant song this time if you turn up the Just called out of bin bag. ,. thank good luck. I fell embarrassed the young people looking on things and this is brilliant. They have no idea. .. leave them be ..
guess there's no reason to watch them alive...hiding behind sunglasses and hoody, cigarette...if you don't want to perform, just don't. Stop milking the money cow then and be genuine and own your legacy. This is a depressing performance of a brilliant song.
Still smoking on stage at this point, now not so cool and ones sees he notably packed on the lbs. to where he got called an FF; have to chuckle for who hasn't dealt with weight issues a time or two. Now Ian super skinny and it's Will dealing with lbs. Plus whomever his gf, at this point, as rock's second (unknown Yoko Ono), (meaning someone who seeks you to pursue their own art thru you) did Ian zero favors, so he even clocked off stage on us for a while by his own admission. Rock is a hard life.
Bien, está claro que esta desafinado y no está bien, pero la peña se pone a criticar sin saber, lo mismo estaba algo enfermo, o con la voz tomada, pero....es mejor ponerle a parir, alguno ha cantado alguna vez??? Por curiosidad.....joder!!!
First of all, to me i dont like anything live or have never been to a lve concert! Now matter how good a singer is, maybe he was tired ftom traveling, under the weather, any number of things! Maybe they had shitty equipment at that venue! We are all spoiled by the studio recording that we expect the exact same soung when performed live! Remember folks, we are all human beings, we put these stars in such a high pedestal, that know ine can live up to those expetations!
Awful ,voice shod ,band sound amateur ,no atmosphere, relying on their Andy Warhol fifteen minutes of which long past. Remember them at their peak when they where a force to be reckoned with.
Toute ma jeunesse. Tout leurs albums. Nous sommes en 2024 j"ai 42 ans et RIEN A CHANGE POUR MOI.. JE LES AIME TOUJOURS ET TOUJOURS....❤
Brilliant what Brilliant voice not aged fantastic looks fabulous
I think it is what it is. It’s okay. Life is hard and we all do what we do.
Oddly enough it's the only song of theirs that I know. It's absolutely magnificent in every way.
IM used to be a roadie for the teardrop explodes and his nickname was Duke ⚡ also the chap who died in a motorbike accident Stewart desomething was the boyfriend of a girl I know and seven seas is their best song 😜
@@ackerjawaka1966Pete ....Johnson.
@@julianbrowne7026 ta 🍻🍺
You should check out their collection of singles called Songs to Learn and Sing. Picked it up cause the cover looked good, and had it on for weeks.
Amazing can watch indoors on a phone 📱 computer if have one. Thanks for recording pretend there. Sure other songs I know loved so much in the 80s. Yearning, oh & I worked for MTV in a past life. Love music 🎶
The Unibomber looks great!
I saw them twice a couple of years ago, Manchester and Leeds, close enough to hand him a crucifix, snd i must say his act is cleaner. Especially Leeds as it was an extra gig to pay back for a lumbago shortened original. That night he eas gentle snd genuine and despite the spiky blather between songs, he came across as just a man bewlidered and delighted that life had let hom make s living travelling the world and singing great songs with a band of brilliant players. God bless y Macca.
Es un pedazo de grupo de toda la vida, no hay que decir mas
Great song!
What a brilliant song which underwent a renaissance on the donnie darko soundtrack
"lemme see if I can completely ruin my reputation".
Ouch. His voice has left the building!
Ian wtf? You had a moment on the chorus but what happened. We don't need another Liam Gallagher! Shape up bro!
Yet none of you criticizing him have any success ...still haunting
It seems that ian's voice doesn't echo anymore unlike dave gahan of depeche mode... i miss how ian sings & sounds back in the day...
U are spot on. ,
All Singers that Smoke suffer that effect, but he's still Amazing.
Brilliant ❤
This is the greatest song ever written according to the guy that wrote it.
It is a great song tho
that bad Bunny is great.
Great shame getting old 😢😢
Me gusta como interpretó esta canción en este concierto, le puso mas sentimiento
Ian's voice is SHOT!! .. lighten up on the cigs.. It's over!
saw him 2022 ,his voice was spot on
Ian doesn't have the strength to sing anymore, this sounds like the meow of a hungry cat. I don't understand the comments of people who are amazed at how it sounds. Is it enough just to appear on stage for us to be happy? It's not for me.
I loved Mac in the early 80s. Nobody like him.
Still a knob
He actually sounds incredible here compared to a few years before!
