I prefer the old art. I understand what they where going for with the new art and it seems like a cool idea but it just comes off as unprofessional and lazy to me. Now I know it isnt but what I'm getting at is it feels like my 5 year old found some pictures online and printed them out to use them. It used to have a nice unique look that was consistent on all the cards for the most part and even the ones that changed the look, example extreme prime wardens, still looked close enough to the rest of the art.
Weird, I love the new art. Feels like it could've come straight out of the pages of a comic book. The really awesome thing is, when you know the lore, you can even see that the style varies from card to card depending on which era of the comics timeline the event depicted in the card occurred. If you ask me, that's awesome! I did like the old art, it was more colorful and messy in a playful way. But I love the stronger comic theme and...being able to tell what's actually happening...in the new art.
@@pandosham in my opinion, an artist doesn't lose their charm by choosing to hone their artstyle. The art is just as unique as it ever was, but Adam Rebottaro is no longer an amateur, he is an expert capable of creating exactly what he wants to create.
The old edition came with 10 heroes. The change here is that they put in two full teams from the fictional comics lore. The Freedom Five were already in the core box, but the Prime Wardens included two heroes (Captain Cosmic and Argent Adept) that originally came in expansion content. They wanted to lump the teams members together and so brought those two over as well as Unity who was a sidekick/intern for the Freedom Five. This means that one original edition hero (Visionary) got bumped to a later box of Definitive Edition stuff.
How's the best thing about old Sentinels compared to the new: The comboing between heroes?(For example you had one hero give another a card play, which gave the third a power usage etc OR something like Omnitron playing Unity's Golems of the top of her deck without her needing to destroy her equipment to play them)
Loved the original Sentinels, but gotta say Definitive Edition is so much better to me! I was surprised how even the small changes like health dials, keywords, and clearly defined phases helped quicken the game and improved the overall experience. The big and small changes to some of the characters have been incredible to play too. Can’t wait to get Rook City Renegades, which has way more exciting new things!
This game is a go to for my playgroup, we always seem to sneak in a game or two even when we have some other games going on. I have all the official product for Sentinels, and was looking at if I should get the new edition and so far I would have to say no. I like a lot of the new art assets and inclusion of keywords(we play magic, so keyword are something my group can understand very well), but there's nothing new for someone that has been playing it for some time and has expansions. It will be interesting to see what comes out in the future. Thanks for the overview of what's what.
I'm a megafan so naturally dived in but still have all the old content. For the typical person though yeah if you have all of one, you can save the cash.
I do feel that it's a lot new. In the most obvious case, Bunker, Tempest, and Fanatic are effectively all-new heroes. Beyond that, nothing feels the same as the old edition, as Definitive has much faster tempo...by comparison the old edition tended to plod along, especially when heroes didn't find a specific card or two. A simple example which rings true for the design throughout: Instead of simply attacking and playing 1 card per turn, Warlord Voss now summons one of his flagships when he flips, and he plays an extra card if the first card he plays is a Gene-bound (weak card). Which shows, in this edition the Villain and the Heroes are expected to do something significant every turn. The difference leaves nothing in the game feeling quite the same as before, even the stuff that was perfectly well-designed in the original.
This game has been on my radar for awhile now but I was never sure with the different variants of it. After watching this video I will definitely be adding this one to my collection to play. Keep up the awesome content my friend. I'm looking forward to seeing more of this game.
I'm from the UK I would love this awesome free give away if its not too late.. I'm currently waiting for the big box addition of pursuit of happiness but this game would definitely ease my hunger till then. As pursuit of happiness is raking ages. I have 3 boars games so having this would be my fourth lol..
I was able to get the Enhanced Edition brand new in wrap for $14, then out of stock Villains new, for $10, the Villains of the multiverse for $12 and one mini expansion for $4. I’ll get whatever else they have on their website. Fun game. I love deck building (Star Realms, Marvel, Dune, Astro Knights…) happy to add this old school gem to the collection.
Hmmm... the keywords thing would be better if there were reference cards but without them I'm handing around the rule book all the time where the original cards, while wordy, have the rule right one the card. Seems like all those of us who have a lot of the original need are some dials...
The Rook City Renegades KS update from today shows reference cards that they'll be including due to popular demand. Sure that doesn't help the core box, but it is something they're addressing.
