@@ThePakistanExperience *You forgot to mention some key aspects here:* • Pakistan has a history of forced disappearances and human rights violation's in Balochistan as per UN. • Iran, USA, Taliban, China are all involved there as Balochistan exists in Afghanistan and Iran too. • Balochistan was technically illegally occupied as Khan of Qalat never agreed for a merger. Their tribal and religious chieftains even today consider Balochistan as a separate state. • Groups like BLA etc are those people which Pakistan army used as Mujahideens in Afghanistan. Quetta, Khyber etc were the usual bases back then. • Selling their resources and lands to China is a major problem. USA is extremely wary of CPEC. Pakistan in fact had given bases to USA here to counter Iran and Afghanistan. • Baloch fishermen are in a dire state as their old mechanical boats can't compete with modern fish trawlers China uses there. • Lack of education, healthcare infrastructure. Connectivity in tribal areas is bon existent. • History of Balochistan and it's culture is non-existent in Pak studies. Maybe considering the atrocities what General Tikka Khan did in Balochistan (and also bangladesh). Also, the fact that they always wanted to remain independent. • Pakistan has been doing terrørism in Indian Kashmir by using groups like Laskhar, Jaish, Hizbul, TRF etc. And if this continues, India will be forced to intervene. • Lastly, live media reporting is banned in Balochistan and even POK.
@@ÆßVThe polit bureau of CCP has been warning Pakistan about their misadventures both in India's Kashmir and Balochistan. China's priorities will always supersede the Baloch people. That's the deal done by Pakistan's rulers. They should've thought about the blowback from the locals. It's not our fault that Pak elites are busy minting money. They themselves don't give a damn, why should we care. We are doing business here. Pakistan's two way deals with America and China aren't helping either.
@@ÆßV *The most sensible comment here.* India wouldn't wanna intervene probably cuz they don't want this region to be destabilized as it'll hamper their growth. They could easily carve out Balochistan like they did in Bangladesh in 13 days. Pakistan's nefarious activities in Indian Kashmir will indeed be last nail in the coffin. Pakistan as usual is playing a swinger between the USA and China and fulfilling their interests. Establishment is sold to foreign powers and the awaam is radicalised and militant. A deadly cocktail.
Good to see this addressed, if you are calling BLA as terrorist, then what is happening in Kashmir by Pakistani based organization would also be terrorism. I hope you agree with this.
You're miserably wrong on this. I would've called them freedom fighters if they only targeted army or security personnel. But now they are targeting innocent civilians? This is terorrism.
You seem to be new here in Pakistani left circle. Time and time again Shehzad and other podcasters have mentioned them as terrorists. Faisal Warraich of dekho suno jano has gone in depth on this topic and explained how people he knew got involved in that terrorism wave.. and how our establishment misguided them into terrorism.
My husband and I were talking about this a couple of hours ago, and I was saying exactly what Shehzad is saying. He said, "Oh, you’ve learned this from the TPE guy," and I was like, "He hasn't even said anything yet." But now, after watching this video, I want to thank you for educating me enough that I can understand things on my own.
@@ThePakistanExperienceIs that punjabi musalman & Bangali musalman was 2 qaumi nazaria in 1971 Now Baloch musalman & punjabi musalman is 2 qaumi nazaria How many 2 qaumi nazaria excist in Pak ?
@@TariqMoaz phir boydcott the sui gas and all resources too chutu aadmi thoda dimag lagao balochon ke sath kharab hua tha toh ab unme se kuch pagal hogye hai joke as a baloch woh mere punjabi bhaiyon ko mar rhe but balochon ke sath galat hua unko rights do to sab peace hojayega warna to phir balochistan independence hi hoga aur phir bethe rehna
@@StoriesInUrdu.that’s a very dangerous line, you should never wish for us to utter. because we have the “logistics” the make pak crumble like a cookie 🍪🍪
@@StoriesInUrdu. kid? HA! don’t your elders teach you to respect men And to not back answer us? be a good women and wear your hijab and be submissive 🤫, maybe if your a good girl I’ll give some aata. :)
Don't be disheartened Shehzad. Don't lose your voice! Advice from a wellwisher - Make a plan for yourself for 15 days off every 6 months notwithstanding any work/family/social compulsions. Take a holiday. Backpack and go on drive. Do a staycation and watch everything you think you missed. Just unplug yourselves until and unless something is extremely urgent. Do this and you will feel better! Well wishes from India!
Fazool baat .... Balochistan is too big....my friend in the military is stationed 200 from unit HQ , the areas they patrol take 3 hours to do and in that time these groups kill and run
Bela ma 12 13 ghanta operation jarri Raha ....kl sham ko ssg na elaka khali kraya ....just because you don't know the reality on ground doesn't things didn't happen
I am so tired of this narrative by India. Yes what happened to Hindus was wrong, but you have been using this for occupying Kashmir for almost 50 years. We will admit our faults which are many, but India needs to admit their fault too so we can forgive forget and move on.
@@syedalirizwan-ok7qmdo u know thousands of Hindus are still today not able to return to kashmir ?? These Hindus were not outsiders but original habitants of kashmir, , and still today thousands of them live outside kashmir due to terrorism . .. . . . Till that day, we definitely have an excuse
You can't invade land of aboriginal Hindus ..pillage , rape, convert locals across centuries changing demography and then claim that somehow the original folks of that land are occupiers... Yeh narrative ab kahi nahi chalega duniya mai... Sabki aankhein khuli gayi hai... By your logic then Balochistan is also occupied by you (Pakistan)... De do wapas unhe
I'm from Punjab and I acknowledge and agree with every single point you make. You are one of my heroes. You continue to teach me, with every video, the way to articulate these points to my circle of friends and family. But your mental health is my primary concern, so don't compromise on that for anything or anyone. Protect yourself first. Love you.
پنجابیوں کو جٹ، راجپوت، اعوان اور کھرل وغیرہ میں تقسیم کر دیا گیا ہے، اگر پنجابی اکٹھے ہو کر آواز نہیں اٹھائیں گے تو بلوچ پنجاب میں آئیں گے اور ہر پنجابی کے ساتھ وہی کریں گے جو 25 اگست کو بلوچستان کے واقعے میں پنجابیوں کے ساتھ کر چکے ہیں۔
I'm Pashtun from Balochistan, I'm ashamed and I'm so sorry for what happened to our Punjabi brothers. This is so brutal and heinous for so many reasons. I've so many Punjabi friends and they're amazing people n support us in our issues in Balochistan. I'm sick to my stomach. Them terrorists killed 2 of my relatives in yesterdays incident. I wonder Pakistan is pushing people of Balochistan for such crimes. Balochistan has everything yet has nothing. Plz give us people of Balochistan our rights, plz stop these innocents getting killed, let us live, give us infrastructure, give us hospitals, give us universities ffs
we need millions of voices like u to bring back "Sanity" & "rationality" in Pak. U r doing a great service to bring awareness thru media. u r a beacon of light, plz dont give up.
@@costructivecritic East Turkestan from China, Donbass, Crimea from Russia, Rohingya from Myanmar, Kashmir from India, Pashtuns, Baloch from Pakistan , earlier Qubec from Canada, Catalunia from Spain. almost Every big country has some sort of Secessionist
Class solidarity between the common Baloch, Pashtun, Seraiki, Sindhi, Punjabi, Muhajir, Hindu, Christian, Shia, Sunni etc is needed to tackle the menace of an exploitative and repressive Establishment.
We Bengalis had suffered because of this Punjabi dominence, now Baloch are facing same thing🙁How to misuse power for own benifits and supress others is the thing elite Punjabis directly got from Britishers....shame..must stop this or be ready for another 1971😊😊😊
I am an Indian Punjabi, Pakistani Punjabis are not responsible for this, they are not the elites of Pakistan most of the leaders of Pakistan have not been Punjabi actually Bhuto is Sindhi, The military Junta at the time of Bangladesh war was entirely Pathan and Muhajir. The Punjabis of Pakistan have no identity their language and culture are regarded as jahil and they cannot even take pride in their ancestors, language or culture. Punjabi Muslims actually were the only Muslim in the Northern Part of British India that voted against Partition the strongest supporters were the Muslims of the Central Provinces and Bengal. So no you did not suffer because of Punjabi dominance as that dominance is a myth.
Don’t lie, it was never because of panjabis but urdu speaking muhajirs , one of them was quaid e Azam who opposed urdu on ur Bengali people , and the army was full of pashtun people and pashtun general , who killed your Bengali people
Bro I am a Punjabi here. we haven't done shit. wtf are we getting accused of. Our political leaders spend money on main areas of Punjab because of the high population (more votes). That's it. We have always stood with 'Haq" and we are with our Balochi brothers even if there are extremists among them who want our demise. We support Bengalis too, the dictator of that time committed atrocities and we're with you. We lost all of our troops there as well, who thought that they were fighting rebels. We, in Punjab, ourselves are facing oppression. People are disappearing everyday for saying stuff online. Women were dragged from their houses for supporting PTI, etc. Do not listen to this UA-camr, he continually speaks provocatively to get more clicks and also clearly has an agenda.
@@Doabann How you dragged the Quaid-e-Azam into this is beyond me. The atrocity happened in 1971 buddy, decades after Quaid-e-Azam's death. Quaid-e-Azam is Top G, don't drag him into this.
Being a baloch myself i am really sad on what BLA did. Every life is precious whether it is a Punjabi, Sindhi, Baloch, Pathan or anyone else. Agreed with whatever you said. Keep making such videos.
I am 15year old boy from Punjab and belongs to a middle class family.I always like your videos because you always speak on the basis of logic and knowledge.You can be somewhere worng but your intentions cannot be doubted.Don't care of those peoples who are abusing you,many are also praying for you.May Allah protect you and give you a long happy life,Inshallah❤😉
Yeah ek aur tato hy establishment ka. Yeah bak bak kr raha hy against Punjabis. Asal culprit muhajir hy. Pashtun hy. Punjabi leaders ek he tha Pakistan Bannatyne waqat usay bhe muhajir liqaqt ne Nikal Dia. Is me itna dam hy live ajaye Mery Sath. Aj bbe elite class muhajirs ke hy Pakistan ke Har institute me. Yeah kabhe nahi bolu GA unke khilaf. Yeah
he doesn't have a consistent stand, he doesn't condemn hamas but calls BLA terrorist even though Hamas is far more brutal in targeting women to sexually assault and children to massacre. He celebrates the killing of non muslims by muslims, ultimately, as long as he can find a flimsy excuse to do so.
I don't understand sometimes muslims never accepts concept of terrorism and they use to argue me there is no terrorism but when they face anything they will blame on terrorism. I condemn any act of terror. Rest in Peace 🕊️
I must say that India should take advantage of Balochistan crisis of Pakistan, we should support our Baloch brothers and sisters to get independence from the rogue state.
@jojo.s_bekaar_adventures Who told you that I hate Muslims in my country? I have many Muslim friends, and I despise radical Muslims who do not represent true Islam.
