Zadie Smith Is WRONG: WORDS Are Not VIOLENCE, Zionism Is: Briahna Joy Gray

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 тра 2024
  • Briahna Joy Gray argues against "bothsiderisms" present in many reports about the Israel-Palestine war. #zionists #palestine
    About Rising:
    Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
    Follow Rising on social media:
    Website: Hill.TV
    Facebook: HillTVLive/
    Instagram: @HillTVLive
    Twitter: @HillTVLive

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,4 тис.

  • @pn312
    @pn312 28 днів тому +266

    My Italian heritage PROVES that I deserve a condo in Rome … and a house in Jerusalem because the Romans were unfairly forced out of the Holy Land! 😂

    • @leviashanken2506
      @leviashanken2506 28 днів тому +5

      By the Arabs!

    • @pn312
      @pn312 28 днів тому +47

      @leviashanken2506 Exactly! And since those Arabs took my birthright in 638, Jupiter decrees that I return to reclaim my land!
      You may say that sounds ridiculous... I agree. But ridiculous claims are the foundation of modern Zionism.

    • @leviashanken2506
      @leviashanken2506 28 днів тому +3

      @@pn312 but the Roman conquerors came from Rome and had Rome to return to so this would be ridiculous but not at all comparable to the situation with Israel. And quite ignorant and insensitive, too.

    • @dilonkumar4960
      @dilonkumar4960 26 днів тому

      @@leviashanken2506but Jews came from modern day Iraq an took the land from cannites ,an most Jews today come from Europe they are dual national so go

    • @stefaniabrazzi1358
      @stefaniabrazzi1358 26 днів тому +35

      ​@@leviashanken2506most Israeli have dual citizenship, so they can go BACK where they come from Europe Russia USA

  • @mariaclaraps1971
    @mariaclaraps1971 28 днів тому +328

    They are not feeling unsafe: they're feeling guilty. 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

    • @alpheuswoodley8435
      @alpheuswoodley8435 26 днів тому +1

      🙌

    • @TechThisWayNow
      @TechThisWayNow 25 днів тому +10

      I dont think they know what that feels like

    • @abdifupi2587
      @abdifupi2587 25 днів тому +3

      They don’t even feel that

    • @lynnevenables7193
      @lynnevenables7193 25 днів тому

      It’s the fact that their white supremacy is being challenged, every spokesperson I’ve listened to on the Israeli side sounds like extreme spoiled brats!

    • @ahimsainthekitchen
      @ahimsainthekitchen 25 днів тому +3

      @@TechThisWayNow I agree. Someone with NO soul, a liar, a thief has no conscience, therefore has no ability to feel guilty.

  • @louisesumrell6331
    @louisesumrell6331 28 днів тому +275

    "They call it "the American Dream" because you have to be asleep to believe it."
    -George Carlin

  • @amania9254
    @amania9254 28 днів тому +273

    Why the Apartheid Israel lobbyists are not yet registered as Foreign Agents whom they are?

    • @thinkbeforeyoutype7106
      @thinkbeforeyoutype7106 26 днів тому +15

      Exactly!

    • @MadhuKrishnaDasa
      @MadhuKrishnaDasa 26 днів тому +22

      JFK tried to ....aaaannnnd .....

    • @user-bs9hm6gg9i
      @user-bs9hm6gg9i 26 днів тому

      1)israel is far more secular and respective of religious freedom than any arab country
      2)with the treatment of kurds turkmen domari and afro iraqis in iraq,and non arabized/black people in sudan and maurtiania and sudan - the arab league and its spokespersons better be careful who they call apartheid. it has nothing to do with race and i promise we chase black islamists just as fiercely as we do blond ones. our mizrahi communities wont be subjected to another 1929 hebron and safed pogrom or 194q farhud without retaliation...
      3)maybe the pro palestinians can find donors in america and not from qatari dictatorship or chinese dystopia who support their cause and then they wont be registered as foreign agents? and qatar still refuse to do so even though the DOJ ordered them to do so.

    • @seanhammer6296
      @seanhammer6296 26 днів тому +8

      ​@@MadhuKrishnaDasa...then he got shot.

    • @donaldcarpenter5328
      @donaldcarpenter5328 26 днів тому

      The ABOMINATION is called "DUAL CITIZENSHIP"!!!!!!!!!!

  • @JohnFelinn
    @JohnFelinn 28 днів тому +965

    A Palestinian wrote
    "I Am Christian Palestinian from Nazareth. I hate how the situation is painted as Jew Vs Muslim. Its Zionism vs humans..."

    • @D-E-S_8559
      @D-E-S_8559 28 днів тому +35

      African American remember with great caution that even at the purported ending of "democractic" chatel slavery, other forms of repressive realities were adopted instantaneously to keep them a perpetual servant under class, in much the same way that Americans can now finally see and relate with the current plight of the Palestinians----there was a time in America up until 1964, when they were finally granted civil rights and quite frankly citizenship. Back then even NEW immigrants had more rights than ALL AND ANY of those African Americans.
      Now, we see the same thing in zionist Israel, where foreigners are granted more rights than ALL the other natives regardless of their status----which makes one question who or what in the govt determines who is or isn't a Jew worth the right of return, and if Arabs are allowed to convert to judaism, if that is the only way they can access equal rights...

    • @redaawadallah4518
      @redaawadallah4518 28 днів тому +12

      💯

    • @amro676
      @amro676 28 днів тому

      ​@@justjunk8565
      And native Americans didn't call themselves native Americans until foreign colonizers started genociding them and stealing their lands .. it doesn't negate they are native to the land we call America..
      They just didn't need a unified national identity until their existence were threatened..
      ..
      So also the native people of the land called palestine.. didn't actually need a unified identity until foreign colonisers started massacring and ethnically cleansing them from their homes and lands

    • @memeisticdan4135
      @memeisticdan4135 28 днів тому +19

      ​@@justjunk8565i thought a Palestinian was from Palestine. Are you saying there is/was no such place as Palestine?

    • @Tiger00740
      @Tiger00740 28 днів тому +3

      Left or right BLA BLA BLA if you were in Palestine or other and you are from the west you’re human value is zero!!
      This will never change never!! Let’s mind our own business and care for our own country

  • @JohnFelinn
    @JohnFelinn 28 днів тому +580

    Opposing genocide even if the perpetrators are Jewish, is not antisemitic.

