Audio Engineers React to Garage Inc. Disc 1 by Metallica!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 чер 2024
- You see the title of the video...you know what is happening!
Link to listen to the album on Spotify:
open.spotify.com/album/5b7HQ0...
Link to Chris Parker's "Musical Taste" video:
• "Our Musical Taste" - ...
Link to Chris Schoenberg's "Musical Taste" video:
• "Our Musical Taste" - ...
Link to Patrick's "Musical Taste: video:
• "Our Musical Taste" - ...
Link to Patrick's Cancer Update Vol. 1:
• Cancer Update Vol. 1 │...
Timestamps:
00:00:00 Intro
00:06:11 Talking Garage Inc.
00:16:22 Cover Songs in General
00:33:03 Free Speech For the Dumb Reaction and Discussion
00:39:30 It's Electric Reaction and Discussion
00:51:14 Sabbra Cadabra Reaction and Discussion
01:14:30 Turn The Page Reaction and Discussion
01:29:29 Die, Die My Darling Reaction and Discussion
01:44:15 Loverman Reaction and Discussion
01:59:43 Merciful Fate Reaction and Discussion
02:26:27 Astronomy Reaction and Discussion
02:34:26 Whiskey in the Jar Reaction and Discussion
02:51:58 Tuseday's Gone Reaction and Discussion
03:06:41 The More I See Reaction and Discussion
03:11:13 Overall Thoughts/Review
03:26:23 OTHER Metallica Songs
03:30:48 Outro
THANK YOU so much for watching this video and for being the kind of person who reads the descriptions to see my thank you notes down here! You are the man!
Astronomy is the absolute hidden gem on this first disc
Yup. Astronomy is one of the top 5 songs they’ve ever done.
Absolutely. For me, Inamorata sounds like a homage to Astronomy, except it’s not as good. The bass tone and the descending bass riff part in particular.
Hell yes, it is. Amazing rendition.
Can't wait for your S&M reaction guys.
Yes
Yes!!!! Please do S&M! Also, speedy recovery!
I'd pay good money for a "Shut the hell up, Patrick" shirt lol. Remote Chris needs to trademark the phrase.
He did tell Patrick that he'd pay him to shut up lol
i'm only 10 minutes in, you asked if they ever did other covers; They did a covel medley of Dio/Heaven&hell/Rainbow - And its fantastic. It's called Ronnie Rising. They also did an Iron Maiden cover "Remember tomorrow".
Yes, it's on Hardwired's Disc 3, along with When a blind man cries and Remember tomorrow.
no way didnt know that
dont forget all charity concerts trough the years
They sound so tight in the Ronnie Rising medley. I remember when it came out, and I was praying and hoping that this sound was going to be on the album they were working on.
When a man cries - cover is so good!!!
3:01:30 They have many acoustic versions of their songs. They performed acoustic sets at the "Bridge school benefit" concerts in the 90's. Now they have their own benefit concert, "All within my helping hands foundation," where they perform acoustically.
They have also released acoustic versions of "All within my hands" and "Blackened" during the covid lock downs.
And disposable heroes !!!!!!
During a concert in Brisbane back in early 2000's they did a acoustic version of....The Four Horsemen! Yeh....the crowd there went strangly silent until Jason fired them up!
They also did creeping death for the awmh remote covid gig i think back in 2020
Patrick's ability to make jokes and be so positive out of such a difficult situation is truly inspiring! means a lot to me especially as I have lost several loved ones to cancer and another relative is also currently fighting the disease. Thanks for being amazing!
An interesting thing is that this album sold a shit ton for a cover album, and several of the artists covered on it made way more money just from royalties on this album than any of their own records.
Yep the irony is that with the way that recording contracts historically work, artists who don't sell tons of records actually made mediocre money if any money at all off their own recordings... Including a lot of the bands covered by Metallica. Every band covered by Metallica has been very grateful.
All the "unknower" bands covered in this albums changed their financies after this album hahahaha
True - My Dad wrote 'Crash Course' and 'Breadfan' and it has certainly helped my finances ;-)
@@jconrad7082 Damn, that's cool if it's true. Of which Budgie member are you the son?