@@sofialatif564 the problem is Pakistanis are ill informed and obtuse… As far as Khalistan goes there is hardly a murmur in India for it.. only some crazies in Canada and UK keep on doing some antics .. Sikhs are well regarded and distributed all over India… there is no tangible demand for Khalistan in India The Manipur issue is a Kuki vs Maiti tribe issue … it’s not secessionist issue Kashmir surely has a secessionist flavour and was fully supported by Pakistan to extent possible.. now with pak going down the drain I’m sure even a single Kashmiri would not like to go with pak… and a seperate state is not tangible due to its geography Although we Indians would be happy if Pakistan remains stable as an unstable Pakistan is not good for India .. but due to your mishandling Balochistan however will secede like Bangladesh just watch
My heart aches to see you and Mr. Muzzamil getting frustrated and disappointed with each passing day. I would like to share my story with you. I come from Lahore and have completed my MSc Hons in Agriculture from University of Agriculture, FSD in 2019. I have changed my Political and Social views in last 10 years thanks to The Pakistan Experience, Muzzamil Hussain and Dekho Suno Jano. I feel like there are thousands who have unlearned all the propaganda just like me and MILLIONS MORE TO GO. I hope to see you thrive and make such truthful content which will make us into much much better individuals and ultimately a better nation.
Shehzad bhai don't think that Urdu speaking people's hate's you because i am as a urdu speaking and my friends & family circle is with you because you're always talk truth , Stay strong God bless you ❤️❤️❤️
@@ThePakistanExperiencebhai i am a urdu speaker too and i second you in so many things, bus jahan difference of opinion banta hai wo to sab ka right hai, bus bhai us chutye ko na bulaya karo parizaad drama jaan ko agaya hai, na wo drama banta na wo chutya itni baten ch****, is k ilawa phul saport saar
@@ThePakistanExperiencetert sath ab pirate Punjab kry ga hate kau k tone kaha unke national assembly me seats ziada hy. Js ke jitni abadi Hoge utni seats Hoge. India me up ke seats sb se ziada hy. What Kab kise ne hate ke hy UP se. Ek Punjabi hy jo tumhe kuch nahi krhty tum bao bao krty jaty hooo
If for you Hamas is Palestine's army, then how is BLA a terrorist organization for you? Are you not hypocrites? When Pakistan Army killed BLA people, women and children, you never made any video. But when your people died today, you started talking about the rights of Bolichistan.
Bangladesh and Balochitan are two different things Balochistan doesn't share a direct border with India so it is quite difficult for India to help the Balochitan for freedom.
@@Salu_GujjarGurjar7431Even in Bangladesh war , , India fought on 2 fronts , , West and East Pakistan .. .this time it would be easy to focus on one front, , , penetrating from Sindh to Balochistan
@@_Parmatma_ not on west front only in eastern front western front is well solved in 1948 when Pakistan controlled hald region of Kashmir and India after 1948 take revenge from Pakistan with the help of Israel and succeed to liberate Bangladesh. But India is still trying to liberate Balochitan & KPk because India believes Pakistan is involved in funding Indian side kashmiri fighters & Khalistani fighters. But Balochistan is a different chapter Iran, Afghanistan side will not use directly against Pakistan India will try to use only local groups from Balochitan region but in last they all will fail.
@@_Parmatma_ Even when new government of USA will contact Pakistani government or some issues will be solve between USA and Pakistan this small issue of Balochitan will also be solve USA itself involved in this matter you know very well how USA changed pro Indian regime of Bangladesh in the face of Sheikh Haseena.
I am from hyderabad india, i like your vedios, but Pakistan have so many probleams still why all your army and top people intrested in indian muslims. Set your home order.
When you have nothing to show or contribute to world, you will have to point to some thing against others to show there are issues. In Pakistan: When Babar and Pervez board a bus, they fight for a seat, fight settles down after 10 minutes, Babar gets the seat. life goes on. In India: When Vinay and Pervez board a bus, they fight for a seat, fight settles down after 10 minutes, Vinay gets the seat. Next day a certain newspapers/ Vloggers/bloggers will write' Minority under threat in India' Pervez denied a seat in bus. Pakistan will point will raise this issue.
@@edgecase1047 al jazeera, bbc, global times will write articles about how horrible India is. low cost attempts try to keep the country from reaching it's obvious full potential
Shehzad bhai you're an asset! Please don't stop, you're the hope of all of us Pakistanis who have the same views and thoughts but are too scared to speak publically.
These youtubers are using double standards. When Punjabis are killed, then it is terrorism and when Balochis are killed by Punjabi soldiers it is nationalism. This guy is educated?
Pmd9756 A real baloch will stand against oppression of Bla the way they are conducting attacks are harm to humanity and whole nation I am a Pathan but Pakistani first our Country is Pakistan no matter what happens to this country this is our country this not just the country of Sindhis Pathans Balochis Punjabis but country of Pakistanis and Pakistan Zindabad no matter what happens and you are the terrorist bro you are not baloch instead you are a terrorist and the people who sell their country for 20 rupees and join the so called Bla Baloch liberation army we all Pakistanis should stand against the oppression of BLA which included Pathan Punjabi and Balochis so remember that not just Punjabis are killed but Balochis are also killed and inshallah your plan to free Balochistan from Pakistan will never succeed and will fail inshallah BLA the oppressors of Humanity Should be banned forever inshallah
I am a 24-year-old from KPK, currently living in Punjab. I've met people from Punjab, Kashmir, Balochistan, KPK, and Sindh, and everyone has been genuinely nice. I don't have much faith in anything, but I will put my faith in the newer, younger generation, who are more understanding than the older generation that has been spreading hate. We are not meant to hate each other; we need to function as one.
As a Punjabi I'm terrified right now (as I live near Balochistan). I 110 % agree that every province should get its rights but I mean politicians or generals take these decisions. Common Punjabis (even Punjabis from Uper middle class) r not involved in these matters. Shouldn't we focus on "rights 4 every1" than "y Punjabis r getting more rights than every1 in Pakistan" (even we r not getting every human right, there is no JUSTICE in courts, we r also scared of our Police, Elites r dominant here too). & Southern/Lower Punjab is just like any other province (watch Syed Muzammil's video on Southern Punjab 2 understand our situation).
@@moviemango143 I don't mind a free Balochistan tbh but the thing is we all would have 2 suffer a bloody war. This generation (of Balochi, Punjabis, Sindhis, Pathans) would be doomed even in case of civil war🤦♀️I hope our establishment decides 2 give Balochis their rights as an equal citizen. Love & peace from Punjab🙌
Then hamas is also terrorist but wait you guys call it a reaction to exactly it was a reaction of brutality of Israel same here punjabis have killed so many balochis in the uniform millions are missing arent that terrorism? Come on think that we all have to answer almighty one day
Thousand of Pakistani died, your always answer was Balochistan ka masla Kiya hy.... Sindhiyon pathonon ka msla Kiya hy.... Ab panjabi marain hain to pori mulk my aag lg gaey hy.... Now come on grounds and solve issue genuinely. Panjab has enjoyed all resources, electricity, gas, oil. Now this idiot with mic come on screen and saying to us that you are also terrorist...
BLA did that because normal Punjabis need to understand what their brethren do with people in other provinces or with ethnic minorities while they hold an office of powers. It doesn't justify the actions of BLA, but Punjabis needs to come out and fight against oppressors who are their own.
When Pakistan did not even exist, Balochistan was a very big area. A large part of today's Pakistan and Iran together formed Balochistan. Before entering Balochistan, there used to be a very big gate, that gate was made of pure gold and expensive stones. That gate reflected the richness of the Indian continent. Foreign invaders looted this rich land and are looting it even today.😢😢😢😢
I have a question shehzad: I’ve consistently supported Mahrang Baloch’s efforts to raise awareness about missing persons in Balochistan. However, I haven’t seen any recent public statements from her condemning the ongoing brutality by BLA. Why is it that people from Punjab, particularly the common folks, continue to stand in solidarity with the people of Balochistan. I’m not expecting sympathy from the BLA. But can you show me any single condemnation from Mahrang Baloch?
People of Punjab don’t. Should we only support human rights causes in exchange for them supporting us or should we support them because it is the right thing to do?
@@hameed2k1she is a human too here she is making big mistake that she will realize later And may be she is scared of bla or she doesn't want to be in a war with bla too like pakistani elite
So sorry for what you have to deal with for educating this nation. There people who want to know and learn about the things which are not there on mainstream media. Thanks for existing & discussing all the facts. Stay safe & strong.
Why would she when Punjabis call her father a te rrorist? Punjabi army abducted innocent Balochis and labelled them as te rrorists. Why did you expect her to show mercy when in fact Islamabad police were doing lathicharge on Baloch women and children during peaceful protests?
BLA is very similar to Hamas (both in terms of objectives and tactics) and I find it really funny how Pakistanis are blindly supporting one and blindly hating on the other...
@@mike-oj7sy both are fighting a powerful military/govt which they perceive to be an occupyer over their indigenous lands and both are more than willing to use terror tactics against civil and military targets in pursuit of that goal. Pakistanis were making fun of piers morgan for asking palestinians to condemn hamas, and just yesterday a video on twitter resurfaced and was being shared in which ghareeda farooqi was asking mahrang baloch to condemn BLA💀. Anyone with even a tiny bit of critical thought can see the very obvious similarities
Waise toh main half Punjabi half Pashtun Hun or mere ancestors pehlay Patiala or post independence Lahore mein settle Hain or yeh news mere Dil or dimagh se NAHI Nikal Rahi 😭 Innocent, working class Punjabis kyun maara inko yaar tumhara problem establishment ya powerful class se hai aik common Punjabi ka Kya qasoor hai? Or Dr Mahrang Baloch ko condemn Karna chahiye tha is ko but Punjabis ke qatal e aam per woh khamosh Hain 😔. Allah mere pyaray watan Pakistan ki hifazat farmaye.
کیوں کے تم بے وقوف ہو یہ کسی اسٹیبلشمنٹ کے خلاف نہیں ان کے خون میں پنجابی سے نفرت ہے بھٹو سے مشرف تک کوئی پنجابی نہیں تھا لیکن ان کی دشمنی پنجابی سے ہے مزدوروں کو مار کر بہت بڑا کارنامہ کیا ہے انھوں نے برحال مسلمان پنجابی تو اب پنجابی بھی نہیں رہے پنجابی صرف سکھ ہیں جو کہ اب پاکستان پنجاب میں نہیں.
Out of 23 people, 18 were Saraiki. 5 laborers(Saraiki) yesterday died in Pindi 14 Policemen(saraiki) were killed in RYK incident. Portraying them as Punjabi, why?
It is heartwarming to listen to you, me n my friend we often watch n later discuss… u put a lot of effort n are very committed to all the sensitive topics u pick … wish u more success and pray for ur safety… love n prayers stay safe n blessed
lots of duas for you dear Shehzad, this video broke my heart and I could literally feel the hurt suffered by you. just want you to know that I have personally formed so many opinions based on your podcasts and have learnt so much, most of all I have learnt to look at things subjectively and for that I am truly indebted to you. May Allah protect you always
As someone from Quetta, your clear mindedness and courage in calling out Pakistani hypocrisy is honestly very refreshing. It must be very difficult. More strength to you. Keep calling these idiots out on social media but hope you dont get bogged down in the individual tweets and videos... that will drain your life.
I can see in the comments how Indian Hindus and Pakistani extremists koshish kar rhe hen ke kisi trha se hate or phele. I just want to say please look at your country and what is happening there. Protect your women first before trying to spread hate among others. Most Indians, especially Modi lovers excel in spreading fake news and hate. So, it is our duty as Pakistanis to keep on ignoring them as if they are whispers from Shaitaan. As a pathaan living in Punjab, i love every community. Agar Pakistan nahi to hum nahi.
konsi fake news? tumne fake news faila rakhi hai india mei musalmaan khatre mei hai. pta ni aisa konse khatre mei hai musalman, population percentage unki badh rhi hai. govt schemes mei disproportionately muslims ko benefits mil rhe hai. fake news tum failate ho bina padhe
@@harshitgarg3436 These are people who read aasmani kitab, without lies their religion dies 🤣 Jhuth bol bol kar toh country ka beda gark kar rakha hai. They only watch army sponsored news and Dhruv Tatti. Idhar aate ki line mein lagi hai kaum aur udhar Pakisatni in L0ndon are stopping traffic to celebrate 14th August 🤣🤣 Desh se bhaag ke Independence Day manaate hain. British logo ne inki khub hawaa tight ki huyi hai.
