GST On Popcorns?: Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman Clarifies | NDTV Profit

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 439

  • @anon-zk6iz
    @anon-zk6iz 5 днів тому +388

    Taxes like the UK, infrastructure and services like Somalia. Welcome to Bharat!

    • @prabhusankar8346
      @prabhusankar8346 5 днів тому +12

      Even UK doesn't have such Tax system 😂

    • @rakshathshetty6754
      @rakshathshetty6754 5 днів тому

      with out taxes how exactly will govt build infra?

    • @prabhusankar8346
      @prabhusankar8346 5 днів тому +16

      @@rakshathshetty6754 With so much of tax money what did they do till now in infra ?

    • @SDFNI3894YR
      @SDFNI3894YR 4 дні тому

      same old copy paste.

    • @Einstein_rocks
      @Einstein_rocks 4 дні тому +5

      ​@@rakshathshetty6754
      Go find how other countries did ......
      Increase exports not taxes

  • @parvadhami980
    @parvadhami980 5 днів тому +327

    Water in well: 5%
    Water in Pot: 12%
    Water in Bottle: 18%
    Water in Fridge: 28%

    • @vina4385
      @vina4385 5 днів тому +27

      Toilet 50% gst

    • @prabhusankar8346
      @prabhusankar8346 5 днів тому

      ​@@vina4385😂😂

    • @saroshvarghese362
      @saroshvarghese362 5 днів тому

      🤣🤣🤣

    • @TheVijaygan
      @TheVijaygan 5 днів тому

      Any water 53% GST irrespective of above taxes mentioned

    • @lakshmaninside
      @lakshmaninside 5 днів тому +2

      Water in Soda bottle 100% as it is used with alcohol for dilution 😅😅😅😅

  • @naveenv023
    @naveenv023 5 днів тому +191

    She can single handedly bring BJP down in next elections.

    • @premavathyammalleela6228
      @premavathyammalleela6228 5 днів тому +26

      True. Now I feel not voting for BJP.

    • @clove2947
      @clove2947 5 днів тому +25

      BJP has always been down undyingly...dw! They came to power because of the andhabhakths of this country!

    • @clove2947
      @clove2947 5 днів тому +8

      BJP has always been down undyingly...dw! They came to power because of the andhabhakths of this country!

    • @ShivanshThakur-sh8ub
      @ShivanshThakur-sh8ub 5 днів тому

      ​​@@clove2947 burnol x 3.

    • @om7799
      @om7799 5 днів тому +4

      ​@@clove2947 dude chill! How crazy are you to write 3 same comments.

  • @ConsiderateZED
    @ConsiderateZED 5 днів тому +128

    Truly GOAT FIN Minister......No need of war or Pakistan or China ..She will take care of Bharat till the END...😅

  • @beautykingdom5629
    @beautykingdom5629 5 днів тому +200

    They are seriously crazy. No hope for financial reforms. If finance minister of 4th largest economy in the world is busy discussing popcorn there is nothing to say😂

    • @SDFNI3894YR
      @SDFNI3894YR 4 дні тому +2

      lol. its actually a good thing they are they discussing popcorn and toilet paper. it shows government is keeping a deeper outlook. and not just shallow. the effect of popcorn tax is that 400 rs popcorn will still remain 400, but theatre owners will pay more tax. bcoz they know if price is increased more, people won't buy. Government is not foolish.

    • @Pranav_Youtube_Reddit
      @Pranav_Youtube_Reddit 4 дні тому +1

      i think PVR waale bohot kamaa rahe hai, isliye.

    • @tanaya1717
      @tanaya1717 День тому

      Seriously, kabhi progress hone hi nai denge... Buss poverty leke arey he ye india may... Bussiness growth, education, jobs, pe dhyaan de... Education itna mehnga kar rakha.. Bussiness growth hone ni dete.. Na jobs...

  • @MaxLogan-wu2xw
    @MaxLogan-wu2xw 5 днів тому +209

    Butter chicken without butter 18% GST. Butter chicken with butter 30% GST. Butter chicken with Butter and Chicken 50% GST. Empty box of butter chicken 10% GST only.

