I really don't understand why anybody is mad at this, nobody is trying to "Replace" Amy Winehouse. It's a cover for a movie...that's it. To be honest it's pretty good, the arrangement makes it sultry and it goes with the movie well. Bey's voice is haunting. If you honestly think this is "horrible", you honestly don't know good music.
If Amy Winehouse was still around I bet the movie will still go to her to do a remix version of this song. But she was gone for 2 years already then......
King KeVante' who cant like beyonce,that not the point they took the song remixed and not even got full permission before putting it out there.thats what so wrong.beyonce woul sound amazing singing anything
Covers aren't meant to sound exactly like the original. Otherwise there would be no point in making a fucking cover. This version is awesome in its own way as is the original.
It gives more dimension with this type of music yk if it was pop it wouldn’t be as good but since they put the r&b, slow, type is whet made it sm better
This is a wonderful cover imho. Andre 3000's vocal dexterity is otherworldly, is there anything he can't do? Beyonce has a great voice tbh but we would be saying this if she wasn't so mainstream - now she's 'Queen B' so people gotta hate on her.
If anyone has seen the move The Great Gatsby, you'd understand how much this "version" of the song correlates with the scene. I still love Amy Winehouse. The only album I've ever bought.
I love A3000's part! He has such an understanding of the depth and contemplative delivery of Winehouse; it is more than admiration. My love to you, Mr. A3. And, Amy, a tear for you, my dear, your talent is sorely missed.
This song may be a remake, but it by no means disrespects Amy's version. It may not be your taste, but hey that's fine. Just don't get mad at someone for doing a deed that is continuously done in the music industry and creating a new version of a song. Also, this version was made for a different reason, to have a different effect on the listener, whilst aiming to maintain the original essence of Amy's version. It was made for the Great Gatsby film. *Here's why it was used:* The recent Great Gatsby is basically a modern version of the book. Baz Luhrmann (the director) used modern music so that we understand what it was like for the people in the 20s. Back then, Jazz was original. The new music. It was extremely popular. By using this kind of music, Luhrmann is giving us perspective. This kind of music is popular now. It's original. He used this kind of music for the same reasons he cast an Indian guy for the part of Wolfsheim, an evidently stereotypical Jewish guy. Whilst Jews were discriminated and stereotyped in the 1920s, they are not anymore. Today, since 9/11, Americans are more racist towards people who seem like Muslims than they are with Jews. (btw the film is American and aimed at Americans). By casting an Indian, we can kind of know what people in the 1920s would have been like, because of our own reactions. What I'm trying to say is that yes, Luhrmann could have used the original version, but by creating this remake he is giving us a new perspective to a great song. And if you've watched the film, you'll find it fits right in.
I think this song and crazy in love (from the same soundtrack) did a great job at not making them sound like covers or remakes. They made it sound like their own song while curating it perfectly for the movie.
it's funny, because Andre is playing the guy who Amy was singing about . like when he says: I go back to her, and you go back to black. instead of: you go back to her and I go back to black
I read it’s on Tidal. What Beyonce and JayZ own. So if anything, greed. Copyright claim. Etc. Given it’s a cover, and not her own song, or Andre’s, it definitely should be on other platforms. Cos it’s Winehouse song. Give respect to the dead, yknow? But the carters don’t care. We’re talking about a mother who sued a business for having “blue ivy” as their biz name before the girl was ever born / conceived
All yall ppl sayin remove andre 3 thou. That man was possibly one of the greatest rappers ever. If yall insult the vocals, just listen to them for a sec and actually get the meaning
I never understand why some people try to talk down on this cover. It's like we have to compare everything or make competition of everything. I enjoy this version as well as Amy Winehouse's version. Good music is good music so why not enjoy?