What bro ? World recognise Pakistan as a terror sponsor country. ◉‿◉ Osmosis bin lantern was found in Abbottabad. pakistanis have very short memory ?
What bro ? World recognise Pakistan as a terror sponsor country. ◉‿◉ Osmosis bin lantern was found in Abbottabad. Tumhari fauj bhi ek deshatgard tanzeem h. Bengalis p kitna julm kiya.
What happened in Bangladesh? Sheikh mujib just wanted power he was power Hungary his daughter sh hasina is same now in India. Why sh hasina is India now?
Most of the war crimes during 1971 in Bangladesh were done by Punjabi soldiers. Apart from Punjabis, Sindhis played a vital role in those atrocities @@raffayali5291
@@raffayali5291idiot it's the army of punjab did it ..... Punjabis taking all resources from bolchistan nd still it is by far the poorest underdeveloped neglected region
Bhai apki baat puri tarah se sahi hai as a Indian and also a sanatani ham log bhi chahte hai ki kisi bhi begunah ki jaan nhi jana chahiye chahe vo baloch ho ya Panjabi
"sachi baat kahi thi maine logoun ne sooli pe charhaya mujhko zehr ka jaam pilaya phir bhi unhen chain na aayaa" Shehzad bhai! Taareekh gawah hai ke sachay log hamesha aese hi khayalat or logoun ki nazar hote hain! yeh tab tak chalta rahega jab tak insan sach bolta rahega! But you really don't have any idea what these videos mean to us! You are enlightening lives, you are doing an unbelievable job, we owe you a lot. Lots of love and best wishes!
But Same thing happened in Kashmir in 1990 with indigenous Kashmiri Hindus and In Punjab with Punjabi Hindu using Sikhs in 1980s… ironically sponsored by Pakistan… Boya ped babbool ka AAM knha se hoye
But you forgot to mention this Mahrang and his gang indirectly supports BLA BLF and never condem these terrorists. His father ghaffar lango was also a BLA terrorist.
Punjabi as identity is a very weak identity, specifically in Pakistan it's more of a social identity I would say than a genetic one, if you live in Punjab then you are Punjabi, no strings attacked. you don't have to learn the language don't have to follow any customs. and you sure don't have to be born into it. that's it... that is why there are Punjabi Pashtoon and Punjabi Baloch... and they feel right at home. now I live in a small Punjabi village in central Punjab, and we do have Baloch Pashtuns Kashmiris even a few European housewives if you can count them as well... never had a problem with any of them or vice versa.. but still, we are hated... WHY??? and why are Punjabis angry with nonviolent Baloch human rights activists...? first of all, Pakistan has been an agrarian society from the start that is and Punjab is the most fertile region in Pakistan the number of small landowners is also greater than in any other province, thus more people have money directly from their own cultivated fields than from wages. then capitalism comes into play... most of the development that you see in Punjab as compared to say Sindh is done by the private sector. private hospitals, private schools... in short there is more money in circulation and that makes it a large market of goods. now where there is a market there is taxation.. and once you collect that tax you want to spend that money in a fashion that will increase your taxes. you build roads railway lines airports, subsidized factories.. etc so you don't want to spend money away from population centers where there is no use for that infrastructure in a way that increases taxation... and these mineral projects that people think are just bundles of wealth lying in the ground are not exactly what people make them out to be, for example, a lot of infrastructure has to be built in such places for it to be even viable to be mined... and further away you are from population centers, more expansive these infrastructure projected become... so let's say you have extracted natural gas from a province, what are you going to do with it... on its own, it's not a currency or of any value, you have to sell it, and best of luck trying to sell your expansive natural gas in front of the biggest and cheapest natural gas reserve in the world Qatar... so now look for a domestic market, and where does that take us, of course, the market, the population centers... because let's not forget our goal is to make money out of it recover our expenditures, and then earn profits, not to do charity and give it away to poor people who cannot even afford it... and then repeat that entire cycle over and over again...
Brilliant take on the issue, aisi sensible voices dono desho me chahiye. What a balanced mind you have with respect to the facts and the overall take on violence! Keep up the good work. Rest in peace, all the innocent, affected families 🙏🏻 Take care brother
Shehzad, you are one of the few sane voice coming out of Pakistan I sincerely wish and hope you will keep the good work going. I really love and wait for your podcasts to appear on the UA-cam channel. Please keep safe and if possible continue giving us gems.
I was talking to my friend in Balochistan, he went to an office to get some papers and there were people ranting on how the state in unjust...on being asked what has happened they said they "only" the AC for whole day and the government gives a bill of 7000 ...its unfathomable....if you were in punjab you'd get a bill of 25000+ ....there is a lack of education, infrastructure there coupled with the feudal system that actually cripples the system ....and the lords there have to make an a common enemy ...which they make Punjabis...the operations in Balochistan were done by pervaz mushraff(a mahajir) and ayub khan( a ethic pashtun) but still they target the punjabis...+ Also people like marang baloch who are haled as activists propogated and even posted that people like mahal baloch were kidnapped by the state( btw mahal was involved in the bombings yesterday) and her silence on the killing of innocent average punjabis add to the discredit of this character
@@ThePakistanExperiencekoi baat nahi state propaganda bee kabi kabi acha hota Look what Israel and USA achieved with state propaganda And justice only delivered with F-16s
Bat such hae pr punjabi Punjabiyat ki bat kerte hae. Culture India Punjabi se same honeki bat krte hae Hindu Sikh Punjabi ko bolte hae asi Punjabi tusi Punjabi
اور اس میں یہ شہزاد بھی شامل ہے اب آئے بائے کر رہا ہے لیکن آہستہ آہستہ اب پنجابی کو بھی سمجھ آہ رہی ہے میں نے اس کی بہت پوڈکاسٹ دیکھی ہیں اس میں پنجابی کے لئے بغض ہے جو یہ چھپا نہیں سکتا ایک واقعہ بتا دیں پنجاب میں جہاں پنجابی نے کسی دوسری قوم کے شناختی کارڈ دیکھ کر انھیں قتل کیا ہو؟
@@sofialatif564 Punjabi KO punjabiyat ki bat karni Chahiye Ye unka haq hai aur agar tum Punjabi hu Tu lakh lanat tum jeso par pehla apni zuban Punjabi ty bol lawo zuban bolni aundi ni ty gal karny jy punjab di hypocrites
Shehzad, your videos are incredibly heartwarming, and the intention behind creating them is both genuine and filled with empathy. Don’t let the negativity from others get to you-they simply fail to grasp your message. Remember, there are countless people who find inspiration in your work. Keep shining, and know that you are in my prayers!
Paani Kay hawaalay say Punjab nay 3 darya diye thay Pakistan Kay liye, south Punjab khaas taur par tail par Rahim yar khan waghaira may paani nahi aata aur Sindh Chala jaata hai. Plus historically Lahore division British time ki kahin gunna zayada fertile hai doabs ki wajah say.
aik question hy kia punjab ka agriculture hy wo natural resource nhi hy. kia punjab ki 12 -13 cror awam punjab ka resource nhi hy. kia punjab ki traqi sirf Balochistan ki gas sey howi. gas kay ilawa konsa natural resource aj tak Balochistan sey extract howa. top exports rice, cotton, textile, fruits sab 70% to 90% Punjab produce karta.
@@ThePakistanExperience Pakistan ney ceto sento defence deals ki os sey help howi. 1960 main indus water treaty key result main world bank ki help sey canals bani or punjab key agriculture ki waja sey gdp 6% cross kya.1958 main gawadar oman sey buy kia feroz khan noon ney or Balochistan main shamil kya. iss sarry time main punjabi kassan ney mehnat b shamil karoo. point sirf yea hy k punjab ki contribution ko aknowledege b karo.punjab sirf jute or Balochistan ki gas ki waja sey agay nhi apni mehnat sey b agay hy. bass har time yea hi sunty punjab khaa gay hum tu.
@@farhantariq4232I agree , if you only condemn punjabis , these extremist groups then also start using these talking points to spread hate against punjabis which is evident due to the fact that there were many comments where people were celebrating BLA terrorists Killings of punjabis
@@ThePakistanExperience kabi industrial location theory parhi hy. industries wahan lagti jahan raw material hoo or market place hoo. jahan plain ground ho , freshwater hoo. jahan temperature moderate hoo. ab punjab main yea sab condition meet hoti hain. iss main punjab ka kia kasoor hy.
The thing about this guy that I like best is that he has an innocent, puppo look on his face which completely belies the intellectual disposition he has. He is very intelligent and has excellent analysis. But he looks like he is a devil-may-care young guy. Keep the good work up brother. God bless you.
Take a break from current affairs for a while. Clearly this ordeal is taking a toll on your mental health (as it is apparent in this video). And lastly, pay zero attention to the trolls as they are all bark no bite. As for Pakistanis, may Allah grant us tolerance for acknowledging different viewpoints. Ameen
@@ThePakistanExperience inshallah, you will weather the storm and come back stronger than ever. Just take a time out to recuperate and gather your energy. You have a unique platform which is nothing less than a blessing. People from both ends of the spectrum listen to your podcast. Needless to say, you're making a difference in so many people's lives (and opinions). So stay strong.
@@ThePakistanExperience like how u destroy kashmir in the name of religion u feel the pain in Pakistan will be split to pieces, every Pakistani will go thru depression
Brother I don’t know why you haven’t got many subscribers but your videos are very informative and full of knowledge I am from England and I am a Sikh but I like every Human Being and I support you
GHQ and ISI are 100% Punjabi shows for Punjab benefits. Pakistan bureaucracy is Punjabi head by ex Punjabi faujis. Sparko space program is head by a Punjabi General with a degree in political science Police of other 3 provinces are hired from Punjab Important political decisions were always made in Punjab courts by Punjabi judges e.g Bhutto Hanging Most Non Punjabi politicians were killed a few were kicked out of the country for ever. Punjabi politicians were given chances to rule again and again. 70% of profit from Sui gas from Balochistan is taken by Punjab Two punjbai generals are selling gold of Balochistan's gold mines are punjabis Gas and mineral reserves found in Kohat Bannu ( KPK) ar under control of Punjbai Generals and hence the drama of talibans and terrorism All beggars arrested in Saudi, Dubai are Punjabis People behind rape, prostitution and human trafficking in UK are punjabis. Having said that, these people killed in Balochistan was done by RAW. Baloch are against Punjabi fauj.
@@mrjojo166 now see this, a modi fan will never watch a Pakistani Channel in first place. Second, this is south Indian mockery accent, so mock with something that will offend north Indian. Third, I live in Islamabad.
Pakistan is not the occupying force as per international law, Israel is in Palestine giving the people of Palestine an internationally recognized right of resistance to the occupier.
