CMON"s Dune: War for Arrakis - Gameplay with the Designer

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 112

  • @hughroe8598
    @hughroe8598 2 роки тому +17

    This video was really well produced and the game looks great. I was all up for pledging on kickstarter but I think the price point is high when you factor shipping plus taxes (where applicable). As a UK resident the total costs is nearly $200 Inc of shipping and taxes. The stretch goals are very minimal addons currently , most of which aren't kickstarter exclusive and I struggle to see the benefit in paying twice as much for a game that has little material difference to the retail version. I will just wait for its retail release and pick up then.

  • @UKDagnar
    @UKDagnar 2 роки тому +22

    The Spice must flow...to cover the incredible shipping costs! They must be using Guild Heighliners to ship them at these rates :(

    • @kaibe5241
      @kaibe5241 2 роки тому

      Shipping has gone up considerably worldwide, but the US is notoriously bad for shipping costs, nfi why.

    • @UKDagnar
      @UKDagnar 2 роки тому

      @@kaibe5241 It did go up it has now reduced. Not down to pre COVID prices but a lot lower than the peak 12 months ago

  • @Arkhonai
    @Arkhonai 2 роки тому +6

    Curious about 4player mode, overall seems to be a nice game. Marketing as "multiple victory conditions" would be false though. Both sides have clear one condition, though a bit flexible way to get there. That is a little bit of a let down. Rest looks quite fine, little shallow, but fine. Absolutely loving the IP so thanks to the devs for giving us opportunity to test through TTS. Most likely will back the project.

  • @stonehorsegaming
    @stonehorsegaming 2 роки тому +12

    The shipping costs are eye watering... and frankly putting me on the fence.
    Love the book, enjoyed the films, not sure that I need this at the price they are asking.

    • @simonb4689
      @simonb4689 2 роки тому +2

      Yeah same thing. FOMO is going to grab a lot of ppl with all the KS exclusive. If you want this, you have to grab it now imo and eat that ridiculous shipping price

    •  Рік тому

      just buy dune 2019

    • @stonehorsegaming
      @stonehorsegaming Рік тому

      @Gary Langford having played that the other day, I have to agree. Such a good game.

  • @kadeus1955
    @kadeus1955 2 роки тому +2

    Really looking forward to this :) enjoying how far the Tts content has come from way back when it was first happening.

  • @billcaldwell7904
    @billcaldwell7904 2 роки тому +9

    great job with the camera angles , you can tell how much work you put in !

  • @artemisp2819
    @artemisp2819 2 роки тому

    Minor point, but the Spacing Guild token is referred to as the Landsraad token numerous times throughout the playthrough. The black token (with the three circles) is the Spacing Guild, the red and black circle on a yellow field is the CHOAM token, and the black in white circle on the blue field is the Landsraad token.

  • @nathansutterfield
    @nathansutterfield 2 роки тому +3

    So stoked

  • @RafaelCabreraAzrael
    @RafaelCabreraAzrael 5 місяців тому

    THE SPICE MUST FLOW!

  • @PiR8Rob
    @PiR8Rob 7 місяців тому +1

    I don't understand why in the first round Chase got to keep the harvester in the area that was also occupied by one of Shira's legions. Seems like a pretty big oversight that Francesco should have caught.

    • @Quackalope
      @Quackalope  7 місяців тому +1

      Playing on TTS and on camera it can be easy to overlook something :)

  • @lukewisner8597
    @lukewisner8597 2 роки тому +3

    Looks like a lot of fun! I’d love to see the designers make a Wheel of Time game with the same system. It works so well for capturing the theme of a fantasy world

    • @brandonjohnson9876
      @brandonjohnson9876 7 годин тому

      @@lukewisner8597 War of the Ring shares many similarities with this game, but set in the Lord of the Ring universe. Dice for actions, asymmetric factions and win conditions, two card decks for each faction, unit stacking rules that with regular and elite units, leaders (named and generic), etc. I believe both games shared core designers as well.
      It’s not WoT, but it works well if you want a fantasy themed version of this.