    • @adinahaun6001
      @adinahaun6001 28 днів тому

      Biden is counting on people not understanding this!

    • @NickFromDetroit
      @NickFromDetroit 28 днів тому +18

      Genocide has a definition. Try looking it up sometime.

    • @AndrewJackson1841
      @AndrewJackson1841 28 днів тому +18

      The accusation still seems to steer the conversation from ongoing war crimes to what is or isn't "antisemitism". At what point do you simply admit it's a meaningless ad hominem?

    • @AndrewJackson1841
      @AndrewJackson1841 28 днів тому +18

      @@NickFromDetroit Your point?

    • @NickFromDetroit
      @NickFromDetroit 28 днів тому

      @@AndrewJackson1841 , 1) No genocide is occurring in Gaza.
      2) Falsely calling it a genocide is anti-Semitic.
      3) No nation on earth has done more to keep collateral damage to a minimum than Israel.
      4) Hamas Gazan jihadis always target civilians, which are war crimes.

  • @malungisamaseko3155
    @malungisamaseko3155 28 днів тому +215

    "it looks like apartheid, it talks like apartheid, it is apartheid" Gideon Levy

    • @a-sf6nc
      @a-sf6nc 28 днів тому +4

      Visit Israel, walk in the streets of any city, go to courtrooms, police stations, hospitals see how many are arabs. (Spoiler alert -a lot...!!!) Including the Knesset. So find another word to describe Israel if you don't like the way it's leaded, but apartheid is just not it .

    • @malungisamaseko3155
      @malungisamaseko3155 28 днів тому +17

      @@a-sf6nc 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Care to tell me which streets to use. There are sure streets which are only used by the chosen ones. How many check points will I come across where I will be threatened with deportation if I bring a camera? I want to be prepared

    • @SonderDAzeX-nc6vg
      @SonderDAzeX-nc6vg 28 днів тому

      @@a-sf6nc The leader of Israel ,Benjamin Netayahu has said Israel is a Jewish state. Also many members of the Knesset have incited genocidal intent. Not suprising that most have been from the Likud party.

    • @gsp3428
      @gsp3428 28 днів тому +2

      from someone who doesnt even know what the word means, and probably has never even been to Israel, just uses buzz words, like other nazis.

    • @jpah8944
      @jpah8944 28 днів тому

      So Palestine is guilty of that then. I mean their Christian populations have been decimated by the Muslims through apartheid like actions.

  • @CountryWilde
    @CountryWilde 28 днів тому +55

    "Here we are now" is not a justification for genocide, Robbie!

  • @travisflores7300
    @travisflores7300 28 днів тому +633

    Pro Palestine: Theres a genocide happening!
    Pro Israel : You're being rude

    • @HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings
      @HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings 28 днів тому +16

      Mind Begs the Question:
      - If a Semitic State
      - Engage in Genocide/Apartheid
      - To speak,act against it
      - Is Anti Semitic or Pro Freedom?

    • @bodhisattva3774
      @bodhisattva3774 28 днів тому +48

      ​@cbs63 please, that garbage has been fully debunked. BTW, Israel uses human shields. Their military installations are in residential areas. But good job mindlessly parroting imperial talking points.

    • @belgianbull4722
      @belgianbull4722 28 днів тому +17

      @@bodhisattva3774 yes, and even more so that in Israel young people are forced to join the military

    • @dancarter6044
      @dancarter6044 28 днів тому +10

      Pro Reality, there is no genocide.

    • @davidwestwater2219
      @davidwestwater2219 28 днів тому +8

      Lets make israel southafrica

  • @user-ly9cj7vb3o
    @user-ly9cj7vb3o 28 днів тому +304

    You forgot the 6yr Palestinian boy along with his mother who were killed by their landlord The Jews complain but only the Palestinians are actually being killed or injured

    • @kovie9162
      @kovie9162 28 днів тому +12

      Really, no Jews have been killed in this conflict? And you're also blaming Israel for that boy's death?
      Offensive and idiotic.

    • @slappyfun
      @slappyfun 28 днів тому

      @@kovie9162come on, you get the point, no? The obviously more vulnerable people are the Palestinians. Protestors here are speaking up for them. Stop the brutal occupation and literal murdering first then we can start to address people’s unsafe feelings here.

    • @miguelvigoa7271
      @miguelvigoa7271 28 днів тому

      And the Jews don’t get killed ?? You need to learn history

    • @jnananinja7436
      @jnananinja7436 28 днів тому +35

      @@kovie9162Ah, ur offended 😢

    • @xftbllplyr2091
      @xftbllplyr2091 27 днів тому +23

      @@kovie9162the cry in pain as they strike you

  • @sarahamad897
    @sarahamad897 28 днів тому +39

    Thank you for being the Palestinian voice Bri!!! May god bless you

  • @elaine5953
    @elaine5953 28 днів тому +35

    Her look when Robbie went onto his ignorant spoon fed rant is priceless.

  • @unipartyhellscape8895
    @unipartyhellscape8895 28 днів тому +198

    Briahna's face @15:55 when Robby makes the argument for collective punishment for about the 400th time puts into view an exasperation we all feel by now arguing with human beings who seem to have no moral compass.

    • @Dle8647
      @Dle8647 28 днів тому +38

      She’s got slot of self control I would be losing my mind

    • @tonybanks1035
      @tonybanks1035 28 днів тому +10

      all those who think Robby lacks moral compass actually lack a brain. So there's really no solution

    • @sburn1919
      @sburn1919 28 днів тому +2

      The claim that Robbie is the one exhausting viewers is so incredible that it immediately depletes the credibility of the speaker

    • @sburn1919
      @sburn1919 28 днів тому +7

      Her face says “I’m a big baby and when Robbie disagrees with me at all I pout.”

    • @NeorecnamorceN
      @NeorecnamorceN 28 днів тому +31

      ​@@tonybanks1035 he has a moral compass, he is just reading it backwards. Imagine arguing for collective punishment and thinking you are in the right, truly a brain dead argument if I've ever heard one.

  • @kimmi8389
    @kimmi8389 28 днів тому +192

    Robbie’s cognitive dissonance will not allow him to ever understand this issue

    • @adrianthornton8288
      @adrianthornton8288 27 днів тому +2

      That is not his job....