Hobbos be steppin' up to tha mic like....
❤
Never mind the music... 1:34...WHO is that chic?
musicians smoking used to be a non-event, nowadays people get stuck on that, also his voice is far from being destroyed by his years of smoking so.
At least McCulloch is tall,good looking and has ' attitude'
His voice sounds different, no more deep tone. Now it is more raspy.
Top
Busted
Tune and a half
They need pompous synths at the chorus like in the cover by the Chvrches
Cigarette - no way - he could have put that cig down for this song. Really.
Still better than U2
He still sings with the same soul
Cigarro acabou com a voz dele...uma pena..😢😢
pete a gentleman
I love this band ❤️❤️ but i think this delivery of the song was so low energy, i think He could do better
tiene el pose de julian casablancas o julian lo tiene de el ...
Es en serio? o estás jugando.... La pregunta ofende, en verdad xD
No piano? That's so sad....
he reminds me a little of LaFlamme
Looks like they were dug up for the day
Kids, this is what 40 years of chain smoking will do to you. Do not try this at home. You kids stay in school!
Shut up hater, mac solos your fav
It's not smoking the problem
🎉
Too late 😂
You’re right, but look at Bono , quit the fags 30 years ago and his voice is worse.
No excuse though!
Don’t smoke kids!!!
is there a word for a person that is not even half as cool as they think they are? insert here nxt to Ian ________
Don't know a word, but he thinks he's the coolest thing to ever walk the planet, a king on a throne and you have no permission to approach, shades, etc.; he's got to keep a barrier between himself and everyone, the guy can't have relationships of meaning this way.
He's still cooler than all the modern poseurs by a country mile.
are you his ex or soemthing?@@katherinestaudt8492
@@GaryM67-71 yes ice , i have to agree , to compare to modern poseurs , definitely!
Wow, really? Wow.. cashing in just retire it was a brilliant song this time if you turn up the Just called out of bin bag. ,. thank good luck. I fell embarrassed the young people looking on things and this is brilliant. They have no idea. .. leave them be ..
guess there's no reason to watch them alive...hiding behind sunglasses and hoody, cigarette...if you don't want to perform, just don't. Stop milking the money cow then and be genuine and own your legacy. This is a depressing performance of a brilliant song.
Still smoking on stage at this point, now not so cool and ones sees he notably packed on the lbs. to where he got called an FF; have to chuckle for who hasn't dealt with weight issues a time or two. Now Ian super skinny and it's Will dealing with lbs. Plus whomever his gf, at this point, as rock's second (unknown Yoko Ono), (meaning someone who seeks you to pursue their own art thru you) did Ian zero favors, so he even clocked off stage on us for a while by his own admission. Rock is a hard life.
A bit strange.....
Big old beer jowls.
La peor interpretación en vivo de esta gran canción
yikes
Come for me, but I just think that’s lazy ..
2025
A little dramatic
Bien, está claro que esta desafinado y no está bien, pero la peña se pone a criticar sin saber, lo mismo estaba algo enfermo, o con la voz tomada, pero....es mejor ponerle a parir, alguno ha cantado alguna vez??? Por curiosidad.....joder!!!
First of all, to me i dont like anything live or have never been to a lve concert! Now matter how good a singer is, maybe he was tired ftom traveling, under the weather, any number of things! Maybe they had shitty equipment at that venue! We are all spoiled by the studio recording that we expect the exact same soung when performed live! Remember folks, we are all human beings, we put these stars in such a high pedestal, that know ine can live up to those expetations!
De um modo geral Stone Roses é melhor. Mas eles n tem uma Killing Moon ...
The dark lasses, hoody and otherwise dressing looks like Ian does not care much. Otherwise a good rendition.
Awful ,voice shod ,band sound amateur ,no atmosphere, relying on their Andy Warhol fifteen minutes of which long past. Remember them at their peak when they where a force to be reckoned with.
People get old. Just wait your turn. 😉🤫
this is bad
You’re bad
Does this guy think that he is cool?
He certainly was when this song was originally released
Youngin I named my son after him, so yes he was!!!
Are you fucking serious?
Feet!
Wank
Some of you in these comments need to lighten up jfc
SO BAD
Big fan of Echo and the Bunnymen, but Ian's vocal were shit in this particular performance.
Indeed, that is everyone's general opinion. Musicians have good days and bad days.
Pathetic on all levels.
damn bro what happened? :(
❤
❤