  • @musicadmire-1999
    @musicadmire-1999 5 днів тому +83

    Next time they will put gst on normal birth and c section too.

    • @musicadmire-1999
      @musicadmire-1999 3 дні тому

      @tk-ld5cd If the person is not present, who will pay.
      Indians do not pay for themselves and do not expect it.

    • @goodminion9320
      @goodminion9320 2 дні тому

      Don’t give this woman ideas

    • @rotihalwa586
      @rotihalwa586 2 дні тому

      LMAOOOOOOOO​@@goodminion9320

  • @khalilbaig1759
    @khalilbaig1759 5 днів тому +59

    Inhaling Oxigen GST - 50%
    Exhaling Carbon dioxide GST - 50%

    • @jzjzjzbz
      @jzjzjzbz 2 дні тому +2

      😂😂😂😂😂 basic needs

  • @sanketnandurkar4535
    @sanketnandurkar4535 5 днів тому +75

    28% GST on FM if failed to deliver the economic growth 🤔🤐

  • @marajat1
    @marajat1 5 днів тому +29

    People with Diabetes ( Sugar) would be the next to be charged extra 10% GST, "because sugar aur sugar walo ko alag se treat kiya jata hai".

  • @divyomchauhan9253
    @divyomchauhan9253 5 днів тому +79

    They should really dismiss her

    • @prakashraj8298
      @prakashraj8298 5 днів тому +10

      Who will dismiss her. Unfortunately all are like her. Birds of same feather flock together.

    • @dv9239
      @dv9239 День тому

      It's them talking through her
      You think she comes up with these taxes?

  • @stoic2857
    @stoic2857 5 днів тому +31

    This woman is by far the most delusional cabinet minister we have right now. Zero dialogue between the people and our ministers.

  • @SMCGPRA
    @SMCGPRA 5 днів тому +31

    Simply irrational taxes still not refunding taxes this lady is worst fm

  • @suresht.r261
    @suresht.r261 5 днів тому +18

    Useless minister in BJP 😅

  • @vivekra
    @vivekra 5 днів тому +20

    But sugar is Rs 50 per kg. If it is so bad, tax that heavily. Why have sugar in tea. Tax tea with sugar also.

  • @DoIt-e3l
    @DoIt-e3l 5 днів тому +20

    These are our world class politicians.
    Only God can save us.
    We are so lucky to have you as our finance minister.
    🍿 🍿 🍿 🍿 🍿 🍿 🍿 🍿 🍿 🍿 🍿.
    Popcorn ,popcorn
    Hai reh popcorn.

  • @vasanthbhat3453
    @vasanthbhat3453 5 днів тому +8

    India shortly becoming 4th or 3rd world econony, but still it is not able to provide pure drinking water to common man. Even though it is taxing 18 pct on mineral water!

  • @Mathew-k9k
    @Mathew-k9k 5 днів тому +22

    This lady is very silly

  • @perathuselvi861
    @perathuselvi861 5 днів тому +13

    Declared tax war against middle class people.such time decrease the expenses save the money.otherwise life is dangerous

  • @dgangadhar6574
    @dgangadhar6574 5 днів тому +6

    With this kind of huge taxes india will become 1st largest economy.
    Tax on pop corn seeds
    Tax on fertilizer used on popcorn field
    Tax on popcorn seeds yield
    Tax on farmers for selling popcorn grains
    Tax on popcorn grains buyer
    Tax on popcorn grain distributor
    Tax on popcorn grain for selling in retail store, wholesale markets
    Tax on popcorn grains for processing like salted, caramelized..etc
    Tax on consumer for buying finished popcorn
    Tax on seller for selling to customer.

  • @koteswarraokolluru6969
    @koteswarraokolluru6969 3 дні тому +8

    People criticized collecting tax from Gukesh winning money.
    now she is taking revenge

  • @maulaalichennur589
    @maulaalichennur589 5 днів тому +15

    Next Gst on hair cut.