  • @maxf.7262
    @maxf.7262 2 роки тому +1

    Ty for the gamplay! Is realy compelling!

  • @mickelboy182
    @mickelboy182 2 роки тому +14

    It amazes me CMON never has prototypes of these games.... Even tiny publishers normally have SOMETHING.

    • @CB-yh3db
      @CB-yh3db 2 роки тому

      CMON is a big company, but it’s just so much cheaper to and easier (no travel) to do this through table top simulator. Don’t get me wrong, I agree that you don’t completely get a sense of the scope, table presence, magnitude as playing in person. Since the KS is next week, they must have some physical prototypes, I would figure.

    • @mickelboy182
      @mickelboy182 2 роки тому +5

      @@CB-yh3db of course its cheaper, but the same thing with Marvel Zombies. That campaign made millions and millions and they never demoed a prototype. They really do take their userbase for granted.

    • @CB-yh3db
      @CB-yh3db 2 роки тому

      @@mickelboy182 - I agree that they should have a prototype or two imo. But unfortunately, as a publicly traded company they have a fiduciary responsibility to maximize profits. Which often means doing things that are not in the best interest of the consumer especially when they know that with an IP like Dune….the spice…er…I mean money will flow. Did they lose backers because of a lack of physical prototype for Marvel Zombies? Maybe, but that project was extremely successful. Again, I heard about the shipping debacle of Marvel Zombies, but this is the result when companies are narrowly focused on Capitalism and neglect their fan base/customers imo. I realize molds are very expensive but with the prevalence of 3D printers, I am sure they could have created some prototypes and simply said “These are not final production, etc, etc but I think CMON tends to like to put out some decent miniatures even in their prototypes like in the videos for Marvel United. Perhaps, they couldn’t showcase the miniatures because they needed final approval from the Frank Herbert estate. I dunno.

    • @mickelboy182
      @mickelboy182 2 роки тому +3

      @@CB-yh3db you are being a little hysterical raising that they are publically listed and thus need to cut all corners. The cost of producing a prototype is negligible for the marketing benefit, particularly when we are talking of the economies of scale that CMON participates in.

    • @CB-yh3db
      @CB-yh3db 2 роки тому +4

      @@mickelboy182 - Then what is they rationale for not producing prototypes if it isn’t to save money ? My point about them being a publicly traded company is that they put money/profitably/reducing costs first and foremost. Are they just thumbing their nose at their fans/customers ? Is it just that they are tone deaf as to what their patrons want to see? Or perhaps, they figure they can save money (as many businesses seek to do) and they know that they probably won’t lose any customers because people love Dune, Marvel, etc. lol….hardly hysterical in fact quite the opposite. Hysterical meaning, ‘derived from extreme emotion’. Seems quite logical when you look at it from that standpoint. No emotions at all. We might disagree on this point, but at least we agree, that CMON should have physical prototypes. :)

  • @JanusZudnik
    @JanusZudnik Рік тому +1

    Your gameplay convinced me that the nature of the game is not the epic stature of War of the Ring but rather similar to its three skirmish affiliates, The Battle of Five Armies and the two scenarios for the WOTR v1 expansion, Gondor and Rohan.
    It's quite clear: Unit placement, how characters enter play, unit cap in one area and even the use of vehicles.
    The theme is also right for the format: it's the Desert War, which is a snapshot of the greater conflict and story; a scenario.
    I'm even suspecting that maybe Nepitello is the head of these affiliates and it shows?

  • @ferretfather2000
    @ferretfather2000 6 місяців тому

    The Sleeper Has Awakened!

  • @andreasremoundos80
    @andreasremoundos80 2 роки тому +1

    QUACK!!

  • @JoeHuddleston
    @JoeHuddleston 2 роки тому +2

    We'll see. Not 100% sold yet.

