As a 6'6 Firefighter, I have had good results with Rouge brand tools. Almost all of them have longer handles, and that helps me stay upright. The Pulaski, a great tool, seems undersized for tall men. Perfect for the generation it was created!
I'm not even near as tall as you and the difference I noticed with a long handle on our homemade "Super-Ps" was significant. I've used the Rogue hoe but never their pulaski. Looks great.
Thank you for telling the story of Ed Pulaski. I believe that was the Peshtigo fire, which broke out the same day as the Great Chicago Fire. This fire began Oct. 8, 1871 in and around Peshtigo, Wisconsin. It was a terribly dry year. The Peshtigo fire caused more property damage but the fire in the city got all the press coverage. But this fire took between 1200 and 2400 lives.
It wasn’t the Peshtigo Fire… it was the Great Fire of 1910 a few decades later (even I had to look it up, as Peshtigo didn’t sound quite right). I didn’t even know that 5 of his men didn’t heed his orders and perished.
@@TexasFire_Cross If anyone else is interested in the story of Ed Pulaski and the actual fire he fought (in 1910), I highly recommend the documentary The Big Burn by American Experience on PBS. You can watch it for free here on on UA-cam. One of the many heroes of such a watershed moment in the history of firefighting and the US Forest Service.
As someone who grew up in a small town--chopping wood and playing in the forests--who now lives in a big city, I just love watching your videos. Also, as an artist, I admire your craftsmanship when building or modifying tools. Favourite new UA-cam channel, for sure. (Also, great production values and editing!)
You have stated on multiple videos to like the video as do many others and I never do until now. For no reason really but I have been enjoying your channel for the last year or so now. We have a remote 5 acres on Kodiak Island here in Alaska and we are just starting our journey to start some forestry stewardship and tree removal to make room for our eventual family second home / retirement homestead. I absolutely LOVE your content and your approach to your videos. I have built your cantilevered work bench in my shop already and my Christmas list continues to grow based on your videos like this. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!!! And keep up the great videos and content I learn something new from EVERY video and it inspires me!
I’m not sure I’ve seen all of your videos on UA-cam Cody, but I seen the vast majority and love them. Keep up the good work and god bless. You are living the real American dream👍👍👍👍👍
Darn, I just bought the original. My one and only experience with the Polaski is building a switchback trail in the back country in Idaho. I was so impressed with that tool I thanked Mr. Polaski every day :-). The new one I just acquired is due to a divorce couple years ago.
Hi, I'm loving your channel. You sir and your families story, are an inspiration to us as we undertake our own relocation and completely new beginning. From the valleys of South Wales to The Highlands Of Scotland later this year. Thank you. Regards Jason.
Ok, as for a requested comment,I already have two FSS Pulasky axes.They were given to me by a retired fireman that I've done some yard work for,one is used,the other never has been,the Rouge looks useful,personally,I can't justify buying one,the FSS works fine..when I need it for a specific task,thank you for the vid though,I will most likely,eventually buy one anyway,now that I know It exists.
I have been a subscriber now for about 2 months or so and along with watching all your new videos as you post them I have been binge watching all your other videos in between. Great channel Cody.
This was great timing!! I was looking at Rogue's website last night then checked your channel and this video showed up!! Looks like a great tool built the right way!! I'm tempted to get a few of their tools to add to my arsenal. Keep up the great work Cody!!
Another great review... Hope you and the family are all ready for winter.... Would love to see additional videos on how you prepare the homestead for winter.....
Cody, I'm building a 6*6 type 3 truck for my department as we speak. I'm 90% sure most, if not all of my hand tools will be Rogue tools. Thanks for introducing me to what appears to be outstanding tools.
Longer handle=more leverage and torque. It's gonna hit harder and feel heavier. It's the principle of why holding an 8 pound weight out with your arm isn't as hard as holding an 8 pound sledge out by the end of the handle. Also the head could just be poorly balanced
I think that the FSS is still gonna be around for a while and possibly even passed on to your son, because it is a classic and a beautiful tool to behold. But You gotta love the absolute functionality of the ROGUE tool and its tough resilient features. Both are attractive accompaniments in the same situations however for usibility and easy tool maintenance on the path, ROGUE!! Looking forward to part 2!! Thanks Wranglerstar. Its worth the Effort. Your channel has definitely shaped my life for the better.
Two crewmembers of mine ordered a few Rogue tools to use personally on the line, and most of them broke under relatively little use.. One broke clean off at the welds and the others broke off at the handles under "normal" use. They were Rogue hoes, not the Pulaski-esque too. Just FYI from other actual Rogue users.
