Hope you enjoy this Northern European Thermopylae ;) 🚩 If you'd like to support what we do, you can do so on Patreon: www.patreon.com/historymarche - By joining us on Patreon you get to see our videos before everyone else, ads free, and periodically you can vote to choose topics for our channel.
*Remember the legend* I can only be patient and keep making videos. I'm quite thankful I've reached 20k subscrivers, truly means a lot. *Abdullah Al Mamun* My patrons decide which battle will be chosen for the next video, but I can include a topic from the Mughal empire when the next voting comes up.
@ Pyrphoros Today the Dutch and the Danish are B.F.F. :-), but Denmark then wasn't that nice and 'hygge' country known (and loved :-) today. It was rather an expansionist super-power, controlling the whole baltic region...! (more like Russia in the cold-war-era...!)
I`d flee too... They`d smear cow shit on my armor... But this battle shows why knights were fazed from battlefields, and only kept in some "upgraded forms" like Ottoman Sipahi or Polish- Lithuanian Hussars- they were too immobile, and unable to fight in specyfic situation, while their pesant militia counter part was vastly cheaper to maintain. But we have to remeber- knights fought on both sides of this conflict...
@ There were men at arms, who "were armored like a knight"- and by thst time Western Europe lost their lance wielding skill- one of my kinsmen(circa 1510) was watching Spaniards at Tournamet and he noticed that 2 "knights" passed each other 12 times without breaking their lances. It was observed all over Wester Europe, that lance was no longer deciding factor in combat... Only musket or pistols Though I always wanted to know where they managed to find 2000 knights... If i remember correctly even Teutonic Order had about 500 Knights at best... And they were "Knightly Order"...
iam from dithmarschen and i have to say u did a great job. also in germany this incredible battle is mostly unknown, but we dithmarschens are proud of this battle, free farmers fought for there freedom against superior knights and won. After the battle they only burried the poor foodmen, not the knights. The sentence "Look out Guard! Here come the peasants!" in origin" Ward de Gard de Bur de kümmt!"
What is so ingenious avout Wulf Isebrand’s plan is that normally when you ambush somebody you pick a chokepoint, hide your forces there and trick the enemy into thinking it is safe to pass there. So the attack is the surprise, Wulf Isebrand turned that around. He used his meager forces as bait and hid the choakpoint using flooding which not only hid the drainage ditches but also quickly turned the land into what it originally was, a bog. On top of that he carefully engineered a crowd disaster. I’ve seen a partial casualty lists of Danish/German deaths from Hemmingsted (nobles only, of course). All the men from whole families were killed there, knights and nobles with all of their sons. To add insult to injury the Dittmarshians buried the common soldiers after the battle but left the bodies of nobles to be eaten by wild animals.
Baltic Hammer It was just a partial list of names of Danish and German aristocrats killed at Hemmingstedt, no details of where they came from. It was sent to the bishop of Bremen in the hope he could get the Ditmarshians to hand the remains over for burial. There was hardly a noble family in Denmark or N-Germany who did not lose a relative at Hemmingstedt.
HistoryMarche I’d take that with a grain of salt. It is one of those things that is often said but I’m not certain if it actually happened. That being said, I did read it on an info tablet at the official memorial to the battle at Hemmingstedt so there is probably some truth to this story. It also sounds right since nobles from surrounding areas had been trying to subjugate the Ditmarshians on and off for centuries and the nobles were pretty brutal about it. There was not a spark of love lost there. The memorial is worth visiting. The Ditmarshians are still very proud of this victory (and so they should be). They have built a massive diorama showing the battle in a display case with literally hundreds of tin soldiers on a terrain model of the battlefield complete with houses. It's a bit hard to find though. I'm glad you found the time to cover Hemmingstedt, IMHO it is one of the most ingeniously planned ambushes of the entire Middle Ages. Like Gallipoli and the battles in the Karelian Isthmus during the Winter War, Hemmingstedt is a classic example of how to use terrain as a weapon.
I think I've seen parts of that battle display in pictures, it looked awesome! There is a chance I will visit my brother in Sweden so I might take a detour to see the memorial, it would definitely be worth the trip.
cresswelled only -2 crossing penalties? I mean the Danish commander is probably only 1 command star while the peasant commander already maxed out his command star ratings.
That would br Sun Tzu's response to most of Danish millitary history, our kings and generals allways found new and inventive ways of turning victories into defeats.
6:08 - "An act of desperation or clever planning" - lovely quote! Applies to most out of box thinking in history - Desperation if you lose and clever if you win. Finally got a chance to see this. Amazing video as always!
Clearly Wulf Isebrand was one of those very talented field commanders who unfortunately has, for a long time, been not as well-mentioned as they should have been. It is clear from this video that Isebrand used an effective strategy that denied the Danes their numerical superiority while giving him a stronger front.
He also acted decisively rushing to fortify and defend the only spot where they could stand a chance. Timely action and applied mastering of command is what makes a great general from a (only) good strategist.
The guy had natural talent, and we don't know much about him. Perhaps he served as a mercenary in his native land, before settling down? There was clearly a reason that he was chosen to lead the militia.
It’s too bad this was the only time he lead an army. I’m guessing he was a minor noble who had served as a junior officer in some war or wars before leaving, which is he knew how to prepare and command. More importantly, he knew the deceptively complicated landscape intimately and was able to use that to create a position, which would have never been attacked if the Danish thought they would really stand and fight.