@olczaa get over yourself. just because it's not your taste ,doesnt mean it's not music You may like the original version others may prefer this cover why can't we just appreciate the song it's self
@olczaa Beyoncé is legend status, she isn't a 'product of the industry', otherwise she would care about reaching number 1 on the charts - which is clear she doesn't anymore by her lack of promotion and even saying it herself in interviews. This is why she continues to make music but now for a different audience and a deeper purpose, as shown by her recent albums which are dedicated to the struggle of african-americans. Listen to her song 'brown skin girl' and tell me whether that sounds like a song made solely for the purpose of money? And she can do more than just sing - her vocals are once of the best technically in the pop industry, not to mention she can dance well at the same time, a feat only comparable to singers such as Michael Jackson. People love to underestimate Beyoncé, but if she were dead, everyone would be crying at her grave.
@olczaa And also as shown by all this, she certainly has a say in what she puts out :) Notice all the people she herself has sued for using it without her permission.
boynatey44 it fit the movie perfectly. Some people I guess just aren't open to new versions. It's awesome to see how different artists take their own spin on a piece.
Lmao people are so butthurt for no reason. Obviously the original is better, but this one ain't bad either. Beyoncé was hardly trying in this version, but she sang it a way that fit the mood for the movie's soundtrack, which was her job. Her and André sounded flawless together. Stop acting as if Beyoncé was trying to somehow steal this song; it wasn't even a single nor was she showing 1/10 of her vocal ability. Stfu.
+JOLUS FAP Herrera it's their way not Amy's now stfu and enjoy this great piece also it just fits perfectly in the movie if you had some doubt about it
It makes me happy to see, most of the people here, still supporting Amy, she was a wonderful person, and I only started really supporting here, after her demise. But I feel people are getting really emotional over this song. Amy was the creator of the song, if there was no Amy version to it, there wouldn't be any version of it. They have just done a beats version off of it, and I have to say, these are some dirty catchy beats. But yes, it is a good version, uncomparably to the original version.
You guys really think Amy would care about all of yall defending her saying this is garbage and not music and how they ruined the song? I think all artist have a common passion and it's music. Both songs are great they took her song and brought it to my generation. I personally wasn't a fan of Amy I enjoy more upbeat songs but I think Beyoncé did a good job carrying over Amy's distress and stress and strength to overcome. Both good songs not saying ones better than the other but let's get back to what the artists really want. For us to enjoy the music and the vibes and stories that come out of it.
Love this version. I wish people would realize this was made for The Great Gatsby and NOT an Amy Winehouse tribute CD. This version fit the movie perfectly.
Man.... this did not get the recognition it needed! From Amy’s memory.. the beat... the vocal play... jazzy feel. Eerie vibes! Bass... 808s .... yeah this remake is a playground! So much fun.
Can't beleieve I've only just discovered this! I adore Amy of course but this version is also amazing they made the song their own. Going to checkout the whole soundtrack now LOVE
Let me tell yall how I had a whole experience with this song back in 2013. Literally felt something come over me. Idk what’s in this song but baby don’t play with it.
Perfect melody to a perfect storyline. Shall we...dive into the inexplicable pool of life. “I was within and without...simultaneously enchanted and repelled by the inexhaustible variety of life.”
I think people are upset for this version of song because of the heart break that lies behind the original song by the amazing Amy winehouse. Her last performance was indeed heart ailing when she performed this and then we see Bey sing it and the reaction is how dare she. In which is natural because of the love fans have for Amy’s gift. No one could ever forget Mrs Winehouse even if they tried she’s a gem!
I dont think anyone appreciates how they modernised this song! They took an already amazing original song and just updated it! (and they only did it for a movie its not like you hear this on the radio or anything!) Im mean the original will always be my favorite version of this song but I do like how they re-styled this song and changed it up for a movie set in the 20's while still making the sound relatable to our modern music style
I think both versions are fantastic in different ways. I heard this one first, so that might be why I like it so much. But I see it as different songs with the same lyrics, not just one being a better/worse version of the other.
These people hating are mostly just girls that try to be some alternative indie type shit and get so easily butt hurt when someone makes stuff with the people they stan. They never even know her before she died
olczaa You're angering yourself over Beyonce. If you dislike her, why spend your precious time on her? Stop being miserable and listen to Amy Winehouse. It's not hard.
olczaa Why you're here is very relevant to the comment you made. You're up and down this whole comment section just to denounce an artist to uplift another one. You most definitely look miserable. You have a say just like everyone, yes. But don't use free speech to cover your bitterness. You're mad at the fact that Beyonce is as big as she is and you don't like her music so you come to a video featuring her just to drag her name. Sounds miserable to me.