Love the responsibility outro! Right on.. Im not sure that you relize youre doing it but in these comparison posts you always seem to favor one tool or the other! In fairness, your final reviews seem to compensate for it but i am deeply, genuinly interested in knowing what is the best! Either way i cant stop watching your videos and please stay true and keep them coming!!
The bias often comes out. It’s probably true of most people though. Ford, Dodge, or Chevy... most people have a bias and won’t recognize another brand for being better. Just my analogy.
I really like the rogue tools. Can't wait to watch part two. I am still partial to the standard Polaski. Like your self I have used one on wild land fires and it just feels right. Great video thanks again
I'd like to give the Rogue Pulaski a try. Here in Florida the FFS Pulaski is generally not the preferred hand tool. Mainly due to our softer soils and lack of rocks. Council Rakes work well here but they aren't the tool for cutting through roots
I'm a gardener..an I love the look of these rogue tools..so fed up with tools that are made these days made from crap metal an no thinking of detail goes into them...Thanks i will be buying some mixture of tools of rogue.
We had a few at each of our parks, and I am sure they still do, for trail building and maintenance. I have always wanted to add one to my tool shed simply because of its versatility. Because they are sort of a specialty tool I have never seen them in a regular hardware store or home center.
I would like rogue to add another model to their Pulaski line. One that incorporates a more traditional axe profile. Not to say I don't enjoy the thin profile of the current model, but both profiles have their place. However, it's a tough area of compromise with weight being an ever present issue. Keep up the good work and thank you for the amazing content.
G'day from Tasmania. Great channel. Particularly liked this video. One thought, set up a rig with a hinge at the butt of the tool. Then release each from the same height. Then you can compare their respective bite depth. This rig could be used on axes, mauls, whatever. You could do a 'nest bite board' like top gears lap time board. Cheers.
Good comparison Cody, I always enjoy hearing/seeing your take on tools & gear. Your input is very valuable since you are actually using these items in real life situations. Please keep em coming!!
My take on the extra couple ounces would come from a backpacking perspective. Every ounce I can shave allows me to go that much further or be that much more energized when I arrive at camp. Ounces don't seem like much until you carry them mile after mile or, in this case, swing the axe 50 times.
The Rogue definitely looks like it performs better. It’s also the second in each test, which means you were probably more tuckered out at that point. Just my humble opinion. God bless you and yours and stay safe and healthy, my friend!!
Spent many many (too many) hours cutting hand line with a pulaski. Great (the best) tool for that job. Seems like a lifetime ago but good days. Interested in seeing the conclusion...off to part 2!
While its a tool i would never have a use for hence ill never buy one. I enjoyed that video heaps. Its a credit to youre video making skills that i can sit through and enjoy film on something i have no use or ginuine interest in. Keep up the good work. Thanks
Alright guys, we're going to chill in this cave until the literal fire hurricane outside dies down a bit. YOU CAN'T TELL US WHAT DO!! Did they just....not believe there was a fire tornado?
I think these comparisons, you try to be scientific and compare apples to apples, but one thing that struck me right away is that the number of strokes might give an advantage to the bigger tool with more leverage, all else being equal. When fighting wildfires, effort and time are also important factors, and of these, time is not subjective but effort sure is, and it's a major aspect of the task, one you took some time addressing. Great work, now on to part 2!
good testing/review, I really like the Pulaski, but a new take on it by Rouge seems like a good tool too. Perhaps with some future improvements, one day the Rouge could be better.
Reminds me of my dad building me a potato hilling hoe which he make out of an old cultivator disk, I spent many hours as a kid swinging it in mom's garden. Good to see old steel re-purposed.
You seem to like the familiarity of the FSS axe. One thing that you haven't mentioned yet is the straighter cutting edge on the Rouge axe. Would this be more effective against the more curved edge of the FSS? I have watched a few videos that say to redress the head with a file to get the rounded edge straighter. I'll have a try on my axes at home as one that was left to me by my dad, and belonged to his dad before him, has a very curved cutting edge. Interesting video with plenty of food for thought. Thanks.
Mate, you rock. You show what you want to show and it's always interesting always a pleasure to watch. I thank you sir for all the great videos and the knowledge that you share.
I like the Rogue so far. I have used the old one fighting grass fires in Ok as a soldier. It was so much better than an e tool for clearing fire breaks but the wider and sharper Rogue looked way better.