    • @sri-6374
      @sri-6374 3 дні тому +1

      Ohh no if she sees this that's gonna happen too lol

    • @maybeiamabrownie2471
      @maybeiamabrownie2471 День тому

      with the way things have been going doesn't seem too improbable

  • @The_EastCoast_Couple
    @The_EastCoast_Couple 4 дні тому +5

    Eating popcorn is luxury,
    Buying a car, a home are dream of every middle class. But if you want them you have to stop eating caramel popcorn

  • @MAXBRANEY
    @MAXBRANEY 5 днів тому +11

    Oxygen in delhi 0%
    Oxygen in other parts of state 60%

  • @sravanbharathi5765
    @sravanbharathi5765 5 днів тому +15

    Plz charge 250% gst on popcorn,, and food in movie theaters 👍👍👍👍👍👍 truly

  • @lahomelo4518
    @lahomelo4518 5 днів тому +30

    Chai mein sugar usmey bi tax Q nahi leta😂

    • @Biologygrasp
      @Biologygrasp 5 днів тому +4

      Please Keep Calm bro 😢

    • @garalamunormal5316
      @garalamunormal5316 5 днів тому +4

      @@Biologygrasp 100 percent true. if she listen then she will charge 18% GST on each tea served in kaakaa hotels also

    • @pks001
      @pks001 5 днів тому +1

      😂😂😂

  • @KVR8527
    @KVR8527 5 днів тому +11

    She is a funny character. Does not understand anything about tax. Her husband tells it correctly how foolish she is 😢. One, nation One tax. But its a gumla. Every piece on an article has departe tax
    Pushing responsibility to states😂😂😂

  • @Itz_me_youtube_owner
    @Itz_me_youtube_owner 3 дні тому +14

    She not finance minister she is collection queen 😂

  • @Therealweirdo
    @Therealweirdo 2 дні тому +4

    One day Indians will realise British were good 😂😂😂😂

  • @The_EastCoast_Couple
    @The_EastCoast_Couple 4 дні тому +7

    How to become economic superpower.?
    Lower class, middle class life improvement =❎
    By imposing more taxes =✅

  • @owls077
    @owls077 4 дні тому +4

    FM would say I don't eat popcorn 😂

  • @altudtaltu3922
    @altudtaltu3922 5 днів тому +4

    5 Minutes talk 3% GST
    10 Minutes talk 5% GST
    5 Minutes silent 12% GST
    Next New Digital India

  • @SuperAsakho
    @SuperAsakho 5 днів тому +20

    In Manipur people are dying everyday because of incapable and incompetent Government.
    Look at our Finance Minister talking about taxing Popcorn.
    Double Standard and insensitive.

  • @aratighodke8720
    @aratighodke8720 3 дні тому +5

    Ma’am we middle class people are breathing so please uspar bhi GST lelo jiske nostrils chhote usase 5% GST, jiske nostrils bade usase 18% GST lelo itna bhi daya kyun kar rahe ho

  • @ravic4768
    @ravic4768 5 днів тому +9

    Bcoz of this minister only BJP loosing seats

    • @atulkumar-lm7cg
      @atulkumar-lm7cg 4 дні тому

      nope she is the reason behind BJP's victory , looting middle class and distributing freebies to get votes

    • @Mannu_Maanu
      @Mannu_Maanu 2 дні тому

      Modi is behind her stupidity 😅

  • @itsmovies24
    @itsmovies24 4 дні тому +4

    India's economy is slowing down, and the middle class is facing significant challenges, largely due to toxic tax policies; while Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman bears substantial responsibility, the entire central government, including Prime Minister Narendra Modi under whose leadership the finance ministry operates, is equally accountable.

  • @narayanaswamys8786
    @narayanaswamys8786 5 днів тому +16

    How much GST for using electrical cremitorium?