  • @zak1090
    @zak1090 2 роки тому

    More Dune!

  • @freebordor
    @freebordor 2 роки тому +4

    I’m excited to see the four player mode. I feel a lot of the draw of Dune is the different groups interacting. Hopefully will be legit!

    • @freebordor
      @freebordor 2 роки тому

      @@ilqrd.6608 I have War of the Ring and you can see that this game is set up as a strong 2 player game. Who’s to say the 4 player mode isn’t just as good? That’s what I’m excited to see.

  • @ondrejmed6243
    @ondrejmed6243 2 роки тому +4

    I am really looking forward to this game, but the amount of luck scares me. Drawing cards, tokens (two different types), sietch values (if I understood well, that they are determined by chance), rolling dice (actions + combat + storm at the end of the turn) and I don´t see many ways to mitigate much of it. What are your thoughts on that?

    • @jonny1speed85
      @jonny1speed85 2 роки тому +4

      Have you played War of the Ring? It will be very similar to that, in that it's definitely not a pure strategist's game, but more of a narrative experience with a fair bit of luck. If that doesn't sound like you're sort of game then you probably are right to pass.
      To address the dice rolling concerns you have, the action dice luck is not too much of a problem, as they are flexible and can be used for plenty of things, they are more to add variance between play throughs, and to stop everyone just taking the same perfectly optimal opening moves every game.
      The combat dice add a bit of uncertainty to battles. You aren't sure of victory even with superior numbers. You can mitigate this through the use of leaders and their abilities, or by ensuring you have sufficient overwhelming numbers to guarantee an attrition victory.
      The sietch values are fixed, but their locations are randomised to ensure the Harkonnens have to search and find the optimal sietches to destroy. If they weren't then the game would become all about the Harkonnens rushing the known optimal sietches and ignoring the rest.
      In regards to the storm damage and worm damage to troops, this could have been mitigated by the Harkonnen player by attacking from the plateau where worms do not attack and legions are safe from storm damage, or ensuring they had an action die remaining after combat resolved to be able to move onto the adjacent safety of the plateau.

    • @brandonjohnson9876
      @brandonjohnson9876 7 годин тому

      @@jonny1speed85one correction, worms can attack into plateaus, but not move into them. They can’t attack into mountains.

  • @joeferreti9442
    @joeferreti9442 Рік тому +1

    Sad that you didn't play till the end of the game.

  • @Ramistrov
    @Ramistrov Рік тому +1

    Would love to see a 4 player

  • @ludomancersvault5518
    @ludomancersvault5518 2 роки тому +1

    Shira really brought her "A" game. Well played, Shira.

  • @andraslibal
    @andraslibal 2 місяці тому

    Why does CMON do a kickstarter they have enough money to make a product from finish to start without a kickstarter.
    This is just a way to wring out more money from the customers and delay the product release.
    When it becomes a real product that can be bought in stores at normal prices then I will consider it.

  • @Joecuts
    @Joecuts Рік тому

    How strict are those kickstarter exclusives? Cause the cards and figurines are already made... bit shitty to only use it on the backers.
    Is it common they'll be for sale in an expansion?

  • @kevincragun5853
    @kevincragun5853 2 роки тому +2

    I know this going to be a Day 1 back, but dang it, knowing we’ll probably have to wait 1.5 years to get it bites. My wallet is crying already! 🤤

  • @elqord.1118
    @elqord.1118 2 роки тому +4

    I passed on Marvel Zombies, passed on Cyberpunk and didn’t back a CMON game this year so far…this one though I gotta get. I hope it’s just a core box with everything in it. If they ruin this with a dozen add ons I will 100% pass though.

    • @Bladedheart
      @Bladedheart 2 роки тому

      It's CMON. There will be stretch goals. There will be add-ons. Dozens of add-ons? Probably not, but definitely some.