@@pandabearguy1 My Dad was Burke Shelley (My real name is Nat Shelley), bass player and singer in Budgie.. and yeah, it is pretty cool! ;-) Peace
When the plug doesn’t come through, Patrick and the boys do
Patrick “I’m so exited to listen to Turn the Page”
Then proceeds to talk over the entire song and not listen to any of it.
Love Pat and praying for him , but that’ll never change man
Don't forget about the lords of summer because you missed it in the hardwired video!
Agreed. And also, it would be great to get a comparison between the 'First Pass' version and the final version that's on disc 2 of Hardwired.
@@kbr1656id love that
All from the disc 3 of hardwired indeed
also remember tomorrow, ronnie rising medley and when a blind man cries
@@sercan068 I posted multiple comments on this video (I add them as the topics come up), and I did mention these as well. Those are some of my favorite covers.
James and Jason both sing on "Die, Die My Darling". On live performances, also Kirk joins on backing vocals 😊
I love your guys' banter during the reaction...Can tell you have a lot of fun doing this! Keep it up, and hope to see many more!
Excited to listen to this and hear you guys together again. Hope you are getting along well Patrick, thoughts and prayers out to you
Glad to see you're looking and feeling healthier and healthier as the days go by. Always appreciate the content and reactions!
The backing vocals on Die Die My darling is all the members singing. There's a video that shows the recording session
Talked thru everything.
When it comes to Metallica, cover songs are a big part of their roots and identity. And tbh they take other bands' songs and make them their own better than any other band in my opinion. Both disc1 and disc2 are great. They are Metallica like they are in essence. Gritty, groovy and aggressive (even though the first disc is much more chill because of the phase they were in their style of music).
So good to have you all back guys ❤
Another banger of a video guys! I normally watch the metallica reactions but since your reaction skills have improved drastically i think all of your videos deserve a watch
I´m happy you´re doing this one. Garage Inc often gets overlooked because it´s a cover album, but most of them are damn good covers.
Hope you're doing well! I enjoy your reactions because none of my friends have anything like the same musical interests as me, so our music chats are all very superficial and this scratches an itch.
Love the part at 8:43 when Mr. Parker says ''I stink''. Made my day. Also, he's wrong about them not doing covers anymore. There's 2 covers and 1 medley on the bonus disc of Hardwired.
yeah but the covers on that disc are from 2008 and 2012 so when it comes to studio covers they havent done one in 12 years
@@blackdragons95 It's still more recent than garage. (Also the Dio medley is from 2014)
@@TeamWolfySoupyDio medley was released in 2014, but I think I saw it once somewhere that it was recorded back to back with When A Blind Man Cries and that one was recorded in 2012. But I don’t know for sure
Great reaction! We will be waiting for the second disc!!
So here you are changing my Sunday plans. Good to see you guys!
I have been waiting for this forever but i’m at work and will have to listen later see y’all in 8 hours!!!
Ok here we go!
We love your Metallica reviews! Thanks for sharing!!❤
I once heard James in an interview say that Garage Inc was to “pay back” all the bands they were covering early on that helped them get their start.
I guess the idea is Metallica knew they were going to have to pay out royalties to the original bands on this album - some of whom had really short or unsuccessful careers - so they made they album knowing that if it sold well it may have been some of these band’s biggest pay checks of their careers.
The writers of the two big singles from it by Bob Segar and Thin Lizzy probably didn’t need any help but I bet the bands that wrote songs like Last Caress and Am I Evil never saw record sales close to what they knew Garage Inc would do.