My ancestors come from Dithmarschen and my grandma often told me the story. And she told me that there were many small ditches under water. You must not forget that Dithmarschen is situated directly at the North Sea. So when they opened the flood gates several big and much more small diches were flooded. And that´s where the heavy armour of the Danish knights were fatal. It made them so heavy that they couldn´t get out of the ditches and drowned whereas the men of Dithmarschen used their long sticks to jump over the ditches. And by the way - I know from experience that the folks from Dithmarschen are extremely stubborn by nature. No wonder they even fought the Danish army.
As a local I can say you are god damn right, in Heide, it is still celebrated every two years, as part of the festival we call “Marktfrieden” or market peace. We celebrate how the city was founded as a gathering place for merchants and remember our medieval heritage. They also show the same theater piece, every time, it is a dramatization of the events that lead up to the battle up to the victory. And we never talk about 1559.
thx for reply^^ what will your next video be? oh btw, will you be covering 30 years war?? tbh I've never learnt anything about 30 years wars. Im curious
Have you heard of the campaigns' of Napoleon and Hitler into Russia? They are very famous examples of not fighting in winter. Of course the cause behind losing wasn't only due to the bitter Russian winter, I don't know about Hitler but Napoleon wasn't stupid or ghastly ignorant, why his campaign failed had a lot more to it than the Russian winter. But still these are two very famous examples.
It depends mate on the area you live in.And the harshness of the winters. Epaminontas of Thebes marched in winter (armies never marched on winter in that era in Greece)and totally surprised the Spartans crushed them and freed Helot cities all over the Peloponnese. He put the final nail in the coffin in their military supremacy in the region. Romans adored that guy and considered him a great tactician , regarded as great as Alexander in their eyes :) . ua-cam.com/video/Om7sJKCTp10/v-deo.html
The details during the battle are incredible it makes it so much more interesting. It's as if you were actually there and had written down the details which maneuvers were taken and how. So much better than blocks just crashing into each other and instantly disintegrating (you might know which channel I refer to). Once again excellent video I started to miss you haha. Too bad you are on your own it takes a lot of effort to make one video I can really see that. Hope you find some assistant soon when you grow bigger ( which you undoubtedly will). You are up there with bazbattles haha.
That was great. :) I am actually more intrigued about the history and motivation behind Dithmarsians though. How did they resist the might of entire countries for so long and why did they persist in such overwhelming odds? Sounds like a fascinating culture/society in history. Thanks for the hard work.
I religiously follow all the channels which cover battles of history, and though I usually never comment on them, I felt the need to make an exception in this case, as this has been my favorite animation style out of all of the channels of this genre. Fantastic work!
I'm very impressed with this channel. Great video, I have never heard of this battle before so it was real interesting to learn about it from your vocal description and graphics.
Damn good video, amazing graphics. It's nice to hear a story of peasant's defeating a monarchist army after having just been reading about the Germany peasant's war.
This channel is always an education. I loved hearing about this "farmers' republic," and I appreciate the info that surfaces in banners after the closing. Sad to hear about the torture and the "take no prisoners," but it is good to have it addressed. Great voice over work by Alex Doddy.
Sad reality about prisoners is that, during the course of "normal" warfare of the medieval period, only nobles were taken prisoner and the common peasant or mercenary soldier could expect to be executed if captured. So when peasant uprisings and resistance happened, they tended to defy convention and execute the nobles too, because they knew the same would happen to them.
Brett DuVale thank you for the info. These “incidentals” are fascinating parts of History Marche videos, like the Spanish townspeople sold into slavery by Hannibal after they unsuccessfully resisted a siege.
It is still used in parts of northern germany. Mostly in frisian areas and more in some kind of lowland games. The danish black guard should have known it too. they were mercenaries from netherlands and frisian areas like Groningen.
Yes it's definitely good to have a sponsor on a video. It's still not a huge deal financially though since my channel is still small, and the fees are smaller as well. I'm still not approved for UA-cam partnership so I have nothing flowing in there, but there is Patreon, I'm thankful to my patrons from the bottom of my heart, really.
This video is sponsored by *Total Battle.* Check out their awesome website to learn more: *totalbattle.com/en/* Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed the video please like, subscribe, comment and share. And if you’re feeling generous visit our Patreon page. Every dollar helps. Patreon link: *www.patreon.com/historymarche*
BazBattles, Epic History and Kings and General are teams. This one here is apparently one Dude. Those Channels also used to be slow at the begining, but as they master their craft, expand their team and upgrade their equipment, they get to crank out videos faster without loosing quality.
Thats the plan. HistoryMarche does all the animation, writing etc... on his own. The only other person involved is myself just doing the voiceover. The goal is to definitely put out bigger and better content more regularly. Its just going to take a bit of time
I wish to say, that having watched his video when it came out, the whole production keeps me coming back for more. The story is awesome as I always love an underdog story. Thank you for making such a wonderful video. I wish you much for success as you already have because you do a fantastic job.
@@HistoryMarche This is truly one of the best youtube videos I've ever seen, from the animation, to the narration, to the overall narrative itself. Absolutely fantastic.
Great piece of history! Where do men get the courage to oppose such a vast army with a few hundred of their fellows? This is true heroism, and the story deserves to be known far and wide. We may need such courage in the days ahead. Thank you very much for this great video!
black guard's battle cry : "look out peasants ,here comes the guard" peasants : seems original,let's make a change to it "look out guard,here comes to peasants" badass
Ya know what? I'm not even mad that the Danes lost this one, even though I am one. The Dithmarsians fought incredibly well here, choosing a battleground that fit them perfectly, neutralizing the Danes' numerical superiority, holding their defensive line without wavering, and carrying out well timed and well placed counter-attacks.
