Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Looking Back as We Look Forward ~ Dr. Yasir Qadhi | 7th December 2013 - Change & Modernity
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 гру 2013
- Not all change is bad - sometimes you must change in order to survive.
In this highly controversial and paradigm-shifting talk, Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi challenges us to think about change within 'Islam' - not the 'Islam' that is unchangeable, but the opinions of scholars who interpret the texts of Islam and think it is 'Islam'.
Our history has plenty of lessons for us to learn from, and modern challenges require fresh thought. There are, as always, extremes in our Ummah: those who want to change everything and make the haram into halal, and those who do not understand that the Shariah allows for some change and fresh ideas.
This is a talk not to be missed!
IlmFest 2013 Detroit Michigan - AlMaghrib Institue
The Rise & Fall of the Muslim Ummah and the Printing Press: • The Rise & Fall of the...
Challenges of Modernity for the Muslim Family: • Challenges of Modernit...
Innovation & Bid'ah in Islam | Challenges in Modernity | Is Coffee an intoxicant Halal or Haram | Fatwa on new ideas | Western Scholars | Schools of thought | Hanafi Shafi'i Maliki Hanbali | Salafi Sufi Tarika Deobandi | Muslim Ummah | Western Musims | Shisha Hookah | MBC Serial on Omar ibn Khattab | Saudi Arabic Government | Al-Azhar University | Madinah University |
Our Ummah is in need of more such lectures. May Allah azza wajal preserve scholars like Sheikh Yasir Qadhi and others...
I can't take it anymore i'm.going to repent today become a good Muslim! Become a servant of God! This lecture got me. u don't know why but it did and it got me thinking! I want to be like just like Yasir Qadhi!
الله يوفقك اخي بدربك
This is a fantastic and refreshing talk. It reminds me of the statement "Don't let the clarity of the text blind you from the complexity of the context" - SM Hasan al-Banna
May Allah increase Sheik Yasir Qadhi’s life span. He gave me free knowledge. Last three years there’s a day that I don’t take one or two of his lectures. I finished thr seerah twice 104 episodes. Alhamdulilah
Extremely eye opening. Watching this in 2024
I wish we have more sheikhs like him, ameeeeeeen.
100%
This reminds how much unity will empowerment Muslim ummah..so much khair ❤
Putting Islam in context--- such a good lecture!
Knowledgeable and forward thinking sheikh. This kind of sheikh is what our ummah need. May allah reward you Sheikh Yasir Qadhi
And here I am having my morning coffee as I watch this wonderful lecture
Amazing lecture from an excellent scholar of our time Masha Allah.
Such a good lecture!! Love Sh Qadhi!!
As-Salaam Alaikum ☪️ i really learn so much listening in on your lectures. May Allah continue to give you strength to help us all who has ears to hear. Allah Hafiz 🛐
Jazak Allah khair Shaykh Yasir :)
Next time you go to Mecca,
Enjoy your milk infused Mocha,
Marked as having been exported from Mukha,
And manifested as Coffee beans of Khafa,
Without the discomfort of the fatwa,
That used to forbid Mocha,
In the City of Mecca.
MashaAllah...there is no other option than to love sheikh Yasir!!! May Allah swt reward you sheikh with only the best of dunya and akhirah. Ameen. Many salaams from Austria (not there where the kangoroos are)...
i completely agree with most of what dr. qadhi said in this video. May Allah produce many many more people who are like sheikh qadhi.
shaikh u can read pulse of society thats why large mass like u..great massage u r giving to society...we love u...we pray for u....
may allh bless u and afiya ..ameen
I watched the umar series 3 times and I love it I honestly don't care what anyone says ;-)
JhazakAllah! I am happy that they are scholars who think like this! I wish my locality followed this to.
Shared it on my Face Book and with my friends. This is what I personaly think but the way he has said, beautifull. So many duas.
What an Amazing Video, with so Much Detail Mashallah May Allah reward and Preserve Yasir Qadhi Allahumma Ameen
Welcome to the age of Misconception, just stick true to Allah's commands and Follow Prophet Muhammad(SAW)'s footsteps and tell people the Truth and you'll be find
Abdullah Muhammad Ameeen Ameen Ameen
Questions::
1) Are the stories of the Omar (ra) in the series 'AUTHENTIC' ?