So now international law and not will of people decide who is occupier who isnt? That means all subnational independence movement are illegitimate? Uighur, tibatiens, chechen, kurds etc hv not right to fight? Guess what even Viet Cong werent internationally recognised @@ThePakistanExperience
Pakistan by force occupied Balochistan, Pakistan ioccupies land, exploits natural resources like sui gas fields, kill innocent baluchis, jails baluchis , raped innocents like Dr shazia which perpetuated in killing of Nawab Bugti,.. There is no difference between BLA and Hamas. Shahzad dont be a hypocrite.
The only problem with punjabis is they are educated and let everybody live in their areas jis din Punjabi nationalism jag gya phir Good Game ho jana ha Pakistan ka
@@Blender_Nerd_1 Siraiki he hu ma loday and very happy with our secular community here in punjab kam sa kam mehmano ko buses sa utar k goliyan ni marta. shame on you
Well you people called same jihadis as freedom fighters who dragged Hindus from uses in Kashmir and massacred them ….Now how come Same freedom fighters are called terrorists! Hypocrisy? What you sow shall you reap ! Karma calling !!!!😮
Excellent analysis as always don’t let yourself bother other bloggers who are trying to attack you with names, you are true and I stand by you do not give up!
I don't know what say, i really am speechless. You have done more than many of us for this country. Huge respect for u legend. Try to stay safe, sound, health, and alive💔
What about 600 billions given to balochistan every year by NFC award.where that mony goes.235 cror recovered from balochistan finance minister.They are real culprits
@@ThePakistanExperiencesir jo b banata hy government unkay chosen political representatives to hoty hain na, jinka taaluq b balochistan sy he hota hy aur unky pas billions of billions ky funds b available hoty hain. To log unko Q ni krty qatal? Unky culprit Q nai bolty? Un per attacks Q ni hoty? Because punjab and the people living in punajb are soft targets and blaming punjab and punjabis for everything is very easy to sell
@@muhammadislamraeessi5356 BHAI I DON'T UNDERSTAND THIS SCRIPT (is it shahmukhi punjabi script??) AND I ALSO DIDN'T UNDERSTOOD ITS TRANLATION . I WOULD BE THANKFUL IF U WRITE IN ENGLISH ALPHABETS
You need a break, btw i watch most of your videos because it's honest and informative. Additionally, you explain things very well. God has given you special qualities, make full use of it.
Punjab is blamed because it is large provence. Pakiatani Punjabi keep talking about Punjabiyat, kartarpur, Punjabi culture greater Punjab. Khalistan. Pakistani Punjabi want to reunite Pakistan Punjabi with India. This is why people in Balochistan hate Punjabis, Muslims talk about Ummah were is concept of ummah?
oh bhai koi jaroorat nahi hai indian punjab se reunite hone ke liye. we have enough problems in our country to deal with we dont want a radicalized pakistani population to deal with. i wish you the very best and hope your pakistan reach new heights, but humaare paas mat aao. ho sake toh border pe ek nadi khod do taaki dono taraf se terrorist infiltrate na kare
“Profile picture hai palestine !!
Par dil hai Israel “…..arrrrrrrrrr unbelievable line….Mind boggling…Respect Bhai ❤
❤️
@@o.p.revolutionary7829 Pakistan and Israel are the same.
@@ThePakistanExperience *You forgot to mention some key aspects here:*
• Pakistan has a history of forced disappearances and human rights violation's in Balochistan as per UN.
• Iran, USA, Taliban, China are all involved there as Balochistan exists in Afghanistan and Iran too.
• Balochistan was technically illegally occupied as Khan of Qalat never agreed for a merger. Their tribal and religious chieftains even today consider Balochistan as a separate state.
• Groups like BLA etc are those people which Pakistan army used as Mujahideens in Afghanistan. Quetta, Khyber etc were the usual bases back then.
• Selling their resources and lands to China is a major problem. USA is extremely wary of CPEC. Pakistan in fact had given bases to USA here to counter Iran and Afghanistan.
• Baloch fishermen are in a dire state as their old mechanical boats can't compete with modern fish trawlers China uses there.
• Lack of education, healthcare infrastructure. Connectivity in tribal areas is bon existent.
• History of Balochistan and it's culture is non-existent in Pak studies. Maybe considering the atrocities what General Tikka Khan did in Balochistan (and also bangladesh). Also, the fact that they always wanted to remain independent.
• Pakistan has been doing terrørism in Indian Kashmir by using groups like Laskhar, Jaish, Hizbul, TRF etc. And if this continues, India will be forced to intervene.
• Lastly, live media reporting is banned in Balochistan and even POK.
@@ÆßVThe polit bureau of CCP has been warning Pakistan about their misadventures both in India's Kashmir and Balochistan. China's priorities will always supersede the Baloch people. That's the deal done by Pakistan's rulers. They should've thought about the blowback from the locals. It's not our fault that Pak elites are busy minting money. They themselves don't give a damn, why should we care. We are doing business here. Pakistan's two way deals with America and China aren't helping either.
@@ÆßV *The most sensible comment here.* India wouldn't wanna intervene probably cuz they don't want this region to be destabilized as it'll hamper their growth. They could easily carve out Balochistan like they did in Bangladesh in 13 days.
Pakistan's nefarious activities in Indian Kashmir will indeed be last nail in the coffin.
Pakistan as usual is playing a swinger between the USA and China and fulfilling their interests. Establishment is sold to foreign powers and the awaam is radicalised and militant. A deadly cocktail.
Good to see this addressed, if you are calling BLA as terrorist, then what is happening in Kashmir by Pakistani based organization would also be terrorism. I hope you agree with this.
if BLA is terrorist, HAMAS is ultra terrorist - somehow he doesn't seem to be able to see this. With liberals like these, why do you need jihadis?
Why give importance to these people
@@dramaworld5987 bahot hi AJEEB tarah ki sukun ka ehsas hota hai.. pak ki so called elite ko taklif hoti hai toh..
You're miserably wrong on this.
I would've called them freedom fighters if they only targeted army or security personnel. But now they are targeting innocent civilians? This is terorrism.
You seem to be new here in Pakistani left circle.
Time and time again Shehzad and other podcasters have mentioned them as terrorists.
Faisal Warraich of dekho suno jano has gone in depth on this topic and explained how people he knew got involved in that terrorism wave.. and how our establishment misguided them into terrorism.
My husband and I were talking about this a couple of hours ago, and I was saying exactly what Shehzad is saying. He said, "Oh, you’ve learned this from the TPE guy," and I was like, "He hasn't even said anything yet." But now, after watching this video, I want to thank you for educating me enough that I can understand things on my own.
🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌❤️
@@ThePakistanExperienceIs that punjabi musalman & Bangali musalman was 2 qaumi nazaria in 1971
Now Baloch musalman & punjabi musalman is 2 qaumi nazaria
How many 2 qaumi nazaria excist in Pak ?
Boycott All baloch and brahui community hotel in punjab and punjabi majority area in whole Pakistan Pakistan 🇵🇰🇪🇸Zindabad
Best of Luck
@@TariqMoaz phir boydcott the sui gas and all resources too chutu aadmi thoda dimag lagao balochon ke sath kharab hua tha toh ab unme se kuch pagal hogye hai joke as a baloch woh mere punjabi bhaiyon ko mar rhe but balochon ke sath galat hua unko rights do to sab peace hojayega warna to phir balochistan independence hi hoga aur phir bethe rehna
Full support to Balochistan from India.
Fullll sapooort saaar
@@StoriesInUrdu. Yes mulle, Fullll sapooort !!!
@@StoriesInUrdu.that’s a very dangerous line, you should never wish for us to utter. because we have the “logistics” the make pak crumble like a cookie 🍪🍪
@@grimsobad8545 fo kid 😭🤣
@@StoriesInUrdu. kid? HA! don’t your elders teach you to respect men And to not back answer us? be a good women and wear your hijab and be submissive 🤫, maybe if your a good girl I’ll give some aata. :)
Don't be disheartened Shehzad. Don't lose your voice!
Advice from a wellwisher - Make a plan for yourself for 15 days off every 6 months notwithstanding any work/family/social compulsions. Take a holiday. Backpack and go on drive. Do a staycation and watch everything you think you missed. Just unplug yourselves until and unless something is extremely urgent. Do this and you will feel better!
Well wishes from India!
❤️
Balochistan is not Pakistan.
Why Your lambar one army did not resist again BLA Fighter ?
Operation continued for 24 hours
Where was lamber one army ?
Fake account
Wait and watch operation will is already happening
In a queue to receive dollars 😂
Fazool baat .... Balochistan is too big....my friend in the military is stationed 200 from unit HQ , the areas they patrol take 3 hours to do and in that time these groups kill and run
Bela ma 12 13 ghanta operation jarri Raha ....kl sham ko ssg na elaka khali kraya ....just because you don't know the reality on ground doesn't things didn't happen
Jazbe waali qaum ko aise mat bol yaar 😐
This is exactly what happened to Kashmiri Pandits but now they realise terrorism. Ironic too say.. Nothing but hum hindu bolte hai acha karm karna
I am so tired of this narrative by India. Yes what happened to Hindus was wrong, but you have been using this for occupying Kashmir for almost 50 years. We will admit our faults which are many, but India needs to admit their fault too so we can forgive forget and move on.
@@syedalirizwan-ok7qmdo u know thousands of Hindus are still today not able to return to kashmir ??
These Hindus were not outsiders but original habitants of kashmir, , and still today thousands of them live outside kashmir due to terrorism . .. . .
.
Till that day, we definitely have an excuse
You can't invade land of aboriginal Hindus ..pillage , rape, convert locals across centuries changing demography and then claim that somehow the original folks of that land are occupiers...
Yeh narrative ab kahi nahi chalega duniya mai... Sabki aankhein khuli gayi hai...
By your logic then Balochistan is also occupied by you (Pakistan)... De do wapas unhe
@@_Parmatma_ yeah so can't many Muslims.
We indian can move on, talk to ur government not to ask any help Or trade with india. That how we can move on.
I'm from Punjab and I acknowledge and agree with every single point you make. You are one of my heroes. You continue to teach me, with every video, the way to articulate these points to my circle of friends and family. But your mental health is my primary concern, so don't compromise on that for anything or anyone. Protect yourself first. Love you.
❤️🙌
@@ThePakistanExperiencefrom mountain to the sea
Balochistan will be free..
❤❤❤
پنجابیوں کو جٹ، راجپوت، اعوان اور کھرل وغیرہ میں تقسیم کر دیا گیا ہے، اگر پنجابی اکٹھے ہو کر آواز نہیں اٹھائیں گے تو بلوچ پنجاب میں آئیں گے اور ہر پنجابی کے ساتھ وہی کریں گے جو 25 اگست کو بلوچستان کے واقعے میں پنجابیوں کے ساتھ کر چکے ہیں۔
I'm Pashtun from Balochistan, I'm ashamed and I'm so sorry for what happened to our Punjabi brothers. This is so brutal and heinous for so many reasons. I've so many Punjabi friends and they're amazing people n support us in our issues in Balochistan. I'm sick to my stomach. Them terrorists killed 2 of my relatives in yesterdays incident. I wonder Pakistan is pushing people of Balochistan for such crimes. Balochistan has everything yet has nothing. Plz give us people of Balochistan our rights, plz stop these innocents getting killed, let us live, give us infrastructure, give us hospitals, give us universities ffs
Balochistan is not Pakistan.
@@indic5007take your shit somewhere else
@@indic5007 fuck you we are pakistanis, even though i am from punjab
Well said 🙌
@@indic5007 khalistan kashmir Manipur is not randians 🇮🇳
we need millions of voices like u to bring back "Sanity" & "rationality" in Pak. U r doing a great service to bring awareness thru media. u r a beacon of light, plz dont give up.