i been waiting for this for so long, im a huge fan of garage inc
They have done a ton of covers since Garage Inc...Remember Tomorrow by Iron Maiden, When A Blind Man Cries by Deep Purple, a Rainbow Rising Medley, a BUNCH of Ramones covers in the St. Anger era, and they've done All Your Lies and Head Injury by Soundgarden, Borderline by Thin Lizzy, In My Life by the Beatles, Hole In The Sky by Black Sabbath, It's Killing Me by UFO,
Also Veteran of the Psychic Wars by Blue Öyster Cult and Would? by Alice in Chains
You Really Got Me with Ray Davies
I Just Want To Celebrate
Only Happy When It Rains
Please Don't Judas Me
Diary Of A Madman
Don’t forget the House Of The Rising Sun cover from 2020 AWMH concert
I want to say something about the conversation in 10:00 minutes, they did even more cover songs after Garage Inc. and they are all on the bonus limited 3 disc Hardwired To Self Destruct album you haven't listened to
lets go patrick!!!! love to see it and looking forward very much to S&M i think you will love it
Great video guys! I was waiting for this. They already played fade to black and other songs unplugged
3:30:10 To be honest Chris, it's because you guys are the only guys I have found on UA-cam that actually make this kind of content. Long-form, in-depth, chill-vibe music reviews for my favorite artist of all time (Metallica). I started watching your guys's videos back in August, and I've watched every Metallica one since, as well as some other ones. I love this channel, and I love the long-form content. Like the other Chris said, it's good for getting through stuff too. I'll have the video up and listen to it while I do homework (about to graduate college) or when I am playing a casual video game at night. It's nice to hear the technical perspective when it comes to these albums that I've heard dozens of times. Anyway, sorry for the ramble, I just wanted to respond to the question. Great video, guys! Keep up the good work! Even though I rarely ever agree with Patrick's opinions, I can't wait for more!
The Sabbra Cadabra cover is so good
Its not that good
They also did a cover of House of the rising sun in a 2020 streaming show, and a lot more during their acoustic shows (Borderline and It's killing me are the most recent ones)
And, yes, you should definitely listen to We did it again, it's absolutely horrible and hilarious.
Bro disc 2 finna be so fun to see them listening to lmaoo. And dont forget lords of summer!
YOOOOOOO! LETS GO!! Sorta sad we didnt get the premiere, but fuck yeah. Looking forward to this!
Patrick and an energy drink is a wild combo
They’ve done heaps of covers since this release. They usually do covers before they record a new album, and I wouldn’t be surprised if they have a few unreleased covers from recent years.
They did all the Ramones covers in 2003, and since then it’s been sporadic but in studio they’ve covered Iron Maiden, Ennio Morricone, Rainbow, Deep Purple and Kinks.
They also recorded some live acoustic covers at numerous Bridge School Benefit gigs and others.
~2:46:00 how about covers that are almost note for note identical? Anthrax covered Kansas' "Carry On Wayward Son" and you could literally play the two tracks at the same time and they're perfectly in sync
Wishing you speedy recovery mate!
Wow you look so much healthier! Glad to see it
Diamond Head was a major influence on Metallica, their earliest shows they only had a couple of original songs and would play 4-5 Diamond Head covers along with other NWOBHM (New Wave of British Heavy Metal) cover songs, many of which are on Disc 2 of Garage Inc
Yeah, and listen to Metallica's "Seek & Destroy" next to Diamond Head's "Sucking My Love" and you can soooo hear the influence they had on them at the time. They adored Diamond Head. :-) Rightfully so... Diamond Head was an amazing band.
@@KabukiKid Even Too Far Gone? from 72S sounds like Sucking My Love..
@@marcreichman Oh yes... you can definitely hear it there, as well.
MERCYFUL FATE medley makes me keep headbanging over & over again
"We're going to get right in it" 33 minutes later...🤣
Patrick, you look well. All the best for you, man.
Btw, there is a new fan-version of St Anger, "St [b]Anger", which has new instrumentation, small changes to arrangement, some editing (album is 30mins shorter) but Hetfield's vocals. I find it, frankly, incredible.
This!