Amy's original of this was beautiful, as was this version. I'm a huge Amy fan (anyone who knows me will tell you) and had my expectations high for this version. They were almost met. The only thing was how soulful the original was, and this version was more hip-hop. That's fine. It was a refreshing revamp of the song.
I actually enjoyed this version better, because I could understand the words better. The words were also delivered in a way that made the message easier to interpret. Amy's version was really good, but harder to understand and interpret.
Molly Shannon why are you telling me to shut up? I had no dislike for this version. I enjoyed it, actually, so if it came off as though i didn't, sorry. I just enjoyed Amy's version more, and always will enjoy it more. It's just my preference.
nah 3 stacks and Bey made a good song way back, so it was nice to see them work together again for this. interesting combo though yeah. “Party” is a legendary song, probably one of my favorite if not my favorite period, Beyoncé songs. Andre 3k always Fire too.
Who is still listening in 2024?
I’m sad they don’t have this song on apple 😢
Me 🙌🏻
🧡
I miss this bey 😢
This films soundtrack was so lit 😣🔥🔥
haribo hipster ur lit
Anita Alumay ur lit too
Co Co No, your Lit
@@georgemunoz9473 you're* ;)
Xan Anthony you’re lit 🔥
I really don't understand why anybody is mad at this, nobody is trying to "Replace" Amy Winehouse. It's a cover for a movie...that's it. To be honest it's pretty good, the arrangement makes it sultry and it goes with the movie well. Bey's voice is haunting. If you honestly think this is "horrible", you honestly don't know good music.
If Amy Winehouse was still around I bet the movie will still go to her to do a remix version of this song. But she was gone for 2 years already then......
King KeVante' who cant like beyonce,that not the point they took the song remixed and not even got full permission before putting it out there.thats what so wrong.beyonce woul sound amazing singing anything
Evan Wang They definitely would have still gone to Beyonce.. she was on the soundtrack and they still had Emile Sande cover Crazy in Love
the king has spoken. so what?
I so agree with you. The ppl commenting negatively probably only listens to mainstream music. This cover is pure artistry.
This version is absolutely hypnotizing, it’s impossible to replicate the sound of the first version but this was just
Covers aren't meant to sound exactly like the original. Otherwise there would be no point in making a fucking cover. This version is awesome in its own way as is the original.
Amen...they made it thier own. I like it..but love Amy Winehouses version
cosign 10000% all these people coming for beyoncé and andre 3000 ans saying they ruined the song obviously don't understand the meaning of a cover
Always thought this version was way better hot take or not idc, that beat drop hits a nerve that Amy’s style could not. Respectfully
The Great Gatsby is one of the best movies i have ever seen
So you never see other movies
READ the book , wait a year read it again. enjoy.........
It is considered one of the greatest works of American literature.
For sure, watch the film, wait a year watch it again, enjoy !!!
@@Depressiva its a great movie. Too bad your can't appreciate
Andre 3000 is a pioneer of modern music outkast was a revolutionary group and his talent is remarkable
kakarrot15 agreed
kakarrot15 andre absolutely killed it
Maybe, but he sings like shit...
kakarrot15 Word!!!
preach
when beyonce came in so smooth......beautiful
This STILL bumps...the haunting feeling of it is INSANE
Bey did her thing. Love this.
Fake Bitch
@@el_mas_mafioso imagine being that mad 🥴
@@kayygee848 right???!!! Tragic.
7 yrs later, and she really did
I hate that this isn’t on streaming platforms! It’s so good!
Do we know why? It’s such a bummer
Also wondering this
I just now figured that out
it used to be!!! this whole album used to be. i wonder why not. i used to have this song on repeat in the day
No it's not 😅
anyone here in 2024?!
Here.
wish this was on spotify i come back to it like once a month hahah
Here
Here!! So sad this isn’t available on Apple Music.
2024
This STILL bumps...the haunting feeling of it is INSANE
Can't we just love both versions?