❤️
What is the difference between the freedom fight for Balochistan from Pakistan, Palestine from Israel, and Kurdistan from Turkey?
@@costructivecritic if it is mu$lim against mu$lim , keep but if it is mu$lim against non mu$lim , them shout out loud , except if it is against China
Hamas, Gaza and the History of the Israel-Palestine Conflict - Shehzad Ghias - #TPE
ua-cam.com/video/uophJhTIrtM/v-deo.html
@@ThePakistanExperiencethen didn't Pakistan forcibly annex part of Balochistan? Kingdom of Kalat?
@@ThePakistanExperience how different from Azerbaijan and Armenia , where Pakistan damelessly supported Azerbaijan
@@costructivecritic East Turkestan from China, Donbass, Crimea from Russia, Rohingya from Myanmar, Kashmir from India, Pashtuns, Baloch from Pakistan , earlier Qubec from Canada, Catalunia from Spain. almost Every big country has some sort of Secessionist
Class solidarity between the common Baloch, Pashtun, Seraiki, Sindhi, Punjabi, Muhajir, Hindu, Christian, Shia, Sunni etc is needed to tackle the menace of an exploitative and repressive Establishment.
We Bengalis had suffered because of this Punjabi dominence, now Baloch are facing same thing🙁How to misuse power for own benifits and supress others is the thing elite Punjabis directly got from Britishers....shame..must stop this or be ready for another 1971😊😊😊
I am an Indian Punjabi, Pakistani Punjabis are not responsible for this, they are not the elites of Pakistan most of the leaders of Pakistan have not been Punjabi actually Bhuto is Sindhi, The military Junta at the time of Bangladesh war was entirely Pathan and Muhajir. The Punjabis of Pakistan have no identity their language and culture are regarded as jahil and they cannot even take pride in their ancestors, language or culture. Punjabi Muslims actually were the only Muslim in the Northern Part of British India that voted against Partition the strongest supporters were the Muslims of the Central Provinces and Bengal.
So no you did not suffer because of Punjabi dominance as that dominance is a myth.
Don’t lie, it was never because of panjabis but urdu speaking muhajirs , one of them was quaid e Azam who opposed urdu on ur Bengali people , and the army was full of pashtun people and pashtun general , who killed your Bengali people
@@1amarsandhu❤❤❤ thank you, panjab ikh hi a ji ❤️❤️
Bro I am a Punjabi here. we haven't done shit. wtf are we getting accused of. Our political leaders spend money on main areas of Punjab because of the high population (more votes). That's it. We have always stood with 'Haq" and we are with our Balochi brothers even if there are extremists among them who want our demise. We support Bengalis too, the dictator of that time committed atrocities and we're with you. We lost all of our troops there as well, who thought that they were fighting rebels. We, in Punjab, ourselves are facing oppression. People are disappearing everyday for saying stuff online. Women were dragged from their houses for supporting PTI, etc. Do not listen to this UA-camr, he continually speaks provocatively to get more clicks and also clearly has an agenda.
@@Doabann How you dragged the Quaid-e-Azam into this is beyond me. The atrocity happened in 1971 buddy, decades after Quaid-e-Azam's death. Quaid-e-Azam is Top G, don't drag him into this.
Being a baloch myself i am really sad on what BLA did. Every life is precious whether it is a Punjabi, Sindhi, Baloch, Pathan or anyone else.
Agreed with whatever you said. Keep making such videos.
❤️
Then why are Kashmiri lives not precious? Why should Punjabis do jihad in Kashmir and kill innocent Kashmiris?
This unfortunately is never heard from any Punjabi about all others who suffered till date... Natural Justice
@veganube5963 that is a very idiotic statement
@@veganube5963If you haven’t heard from a punjabi before so hear it now Pakistan as a state has oppressed Balochs.
I am 15year old boy from Punjab and belongs to a middle class family.I always like your videos because you always speak on the basis of logic and knowledge.You can be somewhere worng but your intentions cannot be doubted.Don't care of those peoples who are abusing you,many are also praying for you.May Allah protect you and give you a long happy life,Inshallah❤😉
❤️
olla is impotent (or he supports bani israel). find a better god to server rather than the khairul makareen
Young man don’t be WORNG;)
Yeah ek aur tato hy establishment ka. Yeah bak bak kr raha hy against Punjabis. Asal culprit muhajir hy. Pashtun hy. Punjabi leaders ek he tha Pakistan Bannatyne waqat usay bhe muhajir liqaqt ne Nikal Dia. Is me itna dam hy live ajaye Mery Sath. Aj bbe elite class muhajirs ke hy Pakistan ke Har institute me. Yeah kabhe nahi bolu GA unke khilaf. Yeah
All logic goes to a deep hole when Islam prevails.
It takes guts to have consistent stand on whether it is Palestine or Balochistan and speaking publicly about it in Pakistan.
🙌
he doesn't have a consistent stand, he doesn't condemn hamas but calls BLA terrorist even though Hamas is far more brutal in targeting women to sexually assault and children to massacre.
He celebrates the killing of non muslims by muslims, ultimately, as long as he can find a flimsy excuse to do so.
Do you feel the pain now ? This is what we are dealing with in Kashmir
He clearly has a opinion that terrorism is a disproportionate response of state oppression and same goes for kashmir
I don't understand sometimes muslims never accepts concept of terrorism and they use to argue me there is no terrorism but when they face anything they will blame on terrorism. I condemn any act of terror. Rest in Peace 🕊️
No one says, "there is no terrorism", that's stupid.
The problem is your apparently leading argument that somehow terrorism is the result of being a Muslim.
I must say that India should take advantage of Balochistan crisis of Pakistan, we should support our Baloch brothers and sisters to get independence from the rogue state.
you hate muslims in your own country but you support Baloch and Afghans
hypocrisy on its peak
@jojo.s_bekaar_adventures Who told you that I hate Muslims in my country? I have many Muslim friends, and I despise radical Muslims who do not represent true Islam.
@@jojo.s_bekaar_adventures I do not hate Muslims, but Muslims consider me a Kafir and want my people to convert to Islam.
We indian love baloch people, long live baloch people go ahead, free balochistan very soon
We Pakistani love khalistani and manipur people😊
@@sofialatif564 we indian also love khalistani , manipuri kashmiri people
@@sofialatif564 the problem is Pakistanis are ill informed and obtuse…
As far as Khalistan goes there is hardly a murmur in India for it.. only some crazies in Canada and UK keep on doing some antics .. Sikhs are well regarded and distributed all over India… there is no tangible demand for Khalistan in India
The Manipur issue is a Kuki vs Maiti tribe issue … it’s not secessionist issue
Kashmir surely has a secessionist flavour and was fully supported by Pakistan to extent possible.. now with pak going down the drain I’m sure even a single Kashmiri would not like to go with pak… and a seperate state is not tangible due to its geography
Although we Indians would be happy if Pakistan remains stable as an unstable Pakistan is not good for India .. but due to your mishandling Balochistan however will secede like Bangladesh just watch
No you don’t. This is just politics to you nothing else.
My heart aches to see you and Mr. Muzzamil getting frustrated and disappointed with each passing day. I would like to share my story with you. I come from Lahore and have completed my MSc Hons in Agriculture from University of Agriculture, FSD in 2019. I have changed my Political and Social views in last 10 years thanks to The Pakistan Experience, Muzzamil Hussain and Dekho Suno Jano. I feel like there are thousands who have unlearned all the propaganda just like me and MILLIONS MORE TO GO. I hope to see you thrive and make such truthful content which will make us into much much better individuals and ultimately a better nation.
True
One day Muzammil and I will share what all we’ve faced over the past few months ❤️
Shehzad bhai don't think that Urdu speaking people's hate's you because i am as a urdu speaking and my friends & family circle is with you because you're always talk truth , Stay strong God bless you ❤️❤️❤️
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
No group hates me. Aiwain kuch log campaigns chalatay hain on social media hate paida karnay kay liye
@@ThePakistanExperiencebhai i am a urdu speaker too and i second you in so many things, bus jahan difference of opinion banta hai wo to sab ka right hai, bus bhai us chutye ko na bulaya karo parizaad drama jaan ko agaya hai, na wo drama banta na wo chutya itni baten ch****, is k ilawa phul saport saar
Balochistan is not Pakistan.
@@ThePakistanExperiencetert sath ab pirate Punjab kry ga hate kau k tone kaha unke national assembly me seats ziada hy. Js ke jitni abadi Hoge utni seats Hoge. India me up ke seats sb se ziada hy. What Kab kise ne hate ke hy UP se. Ek Punjabi hy jo tumhe kuch nahi krhty tum bao bao krty jaty hooo
If for you Hamas is Palestine's army, then how is BLA a terrorist organization for you? Are you not hypocrites? When Pakistan Army killed BLA people, women and children, you never made any video. But when your people died today, you started talking about the rights of Bolichistan.
BLA is a terrorist organisation. Just like ISIS or Al-Qaeda or TTP.
Which children murdered ?
@@aliarham7158 kya 1947 main
Sikho ke child nhi the
@@aliarham7158Sindh main hinduo ke child nhi he
9 Saal ke hindu ladaki ke sath
40 Saal ke molle se fourceful sadi Kar dete ho
@@ComptetiveApproach
Child abuse is like a sad, common act in Pakistan
Tell me
Did the govt told him to do?
A very sensible and rational way of looking at the whole incident and background of whats happening. Good work!
❤️
I support #FreePunjab
Punjabi brothers have the right to have Thier own separate country
Punjabistan
Stop this nonsense joker
Bruh
Do you mean a land-locked state? which will be dependent on other states for its imports and exports. #Readbeforeyouspeak
@@arslanahmed6996koi bat sea route kay lye kabza kar lay gay power hy sab kuch hoty yy
@@ranahammad6823abhi bhi to qabza hi kiya hua hai
Pakistan need to understand Baloch
Otherwise it will become Bangladesh
Bangladesh and Balochitan are two different things Balochistan doesn't share a direct border with India so it is quite difficult for India to help the Balochitan for freedom.
🤣🤣🤣🤣 swagat nahi karoge hamara
@@Salu_GujjarGurjar7431Even in Bangladesh war , , India fought on 2 fronts , , West and East Pakistan ..
.this time it would be easy to focus on one front, , , penetrating from Sindh to Balochistan
@@_Parmatma_ not on west front only in eastern front western front is well solved in 1948 when Pakistan controlled hald region of Kashmir and India after 1948 take revenge from Pakistan with the help of Israel and succeed to liberate Bangladesh. But India is still trying to liberate Balochitan & KPk because India believes Pakistan is involved in funding Indian side kashmiri fighters & Khalistani fighters. But Balochistan is a different chapter Iran, Afghanistan side will not use directly against Pakistan India will try to use only local groups from Balochitan region but in last they all will fail.
@@_Parmatma_ Even when new government of USA will contact Pakistani government or some issues will be solve between USA and Pakistan this small issue of Balochitan will also be solve USA itself involved in this matter you know very well how USA changed pro Indian regime of Bangladesh in the face of Sheikh Haseena.
I am from hyderabad india, i like your vedios, but Pakistan have so many probleams still why all your army and top people intrested in indian muslims. Set your home order.
if they bad that much brain they wouldn't be like they are. Despite this they support kashmiri and hamas terrorism.
When you have nothing to show or contribute to world, you will have to point to some thing against others to show there are issues.
In Pakistan: When Babar and Pervez board a bus, they fight for a seat, fight settles down after 10 minutes, Babar gets the seat. life goes on.