The nice thing is - that land looked like one would just manage to run through there - it was a treacherous swampy-icey landscape with, at the horizon, hints of a hills and a forest in sight. If in a rout, it would not seem like there was no escape to a panicked mind if in fact, there was none.
This is the first video that I have watched from your channel after being referred here by one of my favorite channels, History Time. I have to say that I like what I see so, here, have a sub.
Led his people to triumph in a battle where they were outnumbered 12 to 1, captured his enemy's national standard, and became a father, all at once. If you could only be remembered by history for one day in your life, Wulf Isebrand certainly managed to pick a good one.
Wow, the militiamen commander was a genius.The flooding, the amazing courage of the peasants that managed to hold their grounds when fighing against better equipped and trained soldiers without having casualties, and the way of not recklessly surrounding the enemy. All those totally remind me lelouch's strategic genius from code geass
As a student of history, your channel is very good. I just found it couple of days ago and have watched almost all the videos. I would love to see a linear warfare video at some point. Maybe the battle of Saratoga, battle of Gettysburg, battle of culloden, battle of Austerlitz. Keep up the good work!
As part of a joint venture, History Marche has been animating a fantastic Napoleonic series with Epic history, over on their channel, which may grab your attention!
@HistoryMarche It’s not just that your videos are perfectly animated, your choice of which battle to cover is fenomenal! P.S. When is the second part of the Second Punic War coming?
Thank you very much for your kind words and feedback Saša :) There might be another video before part 2 of the Second Punic War. I'm still not sure which topic will be covered as my patrons will decide that in a vote that I'll start in about a week - usually I compile a list of topics and from there my patrons choose what will be produced.
Really love the channel and videos, you can really see Sun Tzu's art of war in practice here!!! Looking forward to more videos with battles, from Antiquity to Middle Ages and WW2. Great work!! Kudos to the team that make the research and videos
Thank you so much for your generous words. The research, writing and animation team consists of: Me. I'd surely love to have more people though. Voice over is done by Alex, he's doing an awesome job.
Post scriptum: the place where this happend is now called "Dusenddüwelswarf", thats local dialect an means "hill of the thousand devils". Every dithmarsian man knows this name :-)
I've been slowly watching all of the battles on your channel, and I love them. But I don't understand how any story about any battle could possibly top this one. It's such an entertaining story.
I've read that in most cases battles are not won by killing all enemy, but around 25% often proves to be the breaking point that starts a rout, which cascades into mass slaughter and last stands. This is especially true in battles with low visibility and communication, and to armies with less discipline and have not been trained to rally. Armies like the Romans learned to leave their best troops in reserve and expect the less experienced troops to fall back once they wear down the enemy, while medieval french and german armies often charged headon with their nobleman leaders taking the lead, once they die, the battle falls apart.
Like the Spartans at Leuctra, the destruction of the most elite unit usually results in other troops routing. Hannibal however subverted the Roman tactic of three lines three times, always using flanking and pincers to force the Triarii elite to fight. No small wonder he won Trebia, Tresamine and Cannae. Like Alexander and Epaminondas Hannibal went for the throat.
Also looking forward to the next one maybe even cunning battles such as some that were exemplified in The art of war by Sun Tzu, and not just cunning tactics aswell as costs. Although i can't complain, i enjoy these just as much.
Wow, now I understand what took you so much time of no doing videos, THIS ANIMATION IS AWESOME!! everything is better, now we can clearly see terrain and units are better, too. However, the troops look kinda like flags, is this on purpose? I think that it would be better if they were more like LEGO bricks at the start, and when they are being defeated and start routing, they turn more into the troops in this animation, like flags, as if they had lost their organization and strength. Also, it’s nice to see a non-medieval battle
Glad you liked the video. The troops "bend" over the features of terrain, that's why they may have reminded you of flags. Lego suggestion is worth considering, thanks.
This battle reminds me of a more famous 'peasant' country resisting subjugating from a far more powerful feudal kingdom in Morgarten. In that battle the Swiss Confederacy also managed to beat back the might of the Hapsburgs. I didn't realize there was another autonomous region bordering the Holy Roman Empire who's denizens also fought as mercenaries. I wonder if the Dithmarsians and Swiss ever opened up diplomatic relations because they are very similar in a lot of ways.
Isebrand going back to obscurity reminds me of a Roman general who just wanted to go back to his farm. I find men like these who fight for duty and to protect their land and people greater and more honourable than men who fight for power, glory or pillaging, even if said men were genius generals.
Thanks. As a Dane this battle is known albeit not in these details. The aftermath is very interesting. An depressing for me. Please make a video about that too.
Hope you enjoy this Northern European Thermopylae ;) 🚩 If you'd like to support what we do, you can do so on Patreon: www.patreon.com/historymarche - By joining us on Patreon you get to see our videos before everyone else, ads free, and periodically you can vote to choose topics for our channel.
It's better than Thermopylae because the underdog defenders actually won!
Agreed.
HistoryMarche make video on Mughal empire
*Remember the legend* I can only be patient and keep making videos. I'm quite thankful I've reached 20k subscrivers, truly means a lot.
*Abdullah Al Mamun* My patrons decide which battle will be chosen for the next video, but I can include a topic from the Mughal empire when the next voting comes up.
Will you please make the Spartan Thermoplae 480BC
This is why you never auto-resolve a battle.
lol
This peasant commander obviously first used cheat then auto-resolved.