Can I hate both?
king of toads yes you can, lol and don’t let anybody tell you that you can’t.
"YES WE CAN"~BARACK OBAMA😊
Can't we all just get along?
Useless Uncle yes both versions are good
i dont care what any of you people says, Andre 3000 does no wrong
He obviously did wrong with the "vocals" he used
@Austin What you talkin, Andre 3k did his thang....Different, Yes but thats what you want in a song. You want him to sound like Amy? HA
Hmmm... I didnt even think the question of him doin wrong could manifest itself.
I'm three years late, but I'll say it anyway. To say three stacks got his vocals wrong is to not appreciate true art.
if 3 stacks is in one side, thats the side i'll be
when beyonce came in so smooth......beautiful
One of my favorite covers. The way they were able to make this sound so ghostly yet still hip hop and R&B is incredible! 🔥
I love this version of the song, including Andre 3000's part. It makes the song uniquely different from the original
It gives more dimension with this type of music yk if it was pop it wouldn’t be as good but since they put the r&b, slow, type is whet made it sm better
I wish this was on streaming platforms. This cover is SO good.
It was ok Spotify back in 2013-2016😢
Beyonce really is versatile. An amazing rendition of the song.
This is a wonderful cover imho. Andre 3000's vocal dexterity is otherworldly, is there anything he can't do? Beyonce has a great voice tbh but we would be saying this if she wasn't so mainstream - now she's 'Queen B' so people gotta hate on her.
I love this version. Having a male sing the guy's perspective in the song is genius. Andre 3k and Beyonce killed it (in a good way).
Hate all day, who cares? This is EVERYTHING! I am not a Beyonce fan, but I LOVE this!!!
the same here
Same
Yes same!
This movie literally has the GREATEST soundtrack of ALL TIME!!!!!!! 💛🖤
was stunned at first by the melody but somehow this song 's magic can suck you in and I just listen to it over and over again, unstoppable ritual.
If anyone has seen the move The Great Gatsby, you'd understand how much this "version" of the song correlates with the scene. I still love Amy Winehouse. The only album I've ever bought.
wait what scene was it
I love A3000's part! He has such an understanding of the depth and contemplative delivery of Winehouse; it is more than admiration. My love to you, Mr. A3. And, Amy, a tear for you, my dear, your talent is sorely missed.
This song may be a remake, but it by no means disrespects Amy's version. It may not be your taste, but hey that's fine. Just don't get mad at someone for doing a deed that is continuously done in the music industry and creating a new version of a song.
Also, this version was made for a different reason, to have a different effect on the listener, whilst aiming to maintain the original essence of Amy's version. It was made for the Great Gatsby film.
*Here's why it was used:*
The recent Great Gatsby is basically a modern version of the book. Baz Luhrmann (the director) used modern music so that we understand what it was like for the people in the 20s. Back then, Jazz was original. The new music. It was extremely popular. By using this kind of music, Luhrmann is giving us perspective. This kind of music is popular now. It's original.
He used this kind of music for the same reasons he cast an Indian guy for the part of Wolfsheim, an evidently stereotypical Jewish guy. Whilst Jews were discriminated and stereotyped in the 1920s, they are not anymore. Today, since 9/11, Americans are more racist towards people who seem like Muslims than they are with Jews. (btw the film is American and aimed at Americans). By casting an Indian, we can kind of know what people in the 1920s would have been like, because of our own reactions.
What I'm trying to say is that yes, Luhrmann could have used the original version, but by creating this remake he is giving us a new perspective to a great song. And if you've watched the film, you'll find it fits right in.
Oml yes finally I found someone that appreciates Andre 3000
Its a reck Amy's version the proper version is a lot better
+Luke Southam Alrighty then
So it's kind of the same thing he did with the Romeo + Juliet film? It's honestly genius.
I think this song and crazy in love (from the same soundtrack) did a great job at not making them sound like covers or remakes. They made it sound like their own song while curating it perfectly for the movie.
Simple but perfect.
THIS SONG IS PERFECT! no matter who sang it first or whatever or where it came from!! Shut up and enjoy it!! THANK YOU
Gosh they took it off Spotify and now this was my only source to this specific recording of the song. Thank you!