2) Do we have to TRUST the UNAUTHENTICs?
3) Who are able to make verification?
4) Scholars or people/masses/ummah ?
IF the scholars are DISCONNECTED from people, THEN do we need to follow the masses?
Now,, who are Allaah commanded us to follow? based on what?
Allaahu Aalam.
Q1) Are the stories of the Omar (ra) in the series 'AUTHENTIC' ?
Since a sheikh reviewed the script and as Sh. Yasir told that they took the instances directly from old Seerah books, we can probably believe that the stories presented in this series are more or less 'true' if not 'authentic' per se, according to Hadiths. Remember that many stories of even the Seerah of the Prophet (S) was not preserved/collected according to the science of Hadith (checking the chains of narration and so on) and as such are not as 'authentic' as Shahih Bukhari -- so it's not even a valid question to ask whether the stories of Omar (R) presented in this series are 'authentic' or not. You may avoid it altogether or take it with a grain of salt -- that's what we learn from the wisdom of Solomon.
* Q 2-3 becomes irrelevant after this
Q. IF the scholars are DISCONNECTED from people, THEN do we need to follow the masses? Now,, who are Allaah commanded us to follow? based on what?
As Sh. Yasir told, oftentimes there are differences of opinions among the ulamas -- so, in such a case, you may simply follow the Shekh you have been following or follow a doctrine that seems most convincing according to Quran/Sunnah. Also, remember just because some shekhs are going against something new doesn't mean that it is Haram (according to Quran/Sunnah) -- they are just making interpretations based on Quran/Sunnah and they are not infallible; they may make mistakes (oftentimes, because often they don't have the domain knowledge of the relevant discipline e.g. science/technology), as they did by going against printing press/coffee. I want to end with Sh. Yusuf's final pont: "Islam is above any particular scholars ... be tolerant with the scholars who differ with you ... in the end of the day TRUTH shall prevail" -- you yourself may change your current position then.
All these are my opinions and I'm not a shekh neither am I infallible. So again, u may take it with a grain of salt -- and Allah knows best.
1) You wrote "Since a Syeikh reviewed the script ..."
Question:
1.1) Is the Syeikh a scbolar or just one for the 'masses/people?
1.2) Did he reviewed the stories based on the CORRECT manhad/principles of Ahlul Sunnah Wal Jammaan's (ASWJ)?
1.3) You also agreed that there are some 'problems' in Seerah. Then why not filter and take only the Sahih/Authentic? Islam teaches us to tell and spread the truths.
"Except for those who have believed and done righteous deeds and advised each other to truth and advised each other to patience." Quran Al-Asr (103:3)
2) Yes, there are differences among scholars, as had been told by Rasulullaah (pbuh) in his 73 sects' hadeeth. So we must be VERY careful to choose. Which one is correct? The one which follows Quran and authentic sunnahs, as had been told in Quran and sahih hadeeths, such as "Grab the rope of Allaah with molar teeths".
Yes, Islam is not about particular scholars, but, Islam also gives the solutions to make the choice easier. Since Islam is from Allaah, so, we have to ask Allaah to guides us to the correct path, as we do at least 17 time/day. Yes, we make mistakes, but ...
Anas ibn Malik reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “All of the children of Adam are sinners, and the best of sinners are those who repent.” Source: Sunan Ibn Majah 4251 Status: Saheeh
I am also not a scholar, but, if what I wrote have truths, take it and do research and refers the experts, ie, scholars. Yes, we need scholars who are on the correct manhaj, or become one of the scholar.
Why everthing in Islam have to be correct and authentic?
If someone asks us, "Is your Islam 'authentic?' What is our answer, and the answer is based on what?
My point is, What do we get if me mixed the truth with falsehood, Saheed (authentic) with Daif (weak)? This brings back to the main question
Who are the one who we need to refers to? Scholars or masses?
May Allaah guides us to the truth.
Allaahu A'lam.
bahathir Sheikh-ul-Google
If it brings the TRUTH... so what is rhe problem?
Your words are Gold.
Listening Dr. Yasir Qadhi speak about compromise between the realities of modern life and its problems and Islam, gives me slight hope that reform and some sort of renaissance is possible within Islam. I hope there may be more people within Islam who speak up a bout this very important issue.