Good one
Actually auto-resolve woulda been better in this case. :D
Yes indeed
>Either a Dutch or German immigrant
>Floods his own land to protect it
Totally Dutch.
Haha
A real dutch would not fight the danes but fight the sea itselfe to claim more land!
I want to know what the commander named the kid.
Isebrand have battle-harden german commoner and Landsknecht sword with him.
@ Pyrphoros
Today the Dutch and the Danish are B.F.F. :-), but Denmark then wasn't that nice and 'hygge' country known (and loved :-) today.
It was rather an expansionist super-power, controlling the whole baltic region...!
(more like Russia in the cold-war-era...!)
I laughed like crazy at the peasants' battlecry. "Look out, Guards, here comes the peasants."
Yeah, kind of ironic :D It's like: "What ever you can do, we can do too".
I got goosebumps. Then I almost cried. It's so beautiful. :')
I`d flee too... They`d smear cow shit on my armor...
But this battle shows why knights were fazed from battlefields, and only kept in some "upgraded forms" like Ottoman Sipahi or Polish- Lithuanian Hussars- they were too immobile, and unable to fight in specyfic situation, while their pesant militia counter part was vastly cheaper to maintain.
But we have to remeber- knights fought on both sides of this conflict...
The best line I've heard in a long time!
@ There were men at arms, who "were armored like a knight"- and by thst time Western Europe lost their lance wielding skill- one of my kinsmen(circa 1510) was watching Spaniards at Tournamet and he noticed that 2 "knights" passed each other 12 times without breaking their lances. It was observed all over Wester Europe, that lance was no longer deciding factor in combat... Only musket or pistols
Though I always wanted to know where they managed to find 2000 knights... If i remember correctly even Teutonic Order had about 500 Knights at best... And they were "Knightly Order"...
iam from dithmarschen and i have to say u did a great job. also in germany this incredible battle is mostly unknown, but we dithmarschens are proud of this battle, free farmers fought for there freedom against superior knights and won. After the battle they only burried the poor foodmen, not the knights. The sentence "Look out Guard! Here come the peasants!" in origin" Ward de Gard de Bur de kümmt!"
Very nice to hear compliments from someone who's local to the area. Thank you.
@Sir Wojak IV Nice! Did your grandpa see the vid?
Meine Mutter ist auch aus ditmarschen interessant wie klein die Welt doch ist xD
@@HistoryMarche War de gaar de bur kümmt
Respects to these peasants
What is so ingenious avout Wulf Isebrand’s plan is that normally when you ambush somebody you pick a chokepoint, hide your forces there and trick the enemy into thinking it is safe to pass there. So the attack is the surprise, Wulf Isebrand turned that around. He used his meager forces as bait and hid the choakpoint using flooding which not only hid the drainage ditches but also quickly turned the land into what it originally was, a bog. On top of that he carefully engineered a crowd disaster. I’ve seen a partial casualty lists of Danish/German deaths from Hemmingsted (nobles only, of course). All the men from whole families were killed there, knights and nobles with all of their sons. To add insult to injury the Dittmarshians buried the common soldiers after the battle but left the bodies of nobles to be eaten by wild animals.
Oh wow, thanks for that information. I didn't know that the fallen nobles were left to rot in the open. Fabulous info!
Kristján Rúnarsson
Do the casualty lists have the home town of the person?
Baltic Hammer It was just a partial list of names of Danish and German aristocrats killed at Hemmingstedt, no details of where they came from. It was sent to the bishop of Bremen in the hope he could get the Ditmarshians to hand the remains over for burial. There was hardly a noble family in Denmark or N-Germany who did not lose a relative at Hemmingstedt.
HistoryMarche I’d take that with a grain of salt. It is one of those things that is often said but I’m not certain if it actually happened. That being said, I did read it on an info tablet at the official memorial to the battle at Hemmingstedt so there is probably some truth to this story. It also sounds right since nobles from surrounding areas had been trying to subjugate the Ditmarshians on and off for centuries and the nobles were pretty brutal about it. There was not a spark of love lost there. The memorial is worth visiting. The Ditmarshians are still very proud of this victory (and so they should be). They have built a massive diorama showing the battle in a display case with literally hundreds of tin soldiers on a terrain model of the battlefield complete with houses. It's a bit hard to find though. I'm glad you found the time to cover Hemmingstedt, IMHO it is one of the most ingeniously planned ambushes of the entire Middle Ages. Like Gallipoli and the battles in the Karelian Isthmus during the Winter War, Hemmingstedt is a classic example of how to use terrain as a weapon.
I think I've seen parts of that battle display in pictures, it looked awesome! There is a chance I will visit my brother in Sweden so I might take a detour to see the memorial, it would definitely be worth the trip.
"And they had one gun". The moment you know it will be an epic battle.
Great stuff. Superb animations and a brilliant telling of a little-known but fascinating engagement.
Thanks man, mu ch appreciated :D
I guess the Danes shouldn't have tried to fight with -2 crossing penalties.
Rofl
cresswelled only -2 crossing penalties? I mean the Danish commander is probably only 1 command star while the peasant commander already maxed out his command star ratings.
-3 actually, its a high land + a river crossing.
12000 to 1000 should have been an auto stackwipe
Love all the Europa Universalis IV references in this thread. I just vassalized Dithmarschen as Brandenburg in my game. Their 3k stack fights well. ;)
And Sun Tzu was face palming so hard in his grave...
...indeed...
