WHAT IS KARCH KIRALY THINKING?? (clickbait)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 чер 2024
- Everett Delorme and Rob St. Claire react to the announcement of the USA women's volleyball roster that will represent Team USA at the Paris 2024 Olympic Games!!
Instagram: / volleyballsource2.0
#volleyball #olympics #usavolleyball - Спорт
![ОРБАН приехал к ПУТИНУ и "отчитался" о поездке в Киев 😁 [Пародия]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_0ukDovOWq8/mqdefault.jpg)
Everyone is entitled to their views, but I don't know why some comments below, plus these commentators are weighing in on Week 1 of VNL this year. If we look at the body of work professionally, Carlini outweighs all setters as Champions League Winner, and league wins and standings overall with her teams. @Everett, how can you say she doesn't mesh well with this team? She was an integral starter since the 2019 VNL Finals, 2020 & 2024 Olympic Qualifiers. Carlini is an excellent defender, all around ball handler. @Rob, she doesn't play well off the bench?, she has finished games for Hancock (2022 VNL vs. Thailand, 2023 VNL Bronze vs. Poland (although close loss.). And this isn't "Jordyn Poulter's team." Volleyball is an all around team effort. If Poulter is injured, or needs to be subbed out (3 VNL losses this year she started), i think the term "back up setter" is outdated. It's frustrating that there are certain players that will always get a nod. I guess the coaches don't really take into account the roster accomplishments ie, Jenna Gray (2 Championships and MVP in Brazil), or the best NCAA players, O'neal, Kipp (confused as to why she's never played with the Senior Team), Madi Skinner, etc. Plus i think Hentz is a much better defense player, but hopefully next time around. I believe these are all capable players, some should have been let go, and other young talent as i've named should be given more opportunities, but this is how it is...
Actually, Karch has done that before where he gives the captain role, especially in the VNL, to a player who isn't going to feature in the finals, or in the "bigger" tournament later in the summer.
Also, if you don't let Hancock utilize her jump-spin serve, that drastically reduces her impact, in my opinion.
Carlini will be in the double sub role, but I personally would like to see her start a few matches in VNL week 3 just to see what she can do with the Olympians instead of the team we got in week 1.
Rob, I was hoping you would ask kiraly about the reduction on micah’s serve!
Anyways, you guys are spot on as usual but I do disagree about micah being the “better volleyball player.”
All setters have their pros and cons, for me:
carlini is more overall. She is the best blocker of the 3, and significantly better in floor defense.
Poutler is the best setter of the 3, with a good serve along with it.
Michah’s biggest strength was maybe her serve, and the fact that they reduced it, fked up her chances already. She is the most agressive st the bet but in the end you don’t bring a setter based on anything other than who can give your hitters the best chance of scoring, and that is why poutler is no.1.
However, the us fans must have amnesia because carlini was no.1 all the way up until the roster for the last olympics was announced. So the fact she wasn’t sent then instead of micah and now she has a shot people are crying is pretty comical. If anything, its even now😬 Actually, if anything, this discourse should be on whether poutler or carlini should be the no.1 setter, or if it should be carlini and micah instead.
Poutler is not the same player from last olympics. Carlini had a very weak team week 1 and im not basing her current form based off of that.Carlini is hungry and has alot she wants to prove to many people in these comments. I think she should hit more pipe and more rotations in the opposite side, to give thompson a break.
I also think carlini has a better connection with thonpson, whoin my opinion, along with obogu AND Wong, are significantly below the level they were at this point last olympic cycle.
I want to say its a bit unfair because we have so much depth, we don’t need to ride on the cocktails of what someone achieved 4 years ago. we have viable options like o’neal, hentz, and a few good opposite hitters (NOT CUTTINO) , but for some reason haven’t gotten to play with team usa much, but its too late now. I respect kiraly and if im not mistaken he Michelle and foluke were also coming back from a hiatus (?) last cycle but their experience proved to be worth it. However, they were already in olympic shape during that vnl season.
I wont even say much about the plummer discourse. Volleyball fans are very one track minded. Serve receive is important but its not the only thing in volleyball. We ignore all the things plummer brings to the table because its easier to notice weakness than lets say, what a 6’6 block and do to trouble the minds of a big opposite hitter. Her track record this past season speaks for itself. She can be a big key and her receiving and especially back court defense has improved. I think she should be utilized back row more and they need to remember that she is also a really good opposite hitter.
totally agree with everything here!