And the st. (b)Anger fn rules! I'd love to hear their thoughts on it, but I guess the album reaction is over and done and there are no revisiting. Who knows
Hi Patrick, just wondering about how you guys are going to decide what songs (i think it was 4 from memory) you listen to from each of the other bands like Iron maiden, Pantera, Megadeth etc. Is it something the community could take part in with deciding what songs and in what order you do each band and stuff? Can't wait for S&M either so there is a lot to look forward to. Also, as a huge Iron maiden fan my picks for the four would be Run to the hills, Wasted years, Passchendaele and Coming home
Actually one of the main reasons Metallica did this album (as well as ReLoad and S&M) in such a short span was because they owed record company like 6 more albums after Load and wanted to get out of the contract as quickly as possible. So they put out these three in three years, then they wanted to do another quick one (which turned out to be St. Anger), and the last two were Death Magnetic and Lulu, which obviously took a ton of time.
Ride the Lightning only had 3 songs out of 8 that fade out and one is called Fade to Black so that's allowed!
You have to ignore Patrick’s arbitrary songwriting decrees, like “every song has to have a bridge.” Lol
You should deffo look into DOWN. "Nola" is one of my fave albums!
Yes!
The "beep beep beep" on Die Die My Darling is feedback through a guitar with a pickup turned down and then flicking the toggle switch. Old Ace Frehley trick. I've played this live and know how it was done because I saw the Misfits perform it when they had 2 guitarists in later days
It's really annoying, especially on headphones. 😮
"How do they do Master/Ride unplugged?"
Funny you should say that! They've made acoustic versions of multiple metal songs at their acoustic charity concerts, where they also do acoustic covers (some from Garage Inc; some new). They've done a studio-tier acoustic version of Blackened, and high quality live acoustic versions of Disposable Heroes, Creeping Death, Enter Sandman, Now That We're Dead, Hardwired, and All Within My Hands (which also got into their S&M2 concert). Besides Hardwired, they're all completely reimagined versions of those songs. They're pretty interesting!
For perspective, Lars mentioned in the interview, to get out of Elektra contract and re claim their masters, they need to release 4 remaining albums before 2000. Load Reload, Garage Inc and S&M.
There was some making-of videos recorded for Garage Inc, and there are two things that I definitively remember from them: one is the whiteboard chart where they listed all of the intended songs in rows and had the instrument tracks/stems listed as columns to be checked off for each track as they were recorded.
The other is that the guys got together to record gang vocals at some point, though I don't remember for which song. With that said, I can pick up Jason's vocals in the "die die die my darling" part!
Disc 1 definitely fits in the "Load era" of Metallica. Along with the singles "I disappear" from the MI2 soundtrack, and "No leaf Clover" and "-Human" from S&M. Load era was my favorite era of Metallica...
They have done acoustic sessions for their charity "ALL WITHIN MY HANDS" FOUNDATION.
FINALLY, THANK YOU!!!
Guys, you're the only reaction videos I've seen that are worth watching.
I have two video ideas for you:
1. take some song you like from the Black Album (because it has the best extras in Deluxe editions) and analyse the changes that were made to that song since riff tape, through demos (Black album Deluxe editions have even multiple demo versions of same songs) rough mixes, alternate takes until final version.
2. same thing but maybe something from older album and see differences in sound of the band over different eras of live performances, i.e Moscow 1991, Cunning Stunts 1996, Through the never 2013(?)
Take care, escpecially Patrick!
Regarding the Metallica + rap part of the conversation, there was a Swizz Beatz track called "We Did It Again" featuring Ja Rule and Metallica. Kirk's wah and James' vocals are present. IIRC the track came out when James was in rehab and not long after Jason quit. To me, it sounded like they took some of James' vocals from their vault and just threw it in the track. It was on the "Biker Boyz" movie soundtrack.
Yeah, you can see a small clip of them working on it on Some Kind of Monster.
@1:31:30 There's a Garage Inc. making of video that shows them all (if I remember correctly) shouting DIE, DIE, DIE.
They do have MANY unplugged shows over the years with the "Bridge School Benfit" shows and the "All Within My Hands" Benefit concerts. It is wild. they COMPLETELY re-tooled heavy tunes like "Disposable Heroes", and covered a BUNCH of great tunes. They never stopped doing covers. The Hardwired to Self Destruct Bonus disc had a few covers on it. "Remember Tomorrow" by Iron Maiden. "When a Blind Man Cries" by Deep Purple. "Ronnie Rising" - Medley of Ronnie James Dio tunes. I have a feeling there will be a new Covers album in the near future.