Getting ready to watch part II, my money is on the Pulaski, narrower grubber means it will move down into the ground around the rocks and stones, i think the Rogue won't be able to do this as well, we'll see! lol
Great comparison. No idea what part 2 holds, but about to watch it now. Love your videos/channel! Hope the fss wins, but doubt it based on part one. Traditional is not always the best but in this case is way sexier a design and more practical for daily use and upkeep.
Always love a classic esthetically pleasing tool that works well based on years of service to professionals. However, sometimes a newer version can be better when we fully get used to it. I'd use the classic Pulaski for more casual 'pleasure' work and the Rogue for larger 'serious Getter Done' work.
I've never used a that type of tool, however I have swung sledges and pick ax. My experience is bigger is better when the task is short term and fast is ideal. But if you are looking at an all day task bigger can wear you down faster and overall with breaks included it's not faster. Like for instance using an etool to fill sand bags is better than a full size shovel
Anyone who has cleared a 1/2 acre of Texas or Tennessee hill country knows the Pulaski- a combination axe and mattock. Liked the vid- and the Rogue tool, but it would be nice to hear from some S.J.s who've dropped into hotspots with it all season to see how that weld and it's edges hold up. Make a rifle-type sling on it & a proper sheath & I'd bet you could carry it all day. Oh yeah- Keep the Faith!
"Don't miss the conclusion of this riveting series." HA! As usual, good video. I haven't watched part 2 yet. I can tell that you really want to like the FSS tool, but we may all be won over by Rogue.
Great comparison, yet your statement of "half the time" for the Rough log chop was wrong, what I assume you meant was, half the strokes. I wasn't timing the event, but the Pulaski was equal in time if not faster due to quicker release after every chop.
We used to make these when I worked for the NPS. We called them super pulaskis or super Ps. The problem with the rogue tool axe is, it is too narrow, thats why it sticks. The problem with the FSS pulaski is the grub end is too small. Hence the creation of the superP. I have seen them around since the mid-80s.A great tool
the traditional style looks better aesthetically to me, and it seems more economical. I think it would be the better tool, easier to store/haul around, less bulky, tried and true design, seems to not stick into the wood as bad.
I was thinking the rogue might tire you out a bit more grubbing. Which is harder, moving more dirt each pull, or more pulls because you are moving less each time?
The Rogue doesn't look as slick, but the wider hoe is the key. I will probably invest in one at some time. I do think Cody you are favoring the Rogue, however, the performance speaks for itself. Thanks for the review!
As a 6'6 Firefighter, I have had good results with Rouge brand tools. Almost all of them have longer handles, and that helps me stay upright. The Pulaski, a great tool, seems undersized for tall men. Perfect for the generation it was created!
I'm not even near as tall as you and the difference I noticed with a long handle on our homemade "Super-Ps" was significant. I've used the Rogue hoe but never their pulaski. Looks great.
1911 was a good year for metal tools!
Thank you for telling the story of Ed Pulaski. I believe that was the Peshtigo fire, which broke out the same day as the Great Chicago Fire. This fire began Oct. 8, 1871 in and around Peshtigo, Wisconsin. It was a terribly dry year. The Peshtigo fire caused more property damage but the fire in the city got all the press coverage. But this fire took between 1200 and 2400 lives.
I love knowing the background details. Thanks for the history lesson.
It wasn’t the Peshtigo Fire… it was the Great Fire of 1910 a few decades later (even I had to look it up, as Peshtigo didn’t sound quite right). I didn’t even know that 5 of his men didn’t heed his orders and perished.
@@TexasFire_Cross If anyone else is interested in the story of Ed Pulaski and the actual fire he fought (in 1910), I highly recommend the documentary The Big Burn by American Experience on PBS. You can watch it for free here on on UA-cam. One of the many heroes of such a watershed moment in the history of firefighting and the US Forest Service.
Not sure I have a need for a Pulaski, but I love the videos and appreciate you enthusiasm and thoughtfulness.
As someone who grew up in a small town--chopping wood and playing in the forests--who now lives in a big city, I just love watching your videos. Also, as an artist, I admire your craftsmanship when building or modifying tools. Favourite new UA-cam channel, for sure. (Also, great production values and editing!)