...failing conquerors make always the same mistakes...!
He would have been proud of the peasants
That would br Sun Tzu's response to most of Danish millitary history, our kings and generals allways found new and inventive ways of turning victories into defeats.
😜
@Glenn Krenz That's just mainly due to different writing styles though. It doesn't negate the principles that Sun Tzu taught in his book.
"Look out Guard, here come the Peasants!" Is the sickest quote in the history of warfare.
6:08 - "An act of desperation or clever planning" - lovely quote! Applies to most out of box thinking in history - Desperation if you lose and clever if you win. Finally got a chance to see this. Amazing video as always!
Thank you so much mate. Glad you liked it.
Desperation is often the mother of genius.
"look out guard here comes the peasant" XDD
Clearly Wulf Isebrand was one of those very talented field commanders who unfortunately has, for a long time, been not as well-mentioned as they should have been. It is clear from this video that Isebrand used an effective strategy that denied the Danes their numerical superiority while giving him a stronger front.
He also acted decisively rushing to fortify and defend the only spot where they could stand a chance. Timely action and applied mastering of command is what makes a great general from a (only) good strategist.
Glenn Krenz winning a battle when outnumbered 15 to 1 is no small feat at all, especially when your force is militia
The guy had natural talent, and we don't know much about him. Perhaps he served as a mercenary in his native land, before settling down? There was clearly a reason that he was chosen to lead the militia.
It’s too bad this was the only time he lead an army. I’m guessing he was a minor noble who had served as a junior officer in some war or wars before leaving, which is he knew how to prepare and command. More importantly, he knew the deceptively complicated landscape intimately and was able to use that to create a position, which would have never been attacked if the Danish thought they would really stand and fight.
Seeing a force known for the atrocities it commits be decimated mercilessly is a good feeling.
Get rekt black guards!
Exactly my thought. I’m guessing they acted like Russian soldiers.
Was rooting for Dithmarschen the whole time! :)
Gotta support the underdog!
Same
was rooting for denmark
I wonder why...
Was rooting for... I can`t root for ANYBODY here.. Why would i root for Germans? And why would i root for self centered assholes?
Spartans: no one shall ever equal the glory of Thermopylae
Dithmarschen: lol hold my bier
LMAO
the battle of thermopylae was a defeat for the spartans lol, persians won, this battle was a victory so ofcourse it has much more glory.
@@viraloracle5151 wasnt really a defeat since it allowed the rest of the Greek Army to escape and win the war
My ancestors come from Dithmarschen and my grandma often told me the story. And she told me that there were many small ditches under water. You must not forget that Dithmarschen is situated directly at the North Sea. So when they opened the flood gates several big and much more small diches were flooded. And that´s where the heavy armour of the Danish knights were fatal. It made them so heavy that they couldn´t get out of the ditches and drowned whereas the men of Dithmarschen used their long sticks to jump over the ditches.
And by the way - I know from experience that the folks from Dithmarschen are extremely stubborn by nature. No wonder they even fought the Danish army.
As a Dithmarschian I can confirm, we are an incredibly stubborn but also an incredibly loyal lot. We stick together!
@@Kangooroo08 Ich weiß ......... leider ........
As a local I can say you are god damn right, in Heide, it is still celebrated every two years, as part of the festival we call “Marktfrieden” or market peace.
We celebrate how the city was founded as a gathering place for merchants and remember our medieval heritage. They also show the same theater piece, every time, it is a dramatization of the events that lead up to the battle up to the victory.
And we never talk about 1559.
May I ask what happen in 1559..?
@@decay1928 well... In 1559... Let's just say, they came back...
And by the end of the year Dithmarschen was part of Denmark.
@@scprivat9519 "Success is not final, failure is not fatal: it is the courage to continue that counts."
beautiful video! Such an interesting time period. Love the animations :)
Hey man! Good to see you around. Thank you kindly.
you honestly have the best animations in the "battle history" genre on UA-cam, keep it up!
Thank you very much for the kind words.
I love the three dimensional effect, very useful for portraying the terrain that can be looked over with a traditional perpendicular view.
Thank you kindly. That was exactly why I wanted to try it out.
Ah, wunderbar! Just what I needed today. You have my thanks.
Perfect as usual BTW.
Thank you kindly sir.
what I've learnt from this video:
-dont fight an offensive war during winter
btw this is the best video so far, thx for the immersion :D
I hoped that 3D will bring a bit more immersion. Glad you liked it mate.
thx for reply^^ what will your next video be? oh btw, will you be covering 30 years war?? tbh I've never learnt anything about 30 years wars. Im curious
Unless you're George Washington crossing the Delaware.
Have you heard of the campaigns' of Napoleon and Hitler into Russia? They are very famous examples of not fighting in winter.
Of course the cause behind losing wasn't only due to the bitter Russian winter, I don't know about Hitler but Napoleon wasn't stupid or ghastly ignorant, why his campaign failed had a lot more to it than the Russian winter. But still these are two very famous examples.
It depends mate on the area you live in.And the harshness of the winters. Epaminontas of Thebes marched in winter (armies never marched on winter in that era in Greece)and totally surprised the Spartans crushed them and freed Helot cities all over the Peloponnese. He put the final nail in the coffin in their military supremacy in the region. Romans adored that guy and considered him a great tactician , regarded as great as Alexander in their eyes :) . ua-cam.com/video/Om7sJKCTp10/v-deo.html
You guys are getting better with every video.
Keep going!