Metallica's version of Astronomy is underrated. It's one of the best covers on disc 1.
They’ve done a bunch of acoustic covers as well, including Brothers in Arms (Dire Straits), Borderline (Thin Lizzy), Please Don’t Judas Me (Nazareth), Blackened (er, Metallica…), It’s Killing Me (UFO) and others.
Speaking of covers, and Metallica... It might be interesting for you guys to react to the Metallica songs performed by other huge artists during their MTV Icon spotlight from 2003 awards show. And briefly if you dont know, Icon was a show on MTV that honored musicians who were selected as "cultural icons".
03:01:55 sounds like you wanna listen to Metallica: Disposable Heroes (AWMH Helping Hands Concert - November 3, 2018)
03:11:11 they released the full version on The Memory Remains single in the UK, The Outlaw Torn (Unencumbered by Manufacturing Restrictions Version)
been waiting for more metallica reacts for ages
There's actually some acoustic shows by Metallica. Gems like Disposable heroes, creeping death, blackened, very cool acoustic versions played live.
Metallica covered When a Blind Man Cries by Deep Purple and Remember Tomorrow by Iron Maiden on the deluxe version of Hardwired. That’s the most recent covers Metallica has done to my knowledge
They also covered Rainbow songs in Ronnie Rising Medley
Metallica played a show in 98 at the Roseland Ballroom in New York. It's filmed and so much fun to watch.
Patrick my brother. I hope you recover soon, all the best to you
I am curious.. have you guys ever listened to Guitar Hero's AJFA? i know i heard many people say it's the best "sorta official" version of AJFA, but i wonder what your take would be on it.
Metallica still does cover songs now and again, especially during their acoustic AWMH charity concerts - they released the 2019 concert in limited vinyl and pretty sure its on spotify.
During Chris Cornell Tribute concert they did two SoundGarden covers, also released on limited 7inch via Metallica vinyl club, not sure if those are on spotify or not?
I like the nostelgic lowfi aspect of cassette. It takes me back to the 80s and 90s when CD weren't yet mainstream and you got all the glorious imperfections that comes with tape. It's basically for those of us who want to go back in time, and hear modern music sounding a little more vintage.
Wow, I didn't see this coming. Sweet.
About the "selling a lot of CD's" at 10'50" argument, the thing is that with this album they foremost made rich all the original composers of the songs. I remember an interview from - of course - guy from Diamond Head saying they can live with just the metallica covers royalties, but also Lemmy on "his" movie discussing with actor Billy Bob Thornton in a bar and saying him he received the biggest check of his carreer not from Ace of Spades or any of Motorhead's biggest success, but from the selling of Garage Inc or from the EP "Motorheadache".
Loverman…
Patrick: “I’m loving this song!”
Me “Have you even heard any of it?!?” 🤣🤣
watch it later, just came to click on the thumb and comment ! thanks guys, I love this album. First of their album I listen multiple times until I know every single note
This album was a way for Metallica to pay back the artists who influenced them. Many of the bands like Diamond Head have stated they never have to work again based on the money they made from this. Even Lemmy talked about how lucrative this was for him.
They did gang vocals on Die Die my darling. Its in the making of garage inc. Kirk, Lars and Jason. And then Jason did some extra solo backing tracks to it.
Does anyone have a link to the Discord server Patrick mentioned?
Oops! I forgot to link it! Ill try to fix it when I am at home!
Awesome! Looking forward to joining it. Hope you’re doing well man!
Love every tune on this ❤
Patrick talking non stop for 3 good hours. Please stop and listen sometimes, and please, stop make false statements about Metallica i.e «they never do stuff like that» when they literally do.
there is not a moment of silence...ever! how do you do the analysis? 😅😅😅
I really like the disc 2 track Stone Cold Crazy which is original a Queen song. I think that one is done well
Love watching you guys but jeez is it so hard to shut up for a second and actually listen to the songs? This goes only for one of you three *wink wink*
I’m 42 minutes in and all I hear is their commentary, they’re all ignoring the songs lol
@@beatmet2355 I know right?! What’s even the point of these Videos. Such a Great Record and all in all a cool Idea to listen to these Songs and discussing them, but all I hear is bla bla over the best Parts. It’s like on Purpose, I don’t get it.