    • @robertcarpenter7486
      @robertcarpenter7486 27 днів тому +19

      This is a perfect example of why real debate is not possible with some people. Referring to robbie

    • @boulevard14
      @boulevard14 27 днів тому +2

      Can't handle someone who disagrees with you?

    • @kimmi8389
      @kimmi8389 27 днів тому +23

      @@boulevard14 he can’t even acknowledge factual historical truths about the conflict if it gives concessions to the Palestinians. So no honest discourse can take place.

    • @rumination2399
      @rumination2399 27 днів тому +13

      Yeah. I lost much respect for him since Gaza. Many people in fact

  • @defu-ski5936
    @defu-ski5936 28 днів тому +37

    It's always complicated when you don't want to see the truth.

    • @mobitecstore7344
      @mobitecstore7344 28 днів тому

      It is complicated. Thats why its been going over 70 years.

    • @fritznovak4482
      @fritznovak4482 26 днів тому +1

      It’s always complicated when Americans see everything through a narrow “oppressor vs oppressed” lense

  • @salehdabbakeh1655
    @salehdabbakeh1655 25 днів тому +8

    I was born in a Palestinian refugee camp in Amman, Jordan. The nightmare named Israel has been following me and millions other Palestinians since 1948. We aim to go back to our country, our homes, our properties and our cities. This will eventually happen. It might take another decade or two, but we will liberate our country and regain our freedom. Our Jewish brothers and sisters lived with us peacefully before 1948. They are welcome to live with us in one democratic state where everyone has the same rights. Hamas was established in 1989, some say with Israel's help to fight the PLO then. That is nearly 40 years after the occupation of Palestine and the displacement of the greatest majority of its people.

    • @crystalsharadin9772
      @crystalsharadin9772 23 дні тому

      Beautifully said. I believe this will happen too, and I stand with you! ✊🏼

    • @salehdabbakeh1655
      @salehdabbakeh1655 23 дні тому

      @@crystalsharadin9772 thank you.

  • @fokana1
    @fokana1 28 днів тому +283

    United States of Israel

  • @Test-ju4fy
    @Test-ju4fy 28 днів тому +289

    "Genocide is violence"
    "No, *words* are violence"

    • @azalia423
      @azalia423 28 днів тому +15

      Zadie Smith's publisher is Penguin Random House, Bertelsmann. " Over the decades Bertelsmann and Israel have developed close and extremely stable ties of friendship." (Never Again is Now)

    • @j.thomas8547
      @j.thomas8547 28 днів тому

      Strange, just 10 minutes ago, leftists were saying that things "misgendering" or "MAGA" were a form of violence. Now liberal Jews are learning what it's like to be on the "wrong" side of leftists' beliefs. BTW I personally don't think words are violence. If you believe that Israel should be a Jewish state say it. If you want to support the people of Gaza or even Hamas, say it. Free speech is clarifying.

    • @S62r
      @S62r 28 днів тому

      Notice leftists will never criticize Hamas or place any blame on them? Isn’t the real crime using human shields?

    • @tomasmendezdiaz9833
      @tomasmendezdiaz9833 28 днів тому

      Why do you thing hate speech is condem.

    • @alpheuswoodley8435
      @alpheuswoodley8435 27 днів тому +13

      ​@@tomasmendezdiaz9833 send an ambulance, your words have caused me internal bleeding

  • @wismail68
    @wismail68 28 днів тому +17

    Uphold humanity, freedom and justice.

  • @JohnROgle
    @JohnROgle 28 днів тому +17

    Bri, Thanks for your courage and for speaking the truth about such an evil war.

  • @darrenhilton9402
    @darrenhilton9402 28 днів тому +356

    Palestine has a right to defend itself.

    • @chrismorris8847
      @chrismorris8847 28 днів тому +32

      So does Israel

    • @litedawg
      @litedawg 28 днів тому +2

      Sounds good to Izreel

    • @WhatIfWe615
      @WhatIfWe615 28 днів тому +30

      @@chrismorris8847very true. It would be great if one day Israel wasn’t the attacker and oppressor. (Atleast here in the USA, a person or group cannot invade your home then claim self defense when you try your get the out of your home.)

    • @raulduke2035
      @raulduke2035 28 днів тому

      Palestine doesn’t exist, never did, never will!

    • @Matt_H_
      @Matt_H_ 28 днів тому

      ​@WhatIfWe615
      Nearly every war Israel has been involved in has been reactionary.
      Even the 1967 war, where those called Palestinians voluntarily left their country so a number of Arab countries could attack Israel at once to exterminate the Jews.

  • @seangearhart2494
    @seangearhart2494 28 днів тому +138

    The 34,000 number hasn't moved in months. There's no way it isn't way higher.

    • @belgianbull4722
      @belgianbull4722 28 днів тому +29

      thousands still lying in the rubble, while many others died because of lack of medicine, or famine that aren't even included. The number has been estimated much higher than 34,000

    • @bromosapien4972
      @bromosapien4972 28 днів тому

      @@belgianbull4722 guess you shouldnt vote in Terrorist governments eh

    • @cmike123
      @cmike123 28 днів тому

      Especially with mass graves being uncovered...

    • @wilburhornshnoggle2619
      @wilburhornshnoggle2619 28 днів тому +4

      IKR, it's probably north of 34 Billion...

    • @dorian7215
      @dorian7215 28 днів тому +12

      Recently saw that it’s now at 42k

  • @user-zq7xi1dc4y
    @user-zq7xi1dc4y 28 днів тому +18

    This lady is simply brilliant. The way she was able to zero in on the core of why this conflict exists is admirable.

  • @legalalien2923
    @legalalien2923 28 днів тому +13

    There’s nothing about complicated genocide rob

  • @chessman70
    @chessman70 28 днів тому +202

    Don't you wish our representatives wouldn't be so greedy and just wanting to fill their pockets and do what is right for the American people they "represent"?

    • @Gron257
      @Gron257 28 днів тому +11

      The government you elect is the government you deserve.
      - Thomas Jefferson

    • @nyvarsitysports
      @nyvarsitysports 28 днів тому +5

      It’s a strategic money chess game: either you take the money, or I will offer this same cheap amount to you opponent running against you that happens to think it is a lot of money.
      So, take the money and keep your job, or risk it. This is why the price of them being bought is so cheap.