You have stated on multiple videos to like the video as do many others and I never do until now. For no reason really but I have been enjoying your channel for the last year or so now. We have a remote 5 acres on Kodiak Island here in Alaska and we are just starting our journey to start some forestry stewardship and tree removal to make room for our eventual family second home / retirement homestead. I absolutely LOVE your content and your approach to your videos. I have built your cantilevered work bench in my shop already and my Christmas list continues to grow based on your videos like this. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!!! And keep up the great videos and content I learn something new from EVERY video and it inspires me!
I’m not sure I’ve seen all of your videos on UA-cam Cody, but I seen the vast majority and love them. Keep up the good work and god bless. You are living the real American dream👍👍👍👍👍
Darn, I just bought the original. My one and only experience with the Polaski is building a switchback trail in the back country in Idaho. I was so impressed with that tool I thanked Mr. Polaski every day :-). The new one I just acquired is due to a divorce couple years ago.
I have been looking at buying a Rogue Pulaski. Thanks for putting the tool through its paces!!! Great Job!!!
Hi, I'm loving your channel. You sir and your families story, are an inspiration to us as we undertake our own relocation and completely new beginning. From the valleys of South Wales to The Highlands Of Scotland later this year. Thank you. Regards Jason.
Ok, as for a requested comment,I already have two FSS Pulasky axes.They were given to me by a retired fireman that I've done some yard work for,one is used,the other never has been,the Rouge looks useful,personally,I can't justify buying one,the FSS works fine..when I need it for a specific task,thank you for the vid though,I will most likely,eventually buy one anyway,now that I know It exists.
I have been a subscriber now for about 2 months or so and along with watching all your new videos as you post them I have been binge watching all your other videos in between. Great channel Cody.
This was great timing!! I was looking at Rogue's website last night then checked your channel and this video showed up!!
Looks like a great tool built the right way!! I'm tempted to get a few of their tools to add to my arsenal.
Keep up the great work Cody!!
Another great review... Hope you and the family are all ready for winter.... Would love to see additional videos on how you prepare the homestead for winter.....
Love the real world test that you implement. Thanks for the work you put into these videos!
Thank you Cody for all of the great quality videos you put out there. I am only 15, but you made an impact on my life.
Cody, I'm building a 6*6 type 3 truck for my department as we speak. I'm 90% sure most, if not all of my hand tools will be Rogue tools. Thanks for introducing me to what appears to be outstanding tools.
Longer handle=more leverage and torque. It's gonna hit harder and feel heavier. It's the principle of why holding an 8 pound weight out with your arm isn't as hard as holding an 8 pound sledge out by the end of the handle.
Also the head could just be poorly balanced
I would go with the Rogue , it would help me out with mountain bike trails . thanks for your great info & videos
I think that the FSS is still gonna be around for a while and possibly even passed on to your son, because it is a classic and a beautiful tool to behold.
But You gotta love the absolute functionality of the ROGUE tool and its tough resilient features.
Both are attractive accompaniments in the same situations however for usibility and easy tool maintenance on the path, ROGUE!!
Looking forward to part 2!!
Thanks Wranglerstar.
Its worth the Effort. Your channel has definitely shaped my life for the better.
Two crewmembers of mine ordered a few Rogue tools to use personally on the line, and most of them broke under relatively little use.. One broke clean off at the welds and the others broke off at the handles under "normal" use. They were Rogue hoes, not the Pulaski-esque too. Just FYI from other actual Rogue users.
One is a finely made effective tool, the other is a welded pos.
Love the responsibility outro! Right on.. Im not sure that you relize youre doing it but in these comparison posts you always seem to favor one tool or the other! In fairness, your final reviews seem to compensate for it but i am deeply, genuinly interested in knowing what is the best! Either way i cant stop watching your videos and please stay true and keep them coming!!
The bias often comes out. It’s probably true of most people though. Ford, Dodge, or Chevy... most people have a bias and won’t recognize another brand for being better. Just my analogy.
I really like the rogue tools. Can't wait to watch part two. I am still partial to the standard Polaski. Like your self I have used one on wild land fires and it just feels right. Great video thanks again
Really appreciate your time and effort doing these tool reviews. Thanks!
Fascinating comparisons so far!
Excited to finally see more than a quick clip of the Rouge Pulaski.
I'd like to give the Rogue Pulaski a try. Here in Florida the FFS Pulaski is generally not the preferred hand tool. Mainly due to our softer soils and lack of rocks. Council Rakes work well here but they aren't the tool for cutting through roots
If I ever get a homestead you are making my tool wish list really long.
I'm a gardener..an I love the look of these rogue tools..so fed up with tools that are made these days made from crap metal an no thinking of detail goes into them...Thanks i will be buying some mixture of tools of rogue.