Till this day this song gives me chills. 10/10, the vocals, the emotions, the composition, the beat, the pauses man everything. 10/10
Beyonce killed it,you cannot deny
Everyone talking about Winehouse or Beyonce...did y'all forget Andre 3000
*Winehouse
Thats what I said
Geoff Gustav your profile pic though haha
right
allll kiiiindsss
Oddly, I prefer Andre 3000's bit. It's creepy, I like it.
Andre3000 should have done the whole song
Everything he does is creepy which is why I love him 🖤
@@AriS-mm9xk it's original.... Beyonce isn't as good at this song as her originals like Halo. Dre3k kills it though in my opinion
S.K.S Barbie eh, I like Beyoncé part the most but andre is awesome
The song itself was hella creepy.
it's funny, because Andre is playing the guy who Amy was singing about . like when he says: I go back to her, and you go back to black. instead of: you go back to her and I go back to black
i love this version so much
so funky and creative
i love both singers in it
Am I the only one who loves this version? :))
+Em Twilight I think we are the only 2. This song is awesome.
I love Amy dearly but even I can admit this version is really good. I listen to it as often as I listen to the original!
I love Bey's part but not André's
yes
nope
It is a crime that they took this off of Spotify.
What?! What for!?
I read it’s on Tidal. What Beyonce and JayZ own. So if anything, greed. Copyright claim. Etc. Given it’s a cover, and not her own song, or Andre’s, it definitely should be on other platforms. Cos it’s Winehouse song. Give respect to the dead, yknow? But the carters don’t care. We’re talking about a mother who sued a business for having “blue ivy” as their biz name before the girl was ever born / conceived
7 months later. But that's why I'm here. Couldn't find it on Spotify!
All yall ppl sayin remove andre 3 thou. That man was possibly one of the greatest rappers ever. If yall insult the vocals, just listen to them for a sec and actually get the meaning
One of the few good rappers who can also sing very well
Fuck man, he was the best part of this song!
I never understand why some people try to talk down on this cover. It's like we have to compare everything or make competition of everything. I enjoy this version as well as Amy Winehouse's version. Good music is good music so why not enjoy?
@olczaa get over yourself. just because it's not your taste ,doesnt mean it's not music
You may like the original version others may prefer this cover why can't we just appreciate the song it's self
@olczaa Beyoncé is legend status, she isn't a 'product of the industry', otherwise she would care about reaching number 1 on the charts - which is clear she doesn't anymore by her lack of promotion and even saying it herself in interviews. This is why she continues to make music but now for a different audience and a deeper purpose, as shown by her recent albums which are dedicated to the struggle of african-americans. Listen to her song 'brown skin girl' and tell me whether that sounds like a song made solely for the purpose of money? And she can do more than just sing - her vocals are once of the best technically in the pop industry, not to mention she can dance well at the same time, a feat only comparable to singers such as Michael Jackson. People love to underestimate Beyoncé, but if she were dead, everyone would be crying at her grave.
@olczaa So sis, try again.
@olczaa And also as shown by all this, she certainly has a say in what she puts out :) Notice all the people she herself has sued for using it without her permission.
No one will ever touch Amy's version but there is something I love about this version as well
One of the best covers ive ever heard. Great take on a already great song
doesn't matter what song better the original or not there both really good but can we just look at how good Andre 3000 is ok
preach 👌
right on dude
2019 and it’s still one of the best songs
vxf_Iivez I’m telling you
Why did it take me two years to realize this song is actually fire?!?! 😭🔥
because it's not?
sorry you feel that way
Right! Like why have I been wasting all this time with no appreciation for this gem?!?
Lol don't feel bad... I barely found this song like 2 days ago 😂😂
I just realized this as well😅
Beyoncé is such a versatile artist . She can sing anything & slay any genre ! 🔥👑👌🏽💯 #legend #icon #queenbey
Y’all trippin. This version is phenomenal!
Spending my life appreciating this song.
anything w/ beyonce is amazing. such a good vibe to this song
OMG I LOVE ANDRE 3000 SO MUCH. 😭
He's the best part of this version!