A few villains are harder with five heroes (like villains that are beaten with Hx2 cards are under it, or must have H-1 cards of a certain type out to flip).
Thanks for this comparison and for sharing your opinion, Luke! Although I have been playing this game via the app (which has been consistently beating me), I'd yet to buy a physical copy. Your video convinced me: Definitive Edition, ordered 🙂
That would require a whole video to go into that much detail as there are little tweaks in all sorts of places but honestly the only major changes are that Bunker and Fanatic are now playable again.
Both games I love, but MC could end up around a 9 eventually from 10. Sentinels has consistently been a hit with me. Having a pre-made deck that's unique just makes life so much easier.
I like the new version a lot, but the proprietary sleeves aren't my favorite. I may replace them with my personal favorite mayday premium sleeves. They just slide around too much. Perhaps over time that won't be an issue. But yeah, the box was not designed for their own sleeves, at least not in an organized fashion. That bugs me but I can forgive it. At the moment I can't tell which version I like more, but I have years of experience with the old version so maybe I just need to get more comfortable with the rebalanced characters. Still buying everything because it is stellar
@@TheBrokenMeeple I should have gone down that route with Sentinels 1e and Marvel Champions. Now I'm getting a second mortgage on my house just to sleeve them all
@@TheBrokenMeeple the rules from bgg basically have you shuffle all hero cards you aren't using and use their backs as if you had additional rotating defeated hero.
If u were into marvel comics in the late 80s and early 90s the artstyle is pure nostalgic!
I prefer the old art. I understand what they where going for with the new art and it seems like a cool idea but it just comes off as unprofessional and lazy to me. Now I know it isnt but what I'm getting at is it feels like my 5 year old found some pictures online and printed them out to use them. It used to have a nice unique look that was consistent on all the cards for the most part and even the ones that changed the look, example extreme prime wardens, still looked close enough to the rest of the art.
I can take or leave either art, but I get you, the old one feels more like a comic.
Weird, I love the new art. Feels like it could've come straight out of the pages of a comic book. The really awesome thing is, when you know the lore, you can even see that the style varies from card to card depending on which era of the comics timeline the event depicted in the card occurred. If you ask me, that's awesome!
I did like the old art, it was more colorful and messy in a playful way. But I love the stronger comic theme and...being able to tell what's actually happening...in the new art.
@@kitsunin4690 like that's fine and all but a lot of the charm of the game went away
@@pandosham in my opinion, an artist doesn't lose their charm by choosing to hone their artstyle. The art is just as unique as it ever was, but Adam Rebottaro is no longer an amateur, he is an expert capable of creating exactly what he wants to create.
Top tip: You can sleeve the dividers with 70mm x 70mm sleeves which give them a bit of a boost in the box.
Not a bad idea! 👍
The old edition came with 10 heroes. The change here is that they put in two full teams from the fictional comics lore. The Freedom Five were already in the core box, but the Prime Wardens included two heroes (Captain Cosmic and Argent Adept) that originally came in expansion content. They wanted to lump the teams members together and so brought those two over as well as Unity who was a sidekick/intern for the Freedom Five. This means that one original edition hero (Visionary) got bumped to a later box of Definitive Edition stuff.
I'm all down for thematic team ups!
How's the best thing about old Sentinels compared to the new: The comboing between heroes?(For example you had one hero give another a card play, which gave the third a power usage etc OR something like Omnitron playing Unity's Golems of the top of her deck without her needing to destroy her equipment to play them)
Loved the original Sentinels, but gotta say Definitive Edition is so much better to me! I was surprised how even the small changes like health dials, keywords, and clearly defined phases helped quicken the game and improved the overall experience. The big and small changes to some of the characters have been incredible to play too. Can’t wait to get Rook City Renegades, which has way more exciting new things!
They do make a solid difference to ease of play.
This game is a go to for my playgroup, we always seem to sneak in a game or two even when we have some other games going on.
I have all the official product for Sentinels, and was looking at if I should get the new edition and so far I would have to say no.
I like a lot of the new art assets and inclusion of keywords(we play magic, so keyword are something my group can understand very well), but there's nothing new for someone that has been playing it for some time and has expansions.
It will be interesting to see what comes out in the future.