I think I need one of these Rogue Polaskis. Thanks for your test.
I don't believe the old design can be replaced. It is a testament to a timeless design.
We had a few at each of our parks, and I am sure they still do, for trail building and maintenance. I have always wanted to add one to my tool shed simply because of its versatility. Because they are sort of a specialty tool I have never seen them in a regular hardware store or home center.
I would like rogue to add another model to their Pulaski line. One that incorporates a more traditional axe profile. Not to say I don't enjoy the thin profile of the current model, but both profiles have their place. However, it's a tough area of compromise with weight being an ever present issue.
Keep up the good work and thank you for the amazing content.
The Rogue is my fav. I like the look of there stuff you have shown
Enjoyed this. Haven't used a Pulaski in 40 years. That was a fun summer of hard work and good money.
I've used the original Rogue tool for cutting fire line and liked it very much. Thanks for the comparison review.
- danofiremano
G'day from Tasmania. Great channel. Particularly liked this video. One thought, set up a rig with a hinge at the butt of the tool. Then release each from the same height. Then you can compare their respective bite depth. This rig could be used on axes, mauls, whatever. You could do a 'nest bite board' like top gears lap time board. Cheers.
Good comparison Cody, I always enjoy hearing/seeing your take on tools & gear. Your input is very valuable since you are actually using these items in real life situations. Please keep em coming!!
Another well thought out and expertly produced video. Thank you.
My take on the extra couple ounces would come from a backpacking perspective. Every ounce I can shave allows me to go that much further or be that much more energized when I arrive at camp. Ounces don't seem like much until you carry them mile after mile or, in this case, swing the axe 50 times.
Excellent head to head contest. Two Great tools.
The Rogue definitely looks like it performs better. It’s also the second in each test, which means you were probably more tuckered out at that point. Just my humble opinion. God bless you and yours and stay safe and healthy, my friend!!
Looks like a good tool. I think I will still pick up an FSS Pulaski first though. The FSS is such a great looking tool.
Spent many many (too many) hours cutting hand line with a pulaski. Great (the best) tool for that job. Seems like a lifetime ago but good days. Interested in seeing the conclusion...off to part 2!
Great! Love these comparisons. I love hearing your opinion and value it highly.
Great comparison .thanks cody
I still use a Warwood Forest Adze. It's also stamped Forest Service.
in the rural fire service we use a mcloud tool. very efficient for Australian conditions
While its a tool i would never have a use for hence ill never buy one. I enjoyed that video heaps. Its a credit to youre video making skills that i can sit through and enjoy film on something i have no use or ginuine interest in. Keep up the good work. Thanks
I like all the videos you upload. My family came from Southern Oregon when logging was all done by hand.
I think the rogue is definitely a tool to add to your arsenal for any one better chopper and digger and a great price for a proper tool
Fair-handed, informative. Well done.
Alright guys, we're going to chill in this cave until the literal fire hurricane outside dies down a bit.
YOU CAN'T TELL US WHAT DO!!
Did they just....not believe there was a fire tornado?
Kind of seems applicable today, this comment aged well.
Love the new look of the rogue tool!
I think these comparisons, you try to be scientific and compare apples to apples, but one thing that struck me right away is that the number of strokes might give an advantage to the bigger tool with more leverage, all else being equal. When fighting wildfires, effort and time are also important factors, and of these, time is not subjective but effort sure is, and it's a major aspect of the task, one you took some time addressing. Great work, now on to part 2!
Ready to watch part 2
I wonder what the comparison would be if handle lengths were equal? Interesting results so far! Thanks for taking time to do such a real world test!
looking forward to part 2 on this series. Curious to find out the price points as well.
good testing/review, I really like the Pulaski, but a new take on it by Rouge seems like a good tool too. Perhaps with some future improvements, one day the Rouge could be better.
In rocky terrain the narrow grubbing tool holds advantage
Both are nice looking tools
Reminds me of my dad building me a potato hilling hoe which he make out of an old cultivator disk, I spent many hours as a kid swinging it in mom's garden. Good to see old steel re-purposed.
Nice test... Good review. Ready for part 2!
You seem to like the familiarity of the FSS axe. One thing that you haven't mentioned yet is the straighter cutting edge on the Rouge axe. Would this be more effective against the more curved edge of the FSS? I have watched a few videos that say to redress the head with a file to get the rounded edge straighter. I'll have a try on my axes at home as one that was left to me by my dad, and belonged to his dad before him, has a very curved cutting edge.