This song is like ice cream for my ears! Soothing, and Indulgent ❤
Still a beautiful piece in 2019. I'll be back in 2020... And 2021... I'll be here every damn year
u forgot to come back
This song fits perfect with the movie, the beats everything.
I wonder if anyone of these haters have seen the great gatsby or read it. it's to fit that movie not to be a similar remake
boynatey44 duh
boynatey44 it fit the movie perfectly. Some people I guess just aren't open to new versions. It's awesome to see how different artists take their own spin on a piece.
Nicole Jarel best commentary 🙌🏻
boynatey44
Biss
I just watched the movie, this song is perfect for the movie just like the other songs. Love it!
This track is amazing. That synth just sucks you right in immediately.
It’s keeping her music and artistry alive.
Beyonce's part is the best of the whole song. Her voice to me fits better with darkness of the background music.
I would have loved this arrangement with Amy's voice. She had that timeless style that lent well to the feel of this film.
I can not express how much I'm in love with anything with Leonardo DiCaprio!😍💚😘
Lmao people are so butthurt for no reason. Obviously the original is better, but this one ain't bad either. Beyoncé was hardly trying in this version, but she sang it a way that fit the mood for the movie's soundtrack, which was her job. Her and André sounded flawless together. Stop acting as if Beyoncé was trying to somehow steal this song; it wasn't even a single nor was she showing 1/10 of her vocal ability. Stfu.
I agree with you
+Michael Tyson the song itself is good but the way they sing it horrible
+JOLUS FAP Herrera DCCC oooo9
lkZZzxlkx9ē
+JOLUS FAP Herrera it's their way not Amy's now stfu and enjoy this great piece also it just fits perfectly in the movie if you had some doubt about it
PetroleumJellay hey hey hey man do you kiss ur mother with that mouth gosh
Playing this constantly! One of my favorite remakes 👐
Why isn’t this on spotify
JackNatti also not available on iTunes Music 😢
It’s not on anything but UA-cam
JackNatti the original version by amy winehouse is on spotify now (i couldn’t find it last year for some reason maybe they just readded it)
@@hardusschoeman6260 it's on iTunes but you have to buy the whole soundtrack for it. It's not sold as an individual track.
Jay z owns the soundtrack from the Great Gatsby movie and put the song in his music app called Tidal.
It makes me happy to see, most of the people here, still supporting Amy, she was a wonderful person, and I only started really supporting here, after her demise. But I feel people are getting really emotional over this song. Amy was the creator of the song, if there was no Amy version to it, there wouldn't be any version of it. They have just done a beats version off of it, and I have to say, these are some dirty catchy beats. But yes, it is a good version, uncomparably to the original version.
I like this version because of andre's part.
You guys really think Amy would care about all of yall defending her saying this is garbage and not music and how they ruined the song? I think all artist have a common passion and it's music. Both songs are great they took her song and brought it to my generation. I personally wasn't a fan of Amy I enjoy more upbeat songs but I think Beyoncé did a good job carrying over Amy's distress and stress and strength to overcome. Both good songs not saying ones better than the other but let's get back to what the artists really want. For us to enjoy the music and the vibes and stories that come out of it.
olczaa you really are a hater. Seek help.
I absolutely love this interpretation! It’s infectious and hypnotic. Andre 3000 is a genius and I love Beyoncé her voice puts you in a trance almost
The perfect soundtrack for a perfect movie ❤️✨
This duo is so unexpected, and yet so fitting. Ugh Andre and B did that
is it weird that i like this version so much even after all the hate comments? i still love it and i'm not sorry.
Love this version. I wish people would realize this was made for The Great Gatsby and NOT an Amy Winehouse tribute CD. This version fit the movie perfectly.
They SLAYED it my god... this is perfect...
Man.... this did not get the recognition it needed! From Amy’s memory.. the beat... the vocal play... jazzy feel. Eerie vibes! Bass... 808s .... yeah this remake is a playground! So much fun.
Beyoncé’s part is perfect 🖤
In context to the movie, this version is WAAY better fitting
Can't beleieve I've only just discovered this! I adore Amy of course but this version is also amazing they made the song their own. Going to checkout the whole soundtrack now LOVE
Let me tell yall how I had a whole experience with this song back in 2013. Literally felt something come over me. Idk what’s in this song but baby don’t play with it.