In India: When Vinay and Pervez board a bus, they fight for a seat, fight settles down after 10 minutes, Vinay gets the seat. Next day a certain newspapers/ Vloggers/bloggers will write' Minority under threat in India' Pervez denied a seat in bus. Pakistan will point will raise this issue.
@@edgecase1047 al jazeera, bbc, global times will write articles about how horrible India is. low cost attempts try to keep the country from reaching it's obvious full potential
@@edgecase1047 in most cases Parvez will get the seat as Vinay would be accommodating and parvez boisterous 🤣
Pak getting taste of their own medicine and now they are founding it to be unpalatable.
Vader ....pak nhe sirf pakistan Punjabi army ka bolo 😅 lumber 1 army 😂
I'm from Balochistan and I am feeling sad for those innocent Punjabi brothers who were killed by terrorists
16:03 ❤.
One Day people will. Inshallah.
May Allah protect you and your family.
❤️
Shehzad bhai you're an asset!
Please don't stop, you're the hope of all of us Pakistanis who have the same views and thoughts but are too scared to speak publically.
❤️
Indian have been experiencing this since 30yrs in Kashmir. same pak army supported Lashkar and many more terrorist
Kashmiris struggle is real nd Kashmir and Balochistan have the same history. One day Kshmir will be independent from both the opressors
@@mehak-GB in your dreams 🙏
@@vineetdeorari8017 Seeking independence from British empire was also a dream for many people
@@mehak-GB no harm in dreaming.. reality is very different.
@@vineetdeorari8017 dreams are seen to make them reality.
These youtubers are using double standards. When Punjabis are killed, then it is terrorism and when Balochis are killed by Punjabi soldiers it is nationalism. This guy is educated?
Punjabi Soldiers = BLA ???
Pmd9756 A real baloch will stand against oppression of Bla the way they are conducting attacks are harm to humanity and whole nation I am a Pathan but Pakistani first our Country is Pakistan no matter what happens to this country this is our country this not just the country of Sindhis Pathans Balochis Punjabis but country of Pakistanis and Pakistan Zindabad no matter what happens and you are the terrorist bro you are not baloch instead you are a terrorist and the people who sell their country for 20 rupees and join the so called Bla Baloch liberation army we all Pakistanis should stand against the oppression of BLA which included Pathan Punjabi and Balochis so remember that not just Punjabis are killed but Balochis are also killed and inshallah your plan to free Balochistan from Pakistan will never succeed and will fail inshallah BLA the oppressors of Humanity Should be banned forever inshallah
Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and Balochistan - #TPE
ua-cam.com/video/UIAw1oB0XNg/v-deo.html
There are very few people in India & Pakistan who can take on these issues so sensitively yet boldly like you. Lots of loving wishes. Take care.
I am a 24-year-old from KPK, currently living in Punjab. I've met people from Punjab, Kashmir, Balochistan, KPK, and Sindh, and everyone has been genuinely nice. I don't have much faith in anything, but I will put my faith in the newer, younger generation, who are more understanding than the older generation that has been spreading hate. We are not meant to hate each other; we need to function as one.
From mountain to the sea
Balochistan will be free
11th August 1947 Balochistan was a independent free nation. 27th March 1948, Balochistan was enslaved by pakistan. Free Balochistan!
Islam is the common problem of the Globe 😢😢😢
Hinduism*
Dunya k sab se violent log Hindu hai
@adr_hindi_gaming I mean ram and Krishna see yourself....all the mob lichings happen in India while saying Jai Shree raaam
Why do you think that?
As a Punjabi I'm terrified right now (as I live near Balochistan). I 110 % agree that every province should get its rights but I mean politicians or generals take these decisions. Common Punjabis (even Punjabis from Uper middle class) r not involved in these matters. Shouldn't we focus on "rights 4 every1" than "y Punjabis r getting more rights than every1 in Pakistan" (even we r not getting every human right, there is no JUSTICE in courts, we r also scared of our Police, Elites r dominant here too). & Southern/Lower Punjab is just like any other province (watch Syed Muzammil's video on Southern Punjab 2 understand our situation).
From Mountain to sea
Balochistan will be free...
@@moviemango143 I don't mind a free Balochistan tbh but the thing is we all would have 2 suffer a bloody war. This generation (of Balochi, Punjabis, Sindhis, Pathans) would be doomed even in case of civil war🤦♀️I hope our establishment decides 2 give Balochis their rights as an equal citizen. Love & peace from Punjab🙌
@@MaryamFarhan-hn9dc freedom>>suffering in bloody war.
If you guys supported h@m@s then why not this time....
@@MaryamFarhan-hn9dc first of all "baluchi" is a language when you are refferring to an ethnic group its "baluch" or "baloch" get yourself educated
@@azrasaleem926 OK I'm sorry & what about other points? baaqi maslon pr kuch kahna pasand karen gien miss Azra
Then hamas is also terrorist but wait you guys call it a reaction to exactly it was a reaction of brutality of Israel same here punjabis have killed so many balochis in the uniform millions are missing arent that terrorism? Come on think that we all have to answer almighty one day
Hamas, Gaza and the History of the Israel-Palestine Conflict - Shehzad Ghias - #TPE
ua-cam.com/video/uophJhTIrtM/v-deo.html
@@ThePakistanExperience never knew killing can be categorized
@@ThePakistanExperienceyou can say the difference....
No time to watch it again.
@@sports-pirate if muslims kill non muslims - justified - simple islamic logic. baaki sab intellectual jalebi hai
Thousand of Pakistani died, your always answer was Balochistan ka masla Kiya hy.... Sindhiyon pathonon ka msla Kiya hy.... Ab panjabi marain hain to pori mulk my aag lg gaey hy....
Now come on grounds and solve issue genuinely.
Panjab has enjoyed all resources, electricity, gas, oil.
Now this idiot with mic come on screen and saying to us that you are also terrorist...
RIP innocent people 😢
❤ sensible comment .respect
RIP Innocent Indian muslim christian dalits 😢😢
Rip innocent ,, Baloch
@@Myavepearip Pakistani hindus, Christian, Sikh. At least in India Muslim and Christian’s have increased 3-4 times in 75 years
BLA did that because normal Punjabis need to understand what their brethren do with people in other provinces or with ethnic minorities while they hold an office of powers. It doesn't justify the actions of BLA, but Punjabis needs to come out and fight against oppressors who are their own.
I don't think you are Pakistani or Punjabi, that's why you are lying,.
Hahahahhahahahahh.. Ghayas bhai ki video per Godi whatsapp factory ky tatu bohat zada aaty hain ajkal.
Just spotted one.
Tribute to Akbar Bugti sahab💐 for sacrificing his life for people of Baluchistaan💐
Saar Friend saarr .Modi leader sarr..India superpower saarr.Thankyou saarr
We don't need your sympathies. Worry about your own people first.
Apni aurtain to bacha lo pehly tum apny mulk mai phirty huy darindo sy hamary muamlat mai aaye tang arany.
Ja ker dekho mata per 16 log tu nehi char gaye sarr 😂😂😂
@@AsgharALI12126 6-55 😂😂😂
Thanks!
🙌
When Pakistan did not even exist, Balochistan was a very big area. A large part of today's Pakistan and Iran together formed Balochistan. Before entering Balochistan, there used to be a very big gate, that gate was made of pure gold and expensive stones. That gate reflected the richness of the Indian continent. Foreign invaders looted this rich land and are looting it even today.😢😢😢😢
there was no bundlochistan before 1840................british annexed qallat state and made it bundlochistan
@@vantagehistory1813 there was no !$|am before
@@vantagehistory1813 Baluchistan existing since 7000 bc go update your knowledge
@@tariqmarri5782 baloch are kurd migrants.......
I have a question shehzad:
I’ve consistently supported Mahrang Baloch’s efforts to raise awareness about missing persons in Balochistan. However, I haven’t seen any recent public statements from her condemning the ongoing brutality by BLA.
Why is it that people from Punjab, particularly the common folks, continue to stand in solidarity with the people of Balochistan. I’m not expecting sympathy from the BLA. But can you show me any single condemnation from Mahrang Baloch?
People of Punjab don’t.
Should we only support human rights causes in exchange for them supporting us or should we support them because it is the right thing to do?
@@ThePakistanExperienceso isn't it the right thing for mahrang aslo to do ?
@@hameed2k1she is a human too here she is making big mistake that she will realize later
And may be she is scared of bla or she doesn't want to be in a war with bla too like pakistani elite
@@ThePakistanExperiencethen she is a baloch right activist and not a human rights activist.
@@ThePakistanExperience
We should never support people who don't consider non Baloch as equal human.
There aint no hope left....shivers run down my spine with every new podcast =(
Feel the same way
Why don't you leave Pakistan just for safety purposes yaar...bad me phir wapis chalejana....
M happy that's it. ❤❤😂😂
@@SilentTraderviewinn ko kuch nahi hoga kyon ki yeh b jihadi hai. 😂😂
@@nyaligusar2264 A$s høõlë you know nothing
#FreeBalochistan
#AllEyesOnBalochistan
Saar Friend saarr .Modi leader sarr..India superpower saarr.Thankyou saarr
Free Indi sir
@@mrjojo166 pdofile Muhammad follower saar
@@mrjojo166 pdofile Muhammad follower saar
@@mehak-GB pdofile Muhammad follower saar , maj-hub saar
So sorry for what you have to deal with for educating this nation. There people who want to know and learn about the things which are not there on mainstream media.
Thanks for existing & discussing all the facts.
Stay safe & strong.
Did Mahrang Baloch ever condemn the killing of Punjabis? No, I didn't see that.
اب مزاحمت کو وقت ختم
Respect others first and they will respect back, it is not something automatic.
Why would she when Punjabis call her father a te rrorist? Punjabi army abducted innocent Balochis and labelled them as te rrorists. Why did you expect her to show mercy when in fact Islamabad police were doing lathicharge on Baloch women and children during peaceful protests?
@@deepalall647 ullo ke pathe punjabi army sari ethnicities ha usme
Can you condemn Paki Army as terrorists organisation.
BLA is very similar to Hamas (both in terms of objectives and tactics) and I find it really funny how Pakistanis are blindly supporting one and blindly hating on the other...
Hamas BLA zameen asman farak ha. Konse dunya rahte hoo bhai.
@@mike-oj7sy both are fighting a powerful military/govt which they perceive to be an occupyer over their indigenous lands and both are more than willing to use terror tactics against civil and military targets in pursuit of that goal. Pakistanis were making fun of piers morgan for asking palestinians to condemn hamas, and just yesterday a video on twitter resurfaced and was being shared in which ghareeda farooqi was asking mahrang baloch to condemn BLA💀. Anyone with even a tiny bit of critical thought can see the very obvious similarities
@@mike-oj7sy yeah, Hamas is far worse - yet Pakistani support them. They deserve far worse than BLA.
Ex Muslim sahil ❤❤❤❤❤
Adam Seeker ❤❤❤❤❤
Ghar le jao apnay
@@OyePapaJiapki amma ka thoku
@@basheerwayne69teri ammi ko nahin kali h uski🤮🤮
X hindu pandit aamir huq ne awaje huq pe bulaya hai
Waise toh main half Punjabi half Pashtun Hun or mere ancestors pehlay Patiala or post independence Lahore mein settle Hain or yeh news mere Dil or dimagh se NAHI Nikal Rahi 😭 Innocent, working class Punjabis kyun maara inko yaar tumhara problem establishment ya powerful class se hai aik common Punjabi ka Kya qasoor hai? Or Dr Mahrang Baloch ko condemn Karna chahiye tha is ko but Punjabis ke qatal e aam per woh khamosh Hain 😔. Allah mere pyaray watan Pakistan ki hifazat farmaye.