Thank you kindly
The details during the battle are incredible it makes it so much more interesting. It's as if you were actually there and had written down the details which maneuvers were taken and how. So much better than blocks just crashing into each other and instantly disintegrating (you might know which channel I refer to). Once again excellent video I started to miss you haha. Too bad you are on your own it takes a lot of effort to make one video I can really see that. Hope you find some assistant soon when you grow bigger ( which you undoubtedly will). You are up there with bazbattles haha.
Hey man :). Thank you very much for the generous words.
Hey, don't disrespect the rectangles! 😡
Hope you're not referring to Baz, Baz is awesome.
are you referring to historia civils?
Where is my historical drama/action movie about this battle? That was awesome
Let's write a petition to Ridley Scott!
HistoryMarche Oh god not him. He’s nearly as bad as Mel Gibson in the historical film department
@@virusguy5611 But flooding the lands and provoking aliens to attack the invader's flanks takes cunning advantage of the alien's aquatic capabilities!
I swear I've watched this a total of 15 times this year, I don't know why I just subconsciously click on it every time it is recommended to me.
man Dithmarschen was Kicking ass back in 1500.
Sure was, just play Europa Universalis IV :D
And again in 1864
That was great. :) I am actually more intrigued about the history and motivation behind Dithmarsians though. How did they resist the might of entire countries for so long and why did they persist in such overwhelming odds? Sounds like a fascinating culture/society in history. Thanks for the hard work.
This should be a movie!!!!
Thank you sir. Maybe Ridley Scott will pick it up :D
Anything that enforces Europeans history will NEVER be made available by hollyweird.
They hate Europeans
@@jewberggoldstein7112 Well we certainly don't want to encourage Bollywood to pick it up!
@@jewberggoldstein7112 *cough exodus cough*
I religiously follow all the channels which cover battles of history, and though I usually never comment on them, I felt the need to make an exception in this case, as this has been my favorite animation style out of all of the channels of this genre. Fantastic work!
Thank you very much for your kind words sir.
This is awesome!
- a little known and very interesting battle
- exquisite quality and details
- the maps, OMG it's the map porn! :) Especially at 0:40
Thank you sir, thank you kindly.
Yeah, the maps where spot on.
@@HistoryMarche I also thoroughly enjoy the maps (map porn, Artur) thank you
Map Porn >>>>>>> Real Porn (which destroys manhood and vitality).
ua-cam.com/video/JkrbomvXuOE/v-deo.html
I'm very impressed with this channel. Great video, I have never heard of this battle before so it was real interesting to learn about it from your vocal description and graphics.
Thank you very much for your kind words.
It is clear that Isebrand was a huge fan of Leonidas.
That's exactly what I thought when I researched this. It reminds me of Thermopylae in every way.
Now I'm imagining him to look like Gerard Butler.
@@HistoryMarche could it be possible he knew about thermophylae? Probably not i think
And Hannibal Barca, the way he hemmed in the Landsknechts on all sides was very reminiscent of Cannae.
After finishing a campaign with dithmarschen on eu4 this video is beyond epic. Amazing job mate :).
I bet you like my Dithmarschen flag better than the one done by Paradox eh? :D
I did, but they the paradox one was amazing.
Damn good video, amazing graphics. It's nice to hear a story of peasant's defeating a monarchist army after having just been reading about the Germany peasant's war.
Indeed, if I ever read about true underdogs winning the day, this was it.
Well done indeed! Excellent story and graphics are great. Also I wish to thank you for your nicely timed use of the Wilhelm Scream/Yell
Thank you sir. Glad you liked the video.
This channel is always an education. I loved hearing about this "farmers' republic," and I appreciate the info that surfaces in banners after the closing.
Sad to hear about the torture and the "take no prisoners," but it is good to have it addressed.
Great voice over work by Alex Doddy.
Thank you kindly Brian, appreciate it. And yes, Alex truly does a great job.
Sad reality about prisoners is that, during the course of "normal" warfare of the medieval period, only nobles were taken prisoner and the common peasant or mercenary soldier could expect to be executed if captured. So when peasant uprisings and resistance happened, they tended to defy convention and execute the nobles too, because they knew the same would happen to them.
Brett DuVale thank you for the info. These “incidentals” are fascinating parts of History Marche videos, like the Spanish townspeople sold into slavery by Hannibal after they unsuccessfully resisted a siege.
Thanks Brian :D
The dimarschen peasents vaulted over using poles lmao what bosses
Indeed, I loved that detail. Simple, yet ingenious.
@@Baltic_Hammer6162 See a modern application: ua-cam.com/video/bZH_8G3YIpw/v-deo.html
That is how they would move around daily. Swamp farming is an art.
It is still used in parts of northern germany. Mostly in frisian areas and more in some kind of lowland games. The danish black guard should have known it too. they were mercenaries from netherlands and frisian areas like Groningen.
@@mweskamppp Groningen is a frisian area?
Look out Guard! Here come the peasants!
Best quote ever.
Very cool video. I admire how you are able to get the info across in a fun and interesting way. I look forward to seeing more.
Thank you kindly sir.
Nice to see you grow from a few hundred subs to 20k :) I hope you keep doing battles like this (rarely known ones).
Thank you kindly :)
totaly agree. i especially like how (unlike most other channels) the numbers and army comps are presented. gives a nice overview
Hell yea... Nice job getting sponsored...
Quick turn around on uploads.
Thank you!