Having this song available was definitely a huge factor why I switched from Spotify 😅
i miss amy winehouse soo much man!!
me and you both.. she was so beautiful
She's suffering cause of this awful cover :(
Perfect melody to a perfect storyline. Shall we...dive into the inexplicable pool of life. “I was within and without...simultaneously enchanted and repelled by the inexhaustible variety of life.”
Love this version - unique musical tone; Scarface, Amy Winehouse and Great Gatsby all wrapped up in one.
I actually love this version. I heard this one before I ever heard the original, but I like Amy's too. It's just that this goes with the GG movie.
WHY IS THIS NOT IN SPOTIFY
Ownership issues
Coz that's a shitty app that misses a lot of GREAT music, I'll never pay 4 that.
Tidal app has it cause of Jay Z
I think people are upset for this version of song because of the heart break that lies behind the original song by the amazing Amy winehouse. Her last performance was indeed heart ailing when she performed this and then we see Bey sing it and the reaction is how dare she. In which is natural because of the love fans have for Amy’s gift. No one could ever forget Mrs Winehouse even if they tried she’s a gem!
I love this version!
I dont think anyone appreciates how they modernised this song! They took an already amazing original song and just updated it! (and they only did it for a movie its not like you hear this on the radio or anything!) Im mean the original will always be my favorite version of this song but I do like how they re-styled this song and changed it up for a movie set in the 20's while still making the sound relatable to our modern music style
Good, but no one can EVER replace Amy. RIP Amy Winhouse. You will be, and already are, missed.
Ready for the new collab!
2019 still got this, i just love the beats and how they both synced into it
I think both versions are fantastic in different ways. I heard this one first, so that might be why I like it so much. But I see it as different songs with the same lyrics, not just one being a better/worse version of the other.
2022 & still listening ❤ i love this cover
In 2022, I'm still MINDBLOWN by how they FREAKES this! Sickening! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I wish this version was available on Spotify
Shit this is fucking awesome! Beyonce sounds amazing
These people hating are mostly just girls that try to be some alternative indie type shit and get so easily butt hurt when someone makes stuff with the people they stan. They never even know her before she died
olczaa You're angering yourself over Beyonce. If you dislike her, why spend your precious time on her? Stop being miserable and listen to Amy Winehouse. It's not hard.
olczaa Why you're here is very relevant to the comment you made. You're up and down this whole comment section just to denounce an artist to uplift another one. You most definitely look miserable. You have a say just like everyone, yes. But don't use free speech to cover your bitterness. You're mad at the fact that Beyonce is as big as she is and you don't like her music so you come to a video featuring her just to drag her name. Sounds miserable to me.
This film has the best soundtrack I have ever heard and watched in my life.
who still listening to this in 2019
R Tamimi xo 2020
2021
Amy's original of this was beautiful, as was this version.
I'm a huge Amy fan (anyone who knows me will tell you) and had my expectations high for this version. They were almost met. The only thing was how soulful the original was, and this version was more hip-hop. That's fine. It was a refreshing revamp of the song.
I actually enjoyed this version better, because I could understand the words better. The words were also delivered in a way that made the message easier to interpret. Amy's version was really good, but harder to understand and interpret.
shut up
Molly Shannon why are you telling me to shut up? I had no dislike for this version. I enjoyed it, actually, so if it came off as though i didn't, sorry. I just enjoyed Amy's version more, and always will enjoy it more. It's just my preference.
No, I just have an opinion. If you don't like it, then you have proven that you have one of your own.
SAME
they're voices oddly fit... and this isn't a feature I would think could work, but it does. For me at least.
hsg57 it fits with the movie
They also got a song together ‘Party’ check it out !
nah 3 stacks and Bey made a good song way back, so it was nice to see them work together again for this. interesting combo though yeah. “Party” is a legendary song, probably one of my favorite if not my favorite period, Beyoncé songs. Andre 3k always Fire too.
LOVE this song since it Was out! Time flies by the way!😅