    • @nyvarsitysports
      @nyvarsitysports 28 днів тому +11

      I personally would take the AIPAC money and when I got elected, give them the finger.

    • @tivobelievo7390
      @tivobelievo7390 28 днів тому +1

      @OP: Lol, if only! 😄

    • @belgianbull4722
      @belgianbull4722 28 днів тому +14

      @@nyvarsitysports The way for us as voters to decrease the impact of AIPAC and Israel would be to vote third party. When democrats see that they are losing elections because of this than maybe their stance might change

  • @user-yg7nc1bi5u
    @user-yg7nc1bi5u 28 днів тому +268

    Bri is exactly right. Don't let anyone distract from the reality of the genocide in Gaza and both the responsibility of Israel and our government for it.

    • @belgianbull4722
      @belgianbull4722 28 днів тому +15

      When someone calls me anti semitic solely for criticizing Israel and Israeli war crimes I take it as a badge of honor, since them calling me anti semitic instead of retorting with facts shows they lost the argument

    • @traviscutler9912
      @traviscutler9912 28 днів тому +12

      When you stop giving a s#!+ if you get fired.
      Good job Bri, rub their noses in the truth.

    • @Matt_H_
      @Matt_H_ 28 днів тому +4

      I hate how there was a ceasefire for years and then Israel broke it on October 7th with their terrorist attack on a music concert in Gaza and filmed themselves doing it.

    • @belgianbull4722
      @belgianbull4722 28 днів тому

      @@Matt_H_ The idea that there was a ceasefire for years is wrong. Israel over the years has been killing and detaining people while slowly stealing more and more land, while also destroying homes , I condemn what Hamas did on October 7th, but the Palestinians have contninuosly suffered of Israeli terrorism

    • @fulanicarter2328
      @fulanicarter2328 28 днів тому +1

      yA THEY GOT REALLY WORK HARD TO FIND A SCRIPT FOR ROBO BOY.

  • @natalianunez1385
    @natalianunez1385 28 днів тому +44

    Fantastic radar Bri💔🇵🇸.
    Listening to Robbie defend what Israel is doing “because Hamas” is exhausting

    • @omahhum82
      @omahhum82 28 днів тому +1

      The truth can be exhausting

    • @kenw4930
      @kenw4930 26 днів тому +1

      @@omahhum82 and so can bullsh*t

  • @adnans8778
    @adnans8778 26 днів тому +5

    Brilliant monologue. Most adults have been so brainwashed, over-intellectualised and lost their grasp of basic morality that they cannot see the plain truth.
    Does Robby think the genocides of Native Americans, Australian Aboriginals, European Jews, Kenyan Mau Mau, Belgian Congolese and Franco Algerians were also incredibly complex that he couldn't grasp which party was the victim and which the perpetrator?

  • @erikdolnack846
    @erikdolnack846 28 днів тому +103

    How can you be certain just who is, in fact "Jewish", and who is not, in a nation that prohibits DNA testing on individuals living there?

    • @mikelgeren149
      @mikelgeren149 28 днів тому

      Khazars are eighth century converts to the Pharisess' Talmudism . Khazars have no DNA relationship to the biblical people known as Israel or Judah .
      Kenites were the leaders of the Pharisees , said so by Jesus Christ in John 8 . It may be correct to say that modern Khazars are "spiritual" Kenites , but still the Khazars have NO DNA relationship to biblical people , and therefore NO claim to land in Palestine . Khazars' claims to land in Palestine are predicated on lies .

    • @liz-iy6zm
      @liz-iy6zm 28 днів тому

      because the Jews there have NO MIDDLE EASTERN BLOOD. they are all Ashkenazi!!

    • @karenz1634
      @karenz1634 27 днів тому +16

      Jewish is a religion, not a race or ethnicity.

    • @mikelgeren149
      @mikelgeren149 27 днів тому

      @@karenz1634 so why won't Israel open their society to everyone claiming to be Jews ?

    • @user-cg1qq2er8x
      @user-cg1qq2er8x 27 днів тому

      This has been determined by every country before DNA testing was invented. Jews are a people and they have long records.

  • @roboldx9171
    @roboldx9171 28 днів тому +237

    Bria's face says it all. How do you explain justice to those who are not truly just?

    • @manicmadpanickedman2249
      @manicmadpanickedman2249 28 днів тому

      Hypotheticaly what is
      more likely to cause harm! or death!
      Drugs! or living! 🤔
      Living obviously because it's 100%fatal
      because when you live you die??? that is fact yes???
      So on that ground
      What do you do to drug dealers and why ??
      If your the one with the elicit substance ...
      So does that
      not make people
      who have kids
      life dealers???? 😂😂😂
      So, based on that, what is more hanus ???😂😂
      also sober refers strictly to abstinence from alcohol and your ability to be serious or solemn
      Nothing else
      And addiction is something that you are physically or mentally dependent on and can't stop taking it without adverse effects .....
      that includes food 😂😂😂😂 people are silly read a book called the dictionary this ain't pictionary

    • @wilburhornshnoggle2619
      @wilburhornshnoggle2619 28 днів тому +8

      Let me guess, you and Brie are truly just. amirite?

    • @roboldx9171
      @roboldx9171 28 днів тому +18

      @@wilburhornshnoggle2619, Just enough to truly understand the meaning of the word 'Amalek', used by a psychopathic leader. Amirite?

    • @JLuisCastaneda
      @JLuisCastaneda 28 днів тому +2

      Easily the most arrogant thing I’ve seen in writing today

    • @roboldx9171
      @roboldx9171 28 днів тому +7

      @@JLuisCastaneda Wow! You are so easily impressed.

  • @ZIMCoin
    @ZIMCoin 28 днів тому +5

    Wow! I often find myself disagreeing with Briahna, but she absolutely nailed this one!!! Thank you Briahna, for speaking up and giving a voice to the 15,000 dead Palestinian children.

  • @Lisa_Mojica
    @Lisa_Mojica 28 днів тому +9

    Robbie had me fooled for a second. How does he STILL not know the historical starting point

    • @omahhum82
      @omahhum82 28 днів тому

      Oh? What is that point? Enlighten us

    • @_Helicam_
      @_Helicam_ 22 дні тому

      @@omahhum82 That's depends on the particular point they trying to push.