Yes it's definitely good to have a sponsor on a video. It's still not a huge deal financially though since my channel is still small, and the fees are smaller as well. I'm still not approved for UA-cam partnership so I have nothing flowing in there, but there is Patreon, I'm thankful to my patrons from the bottom of my heart, really.
This video is sponsored by *Total Battle.* Check out their awesome website to learn more: *totalbattle.com/en/*
Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed the video please like, subscribe, comment and share. And if you’re feeling generous visit our Patreon page. Every dollar helps.
Patreon link: *www.patreon.com/historymarche*
Loved it! Two Questions:
-What Software did you use?
-What's the music at the end?
producing videos with this level of quality and detail takes a long time. Great job, HistoryMarche!
BazBattles, Epic History and Kings and General are teams. This one here is apparently one Dude. Those Channels also used to be slow at the begining, but as they master their craft, expand their team and upgrade their equipment, they get to crank out videos faster without loosing quality.
Then Help and support them on their Patreon.
Thats the plan. HistoryMarche does all the animation, writing etc... on his own. The only other person involved is myself just doing the voiceover. The goal is to definitely put out bigger and better content more regularly. Its just going to take a bit of time
I wish to say, that having watched his video when it came out, the whole production keeps me coming back for more.
The story is awesome as I always love an underdog story.
Thank you for making such a wonderful video.
I wish you much for success as you already have because you do a fantastic job.
Wow, thank you!
@@HistoryMarche This is truly one of the best youtube videos I've ever seen, from the animation, to the narration, to the overall narrative itself. Absolutely fantastic.
Thanks for making such a great video about fascinating moment in history that l had never heard of!
Glad I helped you learn something new :)
The quality of your videos is amazing! Also very cool that you choose more unknown battles, keep it up!
Glad you liked the topic and the video :D
Who is Mimi? RIP Mimi nonetheless.
Your videos are very well made with nice commentery i really love these ! Keep up the good work of enlarging our knowlage !
Thank you very much for your kind words.
Great piece of history! Where do men get the courage to oppose such a vast army with a few hundred of their fellows? This is true heroism, and the story deserves to be known far and wide. We may need such courage in the days ahead. Thank you very much for this great video!
I mean who wants to be peasants working to death for some shitty lord?
It is the rare and one of the best examples of how the relief is used as a strategic tool in the battle!
black guard's battle cry : "look out peasants ,here comes the guard"
peasants : seems original,let's make a change to it
"look out guard,here comes to peasants"
badass
Your videos are getting better and better by the upload, great job
Ya know what? I'm not even mad that the Danes lost this one, even though I am one. The Dithmarsians fought incredibly well here, choosing a battleground that fit them perfectly, neutralizing the Danes' numerical superiority, holding their defensive line without wavering, and carrying out well timed and well placed counter-attacks.
Well said sir.
This was great, I'm a history nerd and I never even heard of this battle before now, your doing great work
Very glad you enjoyed the video. Thank you for watching.
that peasants Republic moral though
What happened in Meldorf must've been a motivator to fight to the last man.
Taking no prisoners can be a great tactic to intimidate the enemy but if the enemy can't or won't run away well it just makes them fight harder
The nice thing is - that land looked like one would just manage to run through there - it was a treacherous swampy-icey landscape with, at the horizon, hints of a hills and a forest in sight. If in a rout, it would not seem like there was no escape to a panicked mind if in fact, there was none.
This is the first video that I have watched from your channel after being referred here by one of my favorite channels, History Time. I have to say that I like what I see so, here, have a sub.
Cheers! Thank you for stopping by and welcome to the channel. Thumbs up to History Time for the recommendation.
Very interesting piece of history that I was never aware of. Thanks for sharing and something new learned. Cheers!
Glad you enjoyed it.
Led his people to triumph in a battle where they were outnumbered 12 to 1, captured his enemy's national standard, and became a father, all at once. If you could only be remembered by history for one day in your life, Wulf Isebrand certainly managed to pick a good one.
You know shit's about to go down when he says casus belli.
lol
Really enjoyed the video, great job!
Thank you sir.
Wow, the militiamen commander was a genius.The flooding, the amazing courage of the peasants that managed to hold their grounds when fighing against better equipped and trained soldiers without having casualties, and the way of not recklessly surrounding the enemy.
All those totally remind me lelouch's strategic genius from code geass
As a student of history, your channel is very good. I just found it couple of days ago and have watched almost all the videos. I would love to see a linear warfare video at some point. Maybe the battle of Saratoga, battle of Gettysburg, battle of culloden, battle of Austerlitz. Keep up the good work!
As part of a joint venture, History Marche has been animating a fantastic Napoleonic series with Epic history, over on their channel, which may grab your attention!
@HistoryMarche It’s not just that your videos are perfectly animated, your choice of which battle to cover is fenomenal! P.S. When is the second part of the Second Punic War coming?
Thank you very much for your kind words and feedback Saša :) There might be another video before part 2 of the Second Punic War. I'm still not sure which topic will be covered as my patrons will decide that in a vote that I'll start in about a week - usually I compile a list of topics and from there my patrons choose what will be produced.
Excellent production quality, thank you for the effort :)
Thank you very much sir.
Not at all, thank *you* for making these, and putting quite a bit of effort into it as well :)
Really love the channel and videos, you can really see Sun Tzu's art of war in practice here!!! Looking forward to more videos with battles, from Antiquity to Middle Ages and WW2. Great work!! Kudos to the team that make the research and videos
Thank you so much for your generous words. The research, writing and animation team consists of: Me. I'd surely love to have more people though. Voice over is done by Alex, he's doing an awesome job.