  • @korsus7055
    @korsus7055 2 роки тому +1

    Great video Jesse. Nepitello/Maggi... we are talking of WoTR best game ever + CMON... this is a guaranteed success

  • @CJUzziel
    @CJUzziel 2 роки тому

    Thanks for the video. Would you say this is simpler than War of the Ring? Also, War of the Ring leans more toward two players even though you can play four. Is it the same with Dune?

    • @InVinceIble009
      @InVinceIble009 2 роки тому

      He can't say, he's never played War of the Ring!

    • @CJUzziel
      @CJUzziel 2 роки тому

      @@InVinceIble009 😥 Perhaps someone else in the video have some thoughts on this?

    • @JanusZudnik
      @JanusZudnik Рік тому +1

      This is more in the veins of The Battle of Five Armies and therefore much simpler and less epic than War of the Ring, I suspect they promote it this way because the former (and its predecessors: the two scenarios of the expansion for the first WOTR) never got that popular...

    • @InVinceIble009
      @InVinceIble009 Рік тому

      @@JanusZudnik question is... is it better than battle of the five armies though? I'm not a huge fan of this one too. But I'd need a steady player to play it more with

    • @JanusZudnik
      @JanusZudnik Рік тому

      @@InVinceIble009 It's hard to tell. TBOFA has a fairly complicated battle machanic, I especially like the damage tokens dealt to armies, but this here streamlined system could make for quick and fun games, and with the Possible Futures variants, the alternative leaders, offer some interesting replayability options, although the characters seem less different than in TBOFA...

  • @MrScrawnjuan
    @MrScrawnjuan 2 роки тому

    Having no minis made and expecting delivery in 8 months is bold

  • @seniscram7958
    @seniscram7958 2 роки тому

    Looks like the epic KS game of the year. Exciting. Also excited about my pledge for Bloodstone on GameFound.

  • @IchbinsderBen
    @IchbinsderBen 2 роки тому +1

    Either it was an oversight, or this was against the rules as described in the WIP Rulebook but the way the Sandworms were placed in relation to the harvesters during Step 3 was not really correct - or the Rulebook is wrong.

    • @IchbinsderBen
      @IchbinsderBen 2 роки тому +2

      There also was a harvester sharing a space with Atreides. It should have been removed after they moved it, right?

  • @joshmidd
    @joshmidd Рік тому +1

    10:53 😂

    • @joshmidd
      @joshmidd Рік тому +1

      Well, I am definitely proficient. Got that set up down to ~20 mins with me and my bro.

  • @elqord.1118
    @elqord.1118 2 роки тому

    The number of times Shira had to flip the tokens to see how many units were placed should tell you how big of a pain that will be when playing the actual game in physical form. I honestly believe that a extra dry erase map with a mini version of the map would be super helpful so the player can mark that behind a shield and doesn’t have to keep flipping over tokens hundreds of times

  • @BillyTheRealDeal
    @BillyTheRealDeal 2 роки тому

    This playthrough has sold me on the game. Now I need to read the books to get the lore before it arrives in fall of 2023. Thank you all.

  • @JohnHoliver
    @JohnHoliver 2 роки тому +3

    I'm super excited to not back any more CMON games in KS! Let's goooo! /o/

    • @JohnHoliver
      @JohnHoliver 2 роки тому +1

      I'm sorry you feel hurt by my comment. Everybody seems to be sharing their excitement, I thought it was cool to share mine too :)
      If you want to know objective reasons behind my excitement, feel free to ask. If not, it's equally fine.

    • @Quackalope
      @Quackalope  2 роки тому +1

      Everyone is entitled to their own opinions. What games do you enjoy?

    • @JohnHoliver
      @JohnHoliver 2 роки тому

      @@Quackalope really digging Oathsworn atm, soon to start ch9. Did you already lost/win the challenge from Jamie?

  • @fubarbox
    @fubarbox 2 роки тому +1

    is there a good place to read the rulebook? its a bit of a pain inside TTS

    • @helixcom
      @helixcom 2 роки тому +1

      Hover over anything in TTS (a page of the rulebook) and hold the "ALT" key down. It makes it much easier to read it.