Thanks for your thoughtful and timely coverage.
Hancock a better volleyball player overall? Huh? Blocking? Back row D? Carlini is really good at those. I'll keep listening to the rest.
Same here. Carlini all the way. For some reason USA has many talented players in outside hitter position but good setters are few and far between. Carlini is great, she needs to play as much as possible to find her rhythm with this main squad.
Oh yeah, Hancock much better, you heard it right. Maybe carlini was chosen because she was the setter last OQ. But during the first week of this VNL she wasnt really great, or just the connection. Hope that improves. But congrats.
@@eme981to be fair the team week one was really week, not sure its right to put that on carlini
I like the roster, especially when considered together with the alternates. Let's go.
Kiraly should just bounce off from the momentum of Conegliano OHs' season. Larson and Cook will definitely makeup for the Plummer's lack of passing. Great MBs choices, hopefully we get to see Ogbogu gain some traction in time for the Olympics.
She’s one of the middle, her Dena and Haley
Difference is, theres no wolosch setting up one on ones or haak to get a kill when they cant buy a pass
@@estherkarawei232difference is there is no confident opposite. Alot of people are missing the fact st how big jordan thompson inconsistency has affected week 2 games
Everett calling ppl "stupid" for not thinking Plummer was a lock is both annoying and well, stupid. It's not the craziest opinion to have considering her serve-receive and defense is not as strong as some of the other outsides that were cut. If you watched how she served in Arlington, it wasn't pretty either. I watched her season at Imoco but let's not pretend like she didn't have those weaknesses there too. She was often subbed out or choked with little room to cover on serve-receive. It was less noticeable because Robinson and De Gennaro command the back court.
I mean you just proved him right...
Am I the only one who thinks that if Hancock were to be part of the team, she should take Poulter’s spot and not Carlini’s? Pre-injury Poulter was amazing but she’s now slower and doesn’t connect as well with the players except Larson
Love all three though
Bad choice not picking Micha... im really surprised and im so mad...
why didn't you make post-match interviews for the USA-Türkiye match? Kinda curious what players have thought about the match?
Turkish volleyball players were too good to give interview.
@@user-a17hsji6 don't worry you got the medal for the biggest Turkish team hater🏅keep doing it :))
I thought it was because the first week not in Canada
they did. I'm guessing you're specifically asking about Turkish players, they said the players did NOT want to do an interview.
I’m with you guys on Carlini’s issue
Frantti was heartbreaking! I mean larson should have just give it to the younger players. She already proved everything! Also Frantti was always a game changer
I still miss Ben Patch, The Revelation
Ummm Kathryn Plummer has been a professional volleyball player for 4 yrs
Kathryn plummer shouldnt be a lock due to her poor serve receive , yeah its not bad but most of the USA loses came down to them targeting her with serves or spikes and having to play out of system constantly
Then the others shouldnt be a lock for not being able to terminate like her or put up a block on the big opposite hitters. Volleyball is about alot of different things, you american fans like to use her as a scapegoat when things aren't going well...meanwhile, and cook are the most successful wing spikers this past club season. Check her club season stats and tell me why she shouldn't be a lock and why we should put players like frantti in who have left little to be desired in their club season. Come on.
@@Mike-bv3bt didnt say she shouldnt make it lol, its just something to consider, maybe in her club team it works out for her very well but internationally with a whole different roaster its something else, also I am not even am american fan LOL im canadian with european decent and only really watch USA players when they are verisng the teams i support and from watching those games i can already tell her receiving, passing and backline defending is a very exploitable weak point for a once unbeatable USA. My dad barely watches games with me, but any game he watches where plummer is playing, he says "they need to serve on 2" and "2 is in the back, they need to aim for her with their hitting" and thats what the teams do and thats how they are winning
I would be a bigger Plummer fan if she passed better more consistent and got her tall ass of the floor and stopped getting stop or scarred by a 6 to 6'2" block. My god she 6'6"
I agree 100%. Her hitting power is great, but her defense is lacking imo.
Carlini clearly read hundred comments about her inconsistent games ,than that is Chalenge for her to prove that ,do that!
Justice for Ali Franti!
agree with the Carlini over Micha take. She just lacked the juice when she played in week 1 of VNL and whenever she comes off the bench. I think Karch is looking for height as well.
Why would you not take Micah Hancock as the second setter. She’s nearly as good as Carlini at setting, but better at defense and has one of the best jump serves in the world.