Islam itself won't reform but the interpretations can be more analysed
Glad you mentioned Malaysia, salam from Malaysia.
Al-amdulillah, as usual beautiful rendition. I always tell all this critics to go make their own video and wait for the response to it. May Allah bless Islam with more right thinking scholars like Shayk Qadir.
Masha Allah, a great lecture, may Allah preserve and reward brother Yasir. I agree with much of what he said but I do think we should use extreme caution when we try to "change" Islam to conform to modernity and secularism because it can quickly become a very slippery slope. For example free mixing between genders, dating, putting our parents in retirement homes, these are part of this culture, but I in my humble opinion see them as contradictory to the spirit of Islam. Does not the Quran say to not even go near zina and to be the very best to our parents.
Advancing Technology is the way forward for the lands of the East. They must adopt, adapt, advance, and create modern technology.
In the end, Western ideology is nothing more than a series of fads that just come and go. What the west tries to portray as "modern" and "civilized" can better be defined using the words "Recent" and "Temporary".
Westernization and Modernization are not synonymous. The illusion that they are so is just a delusion upheld by the fact that, at this point in time, advanced technology happens to reside in the west, making the West merely APPEAR more modern.
If you take that technology away from the west, and give it to XYZ group of people, Western ideologies such as liberalism, feminism, Nationalism, and Secularism will be seen as barbaric and premitive.
Those who aim to be civilized and portray their own ideologies as civilized must adopt, adapt, advance, and create modern technology. Unfortunately, the lands in the East tend to have elites that buy western technology rather than create it themselves. This is not the way forward. This is literally why the Ottomans joined and lost WWI. Technology can be defined as modern. Ideology cannot be defined as modern, merely portrayed as such.
Alhamdulila! Had opportunity to attend this aweosome event.
One of the best yasir qadhi lectures.. amazing
Great guy.Love his knowledge.
نحبك في الله دكتور ياسر 💓
Wallahi more ppl should give this as a Qutbah.
Jazak Allah khair sheikh! Amazing lecture.
Mashallah nice lecture.
Hmmm this is interesting.... I Like this guy. He seem educated.
) Flexibility used where available. But should Nuh changed his message to keep his son inside Islam??
2) How does average layperson in the West find access to qualify local ulama?
3) Has YQ considered long term implications on high laxity? People action's/traditions become Islam for later generations.
Many good points, opens ALOT of avenues for discussion
I love Sh. Yasir Qadhi a lot, but I'm pretty sure it was "The Dark Knight Rises" rather than "The Dark Knight"
Nah there is another batman movie called the Dark Night
@@tahabajwa7392 The Dark Knight is the 2nd installment in the series, whereas Dark Knight Rises is the 3rd
Assalamu alikum, let us listen to this lecture for us to know that Islam is not like a one way traffic.
Listen to it.
MashAllah beautiful lecture as usual :)
assalamualeykum mashallah brother Yasir Qdi I always inspired by his lecture & gaining knowledge to understand more about sharia & islam.May Allah bless & protect our scholars ameen
Interesting lecture Subhan Allah and history about coffee ☕ in the Muslim land how it was consider to be haram and the schoolar change the view ,the printed press to Tv series ,is good that Shaykh Yasir Qadhi pointed out many schoolars don't understand the reality but they are humans and make mistake
Amazing lecture.. jazakhallahu khayran..
excellent
mashaAllah.....Great Lecture
masha ALLLAH barek ALLAH fik unfortunately this is what happening this days
Excellent Presentation .
May Allah give more strength and patience to this brother, in order for him to contenue on his path
wow! what a wonderful talk! barakallah shiek!!
bro find the mbc in youtube type "omar mbc" you will find the video
I love Dr. Yasir Qadhi and he's one of my most favorite scholars, but I don't agree with him on the issue of wisdom coming from experience (not from books). Allah himself says that He has given the book (Qur'an) and the Hiqmah (Wisdom from Sunnah). I've lived in England for several years, I don't think our Bangladeshi scholars are incapable of giving the right fatwas for people living in England.