    • @fubarbox
      @fubarbox 2 роки тому

      @@helixcom Thanks. I knew that was possible, its just a hassle. It is nice when game companies put a link to their rules in as well so it is more convenient to read them. Which it looks like they now have. They must have updated because it was called Dune7 when I subscribed and now it has its actual name as well.

  • @LetsKeepThePeace
    @LetsKeepThePeace 2 роки тому +2

    Do we know how much it will cost? Ballpark?

    • @kumanight
      @kumanight 2 роки тому +1

      Core box probably about $120-$150, expansions likely around $40-$50 each and probably a $400-600 all-in

    • @frankndice
      @frankndice 2 роки тому +1

      Shipping will be like $60

    • @VaultBoy13
      @VaultBoy13 2 роки тому +2

      @@kumanight Doubt it'll go into the $400-600 range. This will probably be $300 for a gameplay all-in. There's little reason to expect this to look different from Rising Sun or Ankh when it comes to gameplay/expansion content.
      I suppose they could throw that off by having a 2-foot tall sandworm sculpt that functions as a water feature by vomiting blue water during the game.
      They could do some junky bling ala He-Man with plastic terrain. But, the board looks really good, and terrain would reduce the functionality.
      I'm sure CMON can find a way to milk backers for $600 with this. But, I don't think they'll find a way to do it with gameplay.

    • @frankndice
      @frankndice 2 роки тому +1

      @@ilqrd.6608 is that for real?

    • @cartergreen2309
      @cartergreen2309 2 роки тому +2

      @@frankndice i wouldn't be surprised if they continue their trend of raising it and shipping hits 80+ this time. The bad part is they are the only company I see jacking shipping costs like this. Pretty much no chance I back a CMON game again until they stop taking advantage of people like that. I'll wait till it's in retail

  • @blaarghwee
    @blaarghwee 2 роки тому +1

    Of all the Dune games that have been popping up this looks most interesting. Aside from OG Dune.
    Still.. I'd love to see something go beyond book 1.

    • @Deafz
      @Deafz 2 роки тому +3

      Dune Imperium is realy good though! Maybe not as visually pleasing as War with all its' minis, but mechanically a really good game!

    • @ryancain6012
      @ryancain6012 Рік тому

      Avalon Hill's Dune includes content from the sequels.

  • @jacobsmit4104
    @jacobsmit4104 2 роки тому

    This is sooo awesome!!!

  • @Magicman1625
    @Magicman1625 2 роки тому

    So you can use a strategy die to move a legion with a leader? I thought you could only do that with a Leadership die? 🤔

    • @haoz8074
      @haoz8074 2 роки тому

      In war of the ring you can move armies with leader or army dice, and armies can include leaders (even when moved with army dice).

    • @Magicman1625
      @Magicman1625 2 роки тому

      @@haoz8074 Which means I've been playing WOTR wrong all this time 😔
      The Dune rulebook makes it clear once I read it but the WOTR rulebook wasn't very clear on this point.
      Ah well next game I can play it right and have so much more freedom with armies lol 😆

    • @jamdowdy2754
      @jamdowdy2754 2 роки тому

      @@Magicman1625 War of the Ring is pretty clear with it I thought, they have two player aids that describe everything the dice do

    • @Magicman1625
      @Magicman1625 2 роки тому

      @@jamdowdy2754 Well I simply misunderstood what is considered an Army because it says you can move two different armies with an Army die result.
      I thought Leaders were separate since they don't count towards the total units in a space and since they had thier own die facing to move armies with.
      Just a lot of technical terms like Armies, Units, Leaders and such

  • @Youssef-qb3cx
    @Youssef-qb3cx 2 роки тому

    Seems really finicky - is that just a TTS thing?