  • @JohnFelinn
    @JohnFelinn 28 днів тому +193

    Palestine is occupied land, and under international law, the Palestinians have the legal right to resist this occupation by any and all means.

    • @KungPowShitzu
      @KungPowShitzu 28 днів тому +22

      International law says Israel is a sovereign nation

    • @a-sf6nc
      @a-sf6nc 28 днів тому +14

      Occupied from whom? Was their a palastinen state before an Israeli state?

    • @mohammedkadwa7072
      @mohammedkadwa7072 28 днів тому +18

      ​@@a-sf6ncgo read a book

    • @luqstar
      @luqstar 28 днів тому +5

      Thank you not waiting on Robby to open his mouth before ending the video.

    • @JoeBeThere
      @JoeBeThere 28 днів тому +4

      @@KungPowShitzu that must abide by the law they have ratified, but you fail to see that logic

  • @_Make_America_Native_Again_.
    @_Make_America_Native_Again_. 28 днів тому +142

    They are doing to PaIestinians, what they did to Native Americans…..

    • @badmf7551
      @badmf7551 28 днів тому +9

      Don't ever compare them. Native Americans aren't terrorists 🤷‍♂️

    • @AverageJoe483
      @AverageJoe483 28 днів тому +9

      Not really . Natives were never homogenous as a nation but 1000s of tribes that fought each other . In fact many allied with the U.S. to take down other tribes .

    • @AverageJoe483
      @AverageJoe483 28 днів тому +5

      @@badmf7551some tribes weren’t and other tribes were .

    • @belgianbull4722
      @belgianbull4722 28 днів тому +25

      @@badmf7551 No but back in the day Native Americans were pushed from their lands and killed, and when they fought back they were labeled as terrorists and worse. There are similarities

    • @twatts1523
      @twatts1523 28 днів тому +14

      @@belgianbull4722Also, the way the children were removed, to “reeducate” them.

  • @SUZESTONE
    @SUZESTONE 28 днів тому +7

    Oh Bri! What to do about Robbie. Excellent on-target radar. Thank you.

  • @user-qf1zg4zz8j
    @user-qf1zg4zz8j 28 днів тому +7

    Brihana one of your best monologues - acutely on point and mesmerising. The truth is powerful and you deliver it well.

  • @validatedclassified2564
    @validatedclassified2564 28 днів тому +147

    Bri's monologue was epic. Well done.

    • @mcu4286
      @mcu4286 28 днів тому +8

      Epic bs

    • @bropitt
      @bropitt 28 днів тому

      well then I will expect her not to use so many hypotheticals from now on

    • @traviscutler9912
      @traviscutler9912 28 днів тому +3

      Katie Helper got fired for an awful lot last.
      When you stop giving a s#!+ if you get fired.
      Good job Bri, rub their noses in the truth.

    • @chadstephens3640
      @chadstephens3640 28 днів тому +2

      Epic 😂😂😂😂 world salad at its finest

    • @user-cg1qq2er8x
      @user-cg1qq2er8x 27 днів тому

      It was a disturbed, dishonest, histrionic rant.

  • @jaguarkaboom8967
    @jaguarkaboom8967 28 днів тому +49

    Bri deserves a raise.

  • @babstra55
    @babstra55 24 дні тому +2

    "they say we are disturbing the peace, but there is no peace. what really bothers them is that we are disturbing the war."

  • @Elboogie404
    @Elboogie404 28 днів тому +24

    There is no way Robby is this naive after all the info, interviews and evidence available. No way.

  • @jennifergottliebel-azhari149
    @jennifergottliebel-azhari149 28 днів тому +103

    She is so articulate. Love her.

  • @delzoid
    @delzoid 28 днів тому +159

    Anti-racism, anti-fascism, and anti-zionism are all intertwined.

    • @vid8w7
      @vid8w7 28 днів тому +5

      @@leviashanken2506 What does that even mean?

    • @kasardevi8
      @kasardevi8 28 днів тому +3

      totally agree

    • @Jeremy-ij1wp
      @Jeremy-ij1wp 28 днів тому +3

      ​@vid8w7 I think they're pointing out the obvious hypocracy

    • @justinfleming5119
      @justinfleming5119 28 днів тому

      Wrong. "Antiracism" and antifascism" are both zionist fronts. That's why you saw attackers of the UCLA encampment dressed in black bloc and using black bloc tactics. That's why the encampments are swimming upstream without the institutional support BLM and OWS benefited from.

    • @chopses8391
      @chopses8391 28 днів тому

      It means if a tree falls in the forest, and no ones hears it, it's antisemitism.@@vid8w7

  • @habsa8855
    @habsa8855 28 днів тому +12

    Thanks Bri for sensible reporting.
    Listening to Robbie’s reverse engineering the victims and aggressors is sickening.

  • @mrsoluwaoseunti
    @mrsoluwaoseunti 28 днів тому +11

    Brie deserves an award

  • @drujackson-xc3ur
    @drujackson-xc3ur 28 днів тому +184

    whether it’s robbie or piers morgan they forget everything they learn in the interview before and just return to their factory settings “do you condemn Hamas” “rapings and beheaded babies”

    • @twatts1523
      @twatts1523 28 днів тому +13

      So true!

    • @janetoconnor3636
      @janetoconnor3636 28 днів тому

      They was no beheading of babies on October 7 that has already been shown and debunked.

    • @scottmcloughlin4371
      @scottmcloughlin4371 28 днів тому

      @@twatts1523 And the 35,000 dead bodies are not "Hamas." And the 17,000 orphans are not "Hamas." The nonstop nonsense online is astounding. Americans want to whine about college students. Why? They can't handle the reality of so many graves.

    • @carlotulio3411
      @carlotulio3411 28 днів тому +7

      So true! 😂

    • @garetroth5683
      @garetroth5683 28 днів тому +11

      They're evil. Say it.

  • @carolinaamado1854
    @carolinaamado1854 28 днів тому +36

    Thank you Briahna. Extremely comprehensive

  • @montanacreed5826
    @montanacreed5826 24 дні тому +1

    "A terrorist is someone who has a bomb, but doesn't have an airforce."
    (William Blum)

  • @jihenfrikha5056
    @jihenfrikha5056 28 днів тому +11

    Bri exposed a lot of taboos in this monologue, precisely about the original sin of this conflict. This is particularly brave. She is admirable.