Thanks for the overview of what's what.
I'm a megafan so naturally dived in but still have all the old content. For the typical person though yeah if you have all of one, you can save the cash.
I do feel that it's a lot new. In the most obvious case, Bunker, Tempest, and Fanatic are effectively all-new heroes. Beyond that, nothing feels the same as the old edition, as Definitive has much faster tempo...by comparison the old edition tended to plod along, especially when heroes didn't find a specific card or two.
A simple example which rings true for the design throughout: Instead of simply attacking and playing 1 card per turn, Warlord Voss now summons one of his flagships when he flips, and he plays an extra card if the first card he plays is a Gene-bound (weak card).
Which shows, in this edition the Villain and the Heroes are expected to do something significant every turn. The difference leaves nothing in the game feeling quite the same as before, even the stuff that was perfectly well-designed in the original.
Perfect, I wanted to ask you on review video what is the difference between 2 versions.
This game has been on my radar for awhile now but I was never sure with the different variants of it. After watching this video I will definitely be adding this one to my collection to play. Keep up the awesome content my friend. I'm looking forward to seeing more of this game.
Hope you enjoy it!
I'm from the UK I would love this awesome free give away if its not too late.. I'm currently waiting for the big box addition of pursuit of happiness but this game would definitely ease my hunger till then. As pursuit of happiness is raking ages. I have 3 boars games so having this would be my fourth lol..
I was able to get the Enhanced Edition brand new in wrap for $14, then out of stock Villains new, for $10, the Villains of the multiverse for $12 and one mini expansion for $4.
I’ll get whatever else they have on their website.
Fun game. I love deck building (Star Realms, Marvel, Dune, Astro Knights…) happy to add this old school gem to the collection.
Hmmm... the keywords thing would be better if there were reference cards but without them I'm handing around the rule book all the time where the original cards, while wordy, have the rule right one the card.
Seems like all those of us who have a lot of the original need are some dials...
The Rook City Renegades KS update from today shows reference cards that they'll be including due to popular demand. Sure that doesn't help the core box, but it is something they're addressing.
Most who enjoy it will get the expansion eventually so I'm glad they're at least addressing it.
A few villains are harder with five heroes (like villains that are beaten with Hx2 cards are under it, or must have H-1 cards of a certain type out to flip).
Thanks for this comparison and for sharing your opinion, Luke! Although I have been playing this game via the app (which has been consistently beating me), I'd yet to buy a physical copy. Your video convinced me: Definitive Edition, ordered 🙂
Nice one Ion! :D
Hm, I was hoping you'd go into some detail in regards to the actual gameplay-changes/rebalancings to characters/villains...any thoughts?
That would require a whole video to go into that much detail as there are little tweaks in all sorts of places but honestly the only major changes are that Bunker and Fanatic are now playable again.
Just picked up the definitive edition last week and it's on the table today. Excited to learn it after watching this and your review of it.
Hope you enjoy it!
How do you feel this game compares to Marvel Champions?
Both games I love, but MC could end up around a 9 eventually from 10. Sentinels has consistently been a hit with me. Having a pre-made deck that's unique just makes life so much easier.
I like the new version a lot, but the proprietary sleeves aren't my favorite. I may replace them with my personal favorite mayday premium sleeves. They just slide around too much. Perhaps over time that won't be an issue. But yeah, the box was not designed for their own sleeves, at least not in an organized fashion. That bugs me but I can forgive it. At the moment I can't tell which version I like more, but I have years of experience with the old version so maybe I just need to get more comfortable with the rebalanced characters. Still buying everything because it is stellar
Sleeve Kings for the win for my sleeves.
@@TheBrokenMeeple I should have gone down that route with Sentinels 1e and Marvel Champions. Now I'm getting a second mortgage on my house just to sleeve them all
It is such a huge disappointment they didn't make good rules for 1 or 2 heroes, we have good fan rules, but this was a missed opportunity.
Yeah I agree, I can pilot 3-4 decks fine but why not make life easier? Curious what the fan rules are.
@@TheBrokenMeeple the rules from bgg basically have you shuffle all hero cards you aren't using and use their backs as if you had additional rotating defeated hero.
@@mikolajwitkowski8093 so essentially two incapacitated heroes triggering every round?
Great comparison video.
Thanks!