  • @maximalDruck
    @maximalDruck 2 роки тому

    Hmmmmm..i dunno. I’m usually really into this type of game and I really love the theme..but somehow it doesn’t seem appealing gameplay wise. Maybe its the overuse of dice..

  • @Quackalope
    @Quackalope  2 роки тому +1

    Follow the KS - www.kickstarter.com/projects/cmon/dune-war-for-arrakis?ref=clipboard-prelaunch

  • @thehaydenroper
    @thehaydenroper 2 роки тому

    Is it really easier to run this on 2 computers than to just get an extra monitor for 1? 😂

  • @Rundeish
    @Rundeish 2 роки тому +10

    Looks quite boring and not very appealing. Easy skip.

    • @elqord.1118
      @elqord.1118 2 роки тому +1

      Thanks Rune. We needed to know your thoughts. Knowing your gaming experience, preferences and habits this comment proved invaluable. Appreciate it.

    • @Rundeish
      @Rundeish 2 роки тому +4

      @@elqord.1118 keep the same energy for the positive comments.

    • @lastburning
      @lastburning 2 роки тому +1

      @@elqord.1118 I hope you have the same standards for positive comments too.

  • @nathanmichael167
    @nathanmichael167 Рік тому

    Fool Me once Cmon, Fool me Twice... Fool me three times . Feels too lucky and a bit unbalanced. They are definately missing Lang on this one.

  • @a1karaoke
    @a1karaoke Рік тому

    I wanna see more CMON games go straigth to retail with the option for delux versions ect all this buy now get when were ready plus shipping costs is too much .

  • @Thebrewgeek1
    @Thebrewgeek1 2 роки тому +1

    Sorry but TTS play throughs are awful!

  • @mikaelbrresen983
    @mikaelbrresen983 2 роки тому +1

    Rulebook please...

  • @MerrillWhiteKalEl
    @MerrillWhiteKalEl 2 роки тому

    CMON SANDWORM

  • @kirilivanov92
    @kirilivanov92 2 роки тому +1

    2nd comment :( Quack ! super excited about this one, but will see if it will overthrone Imperium

  • @Shrek-fc3gp
    @Shrek-fc3gp 2 роки тому +1

    Quack

  • @FranzBazar
    @FranzBazar 4 місяці тому

    So. Much. Talking. up front.. had to move on before you started the game

  • @metalrock720
    @metalrock720 2 роки тому +12

    Respectfully - please stop upselling CMON - it makes it really hard to take it seriously. Rather just hear about the game.

    • @Quackalope
      @Quackalope  2 роки тому +22

      Respectfully - I’m allowed to be excited about a game.

    • @aanthoine
      @aanthoine 2 роки тому

      @@Quackalope huge fan of ankh here. Would you rate it "higher" , same or lower than ankh? It seems fun, just not sure yet. I should try it on tts

  • @dreadknot69
    @dreadknot69 Рік тому

    Thanks for reminding me how much I hated this movie. Hard pass for me.

  • @rentless666
    @rentless666 2 роки тому +3

    This looks like another garbage game with a lot of pretty plastic for people to paint.

    • @Dthamilaye
      @Dthamilaye 2 роки тому +1

      Well, this is from the creators of War of the ring, one of the best two player games out there. If this is anything close to WotR, it will be up there at the top of the two players games list as well. The gameplay had many similar elements, not sure if I would prefer this to WoTR though, I have to see (or read) more.
      Of course, knowing CMON, this will be produced bit differently than WOTR. I would assume bigger minis in CMON style (WOTR minis are quite small compared to "normal" cmon stuff). Maybe more other bling as well. I don't mind that too much though, as long as the game is great.
      Another great 2 player game is Ankh. Also blinged to the top, but still great game.

  • @Flo_-ox2qe
    @Flo_-ox2qe 2 роки тому

    Hope for a German version. Otherwise it is a skip for me

  • @robertglass4197
    @robertglass4197 2 роки тому +1

    QUACK!!