Hancock better at defense than Carlini? Do you live in an alternate Universe?
We appreciate Carlini a lot more than Americans it seems. She is great, you should be happy.
she's a better server for sure and great with the occasional unpredictable offense but I'd say Carlini is the better defender.
Carlini defends better! Whether it's floor defense and blocking. She's known for her superb floor defense. That's a fact lol! Micha is probably the best server for USA.
@@blaz3ofgloryshe defends like a libero! People are just hating on her for no reason lol
@@annereyes6887 yup, agreed.
I thought that we’ll see Frantty in Paris 😢
Talking about Serbia. Are you aware that Serbia played two games Against Argentina in Argentina before traveling to Ottawa? Each team won a game.
Carlini has the better connection compared to all 3 at this moment, All Poulter does is set outside
Franti and Hancock! 😢
I totally agree. Carlini was at her prime last Olympics and didn’t make the team. Yet I don’t see her being that girl this Olympics. On top of that, her last couple seasons in Europe were kinda mehhh. Well. Maybe there is something we don’t see.
when you search about their overall career achievements, it's clearly seen that Carlini is more experienced and successful than Hancock. She already deserved to be an Olympian in 2021 but she made it this year finally. She is just getting what she has after a couple of years. And when you compare about their skills, Carlini is like a real threat on the defensive side of the team against other countries. She just digs the ball like a libero. Congrats to her and good luck in Paris :)
Hancock is a mid tier setter, she wouldn't have made the roster in top 6-7 teams in 2021 yet she made it to the USA team, that was a surprise. This here now is not a surprise, it is what it should be.
Carlini makes any team she plays in more resilient. That is what USA team is lacking at the moment. Resilience paves the way for closure, closing the set that is. This is what we (Turkiye) struggled in the past and USA was very good at it, because you had Bartsch, a younger Larson and Kelsey, amazing three players that just digged every ball from the grave and gave that extra boost in defense. Now you might be better at attacks, I don't know but you will definitely miss Bartsch and Larson at her peak. Carlini defends like a libero, which is not a bad addition to your team.
@@F355exactly! Out of the three setters, she had the best club season record. She's a champion league winner. She started from Scandicci, Novara, Dinamo Kazan, THY, Casalmaggiore and Aydin.
I think people overlook her resilience and confidence as a player. Her digs are immaculate. That's her signature since NCAA days.
And hancock was better when she had a jump serve...now she doesn't. If carlini didnt make it to the olympics when she deserved to, then I think its fair game now she goes even if she is not in her prime as you say...which seems very subjective. She has not been the lead setter for the us squad since last olympic cycle, she has alot to prove.
I agree, the Carlini choice is just odd.
KARCH TOLD THE TEAM ONE BY ONE, YOU’LL NEVER BELIEVE WHAT HAPPENS NEXT (clickbait)
I would 100% go with Carlini. I never even understood how Hancock made the national team.
Isn't one libero risky? I guess if worst case scenario happens Cook would play as libero.
The 4 OHs make sense. But i don't understand why Kiraly never tried position swap with Plummer and Thompson. You gotta have your slow physical player as opposite. Thompson's attack style looks like a better fit for OH. Might be terrible idea. Might not. You can't know without trying.
No offense but are you new to volleyball? They always pick one libero, there are not alot of spots...Plummer has been playing outside for years and in club, and thompson has been doing the same as an opposite; to suddenly have them switch because of an armswing is ridiculous. They can both play either position and have in college but for the past 4 years they have been doing what they are doing now. Plummer's block against the opposing tall opposite hitters is very under-looked. Thompson looks off because she hasn't been her self for the past year. Look at her games last olympic cycle; she was unstopable.
I'd have picked Frantti over Plummer. But they didn't ask me.
The Brazilian team Will be annunciated in the airport, when will going to Paris
Lmao
😂😂😂 lol such a drama
KARCH CHOSE THE TEAM USING THIS ONE OLD TRICK THAT VOLLEYBALLWORLD DON’T WANT YOU TO KNOW (clickbait)
Lol american fans are fans of players and not volleyball indeed...anyone following the sport would know how frantti has been performing at vakifbank this past season, and she came here in week one and didn't help her case at all. Her one saving grace is her passing and she was even inconsistent in that. Actually, none of the USA players on vakifbank have had a good season (frantti, obogu, thompson), thats some suspicious shit if you ask me. Thompson should have stayed in the Italian league...maybe something is going on in her personal life? She gives that vibe.