  • @dhanasampathn311
    @dhanasampathn311 5 днів тому +5

    When we have a Useless Finance Minister the Popcorn, Which is a Food item also will become a Big Debate.😅

  • @psathya7619
    @psathya7619 5 днів тому +4

    For this nonsence only we need changed Govt.therr is no any balance products in India' to put GST sorry Modiji Jai Shri Ram

  • @SouravPlaysOff
    @SouravPlaysOff 5 днів тому +6

    Am i watching some pakistani news channel? Are we literally watching tax on popcorn? And people are debating on it? 😭😭

  • @whatsappstatuslover2613
    @whatsappstatuslover2613 3 дні тому +3

    Dear Minister just because middle class is silent don’t think you can do whatever you want once ppl come on roads you will not even stand a chance to live in this country

  • @shivkapoor426
    @shivkapoor426 2 дні тому +5

    Golgappe 5%GST
    Meethi papri 18%GST

  • @HaizuHashu
    @HaizuHashu 5 днів тому +6

    Worst fm😂

  • @MadhuHV
    @MadhuHV 5 днів тому +4

    I took 5100rs car insurance, i paid more than 920 as GST, i can do many things with 900 rs , why government is sucking middle class people blood. They do all improvements with public money but later they tell Modi did it.

  • @pushpakumardaniel3751
    @pushpakumardaniel3751 5 днів тому +5

    It is a shameful disgrace for any government in India to tax food. This tax money is simply wasted. Only a government that is 🤬😡🤐 will tax food!

  • @rishabh7918
    @rishabh7918 3 дні тому +4

    Will you tax your corrupt officials,ministers, and businessmen?

  • @sibi2k4
    @sibi2k4 5 днів тому +5

    See the wealth of all politicians. Only they are the richest in india. No benefits for the common man.

  • @YashLodhaDream
    @YashLodhaDream 3 дні тому +5

    Plz make petrol diesel under gst...

  • @SardarKhan-gp2jc
    @SardarKhan-gp2jc 5 днів тому +3

    Next discussion bore water + tea powder= GST different, packed bottel water + tea powder= GST different, water+ packet milk different gst, water + tea powder+ milk different Gst, water + milk + tea powder+ sugar different Gst, if packed sugar used different GST, if milk directly purchase from milk man it's different GST evry Indian should know GST rules before purchase or eating

  • @stephentk3413
    @stephentk3413 5 днів тому +4

    We will be made to pay GST for the air(oxigen) we breath.. Horrible - really horrible administration😢

  • @popesk.k1254
    @popesk.k1254 5 днів тому +6

    All this stupidity

  • @rashmidas07
    @rashmidas07 3 дні тому +3

    You should apply 15% Gst on Living because we indians eat a hell lot of sugar -- freaking sugar💰

  • @sridharthumiki7755
    @sridharthumiki7755 4 дні тому +2

    There should be tax on the winter wear because you are safe from cold.God save us.

  • @skzonevlogs1358
    @skzonevlogs1358 3 дні тому +2

    Anything left for tax pls do it quick madam... So we can be relief😌

  • @Nagesh_Reddy
    @Nagesh_Reddy 2 дні тому +3

    25 % GST if you get white hair and 0% GST if you maintain black hair

    • @shankar837640
      @shankar837640 2 дні тому

      Already 18 percent gst for hair dye

    • @Nagesh_Reddy
      @Nagesh_Reddy 2 дні тому +1

      @shankar837640 haa she may increase that to 25%😀

  • @venkataramananrengan1913
    @venkataramananrengan1913 5 днів тому +6

    When we will get rid of this arrogance. Treating every one else as idiots. Only a handful got exempted. Adhani ji, ambani ji like

  • @abhina0101
    @abhina0101 5 днів тому +2

    Wish my Central Government would become "AATMA-NIRBHAR" first then......and not to depend on TAX for revenue.