    • @omahhum82
      @omahhum82 28 днів тому +1

      Taboos? Those dusty talking points have been around liberal circles for decades

    • @jihenfrikha5056
      @jihenfrikha5056 27 днів тому +1

      @@omahhum82 she literally said that Israel doesn't have the right to exist as an ethnostate for Jews only. I didn't expect this to be allowed to be said on The Hill.

    • @omahhum82
      @omahhum82 27 днів тому

      @@jihenfrikha5056 she’s been dancing around it for a while, and I don’t think anybody is surprised. She doesn’t seem to care that the entire Arab world is made of ethno states though

    • @jihenfrikha5056
      @jihenfrikha5056 27 днів тому

      @@omahhum82Arab countries have had a majority of Arab populaton since the beginning of the middle ages. the Zionist project would have worked centuries ago the way orther settler colonial projects worked in north America and Australia etc. Israel was created in the mid 20th century, it's an outdated colonial concept that no longer fits international laws and global human rights. Too bad for then but it's no longer sustainable.

  • @chessman70
    @chessman70 28 днів тому +71

    This situation is horribly depressing me.

    • @wilburhornshnoggle2619
      @wilburhornshnoggle2619 28 днів тому +1

      Turn tv off..

    • @newchild5161
      @newchild5161 28 днів тому +1

      Its fine as humans we disagree all the time

    • @friendoftheforest1736
      @friendoftheforest1736 28 днів тому +10

      That means you are a human. You are already better then every politician that supports this for more campaign funds for their personal re-election.

    • @kindGSL
      @kindGSL 28 днів тому +6

      Me too.

    • @bible1st
      @bible1st 28 днів тому

      Read the Bible. Then your will understand the truth about all of these matters.

  • @BigRobWill
    @BigRobWill 28 днів тому +82

    At this point the producers have to be telling Robbie that he must make a counterargument no matter what because even a blind man could see what Bri stated is undeniable fact.

    • @Lwbxci
      @Lwbxci 28 днів тому +1

      Sometimes feels like the shows premise is like a WWE match where one of them plays the "heel"

    • @leviashanken2506
      @leviashanken2506 28 днів тому +1

      Interesting because Bri did not at all deal with the issue of Hamas (let alone Oct 7) and some of us would like to know what the solution is without their surrender. So I'm grateful that Robbie asked but Bri didn't answer but made that 'I told you so' look into the camera.

    • @spiritof6663
      @spiritof6663 28 днів тому +6

      @@leviashanken2506 It's because the answer to that question has already been given SO many times, that those who are asked for the 50,000th time simply shrug in exasperation as Bri is now doing here. Her and Robby have been over this countless times and for him to act like this is some "gotcha" question is really begging credulity at this point.

    • @leviashanken2506
      @leviashanken2506 28 днів тому

      @@spiritof6663 I know this, I've been watching this for a long time too. But I don't think Robbie presented it as a gotcha but a legitimate question that has not been satisfactorily answered. Surely Bri has repeated her legitimate points many times, too . That's no excuse to trivialize her side or his side.

    • @1Dark.Paradise.Lost1
      @1Dark.Paradise.Lost1 23 дні тому

      There aren't two sides in a genocide ​

  • @McScruffie
    @McScruffie 25 днів тому +4

    Robbie never fails to disappoint.

  • @davelocke
    @davelocke 28 днів тому +4

    Roborob never disapoints.

  • @DSRS320
    @DSRS320 28 днів тому +221

    Israel rejected Hamas agreement for a ceasefire and release of hostages. This was never about the hostages. If is wasn’t clear before it is definitely clear now. Israel has invaded Rafah. Palestinians have no where left to go 💔

    • @Ivan.A.Trulyuski
      @Ivan.A.Trulyuski 28 днів тому +17

      The agreement that leaves Hamas in charge..

    • @skontheroad
      @skontheroad 28 днів тому

      Not what happened. They produced document that did not reflect what was agreed upon, so Israel said NO!
      And thank goodness! They wanted 700 prisoners--criminals!, released in exchange for 132 Hostages!

    • @davelocke
      @davelocke 28 днів тому +7

      @@Ivan.A.Trulyuski and now sacrifices the hostages that were never important in the first place.

    • @liuj88
      @liuj88 28 днів тому +6

      @@Ivan.A.Trulyuski
      As opposed to giving Isr control?

    • @Matt_H_
      @Matt_H_ 28 днів тому +7

      The agreement that would still leave hundreds of hostages in Gaza?

  • @theeedave3372
    @theeedave3372 28 днів тому +86

    One side has the power to control food, water, and electricity into the region. Collective punishment.
    One side receives billions in foreign aid, plus weapons.
    Let's not overcomplicate things

    • @oldskoolbird
      @oldskoolbird 28 днів тому

      Zionists never want to admit to those crystal clear facts.

    • @cosmicbear88-23
      @cosmicbear88-23 28 днів тому

      Gaza has received 4.6 billion in foreign aid and also receives foreign weapons from states like Iran. Why should Israel provide any of those things to a state who wants them destroyed? All that money, they could have provided those things for themselves instead of building missles and tunnels.

    • @elda6973
      @elda6973 28 днів тому +2

      The side that controls the power and water is because the work hard to have a working environment … that’s always been the case …

    • @leviashanken2506
      @leviashanken2506 28 днів тому

      Whereas Hamas receives nothing from impoverished Qatar billionaires.

    • @Celisarei
      @Celisarei 28 днів тому +1

      @@elda6973🤦‍♀️ 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

  • @ln957
    @ln957 26 днів тому +4

    Very well said by Briahna.

  • @0zRevolution
    @0zRevolution 28 днів тому +6

    Robbie being infinitely clueless..
    Doesn't see an aparth*id state as a problem

  • @mekanator108
    @mekanator108 28 днів тому +18

    would Zadie smith tell MLK or Malcolm X that some white people are not racist and that the language they used is hurtful to them?

    • @glbale
      @glbale 28 днів тому +5

      Of course. She would be absolutely consistent.

  • @bwebs25
    @bwebs25 28 днів тому +22

    More people need to hear this monologue.