I really appreciate this lecture, and this vedio is an answer to those UA-camr who are refuting sh yasir qadhi
There are sooo many things that I thought I understood... But as much as I have enjoyed the lecture, I am left confused regarding many issues I had previously received opinions on from different modern scholars! I don't think I am alone here, although I cannot find anyone commenting on such a problem. It would be great if I could address these issues directly to Sheikh Yasir Qadhi, or any other scholar face to face, but unfortunately I live in Germany with no English speaking sheikh that I know of.
Knowledge is an ocean and the resources are available. Before jumping in to swim its good to study the fundamentals like tawheed, the life of the Prophet (SAW). If you make an effort to find a sheikh in Germany, Allah (SWT) will bless your journey. You will realize that the different opinions are regarding details of practice which reflect that Islam can accommodate many ideas and lifestyles/cultures. However there is unanimous consensus regarding the core of our deen
Sheykh Qadhi said in this lecture, that he has no problem with personal celebrations. Does that include celebrating birthdays? He is a distinguished scholar, therefore I am sure that this is not merely his personal opinion.
Highly energetic & beautiful lecture. Must be the Mocha effect!
Sheikh Yasir, I recommend you to first finish the seerah if the messenger SWWS because people are waiting for it!
He's not working for you, jerk. He'll finish it if he wants, and do nothing if he wants. Cake!!
Yasir Qadhi, do you honestly expect the Scholars to change aspects of the Deen of Allaah and make Halaal, what Allaah made Haraam? No, because that is the trait of the jewish scholars, who changed what Allaah made halaal into haraam, and what Allaah made haraam into halaal.
Remember this important statement: ''The Scholars are the Inheritors of the Prophets.'' Without the Scholars we would be lost.
Make no mistake everyone, Yasir Qadhi is calling you to misguidance. We need to stick to the Scholars. Those Ulamah that call to the way of the Salaf as-Saalih (Pious Predecessors).
saeed1602 He did not condone this. The entire point of the lecture is what Allah makes haram is haram. What Allah makes halal is halal. Everything else is malleable, and we shouldn't stick to unessential rules if they harm the Ummah. Allah did not make coffee haram, the scholars did.
+saeed1602 : You neo salafis today are far from the true salaf.
That was very motivating...
Damn.........Our Sheikh got bars in the end
Amazing, insightful lecture mA!
A MASTER
Has anybody realized that what the printing press allows for is what Yasir Qadhi himself says he doesn't want? If outsourcing fatwas is bad, then what would you think about a man who writes a book, a man of limited learning and limited experience now being capable of reaching an unlimited audience and incapable of being asked any follow up questions regarding that book?
I think you a very valid point. But YQ already addressed this issue in the 5 points he discussed.
Amir Basheer
Here's the problem. When we say "get with the times" it usually means go with the flow and be with the people. It is not the job of the ulema to be with the people in the sense that he means, it is the job of the people to be with the ulema
You are speaking the truth my dear friend.
I would like to remind you of an incident that took place 1400 years ago. When muslims were migrating to abseeniya prophet, this is when islam had not revealed itself completely. Most of islams rules and regulations came into effect only in madeena. before the muhajireen went to abseeniya our messenger peace be upon him asked them how will decided what is right and worng they said based on quran. then prophet said what if there is no mention of it in the quran then they said we will base on what you said and if you didnt say antying about it then we will derive it based the first two. not the exact words but you know what i mean.
My dear friend this is called ijthihaad. we are living in times were there are new challenges new ways of lifes. these issues did not exist at the time of the messenger or the sahaba. it is the responsibility of our scholars to be cognizant of these changes and needs and give the correct fathwa based on the quran and hadeeth. sometimes they get it wrong but as long as it is done in good faith and does not harm others these changes are legitimate.
Yasir qadhi i think is a mujaddin of our times. i have started listening to me very recently but i can already see he is genuine and is sincere.
I have already chosen him to be my third ustad.
i pray to allah to guide this man and reward him multiple times and grand him jannah and forgive him if he has made any mistakes.
Amir Basheer
you said "we are living in times were there are new challenges new ways of lifes. these issues did not exist at the time of the messenger"
Could you please explain what about our times is different exactly?
my dear brother,
if you do not know it already i do not think any explanation from my side will be able to convince you.
Let us leave this topic in good faith and friendship..
Assalamu alaikum wa rahmathullah..