Check out the bonus disc of Hardwired as there are three more recent covers from late 2000s-2010s that you should definitely check out: the aforementioned Ronnie Rising Medley covering Rainbow and Dio, Remember Tomorrow that belongs to Iron Maiden and an amazing rendition of When A Blind Man Cries by Deep Purple.
Thank you for the video! Great to see all the three of you together again :)
To answer chris’ question on why we watch for so long, it’s because I’m the living embodiment of adhd and gotta clean my room
i almost know every dental filling Yawning not-remote-Chris has at this point XD
They still do covers to this day. Like other posters have stated, the deluxe version of Harwired, disc 3 has some covers. There's a medley of Dio songs that they did for that trivute album. When A Blind Man Cries, a Deep Purple song is from that tribute album, and the Iron Maiden song Remember Tomorrow.
Also Metallica still does plays covers live at their shows still. During the World Magnetic tour in the late 2000's, during their encore, they played various cover songs. Also, they've included Turn The Page and Whiskey In The Jar in their live set to this day
It would be awesome to do the one-off songs. Remember Tomorrow, When A Blind Man Cries, and Ronnie Rising Medley are extras on Hardwired and are really good imo. I haven't even heard some of the songs you listed, so that video would be great.
Funniest moment in any of these videos ever: "I'LL PAY YOU TO NOT SPEAK DURING THESE PARTS!"
...and I feel the pain.
Some of my favorite covers NOT on this album:
3. "Today Your Love, Tomorrow the World" by The Ramones
2. "When a Blind Man Cries" by Deep Purple
1. "Remember Tomorrow" by Iron Maiden
Note: In the St. Anger era, they recorded a whole EP's worth of Ramones covers as possible releases on a Ramones tribute album. "53rd and 3rd" was the song chosen, I believe. But they also did "Commando," "Cretin Hop," We're a Happy Family," and "Now I Wanna Sniff Some Glue."
“When a blind man cries” on 2019 AWMH concert is so freaking good
Isn't that, with the re-recordings like what Journey did, when Kiss (for 2009's Sonic Boom), had a bonus CD in there of the band (Gene, Paul, Tommy, Eric S.) going and re-recording Kiss Klassics?
There was an acoustic concert of load/reload played in barn😁
I saw ones on yt..
It never fails to amuse me how much automatic disdain Patrick has for anything pre-Godsmack or that isn't Godsmack.
Hardwired Deluxe Edition have cover songs on it. Ronnie Rising Medley (Dio), When A Blind Man Cries (Deep Purple) and Remember Tomorrow (Iron Maiden)
I actually liked those songs better, especially the Dio medley.
the 6 Ramones covers they did are fun, Kirk, Lars and Bob Rock all have vocals on 1 song and Lars does a verse in another.
Can't wait for your S&M reaction, but actually watching Symphony and Metallica performing together is not the same as just listening to it. In the DVD, you can choose to listen to only Metallica, only the Symphony, or both together, in 5.1 or 2.1 surround sound, so you can isolate the voice from other instruments. As a bonus, it has 40 minutes of video showing how they prepared, practiced, and recorded the whole thing among other features.
3:30:09 Cause we we like you guys!
Personally I don't see any great reason to break up Garage Inc. disc 2 but if you wanna split it up -- fine. Not sure why anyone would have a problem with that, especially considering they were all recorded at different times.
Super late comment, but I think the big reason why they made this was because of all of the existing bootlegs that floated out there of their previous covers. Apparently, the "Garage Days Re-Revisited" EP is among the most bootlegged Metallica releases out there, so I think the band decided to just compile all of their previous covers onto the second disk for those who are looking for those tracks, and then they made a brand new disk of material to catch the interest of hardcore fans who already own the covers or those out there just looking for more Metallica.