Illegally occupied balochs 😢😢
کیوں کے تم بے وقوف ہو یہ کسی اسٹیبلشمنٹ کے خلاف نہیں ان کے خون میں پنجابی سے نفرت ہے بھٹو سے مشرف تک کوئی پنجابی نہیں تھا لیکن ان کی دشمنی پنجابی سے ہے
مزدوروں کو مار کر بہت بڑا کارنامہ کیا ہے انھوں نے
برحال مسلمان پنجابی تو اب پنجابی بھی نہیں رہے پنجابی صرف سکھ ہیں جو کہ اب پاکستان پنجاب میں نہیں.
@@StudyGlobal-d1b shutup Hindu
Thank you for talking sense in these tough times. Much love and respect from Balochistan ❤
❤️
Balochistan will be free
Out of 23 people, 18 were Saraiki.
5 laborers(Saraiki) yesterday died in Pindi
14 Policemen(saraiki) were killed in RYK incident.
Portraying them as Punjabi, why?
Military people were targeted not Punjabis
All know its punjabis😂😂
agr unko pta hy bhnady military k hy toh ID cards check nah krty. get ur facts straight and stand up for the right thing u illiterate puppet.
Peaceful Community Spreading Peace MaashaOm❤
Saar Friend saarr .Modi leader sarr..India superpower saarr.Thankyou saarr
@@mrjojo166Allah ke nam pe de de re baba allah ke nam pe de de
@@mrjojo166 Hamko 1 Billion dedo Saar Hum Riyaasat e Pudinaaa Bnanw vaale h Sir…Chinaa Hmara Abbbu Hai Sir..Hmara Handsome PM Jail me hai Saar😅😂😂🤣
Good analysis tbh , made me to re-assess on how to think about this issue ❤❤
❤️
It is heartwarming to listen to you, me n my friend we often watch n later discuss… u put a lot of effort n are very committed to all the sensitive topics u pick … wish u more success and pray for ur safety… love n prayers stay safe n blessed
❤️
lots of duas for you dear Shehzad, this video broke my heart and I could literally feel the hurt suffered by you. just want you to know that I have personally formed so many opinions based on your podcasts and have learnt so much, most of all I have learnt to look at things subjectively and for that I am truly indebted to you. May Allah protect you always
As someone from Quetta, your clear mindedness and courage in calling out Pakistani hypocrisy is honestly very refreshing. It must be very difficult. More strength to you.
Keep calling these idiots out on social media but hope you dont get bogged down in the individual tweets and videos... that will drain your life.
🙌
I can see in the comments how Indian Hindus and Pakistani extremists koshish kar rhe hen ke kisi trha se hate or phele. I just want to say please look at your country and what is happening there. Protect your women first before trying to spread hate among others. Most Indians, especially Modi lovers excel in spreading fake news and hate. So, it is our duty as Pakistanis to keep on ignoring them as if they are whispers from Shaitaan. As a pathaan living in Punjab, i love every community. Agar Pakistan nahi to hum nahi.
konsi fake news? tumne fake news faila rakhi hai india mei musalmaan khatre mei hai. pta ni aisa konse khatre mei hai musalman, population percentage unki badh rhi hai. govt schemes mei disproportionately muslims ko benefits mil rhe hai. fake news tum failate ho bina padhe
@@harshitgarg3436 chhod yaar - agar reuben frost pathan ho sakta hai to phir uski dunia hi alag hai - let him be happy
@@harshitgarg3436 These are people who read aasmani kitab, without lies their religion dies 🤣 Jhuth bol bol kar toh country ka beda gark kar rakha hai. They only watch army sponsored news and Dhruv Tatti. Idhar aate ki line mein lagi hai kaum aur udhar Pakisatni in L0ndon are stopping traffic to celebrate 14th August 🤣🤣 Desh se bhaag ke Independence Day manaate hain. British logo ne inki khub hawaa tight ki huyi hai.
What bro ? World recognise Pakistan as a terror sponsor country. ◉‿◉
Osmosis bin lantern was found in Abbottabad. pakistanis have very short memory ?
What bro ? World recognise Pakistan as a terror sponsor country. ◉‿◉
Osmosis bin lantern was found in Abbottabad. Tumhari fauj bhi ek deshatgard tanzeem h.
Bengalis p kitna julm kiya.
Well Punjabis did the same to them and bangladeshi
Well tell me if zulfiqar ali bhutto or gen yahya khan were punjabis ?
What happened in Bangladesh?
Sheikh mujib just wanted power he was power Hungary his daughter sh hasina is same now in India. Why sh hasina is India now?
Most of the war crimes during 1971 in Bangladesh were done by Punjabi soldiers. Apart from Punjabis, Sindhis played a vital role in those atrocities @@raffayali5291
@@raffayali5291idiot it's the army of punjab did it ..... Punjabis taking all resources from bolchistan nd still it is by far the poorest underdeveloped neglected region
@@atheistonyoutube Does it mean Pakistani didnt committed any w:ar cri**mes in Bangladesh? Absolutely they did.
Bhai apki baat puri tarah se sahi hai as a Indian and also a sanatani ham log bhi chahte hai ki kisi bhi begunah ki jaan nhi jana chahiye chahe vo baloch ho ya Panjabi
"sachi baat kahi thi maine
logoun ne sooli pe charhaya
mujhko zehr ka jaam pilaya
phir bhi unhen chain na aayaa"
Shehzad bhai! Taareekh gawah hai ke sachay log hamesha aese hi khayalat or logoun ki nazar hote hain!
yeh tab tak chalta rahega jab tak insan sach bolta rahega!
But you really don't have any idea what these videos mean to us! You are enlightening lives, you are doing an unbelievable job, we owe you a lot.
Lots of love and best wishes!
But Same thing happened in Kashmir in 1990 with indigenous Kashmiri Hindus and In Punjab with Punjabi Hindu using Sikhs in 1980s… ironically sponsored by Pakistan… Boya ped babbool ka AAM knha se hoye
But it’s sad….. poor innocent people always die…. Elites decides fate of common people living in safe place.
But you forgot to mention this Mahrang and his gang indirectly supports BLA BLF and never condem these terrorists.
His father ghaffar lango was also a BLA terrorist.
Just like Hamas???
Punjabi as identity is a very weak identity, specifically in Pakistan
it's more of a social identity I would say than a genetic one, if you live in Punjab then you are Punjabi, no strings attacked.
you don't have to learn the language don't have to follow any customs. and you sure don't have to be born into it. that's it...
that is why there are Punjabi Pashtoon and Punjabi Baloch... and they feel right at home.
now I live in a small Punjabi village in central Punjab, and we do have Baloch Pashtuns Kashmiris even a few European housewives if you can count them as well... never had a problem with any of them or vice versa..
but still, we are hated... WHY??? and why are Punjabis angry with nonviolent Baloch human rights activists...?
first of all, Pakistan has been an agrarian society from the start that is and Punjab is the most fertile region in Pakistan the number of small landowners is also greater than in any other province, thus more people have money directly from their own cultivated fields than from wages. then capitalism comes into play... most of the development that you see in Punjab as compared to say Sindh is done by the private sector. private hospitals, private schools... in short there is more money in circulation and that makes it a large market of goods. now where there is a market there is taxation.. and once you collect that tax you want to spend that money in a fashion that will increase your taxes. you build roads railway lines airports, subsidized factories.. etc
so you don't want to spend money away from population centers where there is no use for that infrastructure in a way that increases taxation...
and these mineral projects that people think are just bundles of wealth lying in the ground are not exactly what people make them out to be, for example, a lot of infrastructure has to be built in such places for it to be even viable to be mined... and further away you are from population centers, more expansive these infrastructure projected become...
so let's say you have extracted natural gas from a province, what are you going to do with it... on its own, it's not a currency or of any value, you have to sell it, and best of luck trying to sell your expansive natural gas in front of the biggest and cheapest natural gas reserve in the world Qatar...
so now look for a domestic market, and where does that take us, of course, the market, the population centers... because let's not forget our goal is to make money out of it recover our expenditures, and then earn profits, not to do charity and give it away to poor people who cannot even afford it... and then repeat that entire cycle over and over again...
Great response ❤ mashallah
❤most sensible comment I’ve ever seen
Great brother
Punjabiyo ne saari tarakki apne dam pe kari hai. Balochistan ka kuchh nahi loota. Balochistan ko India k RAAAAAA ne loota hai🤣
Brilliant take on the issue, aisi sensible voices dono desho me chahiye. What a balanced mind you have with respect to the facts and the overall take on violence!
Keep up the good work. Rest in peace, all the innocent, affected families 🙏🏻
Take care brother
❤️
Shehzad, you are one of the few sane voice coming out of Pakistan I sincerely wish and hope you will keep the good work going. I really love and wait for your podcasts to appear on the UA-cam channel.
Please keep safe and if possible continue giving us gems.
❤️
I was talking to my friend in Balochistan, he went to an office to get some papers and there were people ranting on how the state in unjust...on being asked what has happened they said they "only" the AC for whole day and the government gives a bill of 7000 ...its unfathomable....if you were in punjab you'd get a bill of 25000+ ....there is a lack of education, infrastructure there coupled with the feudal system that actually cripples the system ....and the lords there have to make an a common enemy ...which they make Punjabis...the operations in Balochistan were done by pervaz mushraff(a mahajir) and ayub khan( a ethic pashtun) but still they target the punjabis...+ Also people like marang baloch who are haled as activists propogated and even posted that people like mahal baloch were kidnapped by the state( btw mahal was involved in the bombings yesterday) and her silence on the killing of innocent average punjabis add to the discredit of this character
Bhai aap poori terhan state propagnda mai achukay ho
x.com/imaanzhazir/status/1828268604078391586?s=46
The two Mahals are completely different people
@@ThePakistanExperiencekoi baat nahi state propaganda bee kabi kabi acha hota
Look what Israel and USA achieved with state propaganda
And justice only delivered with F-16s
Punjabion ky khilaf jo zehr social media py gola gia wo ab tashddud ma badl chuka hy..
Bat such hae pr punjabi Punjabiyat ki bat kerte hae.
Culture India Punjabi se same honeki bat krte hae Hindu Sikh Punjabi ko bolte hae asi Punjabi tusi Punjabi
Sahi kaha wese bilkul
@@atheistonyoutubeapko kisny kaha punjabi punjabiyt ki baat karty .matlab khud sy kuch bhi bolo.
اور اس میں یہ شہزاد بھی شامل ہے اب آئے بائے کر رہا ہے لیکن آہستہ آہستہ اب پنجابی کو بھی سمجھ آہ رہی ہے
میں نے اس کی بہت پوڈکاسٹ دیکھی ہیں اس میں پنجابی کے لئے بغض ہے جو یہ چھپا نہیں سکتا ایک واقعہ بتا دیں پنجاب میں جہاں پنجابی نے کسی دوسری قوم کے شناختی کارڈ دیکھ کر انھیں قتل کیا ہو؟
@@sofialatif564 Punjabi KO punjabiyat ki bat karni Chahiye Ye unka haq hai aur agar tum Punjabi hu Tu lakh lanat tum jeso par pehla apni zuban Punjabi ty bol lawo zuban bolni aundi ni ty gal karny jy punjab di hypocrites
Free Balochistan
Saar Friend saarr .Modi leader sarr..India superpower saarr.Thankyou saarr
Free Khalistan
@@shahsaeed3697 khalistan capital lahore 🤭🤣
@@Zimpal_Azam Lahore is not sikh majority like Amritsar 🤣
@@DivinePathProductions Lahore is Punjab check history 🤣🤣
Shehzad, your videos are incredibly heartwarming, and the intention behind creating them is both genuine and filled with empathy. Don’t let the negativity from others get to you-they simply fail to grasp your message. Remember, there are countless people who find inspiration in your work. Keep shining, and know that you are in my prayers!