U save my day
Thank you for watching :)
Post scriptum: the place where this happend is now called "Dusenddüwelswarf", thats local dialect an means "hill of the thousand devils". Every dithmarsian man knows this name :-)
Hehe, that's a cool bit of trivia. Awesome name and definitely fitting
Just when I thought nothing could cheer me up, this popped up. Great job!
Thank you for the kind words.
I think this may officially be my favorite military engagement of all time now.
Wow, good improvement!!! Very nice visuals and research. I like your work sir!!
Thank you kindly.
"...but my Lord, the battle plan looked good on paper"
King Johan : "Now look! If you'll eat this paper, we wouldn't talk about this day any more. Even in court! Okay?"
Like Market Garden.
Holy crap this is epic. Cant wait for the next video
Thank you sir.
There are many other history UA-camrs, but none top your artwork!
Thank you for the kind words :)
I've been slowly watching all of the battles on your channel, and I love them. But I don't understand how any story about any battle could possibly top this one. It's such an entertaining story.
"All hail the underdogs, all hail the new kids. All hail the outlaws..."
Nice video with effective music and talking 👍👏with clearly explained of events thanks
[4:24] *Gambesons / padded armors, not leather jackets. Love your videos HM still. :)
OMG, those 3D boxes are amazing. Awesome
On my tombstone it'll say: "Here lies Mago, he brought 3D boxes to life"
I've read that in most cases battles are not won by killing all enemy, but around 25% often proves to be the breaking point that starts a rout, which cascades into mass slaughter and last stands. This is especially true in battles with low visibility and communication, and to armies with less discipline and have not been trained to rally. Armies like the Romans learned to leave their best troops in reserve and expect the less experienced troops to fall back once they wear down the enemy, while medieval french and german armies often charged headon with their nobleman leaders taking the lead, once they die, the battle falls apart.
Like the Spartans at Leuctra, the destruction of the most elite unit usually results in other troops routing.
Hannibal however subverted the Roman tactic of three lines three times, always using flanking and pincers to force the Triarii elite to fight. No small wonder he won Trebia, Tresamine and Cannae. Like Alexander and Epaminondas Hannibal went for the throat.
always awesome to see a new vid. Great job!
Glad you liked it :)
Also looking forward to the next one maybe even cunning battles such as some that were exemplified in The art of war by Sun Tzu, and not just cunning tactics aswell as costs. Although i can't complain, i enjoy these just as much.
Wow, now I understand what took you so much time of no doing videos, THIS ANIMATION IS AWESOME!! everything is better, now we can clearly see terrain and units are better, too.
However, the troops look kinda like flags, is this on purpose? I think that it would be better if they were more like LEGO bricks at the start, and when they are being defeated and start routing, they turn more into the troops in this animation, like flags, as if they had lost their organization and strength. Also, it’s nice to see a non-medieval battle
Glad you liked the video. The troops "bend" over the features of terrain, that's why they may have reminded you of flags. Lego suggestion is worth considering, thanks.
You'r welcome, now, where do you find these somewhat unknown battles?
Awesome episode, like always !
Glad you liked it, cheers!
8:15 wilhelm scream? :p Awesome video man!
Awesome video !!! WELL DONE !!!
>immigrates to a peasant community
>becomes their military leader
>humiliates the danes
>refuses to elaborate
>disappears
>Johan Rantzau enters the chat
What a great channel, awesome vids!
Thank you Vlad :)
This battle reminds me of a more famous 'peasant' country resisting subjugating from a far more powerful feudal kingdom in Morgarten. In that battle the Swiss Confederacy also managed to beat back the might of the Hapsburgs. I didn't realize there was another autonomous region bordering the Holy Roman Empire who's denizens also fought as mercenaries. I wonder if the Dithmarsians and Swiss ever opened up diplomatic relations because they are very similar in a lot of ways.
Swiss were deep in the Holy Roman Empire no on borders
This is one interesting battle, I have never heard of 👍 thank you for this video.
Thank you very much. Glad you enjoyed it.
Isebrand going back to obscurity reminds me of a Roman general who just wanted to go back to his farm.
I find men like these who fight for duty and to protect their land and people greater and more honourable than men who fight for power, glory or pillaging, even if said men were genius generals.
Well said.
I think it was Incitatus that roman general
@@HistoryMarche Thank you guys, well met
Great video. Really liked it.
Thanks. As a Dane this battle is known albeit not in these details. The aftermath is very interesting. An depressing for me. Please make a video about that too.
It's very nice to see that someone from Denmark found the video interesting.
Most impressive stand and cimmander ! Nicely done , Thanks .
Glad you enjoyed it!
Bit random, but your voice is very nice to listen to while brewing beer.
Who knows, we might get sponsorship from a beer brewing company now: "Come to get hammered, stay for the lessons" :D
That is the nicest thing anyone has ever said to me!
Cheers!
Is it your voice? Sounds like the "How It's Made" guy ua-cam.com/video/lrcDTzJAcuE/v-deo.html
Nope, though if the discovery channel want to hire me, I wouldn't say no!
Very well made, continue with your work ...
It's beautiful ....
Thank you.
Always love a good underdog story in battles :)
Likewise. Thank you for watching.
Greets from born Dithmarscher. I'am from Meldorf and I must say, you did a great job with that video! Thanks for that! "Wahr di Garr, de Bur de kumt!"
Much better ending than Thermopylae. We need a movie.
"Nobleman, Swerve"
~Wulf Isebrand circa 1500
LOL!