  • @user-li4xt4pk6e
    @user-li4xt4pk6e 28 днів тому +4

    straight to the point Briahna

  • @wfo8023
    @wfo8023 28 днів тому +4

    Brie right as usual

  • @insidertrading1
    @insidertrading1 28 днів тому +28

    The issue isn't Hamas. The West bank is just as targeted and there's no Hamas there. As if you'd lay down and accept if someone forcibly removed you from a home your grand-parents paid off and left to you? You wouldn't surrender! Robby is pro-govt when it suits him. He has no issue with the Israeli govt infringing on the rights of people it wasn't even elected to govern

    • @omahhum82
      @omahhum82 28 днів тому

      The Jews accepted it when they were literally given 24 hour notice by Egypt, Syria, Tunisia, Iraq and the list goes on

    • @aaronhyik346
      @aaronhyik346 28 днів тому

      ​@@omahhum82in your eyes was that bad to do or is it justified?

    • @omahhum82
      @omahhum82 28 днів тому

      @@aaronhyik346 it was bad, but what you don’t understand is that Israelis are not in the “if it’s not fair than don’t do it to others” game. That’s a liberal game that one can afford playing when their survival as people is not on the line. They are about survival, having realized they are unsafe anywhere else in the world.

    • @aaronhyik346
      @aaronhyik346 28 днів тому

      @@omahhum82 there are more than 6 million jews in the US they are safe here not counting the jews in Europe and around the world that is not a justification to steal and m0rder thousands of innocent civilians just so they can have a land, if its bad when is done to the jews is bad when done by the Jews. Sorry but the truth is the truth

    • @sampats89
      @sampats89 27 днів тому

      ​@@omahhum82 funny how everyone was welcome until Israel's foundation

  • @jujutrini8412
    @jujutrini8412 28 днів тому +34

    Robby clearly believes that ethno states are moral. If the USA passed a bill saying that the USA is an ethno state now he’d be saying to Bri “well it’s the law now. That’s it! We just have to live with it. Well I do. You have to go elsewhere!”

    • @timcardona9962
      @timcardona9962 28 днів тому +1

      Nice try but Ethno-states do not have people of different ethnicities serving in govt.

    • @skycryztals
      @skycryztals 28 днів тому +2

      @@timcardona9962 That's the point. Rob would be ok with kicking Bri to the curb if he was legally allowed to. Ethics and morality are a second thought in his mind.

  • @retror.d.1630
    @retror.d.1630 28 днів тому +31

    Robby is so outclassed by Brianna. He is so narrow minded compared to her deep interpretation of Palestine and Israel

    • @leviashanken2506
      @leviashanken2506 28 днів тому +4

      Well he certainly is out-spoken by her, if that's what her class and depth are.

    • @user-cg1qq2er8x
      @user-cg1qq2er8x 27 днів тому

      you are a bot, right?

  • @racfat1
    @racfat1 28 днів тому +3

    Bri.. love you
    Free palestine
    Free america from zionism

  • @Lovely-1999
    @Lovely-1999 28 днів тому +12

    Brihana you’re great♥️

  • @traviscutler9912
    @traviscutler9912 28 днів тому +26

    When you stop giving a s#!+ if you get fired.
    Good job Bri, rub their noses in the truth.

  • @RasenieReggieBless717
    @RasenieReggieBless717 28 днів тому +6

    Queen You said its like its is. 😢 It is not complicated Greed, make, it seems like it complicated to you.because you want its all

  • @williammorris3815
    @williammorris3815 28 днів тому +94

    Why is Robbie pro Israel?

    • @twatts1523
      @twatts1523 28 днів тому

      White supremacy?

    • @JoeBeThere
      @JoeBeThere 28 днів тому +34

      Because that’s his job

    • @kingsolstemp
      @kingsolstemp 28 днів тому +14

      He shares their sentiments.

    • @elviajove8289
      @elviajove8289 28 днів тому +46

      He has no humanity, much less compassion.

    • @joannapplewhite128
      @joannapplewhite128 28 днів тому +28

      Doesn’t want to be attacked by the Lobby

  • @j_r_junior
    @j_r_junior 28 днів тому +16

    Was just planning on starting Zadie Smith’s On Beauty-guess I’ll be skipping that one in the queue. Shame on Smith

    • @rworded1
      @rworded1 28 днів тому

      She's a great writer. I understand (and share) your disgust over her latest apologia for Zionism, but you're missing out if you skip "White Teeth."

    • @Ccats231
      @Ccats231 28 днів тому +1

      @@rworded1meh

    • @rworded1
      @rworded1 28 днів тому

      @@Ccats231 Oh, c'mon... It was a fun read.

  • @AK-np4rp
    @AK-np4rp 26 днів тому +1

    Anyone who thinks it is complicated is not educated on the matter.

  • @glennwooten8361
    @glennwooten8361 23 дні тому +1

    It was refreshing to hear Briahna make her point without being interrupted every other word. I hope the toothless world court doesn't get paid off to look the other way again from this genocide.

  • @user-cb9mk9sm3b
    @user-cb9mk9sm3b 28 днів тому +20

    How would Robby feel if he was kicked out of his home and his land stolen by a bunch of foreigners forming their own ethno state??

    • @jpah8944
      @jpah8944 28 днів тому

      Palestine is the ethno-state. Israel has ten times more diversity than Palestine.

  • @Popkulture818
    @Popkulture818 28 днів тому +12

    Love you Bri

  • @jessicawelch6771
    @jessicawelch6771 25 днів тому +2

    Thank you for always speaking truth even when they try to corner you in. I LOVE listening to your reporting

  • @polyguns
    @polyguns 28 днів тому +3

    Bris face when Robbie says they are fighting till hamas gives up. She hated that point.

    • @JoeBeThere
      @JoeBeThere 28 днів тому

      Because it’s an illogical argument. It’s like saying the IDF must cease to be tomorrow. It’s not ever going to happen. It’s like saying that the U.S. will recognize Palestine when all the Israelis go back to where they came from. Not going to happen. Pie in the sky

  • @JohnFelinn
    @JohnFelinn 28 днів тому +54

    “Zionism is a genocidal ideology”, “It should be dismantled and destroyed “, Professor David Miller, formerly at Bristol University, in comments made in 2024, based on his academic research. Larry Johnson, former CIA analyst described Israel’s genocide on Gaza like the “Nazis when they entered Eastern Europe “.

    • @justinfleming5119
      @justinfleming5119 28 днів тому

      When the Germans invaded Eastern Europe, they liberated nations from Bolshevik terror.