Hancock's serve was a hugeeee strength of hers and now its been reduced... USA volleyball is based off of a deep roster and balanced system; kiraly doesn't need to be perfect in his desicion as we have a chance to win even if we don't send all of the best players per position.
Thompson never deserved the money she got in any club she was in, that is why she jumped from team to team in Turkiye and Italy. She plays better in the national team but she is inconsistent. Vakif got her because every other player was taken already and Thompson was their unwilling choice + Guiddetti's lack of vision.
Thompson played:
1 year in Fenerbahce in 2019-20
2 years in Eczacibasi in 2020-22 (Was injured mostly and was in the bench, as Boskovic is the main opposite)
1 year in Milano in 2022-23
1 year in Vakif in 2023-24
She was an average player at best in all of these teams.
Both Italy and Turkiye are known for their high foreign player retention.
For some reason Thompson was not wanted in any of these teams.
Carlini is the best setter. The other 2 are not consistent. Poulter is not in her best shape health wise.
I'm happy for Carlini. I would probs cry if she didn't make it. It's Poulter's ship and hopefully she can stay healthy.
Still mad about Ben Patch not getting picked.
Carlini lead USA in 2018-19-20 VNL Gold. She should have gone in 2020 not Poultry.
I guess you both missed the horrible passing of Larson during all four Match's. Skinner can not receive or pass. Well you know what they say, everyone has an opinion just like an azz-hole.
Karch will not allow Hancock to jump serve, he wants them all float serving.
personally, its time for larson to move on, shes 37, give it to a younger player to help them build into something better
She is playing amazing, do you want us to win or you want to speak rubbish
@@Mike-bv3bt no i dont want usa to win, theyve won for a long time and its time for something new, and clearly they need something new as they are dropping in world ranking and VNL ranking so maybe they should start training up the young talent so by the next VNL or the one after, they are a threat again, also i am not american AT ALL, dont live there, dont have family there. no connection, I much rather see brazil, Turkiye or poland take GOLD, hell even italy too
@@Mike-bv3bt also why are u fighting me over my personal opinion, if you dont like it you can move on
"WhY ArE YoU FiGhTINg mE BeCAuSe of My PerSoNaL oPINION"
Your personal opinion is stupid. Way to disrespect a legend and then play victim after. No one is fighting you; grow up.
Or maybe, worry about the teams you want to win instead of making stupid comments about the best performing outside hitter for the US so far.
This duo clearly don't follow European volleyball. Carlini is no brainer, I'd pick Carlini over Poulter even. Carlini defends like a libero!!!
Carlini did an amazing job all season in Turkiye, she elevated her team, plus she is a much much better defender than Poulter and Hancock.
Hancock was horrible in 2021 in Novara, Italy and yet she made the olympic team. No one here in Turkiye undestood that choice from Karch, we had expected Carlini.
And finally Carlini is where she deserves to be.
Karch also explained that he and his staff are following these players very closely during their club seasons, that assures me that they know Carlini is the better choice.
It still baffles me why Hancock was chosen in 2021.
Hancock is just a mid tier setter.
Hancock is not mid tier. She’s also one of the best servers in the world
@@isitsustainable820 can't deny that her jump serves are really good tho! I think Carlini is just overshadowed by the success of Tokyo 2020 & VNL 2021.
lol well if you watched Carlini played you’d know she improved recently. Not sure what world you were in. Hancock has always been solid. Carlini may have better defense, but she lacks leadership. You can see it on court.
@@annereyes6887 carlini was literally the lead setter up until that tokyo olympics roster revelation, people seem to forget that. Even though none of the setters have achieved anything spectacular since then, people are going to remember the setters that went to the olympics...and thats what they are riding on...the thing is , we could have won the olympics with either 3 of the setters. Poutler is not the same as before and neither is hancock because they reduced her jump serve to a jump float
Imoco has not been the best team in the world in last 3 years XD do they even have three stars?
Do you keep up with volleyball?! Monica DG- one of the best liberos in the world
Wolosz- best setter in the world
Haak- one of the best opps in the world
Not to mention the rest of their team is stacked, and they’ve won just about everything a team can win the past few years.
You’re new aren’t you
what do you mean they just won the champions league a month ago LOL
this statement is wildddddd
Nice attempt at a joke...try again later