Hamas terrori$t nhi hai lekin bla terrori$t hai...😂😂
Madarsachap logic.
❤️
@@mahmishafatima8434 free balochistan 😂😂
You must’ve been an amazing teacher for how break it down and make it so easy to understand ♥️
❤️
Paani Kay hawaalay say Punjab nay 3 darya diye thay Pakistan Kay liye, south Punjab khaas taur par tail par Rahim yar khan waghaira may paani nahi aata aur Sindh Chala jaata hai. Plus historically Lahore division British time ki kahin gunna zayada fertile hai doabs ki wajah say.
BLA Zindabad ❤🚩👍
aik question hy kia punjab ka agriculture hy wo natural resource nhi hy. kia punjab ki 12 -13 cror awam punjab ka resource nhi hy. kia punjab ki traqi sirf Balochistan ki gas sey howi. gas kay ilawa konsa natural resource aj tak Balochistan sey extract howa. top exports rice, cotton, textile, fruits sab 70% to 90% Punjab produce karta.
Jute east pakistan say extract hua . Watch our podcast on how the economy was run 1947-1971
Pakistan factories lagaye ga hee Punjab mai toh Punjab hee export karay ga na bhai
@@ThePakistanExperience Pakistan ney ceto sento defence deals ki os sey help howi. 1960 main indus water treaty key result main world bank ki help sey canals bani or punjab key agriculture ki waja sey gdp 6% cross kya.1958 main gawadar oman sey buy kia feroz khan noon ney or Balochistan main shamil kya. iss sarry time main punjabi kassan ney mehnat b shamil karoo. point sirf yea hy k punjab ki contribution ko aknowledege b karo.punjab sirf jute or Balochistan ki gas ki waja sey agay nhi apni mehnat sey b agay hy. bass har time yea hi sunty punjab khaa gay hum tu.
@@farhantariq4232I agree , if you only condemn punjabis , these extremist groups then also start using these talking points to spread hate against punjabis which is evident due to the fact that there were many comments where people were celebrating BLA terrorists Killings of punjabis
@@ThePakistanExperience kabi industrial location theory parhi hy. industries wahan lagti jahan raw material hoo or market place hoo. jahan plain ground ho , freshwater hoo. jahan temperature moderate hoo. ab punjab main yea sab condition meet hoti hain. iss main punjab ka kia kasoor hy.
My whole family watchs your channel and it is the most sensible analysis that i have seen keep up the good work.
❤️
The thing about this guy that I like best is that he has an innocent, puppo look on his face which completely belies the intellectual disposition he has. He is very intelligent and has excellent analysis. But he looks like he is a devil-may-care young guy. Keep the good work up brother. God bless you.
❤️🙌
Take a break from current affairs for a while. Clearly this ordeal is taking a toll on your mental health (as it is apparent in this video). And lastly, pay zero attention to the trolls as they are all bark no bite. As for Pakistanis, may Allah grant us tolerance for acknowledging different viewpoints. Ameen
You’re right
It really is taking a toll
@@ThePakistanExperience inshallah, you will weather the storm and come back stronger than ever. Just take a time out to recuperate and gather your energy. You have a unique platform which is nothing less than a blessing. People from both ends of the spectrum listen to your podcast. Needless to say, you're making a difference in so many people's lives (and opinions). So stay strong.
@@ThePakistanExperience like how u destroy kashmir in the name of religion u feel the pain in Pakistan will be split to pieces, every Pakistani will go thru depression
Punjabis are on the top 👌👌💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪
fact. thats the problem.
You just acknowledged the problem facing the country
Brother I don’t know why you haven’t got many subscribers but your videos are very informative and full of knowledge I am from England and I am a Sikh but I like every Human Being and I support you
❤️
GHQ and ISI are 100% Punjabi shows for Punjab benefits.
Pakistan bureaucracy is Punjabi head by ex Punjabi faujis.
Sparko space program is head by a Punjabi General with a degree in political science
Police of other 3 provinces are hired from Punjab
Important political decisions were always made in Punjab courts by Punjabi judges e.g Bhutto Hanging
Most Non Punjabi politicians were killed a few were kicked out of the country for ever. Punjabi politicians were given chances to rule again and again.
70% of profit from Sui gas from Balochistan is taken by Punjab
Two punjbai generals are selling gold of Balochistan's gold mines are punjabis
Gas and mineral reserves found in Kohat Bannu ( KPK) ar under control of Punjbai Generals and hence the drama of talibans and terrorism
All beggars arrested in Saudi, Dubai are Punjabis
People behind rape, prostitution and human trafficking in UK are punjabis.
Having said that, these people killed in Balochistan was done by RAW. Baloch are against Punjabi fauj.
He's blocking the comments 😂😂😂
Abhay jhoot aisa bolo jo believable ho. Mai koi Elon musk hoon how can I block comments from coming
Karde Bhai aap ka channel hai, You are entitled to do anything.
@@OyePapaJi Saar Friend saarr .Modi leader sarr..India superpower saarr.Thankyou saarr
@@mrjojo166 now see this, a modi fan will never watch a Pakistani Channel in first place.
Second, this is south Indian mockery accent, so mock with something that will offend north Indian.
Third, I live in Islamabad.
@@mrjojo166 raa ki sazidh thi
جتنا جلدی أرمی بلوچستان سے واپس أجاۓ اتنا ہی اچھا ہے ۔ ورنہ ایک اوربنگلہ دیش دستک دے رہا ہے۔
You are great because you are real human not Pakistani only real human
*Free Balochistan* 😢👀😭 please
What is the difference between what hamas did on October 7 verus what BLA did yesterday?
Pakistan is not the occupying force as per international law, Israel is in Palestine giving the people of Palestine an internationally recognized right of resistance to the occupier.
@@ThePakistanExperience Oh, so the International laws decides who have the right to lay a claim to their land.
So now international law and not will of people decide who is occupier who isnt?
That means all subnational independence movement are illegitimate?
Uighur, tibatiens, chechen, kurds etc hv not right to fight?
Guess what even Viet Cong werent internationally recognised
@@ThePakistanExperience
Pakistan by force occupied Balochistan, Pakistan ioccupies land, exploits natural resources like sui gas fields, kill innocent baluchis, jails baluchis , raped innocents like Dr shazia which perpetuated in killing of Nawab Bugti,.. There is no difference between BLA and Hamas. Shahzad dont be a hypocrite.
You don’t want to play this game! Otherwise India and Pak will turn back to little princely states.
The only problem with punjabis is they are educated and let everybody live in their areas jis din Punjabi nationalism jag gya phir Good Game ho jana ha Pakistan ka
Siraikiyon ki zameen p qabza KR k bethy hn aur kehty ho doosron ko rehny de rhy hn ? waah
Nice joke from a narcissist, next joke please
@@Blender_Nerd_1سرائیکی پر اگر پنجابیوں نے قبضہ کیا ہوا ہے تو بلوچ نے جو (پنجابی) مارے وہ سرائیکی تھے 😂😂😂
اسلام نے پنجابیوں سے قومیت چھین لی ہے پنجابی صرف سکھ ہیں
@@Blender_Nerd_1 Siraiki he hu ma loday and very happy with our secular community here in punjab kam sa kam mehmano ko buses sa utar k goliyan ni marta. shame on you
Pakistan said free kashmir, free palestain so next free balochistan 😅
Well you people called same jihadis as freedom fighters who dragged Hindus from uses in Kashmir and massacred them ….Now how come
Same freedom fighters are called terrorists! Hypocrisy? What you sow shall you reap ! Karma calling !!!!😮
Yes.
These bukaads have selective mouths...😂
Kashmir was never india
@@abdurrafaymobin4676well it belongs to 72 Hoors when you are blowing yourself up to get it !😀😁😂🤣😅
@@abdurrafaymobin4676 balochistan was never pakistan
Excellent analysis as always don’t let yourself bother other bloggers who are trying to attack you with names, you are true and I stand by you do not give up!
🙌
I don't know what say, i really am speechless. You have done more than many of us for this country. Huge respect for u legend. Try to stay safe, sound, health, and alive💔
❤️
Get out pakistan 🤬
Free Balochistan
Namak haraam Afghani spotted
What about 600 billions given to balochistan every year by NFC award.where that mony goes.235 cror recovered from balochistan finance minister.They are real culprits
Balochistan kee government kaun banata hay?
@@ThePakistanExperience Jo PTI Ki Government Girata Hai
سرکاری سرداروں کو پیسے ملتے ہیں بلوچستان عوام کو نہی
@@ThePakistanExperienceGHQ pindi
@@ThePakistanExperiencesir jo b banata hy government unkay chosen political representatives to hoty hain na, jinka taaluq b balochistan sy he hota hy aur unky pas billions of billions ky funds b available hoty hain. To log unko Q ni krty qatal? Unky culprit Q nai bolty? Un per attacks Q ni hoty?
Because punjab and the people living in punajb are soft targets and blaming punjab and punjabis for everything is very easy to sell
BHAI , PUNJAB TO KHUD OPPRESED HE
سوری ہمیں آج معلوم ہوا
@@muhammadislamraeessi5356 BHAI I DON'T UNDERSTAND THIS SCRIPT (is it shahmukhi punjabi script??) AND I ALSO DIDN'T UNDERSTOOD ITS TRANLATION .
I WOULD BE THANKFUL IF U WRITE IN ENGLISH ALPHABETS
@@justjee7665 I don’t understand too who should blame for Punjabi ( Bechargi) Baluch? Pashtun? Or Sindhi
@@muhammadislamraeessi5356 I THINK THE ONE WHO MUST BE BLAMED FOR ALL IN PAKISTAN IS - GOVERNMENT AND PSEUDO ISMLAM CULTURE
THEY ARE USING ISMLAM AS TOOL TO DOMINATE ON PUBLIC ANDOPRESS THIER MENTAL FREEDOM
which woman is shezad talking about at the end? jou campaign karahi hai iskeh khilaf?
You need a break, btw i watch most of your videos because it's honest and informative.
Additionally, you explain things very well. God has given you special qualities, make full use of it.
❤️
Punjab is blamed because it is large provence. Pakiatani Punjabi keep talking about Punjabiyat, kartarpur, Punjabi culture greater Punjab. Khalistan. Pakistani Punjabi want to reunite Pakistan Punjabi with India. This is why people in Balochistan hate Punjabis, Muslims talk about Ummah were is concept of ummah?
oh bhai koi jaroorat nahi hai indian punjab se reunite hone ke liye. we have enough problems in our country to deal with we dont want a radicalized pakistani population to deal with. i wish you the very best and hope your pakistan reach new heights, but humaare paas mat aao. ho sake toh border pe ek nadi khod do taaki dono taraf se terrorist infiltrate na kare
Hahahhahaa kuch bhi😂
I always thought you are punjabi but i am glade to know that you are from sindh. Love ❤ you bro
I am punjabi by the way
❤️