What I learn from this video, is that scholars have too much power
Super masha allah.shaikh please dua for us
with all do respect anyone who finds what sheikh Yasir is saying as wrong, is really ignorant in the highest degree. how can you defend the fatwa that said coffee was haram. what about the printing press.
how about how some reacted to the radio instead of making a radio channel that broadcasts Quran their first option was to attack the station.
but seriously bro caffeine could make you tripping. 1000 miligram of pure caffeine powder will send you to detached reality for 12 hour.
@@lukidwiputra4644 Luki you would die of water intoxication before you could drink enough coffee to do that to you. I checked and it's around 70 cups of coffee. The same lethal amount as pure water. Is drinking water now Haram?
@@alexojideagu nah man i speaking about the caffeine not the coffee itself.
Coffee causes anxiety on various levels in different people. Imagine an addict saying I don’t feel the effect of the drug it’s okay because I’m use to it honestly this comes off as really arrogant. Maybe they were more in touch and had more self awareness than the accuser who looks down on these learned men. You know how we all have to quit it a week before Ramadan because how it will make our fasts an act of worship very hard
Assalamu alaikkum Jazakallah khair Sheikh
Real Talk.
Dark nights is no comparison to Umar Ibn Al Kathab. An Alim's job is give the correct Islamic ruling rather provide a wholesome Fathawa to the Ummah.
The day when man will call to mind his (whole) endeavour, (The Noble Quran 79:35) And hell will stand forth visible to him who seeth, (The Noble Quran 79:36) Then, as for him who rebelled (The Noble Quran 79:37) And chose the life of the world, (The Noble Quran 79:38) Lo! hell will be his home. (The Noble Quran 79:39) But as for him who feared to stand before his Lord and restrained his soul from lust, (The Noble Quran 79:40) Lo! the Garden will be his home. (The Noble Quran 79:41)
haha I only noticed the white bread when he mentioned it!
23:00-34:00 golden (Omar Series)
I would love to open one as i once 18years ago worked at a photo press.
43 min "experiencing teaches you what book can not do, living with the society"
No disrespect but dr, Yasir is having the same problem / crisis as many of us do, who live in the west and are surrounded by weak / confused muslims.
So the theory (books / islamic knowledge) and practice (applied in the real world) are not matching. What do you change??? Do you change the religion to please the people? NO!
You give the same massage and if the people do not adhere or give you greef, you stay patience, your relationship / love to Allah swt should supersede any other love or loyalty.
Our religion is already easy to follow, so to speak about that we must make islam something that is realistic / livable / doable" could be a step towards compromising with difficult people in a wrong way.
Don't insult people Brother Yasir, not your Brothers.
Can anyone can tell me his sources?
Salaam shaykh. JazakAllah khairan for such an informing lecture. A few followup questions, if you please don't mind answering. I am simply a layman and follow the hanafi school of thought in jurisprudence. My question is regarding the portion where you mention that consensus or ijma'a is when ALL the scholars are in agreement. So does that mean that if 90% of the scholarly body is in agreement on something and 10% disagrees on the contrary, the ummah should consider that 10% offshoot as "forward thinking" and adopt their fatwa and disregard the 90%? Also, we run into the issue as laymen of trying to figure out if so and so person deserves to be labeled as a scholar don't we? Who's scholarship counts and who's doesn't? What happens if 99.9% of the scholarly body of all the different groups say that praying behind a woman is haraam and .01% says its halal? Is that 99.9% considered the ijma'a or consensus opinion? or does it need to be an absolute 100% agreement with no single scholar objecting before the issue is considered the consensus opinion? And if we reject that .01% do we then label that .01% to be non-schloarly which then elevates the 99.9% right at 100%? At what percentage of agreement is a particular opinion on a specific issue considered to be the consensus opinion and who comes up with that determination? This is the confusion I've found within myself and I would be utterly grateful to you if you could provide clarification for me in the midst of your busy and proactive schedule. May Allah bless you immensely in this dunya, make you a means of guidance for mankind till the day of judgement and grant you nothing short of Jannatul Firdous in the afterlife. Ameen. Was-salaam.