  • @shadabreshi1764
    @shadabreshi1764 5 днів тому +3

    Only feaces and urea is tax free please make a policy on it when a person goes for 10 times the 18% rest 10%

  • @VarunKhanna-i8b
    @VarunKhanna-i8b 3 дні тому +3

    I’m from Gujarat yaha daal me bhi Sugar hota hai 😂😂

  • @akhilprasad7272
    @akhilprasad7272 5 днів тому +10

    GSt taken serious on a popcorn to build next statue

  • @ankitmishra55773
    @ankitmishra55773 3 дні тому +3

    So if someone buys mix popcorn at pvr how will it be taxed?? 😂😂 Talentless govt ...she will go down as the dumbest finance minister

  • @rk4755
    @rk4755 3 дні тому +2

    Next council agenda - how to classify salt / sugar / caramel Pani-puri 😊😊! Non important decisions like health insurance etc can wait

  • @Ilovemyworld723
    @Ilovemyworld723 3 дні тому +3

    Soon there will be taxes in breathing too

  • @9605643453
    @9605643453 2 дні тому +2

    Worst minister,, madam all people are not amabanis,,,, have u ever tried for increasing wages and salaries of youngsters according to market inflation,,, shame on u

  • @SVSR9999
    @SVSR9999 4 дні тому +2

    No discussion on 55 th GST Council meeting allowing exemption on Bun, and with Butter & jam 😄

  • @Ramita111
    @Ramita111 3 дні тому +2

    अब बस सांस लेने पर जीएसटी बाकी है, वो भी बजट में लगा दीजिएगा 😅

  • @janardanshigawan9165
    @janardanshigawan9165 4 дні тому +2

    Worst finance minister ever for the middle class people of India

  • @scout4430wonder
    @scout4430wonder 5 днів тому +5

    Give this woman some really work…. Send in the local market to shop…. Idiotic

  • @modela6301
    @modela6301 5 днів тому +1

    Worst FM of india!!! All i can say is madam "1 Large popcorn hi dedo ab"😂

  • @pcgame03
    @pcgame03 День тому +1

    Wow that’s great news for Indians.
    Hope next will be on
    tea, coffee based on with sugar and without sugar.
    plain rice or ghee rice, based on its flavour.
    Kushka or biryani again based on flavour.
    Plain rice or with samber again on flavour.
    Veg or nonveg based on type of dish.
    If Chinese/american food means then 100% gst.
    Loot looooo humko, will keep on paying tax till we die and we won’t save anything.
    If we get salary we need to pay income tax.
    If we buy anything after salary, we need to pay with gst.
    If we import export anything then again we need to pay import / export duty with gst.
    If we take loan / personal loan then also need to pay with gst.
    If I buy any vehicle need to pay with gst.
    If I buy gold or silver for home that too with gst.
    After all these what security you are providing to tax payer.
    How much tax / gst you want to collect from one salaried person at last.

  • @desiyaaro1137
    @desiyaaro1137 3 дні тому +2

    Get her some popcorn

  • @nagireddyramasamy2619
    @nagireddyramasamy2619 5 днів тому +5

    Day by day middle class people are suffering. We want Modiji, Amitshah, but because of this finance minister regional leaders are getting popular support. Honble Modiji is requested to replace her..Middle class Suffering much ,much day to day.

    • @sanjaymore221
      @sanjaymore221 2 дні тому

      She is appointed by Modi .Gangadhar hi Shaktimaan hai

  • @rrbjealp
    @rrbjealp 5 днів тому +3

    Oxigen 28%
    Corbon di oxide 28%😅

  • @JanardhanaRoaC
    @JanardhanaRoaC 5 днів тому +1

    Direct tax on every separate item in India. Second time indirect GST.
    మన ఇండియా మూడుపూవులు ఆరుకాయలుగా వెలిగిపోవటమంటే ఇదేనేమో కదా!!

  • @Indian67
    @Indian67 5 днів тому +1

    Popcorn's tax , she found multi millions product 😂😂😂😂

  • @bejoyjoseh8396
    @bejoyjoseh8396 5 днів тому +3

    😂😂😂😂 what a pitty 🥺🥺🥺what she is trying to do.... Or trying to say 🤣🤣🤣🤣 minister for kitchen 🙏

  • @kingofkings4184
    @kingofkings4184 5 днів тому +2

    G. Garib ki
    S Saja hai
    T Tax🥺

  • @Sahilkumar-l7i6z
    @Sahilkumar-l7i6z День тому +2

    Dusre desho me baate hoti hai ki mangal grah me kaise jaye ye sub aur india me popcorn par gst lagane ki baate hoti hai wahh good

  • @HA-rl4fz
    @HA-rl4fz 4 дні тому +1

    Gst on shitting in indian closet : 2.5%
    Gst on shitting in European closet : 18%
    Coming soon !!!!
    Public : why shitting in European closets so costly?
    FM: I dont give a shit

  • @bhavanapkumar1638
    @bhavanapkumar1638 5 днів тому +3

    GST committee consists of State Govt say…aim is to extract more money from people!