    • @fritznovak4482
      @fritznovak4482 26 днів тому

      Hamas has more in common with the nazis than Israel does.

  • @mohammadraihan8078
    @mohammadraihan8078 28 днів тому +13

    Even Likud party charter says Between the sea and the Jordan there will only be Israeli sovereignty and how that is not anti-Semitic.

  • @akhilleus12
    @akhilleus12 28 днів тому +3

    How does Robby show his face in public?

  • @usamashabibi215
    @usamashabibi215 28 днів тому +3

    Robbie suggests that the US should not be involved but he immediately involves himself by saying Hamas is to blame as if the Palestinians have not been brutalised for decades before Oct 7.

  • @SteStarI718
    @SteStarI718 28 днів тому +7

    Excellent Bri. Such a great detailed analysis explanation with full context of the what & why

  • @Edward3DFX
    @Edward3DFX 28 днів тому +7

    So well put ! Thank you Bri -

  • @Liyaxs
    @Liyaxs 28 днів тому +3

    maybe to Robbie it’s “complicated” but not to the rest of us

    • @JoeBeThere
      @JoeBeThere 28 днів тому

      Ilan Pape has said the greatest piece of propaganda Israel has ever created was saying the situation is complicated. It’s not

  • @TheChase008
    @TheChase008 27 днів тому +2

    Why does Briahna have to resort to sitting there with a child like pouty face while Robby makes his point. It is a discussion. She seems to think that her argument is so compelling that there is no way for anyone to push back. Unfortunately for her there is.

  • @oliviamomich9214
    @oliviamomich9214 28 днів тому +8

    Brie👏🏻🔥

  • @lameru32
    @lameru32 28 днів тому +10

    Briahna: Great job. People share your frustration with the blindspot in others.

  • @EyeGotSoul
    @EyeGotSoul 27 днів тому +2

    The truth sounds like hate to those who hate the truth

  • @jlpowell51
    @jlpowell51 28 днів тому +2

    It seems like some sort of double-standard when people use the term "zionism" as a negative thing while also trying to demand that Palestinians be provided a state of their own. I don't see how you can justify arbitrarily creating a state for one without also being OK with a state being created for the other.

    • @JoeBeThere
      @JoeBeThere 28 днів тому

      Palestinians want self determination, the Israelis want ethnic cleansing. It’s against the Geneva Convention, which Israel has signed and pledged to abide by and uphold. They have not, and it’s clear they have been talking out of both sides of their mouths for generations. History has proven this again and again. If you can’t see the distinction, it’s pitiful

  • @robws007
    @robws007 28 днів тому +18

    Briahna is 100% correct!

  • @Whatsacrakin
    @Whatsacrakin 28 днів тому +15

    Robby has no humanity and it shows , Bri keep up the fight 🙌🏽

  • @richardlanahan8089
    @richardlanahan8089 28 днів тому +10

    How many thousands are working right now to try to get this young woman removed. Maybe it is tens of thousands. Frightening but you know that this is true.

    • @mwecker
      @mwecker 27 днів тому

      She needs to remember her job is supposedly as a journalist. She continues to represent herself as a Hamas' defense lawyer.
      She doesn't belong in journalism, she belongs on The View.

    • @richardlanahan8089
      @richardlanahan8089 27 днів тому +1

      @@mwecker Anti -genocide is not pro-Palestine. One thousand eyes for an eye. One thousand teeth for a tooth etc. Same as forever. "My babies are better than your babies." There is no defense for genocide. I feel I have seen this before in history, say 80-85 years ago. She is smarter than all of those on the View together. This is an example of how to define what racism in practice looks like.

    • @scottphipps2278
      @scottphipps2278 23 дні тому +1

      ​@@mwecker
      THE Israelis founded Hamas
      Bri speaks well she knows her stuff

  • @radman0728
    @radman0728 28 днів тому +34

    Robby is a WASTE!

    • @adinahaun6001
      @adinahaun6001 28 днів тому +5

      Is he bought off? Seems like it.

    • @Johnny-rj9on
      @Johnny-rj9on 28 днів тому +4

      @@adinahaun6001 Brainwashed, but I bet the money doesn't hurt

  • @gbalstad
    @gbalstad 28 днів тому +5

    TRUTH

  • @bibulousape
    @bibulousape 26 днів тому +1

    I would like to know how a group can be determined to be "terrorists" when they operate in an area in which international law is not applied?

  • @ikmaxi
    @ikmaxi 28 днів тому +1

    Thank you for your humanity, Brie! God bless and protect you!

  • @chessman70
    @chessman70 28 днів тому +4

    Epic on point dialogue Briahna.

  • @gabbyandmrb
    @gabbyandmrb 28 днів тому +10

    Powerful monologue Brie❤

  • @annaordoubadi1858
    @annaordoubadi1858 21 день тому +1

    He’s is just so simple minded, but your brilliance makes his ignorance more bearable. Excellent piece, Brianna!

  • @richardwilliams9944
    @richardwilliams9944 24 дні тому +1

    Many Jewish students are protesting the genocide as well. They clearly do not feel threatened

  • @mkn.567
    @mkn.567 28 днів тому +30

    Take your money out of HSBC, Citibank, Barclays, and Chase. These banks have branches and do business in israel. Santander also invests in israeli tech. Put your money in credit unions or local, independent banks. Local banks pay taxes that directly benefit the communities they are in. Your outrage doesn't matter, your protests don't matter. Only your money matters.

    • @chrismorris8847
      @chrismorris8847 28 днів тому +3

      No

    • @davidsomeone6839
      @davidsomeone6839 28 днів тому +1

      what about banks that work with Saudia Arabia? Wait, you don't care what they are doing to Yeminis care of U.S. backing? By the same updated definition of genocide ... that is a genocide. Why is this battle so near and dear to your heart? OR, What about banks here that deal with our govt that did crazy stuff in Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan and Somalia? .... Hmmm ... so, essentially you would have to keep cash on hand. GTFOH

    • @omahhum82
      @omahhum82 28 днів тому

      @@chrismorris8847 I don’t know you, but I love you

    • @chrismorris8847
      @chrismorris8847 27 днів тому

      @@omahhum82 OK then.

  • @joshuarubin3684
    @joshuarubin3684 28 днів тому +5

    Is there a political term for believing in the existence of any other UN recognized country?