MasaAllah
Subhanallah
❤️❤️❤️❤️
did the sheikh diss wahabis and najdis? I'm confused, because most of the AlMaghrib's instructors are trained in KSA, including the sheikh himself
What a stereotype, not sure what you have been continually been fed with! just because they study in saudi they are wahabbis? najdis? on top of that, not only that, clearly shows these terms are loosely. and yet being used to throw around to people!
hannan52 I'm just said those words because the sheikh did. Clearly you haven't even watched the video.
Just like the Islamic Golden Age and Gunpowder Empires
Assalam aleykum thank you bekther for the lecture. Where can i find the conclusions of Idjma ?
but i thought it was not allowed to show sahabah in movies/plays?
Incorrect. The word coffee is not from Kaffa. Coffee comes from Qahwh. Qahwah is from the word “Qahya” which means to suppress ones hunger. The Turkish word “Kahve” comes from “Qahwa”. Then finally COFFEE came from the Turkish word “Kahve (Kaffeh)” and then came the word coffee as. More simplified version. And Allah knows best
To compare the MBC Omar series to coffee is shocking. The majority of the scholars said it is haraam, this is called Ijmaa' "consensus" and it becomes a must for everyone to obey and stay away. Wallahi this is ignorance, may Allah guide yasir qadhi.
Asalamu aleikum warahmatuAllah wabaraktuh,
I am not sure I understood your comment,
are you saying that watching t.v is entirely haram ?
Ijma is consensus, not majority. Consensus means that ALL agree on an opinion. Sh. Yasir Qadhi literally said it.
It was consensus that coffee was haram.
Is drinking coffee a must?
Amazing how people decide what is Halal and Haram which is only Allah's right to do. And then they are overturned. What was once considered Haram is declared Halal. These people are not the ones to follow to Jannah.
Assalamu Alaykom Sheikh Yasir. Please allow me to translate this lecture in Arabic and upload it to my youtube channel
I really appreciate it.
I don't know how to contact you privately
Jazakom Allah kheir
🙄😳Brother, do you blame the ulama for not issuing a fatwa changing haram to halal??? What were they supposed to say?? 🤯
They were supposed to exercise their wisdom based on the Quran and Sunnah, and not repeat what others say.
@@adminmd899 If something is haram, not even 8 billion people or any alim will change it. The whole world eats pigs and it hasn't made them any more halal.
Great job, bark Allah feek ya shaikh..
I like to watch the documentary of mcb pl help me where I can find it thanks
ublished on Aug 15, 2012
Omar Series
www.mbc.net/omar
facebook.com/omar.series
twitter.com/omarseries
MBC1
www.mbc.net/mbc1
facebook.com/mbc1tv
twitter.com/mbc1tweets
Shahid.net
www.shahid.net
facebook.com/shahidvod
twitter.com/shahidvod
Category
Entertainment
License
Standard UA-cam License
I hope you enjoy.
well,, we don't have to bring islam to level of people, we have to bring people to level of islam.
@ 43:30
Search JAVED AHMED GHAMDI...
LOVELY IMAM Look WITH HARDSHIP TIRENESS OF WRITING THIS HOLY KURAN THE HOLY AS -HAAB FOLLOWERS OF MUHAMADU FOUGHT AGAINST THEMSELVES AND SHED BLOOD.EVEN AHLI BAIT SUFFERED WHAT KIND OF DUA DID MUHAMADU DID .DID HE FORM THE 5 SALAT 0R ALMIGHTY ALLAHU GAVE HIM .HOLY QURAN 5:47 .NO MISTAKE IN THE HOLY BIBLE OR INJIL OF JESUS CHRIST PBUH. MAY JEHOVAH GOD ALMIGHTY GUIDE US AMEEN
As a non-believer, I found this lecture quite interesting, but the dude lost me when he went into his little rant about music at 31.20 ... he has an issue with stringed instruments and wind instruments ??? What's that all about ?
Hey,
Some scholars (Not all) don't approve of musical instruments, some however do...
It's something we have a difference of opinion on and the Prophet(peace be upon him) said: "Difference of opinion in my Community is a mercy for people"
Btw you should check out shaykh Muhammad al-Yaqoubi a member of the Prophet's(Peace be upon him) family. :)
And the reason these scholars don't approve of musical instruments would be ... what, exactly ?
murrmac Hi, thought i'd contribute as a student of scholarship myself:
interestingly it is similar to the coffee example he starts off with. There is some evidence from the prophet muhammad that frowns upon stringed instruments, but scholars have explained that in those days, music were usually coupled with drinking/loitering/prostitution. Most scholars have no problem with music that brings benefit. In fact any law of Islam that cannot be linked to a benefit, or brings about more harm than benefit, becomes out of islam.