  • @ProudKannadigaa
    @ProudKannadigaa 3 дні тому

    Yes, you did it correct Madam. You should impose 150% GST so that people will be so happy to buy the Popcorn 🍿.

  • @musicadmire-1999
    @musicadmire-1999 5 днів тому +1

    They are literally telling us not eat popcorn.

  • @brk922
    @brk922 2 дні тому

    GST was such wonderful concept. This govt. simply made mockery of it.

  • @j3cosmos
    @j3cosmos 2 дні тому

    If only she explains how the tax money is spent in such a simplified manner

  • @Moto_Life15
    @Moto_Life15 3 дні тому

    The sellers can cut that 1st 20sec and use it for advertising popcorn😂

  • @gauravchauhan.95
    @gauravchauhan.95 2 дні тому +1

    Now I am against women empowerment.

  • @SoumyaSekhar-m4f
    @SoumyaSekhar-m4f 5 днів тому +1

    Her Brain is also like Popcorn🍿

  • @sameelshamnad6142
    @sameelshamnad6142 5 днів тому +1

    Theatre and other entertainment went silent after this decision took place

  • @prescyljosie4636
    @prescyljosie4636 5 днів тому +2

    Collect so much gst ,tax and still GDP is still in 5.4% shame on u

  • @prashantchaturvedi9385
    @prashantchaturvedi9385 5 днів тому +1

    Itna he serious discussion medical system pe bhe krna chahea

  • @neerajsprem
    @neerajsprem День тому

    I’m seeing for the first time a minister talking about GST on popcorn 😂

  • @starktime3476
    @starktime3476 5 днів тому +4

    so if i have a regular popcorn without salt or caramel then my price is regular so why cant be the tax also same ? 💀and also the finance minister should discuss about finacial problems and to reduce tax for middle class people and control economical condition of India only not this bullshit examples!

  • @debasmitapati5603
    @debasmitapati5603 2 дні тому +1

    Wah Wah, What a logic..shame on you.

  • @rajfacts6167
    @rajfacts6167 2 дні тому +1

    I did a big mistake for voting BJP.😢

  • @RKV8527
    @RKV8527 4 дні тому +1

    Nirmala Sitaraman is anti-middle class anti-pensioners and anti-senior citizens. An old tactic is to form committees and defer the decisions that are frequently adopted to deny benefits of CRUEL GST on Health Insurance. Her husband is right that she does not understand GST. Tax on Bread butter salted butter popcorn masala popcorn etc is funny.
    Corporates pay 25% tax and clap for Modi and praise Modi. But they have no confidence in Modi to make private investments. Nirmala Sitaraman FM is talking at length about popcorn Shame

  • @adityakaranje2672
    @adityakaranje2672 4 дні тому +1

    Teekha pani puri:-5%
    Meethi pani puri:-18%

    • @ahsaanali5192
      @ahsaanali5192 3 дні тому

      Shukr hai mujhe meetha pasand nhi😂

  • @NazninazanDervish
    @NazninazanDervish 5 днів тому +1

    Inefficient but arrogance has no bounds

  • @tarunbhuckal5012
    @tarunbhuckal5012 3 дні тому +1

    Nirmala sitaraman is TAX Minister of Bharat.

  • @rajasdoshi1234
    @rajasdoshi1234 5 днів тому +1

    Why can't government just stop taxing eatables?

  • @gr894
    @gr894 2 дні тому

    Finance minister just want to see growth by increasing taxes and interest rates,not by improving production /products & services..
    Rediculus