Interesting video with plenty of food for thought. Thanks.
Mate, you rock. You show what you want to show and it's always interesting always a pleasure to watch. I thank you sir for all the great videos and the knowledge that you share.
Glad ur doing this style of vid again
I love tool vs tool reviews!
Excellent video. Thanks.
Great video ! Can't wait to see part 2 !
I just built a handle for my USFS Pulaski this past weekend.
Thank you for the continued effort in your videos and the invitation to comment. It's the interaction that is so important here on UA-cam.
thank you for yet another amazing video
I like the Rogue so far. I have used the old one fighting grass fires in Ok as a soldier. It was so much better than an e tool for clearing fire breaks but the wider and sharper Rogue looked way better.
I have not used any of the tools but having seen this video if i had a to choose i would go with the FSS any day of the week
Looks like a great tool
Getting ready to watch part II, my money is on the Pulaski, narrower grubber means it will move down into the ground around the rocks and stones, i think the Rogue won't be able to do this as well, we'll see! lol
Thank you Cody, I know some of these videos have to tax you, but your tough you can take it . awesome show Cody, thank you.
Great comparison. No idea what part 2 holds, but about to watch it now. Love your videos/channel! Hope the fss wins, but doubt it based on part one. Traditional is not always the best but in this case is way sexier a design and more practical for daily use and upkeep.
Really respect your work!
I will never fight fires for a living. BUT I enjoyed your test. Keep up the good work.
Fun to watch; and, it's good to see you back on track...now, on to part II (I'm betting the Rogue wins out.) :>)
Always love a classic esthetically pleasing tool that works well based on years of service to professionals. However, sometimes a newer version can be better when we fully get used to it. I'd use the classic Pulaski for more casual 'pleasure' work and the Rogue for larger 'serious Getter Done' work.
Great job on the video....keep them coming....exact information I was looking for.
I've never used a that type of tool, however I have swung sledges and pick ax. My experience is bigger is better when the task is short term and fast is ideal. But if you are looking at an all day task bigger can wear you down faster and overall with breaks included it's not faster. Like for instance using an etool to fill sand bags is better than a full size shovel
Great videos! Thanks for the great entertainment Cody
I've got a Collins Pulaski. Strongest & best built one i have ever seen or used.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR HONEST, PERSONAL OPINIONS,YOUR A BLESSED MAN WITH A SPECIAL GIFT. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK AND ENJOY THAT FAMILY OF YOURS.
Can’t beat the axe, kit, and tool videos
Thanks for the great video!
Anyone who has cleared a 1/2 acre of Texas or Tennessee hill country knows the Pulaski- a combination axe and mattock. Liked the vid- and the Rogue tool, but it would be nice to hear from some S.J.s who've dropped into hotspots with it all season to see how that weld and it's edges hold up. Make a rifle-type sling on it & a proper sheath & I'd bet you could carry it all day. Oh yeah- Keep the Faith!
"Don't miss the conclusion of this riveting series."
HA!
As usual, good video. I haven't watched part 2 yet. I can tell that you really want to like the FSS tool, but we may all be won over by Rogue.
Great video can definitely see the work you do to make such great videos.
good video, I definitely like the old style polaski more than the new one. I don't like how the new version is welded together.
Great comparison, yet your statement of "half the time" for the Rough log chop was wrong, what I assume you meant was, half the strokes. I wasn't timing the event, but the Pulaski was equal in time if not faster due to quicker release after every chop.
I've used the Pulaski quite extensively, really would like to try the rogue olllllllo
Thank you for your awesome videos! I have learned so much!
We used to make these when I worked for the NPS. We called them super pulaskis or super Ps.
The problem with the rogue tool axe is, it is too narrow, thats why it sticks.
The problem with the FSS pulaski is the grub end is too small.
Hence the creation of the superP. I have seen them around since the mid-80s.A great tool
the traditional style looks better aesthetically to me, and it seems more economical. I think it would be the better tool, easier to store/haul around, less bulky, tried and true design, seems to not stick into the wood as bad.
I don’t mind a few more swings if I don’t have to pry it out
I was thinking the rogue might tire you out a bit more grubbing. Which is harder, moving more dirt each pull, or more pulls because you are moving less each time?
The Rogue doesn't look as slick, but the wider hoe is the key. I will probably invest in one at some time. I do think Cody you are favoring the Rogue, however, the performance speaks for itself. Thanks for the review!
Great videos! You have shown to me that axes are very interesting.