FYI, all of islamic law must be connected to protecting what is called the 5 sacred necessities or it cannot be considered islamic:
1) protecting One's religion (includes one's freedom to choose one's own)
2) Life (killing unjustly is as if you've killed all of humanity)
3) intellect (the reason alcohol consumption is frowned upon)
4) Familial lineage (knowig one's own past, keeping family together etc)
5) material wealth (contract law, property, inheritance etc)
hope that helps
***** That article appears to be definitive ... it is depressing to think that there are millions of muslim children all over the world who are denied the wonderful benefits of learning to play a musical instrument.
I also find it depressing that these same children are denied the benefits of owning a pet dog ... but that's another affair altogether.
murrmac I believe that the Maliki school is fine with Dogs as being pets. keep in mind that the reason it may be frowned upon is because of disease prevention. Especially considering that by their nature dogs, evolving from wolves, like to like people on the face and mouth. A case may be made to change the Islamic opinion given modern medical advances ( something that happens quite often in Islamic Law).
The Prophet saw didn't despise dogs, pigs, or any animals for that matter. In fact he's said: "A man felt very thirsty while he was on the way, there he came across a well. He went down the well, quenched his thirst and came out. Meanwhile he saw a dog panting and licking mud because of excessive thirst. He said to himself, "This dog is suffering from thirst as I did." So, he went down the well again and filled his shoe with water and watered it.Allah thanked him for thatdeed and forgave him. The people said, "O Allah's Apostle (SAW)! Is there a reward for us in serving the animals?" He replied: "Yes, there is a reward for serving any animate (living being)."
"A prostitute was forgiven by Allah, because, passing by a panting dog
near a well and seeing that the dog was about to die of thirst, she took
off her shoe, and tying it with her head-cover she drew out some water
for it. So, Allah forgave her because of that."
It's true what's next?
The lesser of two evils is still evil.
In the Series Umar in MBC tv many respected Sahabas are being acted by some actors .. Even Ummul Mu'minin Fatimatuzzohra (r.a.) is being acted by an actress .. which hurts me most .. I respect Her (r.a.) a lot that i cant watch this serial anymore .. Sahaba (r.a.) are also the most respected persons .. we didnt see them .. so those actors are creating a false pictures of the Sahaba (r'.a. ) in our mind ... i dont like this .. !! no matter how many Muslims watch this and how famous it is .. !!!
What is dark night
It's a movie
Sunni should not be proud of their majority.
QURAN 6:116] Wert thou to follow the common run of those on earth, they will lead thee away from the way of Allah. They follow nothing but conjecture: they do nothing but lie.
with all due respoect to Dr QAdhi, I'm sorry to say that this lecture is embarrasing... as if I listen to an orietnalist... what is his purpose? why he is laughing at our scholars? really I think he want the youngster's hand clapping!
Why can we criticize the west but not our own people for having slavery until 60 years ago?
If there were Shia to have a voice.. in Islamic land.. coffee never would have been considered Haram, If Prophet PBUH was alive coffee never would have been Haram.. but, this show, that Islam was on the hands of who and what they made from it throughout history to present. All those four Sunni groups, (Maliki, Shafie, Hanbali and Hanafis) were wrong back then and are wrong now. the TRUE iSLAM is the Islam of Prophet Mohammad PBUH... and Prophet BBUH said I leave behind two things... Quran and Ahlul Bayt.. the Sunni (Abubakr, Omar and Uthman did not care about his Ahlul Bayt, ALI was to be seen no where. after that the following generation of Sunni murdered his grandson Imam Hussain... how ridiculus path Islam has traveled and where are we now? King Salmon slave of Trump? King of Bahrain with Israel and Jordan..?! who is not laughing on Muslim?!
To compare the MBC Omar series to coffee is shocking. The majority of the scholars said it is haraam, this is called Ijmaa' "consensus" and it becomes a must for everyone to obey and stay away. Wallahi this is ignorance, may Allah guide yasir qadhi.